10/08/2020

(AU) Pressure Builds On Australia Despite Delay To International Climate Talks

Sydney Morning HeraldMike Foley

With November's United Nations climate talks cancelled, green-leaning world leaders will be hoping the Australian government uses the downtime to rethink its controversial climate policies.

The 26th session of the Conference of the Parties, or COP26, was set to be held in Glasgow in November but has been pushed to next year due to the pandemic.

A previous COP developed the 2015 Paris Agreement on climate change and the international pressure countries exert on each other through it continues to have a significant impact on domestic policies, including in Australia.

International pressure on Australia is not expected to ease, despite the 12 month delay to international climate talks in Glasgow. Credit: Jonathan Carroll

Australia's former top climate diplomat, Howard Bamsey, who led negotiations at a number of COPs, says despite the pandemic’s disruption to the Glasgow forum, the British government will continue to pressure Australia and other countries to increase their efforts on greenhouse gas emissions reduction.

“If the Prime Minister hasn’t heard from [his British counterpart] Boris Johnson yet, he certainly will,” says Bamsey, who is adjunct professor at Australian National University’s School of Regulation and Global Governance, and was previously Australia’s special envoy on climate change.

Glasgow is set to be particularly controversial. Under the Paris Agreement, countries are required to revise their emissions plans every five years, which are expected to grow increasingly ambitious in line with the scientific advice on the volume of reductions required to keep global warming to under 2 degrees Celsius.

“This COP was the one where countries came together and heavied one another to do better on climate change,” Bamsey says.

“The UK will expect Australia to do more in the international interest and help the UK achieve a good result in Glasgow, and we will be expected to bring a strong package [of climate policies].

“I’m sure the UK, as soon as it can, will be trying to influence other countries.”

Australia's commitment to the Paris Agreement requires emissions reduction of at least 26 per cent by 2030, based on 2005 levels, and all countries must also reach net-zero emissions by the end of this century.

An overarching requirement is to follow the "best available science" to make the emissions reduction required to limit global warming to under 2 degrees Celsius and as close as possible to 1.5 degrees Celsius, which experts say means the world needs to hit net-zero emissions before 2050.

Energy and Emissions Reduction Minister Angus Taylor has committed to meet the 2030 target and has released a discussion paper on a technology roadmap which he said would be a "cornerstone" of that effort. He maintains that Australia is required to achieve net zero only in the second half of the century.

At last year’s COP in Madrid Australia controversially joined with Brazil and Saudi Arabia to oppose the push from a bloc of 31 countries - including Germany, France, Britain, New Zealand and Pacific nations - to develop the "San Jose principles", which included a ban on countries' use of carry-over credits from expired climate treaties to meet current climate goals.

Frank Jotzo, a professor of environmental economics and lead author of the sixth assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which is used by the COP, says the delay to Glasgow created a wild card for the forum now set for 2021 because it would fall after the US presidential election in November.

“[Democratic presidential nominee Joe] Biden has made it clear an administration under him would act strongly on climate change and would seek to entice other nations to do likewise,” Professor Jotzo says.

“This would also manifest itself through pressure on US allies … and the Australian government’s outlook on climate change commitments and policy will probably shift to some extent, by virtue of the pressure from Washington.

“But if you look back to the Obama presidency in the US, that was also a time when China engaged much more internationally because there can be an element of competition between the big powers.”

Jotzo says it remained “unclear” what role China would play “and it's difficult to speculate”. Bamsey, however, expected China “will play a big role”.

“I see no reason to expect China won’t push ahead very strongly, and I think China will expect Australia to do pretty well too. That’s something that they and the UK will have in common,” he says.

Speaking on Tuesday to a webinar of the Coalition for Conservation group, former Howard government Environment Minister Robert Hill said Australia "can afford to be a leader" on the urgent changes needed to limit the impact from climate change and “the delay of a year I think actually is helpful to Australia”.

“It gives the government a bit more time to work out what Angus Taylor is referring to as his long-term strategy, and the plan is to take that strategy to the COP,” Hill said.

He urged the Morrison government to bolster its technology roadmap with commitments under Paris to emissions reduction beyond 2030, arguing the “longer-term goal has to become a target”.

Bamsey says Australia has "plenty we can take to the next COP, but the focus there will be on targets, and that’s where we don’t have a strong story to tell".

“Most people would be astonished to know what we have done in the international context to bring about the architecture we have now. Our contribution has been strong and we’ve had the international interest in sight," he says.

Bamsey says Australia’s achievements in promoting emissions reduction technology were powerful in land management and our trailblazing take-up of rooftop renewables.

“We have also made a useful contribution in the land sector and related activities, with expertise developed around carbon farming initiatives that other countries don’t have but could be enormously useful for them,” he says.

Links

Climate Change Is Pushing Millions Of People Into Cities Like Addis Ababa. Here's What Rapid Urbanisation Looks Like In The Ethiopian Capital.

Business Insider Australia - Inyoung Choi

Young girls plant trees in Addis Ababa as part of a ‘national tree-planting drive’ in response to climate change. MICHAEL TEWELDE / Contributor / Getty Images

  • Climate change is expected to push people away from uninhabitable rural areas and into cities.
  • For example, The World Bank predicts the urban population of Ethiopia to triple to 42.3 million by 2037.
  • A recent investigation by ProPublica and The New York Times Magazine said that overcrowded cities can lead people to “congregate in slums with little or electricity” which “fuel extremism and chaos.”
  • Economic anthropologist Jason Hickel told Insider in an email that “parts of the world that are being most heavily impacted by climate change are the parts of the world that have done the very least to cause it.”
  • Here’s a look into what rapid urbanisation looks like in Ethiopia’s capital and largest city, Addis Ababa.
Floods, droughts, and food insecurity from climate change are expected to propel people vast populations of people to migrate away from rural areas to cities.

In Ethiopia, for example, data from the country’s central statistics agency predicts the urban population to triple to 42.3 million by 2037, according to a report from the World Bank. The country is undergoing “rapid urbanisation,” where the labour force has doubled in the past two decades and is predicted to rise even more to 82 million by 2030, the report says.

A recent deep investigation by ProPublica and The New York Times Magazine warned of the devastating consequences of extremely rapid urbanisation, pointing out how overcrowded cities can prompt people to “congregate in slums with little or electricity” which “fuel extremism and chaos.”

Because of the country’s massive population influx, Ethiopia’s capital and largest city, Addis Ababa, has been going through that kind of rapid urbanisation. Here’s what the city looks like, through photos.

******
Climate change has led to problems that may force millions of people to abandon their homes to migrate into cities and eventually cross national borders.

Apartments in Addis Ababa in 2016. Eric Lafforgue/Art in All of Us / Contributor / Getty Images


******
Economic anthropologist Jason Hickel told Insider in an email that “droughts and floods caused by climate change” have already made some rural regions of the world “virtually uninhabitable.”

Streets of Addis Ababa. Eric Lafforgue/Art in All of Us / Contributor / Getty Images


******
According to Hickel, these unsustainable conditions of living force “people to abandon their land and search for wages in cities.”

Construction in Addis Ababa. Eric Lafforgue/Art in All of Us / Contributor/Getty Images

******
In Ethiopia, 30% of the population might live in urban areas by 2028, based on the rate of urbanisation, according to The World Bank. Source: The World Bank

Skyline of Addis Ababa. VW Pics / Contributor / Getty Images


******
Rapid urbanisation can push people to congregate in slums. Around 40 per cent of global urban expansion may be in slums, according to a 2017 report published by the UN. Source: United Nations Development Programme Human Development Reports

Two women with leprosy are hospitalized in the slum of Northern Addis Ababa in 2007. Jonathan Alpeyrie / Contributor / Getty Images


******
Hickel says the rise of slums “is a recipe for poverty, political instability and social unrest.”

A young girl collects garbage left on road in the Northern slum of Addis Ababa in 2007. Jonathan Alpeyrie/Getty Images


******
In addition, rapid urbanisation tasks communities with the challenges of meeting the large increase in demands for work.

A shoe manufacturing park in Addis Ababa. SOPA Images / Contributor / Getty Images


******
The World Bank reported that in Ethiopia, the labour force has doubled in the past two decades. Source: The World Bank

A factory in Gelan – roughly an hour drive from Addis Ababa – was impacted by the electricity cuts in Addis Ababa in 2019. EDUARDO SOTERAS/AFP via Getty Images


******
The World Bank reported that Ethiopia will need to create around one million more urban jobs per year between 2019 to 2035 in order to maintain and reduce the current level of unemployment. Source: The World Bank

A modern textile factory in Addis Ababa in 2017. picture alliance / Contributor / Getty Images


******
Hickel told Insider that what’s happening in Ethiopia is “a portent of more to come.” Without radical efforts to reduce global emissions, he says the problem will only get worse.

Addis Ababa’s ‘national tree-planting drive’ in response to climate change. MICHAEL TEWELDE / Contributor / Getty Images


******
A recent investigation by ProPublica and The New York Times Magazine used data to predict migration from climate change. Source: ProPublica and The New York Times Magazine
Children in Addis Ababa in 2019. Anadolu Agency / Contributor / Getty Images


******
While nothing their model is “far from definitive,” they concluded it was clear that “climate change, currently a subtle disrupting influence, becomes a source of major disruption, increasingly driving the displacement of vast populations.”

Hotels in Addis Ababa are mostly closed due to coronavirus. The few that are open are mostly empty. Anadolu Agency / Contributor / Getty Images


******
The late Oxford environmentalist Norman Myers estimated that by 2050 an estimate of 200 million people may have to migrate because of climate change. Source: Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society

A woman sells corn at a Addis Ababa market. Anadolu Agency / Contributor / Getty Images


******
Hickel says that “parts of the world that are being most heavily impacted by climate change are the parts of the world that have done the veryleast to cause it” and that ensuring everyone has “the right to access safe and habitable parts of the planet” should be a “defining struggle” of the 21st century.

A group of women in Addis Ababa in 2019. Anadolu Agency / Contributor / Getty Images


******
10 countries contribute to more than 68% of all greenhouse gas emissions around the world. The US, counting for 13%, comes second to China (26%) and before the EU overall (7.8%). Source: World Resources Institute

Addis Ababa celebrates the third annual ‘Car Free Day’ to reduce air pollution. EDUARDO SOTERAS / Contributor / Getty Images


******
The sustainability and safety of communities like Addis Ababa depend on the decisions other countries make to respond to climate change and migration.

Addis Ababa in August, 2020. Minasse Wondimu Hailu/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images


******
If the US and other developed nations “refuse to welcome migrants but also fail to help them at home” the impact could be devastatingly “lethal,” according to ProPublica and The NY Times Magazine. Source: ProPublica and The New York Times Magazine

Streets of Addis Ababa in 2015. Thomas Imo / Contributor / Getty Images


******
In 2019, the African Development Bank President Akinwumi Adesina said “Africa shouldn’t be in a situation wherein it is begging” for the financial support necessary to contend with climate change. “There has to be climate justice,” Adesina said.  Source: The Associated Press

African Development Bank president Akinwumi Adesina speaks with Burkina Faso president Roch Marc Christian Kaboré at the G5 Sahel Summit in 2019. ISSOUF SANOGO / Contributor / Getty Images


******
Hickel told Insider that the “existing approach to aid is not a meaningful solution,” and said that wealthy nations contributing disproportionately to the “climate breakdown” must stop using fossil fuels and provide “reparations” to vulnerable countries.

A sack of grain donations from USAID in Ethiopia. ullstein bild Dtl. / Contributor / Getty Images


******
The coronavirus pandemic poses yet another set of challenges to Addis Ababa. Ethiopia has a total of 20,900 confirmed cases so far according to Johns Hopkins University.

Officials distribute disinfection works in Addis Ababa in response to coronavirus. Anadolu Agency Contributor.
Links

(AU) New FOI Ruling Orders Disclosure Of CSIRO Internal Documents On Its Response To Murray-Darling Criticisms

The Guardian

The information commissioner says release of material previously redacted by the scientific agency is a matter of public interest

The CSIRO has been criticised over its initial failure to give evidence to the Murray-Darling royal commission and refusal to talk about its latest work on climate change. Photograph: Mark Evans/Getty Images



An important freedom of information ruling from the information commissioner involving the CSIRO has set a new bar on when the public service can withhold documents detailing internal deliberations if they concern matters of public importance.

South Australian senator Rex Patrick has been trying to gain access to CSIRO documents that touch on how the scientific agency dealt with criticisms from the SA royal commission into the Murray-Darling Basin plan.

Commissioner Bret Walker SC, was highly critical of the CSIRO over its initial failure to give evidence to his commission, and its subsequent refusal to talk about its latest work on climate change and the impact on the Murray-Darling Basin.

He cast doubt on the CSIRO’s research integrity on climate change after he heard evidence from an ex-CSIRO scientist that the agency had altered a report known as the “Multiple Benefits” report, after alleged pressure from the MDBA.

Walker also accused the CSIRO of “undue secrecy” over its work on climate change.

Initially the CSIRO refused to participate in the royal commission because it said it was hamstrung by the commonwealth’s high court challenge to block federal public servants being subpoenaed and a direction to federal agencies not to participate.

However it did give evidence late in the inquiry, after the high court challenge was dropped.

When Patrick sought internal documents produced by the CSIRO on how to respond to the drubbing it received from the commissioner, he was met with reams of blacked out documents.

Some deletions were made because the CSIRO considered the material irrelevant.

Some were made because the CSIRO said they contained deliberative matter, which was inextricably entwined with factual matter, and so the factual matter could not be provided either.

Both of these exemptions are increasingly used by departments and agencies to withhold material from journalists and others.

“The trouble when you fight these battles [is] you do so with one hand behind your back. The agency knows what’s under the redactions, the applicant doesn’t,” said Patrick.

The information commissioner, Angeline Falk, accepted Patrick’s submission on deliberative matter because she said that disclosure of the document “would inform the community of the government’s operations and inform debate on a matter of public importance, namely the management of the Murray-Darling Basin.”

“I consider these are the relevant public interest factors favouring disclosure.”

She considered the CSIROs arguments that public servants should be free to express their views when deciding on policy.

“I am not satisfied that the CSIRO has provided sufficient particulars to explain how disclosure of the material in the document at issue would impact the ‘efficient and proper functioning of government’ or ‘the integrity of the decision making process’, or adversely impact on the CSIRO’s ‘ability to implement its legislative functions’ and diminish ‘the ability of CSIRO to engage internally in critical discussions on questions of scientific integrity’,” she said.

“Giving the applicant access to the relevant material at this time would not, on balance, be contrary to the public interest,” she said.

The decision is likely to provide a strong precedent for journalists seeking to gain information on issues such as climate change or the conduct of policy during the pandemic.

“The Murray Darling Basin is a $22bn national food hub. There should be no secrecy in relation to it. We are not talking missile systems or deployment of submarines,” he said.

Patrick also had a win on irrelevant material.

Often documents are ruled within the scope of the FOI request but then large parts are redacted as not strictly relevant to the wording of the request, leaving the document almost meaningless and without context.

The commission is able to look at the documents in their entirety and Falk sided with the applicant, a signal that departments should in future take a more wide ranging interpretation of what is relevant and irrelevant.

In this case, the CSIRO had withheld large swathes of a document entitled “Issues management for SA MDB Royal Commission report release” as irrelevant.

Patrick argued “the scope of the request clearly covers reports, investigations or documents that were produced by the CSIRO as a result of the findings of the RC report”.

“Having regard to the scope of the request and the applicant’s submissions, it is apparent that the applicant’s request would extend to the entirety of a document that the CSIRO has identified as falling within scope.”

The documents themselves are due to be released within 28 days.

Links