Fairfax
Australia will break a commitment made at the Paris
climate summit less than two months ago if CSIRO goes ahead with its
plan to axe its research programs, one of the agency's
leading scientists has warned.
 |
| One of the world's three major atmospheric greenhouse gas recording stations at Cape Grim. |
John Church, a globally recognised expert on sea level
rise and one of CSIRO's most decorated researchers,
said organisation chief Larry Marshall had misled the public by claiming
there was now less need for climate research because the problem had
been "proven".
It came as US scientist James Hansen, sometimes described as
the father of climate change awareness, suggested the decision to cut
the jobs was wrong.
Dr Marshall announced via email on
Thursday that 350 jobs would go over two years as the organisation
moved away from observing and modelling climate change to working on
solutions to the problem.
 |
| Senior CSIRO scientist John Church: cuts will make it difficult for Australia to uphold its part of the Paris deal. Photo: Matthew Newton |
Details of the cuts have not been finalised, but it is
understood one of the world's three major atmospheric greenhouse gas
recording stations at Cape Grim, in Tasmania's north-west, is under
threat. It is the only station of its type in the southern hemisphere.
The
future of programs run by the $120 million RV Investigator research
ship, launched amid fanfare in late 2014, are among those that are
unclear.
CSIRO staff were forthright in their unhappiness
at the cuts at briefings at midday on Friday, describing it as a flawed
strategy.
About 100 jobs are planned to go from units
dedicated to research in areas including greenhouse gas levels, sea
level rise, ocean temperatures, ocean acidification and assessing what
is required to keep global warming to two degrees. The jobs would be
replaced by new positions in other areas.
Dr Church, who
has worked at CSIRO since 1978 and expects to lose his job, said the
cuts would make it difficult for Australia to uphold its part of the
Paris deal, which agreed there should be greater investment in climate
research, including improved observations and early warning systems.
He
said the work of CSIRO was considered particularly important because of
Australia's role as the major developed country in the southern
hemisphere, with a focus on Antarctica and the Pacific.
"There is need for climate science – there are clauses in the Paris
agreement that say that. There is a clear need for ongoing sustained and
enhanced observations. The science community is actually struggling to
address these issues already and so further cuts mean it will be very
difficult."
"That's at variance with what the chief
executive has been saying, that climate science is done. That's clearly
not the case – it's inaccurate, misleading information."
He
said there was a need to "reinvigorate and refocus" climate research.
If CSIRO was to abandon it, this may have to be through a new body.
"There's been talk for decades of a climate change research institute
- maybe now is the time for an institute in which the principal body
would be the Bureau of Meteorology, with support from universities."
Dozens
of scientists issued statements in response to Dr Marshall's
announcement. Many were incensed by the former venture
capitalist's suggestion that climate change science was a narrow field
that had been "proven" to be a problem, and therefore no longer needed
to be a focus.
Dr Church said it was true climate change was proven, but more detail was needed if the world was going to adapt.
"To
talk about it being a narrow science is completely inaccurate – it's a
very broad area. It would be great if CSIRO could invest in mitigation. I
don't see any signs it is doing that significantly."
James
Hansen, a former NASA scientist known for his testimony to US Congress
in 1988 that arguably put concern about climate change on the map, said
he was stunned by the announcement.
"Holy shit! That is unbelievable," he said. "Is a conservative denier government in power?
"This
seems to be a clear-cut case of shooting the messenger with the bad
news. However, the messenger is needed to figure out what to do about
the problem."
It is understood that the fate of the Cape
Grim station, which is jointly operated with the Bureau of Meteorology,
and about 20 scientist positions is not yet decided, but is on the list
of possible cuts.
Cape Grim is among the top sites in
the world for monitoring trends in greenhouse gases because purified air
reaches the Tasmanian coast having blown 20,000 kilometres across the
oceans. The CSIRO has been planning celebrations to mark its 40th
birthday in April.
A CSIRO spokesman denied it would be closed.
Scientists at the Friday briefing were told they would be notified by early March whether they had been sacked.
It was
expected about 110 of some 135 people employed in a unit dedicated to
oceans and atmosphere research would lose their jobs. Most jobs lost
would be in Tasmania.
"The mood is very bad and
depressed," one scientist who requested anonymity said. "People were
questioning the logic of the cuts."
Scientists asked whether Dr Marshall had sought board approval for the move, but did not receive a clear answer.
Among
the programs to go are the natural resource management unit, which last
year released projections of climate change impacts for Australia out
to 2050.
Stefan Rahmstorf,
from Germany's Potsdam Institute of Climate Impact Research and a
visiting professorial fellow at the University of New South Wales, said
Cape Grim had a unique location and was a "critical node in the global
network of monitoring stations".
"It provides essential
data that allows us to understand the patterns of how greenhouse gases
and pollutants spread in the atmosphere."
He said the
planned culling of most of CSIRO's climate research positions would be
viewed as "an act of anti-science vandalism" in Germany.
"Closing
down climate research capacity at a time of rapid global warming is not
just short-sighted, it borders on the insane," he said. "A country that
amputates its ability to analyse and understand climate change in its
own region will simply harm itself – it is basically setting out to
adapt to a changing climate blindfolded."
Axel
Timmermann, professor of oceanography at Hawaii University, said CSIRO
had been a leader in el Nino and climate change research for two
decades.
Links