Wednesday, March 16, 2016

When 'Global Warming' Became 'Climate Change'

Bloomberg Business - Emily Chasan | Jennifer Rossa

When exactly did one become the other, and why?
Christopher Furlong/Getty Images

First there was "global warming." Then came "climate change." Turns out, use of the latter became more prevalent in 2008 and that dominance became irreversible in 2009. Here's how use of the terms compare in stories on the Bloomberg Professional service.

The term "global warming," which describes an increase in the Earth's average temperature surface due to greenhouse gas emissions, is widely believed to have been coined in 1975 by Columbia University geochemist Wallace Broecker, according to NASA. Meanwhile, "climate change," which describes a long-term change in the Earth's climate, appeared a few years later in a 1979 National Academy of Science study on carbon dioxide.
A May 2014 Yale University study found that while "climate change" appears to be preferred by scientists, "global warming" can evoke stronger emotions and issue engagement for some groups of people.
While those mentions in the professional media tracked by Bloomberg show a clear trend, the general public is pretty evenly split. Here's how people have searched for the two terms in Google over the past several years. The spike in searches coincides with the Academy Award in 2007 given to Al Gore's film on global warming, "An Inconvenient Truth."
Source: Google







While the language may be divided, the science over climate change is not.


A Brief History of Global Warming

Links

Why Malcolm Turnbull Should Reverse The Destructive, Clumsy And Dumb CSIRO Cuts

The Guardian - Mark Dreyfus

The gutting of climate science expertise in one of the world’s premier research organisations is not clever, innovative, or agile. It is destructive, clumsy and dumb
‘Mr Turnbull seeks to position himself as a friend of science and a true believer in climate change ... but he is leading a party which still, in 2016, is debating whether climate change is real.’ Photograph: Mick Tsikas/AAP

Historically, there have been two groups that have really been the heart and soul of climate science on the planet. This is one of them.
Those words about CSIRO, spoken by the chief adviser on carbon cycle science at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Lab on the day the CSIRO 350 job cuts were announced, have since been echoed across the global scientific community.
The New York Times has not just written about the CSIRO cuts but also editorialised against them, attributing them to “a deplorable misunderstanding of the importance of basic research into what is arguably the greatest challenge facing the planet.”
A series of senate committee hearings last week heard over and over again about the devastating impact of these cuts on CSIRO’s ability to do its job properly.
Part of CSIRO’s Marine and Atmospheric Division is in Aspendale in my electorate of Isaacs. Together with the Australian Antarctic Division, it is expected to bear the brunt of the Abbott-Turnbull Government’s latest attack on Australia’s world class science and research. The job cuts that have been announced will effectively gut CSIRO’s Aspendale centre.
Established more than 50 years ago, it has produced some of the most important climate change research on the globe. Its scientists have contributed to the International Panel on Climate Change reports which are considered the benchmark of climate change science. It collects and monitors some of the cleanest air in the world from Cape Grim in Tasmania for the World Meteorological Association.
Every year this part of CSIRO produces state of the climate reports with the Australian Bureau of Meteorology to measure the increasing effects of climate change on our country.
I’ll be hosting a community forum on the importance of CSIRO’s Aspendale Centre on 22 March, and it was not hard to convince the former chief scientist of Australia Ian Chubb and climate change expert Will Steffen to come along, such is the depth of respect for its work in the scientific community.
But CSIRO chief executive Larry Marshall, brought in from Silicon Valley by Tony Abbott, believes all these projects should be de-prioritised in favour of climate change mitigation projects and CSIRO should turn its attention to work areas likely to be more commercially viable.
CSIRO is not a glorified consultancy. It is not a start-up looking only to maximise profit opportunities. It is one of the most important scientific institutions in the world with an obligation to do research that is in the long-term public interest, not just the short-term interests of the private sector.
But this is not about Mr Marshall. These decisions would not have been made without the $110 million cut forced on CSIRO in the 2014 federal budget (the one Mr Abbott describes as his “badge of honour”).
Prime Minister Turnbull can reverse these cuts.
The destruction of climate science expertise in Australia’s premier research organisation is not clever, innovative, or agile. It is destructive, clumsy and dumb.
CSIRO cannot and should not exist as a purely commercially-driven organisation. A research rather than a profit focus has still enabled CSIRO scientists to produce some of the most successful scientific patents in Australian history, including Wi-Fi technology, one of the greatest inventions of the digital age. There’s also extended soft-wear contact lenses, Aerogard insect repellent and polymer banknotes.
Commercially driven research and more general research for the “public good” are not incompatible areas of activity for CSIRO. In fact, the former can often flow from the latter. The nature of science is that we sometimes must fund projects that are exploratory without clear and precise objectives to see what they come up with – and sometimes they come up with Wi-Fi.
It is only the Abbott-Turnbull government cuts that have turned this into an either-or situation. Restore the funding, and the balance can be restored.
Mr Turnbull seeks to position himself as a friend of science and a true believer in climate change. But he is leading a party which still, in 2016, is debating whether climate change is real – just look at the NSW Liberal resolution last week to hold a series of debates questioning whether the “science is settled”.
If Mr Turnbull was a bold and decisive leader, he would reverse the cuts to CSIRO now and save Australia’s climate research capacity and reputation for quality science.
Or is he too frightened of the right-wing, climate-sceptic opponents in his own party to do anything?
He needs to make a decision now – not dither until the axe falls.

Links
Analysis CSIRO climate cuts attack a national treasure when we need it most
Climate change has not been answered for farmers: we need more information, not lessRecord-breaking temperatures 'have robbed the Arctic of its winter'

Joe Hockey On CSIRO Cuts: Former Treasurer's Letter To The New York Times Dissected

The Guardian - 

Australia's ambassador to the US defends criticism of his country's climate stance in an editorial – but how do the points he makes stack up?
Former treasurer Joe Hockey, who is now Australia's ambassador to the US, wrote a letter to the New York Times in response to an editorial the newspaper ran titled 'Australia turns its back on climate science'. Photograph: Lukas Coch/EPA

Australia's former treasurer Joe Hockey has weighed into the debate about cuts to climate research at CSIRO, by writing a letter to the New York Times.
In February, CSIRO chief executive Larry Marshall announced the agency would halve its commitment to climate change modelling and measurement.
In his new role as Australia's ambassador to the US, Hockey took umbrage at an editorial the newspaper published, titled "Australia turns its back on climate science".
But in defending Australia's role, he appears to shine a light on budget cuts he made while treasurer, which are now considered partly to blame for the cuts CSIRO's chief executive has made.
His first line of defence in the letter is to point out that there continues to be funding for climate science under the National Environmental Science Program, commonly referred to as Nesp.
Hockey created Nesp in his now notorious 2014-2015 budget. But rather than boosting climate science, it was a budget-saving measure. Nesp was created by amalgamating two other programs and cutting $21.7m in the process.
This fact was raised in a recent Senate inquiry, which examined the cuts.
World-leading CSIRO climate scientist John Church told the Senate in most research programs CSIRO is required to match the funding they receive with revenue from external "clients". But often that client is the government, with money coming from funding programs.
Church said that since CSIRO relied on external funding streams, and the government had shrunk those streams for climate science, it was predictable that CSIRO would move away from conducting climate science research.
"Effectively, at this time we were in a weak position in terms of external earnings," he said.
In his letter, Hockey also said the Australian Antarctic Division and the Bureau of Meteorology would continue to conduct the sort of work that was being cut at CSIRO.
Let's look at the Australian Antarctic Division first. The chief scientist of the Australian Antarctic Division, Gwen Fenton, told a Senate inquiry that about a quarter of their programs rely on the CSIRO in some capacity, and that if CSIRO programs were cut, that would affect their research.
Fenton couldn't quantify the effect, since no details of the cuts have yet been announced. "It is hard to know exactly," she said. "It is hard to conclude that reducing the number of people overall would not reduce the total capability. It is the capability we need in the program."
Then Hockey mentioned the Bureau of Meteorology. That's the bureau that was not told about the cuts more than 24 hours before they were publicly announced. In that hearing, head of the BoM, Rob Vertessy, said there were several joint programs between the two programs and it wasn't clear yet which would be affected. "I am drawing attention to several areas where we are working together, where we are dependent on CSIRO collaboration, and which could be impacted. There are many areas, and it will depend on which of those areas are actually changed."
Hockey's next line was to point out that Australia is "renowned in international climate change forums for contributing a uniquely southern hemisphere perspective". It is the loss of that very reputation – and indeed capability – that has troubled climate scientists in Australia and abroad.
The CSIRO has revealed it is trying to strike a deal with the UK's Met Office to move its unique and highly regarded climate model there, where it is unlikely to get the continued focus on southern hemisphere climate science.
In terms of international reputation, Church told the Senate inquiry it was "already trashed".
Finally, Hockey says "Australia will continue to meet its international climate change obligations and commitments, including those made in the Paris agreement". Indeed, Australia's Climate Council – the reincarnation of the formerly government-run Climate Commission, which Hockey and his government axed – declared in a report that the cuts to climate research at the CSIRO were already in breach of that agreement.

Links

Tuesday, March 15, 2016

Economists Are Out Of Touch With Climate Change

Fairfax - Noah Smith*

If economists are to help us deal with global warming, they need to start studying science.
Economists are as worried by climate change as anyone but have had little impact on public debate about the threat.
Economists are as worried by climate change as anyone but have had little impact on public debate about the threat. Photo: Nic Walker
In the debate over climate change, there is one group from whom you don't hear much: economists. The failure of climate economics to make a difference in the public discussion about climate policy should be a concern for the profession.
Climate economists are just as worried as anyone about the prospect of global warming. A recent survey by the Institute for Policy Integrity found that most climate economists believe climate change is a grave threat. Most supported carbon taxes or cap-and-trade programs to limit emissions, even if these actions were taken unilaterally by the United States. The consensus view was that a catastrophic loss of global gross domestic product – a 25 per cent decline or more – is possible under a "business as usual" scenario.
But for all this concern, economic research has had little impact on the public debate. The problem, as far as I can tell, is that there is a disconnect between climate science and economics. This goes beyond the out-of-date forecasting models used by policy makers. Even within academia, research often uses bad science.
The first climate economics paper I ever read provides a nice illustration of this problem. In 2007, Michael Greenstone, of the University of Chicago, and Olivier Deschenes​, of the University of California-Santa Barbara, published a paper entitled "Climate Change, Mortality, and Adaptation: Evidence from Annual Fluctuations in Weather in the US". The paper tried to estimate how many people would die as a result of global warming. To do this, the authors calculated how many people now die from random temperature fluctuations, due to things such as heat stroke. They then extrapolated this effect using the expected temperature increase from climate change, and found the probable increase in mortality is small.
But there is an obvious problem with this type of analysis, which even a second-year graduate student took about five seconds to figure out.
Global warming will probably kill people in a lot more ways than days of extreme heat do now. If the climate changes a lot, floods will become more common in low-lying areas. Hurricane Katrina provided an example of how a large flood can cause a lot of deaths. This has nothing to do with the mechanism studied by Deschenes and Greenstone – the authors just leave it out. If they had paid more attention to science, they would have taken more sources of mortality into account.
This paper demonstrates how climate economics can go astray. But it is far from an unusual or solitary example. In 2011, the Stockholm Environment Institute published a report that chided climate economists for their failure to keep up with scientific advances.
They glumly reported: "Regrettably, climate economics tends to lag behind climate science, especially in the slow-paced, peer-reviewed economics literature. The analyses rarely portray the most recent advances in climate science; instead, they often incorporate simplified representations of scientific knowledge that is out of date by several years, if not decades. Moreover, climate economics has often been hampered by its uncritical adoption of a traditional cost-benefit framework, minimising or overlooking the deep theoretical problems posed by uncertainty, intergenerational impacts, and long-term technological change."
The disconnect between economics and natural science is certainly part of the problem. Economists are notoriously unwilling to cite research in other social science fields, and this insularity – sometimes called siloing – probably leads them to ignore the natural sciences as well. But many economic phenomena are critically dependent on natural phenomena, so neglecting science can make economic models spit out ludicrous results. Economic models, like any other, are subject to the problem of rubbish in, rubbish out.
This shortcoming plagued a second paper by Deschenes and Greenstone; when they tried to estimate the impact of climate change on agriculture, they were criticised by some of their colleagues for using out-of-date science.
The Stockholm Environment Institute report goes on to detail ways in which economics could improve by paying more attention to the latest science. I am more pessimistic; if top climate economists are ignoring the potential of deaths from flooding, what are the chances they will keep up to date on state-of-the-art models of flood probability?
I suspect there is an even deeper failing than insularity at work here. Many economists treasure their field's ability to produce counter-intuitive results – to tell people things that contradict their intuition. For example, many people think rent control helps poor people; economists have traditionally delighted in explaining to their students why it actually hurts the poor.
Contrarian results such as these are prized, because they seem to show that economics has something to offer that other disciplines don't. Economists probably have the urge to find results showing that, contrary to popular belief, climate change will be benign, or even beneficial, to humanity.
But bias in favour of counter-intuitive results is as bad as any other form of research bias. If biologists came out with a study showing that eating nuclear waste for breakfast is good for you, it would be both eye-catching and at odds with common knowledge, but it would also be silly. In order to have more relevance to the public debate, climate economics should avoid the temptation to be cute, and just get the science right.

*Noah Smith is an assistant professor of finance at Stony Brook University and a freelance writer for finance and business publications.

Record-Breaking Heat Shows World 'Losing Battle' Against Climate Change, Alan Finkel Tells Q&A

ABC News

NASA's analysis of satellite data shows extreme hot spots across the Arctic, Russia, and northern North America. (Supplied: NASA/GISS)

Australia's chief scientist has warned the planet is "losing the battle" against climate change, after new data showed February set a "completely unprecedented" record for the hottest month since global records began.
Key points:
  • February was the hottest seasonally adjusted month since records began in 1880
  • Global temperatures are around 1C warmer than the pre-industrial average
  • Chief scientist Alan Finkel tells Q&A the world is losing battle against climate change
The data released by NASA compared each month going back to 1880 against average temperatures between 1951 and 1980, and confirmed preliminary analysis that February was the hottest month on record.
"You wouldn't want to dismiss it. There is genuine reason for concern," Dr Alan Finkel said during an appearance on the ABC's Q&A program, which focused on science and also discussed AI and gender equality.
"For all the effort we are putting into trying to avoid increases of emission, we are losing.
"What we are doing with solar, wind, changing practices, behavioural practices and things like that, we're not winning the battle."
Meteorologist Dr Jeff Masters said although the absolute hottest month on record was July 2015, July and August tend to be 4C hotter than January and February because the large land mass in the Northern Hemisphere cools the planet during the northern winter.
Writing on the Weather Underground blog, Dr Masters and his co-author Bob Henson said February was exceptional because it was 1.35C hotter than the long-term average, while July was only 0.75C hotter than average.
"Perhaps even more remarkable is that February 2015 crushed the previous February record [set during the peak of the 1997-98 El Nino] by a massive 0.47C," they wrote.
The previous record was January this year, at 1.14C hotter than average, which broke the December 2015 record of 1.10C.
NASA's data also showed that although October 2015 was the first month since 1880 to be more than 1C warmer than average, every month since October has exceeded that mark.
The last month to be colder than average was September 1992, and the last year with two months colder than average was 1978.

Warming 'completely unprecedented', world now in a climate emergency
Dr Masters and Mr Henson described February's result as "an extraordinary margin to beat a monthly world temperature record by," and an "ominous milestone".
"This result is a true shocker, and yet another reminder of the incessant long-term rise in global temperature resulting from human-produced greenhouse gases," they said.
Professor Stefan Rahmstorf from the Potsdam Institute of Climate Impact Research and a visiting professorial fellow at the University of NSW, told Fairfax Media the warming was "completely unprecedented."
"We are in a kind of climate emergency now," he said.
"Governments have promised to act and they need to do better than what they promised in Paris."
The COP21 climate conference in Paris signed an agreement in December 2016 that repeated a 2C target but said the world should pursue a target of limiting warning to 1.5C above pre-industrial levels.
However, Dr Masters said the world is already 1C warmer than the late nineteenth century, and heat stored in the oceans has already committed us to at least another 0.5 degrees of atmospheric warming.
"In short, we are now hurtling at a frightening pace toward the globally agreed maximum of 2.0C warming over pre-industrial levels," he said.
Dr Masters said the next several months should remain well above the long-term average, and 2016 may top 2015 as the warmest year in global record-keeping.

Links

Climate Change And The 2016 US Election

Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists - Richard C. J. Somerville* | Catherine Gautier*

As this is written, all four remaining candidates in the race for the Republican presidential nomination vehemently reject the fundamental findings of modern climate science. These findings are simple to state:
The Earth's climate is now unequivocally warming. Many chains of evidence demonstrate the warming, including increasing atmospheric and ocean temperatures, rising sea levels, shrinking glaciers and ice sheets, and changing precipitation patterns. The main cause of the warming is human activities, especially burning fossil fuels, which increases the amount of heat-trapping gases in the atmosphere. The effects of man-made climate change are already being felt, and they are mainly harmful. The consequences of climate change will become much more severe in the future, unless global actions are taken soon to drastically reduce the amount of heat-trapping gases emitted into the atmosphere.
These conclusions are the results of decades of research by the international scientific community. They have been endorsed by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, and by the National Academy of Sciences and leading scientific professional societies in the US and other countries. The great majority of mainstream climate scientists such as ourselves find these results persuasive.
Nevertheless, Ted Cruz heaps scorn on what he has called "a pseudo-scientific theory." He has dismissed it as, "not science, it's a religion." John Kasich says, "I don't believe that humans are the primary cause of climate change." Marco Rubio agrees, stating, "I do not believe that human activity is causing these dramatic changes to our climate the way these scientists are portraying it." Donald Trump speaks of a "global warming hoax," calling it, "created by and for the Chinese."
These public figures reject mainstream climate science because they view it through a lens that incorporates their firmly held values and convictions. They have a high regard for American capitalism and private industry, or the free enterprise system, and a low regard for taxes and regulation, which they regard as government interference. In rejecting mainstream science, they are expressing their opposition to policies that governments might implement, if the science were accepted.
In the United States, aspiring Republican politicians may also feel the pressure to conform to a litmus test. In order to obtain political and financial support, especially from sources allied with the fossil fuel industry, they may conclude that they must attack mainstream climate science and insist that man-made climate change is not a problem.
However, Mother Nature, or the physical climate system, is not concerned with anybody's values or convictions or political litmus tests. Mother Nature is concerned with natural laws. Heat-trapping gases in the atmosphere do trap heat. That leads to warming. After every politician has expressed an opinion, Mother Nature bats last. Daniel Patrick Moynihan, a politician and sociologist, famously said, "Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not to his own facts."
Yet the Republican Presidential candidates have gone to a great deal of trouble to avoid confronting the facts about climate change. They tirelessly repeat climate myths, the refutations of which are easily found on websites such as www.skepticalscience.com. These politicians like to say, "I am not a scientist," a truth sadly obvious to any scientist. Yet they have refused to learn what science has discovered about climate change. When Republicans in Congress have held hearings on climate change, they produce tired re-runs of political theater. The scientists invited to testify often include the same handful of outlier witnesses whose opinions are known to be compatible with Republican political positions.
Science is the best process that humanity has developed to learn about natural laws. It is self-correcting, based on facts and evidence, not on belief. Marcia McNutt, the distinguished geophysicist who is the incoming president of the US National Academy of Sciences, has said, "Science is a method for deciding whether what we choose to believe has a basis in the laws of nature or not."
Most of the world now accepts that climate science can provide useful input to policymaking. Some 196 countries recently produced the Paris agreement. Stabilizing the climate and preventing dangerous levels of climate disruption, the goal of this agreement, will require vigorous international efforts and strong American leadership. Only one major country today has an important political party that overwhelmingly rejects climate science. That country is the United States; the party is Republican.
Science shows that the climate system responds to the cumulative emissions of heat-trapping gases. Today's generation thus has its hands on the thermostat controlling future climate. Failure to sharply reduce emissions can lead to sea level rise that will literally change the map of the world. Electing a president who, head in the sand, rejects modern climate science would be risky and potentially disastrous. It would needlessly increase the likelihood that future generations will be condemned to cope with a severely disrupted climate.

*Catherine Gautier is a professor emerita at the University of California, Santa Barbara. She has taught classes on climate, energy, and water at both undergraduate and graduate levels.
*Richard Somerville is Distinguished Professor Emeritus and Research Professor at Scripps Institution of Oceanography, University of California, San Diego.

Links

Monday, March 14, 2016

'True Shocker': February Spike In Global Temperatures Stuns Scientists

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

Global temperatures leapt in February, lifting warming from pre-industrial levels to beyond 1.5 degrees, and stoking concerns about a "climate emergency".
According to NASA analysis, average temperatures last month were 1.35 degrees above the norm for the 1951-1980 period.
The jump in temperatures last month was unprecedented in more than a century of records. Photo: Tom Corra

They smashed the previous biggest departure from the average - set only in the previous month - by 0.21 degrees.
"This is really quite stunning ... it's completely unprecedented," said Stefan Rahmstorf, from Germany's Potsdam Institute of Climate Impact Research and a visiting professorial fellow at the University of NSW, noting the NASA data as reported by the Wunderground blog.

The blog's authors, Jeff Masters and Bob Henson, described February's spike as "a true shocker, and yet another reminder of the incessant long-term rise in global temperature resulting from human-produced greenhouse gases".
The monster El Nino event had contributed to the current record run of global temperatures by increasing the area of abnormally warm water in the central and eastern Pacific.
Compared with the rival record giant El Nino of 1997-98, global temperatures are running about 0.5 degrees hotter.
"That shows how much much global warming we have had since then," Professor Rahmstorf said.
The first half of March is at least as warm, he added, and it means temperatures "are clearly more than 1.5 degrees above pre-industrial levels".

'Emergency'
"We are in a kind of climate emergency now," Professor Rahmstorf said, noting that global carbon dioxide levels last year rose by a record rate of more than 3 parts per million.
"Governments have promised to act [to curb greenhouse gas emissions] and they need to do better than what they promised in Paris" at the global climate summit last December, he said.
Australia has not dodged the heat, either, with record national temperatures falling at the start of March, the Bureau of Meteorology said in a special climate statement.
The heat surge also comes as the future of climate science hangs in the balance in Australia , with the CSIRO planning to slash monitoring and modelling research.
The most northerly latitudes of the planet were the most abnormally hot regions in February, with large areas reporting temperatures 12 degrees or warmer than average, the NASA data shows.

The unusual heat in the far north means the Arctic sea ice will be thinner and more vulnerable to melting as the region heads into the warmer months, Professor Rahmstorf said.
Arctic sea ice is already at its smallest extent for this time of year on record. The relatively warm seas are contributing to a warmer atmosphere, reinforcing the long-term trend.

As the Wunderground blog noted, the impacts of the unusual global heat have been felt far and wide, including in severe droughts in Vietnam and Zimbabwe.
Fiji, meanwhile, continues work to recover from Cyclone Winston, the most powerful storm recorded in the southern hemisphere.
"[This warming] is not harmless," Professor Rahmstorf said. "It has quite a negative impact on society and the biosphere."
While February's global heat spike is unlikely to be sustained as the El Nino winds down, the latest indicators "are all symptoms of the general warming trend", he said.

Reef worries
Australia may also see some of that impact in coming weeks, with a large region of the Great Barrier Reef under threat from coral bleaching, according to the latest data from the US National Ocean and Atmospheric Administration.

The Great Barrier Marine Park Authority said on Monday that it detected "highly variable but widespread coral bleaching" across the park.
The area around Lizard Island, situated 250 km north of Cairns, and sites further north, had fared the worst, Russell Reichelt, the authority's chair, said in a statement.
"This is the result of sea-surface temperatures climbing as high as 33 degrees during February," Dr Reichelt said. "In the far north, the surveys found severe bleaching on inshore reefs, along with moderate bleaching on mid-shelf reefs."
Cloud cover had helped to moderate bleaching on southern reefs.
"The events on the Great Barrier Reef are part of the global pressure on coral reefs during a strong El Nino weather system which also affected reefs in Hawaii and the Caribbean," Dr Reichelt said, adding that about 5 per cent of shallow reefs had died as a result of bleaching events in 1998 and 2002.
"Bleaching is a vivid reminder of the need for all of us to continue building the resilience of coral reefs to give them the best chance of dealing with increasing climate change impacts," he said.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative