Monday, March 28, 2016

 Global Warming’s Terrifying New Chemistry

The Nation - Bill McKibben

Our leaders thought fracking would save our climate. They were wrong. Very wrong.
A fracking well in the Eagle Ford Shale region, near Karnes City, Texas. (AP Photo / Aaron M. Sprecher)

 Global warming is, in the end, not about the noisy political battles here on the planet's surface. It actually happens in constant, silent interactions in the atmosphere, where the molecular structure of certain gases traps heat that would otherwise radiate back out to space. If you get the chemistry wrong, it doesn't matter how many landmark climate agreements you sign or how many speeches you give. And it appears the United States may have gotten the chemistry wrong. Really wrong.
There's one greenhouse gas everyone knows about: carbon dioxide, which is what you get when you burn fossil fuels. We talk about a "price on carbon" or argue about a carbon tax; our leaders boast about modest "carbon reductions." But in the last few weeks, CO2's nasty little brother has gotten some serious press. Meet methane, otherwise known as CH4.
In February, Harvard researchers published an explosive paper in Geophysical Research Letters. Using satellite data and ground observations, they concluded that the nation as a whole is leaking methane in massive quantities. Between 2002 and 2014, the data showed that US methane emissions increased by more than 30 percent, accounting for 30 to 60 percent of an enormous spike in methane in the entire planet's atmosphere.
To the extent our leaders have cared about climate change, they've fixed on CO2. Partly as a result, coal-fired power plants have begun to close across the country. They've been replaced mostly with ones that burn natural gas, which is primarily composed of methane. Because burning natural gas releases significantly less carbon dioxide than burning coal, CO2 emissions have begun to trend slowly downward, allowing politicians to take a bow. But this new Harvard data, which comes on the heels of other aerial surveys showing big methane leakage, suggests that our new natural-gas infrastructure has been bleeding methane into the atmosphere in record quantities. And molecule for molecule, this unburned methane is much, much more efficient at trapping heat than carbon dioxide.
The EPA insisted this wasn't happening, that methane was on the decline just like CO2. But it turns out, as some scientists have been insisting for years, the EPA was wrong. Really wrong. This error is the rough equivalent of the New York Stock Exchange announcing tomorrow that the Dow Jones isn't really at 17,000: Its computer program has been making a mistake, and your index fund actually stands at 11,000.
These leaks are big enough to wipe out a large share of the gains from the Obama administration's work on climate change—all those closed coal mines and fuel-efficient cars. In fact, it's even possible that America's contribution to global warming increased during the Obama years. The methane story is utterly at odds with what we've been telling ourselves, not to mention what we've been telling the rest of the planet. It undercuts the promises we made at the climate talks in Paris. It's a disaster—and one that seems set to spread.
The Obama administration, to its credit, seems to be waking up to the problem. Over the winter, the EPA began to revise its methane calculations, and in early March, the United States reached an agreement with Canada to begin the arduous task of stanching some of the leaks from all that new gas infrastructure. But none of this gets to the core problem, which is the rapid spread of fracking. Carbon dioxide is driving the great warming of the planet, but CO2 isn't doing it alone. It's time to take methane seriously.
* * *
To understand how we got here, it's necessary to remember what a savior fracked natural gas looked like to many people, environmentalists included. As George W. Bush took hold of power in Washington, coal was ascendant, here and around the globe. Cheap and plentiful, it was most visibly underwriting the stunning growth of the economy in China, where, by some estimates, a new coal-fired power plant was opening every week. The coal boom didn't just mean smoggy skies over Beijing; it meant the planet's invisible cloud of carbon dioxide was growing faster than ever, and with it the certainty of dramatic global warming.
So lots of people thought it was great news when natural-gas wildcatters began rapidly expanding fracking in the last decade. Fracking involves exploding the sub-surface geology so that gas can leak out through newly opened pores; its refinement brought online new shale deposits across the continent—most notably the Marcellus Shale, stretching from West Virginia up into Pennsylvania and New York. The quantities of gas that geologists said might be available were so vast that they were measured in trillions of cubic feet and in centuries of supply.
The apparently happy fact was that when you burn natural gas, it releases half as much carbon dioxide as coal. A power plant that burned natural gas would therefore, or so the reasoning went, be half as bad for global warming as a power plant that burned coal. Natural gas was also cheap—so, from a politician's point of view, fracking was a win-win situation. You could appease the environmentalists with their incessant yammering about climate change without having to run up the cost of electricity. It would be painless environmentalism, the equivalent of losing weight by cutting your hair.
It's possible that America's contribution to global warming increased during the Obama years.
And it appeared even better than that. If you were President Obama and had inherited a dead-in-the-water economy, the fracking boom offered one of the few economic bright spots. Not only did it employ lots of people, but cheap natural gas had also begun to alter the country's economic equation: Manufacturing jobs were actually returning from overseas, attracted by newly abundant energy. In his 2012 State of the Union address, Obama declared that new natural-gas supplies would not only last the nation a century, but would create 600,000 new jobs by decade's end. In his 2014 address, he announced that "businesses plan to invest almost $100 billion in factories that use natural gas," and pledged to "cut red tape" to get it all done. In fact, the natural-gas revolution has been a constant theme of his energy policy, the tool that made his restrictions on coal palatable. And Obama was never shy about taking credit for at least part of the boom. Public research dollars, he said in 2012, "helped develop the technologies to extract all this natural gas out of shale rock—reminding us that government support is critical in helping businesses get new energy ideas off the ground."
Obama had plenty of help selling natural gas—from the fossil-fuel industry, but also from environmentalists, at least for a while. Robert Kennedy Jr., who had enormous credibility as the founder of the Waterkeeper Alliance and a staff attorney at the Natural Resources Defense Council, wrote a paean in 2009 to the "revolution…over the past two years [that] has left America awash in natural gas and has made it possible to eliminate most of our dependence on deadly, destructive coal practically overnight." Meanwhile, the longtime executive director of the Sierra Club, Carl Pope, had not only taken $25 million from one of the nation's biggest frackers, Chesapeake Energy, to fund his organization, but was also making appearances with the company's CEO to tout the advantages of gas, "an excellent example of a fuel that can be produced in quite a clean way, and shouldn't be wasted." (That CEO, Aubrey McClendon, apparently killed himself earlier this month, crashing his car into a bridge embankment days after being indicted for bid-rigging.) Exxon was in apparent agreement as well: It purchased XTO Energy, becoming the biggest fracker in the world overnight and allowing the company to make the claim that it was helping to drive emissions down.
For a brief shining moment, you couldn't have asked for more. As Obama told a joint session of Congress, "The development of natural gas will create jobs and power trucks and factories that are cleaner and cheaper, proving that we don't have to choose between our environment and our economy."
* * *
Unless, of course, you happened to live in the fracking zone, where nightmares were starting to unfold. In recent decades, most American oil and gas exploration had been concentrated in the western United States, often far from population centers. When there were problems, politicians and media in these states paid little attention.
The Marcellus Shale, though, underlies densely populated eastern states. It wasn't long before stories about the pollution of farm fields and contamination of drinking water from fracking chemicals began to make their way into the national media. In the Delaware Valley, after a fracking company tried to lease his family's farm, a young filmmaker named Josh Fox produced one of the classic environmental documentaries of all time, Gasland, which became instantly famous for its shot of a man lighting on fire the methane flowing from his water faucet.
This reporting helped galvanize a movement—at first town by town, then state by state, and soon across whole regions. The activism was most feverish in New York, where residents could look across the Pennsylvania line and see the ecological havoc that fracking caused. Scores of groups kept up unrelenting pressure that eventually convinced Governor Andrew Cuomo to ban it. Long before that happened, the big environmental groups recanted much of their own support for fracking: The Sierra Club's new executive director, Michael Brune, not only turned down $30 million in potential donations from fracking companies but came out swinging against the practice. "The club needs to…advocate more fiercely to use as little gas as possible," he said. "We're not going to mute our voice on this." As for Robert Kennnedy Jr., by 2013 he was calling natural gas a "catastrophe."
In the end, one of the most important outcomes of the antifracking movement may have been that it attracted the attention of a couple of Cornell scientists. Living on the northern edge of the Marcellus Shale, Robert Howarth and Anthony Ingraffea got interested in the outcry. While everyone else was focused on essentially local issues—would fracking chemicals get in the water supply?—they decided to look more closely at a question that had never gotten much attention: How much methane was invisibly being leaked by these fracking operations?
Natural gas was also cheap—so, from a politician's point of view, fracking was a win-win situation.
Because here's the unhappy fact about methane: Though it produces only half as much carbon as coal when you burn it, if you don't—if it escapes into the air before it can be captured in a pipeline, or anywhere else along its route to a power plant or your stove—then it traps heat in the atmosphere much more efficiently than CO2. Howarth and Ingraffea began producing a series of papers claiming that if even a small percentage of the methane leaked—maybe as little as 3 percent—then fracked gas would do more climate damage than coal. And their preliminary data showed that leak rates could be at least that high: that somewhere between 3.6 and 7.9 percent of methane gas from shale-drilling operations actually escapes into the atmosphere.
To say that no one in power wanted to hear this would be an understatement. The two scientists were roundly attacked by the industry; one trade group called their study the "Ivory Tower's latest fact-free assault on shale gas exploration." Most of the energy establishment joined in. An MIT team, for instance, had just finished an industry-funded report that found "the environmental impacts of shale development are challenging but manageable"; one of its lead authors, the ur-establishment energy expert Henry Jacoby, described the Cornell research as "very weak." One of its other authors, Ernest Moniz, would soon become the US secretary of energy; in his nomination hearings in 2013, he lauded the "stunning increase" in natural gas as a "revolution" and pledged to increase its use domestically.
The trouble for the fracking establishment was that new research kept backing up Howarth and Ingraffea. In January 2013, for instance, aerial overflights of fracking basins in Utah found leak rates as high as 9 percent. "We were expecting to see high methane levels, but I don't think anybody really comprehended the true magnitude of what we would see," said the study's director. But such work was always piecemeal, one area at a time, while other studies—often conducted with industry-supplied data—came up with lower numbers.
* * *
That's why last month's Harvard study came as such a shock. It used satellite data from across the country over a span of more than a decade to demonstrate that US methane emissions had spiked 30 percent since 2002. The EPA had been insisting throughout that period that methane emissions were actually falling, but it was clearly wrong—on a massive scale. In fact, emissions "are substantially higher than we've understood," EPA Administrator Gina McCarthy admitted in early March. The Harvard study wasn't designed to show why US methane emissions were growing—in other parts of the world, as new research makes clear, cattle and wetlands seem to be causing emissions to accelerate. But the spike that the satellites recorded coincided almost perfectly with the era when fracking went big-time.
To make matters worse, during the same decade, experts had become steadily more worried about the effects of methane in any quantity on the atmosphere. Everyone agrees that, molecule for molecule, methane traps far more heat than CO2—but exactly how much wasn't clear. One reason the EPA estimates of America's greenhouse-gas emissions showed such improvement was because the agency, following standard procedures, was assigning a low value to methane and measuring its impact over a 100-year period. But a methane molecule lasts only a couple of decades in the air, compared with centuries for CO2. That's good news, in that methane's effects are transient—and very bad news because that transient but intense effect happens right now, when we're breaking the back of the planet's climate. The EPA's old chemistry and 100-year time frame assigned methane a heating value of 28 to 36 times that of carbon dioxide; a more accurate figure, says Howarth, is between 86 and 105 times the potency of CO2 over the next decade or two.
If you combine Howarth's estimates of leakage rates and the new standard values for the heat-trapping potential of methane, then the picture of America's total greenhouse-gas emissions over the last 15 years looks very different: Instead of peaking in 2007 and then trending downward, as the EPA has maintained, our combined emissions of methane and carbon dioxide have gone steadily and sharply up during the Obama years, Howarth says. We closed coal plants and opened methane leaks, and the result is that things have gotten worse.
Since Howarth is an outspoken opponent of fracking, I ran the Harvard data past an impeccably moderate referee, the venerable climate-policy wonk Dan Lashof. A UC Berkeley PhD who has been in the inner circles of climate policy almost since it began, Lashof has helped write reports from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and craft the Obama administration's plan to cut coal-plant pollution. The longtime head of the Clean Air Program at the Natural Resources Defense Council, he is now the chief operations officer of billionaire Tom Steyer's NextGen Climate America.
We closed coal plants and opened methane leaks, and the result is that things have gotten worse.
"The Harvard paper is important," Lashof said. "It's the most convincing new data I have seen showing that the EPA's estimates of the methane-leak rate are much too low. I think this paper shows that US greenhouse-gas emissions may have gone up over the last decade if you focus on the combined short-term-warming impact."
Under the worst-case scenario—one that assumes that methane is extremely potent and extremely fast-acting—the United States has actually slightly increased its greenhouse-gas emissions from 2005 to 2015. That's the chart below: the blue line shows what we've been telling ourselves and the world about our emissions—that they are falling. The red line, the worst-case calculation from the new numbers, shows just the opposite.
Lashof argues for a more moderate reading of the numbers (calculating methane's impact over 50 years, for instance). But even this estimate—one that attributes less of the methane release to fracking—wipes out as much as three-fifths of the greenhouse-gas reductions that the United States has been claiming. This more modest reassessment is the yellow line in the chart below; it shows the country reducing its greenhouse-gas emissions, but by nowhere near as much as we had thought.

 The lines are doubtless not as smooth as the charts imply, and other studies will provide more detail and perhaps shift the calculations. But any reading of the new data offers a very different version of our recent history. Among other things, either case undercuts the statistics that America used to negotiate the Paris climate accord. It's more upsetting than the discovery last year that China had underestimated its coal use, because China now appears to be cutting back aggressively on coal. If the Harvard data hold up and we keep on fracking, it will be nearly impossible for the United States to meet its promised goal of a 26 to 28 percent reduction in greenhouse gases from 2005 levels by 2025.
 One obvious conclusion from the new data is that we need to move very aggressively to plug as many methane leaks as possible. "The biggest unfinished business for the Obama administration is to establish tight rules on methane emissions from existing [wells and drill sites]," Lashof says. That's the work that Obama and Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau promised to tackle at their conclave in March—although given the time it takes for the EPA to draft new rules, it will likely be long after Obama's departure before anything happens, and the fossil-fuel industry has vowed to fight new regulations.
Also, containing the leaks is easier said than done: After all, methane is a gas, meaning that it's hard to prevent it from escaping. Since methane is invisible and odorless (utilities inject a separate chemical to add a distinctive smell), you need special sensors to even measure leaks. Catastrophic blowouts like the recent one at Porter Ranch in California pour a lot of methane into the air, but even these accidents are small compared to the total seeping out from the millions of pipes, welds, joints, and valves across the country—especially the ones connected with fracking operations, which involve exploding rock to make large, leaky pores. A Canadian government team examined the whole process a couple of years ago and came up with despairing conclusions. Consider the cement seals around drill pipes, says Harvard's Naomi Oreskes, who was a member of the team: "It sounds like it ought to be simple to make a cement seal, but the phrase we finally fixed on is 'an unresolved engineering challenge.' The technical problem is that when you pour cement into a well and it solidifies, it shrinks. You can get gaps in the cement. All wells leak."
With that in mind, the other conclusion from the new data is even more obvious: We need to stop the fracking industry in its tracks, here and abroad. Even with optimistic numbers for all the plausible leaks fixed, Howarth says, methane emissions will keep rising if we keep fracking.
And if we didn't frack, what would we do instead? Ten years ago, the realistic choice was between natural gas and coal. But that choice is no longer germane: Over the same 10 years, the price of a solar panel has dropped at least 80 percent. New inventions have come online, such as air-source heat pumps, which use the latent heat in the air to warm and cool houses, and electric storage batteries. We've reached the point where Denmark can generate 42 percent of its power from the wind, and where Bangladesh is planning to solarize every village in the country within the next five years. We've reached the point, that is, where the idea of natural gas as a "bridge fuel" to a renewable future is a marketing slogan, not a realistic claim (even if that's precisely the phrase that Hillary Clinton used to defend fracking in a debate earlier this month).
One of the nastiest side effects of the fracking boom, in fact, is that the expansion of natural gas has undercut the market for renewables, keeping us from putting up windmills and solar panels at the necessary pace. Joe Romm, a climate analyst at the Center for American Progress, has been tracking the various economic studies more closely than anyone else. Even if you could cut the methane-leakage rates to zero, Romm says, fracked gas (which, remember, still produces 50 percent of the CO2 level emitted by coal when you burn it) would do little to cut the world's greenhouse-gas emissions because it would displace so much truly clean power. A Stanford forum in 2014 assembled more than a dozen expert teams, and their models showed what a drag on a sustainable future cheap, abundant gas would be. "Cutting greenhouse-gas emissions by burning natural gas is like dieting by eating reduced-fat cookies," the principal investigator of the Stanford forum explained. "If you really want to lose weight, you probably need to avoid cookies altogether."
Of course, if you're a cookie company, that's not what you want to hear. And the Exxons have a little more political juice than the Keeblers. To give just one tiny example, during his first term, Obama's then–deputy assistant for energy and climate change, Heather Zichal, headed up an interagency working group to promote the development of domestic natural gas. The working group had been formed after pressure from the American Petroleum Institute, the chief fossil-fuel lobbying group, and Zichal, in a talk to an API gathering, said: "It's hard to overstate how natural gas—and our ability to access more of it than ever—has become a game changer, and that's why it's been a fixture of the president's 'All of the Above' energy strategy." Zichal left her White House job in 2013; one year later, she took a new post on the board of Cheniere Energy, a leading exporter of fracked gas. In the $180,000-a-year job, she joined former CIA head John Deutch, who once led an Energy Department review of fracking safety during the Obama years, and Vicky Bailey, a commissioner of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission under Bill Clinton. That's how it works.
* * *
There was one oddly reassuring number in the Harvard satellite data: The massive new surge of methane from the United States constituted somewhere between 30 and 60 percent of the global growth in methane emissions this past decade. In other words, the relatively small percentage of the planet's surface known as the United States accounts for much (if not most) of the spike in atmospheric methane around the world. Another way of saying this is: We were the first to figure out how to frack. In this new century, we're leading the world into the natural-gas age, just as we poured far more carbon into the 20th-century atmosphere than any other nation. So, thank God, now that we know there's a problem, we could warn the rest of the planet before it goes down the same path.
Except we've been doing exactly the opposite. We've become the planet's salesman for natural gas—and a key player in this scheme could become the next president of the United States. When Hillary Clinton took over the State Department, she set up a special arm, the Bureau of Energy Resources, after close consultation with oil and gas executives. This bureau, with 63 employees, was soon helping sponsor conferences around the world. And much more: Diplomatic cables released by WikiLeaks show that the secretary of state was essentially acting as a broker for the shale-gas industry, twisting the arms of world leaders to make sure US firms got to frack at will.
To take just one example, an article in Mother Jones based on the WikiLeaks cables reveals what happened when fracking came to Bulgaria. In 2011, the country signed a $68 million deal with Chevron, granting the company millions of acres in shale-gas concessions. The Bulgarian public wasn't happy: Tens of thousands were in the streets of Sofia with banners reading Stop Fracking With Our Water. But when Clinton came for a state visit in 2012, she sided with Chevron (one of whose executives had bundled large sums for her presidential campaign in 2008). In fact, the leaked cables show that the main topic of her meetings with Bulgaria's leaders was fracking. Clinton offered to fly in the "best specialists on these new technologies to present the benefits to the Bulgarian people," and she dispatched her Eurasian energy envoy, Richard Morningstar, to lobby hard against a fracking ban in neighboring Romania. Eventually, they won those battles—and today, the State Department provides "assistance" with fracking to dozens of countries around the world, from Cambodia to Papua New Guinea.
So if the United States has had a terrible time tracking down and fixing its methane leaks, ask yourself how it's going to go in Bulgaria. If Canada finds that sealing leaks is an "unresolved engineering challenge," ask yourself how Cambodia's going to make out. If the State Department has its way, then in a few years Harvard's satellites will be measuring gushers of methane from every direction.
* * *
Of course, we can—and perhaps we should— forgive all that past. The information about methane is relatively new; when Obama and Clinton and Zichal started backing fracking, they didn't really know. They could have turned around much earlier, like Kennedy or the Sierra Club. But what they do now will be decisive.
There are a few promising signs. Clinton has at least tempered her enthusiasm for fracking some in recent debates, listing a series of preconditions she'd insist on before new projects were approved; Bernie Sanders, by contrast, has called for a moratorium on new fracking. But Clinton continues to conflate and confuse the chemistry: Natural gas, she said in a recent position paper, has helped US carbon emissions "reach their lowest level in 20 years." It appears that many in power would like to carry on the fracking revolution, albeit a tad more carefully.
Indeed, just last month, Cheniere Energy shipped the first load of American gas overseas from its new export terminal at Sabine Pass in Louisiana. As the ship sailed, Cheniere's vice president of marketing, Meg Gentle, told industry and government officials that natural gas should be rebranded as renewable energy. "I'd challenge everyone here to reframe the debate and make sure natural gas is part of the category of clean energy, not a fossil-fuel category, which is viewed as dirty and not part of the solution," she said. A few days later, Exxon's PR chief, writing in the Los Angeles Times, boasted that the company had been "instrumental in America's shale gas revolution," and that as a result, "America's greenhouse gas emissions have declined to levels not seen since the 1990s."
The new data prove them entirely wrong. The global-warming fight can't just be about carbon dioxide any longer. Those local environmentalists, from New York State to Tasmania, who have managed to enforce fracking bans are doing as much for the climate as they are for their own clean water. That's because fossil fuels are the problem in global warming—and fossil fuels don't come in good and bad flavors. Coal and oil and natural gas have to be left in the ground. All of them.

Renewable Energy Investments: Major Milestones Reached, New World Record Set

United Nations Environment Programme

Summary
  • Coal and gas-fired generation attracted less than half as much capacity investment as renewables last year;
  • Renewables added more to global energy generation capacity than all other technologies combined;
  • For first time, developing world investments in renewables (up 19% in 2015) topped developed nations' (down 8%);
  • World record total of $286 billion invested in renewables last year; makes $2.3 trillion over 12 years
Photo Copyright: PATRICK PLEUL / AFP Reporters

Coal and gas-fired electricity generation last year drew less than half the record investment made in solar, wind and other renewables capacity - one of several important firsts for green energy announced today in a UN-backed report.
Global Trends in Renewable Energy Investment 2016, the 10th edition of the UN Environment Programme's (UNEP's) annual publication, launched today by the Frankfurt School-UNEP Collaborating Centre for Climate & Sustainable Energy Finance and Bloomberg New Energy Finance (BNEF), says the annual global investment in new renewables capacity, at $266 billion, was more than double the estimated $130 billion invested in coal and gas power stations in 2015.
All investments in renewables, including early-stage technology and research and development as well as spending on new capacity, totalled $286 billion in 2015, some 3 per cent higher than the previous record in 2011. Since 2004, the world has invested $2.3 trillion in renewable energy (unadjusted for inflation).
(All figures for renewables in this release include wind, solar, biomass and waste-to-energy, biofuels, geothermal, marine and small hydro, but exclude large hydro-electric projects of more than 50 megawatts.)
Just as significantly, developing world investments in renewables topped those of developed nations for the first time in 2015.
Helped by further falls in generating costs per megawatt-hour, particularly in solar photovoltaics, renewables excluding large hydro made up 54 per cent of added gigawatt capacity of all technologies last year. It marks the first time new installed renewables have topped the capacity added from all conventional technologies.
Further Resources
The 134 gigawatts (GW) of renewable power added worldwide in 2015 compares to 106GW in 2014 and 87GW in 2013.
Were it not for renewables excluding large hydro, annual global CO2emissions would have been an estimated 1.5 gigatonnes higher in 2015.
UNEP Executive Director Achim Steiner said, "Renewables are becoming ever more central to our low-carbon lifestyles, and the record-setting investments in 2015 are further proof of this trend. Importantly, for the first time in 2015, renewables in investments were higher in developing countries than developed."
"Access to clean, modern energy is of enormous value for all societies, but especially so in regions where reliable energy can offer profound improvements in quality of life, economic development and environmental sustainability. Continued and increased investment in renewables is not only good for people and planet, but will be a key element in achieving international targets on climate change and sustainable development."
"By adopting the Sustainable Development Goals last year, the world pledged to end poverty, promote sustainable development, and to ensure healthier lives and access to affordable, sustainable, clean energy for all. Continued and increased investment in renewables will be a significant part of delivering on that promise."
Said Michael Liebreich, Chairman of the Advisory Board at BNEF: "Global investment in renewables capacity hit a new record in 2015, far outpacing that in fossil fuel generating capacity despite falling oil, gas and coal prices. It has broadened out to a wider and wider array of developing countries, helped by sharply reduced costs and by the benefits of local power production over reliance on imported commodities."
As in previous years, the report shows the 2015 renewable energy market was dominated by solar photovoltaics and wind, which together added 118GW in generating capacity, far above the previous record of 94GW set in 2014. Wind added 62GW and photovoltaics 56GW. More modest amounts were provided by biomass and waste-to-power, geothermal, solar thermal and small hydro.
In 2015, more attention was drawn to battery storage as an adjunct to solar and wind projects and to small-scale PV systems. Energy storage is of significant importance as it is one way of providing fast-responding balancing to the grid, whether to deal with demand spikes or variable renewable power generation from wind and solar. Last year, some 250MW of utility-scale electricity storage (excluding pumped hydro and lead-acid batteries) was installed worldwide, up from 160MW in 2014.

Additional energy generating capacity, 2015:
Renewables (excl. large hydro) 134 GW
  • Large Hydro: 22 GW
  • Nuclear: 15 GW
  • Coal-fired: 42 GW
  • Gas-fired: 40 GW
Annual global investments in renewable energy ($US):
  • $286 billion (2015)
  • $273 billion (2014)
  • $234 billion (2013)
  • $257 billion (2012)
  • $279 billion (2011)
  • $239 billion (2010)
  • $179 billion (2009)
  • $182 billion (2008)
  • $154 billion (2007)
  • $112 billion (2006)
  • $73 billion (2005)
  • $47 billion (2004)
12 year total:
  • $2.3 trillion (unadjusted for inflation)
Developing countries on the rise led by China and India
In 2015, for the first time, investments in renewable energy in developing and emerging economy nations ($156 billion, up 19 per cent compared to 2014) surpassed those in developed countries ($130 billion, down 8 per cent from 2014).
Much of these record-breaking developing world investments took place in China (up 17 per cent to $102.9 billion, or 36 per cent of the world total).
Other developing countries showing increased investment included India (up 22 per cent to $10.2 billion), South Africa (up 329 per cent to $4.5 billion), Mexico (up 105 per cent to $4 billion) and Chile (up 151 per cent to $3.4 billion).
Morocco, Turkey and Uruguay all joined the list of countries investing more than $1 billion.
Overall developing country investments last year were 17-times higher than in 2004.
Among developed countries, investment in Europe was down 21 per cent, from $62 billion in 2014 to $48.8 billion in 2015, the continent's lowest figure for nine years despite record investments in offshore wind projects.
The United States was up 19 per cent to $44.1 billion, and in Japan investment was much the same as the previous year at $36.2 billion.
The shift in investment towards developing countries and away from developed economies may be attributed to several factors: China's dash for wind and solar, fast-rising electricity demand in emerging countries, the reduced cost of choosing renewables to meet that demand, sluggish economic growth in the developed world and cutbacks in subsidy support in Europe.
Still a long way to go
That the power generation capacity added by renewables exceeded new capacity added from conventional sources in 2015 shows that structural change is under way.
Renewables, excluding large hydro, still represent a small minority of the world's total installed power capacity (about one-sixth, or 16.2 per cent) but that figure continues to climb (up from 15.2 per cent in 2014). Meanwhile actual electricity generated by those renewables was 10.3 per cent of global generation in 2015 (up from 9.1 per cent in 2014).
"Despite the ambitious signals from COP 21 in Paris and the growing capacity of new installed renewable energy, there is still a long way to go," said Prof. Dr. Udo Steffens, President of the Frankfurt School of Finance & Management.
"Coal-fired power stations and other conventional power plants have long lifetimes. Without further policy interventions, climate altering emissions of carbon dioxide will increase for at least another decade."
The recent big fall in coal, oil and gas prices makes conventional electricity generation more attractive, Dr. Steffens added. "However, the commitments made by all nations at the Paris climate summit in December, echoing statements from last-year's G7 summit, require a very low- or no-carbon electricity system."

Links

Sunday, March 27, 2016

Scientists Fly Glacial Ice To South Pole To Unlock Secrets Of Global Warming

The Guardian - 

High on Mont Blanc, huge ice cores are being extracted to help researchers study the alarming rate of glacial melt
Scientists on the Col du Dôme site on the slopes of Mont Blanc. Photograph: Bruno Jourdain/LGGE / OSUG / UGA

In a few weeks, researchers will begin work on a remarkable scientific project. They will drill deep into the Col du Dôme glacier on Mont Blanc and remove a 130 metre core of ice. Then they will fly it, in sections, by helicopter to a laboratory in Grenoble before shipping it to Antarctica. There the ice core will be placed in a specially constructed vault at the French-Italian Concordia research base, 1,000 miles from the south pole.
The Col du Dôme ice will become the first of several dozen other cores, extracted from glaciers around the world, that will be added to the repository over the next few years. The idea of importing ice to the south pole may seem odd – the polar equivalent of taking coals to Newcastle – but the project has a very serious aim, researchers insist.
Earth's glaciers are now melting at a unprecedented rate as a result of global warming – and that poses a serious scientific problem. As ice forms on a glacier, it encloses small bubbles of air that contain a sample of the atmosphere at that time. From these samples, scientists can measure atmospheric concentrations of gases such as carbon dioxide and methane over periods that range from hundreds to tens of thousands of years into the past.
"Ice cores are like books," said project leader Jérôme Chappellaz, of the Glaciology Laboratory in Grenoble. "Each year a new layer of ice is put down and adds a page to that book, one that records data from a particular year of the glacier's life. It tells us what concentration of gases and pollutants were in the atmosphere at a particular time. And the deeper we go down into the glacier, the further back in time we travel. Unfortunately, as our glaciers melt, the pages of these books – both the ancient and the more recent ones – are being destroyed."
As a result, Chappellaz has set up the Saving Ice in Danger project [PDF], which aims to collect ice core samples and keep them for future analyses. "We are setting up the archive to prevent precious information about past climate change from being wiped from the face of the planet," he added. "This is a race against time."
An indication of the rate at which glaciers have been warming in recent years is provided by measurements that were taken between 1994 and 2005 on the Col du Dôme glacier. Researchers found that temperatures at the heart of the glacier rose by 1.5C in that decade, a rate that would melt the glacier totally in a few decades.
Nor is the problem confined to Europe. Across the globe, ice is disappearing at a staggering rate as rising carbon emissions bring global temperatures to record levels. The snows of Kilimanjaro have melted more than 80% since 1912, for example, while researchers fear most central and eastern Himalayan glaciers could disappear by 2035. Glacier National Park in Montana once contained 150 glaciers. Today there are only a couple of dozen and in a few decades nearly all the park's glaciers are likely to have disappeared, scientists have warned.
Project leader Jérôme Chappellaz examines a sample. Photograph: Lucia Simion

The need to protect the precious information locked into the ice of these glaciers has become urgent, said Chappellaz. In a few weeks, he will co-ordinate the removal of the first ice core – from Col du Dôme, 4,350 metres high on the Mont Blanc massif – that will be taken to the Saving Ice in Danger vault in Antarctica. Next year, a core will be extracted from the Illimani glacier in Bolivia – which has been identified as the most threatened glacier in the Andes – and sent to Concordia.
"Speed will be critically important," said Chappellaz. "We have to ensure there is minimal thawing before getting a core to a freezer. In the case of the Col du Dome core, we will helicopter it straight down the mountain to a cold store at ground level before shipping it to Antarctica.
"Illimani is too high for helicopters so we will have to employ porters to carry sections down – but only at night when temperatures are low enough to prevent thawing."
Other glacier sites that have been targeted by Saving Ice in Danger include the Colle Gniffetti glacier on the Swiss-Italian border; the Huascaran glacier in the Andes; the Guliya glacier on the Tibetan plateau; the East Rongbuk near Mount Everest; and Mount Cook in New Zealand.
"With the exception of glaciers in the Western Himalayas, all the world's great ice sheets are losing ice at an alarming rate and we are to have to act very quickly," said Chappellaz.
The problem for the project is funding, however. "We cannot apply for standard science funding because we are not carrying out research," he added. "We are trying to preserve a source of data for future research and so we are having to apply to private donors – fortunately with some success. The Prince Albert of Monaco Foundation has given us €2m to begin the project."
As a result, scientists hope that in three or four years, a steady supply of ice core samples will be arriving in the vault at Concordia. And given that the average temperature at the site is around minus 50C, there is little danger that a power failure might lead to catastrophic thawing of samples. "This is one of the coldest places on Earth," said Chappellaz. "We should be safe there for a while."

Core facts
Freshly harvested ice from the Mont Blanc site. Photograph: Bruno Jourdain, LGGE / OSUG / UGA

Studies of ice cores have played a key role in demonstrating that carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere have a strong influence on climate change. They have shown that low concentrations occur during cold times and high concentrations in warm periods. This is entirely consistent with the idea that temperature and carbon dioxide levels are intimately linked and that each acts to amplify changes in the other.
"We see no examples in the ice-core record of a major increase in carbon dioxide that was not accompanied by an increase in temperature," says the British Antarctic Survey on its webpage on ice cores and climate change.
As ice cores provide the data that has established this link, they have therefore played a key role in understanding how carbon emissions are driving global warming. Ironically, it is the impact of these emissions that now threatens this crucial source of data about our climate.

Links

Spike In Global Temperature Fuels Climate Change Fears

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

Each of the past 10 months has been a record for global surface temperatures, a US agency says. Photo: Planetary Visions Ltd

The world has lurched closer to the 2-degree global warming limit in recent months, prompting calls by scientists for clearer policies aimed at making Australia and other rich nations carbon-emissions neutral before 2050.
February's spike in global temperatures lifted temperatures to 1.21 degrees above the 20th century average, and were the biggest departure from the norm in 137 years of records. Temperatures over land were 2.3 degrees warmer than average, according to the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).
There are reasons to be optimistic but there also reasons to be terrified 
John Connor, CEO, The Climate Institute
So far this year, 2016 is looking like no other in history, American meteorologist Eric Holthaus noted in an article for the FiveThirtyEight website this week. (See chart below.)

The first half of March was also the hottest on record for Australia with the rest of the planet also on track for more record heat, the Bureau of Meteorology said.
Climatologists such as Stefan Rahmstorf​, from Germany's Potsdam Institute of Climate Impact Research, say the big El Nino event in the Pacific is topping up the background warming from climate change by about 0.2 degrees.
A woman walks past a solar-power street light near a giant coal-fired power station in the central Chinese province of Shanxi. Photo: Getty Images

Complacency should be avoided, therefore, when the mercury's record run inevitably ends in coming months as the El Nino unwinds.
"It's important to take this hot spike as a reminder that this is a really urgent problem" said Professor Rahmstorf, who until last week was also a visiting professorial fellow at the University of NSW. "We are running out of time to avoid a 2-degree world."
The UK Met Office estimated last year we are roughly half way there, based on the estimated average of the 1850-1900 period.
Carbon emissions from energy use have plateaued over the past two years, the IEA says. Photo: act\ian.warden

Professor Rahmstorf said another half a degree of warming is already locked in - even without short-term fluctuations - taking us to the lower end of the 1.5-2-degree limit agreed on by almost 200 nations last December in Paris.
To keep under that mark, the world must reach carbon neutrality - storing as much as emitted - by the second half of the century with developed nations reaching that level by 2050 or sooner, experts say.
Concern and optimism
Pep Canadell​, executive director of CSIRO's global carbon project, said the latest data on atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) levels and emissions offer cause for both concern and optimism.
Last year, CO2 levels measured at NOAA's Mauna Loa site in Hawaii jumped 3.05 parts per million, the fastest increase in 56 years of observations.
Dr Canadell said the leap was made worse by the El Nino. The unusual heat and drought conditions led to vegetation taking up less CO2 than usual, while also creating conditions for the huge fires in Indonesia that blanketed much of south-east Asia for months and exceeded emissions from the whole of the US.
On the plus side, emissions from burning fossil fuels for energy have plateaued for the past two years, the International Energy Agency said earlier this month.

China's decreasing coal consumption - down 2.9 per cent in 2014 and 3.7 per cent last year - is a major reason for the stall in emissions growth.
China delivered as much as 90 per cent of the growth in CO2 since 1990 and "can make this go the other way", Dr Canadell said.
Another contributor has been the rise in renewable energy, with new wind, solar and hydro accounting for about 90 per cent of additional electricity generation in 2015, the IEA estimates.
"Renewables have turned out to be an unexpected success story," Professor Rahmstorf said.
However, cuts in emissions of greenhouse gases from other sectors of the economy - such as agriculture and industry - will be harder to achieve.

Slowdown is over
Stephen Sherwood, an atmospheric scientist at UNSW-based ARC Centre of Excellence for Climate System Science, said the recent surge in warming indicates the slowdown in surface temperature increases of the past 10-15 years is over.
"We knew that was never going to last," Professor Sherwood said, referring to what had been dubbed a "warming hiatus". "We're back on track to where the models were predicting."
Despite facing "an emergency in slow motion," political leaders have largely failed to take major steps to start cutting emissions, he said. "We're not even fighting the battle, so of course we're losing"
John Connor, chief executive of The Climate Institute, said putting a price on carbon was necessary to send "clear signals to the big emitters to take responsibility for their emissions".
"We don't have a clear policy of decarbonising our energy system,"he said.
While there's still time to avoid 2 degrees warming, Australia and other nations "have been given a massive hurry along by the huge extremes we're seeing now," he said.
"There are reasons to be optimistic," Mr Connor said. "But there also reasons to be terrified."

Friday, March 25, 2016

Climate Change: Clean Energy Will Bring Exponential Returns

The Age - Editorial

Climate denialism has dissuaded billions of dollars of potential investment in renewable energy. Photo: Jessica Shapiro

America's great family dynasties were, for the most part, founded on the industries that powered Western economic growth. Oil, railways, car manufacturing, chemicals, banking and property development dominate the landscape of generational wealth in the United States.
One of those dynasties, the Rockefeller family, derived its vast riches from ownership of Standard Oil, now known as ExxonMobil. But one of the philanthropic funds controlled by the Rockefellers has declared it will no longer invest in fossil fuels because of its profound concerns about climate change.
The Rockefeller Family Fund says the clear evidence on climate change leads it to believe that reserves of oil, coal and tar-sands must remain in the ground "if there is any hope for human and natural ecosystems to survive and thrive". It says "there is no sane rationale for companies to continue to explore for new sources of hydrocarbons" and it makes "little sense, financially or ethically" to invest in companies that exploit fossil fuels.
And, in a spectacular denunciation of the company that made the family rich, the fund has damned ExxonMobil for engaging in "morally reprehensible conduct", saying it appears to have deliberately sought to confuse the public about climate change and its effects while seeking to exploit oil exploration as Arctic sea ice recedes.
It is a powerful statement, one that will reverberate through the global investment community because it is testimony to how opinion on climate change has profoundly shifted. The science cannot be denied. "History moves on, as it must," the Rockefeller fund says.
And yet, here in Australia, we are still waiting for this kind of seismic change to sway the investment community and, indeed, the political class. While a smattering of superannuation funds, equity funds and philanthropic foundations prioritise alternative energy investments over those that contribute to greenhouse gases, years of climate denialism from federal and state Coalition governments has dissuaded billions of dollars of potential investment in renewable energy technology and initiatives.
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has been slow to show his credentials on climate change. Still, we welcome his decision to create a $1 billion innovation fund that will invest in clean energy projects. We also welcome his decision to retain the Clean Energy Finance Corporation (CEFC), which invests in sustainable energy initiatives, and the Australian Renewable Energy Agency, which has issued grants totalling $87 million for research and developing pilot projects involving solar, bio-energy, thermal and hydro-power generation.
But The Age urges Mr Turnbull to do much more than this. We say as much because the proposed new fund's $1 billion (dispersed in dollops of $100 million a year over 10 years) is a loan from the CEFC, not new money. It also appears to be focused towards large projects only. By contrast, government grants, which are essential to research and development projects and to small start-ups, do not feature in his announcement.
The fund is a good move, as far as it goes, but we urge Mr Turnbull to be far more courageous in developing intensive policies that might influence industry to move away from fossil fuels. Clean energy development is crucial but, as we have said before, a price on carbon emissions – in conjunction with new energy production – would dramatically change big polluters' behaviour and help transition Australia to a cleaner environment.

The G20 Countries Most Vulnerable To Climate Change Risks

Business Insider - Chris Pash

Escaping the heat. Scout and Christie cool off in Lake Parramatta. Brook Mitchell/Getty Images

Climate change is putting increasing stress on the world's resources, raising risks to the global economy and to global energy, food and water systems.
HSBC has analysed the risks from climate change to G20 countries and it has found the financial damage from floods, droughts, extreme temperatures and fires is large.
The estimated damages bill from climate change is $US309 billion for G20 countries for the decade to 2014 with 39% of that in China, followed by the US (22%) and India (11%).
"In our view, assessing country vulnerability to these stresses enables superior investment decision making," HSBC says in its study Scoring Climate Risk.
"We expect asset managers and owners to develop strategies to account for the impacts of climate change. This report shows investors where the relative risks are likely to be felt harder."
As average temperatures increase across the globe, HSBC says water stress is increasing with Australia and Saudi Arabia posting the largest deterioration in water availability.
On average, G20 water resources have fallen 1.5% compared to HSBC's 2013 analysis.
HSBC says the dominance of floods and droughts illustrates how changing rainfall patterns are currently the driver for a major component of total extreme weather events and associated costs.
"We expect flooding to become more common as climate impacts increase," HSBC says.
The number of extreme weather events is increasing. This chart shows how droughts, extreme temperatures, floods and wildfires are rising.

India, China and Indonesia are the three most vulnerable G20 countries to climate change risk.
Australia sits at 13th place. Here's the full ranking:

Has Veteran Climate Scientist James Hansen Foretold The ‘Loss Of All Coastal Cities’ With Latest Study?

The Guardian - 

Former NASA climate director James Hansen and a team of scientists claim a mechanism in the climate could rapidly raise sea levels by metres
Dr James Hansen, pictured in 2012 Photograph: Murdo MacLeod for the Guardian

James Hansen's name looms large over any history that will likely be written about climate change.
Whether you look at the hard science, the perils of political interference or modern day activism, Dr Hansen is there as a central character.
In a 1988 US Senate hearing, Hansen famously declared that the "greenhouse effect has been detected and is changing our climate now".
Towards the end of his time as the director of NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies, Hansen described how government officials had on other occasions changed his testimony, filtered scientific findings and controlled what scientists could and couldn't say to the media – all to underplay the impact of fossil fuel emissions on the climate.
In recent years, the so-called "grandfather of climate science" has added to his CV the roles of author and twice-arrested climate activist and anti-coal campaigner. He still holds a position at Columbia University.
So when Hansen's latest piece of blockbuster climate research was finalized and released earlier this week, there was understandable global interest, not least because it mapped a potential path to the "loss of all coastal cities" from rising sea levels and the onset of "super storms" previously unseen in the modern era.
So what is Hansen claiming?
Well, the first thing to understand is that Hansen's paper, written with 18 other co-authors, many of them highly-reputable names in climate science in their own right, is far from conventional.
Most scientific papers only take up four or five pages in a journal. Hansen's paper - in the journal Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics - grabs 52 pages (although it's hard to quibble over space when you're laying out a possible path to widespread global disruption and the complete reshaping of coastlines).
Nor was the paper published in a conventional way. If you're getting a faint sense of déjà vu about Hansen's findings, then that could be down to how a draft version of the study was published and widely covered in July last year.
The journal runs an unconventional interactive system of peer review where comments and criticisms from other scientists are published for everyone to see, as are the responses from Hansen and his colleagues.
This is arguably a more transparent way of conducting the scientific process of peer review - something usually carried out privately and anonymously.
None of this should really detract from Hansen and his co-author's central claims.
All hell will break loose in the North Atlantic and neighbouring lands.
Dr James Hansen
Firstly, Hansen says they may have uncovered a mechanism in the Earth's climate system not previously understood that could point to a much more rapid rise in sea levels.When the Earth's ice sheets melt, they place a freshwater lens over neighboring oceans. This lens, argues Hansen, causes the ocean to retain extra heat, which then goes to melting the underside of large ice sheets that fringe the ocean, causing them to add more freshwater to the lens (this is what's known as a "positive feedback" and is not to be confused with the sort of positive feedback you may have got at school for that cracking fifth grade science assignment).
Secondly, according to the paper, all this added water could first slow and then shut down two key ocean currents – and Hansen points to two unusually cold blobs of ocean water off Greenland and off Antarctica as evidence that this process may already be starting.
If these ocean conveyors were to be impacted, this could create much greater temperature differences between the tropics and the north Atlantic, driving "super storms stronger than any in modern times", he argues.
"All hell will break loose in the North Atlantic and neighbouring lands," he says in a video summary.

Dr James Hansen, of Columbia University, summarises his latest research into ice sheet melting, sea level rise and super storms.

Hansen points to evidence from ancient climates (known as paleoclimate data) to suggest this has previously happened on Earth – an interpretation that was challenged during the interactive peer review process.
Now, according to the IPCC, global sea levels will only rise a maximum of not quite a metre by the end of the century.
But Hansen says this is too conservative. His paper claims that climate models, including those used for his paper, don't properly capture the consequences from adding freshwater from melting ice sheets. Sea levels could rise several metres beyond the IPCC's estimates, and the rise would be much faster.
So what's the upshot? According to Hansen:
These feedbacks raise questions about how soon we will pass points of no return in which we will lock-in consequences that cannot be reversed on any time scale that people care about.
Consequences include sea level rise of several metres, which we estimate could occur this century or at the latest next century if fossil fuel emissions continue at a high level.
That would mean the loss of all coastal cities, most of the world's largest cities and all of their history.
The idea that ice sheets are becoming unstable and could raise sea levels several metres is not as controversial as you might think. There is good evidence that sea levels have been many metres higher in earth's history, well before humans came along.
A May 2015 study covered here on Planet Oz found Antarctica's ice sheet alone could have pushed sea levels as much as 17 metres higher, but it would have taken thousands of years.
Commenting on Hansen's study, Dr John Church, a sea level rise expert at Australia's CSIRO, says multimeter sea level rises are consistent with current research, but where Hansen departs is on claiming it could all happen before the end of this century.
But Church says that as fossil fuel emissions grow, the world is committing future generations to much higher sea levels.
"Even with the lower emission scenarios we have committed the world to ongoing sea level rise for centuries," he says.
Other scientists have already challenged many of Hansen's conclusions, as Hansen himself predicted would happen.
"You can be sure that many scientists – indeed most scientists – will find some aspects in our long paper that they would interpret differently," Hansen says.
But he also commented that these disagreements shouldn't be misinterpreted.
I find that the public sometimes misinterprets our science discussions – how research is done. Scepticism is the lifeblood of science. It takes time for conclusions to be agreed upon and details sorted out.
And so it's in this spirit that I think Hansen's paper should be taken.
Hansen and his co-authors have laid out their science and are proposing an idea that will live, die or evolve through the scientific method.
Whether or not March 2016 becomes another seminal moment in Hansen's storied climate career only time, and a failure to reign in fossil fuel emissions, will likely tell.
One final point.
Hansen has long called for a straightforward rising price on greenhouse gas emissions, which he argues would "quicken the transition to cleaner energy."
"This is a tragic situation, because it is unnecessary," he says.
We could already be phasing out fossil fuel emissions if only we stopped allowing the fossil fuel industry to use the atmosphere as a free dumping ground for their waste.
Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative