This photo combination shows Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton(L) on April 4, 2016 and Republican challenger Donald Trump on February 16, 2016. (AFP PHOTO / dskDSK/AFP/Getty Images)
Donald Trump, now the presumptive Republican presidential nominee, has said that "I'm not a big believer in man-made climate change." Hillary Clinton, meanwhile, is a strong proponent
of climate change action, and a supporter of continuing President
Obama's policies on the matter, which include joining and honoring the
Paris climate agreement and instituting the Clean Power Plan, which
would shift domestic electricity generation onto a less carbon-intensive
path.
Now that the race appears to have narrowed to these two,
it sets up a situation that many environmentalists have long hoped for —
one in which a sharp contrast on climate change between the two
candidates means that it might not only come up prominently in an
election, but moreover, actually make a difference. (And if Bernie
Sanders somehow racks up hard-to-imagine delegate totals in coming races or achieves some kind of convention upset, that contrast would only be heightened further.)
That would be pretty different from other recent elections. In 2012, President Obama and the media alike were widely faulted
for rarely talking about climate change. In the 2014 midterms,
meanwhile, billionaire Tom Steyer's super PAC NextGen Climate Action spent $ 74 million, but saw candidates it was opposing win nonetheless in key Senate races.
However,
the issue appears to have grown in public salience since then, and new
polling data, in combination with the very clear difference between
Trump and Clinton on the issue, suggests at least a chance that things
might actually be different this time around.
"It is an important
issue on which to sharpen the contrast in the general election,
particularly with young voters," says Gene Karpinski, the president of
the League of Conservation Voters. Karpinski points out not only that
Clinton already talks about climate change on the stump regularly (and
that it has been a constant theme in Democratic debates) but that her
campaign manager, Robby Mook, formerly headed the campaign of Virginia Gov. Terry McAuliffe, who hit his opponent — Ken Cuccinelli — hard on the issue of climate change.
"In
my view, rarely does any one issue decide a Presidential election, but
being a climate denier hurts Trump," adds Democratic pollster and
strategist Mark Mellman. "Trump's position sends a wider signal about
being anti-science and anti-environment which will make it very
difficult for him to appeal to moderates."
Granted, there remain
plenty of grounds for skepticism — and also ways in which the polling
data itself continues to raise doubts. As has perennially been the case,
climate change still does not rank among the top priorities of most voters,
although it does for a minority, particularly in the liberal Democratic
camp. And so far, while it has come up mainly in Democratic debates, it
has not been a particularly resonant theme in what has been a pretty
off-script and tumultuous election.
"It's an economically
oriented discourse, and it's very personal, which is why you're seeing a
lot of disruption in the political process at this point, and that's
the focus," says Republican strategist and pollster David Winston, who
said he doesn't think climate change will compete with this narrative.
Nonetheless,
other recent polling data reinforces the idea that if there were ever a
year in which climate change could matter, it's this one — both because
of how different Clinton and Trump are, and because of the rising
profile of the issue.
A March Gallup poll,
for instance, found more Americans worried either a "great deal" or a
"fair amount" about global warming than at any time since 2008 — at 64
percent. It also found that a record 65 percent believe that rising
temperatures are being caused by humans, and that all three major
political groups in the U.S. show an upswing in concern. 84 percent of
Democrats, 64 percent of Independents, and 40 percent of Republicans
told Gallup that they "worry a great deal or fair amount" about the
issue.
"Americans are now expressing record- or near-record-high
belief that global warming is happening, as well as concern about the
issue," the group concluded.
Other
types of analysis also suggest the issue has some potential. "Climate
change is the issue that is the most starkly different between Clinton
supporters and Trump supporters," adds Anthony Leiserowitz, who heads
the Yale Project on Climate Change Communication, which has conducted a
number of surveys on the subject. "Among that set of voters that say
that global warming will be one of the key issues on which they base
their vote, she has a huge lead over him." Here's
a chart showing what Leiserowitz – who collaborates with researchers at
George Mason University – means. They found that registered "issue
voters" who rate climate change as "very important" to them favor
Clinton over Trump more than any other kind of issue voter:
Leiserowitz, A., Maibach, E., Roser-Renouf, C., Feinberg, G., & Rosenthal, S. (2016). Hillary Clinton Has the Support of Seven in Ten Registered Voters Who Say Global Warming Is Very Important to Them When Deciding Whom to Vote For; Only 15% of Trump Supporters Say It Is Very Important. Yale University and George Mason University. New Haven, CT: Yale Program on Climate Change Communication.
So who are
these climate issue voters? They are predominantly Democrats (62
percent), to be sure, but 19 percent are also Independents, and 38
percent identify as moderate, according to Leiserowitz's data. Among
Independents who are climate issue voters, 67 percent said the would
vote for Clinton, and 12 percent for Trump, Leiserowitz said.
"The
Clinton campaign sees polling showing profound political vulnerability
on climate for the Republicans generally and Trump specifically, so the
Clinton camp intends to push climate themes aggressively, " adds Paul
Bledsoe, who worked on climate issues in the former Clinton White House
and is now an independent energy consultant. "They see GOP climate
denial fitting into a larger narrative of Trump and the Republicans
being willing to deny factual information injurious to the American
public just because it doesn't fit into Tea Party ideology. That will
be a meta-theme of the campaign, and climate fits into it."
Bledsoe
says he would expect the Clinton campaign to focus on climate change in
"key swing states that are vulnerable to climate impacts, like Florida,
Colorado, Arizona and even Virginia."
Leiserowitz's take is that
Clinton may have an incentive to make a lot of hay out of the topic
(though Trump will not) because it will consolidate her support among
liberal Democrats, who now rank climate change, clean energy and broad
environmental protections as three of their top eight campaign issues,
according to his data. Those who care about it most of all are
supporters of Bernie Sanders — whom Clinton certainly needs to rally in
the general election.
"She
has incentive to talk more about climate change, and because we see
that it's such a stark difference between her and Trump, there may be
political advantage there as well," says Leiserowitz.
Climate
change is now a top issue that is "uniting the progressive Democratic
donor base," adds Betsy Taylor of Breakthrough Strategies &
Solutions, which focuses on the climate issue.
It's not just Leiserowitz's research: A new survey from
the Program for Public Consultation at the University of Maryland, for
instance, questioned over 4,000 registered voters about climate change
policies. Before asking voters for their opinion, the questioners first
showed them a carefully researched presentation of the pros and cons of
several aspects of the debate, such as the Clean Power Plan and the
Paris climate agreement.
It found that 70 percent of the public
overall considers it either a very high or at least a somewhat high
priority to cut down on greenhouse gas emissions, and even on the
contentious Clean Power Plan, similar numbers were supportive after
reading through the pro-con briefing on the issue.
"Most people,
even people who are supporters of Trump, they do not have a view that
this is not an issue, not a problem, and nothing should be done about
it," says Steven Kull, who led the research. "Most have the sense,
'Well, maybe there's some problem, maybe we should take some steps, it's
probably worth it, the cost is not that high.' And another argument
that's very popular is, this is where the world economy is going, in
this green direction, we should really be ahead of the curve on this."
Kull
says that especially when you merge climate related concerns with air
quality concerns, people are supportive of taking action. And he notes
that even among Republicans and especially Independents, there are
significant numbers of voters who care a lot about the issue.
"For
Republicans, those saying that reducing greenhouse gases is a very high
priority is 12 percent, while those saying it not a priority at all is
17 percent," says Kull. "But for independents very high priority is 26
percent, while not at all a priority is 10 percent. Nationally very
high is 34 percent and not at all is 9 percent."
Granted,
all of this remains hypothetical, because we don't yet know how Clinton
might pursue her attack — although it may have already begun. On CBS's "Face the Nation"
Sunday, Clinton said of Trump, "When he says climate change is a
Chinese hoax, what does that mean? Has he ever talked to a scientist, or
is he just again assuming a slogan?"
The biggest uncertainty of
all, though, is how Trump will respond. Unlike other candidates who
might consult the polling numbers above and play defense on the issue,
he may be more inclined to keep on saying what he actually thinks.
Based on these numbers, that could play to Clinton's advantage.
For the Turnbull of old, could a picture be worth a thousand words?
"Climate change is the ultimate long-term problem. We have to
make decisions today, bear costs today so that adverse consequences are
avoided, dangerous consequences, many decades into the future."Malcolm Turnbull, February 9th, 2010
Plainly stated, Mr Turnbull … and in reality not that many decades.
But not that many decades. NASA's GISTEMP global temperature anomaly for the last 40 years, with projection for the next 40 years. The anomaly is measured by month as a departure from the 1951-1980 average. The current trajectory means that within the next 40 years we are set to experience El Nino events with anomalies in excess of +2°C considered in the dangerous realm. Colours map Australian federal election outcomes. Data sourced from NASA.
"Plainly stated: in the absence of a clear carbon price signal either no investments will be made or investments will be made of new carbon-intensive infrastructure because they are more profitable in a world where there is no price on carbon."Malcolm Turnbull
Plainly stated, Mr Turnbull … and indeed nothing much has happened.
Nothing much has happened. Two images, each showing how electricity dispatch maps between fuel types and regions on Australia's National Energy Market for the month of April in 2011, on the left, and April 2016, on the right. Despite a modest increase in wind, and a very modest amount of new solar, the two images illustrate just how little change there has been in the proportion of Carbon intensive dispatch on our grid over the last 5 years. Units are in megawatts, colours are by fuel type. Data sourced from AEMO.
… "But it is not enough to say you support these cuts, you must also deliver a strong, credible policy framework that will deliver them."Malcolm Turnbull
Plainly stated, Mr Turnbull … and yes price signals do work.
Yes, price signals work. Emissions in million tonnes of CO2e by financial year, for electrical power dispatch onto the Victorian grid. Of the many stories this image tells, the most important one is how adept markets are at responding to price signals and the policy settings that surround them. In Victoria, the carbon tax price signal was accompanied by a ~10% decline in electricity sector emissions. Data sourced from AEMO.
The energy internet, the ‘smart’ grid, solar energy and battery storage are converging and the economic benefits are clear
The Royalla solar farm near Canberra was built to generate an average 37,000 MWh of renewable energy each year for the next 20 years and to meet the needs of 4,500 Canberra households. Photograph: Lukas Coch/AAP
Change is coming to the energy landscape. A transition to a new energy economy is happening. In a country like Australia – awash with energy both under and above the ground – this transition could be rapid and profound. There is a lot to lose for those who can’t keep pace.
Last month the government committed $1bn to the Clean Energy Innovation Fund. The fund will have “the primary purpose of earning income or a profitable return” on debt and equity extended to renewable energy, energy efficiency and low-emissions technologies. While many will argue the right way for that money to be used, investment like this is well timed. There are a number of converging technologies driving the transition. Their interaction will affect how we travel, how we live, the way our cities and houses are designed, our fuel supply and attitude to energy efficiency, and even how we interact. One of the maturing technologies is solar. Over the past five years, solar has become a big part of our energy world. The Australian energy market operator estimated last year that by 2023/24 the state of South Australia may, at times, have its entire electricity needs met by solar systems on mostly urban rooftops, without the aid of coal, gas or oil. Together with other renewables, photovoltaics are becoming increasingly competitive. Factoring in the cost of delivering energy through the grid, photovoltaic technology is probably the cheapest electricity supply option at the point of use right now. And it will continue to get cheaper. Another is energy storage. Improvements in battery technology and cost will help overcome the intermittency of renewable energy. Tesla’s push into the consumer mass market is just the beginning of a decade in which electric cars will become significantly more common and at the heart of each electric vehicle is a battery that can store enough electricity to serve the average Australian home for days. Our cars will act as mobile batteries that “plug in” to the home, allowing their energy to be used for household purposes. Batteries will also be installed in our homes, complementing our rooftop solar. Utilities will use them to optimise their grids. This new energy landscape will be more complex, requiring interaction between energy providers and users like never before. Controlling this will be the energy “internet”, a vast array of interconnected devices that will produce, store or use energy. These devices will communicate their energy deficits and surpluses and transport energy to where it is needed most, as well as allowing consumers to remotely control their devices to optimise energy usage. This capability will allow a range of new energy technologies and business models to emerge. Consumers will have more say in what energy they use and how, and by digitally understanding those needs suppliers will be able to optimise their services to align. Another technology reaching maturity is the “smart” energy grid. Despite the self-sufficiency potential of renewable energy, the grid will not become obsolete. Pole and wire infrastructure will allow users to upload and download energy to maximise cost effectiveness and reliability – like off-peak hot water is used now but much more complex. As energy utilisation is automised, unintentional consumption will fall. As with any fundamental disruption, there will be winners and losers. Foreseeing and harnessing the potential of the convergence won’t be easy for incumbents or new entrants. Significant investment will be required to develop and commercialise businesses and technology capable of harnessing the possibilities of convergence. But the potential pay-off for businesses that get it right will be huge. There will be other benefits as well. Until now, I have barely mentioned emissions. The energy transition is happening without reference to its environmental value. And yet, there are environment-related drivers. The final, published agreement from COP21, the climate change-related Conference of Parties 21 held in Paris last December, aims for essentially zero net emissions by 2050, the world over. Why are governments the world over suddenly willing to agree to such ambitious targets? The scientific consensus to act on climate has strengthened, for one. But pragmatic governments may also be seeing signs of tangible, real solutions emerging in energy markets. The timetable outlined in Paris for emissions reductions appears to align well with the published convergence of technologies – very roughly in the next 10 or so years. This, of course, could just be a coincidence but, if so, it is well timed. Decarbonisation of the global economy now has a route that is starting to make commercial sense. Coal, oil and gas will continue as primary energy supplies for some time and simply being more efficient with our energy use is the first way to reduce emissions. As technology converges, we won’t need to be convinced that we should consider the environment: we will be too busy focusing on the economic benefits.
The realities of why we vote the way we do are actually more to do
with appearance, and less to do with policy. In the shadow of an
election, Dr Lissa Johnson explains the psychology behind the polls.
(IMAGE: Gianluca Di natale, Flickr)
The long-anticipated early election has finally been announced, as the election campaign splutters to a start.
So far, it is a world away from the vaudevillian spectacle that has
been the US presidential primaries. No impassioned unshackling from
establishment traditions here.
Words like 'boring' and 'beige' have been doing the rounds.
The treasurer Scott Morrison even sought to distance himself from
another kind of 'b' word on budget night. 'Budget' has such a nasty ring
to it. 'Plan' is much less inflammatory.
Especially when you're selling voodoo economics.
At least we aren't facing a choice between a walking reality TV
disaster and the woman-most-likely-to-start-World War III. I don't envy
those Americans.
Hillary Clinton may be more keen to pick a fight with Russia for no
good reason, but the Republican Party is so crazy that one of the most cited individuals in history, respected MIT professor Noam Chomsky, has called it a radical insurgency.
In an interview with the Huffington Post
earlier this year Chomsky said, "Today, the Republican Party has
drifted off the rails…. It's become what the respected conservative
political analysts Thomas Mann and Norman Ornstein call 'a radical
insurgency'".
We know what that's like, don't we? Remember 'Team Australia' and
'the right to be bigots'? Thank goodness those days are behind us.
The Republican insurgency is so extreme that Chomsky has called it,
"A serious danger to human survival". He qualified his position by
adding, "literally".
Renowned intellectual Noam Chomsky.
Malcolm Turnbull may not have dazzled us with innovation, but at least he doesn't beat the xenophobic drums of War On Terror, shouting "Death Cult" at every opportunity. Plus he's less embarrassing than Donald Trump.
However, Trump and his nationalism are not the danger to which Chomsky refers.
The singular threat to humanity posed by the Republican Party has to do with their climate policies.
In a subsequent interview,
Chomsky was asked why the Republican party frightened him more than the
far right in Europe (or Hilary Clinton for that matter). Chomsky
replied, "The extreme right in Europe is indeed tremendous, but it does
not have the support necessary to accelerate the destruction of life on
the planet…. Today's Republican Party, I would add, is one of the most
dangerous organizations in human history."
Chomsky had earlier "cited 'Republicans' rejection of measures to
deal with climate change, which he called a 'looming environmental
catastrophe.' All of the top Republican presidential candidates are either outright deniers, doubt its seriousness or insist no action should be taken — 'dooming our grandchildren,' Chomsky said."
Despite the obvious significance of this issue, it has been dwarfed
by the media circus surrounding the US presidential primaries. During
the presidential debates, climate change featured in less than two percent of questions to candidates on most news networks.
As is the convention in mainstream election coverage, focus has been
on the race, the spectacle, the candidates' tactics, their gaffes, their
polling, and their reactions to one another. And on providing them with
a megaphone for their postures and pronouncements, ultimately allowing
the candidates to set the agenda in the policy 'debate', as if the
issues they choose to ignore magically disappear.
Meanwhile, back in Australia, our own media circus of sorts is
underway, with our very own Threat-To-Human-Survival Party on the
campaign trail.
The Liberal National Coalition may look and sound different to the
Republicans (with the possible exception of Cori Bernardi, George
Christensen, Peter Dutton, Simon Birmingham, Luke Simpkins, Brett
Whiteley, Barry O'Sullivan, Andrew Hastie, George Brandis… oh never
mind. The list is too long).
Turnbull may look and sound different to Trump. But, like the
Republican Party, the Coalition in Australia is forged from a hard core
of climate nihilism and denialism, elemental to the party's very being.
And, like the Republican Party, the Coalition's policies are in "abject service to private wealth and power."
From the Government's first actions in the earliest days of office
under Abbott – axing the Climate Commission and the carbon tax – to cutting climate research and funding a new fossil fuel industry 'growth centre' under Turnbull, the Coalition has been swinging a wrecking ball through environmental policy from beginning to end.
The latest in this long line of carnage has been the Turnbull Government's first budget, with no mention of climate change and $1.3 billion in cuts to the Australian Renewable Energy Agency.
The beneficiaries, of course, have been the Coalition's financial backers, the fossil fuel industry.
At this "completely unprecedented" time of "climate emergency", were voting a rational endeavour, this would be all anyone needed to know about the Coalition.
Fancy human survival? Like to avoid mass extinction?
Change governments.
As Chomsky notes, "What they are saying is, let's destroy the world. Is that worth voting against? Yeah."
For a country with a small population, we Australians are particularly well poised to destroy the world. As the world's largest exporter of coal, 90 per cent of our current coal reserves must stay in the ground to avoid catastrophic warming. Our Coalition Government, however, is bent on exporting as much as possible while it still can.
This during the second half of the critical decade in which to
prevent planetary meltdown. A matter of importance to the 7 billion
people of the world's population.
At the next federal election, Australian voters will stand at an
unusual moment in human history. They will hold power over life on Earth
in their hands.
Literally. In the form of a pencil.
It is a rare and precious opportunity.
But will Australian voters take it?
Although almost 80 per cent of Australians polled
believe in anthropogenic global warming, almost half (48 -49 per cent
two-party preferred) intend on returning the Coalition to office.
Yes, that's less than it was a few months ago, but still, almost half.
This being the party that has made Australia the worst performing country in the OECD on climate change.
Why would so many people vote them back in? This corporate insurgency that endangers human survival.
Seriously.
Why?
Voting behaviour
In their 2015 book 'The Rationalising Voter',
Professors of Political Science Milton Lodge and Charles S Taber
summarised the psychological literature on voting behaviour, including
their own 20-years worth of research on the subject.
Their book sets out to empirically answer the question, "What
determines how citizens evaluate political leaders, groups and issues?"
Lodge and Taber note that dominant models in political science view
this question from the perspective of an Enlightenment "Rational Man"
("Rational Woman" wasn't yet a thing), in which "the conscious
construction of arguments and reasoning [form]the foundations of pubic
opinion and political behaviour".
Such Enlightenment assumptions inform every aspect of our approach to
elections, electorates and electioneering, overtly at least. Between
now and July we will experience an extended period of argument and
reasoning in pursuit of our opinions and votes.
But will all that argument and reasoning really matter? Do arguments win elections in the end?
Based on the empirical data to 2015, what did Lodge and Taber find
was among the most consistently decisive factors in election outcomes
the world over, apart from money?
Communication strategy? Economic forecasts? Political vision?
Looks.
Across numerous studies in numerous countries, glancing briefly at
photos of electoral candidates is enough to predict election outcomes
with around 70 per cent accuracy.
Prime Minister of Australia Malcolm Turnbull, pictured in parliament delivering the 8th annual Close the Gap report.
In one study, for instance, the average rating of (previously
unknown) Senate candidates' competence, based on one-second glimpses of
their headshots, predicted the outcomes of 70 per cent of the Senate
races held across 2000, 2002 and 2004.
In another study, when people in the US and India rated headshots of
candidates for various public offices in Brazil, judging photos for
"suitability to office", the headshot ratings predicted election
outcomes 75 per cent of the time.
In yet another study, entitled "Predicting Elections: Child's Play",
Swiss children aged 5-13 were asked to select a ship's captain from
photos of two French parliamentary candidates. The children's choices
predicted actual election outcomes with a correlation of 0.71. The
predictive correlation for adults in the study was 0.72.
The researchers posited that voters, whom they note are performing
"one of democracy's most important civic duties… might still be using
the same cues that children do to categorize individuals on competency".
That would explain a lot.
This effect is robust, and holds even when people glimpse photos for as little as one tenth of a second.
Little wonder, then, that a change of face following the leadership
spill last year lifted the Coalition's fortunes without any real change
in policy.
Interestingly, in times of war people prefer 'facial dominance' in
their leaders (rectangular face, strong brow, square jaw). During health
scares they prefer facial attractiveness, presumably for its allusions
to health.
Lodge and Taber note, "All this predictive power without party
identification, ideological proximity, or any of the traditional
predictors of vote choice!" (exclamation mark original).
The Coalition must be hoping that during times of economic transition, people prefer the face of a wealthy businessman.
Needless to say, not everyone casts their vote based on looks.
The authors of the Brazilian election study, "Looking Like a Winner",
observed, "These are strong relationships, large enough to alter the
outcome of all but a handful of the races in our sample."
Gulp.
The looking-like-a-winner effect, however, runs deeper than face value.
Voting and human cognition
As Lodge and Taber explain at length in their book, voters'
susceptibility to appearance reflects fundamental realities of human
cognition. These realities are uncontroversial in cognitive psychology
and neuroscience, but, the authors say, "have gone largely unnoticed in
political science".
In a nutshell, human information processing occurs primarily outside
conscious awareness, and emotion, rather than reason, directs the
unconscious information flow.
This view is supported by "three decades of research, backed by
hundreds of well crafted behavioural studies in social psychology and
now evidence from the neurosciences".
Advanced though our capacity for conscious awareness, our brains can
only handle so much of it. Lodge and Taber point out, for example, that
we can process about 11 million pieces of sensory information per
second. 10 million of those pieces are visual, but we are only
consciously aware of 40. In other words, we notice 1/250,000th of what we see.
Of 1 million pieces of tactile information, we consciously experience 5.
In working memory – the information we hold in conscious awareness –
our brains can manage 7 plus or minus 2 chunks of information at any one
time.
Overall, according to Lodge and Taber, around 98 per cent of what we experience occurs outside our conscious awareness.
Most importantly, the unconsciously processed material influences our
opinions and behaviour. Countless studies have shown that subliminal
stimuli (or "unconscious primes") shape our beliefs and actions without
our realising.
For instance, in one study, people were subliminally exposed to
cartoon smiley-faces, or cartoon frowny-faces (for 39 milliseconds), and
then asked to generate a number of opinion statements on illegal
immigration and energy security. When exposed to smiley-faces people
generated more positive opinions, and when exposed to frowny-faces their
opinions were more negative.
Remarkably, the effect of the unnoticed cartoon faces was stronger
than that of prior attitudes towards immigration and energy security.
Similarly, subliminal priming with positive or negative words (such
as rainbow, paradise, syphilis or vomit) results in more positive or
negative evaluations of political candidates.
Studies such as these form part of a larger empirical literature
demonstrating that unconscious influences shape people's conscious
decision making and reasoning via their emotions.
Tony Abbott eats an onion. Just because.
Lodge and Taber say that "Feelings enter the decision stream before
cognitive considerations, and immediately influence what thoughts and
preferences will enter the decision stream.… Much of the thinking that
we perceive as causally prior to our policy positions are in fact
rationalisations of our feelings".
In other words, we feel first and think later.
This is not a new or radical notion in psychology. Back in 2001, writing on Emotion as Virtue and Vice in the book Citizens and Politics, Professors of psychology Gerald Clore and Linda Isbell described reason as a "gun for hire" in the service of motives and emotions.
Experimentally primed feelings exert their power over reason and
opinion when presented for as little as 15 milliseconds. Conscious
recognition begins to arise after around 100 milliseconds and conscious
decision-making does not begin to unfold until after around 1000
milliseconds.
Lodge and Taber note "conventional models [in political science]…
fail to appreciate the significance of information processes that occur
on a millisecond timescale… Conscious deliberation is in the wake behind
the boat."
As well as subliminal or implicit influences on our political
cognition, there are those we notice consciously, but whose impact on
our thoughts and actions goes undetected. These are known as
"supraliminal", "unappreciated" or "unrecognised primes".
For instance, voters are more likely to support increased taxes to
fund education when casting their vote in a school rather than a church
or fire station. This effect overrides that of postcode partisanship.
In another example, "business paraphernalia" (briefcases, boardrooms,
fancy pens) cause people to be more competitive and less generous in
their allocations of money.
Perhaps our leaders should devise budgets wearing jeans and T-shirts, in student digs.
Relatedly, people report stronger belief in global warming on hotter
days and in warmer rooms, and when seeing images of deserts rather than
snow (using ice imagery to communicate about climate change to sceptical
audiences may need rethinking, then).
Strikingly, ambient temperature has been found to predict belief in
anthropogenic global warming as strongly as political ideology.
Like cartoon smiley-faces, this temperature-effect wields its
unconscious power via our feelings. When people feel hot, or imagine
feeling hot, global warming feels viscerally more real, and belief and
opinion follow.
One can't help but muse that the world may have been a different place if more menopausal women held positions of power.
Lodge and Taber's main thesis is that when people feel good, or bad,
about an issue or party or leader they engage in arguments and reasoning
to rationalise their feelings. The 'rationalising voter'.
Importantly for understanding political cognition, this emotionality
does not reflect the weaknesses of an irrational voting minority. It
reflects the workings of the human mind. It describes us all.
If you are sceptical, consider people with damage to brain areas
governing the experience of emotion, but whose memory, attention,
learning and intelligence remain intact. Such damage removes emotion
from the cognitive equation, yet causes marked deficits in problem solving, not advantages, even for problems based purely on probability.
In other words, feelings not only precede conscious deliberation and
analysis, they are integral to it. We need emotions to reason well.
Lodge and Taber note that this is "In direct contradiction to much
Western thought, which treats affect, feelings and emotion as irrational
intrusions that befuddle decision making."
But what is the point of all this emotional reasoning? Why should
brains so complex be so silly? Why isn't logic the master, and emotion
the slave?
If it were, the Coalition wouldn't stand a chance.
The former Abbott Government Ministry.
To function, human beings must process vast quantities of information
efficiently and effectively. Conscious processes are slow, deliberative
and effortful. Unconscious processes are fast, spontaneous and
effortless.
So that we can manage our enormous information load, the unconscious
system bears the brunt of the information processing, and takes
shortcuts. One such shortcut is to unconsciously tag things "good" or
"bad" (known as affective – or emotional – tags). This triggers
automatic feelings of like or dislike, causing us to approach or avoid
accordingly.
It is a "quick and dirty" pathway, prone to false positives and
negatives, but without it our information processing systems would
overload.
When affective tags line up with reality and our values, they work
well. In these instances "Emotions can provide indispensible guides for
making sensible choices," say Clore and Isbell.
Think empathy and human rights, for instance.
Equally, a thorn in the Coalition's side has been that 'universal
healthcare', 'education' and 'jobs' are positively affectively tagged in
most Australians' minds, making it more difficult to swing the same
wrecking ball through these policy areas as through environmental
policy.
The costs of affective tagging arise when our unconscious minds take
inaccurate and counterproductive shortcuts, such as stereotyping and
prejudice, or judging political candidates based on looks.
Unfortunately, the nature of election campaigns is that they provide
precisely the conditions in which our minds become susceptible to quick
and dirty processing. Our unconscious system is wired to take over, and
take shortcuts, when we are bombarded with information (particularly
conflicting, complicated or confusing information), overwhelmed with
detail, overstimulated with distractions and/or when the consequences of
our actions are delayed.
Under these conditions, political reasoning becomes "a bobbing cork
on the currents of unconscious processes", susceptible to the tidal pull
of unseen psychological forces.
Lodge and Taber say that the failure of traditional Political Science
to account for these implicit processes "goes to the heart of our
discipline's problems in accounting for how, when and why citizens think
and act as they do".
All of this is not to say that our consciously constructed,
well-crafted, carefully considered opinions and arguments are redundant.
When affective tags are reality-based (eg. climate-change-bad, climate-action-good), they lead to logical and productive thought. And argument and reasoning can create affective tags in the first place.
The point is that when our affective tags are divorced from reality, our rationality comes unstuck.
The media and human cognition
In terms of the real-world political ramifications of human cognitive
architecture, Lodge and Taber say, "The most worrisome implication of
our research program, we believe, is the ubiquity of consciously unnoticed and unappreciated
priming events in the media (italics original)… Our conservative
estimate is that implicit cues are embedded in virtually all political
communications".
One such implicit cue, pertinent at election time, is subtleties in media disposition towards political candidates.
In a study of US presidential campaign coverage, for instance, the
facial expression of media presenters varied when they uttered different
candidates' names. Candidates whose names were paired with more
positive facial expressions received greater support from viewers.
I seem to recall an experiment about smiley-faces….
A similar effect has been found for media interviews. When
interviewers' nonverbal behaviour is friendly towards interviewees,
viewers perceive the interviewee more favourably, or unfavourably if the
interviewer is hostile.
Amy McGuire deconstructed the significance of this phenomenon very eloquently last year in respect to the ABCs sugar-coating of Scott Morrison and human rights abuse, during a 'Kitchen Cabinet' interview.
Federal Treasurer Scott Morrison delivers his first budget in Canberra.
Given the opinion-shaping power of media halo effects, the media
infatuation with Turnbull in the early months of his leadership carried
significant opinion-shaping force. This halo-effect, moreover, would
have been intensified by the power of first impressions.
A great deal of research shows that people tend to form snap
impressions of one another, and that first impressions persist, even
despite later contrary information.
In the political realm, the authors of Predicting Elections: Child's Play
note, "Unfortunately, voters anchored in an initial impression do not
appropriately correct the initial inferences; additional information on
the candidates does not change choices by much".
No wonder Turnbull still leads by almost 20 percentage points as
preferred PM, despite his widely acknowledged failures of 'agility',
'innovation' and 'mature government' as leader. And his government's
antagonism to life on Earth.
Another potentially powerful and pervasive mind-bending media force is the ranking and placement of stories.
Experiments led by psychologist Dr Robert Epstein have found that subtly altering the order of search results
in search engines changes the voting intentions of undecided voters by
20 per cent or more, without their realising. Ratings of candidate trust
and liking change along with votes.
Given the power of position, a valuable opportunity to build trust
and liking in climate science was recently missed by the Australian
press. The tragic news of widespread coral bleaching in the Great
Barrier Reef was ranked 9th most reported news topic in the first week of the story breaking, and 10th in the second week, out-ranked by the Tewnty20 World Cup and the Socceroos.
Not the kind of ranking that influences votes.
But do all these media influences really matter? Laboratory
experiments are one thing, but is there any impact on real-life voting
at the end of the day?
If not, what's the harm? Perhaps it's all passing perturbations, like a swell in the sea, leaving no meaningful trace.
I will examine this issue more fully in part II, but suffice to say
that implicit media processes not only influence reality, they create
it.
With respect to voting behaviour, newscasters' facial expressions
have been linked not only to viewers' evaluations of political
candidates but to their votes. During the 1984 US presidential election
coverage, of the newscasters studied, facial bias
(smiley-face/frowny-face) was detected in favour of Ronald Reagan.
Viewers who watched the facially-biased coverage were more likely to
vote for Reagan.
Reagan brought us neoliberalism. Neoliberalism brought us corporate
takeover of everything, the GFC, austerity, unbridled climate change….
You get the idea.
Oh, and the fossil-fuelled Coalition.
Former US president Ronald Reagan. (IMAGE: Gage Skidmore, Flickr)
The Reagan study is not alone. In more recent research, coding of
newspaper content during election campaigns revealed differences across
papers in percentages of negative, neutral and positive mentions for
candidates. Readers' real-world voting patterns followed suit.
The authors concluded that their "results raise serious questions about the media's place in democratic processes."
Serious questions, for instance, about the impact of newspaper coverage of the mining super-profits tax in 2010, 76 per cent of which was negative.
Had anyone tracked the real-world implications of this, the empirical
trail would no doubt have led, along with other trails, to mining's
privileged and protected status in Australia today.
More protected than the Great Barrier Reef.
Professor of Media and Communications Simon Cottle
says, "Journalism has become the principal platform for the
communication and conduct of politics… [and]structures the wider play of
power " in a way that is "consequential for democracy".
This is not simply Professor Cottle's opinion. Journalism has been
shown repeatedly in research to be an active, agenda-setting player in
politics and world affairs.
To pretend otherwise, by claiming that journalism is and can be an objective observer,
serves mainly to disguise this fact, lending already unseen media
influences the added camouflage of 'impartiality'. Biases that favour
the status quo become as good as invisible under cover of 'mere
reporting'.
Moreover, the 'objective observer' is based on a fictitious account
of human information processing, as old as the Enlightenment 'Rational
Man'. Truth is a far more psychologically viable standard, and more
defensible, as John Pilger argues powerfully here.
Needless to say, there are exceptional journalists in the mainstream
media doing outstanding work, with truthful transparency rather than
grandiose delusions of objectivity.
However, the media ecology in which they operate works against them.
During the coming election coverage, for instance – with all the
detail and distraction, numbers and counter-numbers, under cover of
'mere reporting' – will climate change, a faceless entity, get lost in
the face-value fray? In the noisy political personality pageant, and the
commentary on the race, will the quiet realities of climate change get
the top billing they deserve? The billing they need to influence votes?
Or will editors hand politicians a bullhorn, allowing their
priorities and scare-campaigns to dominate, drowning reality out, and
tugging on voters' most visceral and simplistic cognitive impulses?
At the end of it all, will Australians vote for the headshot of
whoever won the popularity contest of the day, or for life on Earth?
In Lodge and Taber's words, "Where, when, how and for whom conscious
processing will successfully override the automatic intuitive response
is the critical unanswered question that goes to the heart of all
discussions of human rationality, and the meaning of a responsible
electorate".
In part II of this series I will look at one journalistic convention
that renders minds particularly psychologically pliable, and runs riot
at election time. With reference to case examples, I will examine how
this convention has closed minds to information on climate change over
decades.
Lastly, I will offer educated guesses as to remedies for this and
other varieties of mass media mind control, drawing on lessons from Psy
Ops, information warfare and the US presidential primaries.
The Guardian - Vicki Arroyo* Louisiana’s sinking Isle de Jean Charles shows the urgent need for measures to combat climate change
A car lies upside down at the edge of a marsh amid other storm debris from Hurricane Katrina. Photograph: Robert F. Bukaty/AP
As seas rise, as floods and droughts become more extreme, as crops
fail and as storms intensify, the world will increasingly face a new
challenge – climate refugees.
In the US, witness the recent plan by the federal government to resettle a Native American tribe before their Isle de Jean Charles home in Louisiana vanishes underwater
– an example that hits close to home. I have deep family roots in south
Louisiana: my mother, sister and brother-in-law, aunt and uncle were
refugees from a weather disaster exacerbated by climate change, losing
their homes in New Orleans during Hurricane Katrina in 2005. A year before, a heart condition killed my father in the aftermath of a stressful evacuation from Hurricane Ivan.
Some scientists already argue that the hundreds of thousands of
Syrians fleeing their war-torn country are as much refugees from climate
change as from conflict, because of years of climate-related drought.
Others predict the world will see hundreds of millions more climate
refugees by mid-century, at a staggering human, financial and political
cost.
And sadly, this looming problem is not a surprise. Way back in 1988, I
represented Louisiana on a global warming task force of the National
Governors' Association. Even then, the sobering effects of increasing
concentrations of carbon dioxide were clear. We didn't miss the irony
that oil-producing coastal states like Louisiana
and Alaska would be hit hard by climate change. Many years later, in
2004, while serving on a federal climate-change task force, I saw the
simulated devastation wreaked by computer-generated storm "Pam" along
the Gulf coast. I was shaken, and prayed it would never actually come to
pass. But it did in Katrina and, just three weeks later, the
record-setting Hurricane Rita.
And we can expect far more extreme weather. Over my decades of work
on climate change, what has been a surprise is that these impacts are
coming faster than we once thought, as the rate and extent of changes –
such as climbing temperatures, increased heat waves and floods, and
rising seas – outstrip projections. The massive ice sheets covering
Greenland and west Antarctica are disintegrating far more quickly than
scientists calculated even in the last IPCC report in 2014.
Earlier this year, on a trip to Antarctica, I saw enormous icebergs
calving off the continent – a stark reminder of the immense changes
under way on the planet we all call home.
As a result, seas are now expected to rise by feet rather than inches
this century, and other changes are accelerating. The first three
months of 2016 have already shattered historical temperature records,
with soaring heat in the Arctic speeding the rate of sea ice loss. With
no ice to protect their coastal villages from storm-tossed waves, Native
American communities in Alaska are also becoming climate refugees, with
a price tag to move just one Inuit village, Shishmaref, estimated at $180m.
Like
many other subsistence cultures living near the water, the people of
Isle de Jean Charles or Shishmaref did little to contribute to climate
change. Neither have many other coastal communities around the world
that will suffer similar fates. It may be that the Louisiana climate
refugees will be among the luckier ones—in the sense that they are
getting help to move away from their sinking island. Countless others
will have to leave their homes with an uncertain future and no place to
welcome them.
I witnessed the heartbreak of losing home and community at first
hand. After Katrina flooded 80% of New Orleans, my relatives, a friend
and their five cats relocated to Arlington, Virginia and lived with me
for several months. I saw the pain of being away from a home that you
did not choose to leave. My sister said that losing her cherished New
Orleans life and being thrown into mine in the Washington, DC area was
like being in the witness protection programme. When it was unclear if
the city would survive, she worried if the culture, food, music,
neighbourhoods and people that made New Orleans unique and irreplaceable
would be lost forever.
My family was able to return to New Orleans, working to make it
stronger. The Isle de Jean Charles tribe doesn't have that option. But
thanks to support from the National Disaster Resilience Competition and
the state, it does have a chance to rebuild elsewhere, though
maintaining their cultural bonds in a new environment could be a
challenge.
It's not that we are leaving home, but that home is leaving us
It's unlikely that millions of others will be given the same
opportunity. From Bangladesh to Boston, from London to Vietnam,
low-lying areas near coasts are endangered. Meanwhile, prolonged
droughts will continue to fuel migration and conflicts in the Middle
East, central and eastern Africa and other regions.
Is there hope in his bleak picture? The Paris Agreement to curb emissions
that cause climate change was a huge, historic step. Now, every nation
must live up to its pledges in that agreement – and go beyond them – if
we are to keep the planet's temperature from rising more than 2C, the
level that scientists believe will prevent catastrophic consequences.
However, we are already in a warming world and we must prepare for
the changes happening today and in the future. We need to use the best
available science to identify and reduce our vulnerabilities to rising
seas, droughts, floods and other impacts. We need not only to invest
more in resilient infrastructure – roads, railways, bridges, ports and
subways; water, wastewater and electricity systems – but also to change
how we invest and rebuild, taking future climate conditions into account
instead of building for historic norms.
We also need to update our laws and policies to make it easier to get
permits for protective measures, including green solutions such as
living shorelines, or for retreating from encroaching water. And at a
time when one major political party in the US denies the very reality of
climate change, we need to find the political will and the economic
resources to do this and to help the most vulnerable. We need to support
not just those displaced, but also those communities that accept
climate refugees.
Perhaps most difficult is the need to engage in wrenching but
necessary conversations about what it means to leave the only home
you've known, and the home where your ancestors are buried, to try to
create a more stable future. These must be conversations for all of us,
not just those in Louisiana or Alaska. The economic, political and
psychological toll of the coming droughts, famines, wars, storms and
rising seas is difficult to fathom. Yet remarkably, even in this active
political season, the need to adapt to climate change has hardly been
mentioned.
For Louisiana, my home state, the stakes couldn't be higher. We've
lost the equivalent of Delaware's entire landmass over the past century,
and the familiar outline of the state is being eaten away. The wetlands
that once provided bountiful resources while serving as a buffer
against storms and floods are continuing to vanish at an alarming rate.
Watching the Louisiana coast sink faster than any other shoreline on the
planet while being buffeted by ever-rising seas and storms, one thing
is clear. It's not that we are leaving home, but that home is leaving
us.
*Vicki Arroyo is executive director of the Georgetown Climate Center and Professor from Practice at Georgetown Law.
Coastal communities around Australia are facing the rising threat of coastal erosion.
AAP/Dave Hunt
Representatives of Australian coastal communities have gathered
this week to discuss the major challenges they face. Delegates at the conference in Rockingham,
Western Australia, represent 40 councils around Australia, some falling
within the 24 federal electorates held by a margin of 5% or less. In contrast to the federal budget, climate change is at the top of their agenda.
At the coming federal election, 24 coastal electorates are held by a margin of 5% or less. Compiled with NATSEM, University of Canberra and the Australian Coastal Councils. Author provided
Coastal councils and their communities call on the Australian Government to play a leadership role in developing a co-ordinated national approach to coastal management by adopting a set of policy initiatives based on the recommendations of the bipartisan Australian Parliamentary Coastal Inquiry.
Challenges of growth and change
Australia's population is set to grow from 24 million to 40 million people by 2050. On present trends, this growth is likely to be concentrated in coastal regions, mostly along the eastern seaboard.
Australian Coastal Councils Association chair Barry Sammels, the mayor of Rockingham, observed:
Coastal seats are among the most vulnerable at the forthcoming election. Some of them are growing very rapidly, and others are changing demographically as 'sea-changers' migrate to coastal areas and people with young families are relocating from the cities in search of a better quality of life. This invariably means these regional coastal electorates, which have traditionally elected conservative political candidates, are becoming politically more volatile.
Coastal communities, in particular those which are changing in character, are demanding these risks be taken seriously. … They currently feel there is a lack of commitment from both major parties to deal with these threats.
Lack of urgency at the top
While bipartisan interest in cities policies is growing, this needs to be extended to coastal regions experiencing big changes on several fronts – demographic, economic and environmental.
The lack of long-term strategic coastal planning puts both communities and environments at risk. The bleaching of the Great Barrier Reef illustrates the impacts of environmental change on tourism, jobs and long-term economic security.
We need a national plan to support local councils to better manage coastal urban development, climate change and the consequences for their communities. We have had over 25 national reports leading to largely no action.
In the communique, coastal councils reasonably call for action on key recommendations of the comprehensive 2009 parliamentary inquiry:
We propose that the following recommendations of the coastal inquiry be adopted: That the Australian Government, in co-operation with state, territory and local governments, and in consultation with coastal stakeholders, develop an Intergovernmental Agreement on the Coastal Zone to be endorsed by the Council of Australian Governments.
And that:
The Australian Government ensure that [the agreement] forms the basis for a National Coastal Zone Policy and Strategy, which should set out the principles, objectives and actions that must be taken to address the challenges of integrated coastal zone management for Australia.
Mandurah, WA, epitomises both the pace of growth of coastal communities and their vulnerability to climate change.Rexness/flickr, CC BY-SA
Action has begun locally Finally, not all coastal planning and management is achieved through law and policy. A great deal of activity occurs locally through goodwill and collaboration. To highlight three examples:
in the west, the Peron Naturaliste Partnership involving nine local councils in the south-west, which won the 2016 Australian Coastal Award for Climate Adaptation
Such collaboration and innovation deserves long-term funding from higher levels of government.
We may have got this far without an integrated approach to coastal planning and management, but without it there is no way we will be able to manage coastal growth with the projected demographic, economic and climate changes.
That's why local councils are demanding immediate action on a national coastal policy to meet the needs of our coastal communities and environment. To ignore their call is a very significant political risk indeed.