Wednesday, May 18, 2016

Climate Change: Flooding Caused By Global Warming To Put One Billion People At Risk By 2060, Charity Warns

The Independent - Will Worley

Flooding is a 'humanitarian crisis waiting to happen'
Flood damage in low-lying Miami could be the most costly in the world Getty


More than a billion people will be at risk from flooding caused by climate change in just a few decades' time, a leading charity has warned.
Christian Aid says that  huge numbers of people in coastal cities would exposed to rising seas, flooding, extreme weather and storm surges by 2060.
The urban poor – a demographic expected to grow in coming years - would be hardest hit, the charity said, in a “humanitarian crisis waiting to happen”.However, the report says a widespread catastrophe was not inevitable and protective measures implemented now could negate the worst effects.
If trends continue, many of the places likely to be hardest hit will be in Asia, but the US will also badly suffer the effects, according to the paper.
South Asia will be the hardest hit, with the Indian cities of Kolkata and Mumbai, and the Bangladeshi city of Dhaka, predicted to have the largest populations – all of at least 11 million people - exposed to coastal flooding by the 2070s.
Severe flooding hits India 2015


Cities in East Asia – Guangzhou and Shanghai in China, Ho Chi Minh City in Vietnam, Bangkok in Thailand and Myanmar’s Yangon - are also likely to have populations of millions at risk of flooding.
All of these places are characterised by rising inequality, the report said, and it is the “poorest people with the fewest assets who have the most to lose”.
Miami, with 4.7 million residents, is the ninth city in terms of populations at risk, but the most at risk in financial terms, with more than $3.5 trillion assets predicted to be exposed to extreme weather and flooding by 2070. New York’s assets, predicted $2.1 trillion, are third most at risk.
Chinese cities are also set to take a "financial hammering”.
In Europe, the low lying Dutch cities of Amsterdam and Rotterdam are ranked the 14th and 15th most at financial risk.
London is deemed a “vulnerable city” by the report, at risk from tidal and surface flooding -- a result of rain pressure on the city’s drainage systems. There is also risk from water shortages because of an increased population, water demand and drought.
The report also highlighted how women are worse affected by men in climate related disasters and said a “gender responsive” approach to planning and preparation was critical.
Christian Aid called for a community led response to develop skills and preparation measures. It also said at least $1billion should be invested by the international community into infrastructure measures in the most vulnerable places. The group also said “every effort” should be made to meet the Paris climate targets but that the world should also prepare for “loss and damage”.

Links

Australia Is Not Prepared For Growing Natural Disasters, Experts Warn

NEWS.com.au - Gavin Fernando

SORRY, folks. The news is not good. This weather is only getting more extreme, natural disasters are getting increasingly more deadly, and we puny humans seem pretty content to sit back and accept our murky fate.
The World Bank has issued a warning to major cities around the world that we're underprepared for major risks from extreme weather and other hazards, which will only intensify due to population growth and surging migration.
By 2050, 1.3 billion people and $AU217 trillion in assets will be affected by worsening river and coastal floods alone.
The report says many city officials have no clear idea of the range of disaster risks they face and how serious they could be.
A combination of sea-level rise and sinking of coastal cities, including from excessive extraction of the groundwater, could drive disaster losses in 136 coastal cities from $US6 billion a year ($A8.1b) in 2010 to $US1 trillion a year by 2070.
In Indonesia, for instance, chances of flooding from overflowing rivers is expected to grow 166 per cent over the next 30 years, while coastal flooding risk could rise 445 per cent.
Nepal's capital Kathmandu could see a 50 per cent rise in earthquake risk by 2045 as more slums and informal buildings go up.
Overall, the message is clear: parts of the world are pretty screwed.

What does this mean for australia?
The report identified rising sea levels, extreme heat and drought as some of the biggest natural disasters that will affect Australia over coming years.
"Sea-level rise is an extremely important influence on evolving hazard," it says.
"It contributes more to increased storm tide heights in Victoria, Australia, than higher wind speeds. This suggests that storm surge risk is likely to increase under climate change, despite the remaining uncertainty around regional changes in cyclone frequency and intensity."
The report also stressed the importance of addressing extreme heatwaves, which Australia, of course, is renowned for. It warned that, since they're already a prime driver of mortality, and since long-duration temperature extremes lead to drought, this could trigger climate-related human migration.
Australia is already seeing an increase in its number of heatwaves. Source: BOM
Australia is already seeing an increase in its number of heatwaves. Source: BOM
While we're reasonably lucky when it comes to hazards like earthquakes and volcanoes, we're already seeing an increase in the number of heatwaves.
Dr Sarah Perkins-Kirkpatrick, a research fellow at UNSW's Climate Change Research Centre, told news.com.au that many people don't seem to realise that heatwaves have killed more people than any other natural disaster, so much so that she dubbed it the "silent killer".
"By 2050, this will have huge implications for public health and infrastructure," she said. By 2050, Sydney and Perth can expect 15 more heatwaves per season, with Melbourne and Adelaide between five and 10.
She said that heatwaves get more frequent going north, but more intense going south, meaning the whole country is more or less affected one way or another.
Meanwhile, The Bureau of Meteorology and CSIRO project the number of extreme fire weather days will grow in southern and eastern Australia by 100 and 300 per cent by 2050 compared to 1980 to 1999.

What are heatwaves?

Dr Perkins-Kirkpatrick stressed that a key part of the problem was Australia's attitude to heatwaves, and climate change more broadly.
"There's this whole culture where we're like 'Just suck it up'," she said. "We need a culture shift. You look at the trade industry where people are on rooftops building houses in 40 degree heat, because if they don't work they don't get paid. We need to take heatwaves more seriously, accept that it's happening, so we can change the course of the century."
Extreme heatwaves will be a growing problem for Australia over the next few decades.
Extreme heatwaves will be a growing problem for Australia over the next few decades. Source: News Corp Australia
She warned that on the east coast residents of western Sydney would be the most vulnerable. It's the hottest part of the city, being further away from the ocean, and a hotspot for rapid population growth.
Reports in the past few years have estimated that Australia's population will reach 42 million by 2050, with about eight million of these people living in Sydney. The World Bank said there's a correlation between population growth and natural disasters.
Earlier this year, the Australian Business Roundtable for Disaster Resilience and Safer Communities predicted that our nation's natural disaster bill will triple to $33 billion by 2050, which is 50 per cent greater than previous estimates.
This was based not only on the physical impact of natural disasters, but the social impacts such as mental health issues, chronic disease and alcohol misuse as a result.
Australian Red Cross Director of Australian Services, Noel Clement, said this filled a critical gap in the research on medium and long-term impact of disasters on Australian communities.
"Governments, business and communities need to work together to address the medium and long-term social impacts of natural disasters through further investment and research into community resilience programs," he said.
Dr Perkins-Kirkpatrick shared this view.
"The Budget barely mentioned climate change — that speaks volumes," she said.
"The CSIRO debacle speaks volumes too.
"We need to adapt. We need to prepare our hospitals so they can be ready when a heatwave occurs. We need education for the elderly, who are the most vulnerable to heatwaves. We need to shift towards mitigation and adaptation."
The world is underprepared for natural hazards, and Australia is not immune.
The world is underprepared for natural hazards, and Australia is not immune. Source: News Limited
In the 2016 Budget, it was announced that the Clean Energy Finance Corporation (CEFC) and the Australian Renewable Energy Agency (ARENA) would refocus their activities "towards the government's innovation agenda".
The CEFC will be responsible for allocating $1 billion in existing funding over 10 years to establish a Clean Energy Innovation Fund. The fund will provide money to assist emerging clean energy technology become commercially viable. The fund will be jointly managed by ARENA, which will also continue to manage its existing portfolio through the new fund.

Climate change at the centre of this year's election.

Environment groups, such as the Australian Conservation Foundation and the Australian Youth Climate Coalition, expressed their disappointment with the government's response to tackling climate change in the Budget, with the latter pointing out that the "Budget provides no new funding for renewable energy".
Regardless, Dr Perkins-Kirkpatrick said we're already locked in for a set amount of change by 2050, meaning that, even if we did take drastic measures to lower our carbon emissions, we wouldn't be free from the effects of what's already been done.
That's a scary thought.

Tuesday, May 17, 2016

Bonn UN Climate Talks Seek To Turn Words Into Action

Deutsche Welle - Reuters | AFP

Climate experts are meeting in Bonn to draw up a rule book from the 2015 Paris Agreeent. Their deliberations come after seven months of record temperatures around the world.
Bonn Deutschland Klimakonferenz im World Conference Center Delegates to the latest round of talks following the Paris Agreement began their work on Monday to work out a detailed plan on how governments are to report and monitor their national plans to curb greenhouse gas emissions.
Their 10-day meeting comes as US space agency NASA reported that last month was the warmest April in statistics dating back to the 19th century. April was the seventh month in a row to break temperature records.
Spiralling global temperatures from 1850-2016.


Costa Rican diplomat Christiana Figueres, the retiring executive secretary of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change
Retiring UN climate director Christiana Figueres told the conference on Monday that the record temperatures were partly caused by the natural warming effect of the El Nino weather activity in the Pacific Ocean but that it was magnified by the build-up of man-made greenhouse gas emissions.
Addressing delegates at the start of the 10-day meeting, Figueres said: "The whole world is united in its commitment to the global goals embodied in the Paris Agreement," telling the 196-nation UN meeting: "Now we must design the details of the path to the safe, prosperous and climate-neutral future to which we all aspire."
The meeting in Germany is the first since the UN members reached a deal in Paris to limit climate change by moving away from the use of fossil fuels to renewable energy by 2100. Last month, the agreement was signed by 175 governments at a ceremony in New York, including top greenhouse-gas emitters China and the United States.The agreement still needs to be ratified by national governments. It will come into force when 55 nations, representing 55 percent of world emissions, have signed up to the plan. French Environment Minister Segolene Royal said she would submit a bill on Tuesday to the French National Assembly, seeking ratification.
Speaking to the Bonn conference on Monday, Royal said: "The Paris Agreement represents the foundations ... Now we have to raise the walls, the roof of a common home."

Warmest April
US scientists have reported that last month was the warmest April recorded, the seventh consecutive month to exceed previous highs. The record means that 2016 will become the warmest calendar year in NASA's database.
NASA records the warmest April on record.



During each of the past seven months, global average surface temperatures have exceeded the 20th century average by more than 1 degree Celsius (1.8 degrees Fahrenheit).
Water pipelines from the Tansa dam, near Mumbai, India
Water pipelines from the Tansa dam, near Mumbai, India
On Monday, the Japan Meteorological Agency backed up NASA in finding that April was the warmest such month since their records began in 1891. The warm weather was most pronounced across the Arctic, from Siberia to Greenland and Alaska. There were deadly heat waves in Thailand and India.
The UN climate talks in Bonn continue until May 26, and will also set the agenda for the next high-level gathering in Marrakesh, Morocco in November.

Links

Climate Change Puts 1.3bn People And $158tn At Risk, Says World Bank

The Guardian - 

Organisation urges better city planning and defensive measures to defend against rapid rise in climate change-linked disasters 
Submerged huts after flooding in Nigeria village
Flooding and drought will affect more people but few countries are planning for it, warns the World Bank. Photograph: Tony Karumba/AFP/Getty Images
The global community is badly prepared for a rapid increase in climate change-related natural disasters that by 2050 will put 1.3 billion people at risk, according to the World Bank.
Urging better planning of cities before it was too late, a report published on Monday from a Bank-run body that focuses on disaster mitigation, said assets worth $158tn – double the total annual output of the global economy – would be in jeopardy by 2050 without preventative action.
The Global Facility for Disaster Reduction and Recovery said total damages from disasters had ballooned in recent decades but warned that worse could be in store as a result of a combination of global warming, an expanding population and the vulnerability of people crammed into slums in low-lying, fast-growing cities that are already overcrowded.
"With climate change and rising numbers of people in urban areas rapidly driving up future risks, there's a real danger the world is woefully unprepared for what lies ahead," said John Roome, the World Bank Group's senior director for climate change.
"Unless we change our approach to future planning for cities and coastal areas that takes into account potential disasters, we run the real risk of locking in decisions that will lead to drastic increases in future losses."
The facility's report cited case studies showing that densely populated coastal cities are sinking at a time when sea levels are rising. It added that the annual cost of natural disasters in 136 coastal cities could increase from $6bn in 2010 to $1tn in 2070.
The report said that the number of deaths and the monetary losses from natural disasters varied from year to year, but the upward trend was pronounced.
Total annual damage – averaged over a 10-year period – had risen tenfold from 1976–1985 to 2005–2014, from $14bn to more than $140bn. The average number of people affected each year had risen over the same period from around 60 million people to more than 170 million.
Although developed countries have been responsible for the bulk of historic global emissions, poorer countries are more vulnerable to the impact of climate change and they demanded financial help from the west as part of last December's breakthrough global deal to reduce emissions.
Oxfam this week called on rich countries to make good on the pledges made at the Paris conference to provide the funding to help developing countries adapt to the effects of global warming.
"Climate change is a brutal reality confronting millions of the world's most vulnerable people. Their need for financial support to adapt to climate extremes is urgent and rising," Oxfam said in its Unfinished Business report.
"International support for adaptation falls well short of what is needed. Latest estimates indicate that only 16% of international climate finance is currently dedicated to adaptation – a mere $4bn–$6bn per year of which is public finance."
According to the the facility, disaster risk is affected by three factors. It said these were: hazard – the frequency of potentially dangerous naturally occurring events, such as earthquakes or tropical cyclones; exposure – the size of the population and the economic assets located in hazard-prone areas; and vulnerability – the susceptibility of the exposed elements to the natural hazard.
It added that hazard was increasing due to climate change; exposure was going up because more people were living in hazardous areas and that vulnerability was on the rise because of badly designed and poorly planned housing.
The World Bank-run body said the population was expected to rise by at least 40% in 14 of the 20 most populated cities in the world between 2015 and 2030, with some cities growing by 10 million people in that period. "Many of the largest cities are located in deltas and are highly prone to floods and other hazards, and as these cities grow, an ever greater number of people and more assets are at risk of disaster."
Francis Ghesquiere, head of the secretariat at the The Global Facility for Disaster Reduction and Recovery, said: "By promoting policies that reduce risk and avoiding actions to drive up risk, we can positively influence the risk environment of the future. The drivers of future risk are within the control of decision makers today. They must seize the moment."

Links

Confirmed: Southern Hemisphere CO2 Level Rises Above Symbolic 400ppm Milestone

Fairfax - 

A significant marker of rising global greenhouse gas emissions has been passed, with a key monitoring site on Tasmania's north-west tip recording atmospheric carbon-dioxide exceeding 400 parts per million for the first time.
As foreshadowed by Fairfax Media last week, a baseline reading at the Cape Grim station that exceeded the 400-ppm mark of the primary gas driving global warming was imminent.
Cape Grim, one of the world's most important monitoring stations for gauging changes in the atmosphere.
Cape Grim, one of the world's most important monitoring stations for gauging changes in the atmosphere. Photo: Auscape
As it turned out, "the unfortunate milestone" was reached on Tuesday May 10 at 8am, local time, said Paul Krummel, who heads the CSIRO team analysing data from the most important site in the southern hemisphere. (See chart below.)

"It's a bit sooner than we expected," Mr Krummel told Fairfax Media. "It just rocketed up there."
Australian emissions are on the increase, particularly in the electricity sector.
Australian emissions are on the increase, particularly in the electricity sector. Photo: Michele Mossop 
Atmospheric readings from Cape Grim, along with two stations in Hawaii and Alaska, are closely watched as they date back decades and closely track a range of pollutants from ozone-depleting chemicals to the various greenhouse gases resulting from burning fossil fuels and clearing forests.
Mr Krummel said that while mostly symbolic, the 400-ppm reading "highlights the problem of rising emissions, which are increasing more rapidly than they used to be".
A report out earlier this year from the World Meteorological Organization noted atmospheric readings of CO2 at the Mauna Loa site in Hawaii rose 3.05 ppm in 2015 alone – the biggest increase in the 56 years of research.
Melting moments: A polar bear off the coast of Svalbard, Norway.
Melting moments: A polar bear off the coast of Svalbard, Norway. Photo: Steven Kazlowski

Sun-Herald editorial illustration from May 15.
Sun-Herald editorial illustration from May 15. Photo: David Rowe
The recent surge in CO2 levels was not unexpected because of the giant El Nino event now breaking up in the Pacific. In El Nino years, global temperatures get a kick higher and droughts tend to be worse. As a result, vegetation take out less CO2 from the atmosphere.
CSIRO's Mr Krummel said the El Nino influence was evident in Cape Grim's reading with barely a dip in the past year as might otherwise be expected in spring.
"This year, it's just plateaued and now it's taken off again," he said, adding the site was "probably one of the last places on earth" to remain below 400 ppm.
Sites in the northern hemisphere exceeded 400 ppm from 2012 onwards. But as the region has greater seasonal variation – mostly because there is more terrestrial vegetation – CO2 concentrations dropped back below that mark each spring.
Once Cape Grim gets past a short period with CO2 levels gyrating around 400 ppm, it will need a huge global effort to curb greenhouse gas emissions to push the level back down.
"It's not going to go back below 400 ppm for a very long time unless we get very good at mitigation," Mr Krummel said.Global CO2 levels were running at roughly 280 ppm up until about 1850 when they started to take off. (See chart below).
Climate scientists, such as David Karoly at Melbourne University, note that when other greenhouse gases, such as methane, are included, the situation is even bleaker.
The so-called carbon dioxide-equivalent level that takes in the full global warming impact is now about 485 ppm.
Both 2014 and 2015 were record hot years globally in data going back about 130 years. With the effect of a strong El Nino overlaying long-term trends, this year is likely to be even hotter after a scorching start.
Ed Hawkins, a climate scientist at the UK's University of Reading, has constructed the following animation showing how the world has warmed in the past 166 years.
Many regions of the world are experiencing unusual warmth for May, with parts of Alaska expected to be 15 degrees warmer than average.
Even Sydney is running about 5 degrees above average so far for May and Australia on the whole is headed for close to its warmest autumn on record.
The Cape Grim site, meanwhile, celebrated its 40th anniversary in March with a cloud over its future because of the CSIRO job cuts.
While management has promised to maintain the facility that it runs in cooperation with the Bureau of Meteorology, the number of CSIRO staff analysing the gases collected at the site is expected to be cut by about one-third from the current tally of about 30 researchers.

Links

Monday, May 16, 2016

April Breaks Global Temperature Record, Marking Seven Months Of New Highs

The Guardian - Michael Slezak

Latest monthly figures add to string of recent temperature records and all but assure 2016 will be hottest year on record
Global land and sea temperature was 1.11C warmer in April 2016 than the average temperature for April during the period 1951-1980. Photograph: Stephane Mahe/Reuters
April 2016 was the hottest April on record globally – and the seventh month in a row to have broken global temperature records.
The latest figures smashed the previous record for April by the largest margin ever recorded.
It makes three months in a row that the monthly record has been broken by the largest margin ever, and seven months in a row that are at least 1C above the 1951-80 mean for that month. When the string of record-smashing months started in February, scientists began talking about a "climate emergency".
Figures released by Nasa over the weekend show the global temperature of land and sea was 1.11C warmer in April than the average temperature for April during the period 1951-1980.
It all but assures that 2016 will be the hottest year on record, and probably by the largest margin ever.

The new record broke the previous one by 0.24C, which was set in 2010, at 0.87C above the baseline average for April. That record itself broke one set three years earlier at 0.75C above the baseline average for April.
NASA records the warmest April on record.

The current blast of hot air around the globe is being spurred by a massive El Niño, which is a release of warm water across the Pacific Ocean. But it's not the biggest El Niño on record and that spike in temperatures is occurring over a background of rapid global warming, pushing temperatures to all-time highs.
"The interesting thing is the scale at which we're breaking records," said Andy Pitman, director of the ARC Centre of Excellence for Climate System Science at the University of New South Wales in Australia. "It's clearly all heading in the wrong direction.
"Climate scientists have been warning about this since at least the 1980s. And it's been bloody obvious since the 2000s. So where's the surprise?" said Pitman.
Pitmans said the recent figures put the recent goal agreed in Paris of just 1.5C warming in doubt. "The 1.5C target, it's wishful thinking. I don't know if you'd get 1.5C if you stopped emissions today. There's inertia in the system. It's putting intense pressure on 2C," he said.
The record temperatures were wreaking havoc with ecosystems around the world. They've triggered the third recorded global coral bleaching, and in Australia 93% of the reefs have been affected by bleaching along the 2,300km Great Barrier Reef. In the northern parts of the reef, it's expected the majority of coral is dead, and on some reefs over 90% of the coral is dying.
A recent analysis showed the bleaching on the Great Barrier Reef was made 175 times more likely because of climate change, and the conditions that caused it would be average in fewer than 20 years.
The April figures come as the symbolic milestone of CO2 concentrations of 400 parts per million (ppm) have been broken at the important Cape Grim measuring station in Tasmania, Australia.
Reflecting on the CO2 concentrations, Pitman said: "The thing that's causing that warming, is going up and up and up. So the cool ocean temperatures we will get with a La Niña are warmer than we'd ever seen more than a few decades ago … This is a full-scale punching of the reef system on an ongoing basis with some occasionally really nasty kicks and it isn't going to recover."
Spiralling global temperatures from 1850-2016.


Links

Direct Action Not Giving Us Bang For Our Buck On Climate Change

The Conversation - 

Energy efficiency projects could receive more subsidies if Direct Action is continued. David González Romero/Flickr, CC BY


Direct Action is the centrepiece of Australia's current greenhouse gas reduction efforts. To date, A$1.7 billion in subsidies has been committed from the government's Emissions Reduction Fund to projects offering to reduce emissions.
The scheme replaced Australia's two-year-old carbon price in 2014 and is a key part of the government's plan to reduce emissions by 5% below 2000 levels by 2020, and 26–28% below 2005 levels by 2030.
Environment Minister Greg Hunt has called Direct Action a "stunning success" and "one of the most effective systems in the world for significantly reducing emissions".
In a new article in Economic Papers, I look into the economics of Direct Action and how it is working. I conclude that the scheme is exposed to funding projects that would have happened without government funding.
This issue has long been known as a threat to schemes of this type, and means that the scheme is likely to be less useful in reducing emissions than the government is claiming.
Commonwealth Procurement Rules require value for money in government purchases. It is not clear we are getting that with Direct Action.

Information problems
The key challenge for schemes like Direct Action is information. What exactly is the scheme buying, and would that have happened without it?
Direct Action works by inviting voluntary project proposals and then allocating funds to the lowest bidders in reverse auctions.
Unfortunately, projects that would have gone ahead even without a subsidy – call them "anyway projects" – have a cost advantage that makes them well placed to win the auctions. It is often difficult for the government to identify such projects. When projects of this type receive funding, taxpayers' money is being used ineffectively.
Economists call this adverse selection, or the "lemons problem".

All about that baseline
The government has developed a set of methods for defining projects and measuring the emission reductions provided by each project against estimated baselines. It is an economy-wide scheme, and there are methods covering everything from energy efficiency to aviation.
As is, the methods leave opportunities for anyway projects to qualify. The Emission Reduction Fund White Paper states that a "flexible approach" is being pursued so as to encourage participation.
One rule is that projects be new. But across the Australian economy, new projects are launched every year. Some happen to reduce emissions. These projects are being attracted into the Direct Action auctions.
Carry-overs from the former Carbon Farming Initiative have also been allowed to side-step the newness requirement.

The experience so far
Three Direct Action auctions have been held to date, with the most recent in late April 2016.
Some of the funded projects are likely to be providing genuine reductions in emissions. Unfortunately, however, some project categories are rather questionable.
Landfill operators have been awarded Direct Action subsidies in each of the auctions. Their projects are often already generating revenues from electricity sales and renewable energy certificates.
Other projects to win subsidies include upgrades to lighting in supermarkets and to the fuel efficiency of vehicles. These are activities that are supposed to happen anyway.
The biggest winner to date has been vegetation projects. Among these are projects to reduce tree clearing, including of invasive native species near Cobar and Bourke in New South Wales. The large payments for these projects are likely to have preserved some vegetation. But some farmers appear to have not actually been planning to clear. If so, funding is going to anyway projects.
This vegetation could be protected under the avoided deforestation category of Direct Action. But was it going to be cleared, and is a taxpayer-funded subsidy the best way to save it? Paul Burke, Author provided
Projects potentially in line for the next auction include boiler upgrades and modifications to aircraft. If Direct Action were to continue for years to come, the bill could become very big.
Journalists such as Lenore Taylor and Tristan Edis are among those who have raised concerns about the quality of Direct Action projects. The government has yet to properly engage with this issue.

This problem could be avoided
There are far better policy approaches than Direct Action subsidies.
A key advantage of either an emissions tax or an emissions trading scheme is that the government does not need to evaluate individual projects from covered enterprises.
These schemes instead introduce a price per unit of emissions and leave the private sector to decide which projects to implement. Large emitters are already required to report their emissions, so implementation is comparatively straightforward. Any revenue raised could be used to reduce other taxes or Australia's budget deficit.
Regulations could also be put to more use. Strengthened restrictions on vegetation clearing and on the release of coal mine gas are examples.
Eligibility to generate offset credits should be tightened to cover only credibly genuine emission reductions that are difficult to achieve using other policies. Some carbon farming activities can meet this criterion, and could generate revenue from private-sector buyers. Public expenditure on new offset projects could be ended.

Better off going back to what was working
There are many other downsides to Direct Action. These include its administrative complexity, the issue of emissions reappearing elsewhere in the economy, and the subsidy culture it inculcates.
The scheme is yet to induce emissions reductions in key sectors of the economy. Emissions from electricity generation are rising again.
Australia has a big challenge ahead in decarbonising our economy. There are many opportunities, but we need to get our policy settings right. It would be better to move on from Direct Action subsidies. An approach centred on pricing emissions makes more sense.

An open-access version of Paul's paper can be downloaded here.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative