Monday, August 01, 2016

Keeping Pace With Climate Change In Crop Development

The Conversation -  | 

Maize can be particularly sensitive to agricultural and climate conditions. Shutterstock
In a context of unprecedented climate change and food insecurity, adaptation in agricultural systems is critical in Africa. It is crucial to breed new varieties of staple crops that are adapted to deal with climatic conditions. This work is a key climate adaptation measure and an important part of international research and development programmes.
Crops have been specifically developed to be resistant to climate-related stresses like drought. There have been impressive advances in the capabilities of crop-breeding programmes as a result of recent investments. An example of this is the Drought Tolerant Maize for Africa initiative. But a new study finds that the new crop varieties that are being developed are struggling to cope with the rate of climatic change.
The study uses crop models and climate change projections to analyse the rate of change in key climate indicators associated with maize. Maize is Africa's most widely grown crop and the main staple for more than 300 million people across the continent.
Maize can be particularly sensitive to climate and management conditions. It is subject to crop failures, which disproportionately affect those with little capacity to invest in inputs like improved seeds and fertilisers, and irrigation.

Crops will struggle
The study identifies the time-scales over which significant increases in temperatures, which shorten the growing period of crops, are expected. It compares this with the time-scales over which new crop varieties are typically bred, tested, and commercially released and adopted in Africa.
Increases in temperature speed up the time that it takes for crops to reach maturity. Shorter crop duration means that the maize accumulates less dry matter through its life cycle, and so yields less. This is why, in different agricultural environments across Africa, varieties are bred to have a duration that matches the full length of the growing season in that particular environment. In Africa, this length is usually defined by the duration of rains.
The results of the study, published in Nature Climate Change, suggest that significant temperature change, outside of the experienced range of current conditions, is likely to take place more quickly than the time in which crops can currently be developed. The consequence is that the durations of newly developed crops are unlikely to be suited to the changed climatic conditions and associated growing seasons.

Making improvements
The study identifies three main options for improving the compatibility between crop development time-scales and those of climatic change.
The first is to speed up the crop development and deployment process. New breeding technologies, like marker-assisted selection of genetic material, can contribute towards this. Marker-assisted selection – where a set of small DNA identifiers, or markers, are used to describe a larger DNA sequence (the genetic material) – helps to identify the desired parent material for breeding quicker than conventional breeding approaches. Institutional and cross-national cooperation in crop breeding can also contribute towards speeding up the breeding process.
The paper also highlights the importance of streamlining processes of regulatory testing and market dissemination. Where appropriate, these can represent a significant component of crop development in some African countries.
A second option is to develop crops in a preemptive way. This can be done in greenhouses regulated at higher temperatures to simulate expected future conditions. It can also take place in analogue locations – locations whose current conditions represent those that are expected to closely correspond with the target areas in the future. Identifying these types of environments has been the subject of recent research. Such an approach requires caution because of the cost involved and the uncertainty associated with future climate projections. The paper makes some cautious recommendations about appropriate temperature increases for preemptive breeding.
A third option is to look at stringent climate change mitigation. Compared with current trajectories of change, it is demonstrated that a global move toward the most ambitious emissions reductions pathways documented by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change would contribute to a better aligning of temperature increases with the time-scales of crop development and deployment.
If new crop varieties are to contribute more effectively to linked challenges of achieving food security and adapting to a changing climate, a combination of these options will be needed. These needs are urgent. They are significant for maize on the African continent, but are not restricted to this crop or continent. The problem of climate change and crop development represents a challenge for agricultural systems across the globe.

Links

Mythbusting: Electricity Prices In South Australia

Renew Economy - Andrew Stock

In recent months, there have been a number of inaccurate media stories linking high electricity prices in South Australia with the State's high proportion of wind and solar generation.
However, a new report from Climate Council reveals that electricity price spikes in South Australia have reduced as renewable energy grows.

Key Findings

1. South Australia is a global leader in renewable energy and is much further ahead than the other states in reducing emissions to tackle climate change.
  • The state is on track to reach its target of 50% renewable electricity by 2030.
  • The state's transition away from fossil fuels, particularly coal, is consistent with action needed to avoid catastrophic climate change and ensure the survival of the Great Barrier Reef.
2. Recent short-term increases in South Australia's wholesale power prices have been driven primarily by a reliance on expensive gas for power and a lack of competition amongst power generators.
  • Average electricity prices have been historically higher in South Australia due to the state's more expensive fossil fuel options and lower electricity market competition.
  • Recent events, including very cold weather, work on the interconnector that restricted supply from Victoria and gas prices at almost four times the usual level, put the two main electricity generators in South Australia in an extraordinarily powerful position to increase prices.
  • Without South Australia's high level of renewables, the state's reliance on expensive gas would be even greater. ›› Queensland (with less than 5% renewable electricity) has until recently experienced similarly high prices to South Australia (with more than 40% renewable electricity).
  • In the past year in particular, all eastern states have experienced similar short-term price patterns over many months, even though New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland generation is overwhelmingly coal based. This is further evidence that the cause of price rises is due to a range of industry factors rather than renewable energy.
3. Renewable energy has dramatically reduced electricity price spikes in South Australia.
  • Electricity price spikes (periods where prices exceeded $5,000/MWh) have fallen significantly across the National Electricity Market as the proportion of renewable energy has increased but especially in South Australia.
  • For comparison, in 2008, South Australia experienced more than 50 price peaks compared to one price peak in 2015.
4. The key to reducing electricity prices in South Australia is reducing the state's reliance on expensive gas through increased competition and a smarter, more connected electricity grid.
  • Improved competition in the electricity market could be achieved by reducing the time intervals set for spot price (wholesale electricity price for a given time period) settlements from half-hour blocks to five-minute blocks.
  • Developing alternative reserve capacity such as large-scale and distributed energy storage would reduce exposure to short-term price exploitation when wind and solar supply are low.
  • Increased interconnection with the eastern states would expand supply options and increase competition with South Australian gas fuelled power plants.
  • AEMO and ElectraNet (2016) have been jointly working together to plan for and accommodate and manage higher levels of wind and solar PV in South Australia.
Links

Your Air Conditioner Is Making You Cooler, And The World Warmer. We Can Change That.

World Bank - Karin Shepardson


Cooling and refrigeration are essential to increasing labor productivity, improving educational outcomes, safeguarding food and minimizing its waste, improving healthcare, and supporting countries' digital ambitions (that computer of yours heats up pretty fast). And all of this, from improved productivity to education to health, is vital to eliminating extreme poverty and boosting shared prosperity across the globe.
And yet, it turns out that that refrigerator in the corner is doing more than extending the life of your fruits and vegetables: it's also contributing to global warming. In a somewhat ironic twist, we know now that in filling the hole in the ozone layer over the past few decades under the aegis of the Montreal Protocol, we unwittingly had been adding to global warming. The good news, though, is that we can act on this quickly, and the result (in ecological terms) is almost immediate. But if we continue as we have been, we could face big problems.
Undoubtedly, the Montreal Protocol's success at reversing a universal environmental problem, depletion of the earth's ozone layer, also helped in our fight against climate change. Without the Montreal Protocol agreement and its 25 years of action to stop production and human consumption of harmful chemicals, the climate challenge facing the world today would be far worse. Overall, the climate achievements in phasing out chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) an organic compound made exclusively of chlorine, fluorine, and carbon, have been equated to the equivalent of eight billion tons a year of CO2. Yet, in hindsight we've learned that hydrofluorocarbons or HFCs, the chemicals picked to replace some CFCs, are very potent greenhouse gasses. What's worse, their use is on the rise globally, since they are seen to be the best substitutes for chemicals used in air conditioners and refrigerators.
The most concerning HFCs are thousands of times more potent than carbon dioxide. Yet unlike carbon dioxide, HFCs tend to stay in the atmosphere for a shorter period, making it possible, if removed, to see a visible reversal of temperature rise impacts within the lifetime of our children. By contrast, the longer atmospheric life of CO2 means it takes longer to see the impact of the removal of the gas, so tangible results would only be seen by our children's children.

From Dubai through Vienna to Kigali
With the climate challenge facing the world already immense, it's clear that action to reduce HFCs must be accelerated to avoid an irreversible tipping point. This has been the key focus of the Montreal Protocol meetings just held in Vienna, attended by ministers from around the world with a focus on phasing down HFCs. One seminal study projected that global temperatures can be reversed by as much as 0.5 degrees Celsius if HFCs and their projected growth are eliminated. We need every tenth of a degree possible.
Several of my colleagues and I attended the Vienna meetings, which were part of a series that started last November in Dubai with the specific aim to work toward amending the Montreal Protocol to phase-down HFCs. An amendment is important because it will give a clear global signal for action and since it's taken within the Montreal Protocol framework, it would enter into legal force rapidly. The discussions highlighted the need for flexibility to respond to different country situations, while at the same time demonstrating strong multilateral consensus for decisive action. The final decision will be made in October in Kigali, Rwanda.

We're already working on it
But with predicted growth projections of HFC being the highest in developing countries (no surprise, since this correlates closely with economic development), the World Bank Group is not waiting for an international agreement to start accelerating action on HFC reductions. We are already working with countries under our Montreal Protocol projects to see where reductions can be taken and where we can reduce HFCs as technology becomes available, affordable, and safe. For example in Thailand, we're working with manufacturers to produce air conditioners that are friendly to the ozone layer, while reducing HFCs and saving energy. Additionally, with Government of Canada support, we are developing tools for Bank teams to identify and act on opportunities for a "triple win" to reduce ozone, reduce HFCs, and increase energy efficiency where air conditioning and refrigeration are part of Bank investments.
We know the Montreal Protocol has already achieved results. We've had reports this year that the recovery of the hole in the ozone layer has already reached a surface area equivalent to the size of India, and full recovery is projected to be achieved before mid-century. But it's too early to celebrate: the challenge remains immense. October will be the time to make a decision that reverberates for generations to come.

Links
Using auctions to support climate and development outcomes
Latin America and the Caribbean: seizing a trillion dollar opportunity in climate investments
Using technology to stay ahead of disaster risk
A map is worth a thousand words: Supporting forest stewards in addressing climate change

Sunday, July 31, 2016

Josh Frydenberg's Rise May Be Best Hope For Climate Bipartisanship 'In A Decade'

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

In this era of accelerated news cycles, one day apparently is a long time in climate change politics.
This past Wednesday, Kane Thornton, chief executive of the Clean Energy Council, began his morning warning delegates to his industry's annual summit to brace for more of the "trash" being hurled at them by opponents of renewable energy.

Climate change (and how to tackle it) is largely responsible for the highest turnover of Prime Ministers in Australia since 1945. Animation by Matt Davidson.

"As we become more successful, we become a bigger target, and we need to understand it's the price we pay for our success," he told the audience in Sydney.
By the day's end, however, the appearance of Josh Frydenberg​, Australia's first federal minister for the environment and energy, had given Thornton cause to believe the battle may be about to turn.
Josh Frydenberg is Australia's first Federal Minister for the Environment and Energy. Photo: Jay Cronan
While the Abbott government's 2015 Energy White Paper all but ignored climate change and backed "a technology neutral policy" on energy sources, Frydenberg was happy to state that energy and climate policy were "effectively two sides of the same coin".
"We are not talking about the economy versus the environment," he told the summit's dinner that evening. "We have to get out of that mindset.
"Other mindsets may soon be cast aside. Mark Butler, Labor's climate change and energy spokesman, praised Frydenberg as a "very energetic, talented, driven minister" who might be capable of bridging one of Australia's widest political gaps.
"The scope for bipartisanship is there on climate change," Butler told Fairfax Media on the sidelines of the summit, adding later: "For the better part of a decade, we've had this toxic division."
Cooling towers and smokestacks at a LaTrobe Valley power plant in Victoria. Photo: Carla Gottgens
The positive vibes preceded election day, including a friendly campaign encounter in Melbourne's Box Hill, parts of which lie in Frydenberg's electorate.
Butler's office also describes as "brilliant" the coordination it received from the resources ministry – then held by Frydenberg – during the caretaker period. By contrast, the relationship with the office of then environment minister Greg Hunt remained one of "trench warfare", much as it had for years.
Solar panel prices have dropped 80 per cent in five years. Photo: Mark Metcalfe
Frydenberg has responded in kind, complimenting Butler with unusually warmth for Canberra: "I have a great deal of respect for him. He's very capable, he's a good advocate."
"There will have to be some handshaking across the aisle, and some deal making and some close consultation in many areas of my portfolio," Frydenberg told the Wednesday dinner.
Clean energy investors are hoping for some policy stability. Photo: Supplied
While the new minister's comments reflect the reality of an expanded senate cross bench – colourfully described as "yellow crazy ants" by Frydenberg – his statements made to the summit and elsewhere this week suggest a change of course is under way from the Abbott years.
Although dubbed "Mr Coal" during his previous role, Frydenberg said the fuel's role would shrink, nothing that recent investment in new electricity generation in Australia had all been in renewable energy. Wind power prices had dropped by half over the past five years and solar PV prices had dived 80 per cent, and battery prices would tumble too, he said.
The current renewable energy target – for annual generation of 33,000 gigawatt-hours of electricity by 2020 – was "set in stone", he added, sparking applause from the diners.
More acclaim, though, was given to comments about the problems in South Australia that had prompted a jump in short-term wholesale electricity prices and triggered one of Frydenberg's first acts in his new ministry – to call state and territory energy ministers for a meeting on August 19.
Defying urgings from some members in his own government and sections of the media to blame the price surge on SA's relatively high dependence on renewable energy, Frydenberg instead downplayed the sector's role in the "crisis".
An ill-timed upgrading of the main power link to Victoria in mid-winter was "the main reason" for the jump, Frydenberg told ABC's Lateline. While the intermittency of renewable energy compared with baseload supplies was a factor, so was a huge jump in gas prices and a cold snap that forced up demand.
Moreover, SA's problems preceded most of the clean energy investments. Yes, short-term prices had jumped three times above the $5000 per megawatt-hour mark this year but in the first quarter of 2008, they did so more than 50 times, Frydenberg told the dinner.
"People have to understand that this volatility is not a new thing … To say it's the fault of renewables is not an accurate assessment," he said.
Frank Jotzo, deputy director of the Crawford School of Public Policy at the Australian National University, said Frydenberg's comments about the energy transition and the decarbonising task "are the kinds of things that we have not really heard from the coalition previously".
However, while there may be convergence between the Coalition and Labor on the climate challenges ahead, there's still a gulf in how they would address them, Professor Jotzo said.
Labor, for instance, supports the re-introduction of a carbon price but the Coalition faces a political problem "because of the past rhetoric" opposed to such a move, he said.
Butler, too, cautioned that the next few weeks would be "critically important" for how Frydenberg and Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull responded "to those trying to stymie any progress on establishing a more mature consensus".
The "real challenge" would be how to "strive for affordable, accessible, and reliable energy supply at the same time as we transition to a lower emissions future", Frydenberg said.
Greens deputy leader Larissa Waters said government policy rather than just the market would be needed to drive the necessary shifts.
 "While we welcome the change in rhetoric on clean energy from warfare to acceptance, actual policy change is needed to deliver and expedite the transition our economy so needs from dirty fuels to clean, and with it the tens of thousands of jobs that we so desperately need," Senator Waters said.
For Thornton, of the Clean Energy Council, Frydenberg's comments had given his industry "real heart".
There's an emerging prospect of "a different approach and a new era of bipartisanship around clean energy and climate policy more broadly," Thornton enthused.
"It's pretty exciting, to be honest."

Links

Rockefeller Fund Takes First Green Stake in Pivot From Oil

Bloomberg - 

Photographer: Chris Ratcliffe/Bloomberg
Summary
  • Fund supports Mainstream's African wind and solar expansion
  • Investment comes after fund pledged fossil fuel divestment
The Rockefeller Brothers Fund, the foundation divesting from the fossil-fuel industry it helped create, took its first direct stake in a renewable energy company in a move meant to bolster the fight against climate change.
The New York City-based fund, founded in 1940 with the profits of Standard Oil Co., provided $10 million to Mainstream Renewable Power Ltd. to expand renewable energy in Africa. The investment was part of an $117.5 million funding round announced last month that included International Finance Corp. and other backers. The investment will help finance as much as $1.9 billion for green energy on the continent.
"The opportunity is huge and for us it's just absolutely in the sweet spot of what we're trying to do with our impact investing," Stephen Heintz, president of the Rockefeller Brothers Fund, said in a telephone interview from New York. "It's completely consistent and advances our philanthropic mission, but does so while supporting market-rate investment and business solutions to climate change."
The Rockefeller Fund joined a group of 800 people and institutions that pledged to divest from fossil fuel companies and boost investments in clean energy, a move intended to put pressure on companies contributing to climate change. Of the fund's $816 million under management, about $97.5 million have gone to so-called "Impact Investments" including its stake in Mainstream as well as positions in vehicles like the New Energy Capital Infrastructure Credit Fund.
The fund is looking to sell 100 percent of its investments in fossil fuel companies that contribute to global warming by at least the end of 2018, said Heintz. The portfolio's exposure to fossil fuel companies has already fallen to 3.3 percent, down from 6.6 percent in April 2014. Investments in the dirtiest sectors -- coal and tar sands -- has fallen to 0.1 percent of the portfolio, Rockefeller said this month.
The Rockefeller investment in the Lekela Power platform, a joint venture between Mainstream and Actis LLP founded in 2015, will help install more than 1.3 gigawatts of renewable electricity across Africa by 2018. Countries targeted by the initiative include South Africa, Ghana, Egypt and Senegal.
"The teaming up of the world's leading independent renewable power developer with a foundation started by members of the family that effectively founded the global oil industry is a significant moment in the world's transition to a new power system based on clean energy," said Mainstream Chief Executive Officer Eddie O'Connor in the statement.
Other investors include IFC African, Latin American and Caribbean Fund and the IFC Catalyst Fund, Ascension Investment Management and Sanlam Ltd. Simmons & Simmons LLP acted as legal counsel to Mainstream and Norton Rose Fulbright LLP to the investor group, according to the statement.
Heintz said the Rockefeller investment is in line with the family's history of pursuing new ideas. John D. Rockefeller, the founder of Standard Oil more than a century ago, was also developing cutting edge fuels when he began investing in oil production at the end of the 19th century. He wanted to displace whale oil, Heintz said.
"I'm absolutely convinced that if he were alive today he would understand this dynamic and he would be on the cutting edge of investing in the clean energy economy because he knows that's where the world is going next," he said.

Future investments
The foundation is looking to expand its investments in renewable energy, with a particular focus on offshore wind farms in the U.K., and the U.S, said Heintz, who has just returned from a trip that included the Scottish Isles and Iceland.
The foundation is also looking at battery storage developments that could help provide stability for intermittent renewable energy technologies such as wind and solar, and is considering investments in renewable energy in the Middle East, where solar auctions have generated record-low prices.
"We're really looking at all those opportunities but we're doing it as very prudent and serious investors. This is not concessional, we're not willing to sacrifice returns and any investment we make, we have to satisfy ourselves that the investment fits the same risk and returns criteria that we would use for any other investment," he said.
In the near-term, RBF is keen to limit risk by investing projects once they're constructed. This could change as the industry matures and it's considering early stage private equity investments.
"This venture capital opportunity is something that's on our radar screen and we're constantly thinking about there's some way for us to be more involved in very promising earlier stage investments," said Heintz.

Links

Saturday, July 30, 2016

Spiral-Tastic: Climate Change In Three Animations

Climate Home - Megan Darby


How do you follow a viral hit?
Climate scientist Ed Hawkins broke the internet in May with a gif that showed global temperatures spiralling since pre-industrial times.
On Facebook, it got 3 million views just through the page “I fucking love science”. Hawkins’ own blog Climate Lab Book temporarily crashed under the weight of hits, which totalled around 100,000.
He’s no Kim Kardashian, but as sci comms goes, this was a runaway success.
It has inspired scientists from Potsdam, Germany and Melbourne, Australia to animate the inexorable rise of carbon dioxide concentrations in the air…

…and how the growing pace of greenhouse gas emissions is eating up the carbon budget to hold global warming below 2C or 1.5C.

Put together with the temperature spiral, they paint a pretty compelling picture.

The genius of the original was to show how the long term warming trend stood out from the noise of natural variation.
Sceptics might put the recent string of 14 record hot months down to El Nino. That weather phenomenon was certainly a factor, but doesn’t explain why the previous decade was so clearly warmer than in the 1850s.
When it comes to carbon dioxide in the air, the increase is more linear, with some seasonal fluctuation as vegetation levels vary.
Finally, the carbon budget graphic joins the dots with human behaviour. It shows how smoke from factories and car exhaust pipes is building up.
In Paris last December, 195 countries agreed to try and limit temperature rise from pre-industrial levels “well below” 2C and to 1.5C if possible.
That implies a ceiling on the volume of greenhouse gases that can be pumped into the air – the “carbon budget”.
There is some uncertainty about how sensitive the climate is to emissions; the budgets shown give a two thirds chance of staying within the threshold.
It may already be too late for 1.5C, as there is a time lag between emissions and their effect on the climate – and coal plants built today have decades to run.
Still, it remains an important marker for communities on the front line of sea level rise and extreme weather.
The more we can eke out the carbon budget, the better their odds become.

Why ‘Sharknado 4’ Matters: Do Climate Disaster Movies Hurt The Climate Cause?

The Conversation -  | 

Disaster movies can raise environmental concerns but also seed misinformation. Disaster via www.shutterstock.com
Given that 2016 is expected to be the hottest year on record, with several months that not only surpassed old heat records but did so by increasingly large margins, it stands to reason climate change should be an issue we as a nation are rushing to address. But we're not, exactly. Instead, climate scientists are subject to political attacks and lawsuits, and debate over whether climate change even exists roils the United States Senate. A reasonable person could be left wondering how the hell we got here.
Social scientists have made great strides in determining what factors influence climate denier attitudes and what kinds of messages have the potential to combat denial. Indeed, a burgeoning movement of academics and communicators are taking on the problem of climate denial with gusto, working nonstop to produce empirically based strategies for getting the message out to the public.
Despite these efforts, researchers have paid less attention to how we're talking about climate change in a larger cultural sense.
Enter "Sharknado." On July 31, the fourth installment of the "Sharknado" film series airs on SyFy. The low-budget films are a surprise smash hit, breaking records in 2013 with the original "Sharknado." It's led to a series of movies and a variety of media spin-offs, including a video game and companion book.


If you've missed this cultural phenomenon, worry not: The film's title tells you most of what you need to know. Major American cities are suddenly beset with waterspouts flinging man-eating sharks – sharknados – through the air at 300 miles per hour, while characters attempt to survive. The plots are predictably ridiculous and the special effects – particularly in the first "Sharknado" – are about what you would expect from a B-movie.
At their heart, however, the "Sharknado" films are stories about climate change, albeit in a way that is scientifically flawed to a comical degree. It's a genre – climate disaster films – we decided to explore as an emerging mode of communication in society.

Fiction helps us understand reality
It's explained in the original "Sharknado" that climate change has created an unusually strong tropical cyclone approaching Southern California. The sequels backed away from that explanation, whether out of a desire to avoid courting political controversy or simply because the creators felt that sharknados needed no explanation, we can't be sure. But casting climate change as a catalyst for extreme, globally threatening natural disasters is a move characteristic of a small but growing genre of climate disaster films.
With a few notable exceptions ("The Day After Tomorrow" and "Snowpiercer" come to mind), climate disaster films tend to be low-budget, made-for-television creatures. Silly as they may seem, they represent the first drops in what is sure to be a storm of fictional depictions of climate change as the issue gains more traction in the public consciousness. In a very real sense, these films are the product of a society attempting to grapple with a massive social threat unlike anything we've seen before.
The Twilight Zone TV series featured episodes about the dangers of nuclear war, including the episode 'Third from the Sun' in 1960, which was based on a science fiction short story. Bureau of Industrial Service
Climate fiction films are important for their potential impact on the public. Climate change itself is difficult to observe for those not trained in environmental sciences; typically people don't notice small changes that happen over time, and carbon dioxide emissions are invisible to the naked eye. Meteorological and climatological records are regularly questioned by climate deniers, some of whom hold political office. Even personal experience may not sway opinions: Research suggests that a person's political leanings can even affect whether he or she perceives unusual weather patterns to be out of the ordinary.
Some scholars hypothesize that this is where fiction comes in. As researcher David Kirby puts it, fiction can serve as a "virtual witnessing tool" that lets us see the scientific process. Literary scholars tout science fiction's ability to show us futures that have not yet come to pass without having to live through them. Indeed, one of fiction's power is this ability to let us explore scenarios and situations in a safe way, without real risk to life or property.
Consider, for instance, the prevalence of fiction about nuclear war during the Cold War. These stories were widely credited with helping society envision the future after a nuclear exchange even as political leaders worked to prevent such an event. Books (and later film adaptations) like "Fail-Safe" and "On the Beach" shaped society's understanding of the consequences of nuclear war. Television shows like the "Twilight Zone" featured stories – and warnings – about nuclear weapons prominently in their plots. President Ronald Reagan even noted in his journal the television movie "The Day After Tomorrow" had a profound effect on him.

Medium for misinformation?
What does this mean for climate change? Like nuclear war, a future in which humanity has undertaken no effort to combat climate change is one we hope to never see. Can fiction play a role in shaping our attitudes and beliefs about climate change and encourage the public to take the threat seriously before it's too late?
A handful of studies were conducted around the release of "The Day After Tomorrow." Similar studies were also conducted on the docudrama "The Age of Stupid" and the documentary "An Inconvenient Truth." But these studies typically examine only blockbuster films and do not address disaster films as a whole.
The studies generally suggest that fictional depictions of climate change can have an effect on audiences – at least in the short term. Seeing clips of these films tends to raise levels of environmental concern and, in some cases, cause people to be more supportive of action to meet the climate threat.

'The Day After Tomorrow' depicts an out-of-control and damaging natural world.

To get a better sense of how fictional disaster films shape environmental attitudes, I (Lauren) conducted an in-depth analysis of 18 disaster films featuring climate change. The results of my research show that most of these films make only tenuous connections between climate change and natural disasters, which affects how people react to them.
Terminology related to climate change and extreme weather is often misused, and it's not uncommon to see films that use the term "climate change" or "global warming" to refer to completely different phenomena – some of which are physically impossible and could happen in no world. For example, one film uses climate change to discuss a buildup of methane gas in the atmosphere that is predicted to ignite, incinerating all life on Earth.
The results from focus groups I held with participants who watched one of three representative disaster films confirm that these scientifically dubious depictions of climate change dilute any perceived environmental message in climate disaster films. Most participants were unconvinced – often with good reason – that anything shown in the films could happen in the real world and did not see much of an environmental message.
More worrisome is the possibility for climate fiction films to distribute misinformation. Because many films draw on real terminology used by climatologists and atmospheric scientists to add a sense of realism to their films, audiences may find themselves confused where fiction ends and facts begin.

Here to stay
There is some precedence for these concerns. Research on historical fiction films suggests that people often remember misinformation presented in fictional narratives and then attribute these "facts" to authoritative sources like textbooks. This has been observed even when participants are warned ahead of time that they will be seeing a dramatization of a historical event that contains inaccuracies.
As society struggles to envision a future shaped by climate change, we will continue to produce works of fiction that depict these futures. Climate disaster films are only one facet of this phenomenon, and more are sure to come.
Follow-up studies examining the effects of "The Day After Tomorrow" on public attitudes toward climate change hint at possible changes.
In the short term, audiences were more concerned about climate change after viewing the film and were more willing to take some political action to combat the threat. Long term, the film seemed to clue audiences in to the problems of climate change, and provided something of a cultural script with which to discuss it.
It's worth noting, however, that "The Day After Tomorrow" was an exception within the larger climate disaster film genre, both in terms of its production value and its (relatively) detailed discussion of climate change. Low-budget films like "Sharknado," which stray very far afield from climate science, likely pose different possibilities for both misinformation and engagement with climate change. The question, then, is how to best tap into this potential while avoiding the pitfalls.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative