Friday, August 26, 2016

Letter Signed By 154 Australian Experts Demands Climate Policy Match The Science

The Guardian* - James Whitmore

Leading climate and environmental scientists urge Malcolm Turnbull to take urgent action ‘while there is still time’
The Great Barrier Reef from space. Reef scientists are among the leading experts who have written to Malcolm Turnbull stressing that the world is already in the grip of climate change. Photograph: International Space Station/Nasa/ESA
More than 150 Australian experts have signed an open letter to the prime minister, Malcolm Turnbull, demanding urgent action on climate change that matches the dire warnings coming from climate scientists.
The letter, organised by the Australian National University climatologist Andrew Glikson, calls on the federal government to make “meaningful reductions of Australia’s peak carbon emissions and coal exports, while there is still time”.
The 154 signatories include leading climate and environmental scientists such as the Climate Council’s Tim Flannery, Will Steffen and Lesley Hughes, as well as reef scientists Ove Hoegh-Guldberg and Charlie Veron.
They point out that July 2016 was the hottest month on record, and followed a nine-month streak of record-breaking months. Average carbon dioxide concentrations in the atmosphere reached 400 parts per million in 2015, and are rising at a rate of nearly 3 ppm each year.
The world is already witnessing the effects of climate change, the letter argues, including an increase in extreme weather events, melting of the polar ice sheets and ocean acidification.
Australia, along with 179 other countries, has signed the climate treaty brokered in Paris last year, aiming to limit average global warming to “well below 2C above pre-industrial levels and to pursue efforts to limit the temperature increase to 1.5C”.
But Glikson warned that “the Paris agreement, being non-binding, is in danger of not being fulfilled by many of the signatories”. The deal will not enter into force until it is ratified by 55 countries accounting for at least 55% of the world’s greenhouse emissions.
Glikson called for action to “transition from carbon-emitting technologies to alternative clean energy as fast as possible, and focus technology on draw-down (sequestration) of greenhouse gases from the atmosphere”.
Australia’s current greenhouse gas target, which it took to December’s Paris climate summit, calls for emissions to be reduced by 26% to 28% below 2005 levels by 2030. It has been widely criticised by experts as not ambitious enough.
Andrew Blakers, professor of engineering at ANU, said Australia could reduce emissions by two-thirds by 2030 “at negligible cost”.
He said the falling cost of renewable energy, particularly solar and wind, the replacement of gas with electricity for heating, and the advent of electric vehicles would eliminate most emissions. Solar and wind installation, now at 1 gigawatt each year, would need to be increased to 2.5 gigawatts each year to reach 100% renewable energy by 2030.
Remaining emissions, from shipping, aviation, and industry, could be eliminated after 2030 at slightly higher costs.
Lesley Hughes, a member of the Climate Council and professor at Macquarie University, said there were a number of factors causing the gap between science and policy, including vested interests, perception of economic downsides of climate action, ideological biases and inertia in the system from investment in fossil fuels. But she said the “most important issue” was the difficulty in convincing people to act to reduce risk decades in the future.
The Climate Change Authority, which advises the government on climate policy, in 2014 recommended Australia adopt a target of 40% to 60% below 2000 levels by 2030.
In a report released on Wednesday, the Climate Institute highlighted that aiming for 1.5C instead of 2C would avoid longer heatwaves and droughts, and give the Great Barrier Reef a better chance of survival.
The institute recommended that Australia adopt an emissions reduction target of 65% below 2005 levels by 2030 and phase out coal power by 2035.

*This article is reproduced from The Conversation.

Links

Surface Water Shifting Around The Earth

BBC News - Rebecca Morelle

Areas in green show where water has turned into land and those in blue show where land has become water. Deltares
Scientists have used satellite images to study how the water on the Earth's surface has changed over 30 years. They found that 115,000 sq km (44,000 sq miles) of land is now covered in water and 173,000 sq km (67,000 sq miles) of water has now become land.
The largest increase in water has been on the Tibetan Plateau, while the Aral Sea has been the biggest conversion of water to land.
The team said many coastal areas have also changed significantly.
The research, carried out by the Deltares Research Institute in the Netherlands, is published in the journal Nature Climate Change.
Add New lakes - seen as blue pixels - are appearing on the Tibetan Plateau. Deltares
The researchers analysed satellite images recorded by NASA's Landsat satellites, which have observed the Earth for decades.
They were able to monitor changes in the Earth's surface down to a resolution of 30m, which can be seen on the Deltares Aqua Monitor.
The team found that vast areas that were once land are now submerged beneath water, with the largest change occurring in the Tibetan Plateau, where melting glaciers are creating huge new lakes.
The team found dams that had been built in North Korea - seen here in blue. Deltares
An increase in the number of dams was also boosting water cover, and using the satellite data, the team was able to detect previously unreported constructions.
Dr Fedor Baart from Deltares said: "We started to look at areas that had not been mapped before.
"We knew in Myanmar that several dams were being built, but we were able to see how many. And we also looked at North Korea, and we found dams being built there just north of the border from South Korea."
The Aral Sea has almost completely dried out - seen here in green. Deltares
Conversely, the researchers also found that even larger areas of water have now become land.
The biggest transformation was seen in the Aral Sea in Central Asia. What was once one of the largest lakes in the world has now almost completely dried up after engineers diverted rivers to irrigate agriculture.
The researchers said Lake Mead near Las Vegas, which is the largest freshwater supply in the United States, was also losing water, and 222 sq km (85 sq miles) of it was now land.
Coastal areas were also analysed, and to the scientists surprise, coastlines had gained more land - 33,700 sq km (13,000 sq miles) - than they had been lost to water (20,100 sq km or 7,800 sq miles).
"We expected that the coast would start to retreat due to sea level rise, but the most surprising thing is that the coasts are growing all over the world," said Dr Baart.
"We're were able to create more land than sea level rise was taking."
In Dubai, the creation of new islands has significantly altered the coastline. Deltares
The researchers said Dubai's coast had been significantly extended, with the creation of new islands to house luxury resorts.
"China has also reconstructed their whole coast from the Yellow Sea all the way down to Hong Kong," sid Dr Baart.
Some areas, such as the Amazon, saw almost equal amounts of conversion of land to water and vice versa because of the natural movements of the river system.
The team says more work now needs to be done to see what impact these global changes may have.
The lead author Gennadii Donchyts from Deltares said: "This analysis was done to understand the extent of these changes. The next step is to understand their impact on nature."

Links

Book Week: 8 Classic Kids' Books About The Environment

Climate Council

It’s Children’s Book Week – the perfect excuse to revisit your favourite picture book, or for those of us reliving our school days, dress up as your favourite literary character!

It’s also the perfect time to celebrate how stories can help us understand the impacts of climate change and the importance of protecting our planet. These are critical lessons for everyone, no matter how young or old.
Here are a few of our favourite children's books doing just that. Happy reading!

1. Where the Forest Meets the Sea
Written and illustrated by Jeannie Baker


“My father says there has been a forest here for over a hundred million years.”
In this beautifully illustrated picture book, a father and son take us on a journey to a lush tropical rain forest in North Queensland. Every time you look at the page, you discover something new hiding in each corner. The final question of the book – (will the forest be here when we come back?) – could be asked about many natural wonders in today’s world. This story offers a perfect opportunity to pause and reflect on the natural beauty of the wilderness – and why we must protect it!

2. The Lorax
Written and illustrated by Dr. Seuss

"I am the Lorax. I speak for the trees.”
This timeless rhyming tale of man vs. nature is made fun and goofy in the classic Dr. Seuss style we all know and love. The greedy Once-ler starts by cutting down one Truffula Tree, but before long he has used up all of the beautiful trees, leaving nothing but smogulous smoke for the Swomee-Swans, Brown Barb-a-loots, Humming-Fish and more that depend on them for survival. The final message is one that still deeply resonates; we all have the power to learn from the past and change for the future.

3. Not your Typical Book About the Environment
Written by Elin Kelsey, illustrated by Clayton Hammer

"It is not filled with doom and gloom messages about the state of the planet. It does not blame you, your baby sister, or your uncle Irving for climate change.”
These are just a few of the ways that Elin Kelsey’s book is different. This delightful picture book serves as a positive reminder of the amazing progress we are making towards tackling climate change. It gets kids (and adults!) to start thinking differently about the environmental impacts of what they do every day – and introduces some of the incredible technologies and possibilities that are already out there. While strongly supporting the need for change – this fun book is about solutions and possibilities. Described as 100% gloom-free by reviewers... who wouldn’t want to read this??

4 The Sign of the Seahorse
Written and illustrated by Graeme Base

“Beyond the ken of mortal men, beneath the wind and waves, there lies a land of shells and sand, of chasms crags and caves”
This story about the threatened inhabitants of a fragile coral reef may be all too close to home for Australians this year – but Graeme Base’s thrilling adventure tale still merits a mention! In this story, residents of Reeftown are threatened when a sneaky real estate deal made by the Greedy Groper floods their area with toxic waste. Fortunately the sea creatures eventually come to the rescue, and in the meantime we are treated to a wonderfully illustrated rhyming adventure tale that helps us connect to the vibrancy of underwater life.

5. The Wump World
Written and illustrated by Bill Peet

“We can’t breathe the air! We can’t drink the water! And we can’t stand the noise! We’ve had enough!”
The adorable wumps are enough to get this book on our list of favourites, but Bill Peet’s story has an important environmental message too. The Pollutians invade the Wump World after using up all the resources on their previous planet, only to do the same thing yet again as soon as they arrive. When even the Pollutians become fed up with the mess they’ve made, they re-locate to a new planet once more. While the Pollutians obviously haven’t learnt their lesson – the question remains, have we?

6. Atmospheric
Written by Carole Wilkinson

“Young people will be the ones grappling with climate change. Atmospheric reminds them they are key to the solution.” – Amanda McKenzie, Climate Council CEO
Atmospheric may not be quite as cheeky as some of the other names on our list – but this non-fiction book for older kids is definitely worth a read. Atmospheric narrates our longtime mistreatment of the atmosphere, how that affects our climate, and what we should be doing about it. Brimming with handy dates, vocab, websites, and other resources, we need more books like this on our shelves! Atmospheric cuts through the cr--, communicating complex ideas in a simple, readable way.

7. Dot and the Kangaroo
Written by Ethel Pedley, illustrated by Frank P. Mahony


“To the children of Australia, in the hope of enlisting their sympathies for the many beautiful, amiable and frolicsome creatures of their fair land; whose extinction through ruthless destruction is being surely accomplished.”
Published way back in 1899, this Australian classic with a deep environmental message has been a household favourite ever since. Lost and afraid in the bush, Dot is saved by the friendly Kangaroo, and taught by the other animals about the human destruction of the bush and the animals within it. The dedication at the front of the book is an important wake up call from an author writing over a century ago!

8. My Place
Written by Nadia Wheatley, illustrated by Donna Rawlins

Like its illustrations, My Place is a book with many different layers. Set in what is now inner city Sydney, My Place moves back in time from 1988-1788, showcasing the changes that have been made to the land, environment, and society. The constants in the landscapes are the big tree and the creek, and if you look closely – you can spot the ways that human influence has changed them. Adults and kids alike have lots to learn from this ab fab picture book.

Thursday, August 25, 2016

Human-Induced Climate Change Began Earlier Than Previously Thought

The Guardian - 

Signs of warming appear as early as 1830 say researchers, whose analysis will help build accurate baseline of temperature before influence of human activity
The first signs of warming from the rise in greenhouse gases which came hand-in-hand with the Industrial Revolution appear as early as 1830. Photograph: Print Collector/Getty Images
Continents and oceans in the northern hemisphere began to warm with industrial-era fossil fuel emissions nearly 200 years ago, pushing back the origins of human-induced climate change to the mid-19th century.
The first signs of warming from the rise in greenhouse gases which came hand-in-hand with the Industrial Revolution appear as early as 1830 in the tropical oceans and the Arctic, meaning that climate change witnessed today began about 180 years ago.
Researchers in Australia found evidence for the early onset of warming after trawling through 500 years of data on tree rings, corals and ice cores that together form a natural archive of Earth's historical temperatures.

Temperature trends for the continents and tropical oceans over the last 500 years. Credit: Abram et al. 

Much of what is known about Earth's climate history is based on instruments that have monitored temperatures from the 1880s onwards. But while these capture the changing conditions seen in the 20th century, they miss the start of the warming trend.
"A lot is known about the climate record for the time when we have instrumental records," said Nerilie Abram, a climate scientist at the Australian National University. "We wanted to look at whether these records give us the full picture."
Pooling the data, the scientists found that temperatures in the tropical oceans and in the air above northern hemisphere land-masses began to rise above natural variations in the 1830s, just as greenhouse gas emissions edged upwards.
The scientists first thought that they were seeing the climate rebound after a period of natural cooling brought on by particles thrown high into the atmosphere from volcanic eruptions. But climate simulations showed that the warming they observed could be explained purely by the small rise in greenhouse gas emissions.
"The changes in greenhouse gases in the 19th century were small compared with the fairly rapid changes we see now, so seeing the climate respond this way was a surprise," said Abrams.

'I brought the graph': Brian Cox refutes claims of climage change denier on Q&A


The southern hemisphere, including Australasia and South America, appeared to start heating up 50 years later, near the turn of the century, while no sign of warming on the continental scale was noticed in Antarctica. The lack of appreciable warming in Antarctica may be down to ocean currents carrying warm waters to the north and away from the frigid continent.
The results are important to build up an accurate baseline of the Earth's temperature before human activity began to wield an influence on the climate. Details of the study, which involved 25 scientists across Australia, the US, Europe and Asia, are published in the journal Nature.
Industrialisation led to only minor rises in greenhouse gases in the 1800s, but what struck the scientists was how swiftly the climate changed as a result. "There is a potential that this could have a flip side," Abram said. "If we can do anything to slow down greenhouse gas emissions, or even start to draw them back, there may be at least some areas of the climate system where we get a rapid payback."
Ed Hawkins, a meteorologist at Reading University, said the results show how tree rings, corals and other natural material can be used to understand the regional and global changes that unfolded during and since the pre-industrial period. "This is further evidence that the climate has already changed significantly since the pre-industrial period," he said.

Links

What Will It Take For Us To Pay Attention To Climate Change?

ABC Science Show - Bob Beale

Australia's coastline has seen massive changes in the past six months, 2015 was recorded as the hottest year on record, and 2016 is shaping up to be even hotter. Former Sydney Morning Herald journalist Bob Beale laments that nobody seems to be taking any notice.
Australians are experiencing an influx of destructive storms and cyclones. (Torsten Blackwood/Getty Images)
My Facebook page prompts me to say what is on my mind. Actually I'm feeling quite wretched. I have a very bad dose of solastalgia, a term coined by my friend Glenn Albrecht, an environmental philosopher.
Solastalgia is feeling homesick while you are still at home, a melancholy brought on by the loss or degradation of a treasured environment. My solastalgia is for my country, indeed for my whole planet. I'm asking myself, what exactly does Earth need to do to get our attention?
To be bluntly colloquial, it's very bloody real, it's right bloody here, right bloody now. It's about as serious a challenge as we can face. We really urgently need to be all on the same page about this.
No, really, what the heckedy-heck does it take to make us truly sit up and notice the massive changes going on in the natural world around us? It's a travesty that so many people are fixated by staring at their so-called smart phones in a search for imaginary Pokémon creatures, while the real plants and animals of the world are turning up their toes in their billions.
Look what has been happening lately around Australia's coastline alone. If our home is girt by sea, as our national anthem says, then all the signs are that we are effectively burning the floorboards. Disaster after disaster is happening.
Think I'm being alarmist? Well, think about this—off Queensland, more than nine-tenths of the Great Barrier Reef has just been bleached. Perhaps a quarter of it has died and likely won't come back.
Look up north in the Gulf—the worst mass die-off of mangroves ever seen, 10,000 hectares of it along great lengths of the coast. Look off Western Australia—960 square kilometres of kelp forest has just disappeared. More than a third of it is now extinct. And all of this has become evident in just the past six months alone. It's as if our oceans have just suffered a massive stroke.
And don't get me started about the terrible decline in bird populations around our shorelines, or about the rapid southward shift of tropical and subtropical fish, seaweeds and urchins. We are finding Nemo in Tasmanian waters!
And don't mention the millions of tonnes of man-made polymer waste materials, PET bottles, caps, bags, disposable plates, wrappers, you name it, that enter our oceans every year, turning them into one great plastic soup. The sand on every single Australian beach is now made up in part of countless grains of plastic. I could go on—but what's the point?
I know I'm far from alone in being aghast about all this. But if the list I have just reeled off hasn't got Australians off their butt demanding action and marching in the streets, I don't know what will.
So friends, I ask again, what will it take?
Climate records are falling with menacing regularity. In recent years we've broken record after record for heat, extreme rain and other disruptive weather events. Last spring we broke heat records. Last summer we had searing heat waves, and extreme temperatures smashed records across south-eastern Australian, followed by our warmest autumn on record.
Sea surface temperatures have been going off the charts as well. The world in general has been cooking too, with June being the hottest month ever recorded globally. 2015 was the warmest year on record, beating the previous mark set in 2014, and now 2016 is likely to break the record again.
Climate change is not some nebulous political game that might affect our grandchildren. To be bluntly colloquial, it's very bloody real, it's right bloody here, right bloody now. It's about as serious a challenge as we can face. We really urgently need to be all on the same page about this. Yet climate change was not even mentioned in the Turnbull government's first budget in May. Not a word, not a sausage. Such assiduous avoidance. Incredible, isn't it?
Worse still, that same budget gouged $1.3 billion in funds away from the Australian Renewable Energy Agency. You have to ask, what on earth were they thinking? And climate change barely caused a flicker of debate in our recent federal election as well.
Instead we were fobbed off yet again by the major parties, and now we have Pauline Hanson elected once again on a platform of outright denial of climate science, to nourish fresh cankers of complacency and social division in our Parliament.
The real border security issue is the appalling damage we ourselves are doing to our coasts and oceans. The real negative gearing is the one we've been imposing on our planet. And the real superannuation problem is the squandering of natural resources, consumption for consumption's sake, at the expense of our kids and grandchildren.
Our civic leaders, our intellectuals, our politicians, and our mass media are playing Pokémon Go with us. When we try to reflect on, to consider and absorb the significance and meaning of these disasters, they blur our field of view by invoking phantoms to distract us. Indeed, they are worse than negligent, they are complicit. They know what needs to be done, but it's so much easier to deflect, distract, deny and delay.
Here's a word I just made up to describe our politicians in action on climate change—stagnertia.
A pox on all of them. A pox on them for leaving unattended and untreated the raging fever afflicting our planet.
One more time I ask, what will it take?


Bob Beale says the Earth is sending strong messages that things are seriously out of balance.

Links

Climate Change Is Thawing Deadly Diseases. Maybe Now We'll Address It?

The Guardian - *

An anthrax outbreak in Russia came from a 75-year-old caribou carcass thawing out. This is only the beginning of this sort of thing happening
'In addition to releasing ancient microbes, melting layers of permafrost also release methane, a greenhouse gas 30 times more potent than carbon dioxide, that in turn causes further warming.' Photograph: Murdo Macleod for the Guardian
Earlier this month, an outbreak of anthrax in northern Russia caused the death of a 12-year-old boy and his grandmother and put 90 people in the hospital. These deadly spores – which had not been seen in the Arctic since 1941 – also spread to 2,300 caribou. Russian troops trained in biological warfare were dispatched to the Yamalo-Nenets region to evacuate hundreds of the indigenous, nomadic people and quarantine the disease.
Americans are likely to associate anthrax with the mysterious white powder that was mailed to news media and US Senate offices in the weeks following 11 September 2001. The bacteria – usually sequestered in biological weapons labs – killed five people and infected 17 others in the most devastating bioterrorism attack in US history.
But in Russia, the spread of illness was not the result of bioterrorism; it was a result of global warming. Record-high temperatures melted Arctic permafrost and released deadly anthrax spores from a thawing carcass of a caribou that had been infected 75 years ago and had stayed frozen in limbo until now. This all suggests that it may not be easy to predict which populations will be most vulnerable to the health impacts of climate change.
In 2013, the National Academy of Sciences hosted a forum on the influence of global environmental change on infectious diseases. In his keynote speech, Dr Jonathan Patz stood in front of a large slide of a mosquito and warned: "Global warming's greatest threat may also be the smallest." The forum focused on many causes of disease, from fungi, bacteria, viruses and mold spores, to vectors like bats and mosquitoes. Climate change can exacerbate the spread of infectious disease by changing the behavior, lifespans and regions of diseases and their carriers.
This can sometimes be hard to prove directly. It can be challenging, for example, to isolate the avenues by which climate change drives emerging infections in warm climates where travel, trade, land use and dense urban living can all lead to the spread of disease. At other times, the signal is bright. Looking way up north in the Arctic – where there are far fewer people, less travel and trade, and fewer infectious diseases – the signal that climate change is a source of disease outbreaks is clear.
It is usually so cold in the tundra that the ground is perennially frozen in deep layers that can date back 3m years. But the usual circumstances no longer apply at the top of the world. The Arctic is warming twice as fast as the rest of the globe. In fact, the area of the anthrax outbreak was 18F (10C) hotter than average, with temperatures reaching 95F (35C). In addition to releasing ancient microbes, melting layers of permafrost also release methane, a greenhouse gas 30 times more potent than carbon dioxide, that in turn causes further warming.
It is not just animal carcasses that are thawing. Indigenous groups living in the tundra do not bury their dead deep underground, opting instead for wooden coffins arranged in above-ground cemeteries. This raises the potential for infections to spread from this source as well.
Could some of the severe infectious diseases that have threatened the planet in the past be reactivated as our northernmost regions thaw? It's not just climate scientists that are concerned about the health threats of a warming world. Public health experts and physicians are also speaking out. The Lancet Commission released a report in 2015 asserting that climate change could reverse the last 50 years of public health advances.
As risk is added to risk, the signals of our changing climate underscore the urgent need to put climate change solutions in place. Even more than we know, our health may depend on it.

*Mona Sarfaty is the director of Program for Climate and Health, Center for Climate Change Communication at George Mason

Links

Wednesday, August 24, 2016

Seven Charts Showing How Countries’ Carbon Footprints Compare

Carbon Brief - Sophie Yeo

Oil refinery, chemical and petrochemical plant at night. Photo: zorazhuang/E+/Getty Images.
The UN's climate body, which was responsible for the Paris Agreement adopted in December 2015, has long been collecting detailed data on greenhouse gas emissions.
When countries met in 2014 for their annual climate conference, they decided that it would be easier to track progress if some of the data from developed countries — annex one countries in UN jargon — was collected together in one document.
The UN produced such a document for the first time in 2015, which compiled emissions data from 2013. At this time, only 31 countries had submitted their data.
The UN has now released the latest version, with emissions compiled for 2014, and this time including 43 countries. Carbon Brief has mined the latest document for the most interesting nuggets of information.
All data is self-reported and, therefore, based on a range of different assumptions and methods, although countries do undergo a check-up by expert review teams. This process of data collection is seen as key to ensuring that each country is sticking to its commitments.
Greenhouse gases come from a variety of sources, including power generation, industry, cars, planes, aviation and leakages. Not every potential source of pollution contributes equally to a country's emissions.
Knowing the composition of a country's carbon footprint provides an insight into its economy, and also highlights which sectors it should be targeting as it tackles climate change.
Oil and gas platform. Photo: curraheeshutter/iStock/Getty Images.
Transportation
Road transport accounts for around 20% of countries' footprints, on average. Emissions are estimated based on fuel sales in each country, which explains why transport makes up 56% of Luxembourg's total footprint. Vehicles entering the country to buy fuel, thanks to low VAT and excise duty, raise its emissions on paper, even though the fuel is probably burnt outside the country's borders.

Road transport's share of total emissions in developed countries (%), 2014. Source: UNFCCC. Chart by Carbon Brief, using Highcharts.

The data for aviation tells a different story. Countries have reported the share of total emissions taken up by domestic aviation — that is, flights that stay within the country's borders.
Here, Norway takes the top spot, with 2.4% of its total emissions taken up by domestic flights. Hungary and Luxembourg, which run no internal flights, emit nothing in this category.

Percentage share of total emissions from domestic aviation for developed countries, 2014. Source: UNFCCC. Chart by Carbon Brief, using Highcharts.

Emissions from international aviation are not included in a country's individual inventory, but the data does compare how much fuel is consumed by domestic and international flights leaving each country.

Jet kerosene and aviation gasoline consumed by domestic (blue columns) and international aviation (yellow columns) in developed countries (exajoules, EJ), 2014. Source: UNFCCC. Chart by Carbon Brief, using Highcharts.


For almost all countries, most of the fuel is used in international flights — a sector which currently does not have an emissions reduction target.
The US is a notable exception to this rule, due to a number of factors, including its size, a preference for holidaying in America and poor public transport. Here, domestic flights consume more fuel than international flights, showing the significance of the recent move in the US to pave the way towards regulations that would limit emissions from domestic flights.

Fugitive emissions
Fugitive emissions are greenhouse gas emissions, mainly methane, that are accidentally lost during the production, storage or transport of oil, coal and gas.
These are, therefore, included in the data that countries have to report. They do so separately for coal, and oil and gas.
The following graph shows each country's total coal production set against the fugitive emissions this causes, expressed as a share of its total emissions.

Coal production in developed countries (blue bars, millions of tonnes, Mt, left-hand axis). Share of total emissions from coal production fugitive methane (purple dots, %, right-hand axis), 2014. Source: UNFCCC. Chart by Carbon Brief, using Highcharts.

The chart shows that producing a large amount of coal does not necessarily mean that the resulting fugitive emissions from mining and handling will occupy a large slice of a country's overall emissions.
The US is a case in point. It produces more coal than any other developed country, yet its fugitive emissions from coal occupy a small share of the country's total emissions, at just 1%. Compare this to Kazakhstan, at the other end of the scale, where coal production is comparatively low, but is nonetheless responsible for 8.5% of the country's emissions.
Such disparities will depend on factors such as the extent to which the economy depends on coal mining as a whole, and whether its mining technology is modern and efficient.
For oil and gas, fugitive emissions are only shown as a percentage of total aggregated emissions in the UNFCCC document, as the graph below shows.

Fugitive methane and CO2 emissions from oil and gas in developed countries as a share of total emissions (%), 2014. Source: UNFCCC. Chart by Carbon Brief, using Highcharts.

By this metric, Russia clearly has the biggest problem with fugitive emissions in its oil and gas sector, with leaked methane and CO2 responsible for more than 30% of its total footprint.
The following graph takes the total share of fugitive methane emissions for oil, coal and gas production in each country and compares it to the total volume of fugitive methane emissions. Countries submit the latter data to the UNFCCC, although it was not included in the aggregation document.

Fugitive methane emissions from oil, coal and gas (blue bars, Mt of CO2 equivalent, left-hand axis). Fugitive emissions' share of developed countries' total footprint (purple dots, %, right-hand axis). Fugitive emissions data for the US, Ukraine, Australia, Kazakhstan, Belarus, New Zealand, Austria and Ireland is for 2012, as 2014 data was not yet available. All percentage share data is for 2014. Source: UNFCCC and Annex 1 Global Map. Chart by Carbon Brief, using Highcharts.

This shows that Russia both emits more fugitive methane from its fossil fuel production than any other developed country, and that this occupies a larger share of the country's total emissions. The US emits the next largest volume of emissions, through this occupies a smaller slice of its overall emissions.
There are several reasons why fugitive methane emissions differ so drastically as a share of total emissions between countries.
It will partly depend on the size of the country's energy extraction industry compared to other emitting sectors, but also on the extent to which the sector is regulated and the type of fossil fuel production.
The inventory reports reflect estimates, rather than measurements of emissions. As a result, some of the reported differences could be down to the choice of accounting method rather than actual emissions.
According to a 2015 study of fugitive emissions by the economic research firm, Rhodium Group:
"Reported leakage rates can vary due to type of oil and gas produced (offshore generally has lower leakage rates than onshore), the state of national infrastructure, air quality and safety policies, and industry management practices, as well as differences in measurement accuracy. For example, using EPA emissions estimates, the US natural gas leakage rate is 1.3%. China's national methane emissions estimates imply a leakage rate of about 0.02%."

Animals
In some countries, agriculture may be responsible for a greater share of emissions than energy.
Countries have provided detailed estimates of their "enteric emissions" — that is, the methane emitted by cows, pigs and sheep. The following chart shows the number of these animals in each country, and the share of total emissions for which they are responsible.

Numbers of pigs, cows and sheep (blue and yellow columns, millions, left-hand axis). Enteric emissions as a share of total emissions (purple dots, %, right-hand axis), 2014. Source: UNFCCC. Chart by Carbon Brief, using Highcharts.

It is in this category that New Zealand dominates. Its 40 million pigs, cows and sheep are responsible for 35% of its emissions. The US has 163 million livestock, yet their methane emissions are responsible for only 5% of its total footprint.
Agriculture is responsible for 46% of New Zealand's emissions, with energy making up just 42%. In the US, energy is responsible for 85%, leaving agriculture responsible for just 11%.
Manure management is also responsible for a chunk of agricultural emissions. This is mainly small as a share of total emissions, but can be significant. For instance, in Denmark, it is responsible for 4% of the country's emissions.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative