Monday, September 26, 2016

Are We Finally About To Get A Global Agreement On Aviation Emissions?

The Conversation -  | 

Aviation emissions are growing about 5% each year. Flying image from www.shutterstock.com
Tomorrow, delegates from more than 190 nations will begin an 11-day meeting in Montreal to determine the final form of a scheme to reduce greenhouse emissions from the aviation industry.
The meeting – the latest in a series of three-yearly summits held by the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO), the United Nations agency tasked with reducing aviation emissions – is poised to decide on a scheme that would ultimately make it mandatory for most airlines from member countries to buy carbon offsets for their flights.
The resolution would fill a key gap in global climate policy. The Paris climate agreement, brokered last December, makes no mention of aviation emissions, despite having featured these in earlier drafts.
Earlier this month, the ICAO Council issued the final draft of a resolution text to be considered – and, presumably, after some debate, approved – at the Montreal meeting.
In its current form, questions will be raised over the scheme’s effectiveness, not least because it won’t become mandatory until 2027 – and even then not for all carriers. But these loopholes make it more likely that the plan will be adopted.

Mandatory offsetting (in the future)
The planned carbon offsetting scheme set out in the draft resolution would begin with a pilot phase running from 2021 to 2023, involving states that have volunteered to participate. These states will have some flexibility in determining the basis of their aircraft operators' offsets.
The purpose of this pilot phase is not really clear, and some aviation industry organisations, such as the Air Transport Action Group, regard it as unnecessary.
A first “formal” phase from 2024 to 2026 would apply to states that voluntarily participate in the pilot phase, and again would offset with reference to options in the resolution text. The main difference between the pilot and first phases is that, for the pilot phase, states can determine the applicable baseline emissions year.
A second, mandatory phase would only operate from 2027 to 2035 and would exempt the least developed countries and those with the smallest proportion of international air travel.
There are also exemptions based on the routes themselves. While the rules would apply to all flights between countries covered by the offsetting requirements, they will not apply to flights that take off or land in a non-member state.

Offsetting the issue
Then there are the well-publicised problems with the whole concept of carbon offsetting. Most countries and groups of countries (and ICAO is a group of countries) have ignored offsets in favour of mechanisms such as emissions trading schemes or carbon taxation – and with good reason.
Offsets, which by definition simply move emissions from one source to another, have little net effect on emissions. As such, offsets could be viewed as a diversion from regulations that genuinely encourage emissions reduction, such as carbon pricing. The Paris Agreement does not directly rely on offsets because all governments recognise that it’s collective, substantive action that counts.
What is really needed is a policy that motivates major industrial sectors – aviation included – to cut emissions and use resources more efficiently. Market-based mechanisms offer the best way to apply the price pressure needed to drive such a change.
The question in designing any market-based mechanism is whether to base it on quantity or price. A quantity-based instrument is an ETS, the most common example of which is a cap-and-trade system; a price-based instrument is a carbon tax.
ICAO has chosen neither of these options. Instead, it has chosen a system of voluntary and then mandatory carbon offsets, with all their attendant problems.

Other issues
An analysis by Carbon Brief has found that even if the aviation industry meets all of its emissions targets, by 2050 it will still have consumed 12% of the global carbon budget for keeping warming to 1.5℃. This could increase to as much as 27% if the industry misses its targets.
Meanwhile, airlines estimate that air travel will grow by an average of almost 5% each year until 2034, in an industry where low-carbon alternatives are difficult to find.
It is perhaps good news, then, that three weeks ago 49 states indicated they were willing to opt into the ICAO’s offsetting scheme in its earliest phase. The following week, in a joint statement, the European Union, Mexico and the Marshall Islands said they would join the scheme. And at G20 talks earlier this month, China and the US offered support.
Brazil, one of the fastest-growing aviation markets, said, however, that it will not join until the mandatory scheme begins in 2027.
Notwithstanding substantive draft texts prepared before the assembly, there is still plenty of negotiating to do before we know its final shape. And despite the pitfalls of carbon offsetting and some difficulty with integrating the scheme with the Paris process, a resolution at the meeting would be a step forward (to be followed by further steps and leaps) for an industry with emissions roughly equal to those of the entire nation of South Korea.

Links

People Would Be Prepared To Fly Less To Help Climate Change Fight, Survey Shows

BT.com - Press Association

As many as six out of 10 people would be prepared to fly less in the next year to help tackle climate change, a survey suggests. 
As many as six out of 10 people would be prepared to fly less in the next year to help tackle climate change, a survey suggests.
Two thirds would be willing to pay extra to "offset" the pollution caused by their European return flights - which green campaigners say costs less than £5.
Environmentalists claim the findings of the poll put pressure on governments and aviation industry leaders to find solutions to the greenhouse gases caused by flying as they gather for a major meeting on the issue.
The poll of 2,089 people for conservation charity WWF found that 60% of people would be willing to cut back on flying in the next year to tackle climate change - excluding those who were already doing so or for whom it was not applicable.
The figure was higher than those who were willing to cut back on driving (47%) or on eating meat (49%), while 70% were prepared to buy fewer new gadgets.
When told that offsetting a European return flight's pollution would cost £5 or less on top of their ticket, 67% of people quizzed in the Populus poll said they would be willing to pay the charge.
The world's first comprehensive climate change deal was secured in Paris in December, but while it commits nations to cutting greenhouse gas emissions it does not directly deal with international flights as they occur between countries not within them.
The proposal on the table at the International Civil Aviation Organisation (Icao) meeting in Montreal, Canada, is an offsetting scheme which will require airlines to invest in carbon reduction projects for every tonne of carbon dioxide they emit above 2020 levels.
But WWF said questions still remained unanswered ahead of the meeting, including what the rules would look like, which countries would be covered and what would be done about biofuels.
WWF-UK chief executive David Nussbaum said: "The most straightforward way to reduce emissions from aviation is to fly less, so it is encouraging that 60% of Britons are prepared to do just that."
He said governments and airlines needed to take on board that people could be willing to turn away from flying to using rail and videoconferencing, when looking for solutions.
He said: "Paying for their pollution won't bankrupt airlines or their passengers.
"Most people don't realise that it costs less than £5 per person to offset the carbon dioxide from a European flight, even with high quality 'gold standard' carbon credits, and yet two thirds are willing to pay that price.
"That should give governments worldwide the confidence to sign up to an ambitious emissions reduction scheme from day one and set their airlines en route to a sustainable future."
WWF wants to see a strong deal that only backs offset schemes and alternative fuels which achieve real cuts in emissions and support sustainable development.
According to the conservation charity the average cost of offsetting a typical return flight to Europe is just £1.60.

Links

Support For Action On Climate Change And Renewables Strongest Since 2008

Climate Institute


The 2016 edition of The Climate Institute’s long running benchmark Climate of the Nation research reveals that support for renewables continues to grow and a surprising number of Australians expect federal leadership in taking action on climate change.
“Australians, in record numbers, accept climate change is happening, and even more can see economic opportunity in the clean energy future they want to be part of,” said The Climate Institute CEO, John Connor.
Connor said there are three headline findings from this year’s comprehensive national research.
“Firstly, the Australian public’s desire for action on climate change, and solutions, is almost as strong as it was when we had bipartisan support for an emissions trading scheme back in 2008, recovering from the lows of 2012 which was the height of the scare campaign before carbon pricing began. Secondly, the sense of urgency has been dampened by frustration with political squabbling, scare campaigns and setbacks. Despite this, there is a strong expectation for leadership and action on climate change, a transition to renewable energy and the phasing out of coal. Perhaps surprisingly, despite the frustration, most task the national level of government with the role of leading, but also support state action."
"Thirdly, people want action to be bipartisan and inclusive - engaging individuals, business and all levels of government in a transition that maximises economic benefits while managing the costs of that shift and of climate impacts. All three combine to show the strongest support for action in almost a decade.”

This edition of Climate of the Nation – research which first started in 2007 - provides evidence of the waning impact of debate, among some in politics and the media, about climate change and renewable energy.
“Seventy-seven per cent of Australians now believe climate change is occurring, up from 64 per cent in 2012, with trust in the science up from a minority in 2012 to 60 per cent now. While not all accept climate change is occurring now, concern about current and potential impacts is high, with 82 per cent concerned about droughts, flooding and the Great Barrier Reef,” Connor said. “At the same time, support for coal power is in decline, with three quarters thinking that governments should implement a plan to ensure the orderly closure of old coal power plants and replacement with clean energy. Only 12 per cent include coal in their top three preferred energy sources, in contrast support for wind and solar has continued to grow to 70 and 86 per cent respectively.”
While there is support for government action, distrust and disappointment is dominant.
“Ninety per cent of Australians think responsibility for action sits at the federal level of government, made up of 67 per cent who say they should take the lead and 23 per cent that say they should contribute. Just 3 per cent say they should take no action. At the same time, only 19 per cent consider the federal government to be doing a good job,” he said. “When it comes to both climate action and energy policy, though, most don’t support delays or half measures - 61 per cent agree a time will come when urgent action becomes necessary, increasing the likelihood of shocks and sudden negative adjustments to jobs, electricity prices and energy security.”
Connor also said that 65 per cent of people want to see Australia be a world leader in finding solutions to climate change, the highest since 2008’s 76 per cent, and up from 52 per cent in 2012. Fifty-nine per cent do not agree that we should wait for other major emitting countries, such as China and the US, before we take action. And Australians generally want more clarity about what individuals and communities can do to help, with 68 per cent of people thinking individuals and households should be contributing to action on climate change.
“With supporting factors such as the successful UN Paris summit, increasing affordability of clean power and transport, as well as mainstream business and investor support, these conditions look more like John Howard’s ‘perfect storm’ of 2007 than 2010-12’s lows after the disappointments of Copenhagen and carbon tax ‘lies’.”
The research for Climate of the Nation 2016 consists of a national Galaxy poll of over 2000 people conducted from 29 July to 7 August, as well as focus groups held by JWS Research in Brisbane, Melbourne and Newcastle.

Who is responsible? Who should take a leading role? Who is doing a good job?


Australians increasingly trust the science and that climate change is occurring.


Animation contrasts Australians' support for solar energy vs coal-fired generation.


Public support for coal and gas continues to decline.


Australians' support for renewable energy continues to grow.


Links

Sunday, September 25, 2016

Earth Could Reach Critical Climate Threshold in Decade, Scientists Warn

Common Dreams - Nadia Prupis

Meanwhile, new research discovers soil may not be trapping carbon as fast as we hoped
Global greenhouse gas emissions are not likely to slow down quickly enough to avoid passing the 1.5°C target, scientists said. (Photo: Jamie McCaffrey/flickr/cc)
The planet could pass the critical 1.5°C global temperature threshold in a decade—and is already two-thirds of the way to hit that warming limit, climate scientists warned on Thursday.
Speaking at a University of Oxford conference this week, led by leading U.K. climate researcher Richard Betts, scientists said global greenhouse gas emissions are not likely to slow down quickly enough to avoid passing the 1.5°C target.
The goal of limiting global warming to 1.5°C was agreed to in the landmark Paris agreement negotiated by 195 nations last year.
But the planet is continuing to experience unprecedented heat month after month, setting 2016 on track to be the hottest year ever recorded. In fact, the scientists said, Earth is currently on a trajectory to hit at least 2.7°C in global temperature rise.
Pete Smith, a plant and soil scientist at the University of Aberdeen in Scotland, said mass lifestyle change must be undertaken to combat rising temperatures, such as developing more sustainable diets, reducing food waste and red meat intake, and importing fewer greenhouse gas-heavy vegetables.
"There are lots of behavioral changes required, not just by the government...but by us," he said. He also warned that controversial geoengineering techniques such as sunlight blocking could become the norm in some countries.
The warning came the same day that Oil Change International released a report that found we have 17 years left to get off fossil fuels, or else face unprecedented and irreversible climate catastrophe.
Yet more bad news also emerged Thursday as a new study published in the journal Science found that the Earth is soaking up carbon at a far slower rate than previously estimated—which could mean a massive setback for environmental efforts.
Once considered a vital weapon in the fight against climate change, the soil, which traps carbon that would ordinarily be released into the atmosphere, has now been found to take a much longer time to absorb carbon than scientists believed—which means its potential for carbon sequestration this century "may only be half of what we thought it was," the Washington Post explains.
As Jim Hall, director of the Environmental Change Institute at the University of Oxford, put it at the conference, "We need to get ready to deal with surprise."

Links

Climate Wars: Is The Sahel The First Battle Zone?

Climate Home - Nick Jubber*

If rainfall decreases, and temperatures rise, as the IPCC's 5th Assessment suggests, resource competition across the Sahel is only likely to intensify
A herdsman on the Séno-Gondo plain of central Mali cares for his goats - a job that is getting harder as populations expand and climate impacts intensify (Pic: Nick Jubber)
Suleiman is a Fulani herdsman on the Séno-Gondo plain of central Mali. One day he set out with his younger brother and his family's cattle towards an inland lake near the village of Gorti.
On the way, they crossed the edge of a recently harvested millet field. The farmer ran out, shouting at Suleiman to keep his animals away from the crops.
'But you've already harvested the field,' said Suleiman. Still, tensions were high and the farmer was anxious about a portion of the field where the millet had yet to be culled.
He called to his neighbours, who surrounded Suleiman, wielding axes and sticks. When Suleiman staggered home, later that day, he was covered in bruises and wounds, and had to be treated at the local medical outpost.
This is the kind of incident that prompts talk of a 'climate war'.
From Nigeria to Sudan, the imbalance between growing populations and dwindling resources is levering conflict in the Sahel (the semi-arid buffer zone between the deserts in the north and the savannas of sub-Saharan Africa). In Suleiman's case, climate is key: as local chief Ali Hajji says, 'this used to be a land of plenty'.
But droughts in the Malian Sahel between the 1960s and 1980s reduced vegetation and water availability, forcing herders to roam further, and prompting farmers to spread their crops more widely.
In 2007, the Nobel Prize chairman, Professor Ole Danbolt Mjos, labelled the Sahel as the setting of 'the world's first climate war'.
Although this claim is loaded with too much drama for most experts, there is a significant roster of voices supporting the contention that conflict in the Sahel is significantly driven by climate (including UN secretary-general Ban-Ki Moon, the UN Environment Programme and the IPCC's 5th Assessment Report on Africa, which asserts that 'climate change will progressively threaten economic growth and human security.'
Droughts in the Malian Sahel between the 1960s and 1980s reduced vegetation and water availability, forcing herders to roam further (Pic: Nick Jubber)
But is 'climate war' an accurate title? 'War' suggests a series of interconnected battlegrounds, some form of military strategy and specified goals.
What is alarming about the Sahelian conflicts is their organic growth: under comparable circumstances, a Hobbesian struggle breaks out, and the result is bloodshed.
Defining this 'war' by 'climate' is also contentious, given the variety of contributing factors. These include the dispersal of Colonel Gaddafi's weapons in Libya, which has increased access and affordability of small arms in countries such as Chad, Nigeria and Burkina Faso.
Land privatisation is key, so too governmental policies on agriculture and land tenure, development projects such as dam-building on the Niger river, embezzlement of drought relief funds, population growth and issues of political representation.
As ecologist Hélène Claudot-Hawad points out, 'in the Sahara the modern states are viewed as machines for turning out minorities who are relegated to the margins'. This marginalisation, as much as climate, impels the conflicts today.
No war has a single cause. 'Climate war' draws attention to the role played by drought and desertification in the diminution of resources.
It also directs analysts beyond political sloganeering to the practical phenomena that enable political leaders to marshal their recruits.
In Mali, for example, the droughts of the 1970s and 1980s abruptly lowered the flood level of the Niger river, prompting rice farmers to move closer to the river-bed. As a result, Tuareg herdsmen were unable to feed their animals from the nutritious bourgou-grasses flanking the river.
'In a very short time,' according to ecologist Charles Grémont, 'the multiple ties with the people and resources of the Niger valley that had long been fundamental to the history of the southern Tuareg were cut off.'
It is from climate-based developments like this that the present-day armed conflict in Mali can be traced.
For observers of the Sahel, the growing intersection of conflicts is alarming.
Fulani herders in Nigeria have been accused of transporting weapons to Boko Haram; Arabic and Tuareg clans have linked up in Northern Mali; and across porous borders, the arms business has proven as successful as the long-standing trades in narco-trafficking and people-smuggling.
There are too many variables to label this simply a 'climate war'; rather, it is a series of conflicts deeply coloured by climate. Mitigation and adaptation, as set out at the UN's 2015 climate summit in Paris are essential elements in reducing these conflicts.
If rainfall is likely to decrease, and temperatures to rise, as the IPCC's 5th Assessment suggests, the resource competition is only likely to intensify.
Without more holistic engagement and an increase in the quality and output of investment, these conflicts are likely to proliferate more widely, intersect more tightly, and increase their impact outside the region.

*Nick Jubber is a writer and a traveller. His latest book, The Timbuktu School for Nomads: Across the Sahara in the shadow of jihad, is published by Nicholas Brealey

Links

Saturday, September 24, 2016

The White House Launches a New Site to Track Climate Change

Fortune - Reuters

Cities like Miami (pictured) will now have access to real-time climate change data thanks to a new website powered by the White House. Photograph by Joe Raedle—Getty Images 
The first of its kind.
A new website powered by the White House and partners including Google GOOGL -0.12% and Microsoft MSFT -0.67% , aims to pull real-time climate data from NASA satellites and other sources for planners preparing for the effects of climate change, its founders said on Thursday.
It is the first partnership of its kind to gather in a single place climate projections and figures for decision-makers previously faced with a dearth of information, according to the World Resources Institute (WRI), one of the partners.
The website, PrepData, will process data from NASA, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, and the U.S. Department of Interior, among other sources.
While raw climate data is often too technical for policy-making, PrepData will translate it into easy-to-use information, the U.S.-based environmental group WRI said in a statement.
John Holdren, director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, said the project comes as communities worldwide face rising seas, more severe droughts, and other climate-related extreme weather.
Last December, 195 nations agreed to try to hold world temperature rise to "well below" 2 degrees Celsius, with an aim of 1.5 degrees Celsius. The Paris agreement was ratified by the United States earlier this month.
"Emissions reductions alone are … not a sufficient response to the climate crisis," said Holdren at a launch of the website on the sidelines of the annual United Nations General Assembly in New York.
"Critical to building climate resilience is ensuring easy access to authoritative, actionable data about ongoing and projected impacts of climate change," he said.
In its current beta form, the website helps users find data relevant to their environment and visualize related risks, mapping coastal flooding or precipitation change, WRI said.
Over the next year, only four users will be able to make use of all the website's functions—California's Sonoma County, the cities of Porto Alegre in Brazil and Durban in South Africa, as well as the Climate Impacts Group at the University of Washington.
But after that it will be open to anyone, WRI said.

Links

Dutch Parliament Votes To Close Down Country's Coal Industry

The Guardian - 

Non-binding vote for 55% cut in CO2 emissions will require closure of remaining five plants and ensure country meets its Paris climate commitments
Five Dutch coal-fired power stations were closed last year but the country still has another five plants in operation, three of which came online in 2015. Photograph: Bloomberg/Bloomberg via Getty Images
The Dutch parliament has voted for a 55% cut in CO2 emissions by 2030, which would require the closure of all the country's coal-fired power plants.
The unexpected vote on Thursday night by 77 to 72 would bring the Netherlands clearly into line with the Paris climate agreement, with some of the most ambitious climate policies in Europe.
It is not binding on the government, but the Liberal and Labour parties say they will now push for speedy implementation of the motion.
Five Dutch coal-fired power stations were closed last year but the country still has another five plants in operation. Three of these came online in 2015, and have been blamed for a 5% rise in the country's emissions last year.
The Dutch Liberal MP and vice president of the parliament, Stientje van Veldhoven, told the Guardian: "Closing down big coal plants – even if they were recently opened – is by far the most cost effective way to achieve the goals of the Paris agreement, and all countries will need to take such far-reaching measures. We cannot continue to use coal as the cheapest source of energy when it is the most expensive from a climate perspective."
A court in the Netherlands last year ordered prime minister Mark Rutte's government to cut its emissions by a quarter by 2020, citing the severity of the global warming threat which the Netherlands has recognised in international treaties.
Dennis van Berkel, legal counsel for Urgenda, the group which brought the case, described the vote as "an enormous leap for climate policy in the Netherlands". The vote also calls for a 25% emissions cut by 2020.
The country's centre-right coalition government is pursuing a twin-track response of appealing the ruling to the country's higher court, while preparing a climate package for early November.
This could include limited coal plant closures, more funding for projects involving renewable energy, carbon capture and storage, and geothermal heating.
Some environmentalists fear that the final package will involve a coalition deal that renders the parliamentary vote obsolete. The issue has been a divisive one in the Netherlands, with the Labour party, a coalition partner in Rutte's government, backing the opposition in yesterday's vote.
The Dutch environment ministry was not immediately available to comment on the vote. However, the economic minister Henk Kamp spoke out earlier this month against any mothballing of the three new plants built by EOn, RWE and Engie.
"They are the cleanest (coal plants) in Europe," he said. "We'd be crazy if we shut them."
In March, the Netherlands will elect a new government, with Geert Wilders' far-right, populist and anti-immigrant Freedom Party leading many opinion polls. Wilders has previously spoken dismissively of "the sinister green-windmill subsidy complex".
Willem Wiskerke, a spokesman for Greenpeace Netherlands said: "He is a climate denier like Donald Trump, nothing more, nothing less, a rightwing, fact-free populist who denies the climate crisis and will not put any effort into solving it."
While yesterday's coal-crushing vote is not formally binding, van Veldhoven said she was optimistic that quick action to force a decision this autumn would tip the government's hand, before next year's elections.
"It is our clear political statement so this is what they must do," she said. "It is a motion, not a law, so there is some room for manoeuvre. But having one coalition partner support it is always a good guarantee that an adopted motion will be enforced."
Following passage of any new law, EU Emissions Trading System permits would also have to be reduced, to prevent a freak surplus lowering the price of carbon allowances, van Veldhoven said.
The parliamentary vote follows a recent report by the consultancy CE Delft, which found that the cheapest way to meet the Netherlands' climate commitments would be to close one or two new coal stations. The paper, which was commissioned by Eneco, a Dutch green power company, estimated this would cost the average household €30 (£26) a year, but save them €80 a year on energy bills.
However, the Dutch government's economic ministry has tallied the bill for closing all of the country's coal plants by 2020 at €7bn. While this would have little effect on energy security and cut Holland's emissions by 31%, the CO2 savings would fall to just 9% due to a rise in coal-produced power imports, the report said.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative