Tuesday, October 04, 2016

South Australia: Failing To Learn The Correct Lessons Will Mean A Failure To Deliver Secure, Affordable Energy In Our Future

Climate Institute


If governments are serious about energy security, they have to face up to the twin challenges of increasingly extreme weather resulting from climate change, and the need to decarbonise the electricity supply.
This requires a thorough, effective national energy strategy, The Climate Institute said today.
“The rapid convention of another COAG Energy Council meeting suggests that governments have at least started to grasp the urgency of the situation,” Climate Institute Head of Policy, Olivia Kember said.
“But the less they face up to the fundamental pressures of climate change and emissions reduction, the less secure our energy system will be, and the higher the costs accruing to energy users.”
Kember said the electricity system has been in a continual process of coping with shocks in recent years.
Australia has now experienced an unexpected decline in demand, uncoordinated expansion of the gas market, the unravelling of bipartisan renewable policies, unjustified retail price hikes, unsustainable wholesale price lows, unprepared-for closures of coal stations, and now an almost unprecedented state-wide blackout.
Firstly, Kember said, we must get beyond the arguments about whether or not a single event is “caused by climate change”. It is a fact that we are adding more energy to an already very dynamic climate system, causing extreme events to become more frequent, and the extremes to become more intense. This means climate change is already affecting the electricity system’s operating conditions and will do so with increasing force over coming decades.
“Back in 2012, we noted the sector was underprepared for stronger winds, more intense rainfall, and more extreme heat,” she said. “But nowhere in the government’s recent national adaptation strategy is there a plan to improve the resilience of the national electricity grid.”
Secondly, she said the reality is, worldwide, electricity systems are undergoing an unstoppable and inevitable transition to cleaner energy. State renewable targets are at best only part of the solution and risk creating more complications within the market if implemented poorly. But the state targets are consistent with both global technology trends and Australia’s international climate commitments. Meanwhile federal policies have allowed emissions to rise, depressed investor confidence and created ongoing uncertainty that affects fundamental operations and maintenance decisions.
“Falsely scapegoating renewables is a dangerous distraction,” Kember said. “To maintain a secure and affordable energy supply we need to integrate planning for climate impacts and net zero emissions electricity into our energy market framework.”
“The solution isn’t to bin state renewable policies, but to make them part of a stronger, better national plan,” she said “This needs to include:
  1. policies to drive an orderly withdrawal of our ageing, high-carbon coal stations and support affected communities through this process;
  2. appropriate incentives for the full range of energy services we require: such as frequency control, dispatchability, and demand management; and
  3. policies that optimise energy productivity, to keep the overall costs of transition as low as possible, maximise the efficiency of energy use and keep users’ bills down.”
She said that dealing with all of these approaches simultaneously, while keeping the lights on and the power bills under control, is not an easy job.
However, Australia will fail in both these regards if it doesn’t take the opportunity to develop a very carefully crafted energy strategy that takes into account all the moving parts of the power sector.

Links

Will Climate Change Sink The Mekong Delta?

Mongabay - 

  • Scientists say the 1-meter sea level rise expected by century's end will displace 3.5-5 million Mekong Delta residents. A 2-meter sea level rise could force three times that to higher ground.
  • Shifting rainfall and flooding patterns are also threatening one of the most highly productive agricultural environments in the world.
  • The onus is now on Vietnam's government in Hanoi to approve a comprehensive adaptation and mitigation plan.
A boat plies a waterway in Vietnam's Mekong Delta. No delta region in the world is more threatened by climate change. Will Vietnam act in time to save it?  Photo by LisArt/Flickr
It's a sad fact that several decades of talk about climate change have hardly anywhere yet led to serious efforts to adapt to phenomena that are virtually unavoidable. Neuroscientists say that's because we're humans. We aren't wired to respond to large, complex, slow-moving threats. Our instinctive response is apathy, not action.
That paradox was much on my mind during a recent visit back to Vietnam's fabulously fertile Mekong Delta, a soggy plain the size of Switzerland. Here the livelihood of 20 percent of Vietnam's 92 million people is gravely threatened by climate change and by a manmade catastrophe, the seemingly unstoppable damming of the upper reaches of the Mekong River.
Samuel Johnson famously said that "nothing concentrates the mind so well as the prospect of imminent hanging." It's been nine years since a World Bank study singled out the Mekong Delta as one of the places on our planet that is most gravely threatened by sea level rise. There if anywhere, I imagined, I'd find a sense of urgency. I'd find adaptive measures well advanced.
I was wrong. Vietnamese government ministries, provincial administrations, experts from Vietnamese universities and thinktanks, experts deployed by the World Bank, the Asian Development Bank and foreign governments: all have been pushing plans and policies. The problem has been to sort out the best ideas, make appropriate decisions and find the resources needed to implement them in a timely, coherent way.
Things may be coming together at last, I concluded after talking with dozens of local officials, professors, journalists and farmers in mid-June. None denied the reality of the problem. Many connected the question of what to do about climate change to older arguments over the best ways to grow more and better crops.
Some of my interlocutors expected that Vietnam's new government will reveal its strategy toward the end of 2016. They hope Hanoi will get it right. Vietnam's a single-party state. Once a policy is adopted and handed down from the top, it isn't easy to change direction. However, if the prescriptions just don't make sense in the 13 Delta provinces, the party/state's local representatives can just fail to follow through. In Vietnam it's common to find unmotivated officials carrying out Hanoi's prescriptions in a formal way, without conviction and, at the end of the day, without much result.
Because the stakes are so high, let's assume that there's only one correct answer: that in the next several  months, Hanoi will approve a comprehensive mitigation and adaptation plan for the 13 Delta provinces, and the provinces will like it enough to carry it out. Anything less would be a terrible result.
Left: The Mekong River and its watershed. The river originates in the Tibetan Plateau of China, where it is known as the Lancang River; it then proceeds through Myanmar, Thailand, Laos, Cambodia and Vietnam. Right: The lower Mekong basin. Images courtesy of Wikipedia and Penprapa Wut/Wikimedia Commons
A precarious prosperity
The Mekong Delta's average elevation is less than 2 meters above sea level. Much of it is perfectly suited to growing rice. Farmers in the Delta also produce fruit, coconuts, river fish and shrimp. Their abundant harvests are made possible by annual flooding and by an intricate network of canals, dams and sluices.
It's a highly engineered environment, a modern hydraulic society based on intensive farming and infrastructure that deflects floods, limits saline intrusion, facilitates river transport and aquaculture, and furnishes the right amount of fresh water for irrigation.
It wasn't always like this, of course. When Vietnamese settlers first moved into the Delta some 300 years ago, they found a wild landscape shaped by a monsoon climate, typhoons and tides and the Mekong's annual flood. Imperial officials, and later French colonial engineers, mobilized tens of thousands of pioneers to dig canals and drainage ditches. As time passed, much of the infrastructural work was mechanized. Decades of insurgency slowed the taming of the Delta but even the years of the "American War" were marked by land reform and the introduction of so-called "miracle rice" — strains that could double harvests provided that irrigation water levels, pesticides and nutrients were carefully managed.
A heli door gunner over the Mekong Delta in 1967. Photo by manhhai/Flickr
The officials who came south after the collapse of the Saigon government in 1975 were intent on reforming agriculture Soviet style, as they'd done in the Red River Delta far to the north. Collectivization didn't work very well, however. Farmers refused to tend collective plots with the same care they'd put into growing crops on their own land. Ten years later, Hanoi conceded the failure of central planning, redistributed agricultural land in family-sized plots and allowed small private businesses to operate alongside state-owned enterprises.
These so-called "doi moi" reforms ushered in a quarter century of astonishing growth in Vietnam's economy. For the Mekong Delta, loans and grants from Western countries funded repair and extension of the water management infrastructure. The introduction of high-yielding rice varieties, expansion of rice lands and emphasis on double and, in some places, triple cropping permitted a rapid increase in rice production, from 7 million to 24 million tons of paddy annually. Vietnam's integration into the global trading system opened up markets for its rice and for new crops — in particular pond-raised shrimp and catfish.
There were skeptics, of course, who spoke up to doubt the sustainability of unprecedented prosperity. Some academics questioned the wisdom of an unremitting focus on rice monoculture. They noted that in districts no longer subject to annual flooding, ever-increasing quantities of pesticides and chemical fertilizer are needed to sustain good harvests. Some farmers complained that the state-owned Vietnam Southern Food Corporation was getting an unfair share of profits from marketing the rice they grew. As the country's food economy shifted from scarcity to surplus, Hanoi's continued emphasis on "food security" — meaning, in the Delta, reserving more than half of its arable land exclusively for rice — seemed increasingly anachronistic.
Still, as food production and exports climbed year after year, it was possible to imagine that prosperity would be permanent in the Mekong Delta. It was only necessary to wish away the warnings of climate change researchers, the huge dams under construction upstream, and the persistently low incomes of the farmers who grew the rice.

Alarm gongs: the future is already happening
For years, Duong Van Ni and his colleagues at Can Tho University have been educating anyone who'll listen about the changes in store for the Mekong Delta. The data's there and it's persuasive.
On an afternoon in mid-June, as monsoon rain pounded the tin roof of a cafe near campus, Professor Ni walked me through the scenario that staff of the University's DRAGON (Delta Research and Global Observation Network) Institute have built and presented to countless audiences. It integrates over 100 years of hydrological and climate data with geographic information system and remote-sensing data contributed by the U.S. Geological Survey.
A NASA satellite image of the Mekong Delta.
No delta area, not the mouths of the Ganges, the Nile or the Mississippi, is more vulnerable than the Mekong estuary to the predictable impacts of climate change. The 1-meter sea level rise expected by the end of the 21st century, all else being equal, will displace 3.5-5 million people. If the sea instead rose by 2 meters, lacking effective countermeasures, some 75 percent of the Delta's 18 million inhabitants would be forced to move to higher ground.
Already, said Professor Ni, there's been a significant decrease in rainfall in the first part of the annual rainy season, and more rain toward the end. The Mekong's annual flood peak has fallen by a third since 2000. The waters from upstream carry less silt to replenish the Delta floodplain. Also, the volume of fresh water is falling while the sea level rises. This allows salt-laden tidal water to penetrate further and further into Delta estuaries and swampy coastal areas during the dry season.
Modeling of current trends suggest that average temperatures in the Mekong Delta will rise by more than 3 degrees Celsius toward the end of the century. Annual rainfall will decrease during the first half of the century, and then rise well above the 20th century average. The area that's flooded each autumn won't change substantially, but the floods won't last as long.
All things being equal, rice yields will plummet as temperatures rise. Lighter rains in the early months of the wet season will challenge farmers' ingenuity. Rising seas and reduced river flows will severely test the system of sea dikes. Riverbanks and the Delta coast are already crumbling; this will accelerate. Farmers who are unable to cope will head north to seek industrial and construction jobs.
That's not all. At slide 70 (of 86) of the DRAGON presentation, attention shifts to upstream dam construction on Delta water regimes. For China, Laos and Thailand, the hydroelectric potential of the upper Mekong is a seemingly irresistable development opportunity. It may be that not all the dams they plan will be built across the Mekong mainstream. Whether a few or many, their impact on agriculture in Vietnam and Cambodia will be profoundly negative, Professor Ni, his colleagues at Can Tho University, and experts at other institutes in southern Vietnam have pounded the alarm gongs for years. The dam cascade is a nearer and more present danger, and apparently just as unstoppable as climate change.
DRAGON Institute's slideshow concludes with a call to action. The future is bleak but not hopelessly so if appropriate adaptation and mitigation strategies are launched. What the Delta needs is revealed: sustainable development based on a triply effective foundation of water source security, food security and social security.

Links

Inequalities Exacerbate Climate Impacts On Poor And Vulnerable People – New UN Report

UN News Centre

The impact of climate change is affecting Lesotho’s progress towards development in a number of areas, including agriculture, food security, water resources, public health and disaster risk management. Photo: FAO
Evidence is increasing that climate change is taking the largest toll on poor and vulnerable people, and these impacts are largely caused by inequalities that increase the risks from climate hazards, according to a new report launched by the United Nations today.
“Sadly, the people at greater risk from climate hazards are the poor, the vulnerable and the marginalized who, in many cases, have been excluded from socioeconomic progress,” noted UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon in the World Economic and Social Survey 2016: Climate Change Resilience – an Opportunity for Reducing Inequalities, produced by the UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs (DESA).
“We have no time to waste – and a great deal to gain – when it comes to addressing the socioeconomic inequalities that deepen poverty and leave people behind,” he added.
Speaking to reporters at UN Headquarters in New York on the launch of the report, the UN Assistant Secretary-General for Economic Development Lenni Montiel said: “Persistent inequalities in access to assets, opportunities, political voice and participation, and in some cases, outright discriminations leave large group of people and community disproportionally exposed and vulnerable to climate hazards.”
He added that through transformative policies, the government can “address the root causes of inequalities, to reduce the vulnerabilities of people to climate hazards, building their longer term resilience.”
On transformative policies, the Chief of Development Strategy and Policy at UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Diana Alarcon, said such policies could help build climate change resilience, close inequality gaps, provide access to financial services, to diversification of the livelihoods, to quality education and health and social security. She added: “it is that kind of transformation that leads to development.”
While there is considerable anecdotal evidence that the poor and the vulnerable suffer greater harm from climate-related disasters, the report determined that much of the harm is not by accident, but that it is due to the failure of governments to close the development gaps that leave large population groups at risk.
In Nepal, mountain infrastructure such as hydropower plants, roads, bridges and communication systems are at risk with climate change and more variability in water runoff. Photo: UNEP GRID Arendal/Lawrence Hislop
 In the past 20 years, 4.2 billion people have been affected by weather-related disasters, including a significant loss of lives. Developing countries are the most affected by climate change impacts. Low-income countries suffered the greatest losses, including economic costs estimated at 5 per cent of gross domestic product.
The report argues that while climate adaptation and resilience are overshadowed by mitigation in climate discussions, they are vital for addressing climate change and achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) by 2030.
Specifically, the report found that families living in poverty systematically occupy the least desirable land to damage from climate hazards, such as mud slides, periods of abnormally hot water, water contamination and flooding. Climate change has the potential to worsen their situation and thereby worsen pre-existent inequalities. The report shows that structural inequalities increase the exposure of vulnerable groups to climate hazards.
According to the latest data, 11 per cent of the world’s population lived in a low-elevation coastal zone in 2000. Many of them were poor and compelled to live in floodplains because they lacked the resources to live in safer areas. The data also underscore that in many countries in South and East Asia, and Latin America and the Caribbean, many people have no other option than to erect their dwellings on precarious hill slopes.
The report also found a larger concentration of poor and marginalized groups in arid, semi-arid and dry sub-humid aridity zones which cover about 40 per cent of the Earth’s land surface. About 29 per cent of the world’s population live in those areas and are facing additional challenges owing to climate change.

Transformative policies for addressing root causes
According to the report, building resilience to climate change provides an opportunity to focus resources on reducing long entrenched inequalities that make people disproportionately vulnerable to climate hazards. The best climate adaptation policies, the report states, are good development policies that strengthen people’s capacity to cope with and adapt to climate hazards in the present and in the medium term.
Looking ahead, the report recommends the use of improved access to climate projections, modern information and communications technologies, and geographical information systems to strengthen national capacity to assess impacts of climate hazards and policy options statistically.
The report voices a concern that international resources to support climate change resilience are insufficient. At last year’s Paris climate conference, informally known as COP21, countries committed to setting a goal of at least $100 billion per year for climate change mitigation and adaptation activities in developing countries. However, adaptation costs alone range from $70 billion to $100 billion per year by 2050 in the developing countries, and these figures are likely to underestimate real costs, according to the report.
The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development calls for transformative policies to deliver on our collective promise to build a life of dignity for all on a cleaner, greener planet.
“The challenges are enormous, but the world possesses the know-how, tools and wealth needed to build a climate-resilient future – a future free from poverty, hunger, discrimination and injustice,” the Secretary-General stressed in the report, noting the importance of the enabling policy environment as well as the support of the international community.

Links

Monday, October 03, 2016

Good News For Asian Elephants As India Ratifies Climate Deal

SBS - Lisa Upton

Scientists who work with wild Asian elephants have welcomed India’s move to ratify the global agreement on climate change.
Wild Asian elephants in Karnataka, southern India. (Nishant Srinivasaiah)
Nishant Srinivasaiah is a certain breed of person, one with a deep reservoir of patience. He spends hours, that stretch into days, waiting and hoping to observe Asian elephants in the wild. “I don’t always have patience with people, but I do with elephants,” he laughs.
Backpack on, binoculars in hand, the PhD student has offered to let SBS join him for the day as he searches for three elephants he’s been observing for many years in the southern Indian state of Karnataka.                 
The leader of the group he calls Tin Tin because his tusks move up in the same direction as Tin Tin’s hair. The others are PT Junior (Perfect Tusks) and Sam (sub-adult male).
Tin Tin, PT Junior and Sam have moved out of a national park to land near a local village, looking for food; there’s nothing more nutritious than an irrigated crop. It’s a risky strategy for both elephants and humans.
“People around here say they’re very scared to come out of their houses,” says Mr Srinivasaiah.
“Similarly for elephants, they’re extremely scared when they’re moving around at night. Increasingly, their behaviour might get more aggressive.”
Mr Srinivasaiah’s study area covers 6000 square kilometres across the states of Karnataka and Tamil Nadu. In the past month, elephants have killed seven people in this area.


Scientists say climate change will bring more extreme weather events, like droughts, which will force hungry elephants to go in search of food. Invariably, this will lead to conflict.
These elephant scientists have welcomed India’s move to ratify the global agreement on climate change agreed in Paris last year.
More than 60 countries have now ratified the agreement representing almost 52 per cent of the world’s greenhouse gas emissions.
Once that figure reaches 55 per cent the deal comes into effect.
India’s Minister of External Affairs, Sushma Swaraj, said October 2 was a significant day for India to ratify the agreement.
“This has been well thought out,” she told the United Nations recently.
“It is the birth anniversary of Mahatma Gandhi who epitomised a lifestyle with the smallest carbon footprint.”
Professor Raman Sukumar, of the Indian Institute of Science and one of the world’s leading Asian elephant experts, says the move is significant.
“I think India has taken a very bold step and joined the global community in its commitment to reduce the emissions of greenhouse gases and dangerous global warming,” he said.
In 1983, Professor Sukumar witnessed the behaviour of a clan of elephants forced from its natural habitat as a result of one of India’s worst droughts.
“Approximately 50 elephants left the states of Tamil Nadu and Karnataka and marched off into the northern regions of Andhra Pradesh where wild elephants had not been seen in the last 300 to 400 years, and there was this sharp escalation in conflict between elephants and people,” he says.
The elephants trampled agriculture crops and dozens of people were killed.
“My fears are that with climate change, with heat waves or the failure of the monsoon, the elephants’ habitat would be highly stressed, that these populations will now start coming out of their natural habitat and starting wandering in human dominated landscapes,” says Professor Sukumar.
“I really don’t think we’re fully prepared to deal with this conflict because of the scale and the magnitude.
“Dealing with this conflict would mean developing the management skills to handle large numbers of elephants. The animals may not just have to be driven back, they may have to be captured and transported back to the forest. Some of the elephants may have to be captured and kept in captivity.”
The Asian elephant is found in 13 countries. India has more than half the global population with an estimated 25,000 to 30,000 in the wild.
But even the most ambitious climate agreement isn't going to stop extreme weather events and their impact on the Asian elephant.
Indian experts say the focus must be on managing the conflict that's coming.
Professor Sukumar says in future local people will need to be educated about how to behave if they encounter wild elephants.
Mr Srinivasaiah often sees villagers getting too close to elephants, assuming they’re docile creatures.
That didn’t happen on the day SBS joined Mr Srinivasaiah.
Tin Tin, PT Junior and Sam spent the day in a dry lake, camouflaged by ipomea weed and undisturbed by humans.
But as the sun set the mighty animals moved on in search of water.
The erratic weather may make some pessimistic about their future, but India’s elephant experts believe the animal is as tough as its hide; that it will survive and adapt to a warming planet.

Links

Medical Staff In Dark About Policies To Mitigate Health Risks Of Climate Change, Study Says

The Guardian - 

While some states have begun developing climate and health policies, 65% said they were not aware of any such policies
A heatwave in Melbourne. Australian health professionals overwhelmingly say they don’t know of any policies that deal with the health implications of climate change. Photograph: Tracey Nearmy/AAP
Australian health professionals overwhelmingly say they don’t know of any policies that deal with the health implications of climate change, despite the World Health Organisation saying “climate change is the greatest threat to global health in the 21st century”.
The results come from the first national snapshot of the knowledge and views of doctors, nurses, health academics and other health professionals on the topic of climate and health.
They were collected by the Climate and Health Alliance, as the group prepares to present its national strategy on climate, health and wellbeing discussion paper to politicians in Canberra this month.
Liz Hanna, the president of the Climate and Health Alliance, said the strategy was supported by groups representing most of the health industry and represented the most important move in the climate and health space in Australia to date.
When the analysis of the survey results was performed, 134 health professionals or representatives of health organisations had completed the survey.
The group was highly aware of climate and health-related issues, with every respondent able to identify at least five of eight major health risks that climate change will bring, including food insecurity, increases in infectious diseases and mental health issues.
Despite that, 45% of respondents said they were not aware of the only national climate change adaptation strategy that deals with health – the National Resilience and Adaptation Strategy. Just 7% said they were “fully aware” of the strategy.
While some states have begun developing climate and health policies, 65% of respondents said they were not aware of any such policies.
“Overwhelmingly, the seemingly well-informed group could not identify many policies at national or state levels specifically targeting the health effects of climate change,” the report said.
Hanna said the lack of awareness was a result of the policies being very minimal. She said the health policies in the National Climate Resilience and Adaptation Strategy were mostly useless. “They’re motherhood statements, rather than anything that has any capacity to make a difference,” Hanna said.
Ninety-eight per cent of the respondents said they supported the development of a National Strategy for Climate, Health and Wellbeing.
Comments in the survey would be used by the Climate and Health Alliance to inform later iterations of the strategy, Hanna said.
Hanna said that, among wealthy countries, Australia was particularly vulnerable to the health impacts of climate change since it had such variable rainfall and was already very hot.
As temperatures rise, the health implications are going to force change in almost every sector, she said.
“In cold countries, landlords and people who manage public housing are required by law to have adequate heating,” Hanna said. “We’re going to get to that point but with cooling.
“It will have to permeate all the way through to cricket clubs, who have members playing out in the sun during the day.”
When the group goes to Canberra this month to present the strategy, it will be joined by representatives from medical colleges, hospital networks and alliances and associations of other health professionals.
“What we’re doing as a health sector is letting the politicians know that there are lots of things that need to be done and we’re here to help,” Hanna said.

Links

Betting The Farm: Farmers Confront Climate Change

ABC Background Briefing - Jo Chandler

Climate change is here, and Australian agriculture is acutely feeling the effects. Three farmers explain how it's impacting their lives and livelihoods.
George Mills at Panshanger, near Longford in Tasmania. (ABC Rural: Rosemary Grant)
Climate change makes farming more of a gamble than it ever was. It should be a complete concern to everyone who eats on this planet, because the whole world is going to be gambling on food production.
Real-world observations of temperature spikes, pasture growth and grape harvests across southern Australia reveal that the landscape is heating up at rates experts did not expect to see until 2030.
In some instances the rates of warming are tracking at 2050 scenarios.
Scientists concerned that climate change is biting harder and faster than models anticipated are campaigning for more research investment to protect Australia's $58 billion agriculture industry from extreme weather.
Background Briefing has learned that their concerns about the capability of Australian research to address climate change will be validated in an independent review by the prestigious Australian Academy of Science.
The review, due for release in the next few weeks, has identified a substantial shortfall in the nation's climate research firepower.
It's understood that the review will recommend that the number of scientists working for CSIRO and its partners on climate science needs to increase by about 90. That is almost double the current number of full time positions.
Meanwhile, the reality is already confronting farmers on the front line, many of them battered by this last year of wild conditions.
Mark McDougall on his potato farm in Tasmania. (ABC RN: Jo Chandler)
Climate change is here, there is no doubt about it ... The hip pocket is when it makes you decide it is here or not, and it hurt our hip pockets, so we know. 
We're going to be still digging spuds at the end of September. We've never done that before, ever — it's a bugger. It's normally the end of May, middle of June, so we're miles behind. We pre-watered before we even planted the crop. Then as soon as we planted, we were watering straight away, then we went from that through until January. We got a rain event at the end of January which wiped out about 1,500 tonnes. Then at the end of April we got another rain event, and lost about another 1,500 tonnes. It costs about $1,000,000 of turnover. It's people we employ who don't get to work. It affects the community, it affects everyone. If that's not climate change, I don't know what is. I've been farming this area all of my life. I've only ever seen one dry period like that before, but never seen the rain events like that.
Brett McClen, chief viticulturist at Brown Brothers. (Supplied: Brown Brothers)
We are seeing grapes ripening faster and ripening within a much shorter timeframe than they once did.
Links

Sunday, October 02, 2016

Climate Change And The Astrobiology Of The Anthropocene

National Public Radio - *

The Geologic History of Earth. Note the timescales. We are currently in the Holocene, which has been warm and moist and a great time to grow human civilization. But the activity of civilization is now pushing the planet into a new epoch which scientists call the Anthropocene. Ray Troll/Troll Art
You can't solve a problem until you understand it. When it comes to climate change, on a fundamental level we don't really understand the problem.
For some time now, I've been writing about the need to broaden our thinking about climate. That includes our role in changing it — and the profound challenges those changes pose to our rightly cherished "project" of civilization.
Today, I want to sharpen the point.
But first, as always, let's be clear: We have not gotten the science wrong. The Earth's climate is changing because of human activity. That part has been well-established for awhile now, in spite of the never ending — and always depressing — faux "climate debate" we get in politics.
But the part of climate change we've failed to culturally metabolize is the meaning of what's happening to us and the planet.
In other words, what we don't get is the true planetary context of the planetary transformation human civilization is driving. Getting this context right is, I think, essential — and I'm dedicating most of the year to writing a book on the subject. The book's focus is what I believe should be a new scientific (and philosophical) enterprise: the astrobiology of the Anthropocene.
I meet a lot of folks who've heard of both astrobiology and the Anthropocene before. In general, however, lots of people look at me a bit sideways when I use either word, much less lump them together as the future of humanity.
Given that experience, let's start with a couple of definitions.
A trip to NASA's astrobiology homepage will tell you the field is all about understanding life in its planetary context. It might seem strange to have an entire scientific domain dedicated to a subject for which we have just one example (i.e. life on Earth). But take that perspective and you'd miss the spectacular transformation astrobiology has brought to our understanding of life and its possibilities in the universe.
All those planets we've discovered orbiting other stars are part of astrobiological studies. The robot rovers rolling around Mars proving that the planet was once warm and wet — they are astrobiology, too. The same is true for work on Earth's deep history. These studies show us that Earth has been many planets in its past: a potential water world before major continents grew; a totally glaciated snowball world; a hothouse jungle planet. In understanding these transformations, we've gotten to see one example of life and a planet co-evolving over billions of years.
If you want an example, consider how cyanobacteria, or blue-green algae, completely reworked the planet's atmosphere 2.5 billion years ago giving us the oxygen-rich air we breathe today. Another example is the work showing how after the retreat of Ice Age glaciers, Earth entered a warm, wet and climatically stable period that geologists call the Holocene — about 10,000 years ago.
The Holocene has been a good time for human civilization to emerge and thrive. The seasons have been pretty regular, moving between relatively mild boundaries of hot-ish and cold-ish. That transition was the key change and allowed humans to get stable and productive agriculture started.
But, thanks to civilization, the Holocene is now at an end. That's where the story gets really interesting and where the Anthropocene makes its entrance.
Scientists now recognize that our impact on Earth has become so significant we've pushed it out of the Holocene into the Anthropocene, an entirely new geological epoch dominated by our own activity (see Andy Revkin's reporting on the subject). And it's not just about climate change. Human beings have now "colonized" more than 50 percent of the planet's surface. And we drive flows of key planetary substances, like potassium, far above the "natural" levels.
It may seem impossible to some folks that a bunch of hairless "primates" could change an entire planet. But that view misses the most important part of our story, the part that speaks directly to our moment in planetary evolution.
What I'm interested in, now, is putting these two ideas together: the astrobiology of the Anthropocene. That means looking at what's happening to us today from the broadest possible perspective. A couple of years ago, my colleague Woody Sullivan and I published a paper titled "Sustainability and the Astrobiological Perspective: Framing Human Futures in a Planetary Context." The idea was to show how much of what's been learned in astrobiology could be brought to bear in understanding what's happening to us now (a'la climate change, etc.). Going further, we wanted to know how the astrobiological perspective about life and planets might also help us understand what to do next. (Here is a piece I wrote for The New York Times about it, since the paper is behind a pay wall.)
Our robotic probes of Venus and Mars provide one good example of this intersection. Both planets have taught us about climate extremes. Venus is a runaway greenhouse world and Mars is freezing desert. Venus taught us a huge amount about the greenhouse effect. Even better, we have ample evidence that Mars was once a warm, wet and potentially habitable world. That means Mars provides us a laboratory for how planetary climate conditions can change.
So why does that matter so much?
Astrobiology is fundamentally a study of planets and their "habitability" for life. But sustainability is really just a concern over the habitability of one planet (Earth) for a certain kind of species (homo sapiens) with a certain kind of organization (modern civilization). That means our urgent questions about sustainability are a subset of questions about habitability. The key point, here, is the planets in our own solar system, like Mars, show us that habitability is not forever. It will likely be a moving target over time. The same idea is likely true for sustainability — and we are going to need a plan for that.
Woody and I are not the only ones thinking about astrobiology and the Anthropocene. David Grinspoon, a highly-respected planetary scientist has also been pursuing his own line of inquiry on the issue. As the Library of Congress's chair of astrobiology, Grinspoon began exploring his questions with experts in fields as diverse as history and ecology. His new book The Earth In Our Hands gives a beautiful and detailed overview of the ways we must change our thinking if we want to truly understand the transformation in our midst.
Thinking about the astrobiology of the Anthropocene in terms of just our species is, I think, a rich line of inquiry. But I think we can go even further. In the last part of my book I'm following a line of research that is also the focus on my sabbatical year.
As a theoretical physicist, I'm used to watching colleagues take the science we understand now and extend it to new possible domains of behavior. This is what happens when particle physicists think about new, but as yet unobserved, kinds of particles. Such theoretical investigations can prove enormously beneficial in widening our vision of the world's behavior.
There is no reason we can't take the same approach with the astrobiology of the Anthropocene. Earlier this year, Woody and I used the amazing exo-planet data (and some very simple reasoning) to set an empirical limit on the probability that we are the only time in cosmic history that an advanced civilization evolved. It turns out the probability is pretty low — one in 10 billion trillion. In other words, one can argue that the odds are very good that we're not the first time this — meaning an energy intensive civilization — has occurred. With that idea in hand, you can take a theoretical jump and ask a simple question: How likely is it that other young civilizations like our own have run into the kind of sustainability crisis we face today?
We know enough about planets and climate to begin investigating that question. In our 2014 paper, Woody and I presented an outline for this kind approach. One can ignore science fiction issues about alien sociology and just ask physics — i.e. thermodynamic — kinds of questions.
If young civilizations use some particular energy modality (combustion, wind, solar, etc.) what will the feedback on their planet look like? (By the way, as we've discussed before, there is always a planetary feedback when using lots of energy for large-scale civilization building. No free lunches folks. Sorry).
Woody and I sketched out the kind of behaviors you might expect from this kind of modeling. Considering just population, energy use and planetary feedback, one can imagine models showing trajectories of history that lead to collapse or to sustainability.
Which path a civilization finds itself on will depend on the parameters for their planet and the energy modalities (sources) they're using (or switching between). Of course, the models I am building are not reality. But they can prove to be a huge help in understanding the interplay of forces that shape the fate of planetary-scale civilizations like ours. In the end, this kind of understanding can help us at least understand what we're up against. Are we doomed, or is there a lot wiggle room in the choices we have to make?
The key point, for me, is that consideration of the astrobiology of the Anthropocene changes the frame of our debate and lets us see something we have been missing. We're not a plague on the planet. Instead, we are simply another thing the Earth has done in its long history. We're an "expression of the planet," as Kim Stanley Robinson puts it. It's also quite possible that we are not the first civilization is cosmic history to go through something like this. From that perspective, climate change and the sustainability crises may best be seen as our "final exam" (as Raymond PierreHumbert calls it). Better yet, it's our coming of age as a true planetary species.
We will either make it across to the other side with the maturity to "think like a planet" or the planet will just move on without us. That, I believe, is the real meaning of what's happening to us now. It's a perspective we can't afford to miss.

*Adam Frank is a co-founder of the 13.7 blog, an astrophysics professor at the University of Rochester, a book author and a self-described "evangelist of science." 

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative