Reporting that renewable energy caused the blackout in South
Australia was led by the national broadcaster. Ben Eltham says the ABC
was wrong, and reviews the fallout in the wake of the storm.
developed in the Great Australian Bight. As it rotated, the ‘
’ sucked cold air up from the frigid southern ocean, pushing a cold front towards South Australia with 100 km/h winds.
The storm smashed into South Australia the next day, felling trees,
ripping off roofs and buckling high-voltage transmission lines. There
were at least two local tornados, including one at
.
Shortly after 4.18pm, the entire South Australian electricity grid
went down. Widespread damage to the network, including to several 275kV
transmission towers, led to the grid overloading and shutting down.
In the wake of the shut-down, the national grid operator AEMO worked
frantically to restart the system. It took several hours before the grid
got back up and running again; local damage meant some homes were
without electricity for days.
But if you thought the weather was severe, the political storm that
enveloped renewable energy in the wake of the blackout was even more
damaging.
That’s because the blackout provided the perfect opportunity for the
enemies of clean energy in the Coalition to launch an unprecedented
assault against renewables, even before the full details of the blackout
were known.
Anti-renewable rhetoric is nothing new from the Coalition. But what surprised many was the enthusiastic support of the ABC.
was on the airwaves, blaming the blackout on South Australia’s relatively high concentration of renewable energy.
Apparently briefed by both government figures and Nick Xenophon,
Uhlmann reached an editorial judgment even before the wind had stopped
howling. Leveraging the ABC’s cross-platform capabilities, Uhlmann
appeared on radio, TV and online in the hours after the blackout.
sounded a clarion call against the spectre of renewables that he claimed were haunting Australia’s electricity grid.
“The key question is whether that state’s heavy reliance on wind
turbines might have increased the risk of a state-wide blackout,”
Uhlmann thundered. “Renewables are the future but, today, they present
serious engineering problems,” he warned, adding a nice twist for the
climate denialist right: “To deny that is to deny the science.”
Uhlmann even warned of nation-wide blackouts, unless renewables were
addressed. “The grid is being transformed, and that transformation needs
to be managed sensibly, or the entire nation might go to black.”
At the time he wrote that article, Uhlmann had no credible evidence for these claims. It’s hard to know how he could possibly
known, in fact. If he did have private briefings from AEMO, Electranet
or the South Australian government, he did not disclose them.
The night before, in a media conference, South Australian Premier Jay
Weatherill had sheeted home the grid failure to the storm. “Essentially
what happened is a massive set of power was removed and when that
happens it trips the system,”
.
released an hour before Uhlmann’s September 29 article was published,
AEMO also quite clearly stated that the grid was taken down by a cascade
of transmission failures that began with fallen towers in the state’s
north.
Uhlmann’s article did not initially mention either Weatherill’s
remarks, nor the AEMO statement. Later that day, it was updated to
include them.
A delighted government leapt on the assertion that renewable energy
might be to blame. Senior ministers, and then Malcolm Turnbull himself,
made statements questioning the role of wind generation in the event,
and attacking state government renewable energy policies.
On
October 4 and then
again two days later,
Uhlmann wrote further ‘analysis’ pieces for the ABC. He again blamed
South Australia’s renewable energy policies for the blackout.
 |
| Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull. (IMAGE: Veni, Flickr). |
On October 6, he even adopted the position of a religious ‘heretic’,
warning that “if those who claim to be friends of renewables continue to
respond to any criticism with hysterics, then they will be responsible
for ensuring the budding renewable industry suffers irreparable
reputational damage.”
Uhlmann’s rhetorical flourishes made for great reading. They came
complete with some impressive technical details about “synchronous” and
“asynchronous” energy supply sources. It was all grist for the mill of a
hungry media cycle.
But Uhlmann was wrong.
New Matilda approached a number of noted energy analysts and grid
consultants in an attempt to verify Uhlmann’s claims. Their responses
ranged from negative to derisory.
Respected energy analyst Bruce Mountain is the Director of energy
consultancy CME. He told us flatly that “there is no doubt that absent
the weather this would not have occurred”.
“The falling of the power lines, and consequential loss of
generation, caused the tripping of the interconnector,” he said in a
phone interview.
Mountain said he could not understand Uhlmann’s claims about asynchronous generation by wind farms.
“There is a rectifier in every wind turbine which takes direct
current out of the wind-powered generator, it is rectified into an AC
signal and it goes into the grid. The power electronics ensure a
constant frequency of oscillation of the current from the wind
generator, irrespective of wind speeds.”
Mountain added that Australia does need to ensure back-up capacity to
address the intermittency of wind and solar. Renewable sources (hydro
and pumped storage) and storage devices such as batteries, smarter grid
systems, and demand-side management are likely to be valuable in this
back up.
“Wind is a huge energy resource just about everywhere, it’s a well-established technology,” Mountain said.
Mountain also said the investigation into the events of South
Australia would consider the operation of the power system and market.
“Might the network failures and consequential impact have been
anticipated?” he asks.
At UNSW, the Institute for Environmental Studies’ Mark Diesendorf is
widely known as a pioneer in the research of renewable energy systems in
Australia.
“Yes, it was a weather event,” he told New Matilda. “We don’t now
what would have happened if there hadn’t been any wind turbines, but
it’s a pretty reasonable assumption to make that the whole system would
have collapsed anyway – three of its main transmission lines were down.”
“There does have to be continuing balance between supply and demand,
so to that extent Uhlmann was just stating the obvious, but under most
conditions with lots of renewables you can maintain the balance,” he
explained.
“I was very disappointed with the ABC’s coverage,” Diesendorf said.
“It certainly created the impression that wind power was the cause of
all our problems, and there’s not a shred of evidence that has been
produced [for that]yet.”
“They should have been taking a more critical view of the statements
of the government that has proven it is hostile to renewable energy,” he
argued.
Dr Hugh Saddler is the Senior Energy Consultant for energy
engineering firm Pitt & Sherry. He contradicts Uhlmann’s assertion
that “the state’s heavy reliance on wind generation might have made its
grid more vulnerable to a blackout.”
“No,” he wrote in an email in response to our questions. “There was
enough local synchronous generation on line in South Australia at the
time, plus Heywood, to provide more than enough inertia and also FCAS
(Frequency Control Ancillary Services). AEMO has been doing reports each
year for several years calculating how much synchronous generation will
need to be online at all times, plus Heywood.”
 |
| A file image of a storm in Adelaide, in January 2014. (Andy Watson, Flickr) |
Saddler describes Uhlmann’s descriptions of synchronous and
asynchronous supply as “deeply wrong” and “a classic manifestation of
Alexander Pope’s aphorism, ‘a little learning is a dangerous thing …’”
Saddler gives perhaps the best succinct explanation of what happened
on September 28: a cascade of events triggered by the loss of
transmission towers.
“Had the storm not taken out the whole of one 275kV line and the
northern segment of two others (leaving just one fully operational),
there would have been no blackout,” he wrote. “The final triggering
event was the loss of output from six wind farms, presumably because
they tripped out because of their protection settings.”
“The load then switched to the Heywood Interconnector (within a
fraction of a second), which was overloaded and tripped, followed
immediately by the two gas generators online at the time.”
Saddler explained that the wind turbines shut down to protect themselves in the wake of the transmission failure – a fact
confirmed by Neoen Australia yesterday. “There is probably an issue about the protection settings being ‘too conservative’,” he added.
Like Mountain, Saddler argues that the real lesson here was the need
for more distributed energy supply, particularly batteries and
hydropower. “Apart for storing energy for short periods, batteries are
perfect for providing system inertia.”
Other energy experts quoted in the media – including by the ABC
itself – have come to similar conclusions. Gizmodo carried interviews
with
engineering professors Ken Baldwin and Roger Dargaville,
both of whom stressed the weather as the cause, not the energy supply
mix. Baldwin told Gizmodo’s Rae Johnstone that there was “almost
unanimity” on this point.
Finally, a number of ABC outlets themselves carried interviews with
the Grattan Institute’s Tony Wood. Wood is known to be a prominent
sceptic of high renewable energy targets. But even he maintained last
week that “there’s no evidence to suggest this was caused by too much
wind power, or the dependence on wind power.”
UNFORTUNATELY for the accuracy of the ABC’s coverage, Uhlmann’s
reporting set the tone for the national broadcaster as it covered the
South Australian blackout, as an analysis of the ABC’s coverage
establishes.
A content analysis of the ABC’s blackout reporting reveals a clear
bias against renewable energy in the ABC’s reporting of the blackout.
New Matilda analysed all ABC content since September 28 on the
blackout, using the Factiva news database and the ABC’s own search
engine. A total of 54 articles were examined between September 28 and 11
October. Each article was read or listened to, and coded according to
angle and its attitude towards renewable energy.
Of the 54 articles, 23 blamed renewable energy for the blackout, or
led with claims by the government that blamed renewables for the outage.
In contrast, there were 12 that were either positive about renewable
energy, or that reported that renewable energy was not the cause.
19 were neutral.
Perhaps the most common thread in ABC coverage was to lead its
reports with anti-renewable attack lines from the Coalition or South
Australian Senator Nick Xenophon.
The ABC ran at least 11 separate articles covering politicians
blaming the blackout on renewable energy, including comments from
Malcolm Turnbull, Josh Frydenberg (several times), Greg Hunt, Barnaby
Joyce, and state opposition leader Steven Marshall. The ABC’s Fran Kelly
even interviewed Ceduna mayor Alan Suter on
his views about renewable energy.
On September 29, the ABC covered Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull’s
attack on state renewable energy policies, directly linking the blackout
to renewable energy. Stephanie Anderson’s
report led with the attack on renewables.
“Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has criticised the state Labor governments, saying they have prioritised lower emissions over energy security, following a state-wide blackout in South Australia yesterday.
South Australia’s entire power supply was cut off when wild weather toppled dozens of transmission towers and tripped the interconnector with Victoria.
Mr Turnbull said measures targeting lower emissions had to be consistent with energy security.
He told reporters in Tasmania this morning that intermittent renewable energy sources posed a ‘real threat’ for energy security.
Later in the piece, Anderson cautioned that “experts have dismissed
suggestions a reliance on renewable energy was to blame for the outage.”
But this was well down the page, and underneath a subheading that
stated “Concern raised over renewable energy.”
This kind of reporting, in which government attacks against renewable
energy were reported prominently, dominated the ABC’s coverage of the
blackout.
Another good example was
this article
on October 3 by the ABC’s Alexandra Beech. “Federal Industry Minister
Greg Hunt has blamed the South Australian Government for exacerbating
last week’s state-wide power outage,” the article led, reporting Hunt’s
recent opinion piece in Fairfax Media attacking the South Australian
government’s energy policies.
After running Hunt’s attack lines at the top, it quotes Labor’s Bill
Shorten second, and the Greens’ Richard Di Natale at the end.
 |
| Greens leader Richard Di Natale. (IMAGE: Thom Mitchell) |
A similar example was the ABC’s online explainer, published on September 29.
The article was entitled “
SA power outage: How did it happen?” Again, the article leads by questioning whether renewable energy is to blame.
“South Australia and its 1.7 million residents were left without power on Wednesday evening following severe storms.”
So have recent events and a focus on renewable energy created the ‘perfect storm’ for a state-wide blackout?”
The explainer quotes South Australian Premier Jay Weatherill first,
but then goes on to extensively quote Xenophon and Josh Frydenberg, both
attacking the state’s renewable energy policies.
David Lipsom’s Lateline report on the blame game followed the
pattern. The report was introduced with the following lead: “A political
debate is underway about how best to integrate renewable energy into
Australia’s power grid following a state-wide blackout in South
Australia.”
But the report itself contradicted this. Lipsom spoke to a number of
experts, including Bruce Mountain, all of whom reiterated that renewable
energy was not to blame.
Days after the blackout, and even after the AEMO interim report had
been released, the ABC was still framing its reportage by questioning
renewable energy.
On October 6, Weatherill was
interviewed by the ABC’s Michael Brissenden. This is how Brissenden introduced the segment:
As [Tom Iggulden] explained, the dramatic blackout in Australia last week has injected new energy into the political debate over the transition to renewables.
The Federal Government has warned the states that their targets are too ambitious, and a meeting of state energy ministers will be urged to look at a more national approach.
A preliminary report from the Australian energy market operator yesterday suggested that a drop in generation at six wind farms during the storm may have contributed to an overload of the crucial interconnector with Victoria.
I spoke earlier to the South Australian Premier, Jay Weatherill.
Weatherill went on to stress the findings of the AEMO report, and to
argue that the state’s energy mix was not to blame for the blackout.
Brissenden was having none of it, asking repeatedly whether wind farms
were to blame.
There was some balance. A notable counter-example to the prevailing trend was
this article
by Matthew Doran, entitled “SA weather: No link between blackout and
renewable energy, experts say.” In contrast to the reporting from
Uhlmann and others, Doran actually approached engineers and energy
analysts like the Grattan Institute’s Wood, who told him that renewables
were not to blame.
 |
| ABC political reporter Chris Uhlmann. |
But the line from Uhlmann was consistent throughout. In addition to
his appearances on TV and radio, he wrote three opinion pieces in the
wake of the blackout. All blamed renewable energy for the outage.
The ABC’s coverage of the blackout is a good example of how a
dominant frame, once established, can exert a long-lasting influence
over media coverage of a particular event.
On October 6, the ABC’s AM program carried an
interview with US entrepreneur Ilen Zazueta-Hall.
Zazueta-Hall was generally supportive of renewables (although warning
about the rise of so-called ‘dumb solar’), but the article was once
again introduced with a lead questioning the role of renewable energy in
the blackout:
Yesterday’s release of the preliminary report into the state-wide power outage after last week’s super storm in South Australia hasn’t stopped argument over the role of renewables – especially wind energy – in the crisis.
The report – by the Australian Energy Market Operator, or AEMO – said that the blackout was ‘triggered’ by the extreme weather, but there were still questions to be answered about how each component of the electricity system responded.
A leading US solar energy developer says that the South Australian crisis will drive the roll-out of even more renewables.
There were other angles to pursue. Matthew Doran’s article suggested
one possible way to report on the blackout: by speaking with experts and
to AEMO, and in reference to the established facts on the public record
such the interim report.
Another interesting aspect of the ABC’s coverage is what it has
ignored. Buried in the AEMO interim report was an intriguing suggestion
that the electricity grid’s backup power generation systems had failed.
These back-up generators are called “System Restart Ancillary
Services.” There were two supposedly on duty on September 28. Both were
fossil-fuel generators. Both failed. AEMO’s report says it was unable to
start up the state’s main gas generator at Torrens Island, because the
two ‘black start’ generators didn’t work as they should have.
Ironically, the reason for this was because of damage from the storm.
“SRAS provider 2 was not able to provide black start capability due to
the damage caused by the storm to its auxiliary diesel units which are
necessary for the gas turbine to provide restart capability,” AEMO’s
report notes on page 19.
This is not a trivial matter – AEMO pays electricity generators
millions of dollars for the SRAS back-up service. But in the crucial
moment, neither of the two ‘black start’ generators could be brought
online.
 |
| IMAGE: Chuck Coker, Flickr. |
No less a figure than Ross Garnaut pointed this out last week.
Referring to the failure of the back-up generators, Garnaut questioned
what had happened on 28 September. “There are some quite big questions
about why the National Electricity Market systems did not work as they
were designed to,” Garnaut told reporters in Adelaide, in remarks that were picked up by Renew Economy and the Australian Financial Review, but not by the ABC.
We’ve heard nothing about the failure of the back-up generators from the ABC or Chris Uhlmann so far.
The ABC’s coverage of the South Australian blackout matters because,
as taxpayers and citizens, Australians require independence and accuracy
from the national broadcaster.
Accuracy is central to the ABC’s mission. It is enshrined in 80 years of tradition, as well as formal Editorial Policies.
As the ABC’s editorial policy states:
The ABC has a statutory duty to ensure that the gathering and presentation of news and information is accurate according to the recognised standards of objective journalism. Credibility depends heavily on factual accuracy.
But there were grave inaccuracies in Chris Uhlmann’s reporting of the
South Australian blackout, and those inaccuracies leached into the
ABC’s broader coverage.
There are shades here of the ABC’s repeated failures to adequately
cover the unfolding infrastructure disaster of the National Broadband
Network. Once again, political considerations appear to have trumped
sober assessment and diligent factual reporting of a complex policy
issue.
As New Matilda revealed in January,
the ABC’s senior management pressured its former technology editor Nick
Ross to write anti-Labor articles on broadband policy in 2013. Ross had
written a prescient 11,000 word article that predicted many of the
technical problems and cost blowouts that the National Broadband Network
is now encountering. Ross’ highly critical appraisal of Coalition
broadband policy had angered then-Communications spokesperson Malcolm
Turnbull.
Ross eventually left the ABC, after being sidelined by ABC
management. The ABC continues to deny that any editorial policies were
breached.
The ABC is certainly still capable of sound, substantive reporting.
But the Uhlmann line on renewables reveals another, more disturbing sort
of journalism at Aunty: pre-determined, ideologically coloured, and
thinly-sourced. In other words, exactly the sort of journalism that the
ABC is often criticised for by conservatives.
Uhlmann was right to point out that the blackout was a significant
event. He was right to ask how that blackout happened, and what the
implications are for Australian energy policy.
But on the most important aspects of the South Australian blackout, Uhlmann was wrong.
The entire nation is not about to go black.
Asynchronous power was not the issue. The blackout was not caused, or
exacerbated, by renewable energy. It was not caused by the number of
wind turbines connected to the South Australian grid.
It was caused by the storm.
Links