Friday, December 09, 2016

States Could Go It Alone On Emissions: Jay Weatherill

Fairfax - Phillip Coorey

SA Premier Jay Weatherill says the states could go it alone on carbon. Alex Ellinghausen

South Australian premier Jay Weatherill says he will push the states to go it alone on climate change after the federal government caved to pressure from the right wing and rejected looking at a carbon scheme for the electricity sector.
Despite expert advice that an emissions intensity scheme on electricity generators was the lowest cost and most secure option to transition towards gas and renewable energy while meeting Australia's 2030 emissions reduction target, the government slammed the door on the option after a backlash from conservatives, as well as minster Christopher Pyne, who argued it could be seen as putting a price on carbon.
The Premiers and Prime Minister were to discuss the option at Friday's Council of Australian Governments meeting in Canberra on Friday.
The Australian Financial Review reported that Chief Scientist Alan Finkel, who in October was put in charge of the review into Australia's National Energy Market following the blackouts in SA, approved of an emissions intensity scheme for the electricity sector in a preliminary report to COAG. He had intended to advocate its consideration in a verbal briefing to Premiers, sources said.





In  a discussion paper to be put to COAG, it is understood he endorses the concept which is already supported by the Climate Change Authority, the CSIRO and the Australian Energy Market Commission, which is a COAG advisory body.
Mr Weatherill told ABC radio on Thursday that "in the absence of national leadership", he would be urging the states to team up and implement a nationally consistent scheme of their own.
More so given the experts say it would actually reduce power prices and increase energy security.
"It would clean up our energy system," said Mr Weatherill who will sound out his colleagues ahead of Friday's COAG meeting.
"Our first instinct is of course to seek a national scheme," he said. Mr Weatherill said preliminary advice showed a scheme could be established without federal government support.







An  emissions intensity scheme is not a carbon price or carbon tax in that it does not raise revenue by charging for emissions. Instead it would penalise generators who pollute above a baseline limit.
Cleaner emitters who stayed below the baseline would not pay anything and would receive free credits which they could to trade to bigger polluters.
The policy is similar to the Coalition's current direct action policy that has a "safeguards mechanism" designed to penalise emitters for exceeding limits. Polluters are currently paid from the budget to reduce emissions but this is considered unsustainable beyond 2020.
Experts said the government was now limited to high cost options in order to meet the 2030 targets. These were expanding the renewable energy target or to keep pouring money from the budget into direct action to pay polluters to reduce emissions.
Despite this, Mr Turnbull and his ministers insisted on Thursday the government was committed to low electricity prices.
Mr Turnbull said Mr Weatherill would be putting at risk jobs and business with his plan to go it alone.
"We believe that policies should be national," he said.
Treasurer Scott Morrison said: "We are not interested in a carbon tax. The Prime Minister has never supported a carbon tax. Whether it is an ETS or whatever you want to say. That was settled by the Coalition years ago".
"We are interested in engaging in the engineering of ensuring that our electricity costs, pressures on those are reduced and ensuring we have the sufficient supply, whether it is gas or other important areas that will ensure that energy prices have the cost pressures on them reduced."
The backflip came just 36 hours after Energy Minster Josh Frydenberg released on Monday the terms of reference for a review of climate policy for the decade beyond 2020.
This was promised by Tony Abbott in 2015. On Thursday, Mr Morrison dismissed it as "a very low level, housekeeping review".
The terms of reference opened the door to the purchase of cheap international permits to help meet Australia's 2030 emissions reduction target but made no provision for an emissions trading scheme or a carbon tax. But Mr Frydenberg left open the prospect of an emissions intensity scheme for the electricity industry which produces one-third of the nation's carbon emissions.
"We know that there's been a large number of bodies that have recommended an emissions intensity scheme, which is effectively a baseline and credit scheme. We'll look at that," he said in an interview.
Following the backlash and a cabinet meeting on Tuesday afternoon, Mr Frydenberg said:
"The government will not introduce an emissions intensity scheme, which is a form of trading scheme that operates within the electricity generation sector."

Links

Finkel Review Criticises Climate Policy Chaos And Points To Need For Emissions Trading

The Guardian - Katharine Murphy

Exclusive: Report warns investment in electricity has stalled, and existing policies won't see Australian meet its Paris target
The Finkel review note advice from the Climate Change Authority that an emissions intensity scheme 'had the lowest impact on average residential electricity prices'. Photograph: Mick Tsikas/REUTERS
Australia's chief scientist, Alan Finkel, has said investment in the electricity sector has stalled because of "policy instability and uncertainty" – and he's warned that current federal climate policy settings will not allow Australia to meet its emissions reduction targets under the Paris agreement.
In a 58-page report that has been circulated before Friday's Council of Australian Governments meeting between the prime minister and the premiers, Finkel has also given implicit endorsement to an emissions intensity trading scheme for the electricity industry to help manage the transition to lower-emissions energy sources.
While there is no concrete recommendation to that effect, the report, obtained by Guardian Australia, references the evidence from energy regulators that such a scheme would integrate best "with the electricity market's pricing and risk management framework" and "had the lowest economic costs and the lowest impact on electricity prices".
Finkel also notes advice from the Climate Change Authority which says market mechanisms have the lowest average cost of abatement, and of the options modelled, an emissions intensity scheme "had the lowest impact on average residential electricity prices".
The positive commentary from the chief scientist cuts directly across political arguments the Turnbull government has made since dumping its nascent attempt to use the review of the Direct Action policy to explore an intensity trading scheme for electricity – equating carbon pricing with higher power prices for consumers.
The Finkel report was commissioned by the energy and environment minister, Josh Frydenberg, at the last meeting of state and federal energy ministers in the wake of the political controversy that erupted after South Australia endured a statewide blackout in September.
The Turnbull government has wanted to use the much-anticipated report as a springboard to wind back state-based renewable energy targets, which it says are making the electricity market less secure.
But while noting renewables present ongoing challenges to network stability, challenges that have to be carefully managed, Finkel has pointedly warned the federal government its current climate policy is inadequate as it stands.
He also makes the point that a lack of clarity at a federal level about policy and regulatory settings can also affect network security and prices for consumers.
Finkel's report says the relatively short time horizon of federal climate policy, coupled with the Abbott government's attack on the federal renewable energy target, has put investment in abeyance.
"There is evidence that investment in the electricity sector has stalled and investors have become less responsive to investment signals," the report says. "This is due to policy instability and uncertainty driven by numerous reviews into the renewable energy target and a lack of clarity about the policies to reduce emissions after 2020."
"Investment in renewable energy dropped by 52% between 2013 and 2014 and has not yet recovered to the level required to satisfy the RET [renewable energy target]."
Finkel says there is a pressing need for clarity in policy to unlock much-needed investment in the national electricity market, and he says if the clarity fails to materialise, electricity prices will rise for consumers, and energy security will become more of an issue.
"For businesses to take risks on the future and invest, they need to be confident that emissions reduction policies and the mechanisms to achieve them are consistent with Australia's international commitments and will not change drastically in the future."
"Because of the long-term nature of electricity sector investments, investment confidence depends strongly on long-term policy signals."
"The lack of predictability in the electricity sector creates uncertainty around which generation and network assets investors should either invest in or divest from."
"If businesses do not invest when needed, this will impact on the security and reliability of electricity supply."
He also says explicitly the current climate policy, which includes Direct Action, the RET, and the national energy productivity plan, will not guarantee Australia meets its Paris commitments. "While the electricity sector must play an important role in reducing emissions, current policy settings do not provide a clear pathway to the level of reduction required to meet Australia's Paris commitments," the report says.
Finkel says the RET is designed to achieve an increase in large-scale renewable energy generation to 2020 "but not beyond". "The policy also ends in 2030, meaning that projects commencing in 2020 will need to recover their capital costs over only a 10-year period."
He says the Direct Action policy has focused predominantly on land-sector abatement, with very few projects seeking to improve the efficiency of electricity consumption.
Finkel says the safeguard mechanism "is not calibrated to drive emissions reduction".
The Turnbull government on Monday flagged an emissions intensity trading scheme for the electricity sector as part of its scheduled review of its Direct Action climate policy.
But the overture was dumped when Frydenberg folded in the face of internal pressure – a decision which has been widely criticised as short sighted and counterproductive by business, the energy industry and climate groups.
Friday's Coag meeting will also hear a push from the South Australian government to revive emissions trading in the wake of the Turnbull government's decision to preemptively rule it out.
But the push from the premier, Jay Weatherill, appears unlikely to secure unanimous support from other state governments.
South Australia has been leading the charge on an emissions trading scheme for the electricity sector for some months, but New South Wales rebuffed the push on Thursday. The Labor governments in Victoria and Queensland have also backed away from carbon pricing in favour of beefing up their state renewables policies.
Before Friday's talks, Malcolm Turnbull continued efforts to equate carbon pricing with higher electricity prices, and he revived previous criticism of the South Australian government's positive disposition to renewable energy.
"What South Australia is doing is putting at risk the jobs of South Australians, the prospects of South Australian business. Jay Weatherill's approach to energy has been condemned by the business community in South Australia, they're appalled," Turnbull told 3AW on Thursday.
"Major industrial centres – Whyalla, mines, Nyrstar mine and so forth – have had to close down because they don't get reliable power," he said. "The South Australian Labor government has delivered an absolute double whammy of not being able to keep the lights on and having the most expensive electricity in Australia."
But the Labor leader, Bill Shorten, blasted Turnbull for his conduct over the course of the week. "Malcolm Turnbull is demonstrating that he is under pressure, that he is lashing out, and that now he is making terrible decisions about the future of climate change and what governments can do about it," Shorten said.
"Malcolm Turnbull has been muted on taking proper action on climate change. He has been gagged from talking about the solutions we need to tackle harmful carbon pollution."
"This week has become the sickest joke of climate change policy since Malcolm Turnbull got elected."

Links

Government Killed Emissions Scheme Despite Knowing It Could Shave $15 Billion Off Electricity Bills

Fairfax - Adam Morton

The Turnbull government has been sitting on advice that an emissions intensity scheme - the carbon policy it put on the table only to rule out just 36 hours later - would save households and businesses up to $15 billion in electricity bills over a decade.
While Malcolm Turnbull has rejected this sort of scheme by claiming it would push up prices, analysis in an Australian Electricity Market Commission report handed to the government months ago finds it would actually cost consumers far less than other approaches, including doing nothing.

States consider carbon trading
South Australia suggests the states set up their own carbon intensity trading system, but Mike Baird is not so keen. Courtesy ABC News 24.


It finds that would still be the case even if the government boosted its climate target to a 50 per cent cut in emissions by 2030.
Depending on the level of electricity use and the target adopted, modelling by Danny Price of Frontier Economics found costs would be between $3.4 billion and $15 billion lower over the decade to 2030.  Costs would be $11.2 billion lower over this time assuming average electricity use and the existing climate target.
It suggests it would bring down the cost of cleaner gas-fired electricity and renewable energy, more than offsetting an increase in the cost of high-emissions coal power.
Environment and Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg flagged this sort of scheme for the electricity industry would be considered as part of a long-promised climate review, but was forced to backtrack after opposition from conservative government MPs opposed to any form of carbon pricing.
The modelling is part of a group reports on the future of energy to be discussed by the Prime Minister and state premiers ahead at a COAG meeting in Canberra on Friday.
They include a preliminary report into the future security of the electricity market by chief scientist Alan Finkel, which warns that Australia has no clear path to meeting the 2030 emissions target taken to the Paris climate deal under existing policies.
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has said the Coalition would not implement an emissions trading scheme. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen
While it makes no recommendations, the Finkel review cites the market commission, Australian Energy Market Operator and Climate Change Authority as all having found an emissions intensity scheme would have lower costs and less impact on energy security than other policies considered.
It comes in a week in which Mr Turnbull launched an aggressive attack on Labor over its support for emissions intensity trading as well as a 50 per cent renewable energy target.
Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg backtracked on making an emissions intensity scheme part of a government review. Photo: Andrew Meares
Interviewed on Melbourne radio station 3AW on Thursday, Mr Turnbull contrasted Labor's position with the Coalition's determination to keep prices down. He stressed that the government would not impose a carbon tax or an emissions trading scheme.
"I just want to be very, very clear that energy prices are too high already. We will do everything that we can to put downward pressure on energy prices," he said.
Illustration: Ron Tandberg 
Under all scenarios considered, the modelling in the commission report seen by Fairfax Media found an emissions intensity scheme was the cheapest option for consumers and business.
That remained the case if the emissions target was beefed up from a 28 per cent to a 50 per cent cut by 2030 compared with 2005 levels. Under the latter consumers and businesses would still pay $3.4 billion less than if no policy was introduced.
If demand for electricity was higher than average, the collective saving on electricity bills was estimated to be $15 billion.
An emissions intensity scheme sets a limit on how much a power station can freely emit for every unit of power generated. Cleaner generators that emitted less than the limit earn credits, and sell them to high-emitting generators above the baseline.
The limit would be gradually reduced. Proponents say it means coal would effectively subsidise cleaner power. They say the scheme would also encourage a greater range of types of cleaner power, which would increase competition and further reduce costs.
It would initially be likely to boost gas-fired power, which has about half the emissions of black coal generation, at the expense of the dirtiest coal plants. Modelling suggests it would supplying nearly a third of electricity by 2030.
Mr Frydenberg issued a statement late Thursday reiterating the government's opposition to any form of carbon pricing.
He said Labor's expanded renewable energy target would jack up power prices and put the nation's energy security at risk, while the Coaliton had triggered the largest reduction in electricity bills experienced by scrapping the Gillard government's carbon price scheme.
He said the government's 2017 review would be the "next step in our methodical approach to climate change policy".
The commission, which sets the rules for electricity and gas markets and has long supported an emissions intensity scheme, was asked to provide guidance to COAG ahead of next year's climate policy review.
The Finkel report was commissioned to give extra advice after the unprecedented statewide South Australian blackout in September. It says the energy system is undergoing its biggest transition since the 1890s as it shifts to lower-emissions energy, a change that cannot be reversed.
But it highlights the significant challenges faced in transforming the system to run on a growing mix of traditional baseload power, intermittent renewable energy, distributed rooftop solar power and battery storage.
It also warns against the ambitious state renewable energy targets set by Labor governments in Victoria (40 per cent by 2025) South Australia (50 per cent by 2025) and Queensland (50 per cent by 2030), saying they could increase costs and investment uncertainty.
COAG will also hear a push form South Australian Premier Jay Weatherill for a states-based emissions trading scheme, though it is unlikely to receive wide support.
Energy and business groups have called for a national bipartisan plan to help plan an orderly transition to cleaner energy, warning a failure to do so would increase both prices and the risk of blackouts.
Labor climate change spokesman Mark Butler told a press conference Mr Turnbull has turned energy policy into a shambles.
"A growing list of organisations and energy experts... have confirmed over the course of this week that this policy is the best way to drive down power prices and improve energy security," he said.
Climate Institute deputy chief executive Erwin Jackson said without a plan the government risked turning Australia into a third-world economy and was making a mistake "of Stalinist proportions".
Mr Price declined to comment.

Links

Thursday, December 08, 2016

Government Accused Of Forcing Up Power Prices Through Climate Backdown

Fairfax - Adam Morton | Heath Aston

The government faces accusations that it is forcing up electricity prices and reducing energy reliability after abandoning a plan to even consider a climate scheme that experts say could have tackled both.
In a torturous press conference, Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull confirmed that the government had been forced into a U-turn on climate-change policy less than 48 hours after releasing details for a policy review next year.

No carbon tax or emissions trading 
Speculation the government might adopt a carbon intensity trading scheme leads to a clarification from Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull. Courtesy ABC News 24.

After two days of vocal criticism from several Coalition backbenchers, the government dropped plans for the review to consider an emissions intensity scheme for the electricity sector - a form of carbon pricing - to help it meet its climate targets.
Mr Turnbull denied such a scheme had ever been part of the review. "We will not be imposing a carbon tax and we will not be imposing an emissions trading scheme, however it is called," he said.
Prime minister Malcolm Turnbull at the Sydney Fish Markets on Wednesday. Photo: Mick Tsikas
It  came as EnergyAustralia – the country's second biggest greenhouse gas emitter – announced on Wednesday plans to spend $1.5 billion on solar and wind projects.
Asked whether Environment and Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg had the imprimatur of the Prime Minister's Office when he told journalists it would be considered, Mr Turnbull said: "If you want to ask questions about what another minister said, you should address them to him."
Mr Frydenberg subsequently also denied an emissions intensity scheme had ever been on the table, despite having told Fairfax Media and the ABC that the review would look at it.
Mr Turnbull said the government would never increase the cost of energy for Australian families and businesses.
But Frontier Economics chief Danny Price, who advised Mr Turnbull on an emissions intensity scheme as far back as 2009 and who the government last year appointed to the Climate Change Authority board, said the government had turned its back on an option that would have reduced prices.
He said an emissions intensity scheme would improve reliability by helping the electricity industry plan for the closure of existing ageing coal plants by investing in cleaner stations.
"This shows a lack of spine. The policy vacuum that it leaves will be filled by policies that will do exactly what they are trying to avoid," Mr Price said.
"By doing this, it means they are the party of increasing electricity prices and reduced energy security."
Grattan Institute energy program director Tony Wood said an emissions intensity scheme should not be called a carbon tax because it did not raise revenue. He said any policy to cut emissions would have a cost, but those opposing such a scheme were creating more uncertainty and higher prices.
An emissions intensity scheme would set a baseline figure for how much carbon dioxide a power station could emit for every unit of power generated, penalising those who breached their limit and rewarding cleaner models that emitted less with free credits.
Bodies to have recommended an emissions intensity scheme on cost grounds include Energy Networks Australia and the CSIRO.
Energy and business leaders who have called for a bipartisan plan for the future of the electricity system as it shifts to cleaner forms of generation.
Australia Energy Council chief Matthew Warren, representing most electricity generators, declined to comment directly on the about-face, but reiterated substantial policy change was needed.
"The electricity system is visibly deteriorating. It is a system that requires multi-billion-dollar investments and is paralysed because of uncertainty, and until that is resolved, it will continue to deteriorate," Mr Warren said.
Outspoken Liberal backbencher Cory Bernardi welcomed the government backdown. "It was a clear attempt to reintroduce a price on hot air to satisfy the extreme greens and others seduced by the socialist alarmism of anthropogenic climate change," he said.
Opposition leader Bill Shorten said Mr Turnbull was a "weak fellow" who had cave into internal from the Coalition right-wing. "He doesn't believe in anything except saving his job," he said.

Links

Putting American Climate Denial To Good Use

Fairfax - Julian Cribb*

In an interview with Fox News, Donald Trump's newly appointed chief of staff, the Republican National Committee chairman Reince Priebus, confirmed that the official stance of the Trump White House will be that climate science is a "bunch of bunk".
An analysis published in The Washington Post found that America's failure to pull its weight on climate mitigation could boost world temperatures by +2.3 to +2.5 degrees by 2050, depending on whether the rest of the world holds the line agreed to at Paris COP 21, or whether other countries (like Australia, for example) take it as a pretext to backslide on their commitment to present and future generations.
President-elect Donald Trump with his new chief of staff Reince Priebus. Photo: AP
Stripped of political persiflage, the Trump position – as articulated by Priebus and the growing gang of climate deniers appointed to hold office under Trump – is that tens of millions of humans must die to protect the shareholder value of a handful of crumbling US resources corporates who refuse to enter the 21st century and prefer to stick with the 19th and 20th.
According to a World Health Organisation 2016 report "An estimated 12.6 million people died as a result of living or working in an unhealthy environment in 2012 – nearly one in four of total global deaths". Those unhealthy environments mostly consist of air, water, food and furnishings polluted by toxins sourced from the petrochemical and coal industries. In China and India, on average, 4000 people die daily from air pollution alone. Around a third of the world's rising cancer rates are now attributed to chemical exposures, as are the rising waves of autism, reproductive dysfunction and mental disease.
And this doesn't begin to include the numbers who will perish in the famines, wars and weather disasters that will accompany accelerating climate change.
So, including their impact on the global climate, fossil fuels are now claiming lives at a substantially higher rate than did World War II (about 7 million a year). It follows that a decision by the new American leadership to promote fossil fuel use, instead of replacing it with cleaner, safer and more sustainable forms of energy amounts to a declaration of war on humanity as a whole – and one that will, unavoidably, come at the cost of tens of millions of lives.
The same argument applies to the hollow, insincere, foot-dragging policies of Australian political leaders on climate and renewables: many are perfectly willing to sacrifice human lives for the sake of a few cosy coal company sinecures after political retirement. Like asbestos, they are hoping the long industrial chains between the primary sources of pollution and its victims will, for a time, obscure the trail of ultimate responsibility. But, eventually, there will be a Nuremberg.
In the meantime, the world has the interesting issue of how to deal with an America many of us thought of as a friend, ally and benefactor – and which now displays all the potential for becoming a rogue state worse by far than North Korea, in terms of the damage it can inflict on humanity.
The simplest and most elegant solution is the one powerfully articulated by Donald Trump during the election campaign when he declared that Mexico should pay for building his border wall, to keep the tide of emigrants out of the US.
If America wants to damage the world's climate, destabilise the planet and cause havoc to the health of its citizens by promoting toxic energy solutions, then it is only fair that America should pay to clean up the mess it creates and compensate the victims.
The logical answer is for signatories to COP 21 to agree to impose a multilateral carbon tax on the trade (goods and services) of any country that abandons its agreement.
A tax that would pay for all the climate mitigation, reafforestation, water and food security measures, new energy research and especially, for the building of vast new renewable energy plants around the world.
That way, America's coal, oil, gas and shale sector can be made to fund the rise of its competitors – and bankroll the transition to a clean, sustainable world. Since they have devoted recent decades to amassing fortunes at the expense of farmers, native peoples, blue-collar workers and the middle classes of the world, it would be Shakespearean justice to spend those fortunes on improving global wellbeing in this way. If the carbon levy was big enough, it could even be used to end world poverty ...
The aim of a carbon levy on US trade is not to hurt the tens of millions of sensible, caring Americans who don't swallow the Trump nonsense, nor the tens of thousands of ethical American businesses who are already committed to climate action. It is to add steel to their arm and might to their lobby in their effort to compel their country's leaders to abandon this self-defeating course.
Yes, a carbon levy would be a form of sanction. Just like the sanctions America itself supported against apartheid South Africa, Iran, Libya, Cuba and many others. Do such measures work? Well, they certainly appear to – or people wouldn't keep imposing them. They certainly strengthen opposition movements within the sanctioned country. And in America, land of the dollar, money speaks louder than ideals.
The carbon levy should not only be on American-sourced goods and services, but also on products of multinational companies founded or substantially based in the US. That includes Apple, Microsoft, Coca-cola, Continental Grain etc. Oh, and don't forget the US arms industry either – they seem to have the ear of the Trumpists. It could be imposed multilaterally, but in the meantime bilaterally will do. If enough countries impose a carbon levy it will be a sign to Washington that we're serious.
At the same time the carbon levy could be suspended for the "goodies" of the US economy – Elon Musk's electric cars and batteries, for example or solar firms Verengo, SolarCity and SunPower. This would send a clear market signal about what products the world prefers, which ever-agile US commerce would be quick to exploit.
So let's all play the Mexican Wall game back to Mr Trump and his cronies. For the sake of all our grandkids.
Thanks, Donald, for another great business idea!

*Julian Cribb is a science writer and author of 'Surviving the 21st Century'

Links

What An Extraordinary, Gutless Capitulation By Josh Frydenberg

The Guardian - 

‘Josh Frydenberg has gone in the space of 24 hours from saying quite clearly the government would consider an emissions intensity trading scheme for the electricity sector to trying to pretend he said no such thing.’ Photograph: Bloomberg via Getty Images
What an extraordinary capitulation.
Just 24 hours of controversy from entirely predictable quarters and a carefully calibrated process to try to engineer a truce in Australia’s utterly wretched climate politics has been all but abandoned by its architects.
Josh Frydenberg has gone in the space of 24 hours from saying quite clearly the government would consider an emissions intensity trading scheme for the electricity sector to trying to pretend he said no such thing.
The retreat is, frankly, unseemly.
Actually, the retreat is more than unseemly, it’s pathetic – and the consequences of it stretch far beyond yet another apparent failure to do what needs to be done to ensure our economy makes an orderly transition to the carbon-constrained world that the Turnbull government willingly accepted when it signed Australia up to the Paris international climate agreement this time 12 months ago.
Forget the intricacies of the climate policy debate – the government through this botched process has again revealed its true nature to the public.
Yet again the Turnbull government has shown the voting public that it is a divided, roiling, rudderless, chaotic and gutless political outfit, locked into a cycle of chasing its own tail, jumping nervously at shadows.
It doesn’t matter whether or not you are intrinsically a fan of governments embarking on rational policy solutions to vexed public policy problems, whether you accept the science of climate change or whether you don’t, this particular episode chalks up yet another episode in government as chaos theory.
The government now presents to the public as an outfit completely devoid of organising principle, careening to try to stay ahead of the next imbroglio, not because of any external pressure, or ferocious rent seeking by powerful special interests, or slick politics by the opposition – but because everything is about the metastasizing internals.
At the end of the political year, the government looks like a bunch of people clinging to their jobs, and doing whatever it takes to keep clinging to them – or if they are not doing that, they are trying to engineer the downfall of others, week after week, issue after issue.
Sensible people in the government would of course tell you this process of reviewing the manifestly inadequate Direct Action policy was doomed from the start – that it would be impossible to engineer a rational climate policy, one which reduced emissions at the least cost to taxpayers, and steer it successfully through this particular Coalition party room.
Sensible people would say this process was always going to degenerate into a battle of straw men and a proxy war about leadership.
They are doubtless correct in that assessment.
This is, after all, the group of people who elevated something as inoffensive as a market-based mechanism to the status of mass moral panic and a national thought crime.
That’s a collective trance of pure stupid that is very hard to break out of.
Sensible government people would also tell you that the review of Direct Action is still afoot, and it will hear a bunch of arguments in favour of evidence-based policy from business, from the energy sector, from environment groups – arguments that might be able to carry some weight over the next 12 months.
Right now, that’s a very big might.
Right now, the conclusion looks inescapable.
On climate policy the Coalition has backed itself into a tight corner of its own making – and it shows no sign of finding the courage, the steadiness or the integrity to try to manage its way out.

Links

Wednesday, December 07, 2016

Why The Climate Change Policy Is Stuck In A Revolving Door

New Daily - 

Round we go again with yet more discussion papers on climate policy. Photo: AAP
The government’s climate change policy review, announced on Monday, will give anyone interested in the issue a powerful sense of déjà vu.
The review will look at whether Australia’s carbon emission targets are being met, and whether the “lowest cost of abatement” is being achieved.
Significantly, the government is ruling out both a return to a nationwide carbon pricing scheme, and any increase on the current 2020 renewable energy target, which it cut last June from 41,000 GWh to 33,000 GWh.
Beyond that, the review’s terms of reference look better suited to 2007 – the year John Howard asked the head of the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet, Peter Shergold, to draw up plans for an emissions trading scheme.
It’s as if the Gillard government’s emissions trading scheme, erroneously dubbed a ‘carbon tax’, had never been designed, legislated, operated and then repealed.

Point of difference
Environment Minister Josh Frydenberg wants “to hear from experts”.
Environment Minister Josh Frydenberg is trying to differentiate his Direct Action suite of policies as a “sector-by-sector” approach, stressing he will pay particular attention to the “impact of policies on jobs, investment, trade competitiveness, households and regional Australia”.
But hang on, that’s exactly what the Gillard government’s ‘Clean Energy Futures’ package did too.
It has specific carve-outs and compensation packages for sectors such as steel, aluminium and food processing, and left petrol off the list of carbon sources altogether.
Mr Frydenberg told the ABC he would engage in “close engagement with business and the community, beginning with consultation on a discussion paper”.
Again, it’s like being back in 2007, when the Committee for the Economic Development of Australia – perhaps the nation’s least partisan think tank – hosted an international debate between US economists Dr Robert Mendelsohn and Dr Robert Shapiro and Australians Professor Warwick McKibbin and Brian Fisher.
Back then, the main difference in opinion was over whether a carbon tax, an emissions trading system, or a hybrid of the two would be the cheapest way to change the nation’s power consumption habits.
And none of those economists would have called for a ‘standing Green Army’ to plant trees and fix other environmental programs – an Abbott government policy that looks set to be torn up at the next budget, to the chagrin of Mr Abbott himself.

Polluted politics
In the aftermath of Tony Abbott’s devastating campaign against the ‘carbon tax’ between 2011 and 2013, the cheapest way to cut emissions has become a political impossibility.
That said, one form of emissions trading ­– in which the price of permits to pollute are set by an auction process – is back on the table.
The carbon tax was a hot topic for Australia. Photo: Getty
It will reportedly be considered only for big electricity generators – which sounds uncannily like the plan Labor took to this year’s federal election.
Overall, the politics of carbon reduction has become a farce, with Mr Frydenberg telling the ABC on Monday: “We want to hear from the experts, as to the lowest cost of abatement.”
But experts thrashed out those arguments a decade ago! They published pivotal reports such as the Stern Review in the UK, or the Garnaut Review in Australia.
Economist Ross Garnaut tackled what he called the “diabolical” policy problem, by creating Labor’s carbon price-setting mechanism, which included some of the carve-outs listed above.
Moreover, 80 per cent of the revenue raised by that policy was returned as tax cuts and pension/benefit increases – resulting, as noted last week, in a per capita impost on Australians of around $34 per year.

Abbottalypse now
Now, following the Abbott government’s repeal of that package, we have Direct Action – a package centred on the Emissions Reduction Fund, in which the government pays companies, via the cheapest tenders, to stop polluting.
An emission trading scheme for large electricity generators is reportedly back on the table.
So far it has boasted of a low cost per tonne for reducing emissions, overlooking the fact that such an ‘auction’ was always going to buy up the lowest-cost forms of abatement first.
By definition, the higher cost abatement plans will have to be purchased down the track – costing taxpayers more, and more and more, as Mr Abbott might have put it.
That’s why economists have stressed that emissions trading, or even a real carbon tax, is superior. The price doesn’t just keep going up.
But instead of trusting to either of those two approaches, we’ve ended up with a government that wants to “hear from experts” (again) to created a sector-by-sector plan (again), weigh up the impact on “jobs, investment, trade and households” (again) and consult with business and communities (again).
Déjà vu doesn’t begin to describe the revolving door this policy area has now been caught in for a decade.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative