Sunday, December 11, 2016

Australia, Welcome To Your New Climate Change Policy

Fairfax -  Jacqueline Maley

One Nation leader Pauline Hanson visited the Great Barrier Reef a fortnight ago, with two of her fellow senators – Malcolm "I respect the Jews" Roberts, a man whose climate change denial is so intricate you need a PhD to understand it; and poor Brian Burston, who didn't join his colleagues for a snorkel because they couldn't find a wetsuit to fit him.
It appears no invitation was extended to fellow One Nation senator Rod Culleton, who is enjoying his legal adventures far too much for his leader's liking. They left the limelight-hogger back down south.

Pauline Hanson's Great Barrier grief
ABC's 7.30 joins One Nation leader Pauline Hanson during a snorkelling tour of the Great Barrier Reef as the senator and her party attempt to disprove the effects of climate change. Vision courtesy ABC.

Finally the spotlight was back where it should be – on Hanson, who donned a wetsuit, inspected the coral in the waters off Great Keppel Island, and declared the reef ship-shape.
She could see no bleached coral, and the water, alleged by climate activists to be too hot, felt exactly as warm as it should.
One Nation Senator Pauline Hanson assesses some coral near Great Keppel Island. Photo: AAP
"We are being controlled by the UN and these agreements that have been done for people's self interest and where they are driving our nation as a sovereignty and the economics of the whole lot," Hanson told the gathered media.
Doesn't make a lot of sense, does it?
Australia, welcome to your new climate change policy.
This week has seen Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull take fright, yet again, at the right wing of his party, at the mere mention of a carbon pricing scheme.
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull had promised to review the Coalition's climate policies. Photo: Andrew Meares
Literally its mention.
And this mere mention wasn't a scare that crept up on anyone – Turnbull went to the election promising to review the Coalition's climate policies, and on Monday Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg said a climate pricing scheme might be touched upon as being part of that review.
This is a review that might, as its most terrifying result, lead to a discussion paper.
Run for the hills!
"We are edging towards the land of the radical, where policy-making is as fantastical as a go-nowhere boat trip over a bleached-out coral reef."
Malcolm did, leaving his Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg exposed and alone on the wide open plains of reasonable policy-making processes.
Since rejecting the prospect a carbon pricing scheme even being considered, Turnbull has hidden behind the mantra that his government will do nothing to push up electricity prices.
Most experts say that pushing up electricity prices is precisely what the rejection of a carbon pricing system will ultimately do, but no matter.
This way the Prime Minister can play to the respectable retail politics of anxiety over living costs, but also give discreet cover to the climate change deniers, and hopefully staunch the votes many in the Coalition fear will bleed to One Nation at the next election.
Last week Turnbull riffed in Parliament about so-called post-truth politics, at the expense of the Labor opposition.
This week he averted his gaze from the advice of its own agencies, the business lobby and the science community, to insist that the best way to meet emissions targets is not through a carbon pricing scheme.
The Prime Minister is in danger of turning into Brian Burston – he won't quite climb into a wetsuit and get in the water with the climate change deniers, but he's certainly along for the ride.
Since the shock (to many but not all) result of the US presidential election, there has been much hand-wringing among the so-called elite media about whether Australia will catch the same virus.
People regularly cite Australia's economic strength and our egalitarianism as reasons why emotion-driven, fact-free and angry populism will not flourish here as it is flourishing in other Western democracies.
But research recently published by a University of Melbourne academic, Roberto Stefan Foa, and his former Harvard colleague Yascha Mounk, shows that our democratic consensus is fragile too.
The pair has been researching the attitudes of people in so-called "consolidated" democracies, to the conventions and institutions that comprise those democracies.
They have found a disturbing trend – over time, in all the liberal democracies including Australia, open-ness to the idea of military rule has grown, the number of people who think a democratic system is "bad" has grown, support for the concept of civil rights is less, and fewer people express an interest in politics. This trend is especially pronounced in young people, so-called Millennials.
In these conditions, populist politicians gain traction by appealing to emotion and bypassing fact altogether.
These politicians outrage the "elites", precisely because they don't adhere to the values of liberal democracy, which roll all the way back to the Enlightenment. They are playing "our" game but they won't accept the rules we wrote. They don't value rationalism over emotion. They don't abide by the norms so many of us thought (or hoped) were settled, and in this sense they are radical.
And when you have a Prime Minister who refuses facts as squarely as Turnbull did this week, despite being educated, intelligent and on record as knowing those facts better than most people, we are edging towards the land of the radical, where policy-making is as fantastical as a go-nowhere boat trip over a bleached-out coral reef.

Links

We'll All Be Worse Off For Malcolm Turnbull's Climate Policy Fail

Fairfax - Phillip Coorey


Not happy, Mal!

Malcolm Turnbull still seethes over what Labor did to him on Medicare during the election campaign.
Labor's inflated claims that the government planned to privatise universal health care were devastatingly effective. Turnbull frequently describes the campaign as the first incursion into Australia of post-truth politics - telling a bold-faced lie and getting away with it.
In reality, it was the Coalition under Tony Abbott which first made post-truth politics an art form in this country with its hyperbolic attacks on carbon pricing.
Turnbull was a passive observer as Abbott, Barnaby Joyce and others made inflated claims about the impact of "the great big tax on everything". It worked so well it became the template for Labor's Mediscare campaign.
One of the few people in the Coalition with any intellectual honesty is the man who fuelled the trouble - Liberal Senator Cory Bernardi. Alex Ellinghausen
This week, the chicanery caught up with the Coalition when Turnbull, his Energy and Environment Minister Josh Frydenberg and the government in general fell victim to the hyperbole all had helped nurture over the years.
In doing so, the Prime Minister's credibility took a massive blow and consumers and businesses were condemned to a future of second-best energy policy.
Politically, the government surrendered one of its most potent attack lines of recent years - that Labor stood for higher power prices. It has been an epic disaster.
Ironically, one of the few people in the Coalition with any intellectual honesty is the man who fuelled the trouble - Liberal Senator Cory Bernardi.
The South Australian firebrand doesn't believe in man-made climate change and, therefore, sees no need to have any emissions reductions targets, let alone policies to reach them. Simply, he is happy to keep burning brown coal to generate electricity because that is the cheapest form of energy.
The government has condemned Australia to a second-best energy policy and surrendered one of its most potent Labor attack lines. Peter Nicholson
But for the vast majority of his colleagues, this week's policy surrender locks in the Coalition to meeting the 2030 target of reducing emissions by 26 per cent-to-28 per cent on 2005 levels, while not being allowed to use the mechanism that all the experts say would have the least impact on the economy, power prices and security of supply.
That is an emissions intensity scheme in the electricity sector in which generators would be penalised only if they breached a baseline limit. Cleaner emitters who stayed below the baseline would not pay anything and would receive free credits which they could to trade to bigger polluters.
The whole idea is to shift baseload supply towards gas until renewable energy becomes reliable enough. It was in August 2015 that then Prime Minister Tony Abbott, alongside Julie Bishop and then-environment minster Greg Hunt announced the 2030 targets and put in train this transition.
At a press conference, they announced their climate change policy would be reviewed in 2017 to find ways to meet those targets.
Because the government is so scared of its own tail, it reacted by rejecting the very mechanism not only recommended by the experts, but one that had been created surreptitiously by Hunt and which was to be developed into a de facto EIS. Andrew Meares
Their fig-leaf policy of direct action, cobbled together over the summer of 2009-2010 out of fear Kevin Rudd would call a double-dissolution election on climate change in early 2010, involved hoiking money out of the budget to pay people to lower emissions.
This was clearly unsustainable over the longer-term, both financially and environmentally. More so now that the budged is mired in deficit.
Back in August 2015, Hunt had Abbott agree the review, to be conducted in 2017, would examine post-2020 the purchase of cheap permits from developing nations as a way of helping meet the 2030 targets.
Because Abbott was so averse to anything that resembled a market mechanism, he agreed reluctantly.
He said he would rather try first to achieve emissions cuts domestically "rather than get them from other countries".
Otherwise, Hunt and Abbott said one-third of the post-2020 reductions would rely on a continuation of direct action. This would cost $200 million a year, or $2 billion over the decade straight out of the budget, but direct action would also include "safeguards" which is a market mechanism to ensure emitters stay under a declining emissions cap or pay a penalty.
Sound familiar?
The safeguards mechanism developed by Hunt, right under Abbott's nose, was the draft version of the Emissions Intensity Scheme on the electricity sector that Turnbull killed with a sledgehammer this week after Frydenberg alluded to having a look at the idea as part of the policy review, and Bernardi and Co pounced.
Therefore it was of no surprise in government this week that chief scientist Alan Finkel, along with a joint report by the Australian Energy Market Commission and the Australian Energy Market Operator, all concluded the government would not meet the 2030 targets on current policy settings and an EIS had to be the central plank of post-2020 policy.
The other two options - expanding the mandated use of renewable energy or regulating the closure of coal-fired power, would have a greater impact on the economy, create higher power prices and lead to more blackouts.
Not even Abbott, back in 2015, promised the 2030 targets could be achieved without an impact on prices or the budget.
"This is certainly not without cost but the costs are manageable,"he said.
But the Coalition rebels have since regressed, saying now there should be no cost.
And because the government is so scared of its own tail, it reacted by rejecting the very mechanism not only recommended by the experts, but one that had been created surreptitiously by Hunt and which was to be developed into a de facto EIS.
And one that ticks every box with regard to the government's key promise to meet the 2030 targets while keeping prices down and the lights on.
Labor, which promised an EIS at the last election, is now the party of lower prices.
Everyone is jumping ugly on Frydenberg because he said on Monday, after releasing the terms of reference for the review, that the EIS was worthy of consideration.
Front-running by ministers is not allowed. He was ripped a new one on Tuesday night in cabinet.
He was meant to clam up and allow the policy to be developed by stealth and consensus and then sprung on the backbench and the broader public.
The same internal criticism was made of Scott Morrison when he spruiked increasing the GST.
Now Frydenberg has the monumental policy task of mapping out an energy transition path while his hands are tied. And we'll all be worse off for it.

Links

Trump Transition Team For Energy Department Seeks Names Of Employees Involved In Climate Meetings

Washington Post - Steven Mufson | Juliet Eilperin

Chinese President Xi Jinping shakes hands with President Obama and U.N. Secretary General Ban Ki-moon during a joint ratification of the Paris climate change agreement ceremony in Hangzhou, China, on Sept. 3. (How Hwee Young/Reuters)
The Trump transition team has issued a list of 74 questions for the Energy Department, asking agency officials to identify which department employees and contractors have worked on forging an international climate pact as well as domestic efforts to cut the nation’s carbon output.
The questionnaire requests a list of those individuals who have taken part in international climate talks over the past five years and “which programs within DOE are essential to meeting the goals of President Obama’s Climate Action Plan.”
Trump and his team have vowed to dismantle specific aspects of Obama’s climate policies. The questionnaire, which one Energy Department official described as unusually “intrusive” and a matter for departmental lawyers, has raised concern that the Trump transition team was trying to figure out how to target the people, including civil servants, who have helped implement policies under Obama.
Thousands of scientists have signed petitions calling on the president-elect and his team to respect scientific integrity and refrain from singling out individual researchers whose work might conflict with the new administration’s policy goals. This potential clash could prompt a major schism within the federal government, with many career officials waging a battle against incoming political appointees.
Trump’s transition team did not respond to a request for comment. White House deputy press secretary Eric Schultz told reporters that he could not speak to the questionnaire directly, saying, “If you have questions about activity that the president-elect’s team is doing, you should check in with them and try and figure out why they’re doing it.”
But Schultz added, “All I can tell you is that President Obama is enormously proud of the work of civil servants and federal workers across the administration, that over the past eight years they’ve worked to make this country stronger. And they don’t do so out a sense of great pay or because the hours are great. They do so out of a sense of patriotism. And the president’s proud of their record.”
The questionnaire was first reported by Bloomberg News. The Post has obtained its own a copy of both the initial document as well as one with some of the agency’s replies filled in, in addition to confirmation from other people in the department.
The document spanned a broad area of Energy Department activities, including its loan program, its technology research program, responses to Congress, estimates of offshore wind and cleanup of uranium at a site once used by the military for weapons research. In many cases, the inquiries meshed with the priorities of conservative groups such as the Heritage Foundation, which held a meeting on energy and environment issues in Washington on Thursday, as well as priorities outlined in a recent fundraising pitch sent by the American Energy Alliance (AEA), a wing of the Institute for Energy Research.
Thomas Pyle, who heads AEA, leads Trump’s Energy Department transition team. In a recent fundraising pitch, Pyle wrote supporters, “After eight years of the Obama administration’s divisive energy and environmental policies, the American people have voted for a change — a big change. We expect the Trump administration will adopt pro-energy and pro-market policies — much different than the Obama administration’s top-down government approach.”
One question zeroed in on the issue of the “social cost of carbon,” a way of calculating the consequences of greenhouse gas emissions. The transition team asked for a list of department employees or contractors who attended interagency meetings, the dates of the meetings, and emails and other materials associated with them.
The social cost of carbon is a metric that calculates the cost to society of emitting a ton of carbon dioxide to the atmosphere. The Obama administration has used this tool to try to calculate the benefits of regulations and initiatives that lead to lower greenhouse gas emissions.
At Thursday’s Heritage meeting, senior fellow David Kreutzer — who is a member of Trump’s Environmental Protection Agency transition team — attacked the idea of using the social cost of carbon during the regulatory process.
Another question appeared to delve deeply into the mechanisms behind scientific tools called “integrated assessment models,” which scientists use to forecast future changes to the climate and energy system. It also asked what the Energy Department considers to be “the proper equilibrium climate sensitivity,” which is a way that climate researchers calculate how much the planet will eventually warm, depending upon the amount of greenhouse gases emitted into the atmosphere.
“My guess is that they’re trying to undermine the credibility of the science that DOE has produced, particularly in the field of climate science,” said Rob Jackson, a Stanford climate and energy researcher, in response to the question about the Integrated Assessment Models.
The questionnaire also appeared to take aim at the national laboratories, which operate with a high degree of independence but which are part of the Energy Department. The questionnaire asked for a list of the top 20 salaried employees of the labs, the labs’ peer-reviewed publications over the past three years, a list of their professional society memberships, affiliations, and the websites they maintain or contribute to “during work hours.”
The transition team list also asked how to keep open aging nuclear power plants, restart the controversial Yucca mountain nuclear waste site shelved by Obama, and support the licensing of small modular reactors.
It included 15 questions for the Energy Information Administration, some of them routine but some questioning the way the agency uses data about energy production.
The questions called to mind past cases of conflicts between Republican administrations and federal agency scientists, on the environment and other matters.
In Ronald Reagan’s first term, Anne Gorsuch was appointed to head the Environmental Protection Agency amid a major push for regulatory rollback. But after Gorsuch resigned amid controversy in 1983, Congress opened investigations into supposed “hit lists” at the agency used to track the views of members of scientific advisory boards, according to contemporary press reports.
During the George W. Bush administration, meanwhile, there were complaints that scientific documents had been edited to raise doubts about the science of climate change, and that researchers had been prevented from speaking openly to the media and sharing their expertise.
In late 2010, the Obama administration issued government-wide “scientific integrity” guidelines aimed at shielding federal scientists from political interference, part of an effort to distinguish itself from the George W. Bush administration. The four-page memo, written by John Holdren, director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, included a prohibition against agency leaders or public affairs officers asking or demanding federal scientists to alter or suppress their findings. It also instructed agencies to “involve science and technology experts where appropriate” in order to craft “policymaking of the highest integrity.”
Energy Department officials have not yet decided how to respond to the questions targeting the agency’s climate activities, according to federal officials who asked not to be identified to discuss internal deliberations.
“With some of these questions, it feels more like an inquisition than a question, in terms of going after career employees who have been here through Bush years to Clinton, and up to now,” said one current Energy Department employee. “All of a sudden you have questions that feel more like a congressional investigation than an actual probing of how the Department of Energy does its job.”
Michael Halpern, deputy director of the Union of Concerned Scientists’ Center for Science and Democracy, called the memo’s demand that Energy officials identify specific employees “alarming.”
“If the Trump administration is already singling out scientists for doing their jobs, the scientific community is right to be worried about what his administration will do in office. What’s next? Trump administration officials holding up lists of ‘known climatologists’ and urging the public to go after them?” Halpern asked.
He added that lawmakers have attacked executive branch scientists in the past for doing “work they find inconvenient. It seems that they are about to get accomplices in the Department of Energy. But don’t expect the federal workforce to simply roll over. The new administration will find thousands of federal workers who still believe in their departmental mission and will work hard to resist attacks on their peers. Scientists outside government are standing by to expose these actions and fight back.”
Christine McEntee, the executive director of the American Geophysical Union, a large membership society of Earth scientists, added in response to the questionnaire that “we don’t know at AGU the intent of all these questions, but if you look at them without knowing that intent, they are raising alarm for us.”
McEntee said that in general when it comes to politics and science under Trump, “we’re hearing a lot from members, they’re quite concerned.” At the American Geophysical Union fall meeting in San Francisco this December, where over 20,000 scientists gather annually, there will be sessions on the consequences of the election for science and also giving publicly funded scientists legal advice on how to respond to requests for their communications, she said.
The Trump transition team meetings with Energy Department officials so far have excluded political appointees, one current official said.
At the Defense Department, Trump transition personnel are having multiple meetings a day with Pentagon personnel, but in some cases have asked Obama administration political appointees not to attend those meetings, officials there said.

Links

Saturday, December 10, 2016

Households To Power Up To Half Australia, Zero Emissions Within Reach: CSIRO

Fairfax - Adam Morton

As the Coalition backs away from a pledge to consider a climate change policy that the energy industry says it needs, a new study is projecting a rapidly growing mass electricity generator for Australia in the decades ahead: the public.
Consumers using rooftop solar panels and batteries will produce between a third and half of Australia's electricity by mid-century if the right policies are introduced, according to a roadmap from the CSIRO and power and gas transmission body Energy Networks Australia.

Bernardi fumes over carbon trading scheme
Coalition MPs voice their displeasure on the government's climate review including an emissions intensity scheme for electricity generators. Vision courtesy ABC News 24

The two-year analysis also found an emissions intensity scheme for the electricity sector - a form of carbon trading that was to be considered by a government climate policy review until that plan was abandoned on Tuesday afternoon - would be the cheapest way to cut carbon dioxide emissions.
It suggests it could save customers $200 a year by 2030, while helping create a reliable electricity grid with zero emissions by 2050.
Energy Networks chief John Bradley said a low-cost shift to zero emissions would depend on a national climate and energy plan with bipartisan support.
"By contrast, carbon policy which could change dramatically at every election, or differs in every state, is a recipe for a high-cost and less secure electricity service," Mr Bradley said.
His call for the Coalition and Labor to come together on climate policy echoes that made by bodies representing energy generators and major industrial companies.
The Electricity Network Transformation Roadmap forecasts that up to 10 million households and small businesses would have solar panels, battery storage, smart homes and electric vehicles if pricing and incentives were changed to better reflect demand. This would "transform the grid into a platform more like the internet, where customers can trade and share energy".
As many as one in five homes now have rooftop solar systems. Photo: Fairfax Media
It recommends an emissions intensity scheme for power stations be introduced by 2020, following a similar call by the Climate Change Authority, now dominated by Coalition-appointed board members.
On Tuesday, Environment and Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg backed away from saying the government would consider this sort of scheme as part of a wide-ranging departmental review of climate policy next year. A handful of Coalition backbenchers, including Cory Bernardi and Craig Kelly, had called for any form of carbon pricing to be rejected.
Illustration: Ron Tandberg. 
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull earlier said he had never supported a carbon tax - which the emissions intensity scheme is not - and stressed the climate review was "business as usual".
"It's part of the policy we took to the election in 2013 and 2016 and, indeed, we took to the election in 2010. This is business as usual," he said.
Opposition leader Bill Shorten said Labor would examine whatever the government proposed, but predicted the Prime Minister would buckle to MPs opposed to action on climate change to avoid "civil war". Labor promised an intensity scheme as part of its climate policies before this year's federal election.
An intensity scheme would set a baseline figure for how much carbon dioxide a power station could emit for every unit of power generated, penalising those that breached their limit and rewarding cleaner models that emitted less with free credits.
The report found thermal plants, including coal and gas fossil fuels, would be critical in balancing intermittent renewable energy in the years ahead, but would eventually be replaced by technologies using battery storage and biomass.
Getting there would present significant technical, economic and regulatory challenges. It would transform the system away from its original design - large centralised power stations - to a much more decentralised network.
It said a coordinated plan for 2050 could:
  • Make average annual household bills $414 less than they otherwise would have been.
  • Cut network costs to consumers by 30 per cent.
  • Avoid $16 billion in spending on poles and wires.
  • Lead to customers with solar panels, battery storage and electric vehicles earning $2.5 billion a year from network businesses.
The roadmap comes ahead of the Friday release of an interim report into electricity reliability led by chief scientist Alan Finkel, commissioned after South Australia suffered a statewide blackout in September.

Links

Seven Energy Charts That Will Cheer And Frighten About Australia And The World

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

Australia has unmatched renewable energy resources but will meet its climate targets only by intervening to accelerate the retirement of coal-fired power plants, according to Michael Liebreich, founder of global advisory service, Bloomberg New Energy Finance.
Mr Liebreich said the Turnbull government should avoid setting renewable energy targets and instead focus on devising market-based methods to phase out coal.
Anita Ho-Baillie, senior research fellow at UNSW, with a record-breaking solar cell. Photo: UNSW
It  should also avoid "perverse" subsidies, such as the speculated $1 billion loan being considered for Adani's proposed mega-coal mine in Queensland, he said.
The comments come as debate raged among conservative Coalition MPs about the government's plan to review its climate policies in 2017. Causing angst was the plan to examine an emissions intensity scheme for the electricity sector that could generate a carbon price - which prompted a rapid retreat by environment and energy minister Josh Frydenberg.
Mr  Liebreich told a Sydney audience advances in renewable energy technologies were rapid, with solar photovoltaic prices falling by almost a quarter for each doubling of production. For wind, costs sank 19 per cent with each doubling of turbine output. (See chart below.)
Breakthroughs come regularly, with the University of NSW last week revealing it had achieved record efficiency rates for its perovskite solar cells, with prospects of more to come.




The cost of installed capacity for new solar and wind energy had dropped below $US30 per megawatt (or 3¢ per watt) in recent auctions in Chile, Morocco and elsewhere. In Australia, though, the price remains about double that.
Joggers along Shanghai's famous Bund: China's pollution is on the rise. Photo: Andy Wong 
Still, Australia's abundant renewable energy meant the country had potentially the lowest cost for both wind and solar energy. (See chart below.)

Both large-scale wind and solar projects were now cheaper than fossil-fuel energy sources in much of the world, including Australia.
However, their falling costs alone won't see them drop below the existing cost of operating coal plants without some price to reflect the damage of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases, Bloomberg said. (See chart below.)

 Australia will have to reduce overall emissions if it is to meet its 2030 goals pledged at the Paris climate summit in 2015.
Yet, on the government's own projects, emissions are going to increase – not fall – on current policies, although Bloomberg predicts some levelling off.
Any effort to go beyond the 2015 commitments - now set for a 26-28 per cent cut on 2005 levels by 2030 - would have to be much deeper if a 2-degree warming limit agreed at Paris is to be met, Bloomberg said. (See chart below.)


Mr  Liebreich said his greatest concern about the election of Donald Trump to be the next US president was not that he would reverse America's long-term slide in carbon emissions.
Rather, the risk was he would stop the use of "US heft" - deployed by Barack Obama - to discourage the building of more coal-fired power plants in Asia.
On current projections, coal use in power stations is expected to keep rising for decades to come, led by India, China and Japan, exceeding any reductions in the rest of the world, Bloomberg predicts. (See chart below.)

As  Bloomberg notes, the promises made in the Paris agreement would need to be tightened significantly - and soon - if the world is to have any hope of limiting global warming to the 2-degree target. (See chart below.)
Warming since the industrial revolution began is about 1 degree, scientists say.

 While the rise in Asian coal demand may cheer resource employees and governments hoping for a revenue bonanza - think of those based in Canberra and Brisbane - Australia may not get the export boost some are hoping.
According to Bloomberg, India's plans to boost domestic coal supplies should see the need for imports evaporate by about 2023. (See chart below.)


While Adani may yet line up local buyers of coal it could export from its planned Queensland mine and displace local Indian suppliers, that would not necessary be the most economic outcome for India.
"Lots of things that are not economically optimal still happen," Mr Leibreich said.
For Australia to provide funding to underwrite the rail line to Adani and other Galilee Basin mines, though, would also be a distortion from a climate change point of view, he said.
"Given what we know of the science…it seems a perverse use of public money."

Links

Malcolm Turnbull And Premiers Clash Over Climate, Topping A Disastrous Week For Coalition

Fairfax - James Massola | Adam Morton

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull's disastrous week-long spat over a climate-change policy review has culminated in a showdown with state premiers in Canberra, and criticism from the nation's chief business group.
Infrastructure, competition and family violence policies also provoked fights between the Prime Minister and state premiers at Friday's Council of Australian Government meeting.

Not happy, Mal!
South Australia's Jay Weatherill and PM Malcolm Turnbull continue their dispute over electricity policy at the post-COAG press conference.


But it was climate policy that dominated the COAG wash-up, with Mr Turnbull accused of trotting out "infantile slogans" in place of evidence-based policy by South Australian Premier Jay Weatherill.
WA Premier Colin Barnett argued a market-based carbon price mechanism had some role to play in reducing emissions and Victorian Premier Dan Andrews advocated a "proper" examination of climate policy that did not rule out anything - including an emissions intensity scheme - before the federal review was completed.
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull during the COAG press conference at Parliament House. Photo: Andrew Meares
The COAG meeting capped an awful week for Mr Turnbull and the Coalition, which saw the government abandon plans following a backbench revolt to examine the use of an emissions intensity scheme as part of its 2017 review of climate policy, and Environment Minister Josh Frydenberg - who initially said the review would examine an EIS - thrown under a bus even as he reversed course and said there would be no EIS.
The Business Council of Australia, usually a rusted-on supporter of the Coalition, on Friday slammed it for ruling out any prospect of such a scheme being used to reduce carbon emissions.
"The categorical ruling out of mechanisms to achieve this transition [to a low emissions economy], or imposing arbitrary moratoriums on lower-emissions fuels such as onshore gas, constrains the discussion about how agreement can be achieved," chief executive Jennifer Westacott said.
"Both the preliminary report from the Finkel Review Panel and modelling by the Australian Energy Market Commission highlight clearly the options available to government and the costs of ruling particular policies in or out."
An EIS sets a limit on how much a power station can freely emit for every unit of power generated. Cleaner generators that emit less than the limit earn credits, and sell them to dirtier generators above the baseline.
Presenting an issues paper on the electricity market to COAG, chief scientist Alan Finkel cited evidence from the Australian Electricity Market Commission that it would be cheaper to use an emissions intensity scheme to help reach national climate targets than any other option considered, including doing nothing.
Fairfax Media revealed on Thursday that modelling for the commission found electricity bills for consumers and businesses would be up to $15 billion lower over the decade to 2030 if an emissions intensity scheme was in place than if there was no policy.
The modelling was released on Friday.
Defending his government after the meeting, Mr Turnbull ducked questions about the potential for an emissions intensity scheme to actually reduce prices and vowed their would be no carbon tax or emissions trading scheme under his government.
"Critical to maintaining our international competitiveness is energy prices and energy security. We need to ensure that energy is reliable, we need to ensure that it is affordable. We need, of course, to achieve the emissions target cuts that we have agreed to in the Paris treaty," he said.
"The most striking observation from Dr Finkel this morning was that in the last six years household energy prices have risen by 61 per cent, inflation has been 14 per cent . . . that is a massive increase in the burden on Australian households."
But Mr Weatherill suggested Mr Turnbull had misrepresented what an EIS would do and said it was mischievous to conflate it with a carbon tax or emissions trading scheme.
"It was disappointing to see earlier this week the Prime Minister rule out an emissions intensity scheme, he said, adding that the Mr Turnbull had reverted to the "infantile slogans" he had criticised before becoming Prime Minister.
"The whole point of [chief scientist Alan] Finkel's recommendation is this puts downward pressure on electricity prices," he said.
Dr Finkel told the COAG meeting the electricity grid was undergoing unprecedented change, and leaders had a once-in-a-generation chance to reform it during the inevitable shift to a cleaner supply.
Speaking after the meeting, Dr Finkel told Fairfax Media there was evidence an emissions intensity scheme was compatible with maintaining a reliable grid.
He said benefits included that it would encourage low emissions technology of any kind, whether baseload low-emissions gas or renewable energy.
While Mr Turnbull maintained Australia could meet its climate targets with existing policies, Dr Finkel said they were not consistent the 2030 goal set in Paris. "I don't think it's an impossible target to be achieved [but] we need to be methodical about how we get there," he said.
He stressed that the security of the electricity grid was not as strong as in the past, and investors had lost confidence and wanted a coordinated national approach to energy and climate policies.
And Dr Finkel said electricity prices were high – up almost 50 per cent in six years - partly due to network expansion, but also due to high gas prices. He called for more to be done to increase gas supply.
The big three Labor states - Victoria, Queensland and South Australia - all refused to sign up to competition and productivity reforms after the meeting, citing a lack of federal cash.
NSW Premier Mike Baird nominated infrastructure spending as his key priority for the meeting, citing the "sobering" drop in GDP growth on Wednesday and argued governments needed to set new infrastructure goals to drive new economic growth.
He argued for billions of dollars to be pumped into infrastructure, but Mr Turnbull responded bluntly: "We are not an ATM."
Premier Andrews expressed his disappointment that a national deal on family violence leave had not been reached.
The meeting's put off the issue until a decision by the Fair Work Commission, which is considering an application to include an entitlement of 10 days' leave in all modern awards.
Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk said waiting for the decision was a missed opportunity, and suggested COAG meet in regional Australia, where people were hurting in the two-speed economy.

Links

On Climate Policy And Power Prices Turnbull Is Talking Rubbish. Here Are Some Facts


Ruling out carbon pricing is not, to quote Malcolm Turnbull, doing ‘everything that we can to put downward pressure on energy prices’ – it’s a recipe for keeping prices higher. Photograph: Mick Tsikas/AAP 
"I  just want to be very, very clear that energy prices are too high already. We will do everything that we can to put downward pressure on energy prices. We will not impose a carbon tax, or an emissions trading scheme – that is our position."
This is the prime minister, Malcolm Turnbull, talking to the Melbourne radio host, Neil Mitchell, on Thursday, talking nonsense as it turned out – which is what the government has been doing all week on the subject of climate change.
How do I know he was talking nonsense?
There are any number of reports we can draw on to call out what can only be described as unmitigated, lowest common denominator, political crap emanating from the mouth of the prime minister – but I’ll just pick a couple.
Let me share with you the findings of a report that lobbed into the public domain at the start of the week, sandwiched between the government opening what could have been a rational and productive conversation about climate change and energy policy, and the government melting in a small puddle of panic.
A firm called Jacobs was commissioned by the energy networks industry, in cooperation with the CSIRO, to look very carefully at Australia’s climate policy options. Jacobs is the same economic modelling firm used by the Climate Change Authority to analyse the impact of various policies. The CSIRO signed off on the report.
The firm looked at which policy would allow Australia to meet the emissions reduction obligations the Turnbull government signed up to when it ratified the Paris international climate agreement with the least impact on households.
The answer was very clear. It was an emissions intensity trading scheme.
That would be the scheme the energy and environment minister, Josh Frydenberg, very sensibly floated, after he cleverly and carefully set up the Direct Action review with sufficient breadth to be able to consider it – before he ran a mile when Cory Bernardi, Tony Abbott and Craig Kelly started stamping their feet and flaring their nostrils like a triumvirate of bulls in a paddock.
For readers who want more fine print, I’ll quote Jacobs: “The lowest electricity residential bills occur when the existing set of technology-specific policies are extended to all low-emission options and where trading within the generation sector is allowed.
“This is mainly because of the depressing effect on wholesale prices of bringing in and subsidising the dispatch cost of low-emission generation, with the depressing effect of wholesale prices outweighing the scheme liabilities.”
What this means in English is if you set up a technology-neutral emissions trading scheme in the electricity industry, and allow trading to happen, there’s an implicit subsidy for low-emission power generation, and that delivers lower prices for consumers than some of the alternatives.
You might be interested to know that the emissions intensity scheme (now scorned by the Turnbull government as being a source of upward pressure on household energy bills) would deliver an average saving of $216 a year on household electricity bills compared with business as usual.
Let me say that again lest your eyes have glazed over.
A saving.
Lower power bills.
Now what is the “business as usual” example in the Jacob scenario?
That’s the existing policy mix. That would be the Direct Action policy framework, with tighter baselines to drive the reductions required to meet Australia’s Paris commitments of reducing emissions 26% to 28% below 2005 levels by 2030, plus the existing state-based renewable energy targets, which the government in Canberra claims not to like.
The status quo with the tweaks required to hit the Paris target are not the magic formula to lower power prices, they are the opposite. It’s the most expensive option Jacob looked at.
So ruling out carbon pricing is not, to quote Turnbull, doing “everything that we can to put downward pressure on energy prices” – it’s a recipe for keeping power prices higher than they would otherwise be.
And failing the test he’s set for himself is not the only problem Turnbull faces. Lacking the bottle to have a serious conversation about a rational, long-term energy policy framework to govern the electricity industry, and other high emissions players, is a recipe not only for higher power prices, but also for more energy insecurity.
More blackouts. A less efficient grid.
Now how do I know that? Because the chief scientist, Alan Finkel, has produced a report saying so in no uncertain terms.
Finkel has said people can’t invest in new electricity infrastructure in the absence of regulatory certainty, and when investment doesn’t happen, we have a second-rate grid.
So, to recap this tale of woe, Turnbull’s two key political messages since Frydenberg’s unseemly capitulation to conservatives earlier in the week – that we won’t do carbon pricing lest it inflate power bills, and that governments have a fundamental obligation to keep the lights on – are entirely inconsistent with the actions the government is taking.
The government, by digging in, is inflicting a 10th-rate policy on households, on the institutional investors who fund our grid, on the energy industry, on businesses who rely on power supply to generate economic activity.
Voters are being taken for a monumental ride. The government is acting like an outfit that thinks voters are stupid.
Perhaps this is considered smart strategising in our noxious post-truth political times. Perhaps there’s a gamble here that everything will be fine, because voters have had a gutful of experts and their studies, and journalists and their annoying fact-checking and relentless nit-picking. It’s all about the vibe.
Well here’s some vibe in return. Treating voters with contempt isn’t smart. It isn’t clever. It isn’t in the national interest.
It’s just wrong.
For Malcolm Turnbull, who knows better, and has been better, braver, stronger, more committed to evidence and logic and reason, the wrong is magnified.
Over 20 years of political reporting I have applied a consistent test to the governments I’ve watched: are they trying to do some good in the world? Are they trying to make Australia a better place?
On climate policy, apart from pushing through the ratification of the Paris agreement, which was a laudable gesture, and a difficult one to execute given the government’s poisonous internals, the Turnbull government is not trying to do some good in the world.
Right now, it is failing my fundamental test. It’s trying to skate through, and hope no one notices.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative