Thursday, February 09, 2017

Macquarie Group Reaffirms Commitment To Climate Change

Fairfax - Tony Boyd

Tim Bishop, Group Head, Macquarie Capital, revealed his division's "secret sauce" during an annual operational briefing. Supplied
US President Donald Trump might have expunged all mention of climate change from US government websites but that has not stopped Macquarie Group from trumpeting the $US1 trillion of investment banking opportunities in green energy.
One of the highlights of Macquarie's annual operational briefing was the gung ho attitude to green energy shown by the group head of Macquarie Capital, Tim Bishop.
In keeping with Macquarie's direct communication strategy, Bishop's enthusiasm for everything green was first revealed to the market in a YouTube video released on Tuesday morning.
In an short and sharp interview with former ABC journalist Monica Attard, Bishop tried to explain the "secret sauce" behind the success of Macquarie Capital and why he thinks it will do well out of the greening of the global economy.
Bishop said the combination of traditional investment bankers with people having deep operational and technical expertise is something unique to Macquarie Capital.
His presentation for the operational briefing says Macquarie's in-house specialists include civil engineers, geologists, project managers, surveyors, green energy operational staff, green energy commercial managers, electrical engineers and experts in procurement.
Bishop was asked what would drive the profitability of Macquarie Capital in the future and responded by singling out real estate and green energy.
"What is going on in green energy globally is quite an exciting story through Europe and now increasingly in Asia," Bishop said.
"And whether that is solar in Japan, or offshore wind farms in Taiwan or waste plants in Korea, we're big believers in that and we have the expertise to be able to pursue those opportunities.
"Macquarie Capital claims it can play in every aspect of green energy from the development of battery, solar and waste businesses to the construction of these projects as well as offshore wind development. Also, it can operate green energy assets.
Bishop said the expected $US1 trillion in green energy investment expected over the next five years includes $US20 billion in Australia, $US150 billion in Europe, $US240 billion in the Americas and $US600 billion in Asia.
He did not mention the bank's troubled progress toward acquiring the Green Investment Bank in the United Kingdom.
This has been the subject of vehement opposition from UK politicians and activists.
Macquarie's recent track record in green energy investment includes Micheon, Mumbida, 8minuteenergy, Advanced Microgrid Solutions, Baltic2, Japan solar , MGT Power, Galloper, Taiwan Wind and Racebank.
Bishop says Macquarie has in the past and will continue to use its balance sheet to get deals done in the green energy space. He says green energy has the advantage of utilising a range of skills within Macquarie Capital including M&A Advisory, principal investment, technical and operational expertise.

Links

Michael Mann, Climate Scientist In The Crosshairs, Says Fake News Must Be Fought

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

Climate change has long been the target of so-called fake news and its researchers can offer lessons for the wider society in how to handle deliberate misinformation, a leading US scientist said.
Michael Mann, a professor of atmospheric science at Pennsylvania State University who has been attacked by climate change deniers for developing in 1998 the so-called hockey stick graph revealing sharply higher global temperatures after 1900, said the spread of social media made it harder to tackle falsehoods before they gained traction.
Professor Michael Mann, a frequent target of US climate change deniers, is on a speaking tour of Australia. Photo: Steven Siewert
"It's not new to us but it's nonetheless alarming," Professor Mann said. "We're seeing the same opposition to facts and logic and objective discourse, and we're seeing that challenged in our entire body politic."
Dr Mann cited the weekend attack on climate science, a Daily Mail UK article claiming to have uncovered a whistleblower inside the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), as one example. The person questioned the validity of the agency's 2015 finding there had been no pause in global warming in the 1990s onwards, a result that other scientists have recently confirmed.
The UK article drew rapid praise and dissemination from the Republican-controlled House Committee on Science, Space and Technology and other climate denier groups. But it also sparked a speedy debunking from leading scientists such as Gavin Schmidt, head of NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies, who identified muddled use of timelines meant to support the notion of data manipulation.
Others, including a former colleague of the named "whistleblower", John Bates, outlined at length online why the attack on NOAA was flawed. Another report found NOAA's data closely matched other major agencies.
"This time you've seen a very rapid and concerted pushback against the disinformation and misinformation," said Professor Mann, who is on an Australian speaking tour including with the Sydney Environment Institute.

The world is moving closer to catastrophic peril, scientists say
Scientists have moved the hands of their metaphorical 'Doomsday' clock closer to midnight, warning of the increasing threats of nuclear weapons and climate change.

Such a response, though, may become more difficult in the US if new President Donald Trump and his advisers followed up on early signs they would be far more anti-science than the previous Republican president George W. Bush.
"What's different is the total antipathy towards both science and the environment that we see in the incoming administration," he said. "It takes courage to stand up when you have the biggest bully of them all with the pulpit of the White House. threatening scientists with findings he doesn't like."
Professor Mann, a pugnacious 51-year-old who has fronted numerous congressional hearings and faced death threats, said there was little point trying to break through "the politically partisan filter" in which about one-quarter to one-third of Americans screened out the reality and threat of human-triggered global warming.
"No amount of facts or evidence is going to change their views because fundamentally it comes from a place of ideology," he said. On the other hand, efforts should be directed to those who were genuinely confused by the debate stirred up by sceptics but who still had open minds.
One outcome of the attacks on science, though, was that scientists were more reluctant to speak out about the seriousness of the risks, or accepted censorship from state or federal governments in the thrall of vested interests, such as the fossil fuel industry.
"We have to resist them because otherwise the forces of denial prevail, and it grants them success in this effort to cow any voices they don't like into submission," he said.
Among the reasons for optimism were the growth of corporate technology giants, such as Google and Tesla, that increasingly underpin the US and wider economy.
"If you give into the pessimism and gloom too early, you don't have the chance to prevail in the end," Professor Mann said.

Links

Why Coal-Fired Power Handouts Would Be An Attack On Climate And Common Sense

The Guardian - 

The evidence suggests the push for government help is an attempt to squeeze money out of unwise investments made at the end of the mining boom
According to the International Energy Agency, OECD countries such as Australia need to shut down almost all of their coal-fired power stations by about 2035. Photograph: Dan Himbrechts/AAP
The recent coordinated push for new coal-powered electricity generators in Australia comes as the industry is on its last legs.
The intensified push for government handouts can be seen as a last-ditch attempt for the coal industry to squeeze some money out of the unwise investments it made at the end of the mining boom.
Here are the facts and figures that point towards that conclusion.
Australia joined 174 countries and the European Union in 2015, signing the Paris agreement. In doing so, Australia agreed to do its part in keeping the global temperature rise “well below” 2C.
It also commits countries to achieving net-zero emissions “in the second half of this century”.
That agreement, designed to stop runaway climate change, requires that all of Australia’s coal-fired generators close.
According to the International Energy Agency, OECD countries such as Australia need to shut down almost all of their coal-fired power stations by about 2035.
And the rest of the world will need to phase out coal power by 2050, it says.

With coal-fired power stations taking up to a decade to build, and designed to last 30 or 40 years, building new ones now is obviously inconsistent with those commitments.
In particular, Australia has committed to reducing its emissions by 26% below 2005 levels by 2030 – a commitment that is not strong enough to limit global warming at 2C and will need to be “ratcheted up”.
But the Australian government recently released projections of the country’s carbon emissions showing that current policies are going to cause emissions to rise to 2030, not drop, leaving Australia overshooting that commitment by a long way.

In producing those projections, the Department of Environment and Energy assumed that 2,000MW of coal capacity would retire between 2020 and 2030, and that the generation would be taken up by existing coal and some gas. (That’s equivalent to about two large power stations.)
If, instead, even more coal is built, the already rising emissions would get even worse.

Demand for coal for electricity has been dropping
Meanwhile, even before coal generators begin to close, the demand for their power has been dropping as renewables enter the mix.
According to data from the Office of the Chief Economist, the demand for coal-generated electricity has dropped by more than 15% in the past eight years.

Moreover, New South Wales budget papers show that the state government has recently downgraded its projections for domestic consumption by a whopping 20%.
Last year it estimated domestic consumption would be 30m tonnes a year for the next five years. This year it changed that estimate to just 24m tonnes each year.
In response to the new figures, the NSW Greens’ energy spokesman, Jeremy Buckingham, said: “Coal power has been in decline for nearly a decade and it is clear that no one is going to build a new coal-fired power station anywhere in Australia.
“Coal is the whale oil of the 21st century and should be phased out as rapidly as possible for the sake of the climate.”

New coal is the most expensive form of energy
While the proponents of coal talk about coal power being “cheap and reliable”, they are wrong on both fronts.
Coal is now the most expensive form of new power.
According to Bloomberg New Energy Finance, the cost of energy from a new coal power plant would be $134-$203/MWh.
That’s more expensive than wind, solar or highly efficient combined-cycle gas (costing $61-$118/MWh, $78-$140/MWh and $74-$90/MWh, respectively).
Levelised cost of new energy sources in Australia in 2017. (AUD/MWh) Photograph: Bloomberg New Energy Finance
Coal is not ‘reliable’ anymore
Whether or not an energy source is “reliable” depends on what you’re relying on it for.
The only people who still think we need the old-fashioned sort of “baseload power” that coal provides – power that is always running regardless of whether you need it – are those in the coal industry.
Coal power stations are slow to start up and so can’t respond efficiently to fluctuations in supply and demand.
Old energy systems were built assuming coal would always be running. It was the “baseload” energy and other forms of energy such as gas would switch on to satisfy the peaks in demand.
In a world where wind and solar energy can produce a lot of energy, but not constantly, baseload needs to be replaced with flexible power that can smooth out the spiky energy supply created by variable sources of renewable energy.
In the short term, that can be gas. But, in the longer term, to stop runaway climate change, that service will need to be supplied by renewable sources such as battery storage, hydro, solar thermal with storage or geothermal.
When competing with renewables, coal generators end up burning costly fuel, even when they are giving the electricity away for free.
Leonard Quong from Bloomberg New Energy Finance said when releasing a recent report: “In the grid of the not-too-distant future coal’s baseload operation becomes a curse, not a blessing.”
And Steven Holliday, the chief executive of the UK’s National Grid, recently said: “The idea of baseload power is already outdated.”

The coalmining industry has a backlog of projects it can’t get off the ground
According to the Office of the Chief Economist’s most recent Resources and Energy Major Projects Report, there are 37 major coalmining projects that are currently in the works.
However, that number has dropped since the last report a year ago and, in that time, no new projects have moved from along the pipeline from being “committed” to “completed”.
If all the projects still listed as being actively pursued were to reach completion, they would produce almost 300m tonnes of coal each year.
Adam Walters from Energy & Resource Insights said that list is a “salient reminder, if one is needed, that vast amounts of proposed new coal capacity, much with most approvals in place, remains waiting for a favourable market”.
He said most of those projects were begun during the mining boom, when commodity prices were high. With prices depressed, they’ve stayed on the books but are not progressing.
The push for rejuvenating the coal industry with government subsidies is the sort of thing that could help the industry get some of these projects back on track, Walters said.
The global coal industry recently saw its biggest player, Peabody, go bankrupt in the US. If companies are forced to take write-downs for these projects by admitting they will never go ahead, it could mean the end for some of the companies.
At his National Press Club address last week, Malcolm Turnbull appeared to point to this as the reason he is now looking to subsidise the most expensive and dirtiest form of energy, saying that it could help our mining industry. He said: “As the world’s largest coal exporter, we have a vested interest in showing that we can provide both lower emissions and reliable baseload power with state-of-the-art, clean, coal-fired technology.”

Links

Wednesday, February 08, 2017

Australia's Chief Scientist Compares Trump To Stalin Over Climate Censorship

The Guardian - 

Alan Finkel warns that forcing EPA data to undergo political review before publication will ‘cause long-term harm’
Dr Alan Finkel, Australia’s chief scientist, has urged his colleagues in the US to remain ‘frank and fearless’ even though science is ‘literally under attack’. Photograph: Mike Bowers for the Guardian 
Australia’s chief scientist has slammed Donald Trump’s attempt to censor environmental data, saying the US president’s behaviour was comparable to the manipulation of science by the Soviet Union.
Speaking at a scientific roundtable in Canberra on Monday, Alan Finkel warned science was “literally under attack” in the United States and urged his colleagues to keep giving “frank and fearless” advice despite the political opposition.
“The Trump administration has mandated that scientific data published by the United States Environmental Protection Agency from last week going forward has to undergo review by political appointees before that data can be published on the EPA website or elsewhere,” he said.
“It defies logic. It will almost certainly cause long-term harm. It’s reminiscent of the censorship exerted by political officers in the old Soviet Union.
“Every military commander there had a political officer second-guessing his decisions.”
Last month Trump’s administration mandated that any studies or data from scientists at the EPA undergo review by political appointees before they can be released to the public.
The communications director for Trump’s transition team at the EPA, Doug Ericksen, said the review also extended to content on the federal agency’s website, including details of scientific evidence showing the Earth’s climate was warming and human-induced carbon emissions were to blame.
Finkel compared the Trump administration’s attempt to censor science to the behaviour of Soviet dictator Josef Stalin.
“Soviet agricultural science was held back for decades because of the ideology of Trofim Lysenko, who was a proponent of Lamarckism,” he said.
“Stalin loved Lysenko’s conflation of science and Soviet philosophy and used his limitless power to ensure that Lysenko’s unscientific ideas prevailed.
“Lysenko believed that successive generations of crops could be improved by exposing them to the right environment, and so too could successive generations of soviet citizens be improved by exposing them to the right ideology.
“So while Western scientists embraced evolution and genetics, Russian scientists who thought the same were sent to the gulag. Western crops flourished. Russian crops failed.
“Today, the catch-cry of scientists must be frank and fearless advice, no matter the opinion of political commissars stationed at the US EPA,” he said.
A day after the EPA was told to limit its public communications, the White House press secretary, Sean Spicer, added a layer of confusion to reports that the Trump administration had directed the communications crackdown.
“That’s nothing that’s coming from the White House,” he told the press during his daily briefing. “They haven’t been directed by us to do anything.”
But his comments were at odds with statements made by Ericksen, who said the Trump administration was scrutinising studies or data published by scientists at the EPA, and new work was under a “temporary hold” before it could be released.
Finkel was appointed chief scientist by Malcolm Turnbull, replacing former chief scientist Prof Ian Chubb in December.


Links

Meet The 16yo Suing The US Government Over Climate Change

ABC triplej


Xiuhtezcatl Martinez was about eight years old when the fracking boom came to his home state of Colorado. He had grown up outdoors, and his favourite game was hunting frogs and snakes with his dad.
"I didn't really go to school, I just spent a bunch of time in nature," he told Hack.
"As soon as I began to educate myself about climate change, I saw that the world I was in love with was falling apart."

Eight years later, Colorado has more than 50,000 fracking wells, and 16-year-old Xiuhtezcatl (pronounced shooTEZcat) is a superstar activist, currently visiting Australia.
He has addressed the United Nations, and is one of a group of young people suing the US Government over lack of action on climate change.
An application to dismiss the case was denied last year, and the lawyers now plan to take it to the federal court in the coming months.
"We do not have time to waste, we do not have time to push this back," he said.
"We've been to court twice now. The first two times the fossil fuel companies and the US Government said we don't have a right to file this lawsuit.
"But [the court] denied the motion to dismiss. Twenty-one young people overcame a multi-billion-dollar industry and one of the most powerful governments in the world.
The youngest of the plaintiffs is eight years old. The case rests on the legal argument that climate change is so catastrophic to their future, that it threatens their fundamental constitutional right to life and liberty.
A ruling in their favour could be a landmark decision. It also comes as US President Donald Trump is looking to roll back US policy on reducing greenhouse emissions, including promoting the coal industry and quitting the Paris Climate Agreement signed only last year.
"Donald Trump threatens a lot of the action that has been taken over the last four to eight years. But I really don't believe he is going to go through with all these things.
I hope that everything that Trump stands for is going to push people to fight harder than ever to resist."
'Transition to solar, wind, hydro'
Xiuhtezcatl was raised as Indigenous Meshika, of the Aztec people of Mexico City. By age 12, he had organized more than 35 rallies and protests. At 13, he and his younger brother, Itzcuauhtli, were invited to talk about fracking at a middle school in Colorado. They performed the song 'What the Frack' and spoke about methane leaking from wells and poisoning groundwater. Their appearance sparked a counter protest by oil and gas industry activists, who called the Martinez home with threats.
It did not stop Xiuhtezcatl. He is now youth director of Earth Guardians, a worldwide organisation that rallies together young activists and musicians in the fight against climate change. In 2013, President Obama gave him a national community service award. In 2015, in a borrowed suit, he addressed the UN on environmental policy and the future of his generation.
His brother, Itzcuauhtli, has followed in his foot steps. In 2014, aged 11, Itzcuauhtli took a vow of silence to inspire others to speak up about climate change. For 45 days he didn't speak - communicating in sign and via a portable whiteboard.
"Young people have a huge responsibility to be a part of creating solutions. If we look at just the problems it's going to disempower people and make them hopeless," Xiuhtezcatl said.
"A reason I do what I do is to empower young leaders. I don't want to be the only one."
One solution that Xiuhtezcatl offers is redirecting subsidies for fossil fuel companies into renewables like solar, wind and hydro. He says the right combination of existing renewables technology could easily produce enough stable baseload power.
He's sure that shale gas fracking is not a solution to reducing emissions, partly because the wells leak too much methane - a greenhouse gas that is many times more potent than carbon dioxide.
"Shale gas is actually more harmful to the climate," he said.
"We're producing energy the same way as we were 50 years ago, and the entire world is using more and more energy.
"We are going to burn out the earth's resources and cause irreversible damage if we don't transition."

Links

'Horrible Time': CSIRO Climate Science Proves Its Worth One Year After Deep Cuts

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

Climate science at the CSIRO is bouncing back one year after executives modelled its demise, securing new revenue streams in the Pacific and China, and looking to hire new staff.
On February 4 last year, chief executive Larry Marshall shocked staff in the country's premier research body by stating that because the question of whether the climate was changing "has been answered", it was time to deploy resources elsewhere.

The world is moving closer to catastrophic peril, scientists say
Scientists have moved the hands of their metaphorical 'Doomsday' clock closer to midnight, warning of the increasing threats of nuclear weapons and climate change.


At the time as many as 110 of the 140 staff in the Oceans & Atmosphere unit were considered for the axe as part of broader cuts of 350.
Amid a realisation that other agencies – from NASA to the Australian Antarctic Division – depended on CSIRO colleagues and couldn't be easily cut, and a public uproar at home and abroad, the number of redundancies was whittled back.
The number of climate science cuts eventually shrank to 29 and "the net headcount has increased over the past six months", a CSIRO spokesman told Fairfax Media.
Some of the fresh jobs will come at the Climate Science Centre, a new body backed with long-term funding by the Turnbull government. Helen Cleugh, an atmospheric researcher, will take over as its first director on February 13.
The O&A unit is also expected to beat its revenue targets this year, despite the disruption. These include CSIRO winning a contract from the multi-billion dollar Green Climate Fund for a project in Vanuatu.
CSIRO in December also signed a deal with the Qingdao National Laboratory for Marine Science to establish the Centre for Southern Hemisphere Ocean Research.
Warming world: Proposed CSIRO climate cuts drew international rebukes. Photo: NASA
That will form part of the new Climate Science Centre, and involves the Chinese counterpart providing $2 million annually for five years with co-investment by CSIRO, the University of NSW and University of Tasmania, according to an email to staff.
"We are coming out of a horrible time," a senior scientist said, request anonymity. "With a lot more requirement, morale is starting to recover."
Locked in: Long-run funding has now been set aside by CSIRO chief Larry Marshall. Photo: Josh Robenstone
'Overshoot'
Management ranks, though, remain unstable. Alex Wonhas, the head of the energy and environment who managed to salvage many of the proposed jobs, left CSIRO to join global engineering firm Aurecon last month.
"I plan to continue to follow my passion of growing the sustainability and prosperity of our nation," Dr Wonhas told staff in a farewell email.
The search also continues for a new head of O&A after recruitment efforts failed to find a replacement for Ken Lee. Dr Lee, a Canadian oil spill expert, was revealed in private emails released to a Senate inquiry to have sought even deeper cuts - "let's overshoot first" - than were being asked for.
His email was in response to one from Andreas Schiller, then O&A's deputy director of oceans and atmosphere, who suggested CSIRO make a "clean cut" to get rid of "public good/government-funded climate research". Dr Schiller remains acting head of the division.
A spokesman for new industry minister, Arthur Sinodinos, said the cuts were "operational decisions of the organisation", and he supports arrangements now in place.
"The Minister is fully supportive of the science of climate change, and always has been," the spokesman said.

Lifeline
Kim Carr, Labor's industry spokesman, said CSIRO had "subjected to unnecessary upheaval and anxiety" over the past year after it was already reeling from $115 million slashed from funding in the first Abbott government budget.
"Although climate research was thrown a lifeline after global protest, other CSIRO staff were not so lucky," Senator Carr said. "Researchers in the Manufacturing division, Land & Water division and the newly created Data61 have all lost their jobs."
President Donald Trump is set to unleash a much broader assault on science in the US and Australia should ramp up spending to offer "professional refuge to the best climate scientists", a spokesman for Greens senator Peter Whish-Wilson.
"It is critical that the world keeps investing in climate science so we don't face the future blindfolded," he said. "It is in Australia's and the international community's interest to offer US climate scientists jobs elsewhere - let us lead by example and send a strong message."

Links

        Tuesday, February 07, 2017

        Meet El Niño’s Cranky Uncle That Could Send Global Warming Into Hyperdrive

        The Conversation -  |  |  |  |  | 

        Firefighters fight forest fire in Indonesia, triggered in part by El Nino. EPA/RONY MUHARRMAN
        You’ve probably heard about El Niño, the climate system that brings dry and often hotter weather to Australia over summer.
        You might also know that climate change is likely to intensify drought conditions, which is one of the reasons climate scientists keep talking about the desperate need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and the damaging consequences if we don’t.
        El Niño is driven by changes in the Pacific Ocean, and shifts around with its opposite, La Niña, every 2-7 years, in a cycle known as the El Niño Southern Oscillation or ENSO.
        But that’s only part of the story. There’s another important piece of nature’s puzzle in the Pacific Ocean that isn’t often discussed.
        It’s called the Interdecadal Pacific Oscillation, or IPO, a name coined by a study which examined how Australia’s rainfall, temperature, river flow and crop yields changed over decades.
        Since El Niño means “the boy” in Spanish, and La Niña “the girl”, we could call the warm phase of the IPO “El Tío” (the uncle) and the negative phase “La Tía” (the auntie).
        These erratic relatives are hard to predict. El Tío and La Tía phases have been compared to a stumbling drunk. And honestly, can anyone predict what a drunk uncle will say at a family gathering?

        What is El Tío?
        Like ENSO, the IPO is related to the movement of warm water around the Pacific Ocean. Begrudgingly, it shifts its enormous backside around the great Pacific bathtub every 10-30 years, much longer than the 2-7 years of ENSO.
        The IPO’s pattern is similar to ENSO, which has led climate scientists to think that the two are strongly linked. But the IPO operates on much longer timescales.
        We don’t yet have conclusive knowledge of whether the IPO is a specific climate mechanism, and there is a strong school of thought which proposes that it is a combination of several different mechanisms in the ocean and the atmosphere.
        Despite these mysteries, we know that the IPO had an influence on the global warming “hiatus” - the apparent slowdown in global temperature increases over the early 2000s.

        Global temperatures are on the up, but the IPO affects the rate of warming. Author provided, data from NOAA, adapted from England et al. (2014) Nat. Clim. Change
        Temperamental relatives
        When it comes to global temperatures we know that our greenhouse gas emissions since the industrial revolution are the primary driver of the strong warming of the planet. But how do El Tío and La Tía affect our weather and climate from year to year and decade to decade?
        Superimposed on top of the familiar long-term rise in global temperatures are some natural bumps in the road. When you’re hiking up a massive mountain, there are a few dips and hills along the way.
        Several recent studies have shown that the IPO phases, El Tío and La Tía, have a temporary warming and cooling influence on the planet.
        Rainfall around the world is also affected by El Tío and La Tía, including impacts such as floods and drought in the United States, China, Australia and New Zealand.
        In the negative phase of the IPO (La Tía) the surface temperatures of the Pacific Ocean are cooler than usual near the equator and warmer than usual away from the equator.
        Since about the year 2000, some of the excess heat trapped by greenhouse gases has been getting buried in the deep Pacific Ocean, leading to a slowdown in global warming over about the last 15 years. It appears as though we have a kind auntie, La Tía perhaps, who has been cushioning the blow of global warming. For the time being, anyway.
        The flip side of our kind auntie is our bad-tempered uncle, El Tío. He is partly responsible for periods of accelerated warming, like the period from the late 1970s to the late 1990s.
        The IPO has been in its “kind auntie” phase for well over a decade now. But the IPO could be about to flip over to El Tío. If that happens, it is not good news for global temperatures – they will accelerate upwards.

        Models getting better
        One of the challenges to climate science is to understand how the next decade, and the next couple of decades, will unravel. The people who look after our water and our environment want to know things like how fast our planet will warm in the next 10 years, and whether we will have major droughts and floods.
        To do this we can use computer models of Earth’s climate. In our recently published paper in Environmental Research Letters, we evaluated how well a large number of models from around the world simulate the IPO. We found that the models do surprisingly well on some points, but don’t quite simulate the same degree of slow movement (the stubborn behaviour) of El Tío and La Tía that we observe in the real world.
        But some climate models are better at simulating El Tío and La Tía. This is useful because it points the way to better models that could be used to understand the next few decades of El Tío, La Tía and climate change.
        However, more work needs to be done to predict the next shift in the IPO and climate change. This is the topic of a new set of experiments that are going to be part the next round of climate model comparisons.
        With further model development and new observations of the deep ocean available since 2005, scientists will be able to more easily answer some of these important questions.
        Whatever the case, cranky old El Tío is waiting just around the corner. His big stick is poised, ready to give us a massive hiding: a swift rise in global temperatures over the coming decades.
        And like a big smack, that would be no laughing matter.

        Links

        Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative