Tuesday, March 14, 2017

'Clean Coal' Is A Con And It's Costing Us Lives

Huffington Post - Helen Szoke

This renewed debate, where scant word has been uttered on the inextricable links between coal, climate change and poverty, is maddening.
There is no such thing as clean coal. Ashley Cooper via Getty Images
There's been a lot of energy invested this year in a debate over so-called "clean coal" and Australia's electricity supplies.
Recently, Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull took to social media to promise to "keep the lights on" and the power bills paid,scant declaring "all forms of generation" have a role to play in our energy sector. A couple of weeks earlier, Treasurer Scott Morrison was waving around a piece of coal in Parliament before it was passed around like a plaything.
Meanwhile, residents in South Australia, New South Wales and Queensland have just sweltered through a summer of unrelenting, record-breaking temperatures.
Further afield in the Pacific, our Fijian neighbours have marked the one-year anniversary of Cyclone Winston unleashing its devastating fury on the island nation.
The biggest cyclone in Fiji's history, Winston left a trail of destruction, from which communities are still recovering today.
Tragically, Winston killed 44 people, wiped out whole villages, destroyed an estimated 32,000 houses and left 50,000 people in need of shelter. In dollar terms, the damage bill amounted to one fifth of Fiji's gross domestic product.
The reality is coal is not some benign plaything to be used as a prop for a headline-grabbing stunt in our Federal Parliament.
This is what's missing from the current energy debate. The devastation that climate change is causing, and will continue to cause, if we do not curb the use of coal -- the burning of which is the single greatest contributor to climate change.
The reality is coal is not some benign plaything to be used as a prop for a headline-grabbing stunt in our Federal Parliament. It is also no longer the cheapest way to ensure our power bills can be paid.
In Oxfam's work around the world, we know that climate change is not only a driver of record temperatures and increasingly ferocious cyclones, but is also pushing more and more people into deeper poverty. The increasing risk of droughts, floods, hunger and disease caused by climate change is most heavily weighing on the world's most vulnerable communities.
Climate change could drive a staggering 122 million more people into extreme poverty by 2030.
It is already undermining people's ability to feed themselves. Globally, crop yields are likely to decline by 2 percent a decade from the 2030s. Compared to a world without climate change, there could be 25 million more malnourished children under the age of five by 2050 -- 20 times the number of children aged under five in Australia.
Instead of setting about building a smart, clean, reliable and low-cost electricity system, the Australian Government has misled the public about the causes of blackouts and electricity price rises, moved away from renewable energy, and promoted the false promise of "clean coal".
But instead of setting about building a smart, clean, reliable and low-cost electricity system, the Australian Government has misled the public about the causes of blackouts and electricity price rises, moved away from renewable energy, and promoted the false promise of "clean coal". Labor leader Bill Shorten has re-affirmed Labor's commitment to 50 percent renewables by 2030 -- which is certainly a welcome step in the right direction, but it's still short of what is needed.
There is no such thing as clean coal. Limiting the global average temperature rise to 1.5°C, as we and all nations committed to strive towards under the Paris Agreement, means there is simply no room for new coal.
The solution is clear -- to help limit warming to 1.5°C, Australia must move towards 100 percent renewable energy. We must reach zero carbon pollution well before mid-century.
While Australia engages in a time-wasting debate, other nations across the globe -- including our closest neighbours -- grapple with the devastating impacts of climate change and move towards renewable energy at a pace that is leaving our country far behind.
Renewable energy sources are now cheaper than coal, even before we take into account coal's cost in terms of carbon pollution. What's more, renewable energy sources are far better placed to help bring electricity to those in poor countries who currently live without it. Even one of the country's major energy generators has questioned the viability of any more "efficient" coal power stations being built in Australia.
Federal Treasurer Scott Morrison brings a lump of coal to Question Time. Fairfax
Developing countries, often the least responsible for climate change and those left to deal with the consequences, are leading the charge against coal and fossil fuels.
At the Marrakech Climate Change Conference last year, the 48 members of the Climate Vulnerable Forum -- the body for the most vulnerable countries to climate change -- committed to strive for 100 percent renewable energy as soon as possible, and at the latest by 2030 to 2050.
In 2011, global investment in renewable energy surpassed investment in fossil fuels. In 2013, the world began adding more new power from renewable energy sources than from coal, oil and gas combined. And as of 2015, the world has more installed capacity to generate electricity from renewables than from coal.
Pacific island governments, including Fiji -- which will chair the next round of international climate negotiations -- have repeatedly called for a moratorium on the development of new coalmines and are leading by example with ambitious renewable energy plans. But here in Australia -- a country fortunate to have some of the world's most promising renewable energy potential -- the frustrating debate over coal continues.
This renewed debate, where scant word has been uttered on the inextricable links between coal, climate change and poverty, is maddedevelning.
Developing countries, often the least responsible for climate change and those left to deal with the consequences, are leading the charge against coal and fossil fuels.
I have visited some of our neighbouring countries in the Pacific, where communities are being hit hardest by climate change. Where the people who can least afford it are being forced to adapt as their land is swallowed up and to rebuild in the face of extreme weather events.
In the wake of Cyclone Winston, Oxfam worked with our team in Fiji to deliver vital clean drinking water, sanitation supplies and shelter to those who had been left in dire need. The sobering reality is that if climate change is not addressed, Australia will be called on to respond to more devastating emergencies caused by extreme weather, both here in Australia and abroad.
Fijian leaders used the recent anniversary of Winston's destruction to make an impassioned plea for global action on climate change. It's time for Australia to heed this call and make a radical shift in its utterly out-of-step stance -- a position that is against our own interests and at odds with our commitments under the Paris Agreement.
We must reject the "clean coal" con; lives are at stake.

Links

The World’s Oceans Are Storing Up Staggering Amounts Of Heat — And It’s Even More Than We Thought

Washington Post - Chelsea Harvey

A diver films a reef affected by bleaching off Lizard Island in the Great Barrier Reef. (XL Catlin Seaview Survey via AFP/Getty Images)
The world is getting warmer every year, thanks to climate change — but where exactly most of that heat is going may be a surprise.
As a stunning early spring blooms across the United States, just weeks after scientists declared 2016 the hottest year on record, it’s easy to forget that all the extra warmth in the air accounts for only a fraction of the heat produced by greenhouse gas emissions. In fact, more than 90 percent of it gets stored in the ocean. And now, scientists think they’ve calculated just how much the ocean has warmed in the past few decades.
A new study, out Friday in the journal Science Advances, suggests that since 1960, a staggering 337 zetajoules of energy — that’s 337 followed by 21 zeros  — has been added to the ocean in the form of heat. And most of it has occurred since 1980.
“The ocean is the memory of all of the past climate change,” said study co-author Kevin Trenberth, a senior scientist at the National Center for Atmospheric Research.
The new value is a number that significantly exceeds previous estimates, Trenberth noted. Compared with ocean warming estimates produced by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the new values are about 13 percent greater. This is the result of a new methodology for estimating ocean warming, involving a series of steps “that really make this paper different than previous ones,” Trenberth told The Washington Post.
In previous decades, there have been a lot of challenges associated with monitoring temperature changes in the ocean. Before the year 2000 or so, most monitoring instruments had to be deployed from ships. This mean that scientists only had the most reliable data for parts of the world that lie along major shipping routes.
In the past 15 years, though, scientists have developed the “Argo” network, a system of free-drifting devices that are designed to periodically adjust their buoyancy, so they can sink several thousand meters into the sea, collect measurements, and then rise back up to the surface. There are now about 3,500 of these devices deployed throughout the world’s oceans, leading to a much better dispersal of observations.
The new study, which was led by Lijing Cheng of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and included other scientists from that institution, from the National Center for Atmospheric Research, and from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, employs a new methodology for using both the recent Argo measurements and past observations from ships to produce a continuous series of estimates from 1960 to 2015.
The scientists incorporated an updated database of pre-Argo measurements that have been corrected for certain biases, as well as information from climate models, and extended existing observations of ocean conditions taken at specific locations to larger areas of the sea. They then conducted a comparison of recent Argo data with measurements created using their new methodology and found that the method produces true-to-life results.
The results suggest that the ocean has been sucking up more heat than previous research has indicated. In fact, according to Trenberth, the new estimates help explain observations of global sea-level rise that scientists have had difficulty accounting for until now.
A certain percentage of sea-level rise can be attributed to the expansion of ocean water, caused by rising water temperatures, while the rest comes from melting glaciers. Scientists have good estimates of how much melting ice is going into the ocean, but they’ve come up a bit short in the past in trying to reconcile the rest of the planet’s observed sea-level rise with their estimates of how much the ocean has warmed in recent decades.
“This actually fills in the gap,” Trenberth said.
The study also suggests that the extra heat is not being stored evenly throughout the oceans. The Atlantic and Southern oceans, in particular, are the biggest new heat reservoirs, the results indicate, storing about 59 percent of the heat despite accounting for less than half of all the ocean area in the world.
The researchers think the reason has to do with a major ocean current system known as “overturning circulation.” This system is kind of like a giant ocean conveyor belt that runs warm water from the equator toward the poles, where it cools, sinks to the bottom of the oceans and flows back in the other direction. The system helps transport both heat around the world, and the overturning process is pronounced in both the Atlantic and Southern ocean waters.
While the paper’s staggering new results reaffirm the importance of the ocean as a climate change buffer — without it, much of that heat would remain in the atmosphere or the earth’s land masses — it’s certainly not without consequences. Rising ocean temperatures are believed to be a major cause of the mass coral bleaching that’s occurred all over the world over the past several years, in conjunction with an unusually strong El NiƱo beginning in 2015.
It’s still unclear how other organisms might be affected, but many marine animals thrive best within specific temperature ranges. Many marine biologists believe that continued warming, along with other climate-related changes such as ocean acidification, may force certain species to migrate to cooler or deeper areas in the future.
Trenberth added that increasing heat moving into the surface of the ocean could also lead to “dead spots” in the ocean — places where layers of warm water get stuck on top of layers of cooler water. When this stratification happens, it can become more difficult for the waters to mix and churn as they normally would, a process that helps stir up nutrients and oxygen that are vital to marine organisms.
All this is to say that climate change affects far more than just our air temperature — and the new study documents its clear progression in places thousands of meters below the surface of the sea. The results also come at a sensitive point for ocean and climate research, just a week after The Washington Post revealed a proposal from the Trump administration that calls for significant budget cuts for the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, including a 26 percent cut for its Office of Oceanic and Atmospheric Research. It’s the primary research arm of NOAA, Trenberth pointed out, and such drastic cuts to the program could mean even basic observations programs like Argo may no longer continue.
“As a result, the information will not even be there,” Trenberth said. “That would be tragic.”

Links

Curbing Climate Change Has A Dollar Value — Here’s How And Why We Measure It

The Conversation - 

Coal train in Missouri. Assigning a social cost to carbon emissions puts a price on activities that generate them, such as burning fossil fuels. Scott Granneman/Flickr, CC BY-SA
President Trump is expected to issue an executive order soon to reverse Obama-era rules to cut carbon pollution, including a moratorium on leasing public lands for coal mining and a plan to reduce carbon emissions from power plants.
Trump and his appointees argue that these steps will bring coal miners’ jobs back (although coal industry job losses reflect competition from cheap natural gas, not regulations that have yet to take effect). But they ignore the fact that mitigating climate change will produce large economic gains.
While burning fossil fuels produces benefits, such as powering the electric grid and fueling cars, it also generates widespread costs to society – including damages from climate change that affect people around the world now and in the future. Public policies that reduce carbon pollution deliver benefits by avoiding these damages.
Since the Reagan administration, federal agencies have been required to enact only regulations whose potential benefits to society justify or outweigh their potential costs. To quantify benefits from acting to curb climate change, the U.S. government developed a formal measure in 2009 of the value of reducing carbon pollution, which is referred to as the social cost of carbon, or SCC. Currently, federal agencies use an SCC figure of about US$40 per ton in today’s dollars.
Now the Trump administration and critics in Congress may reduce this figure or even stop using it. EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt’s recent comment that carbon dioxide is not “a primary contributor” to climate change suggests that Pruitt may challenge the agency’s 2009 finding that carbon emissions are pollutants and threaten human health.
As an economist for the White House, I was a member of the working group that developed the first government-wide SCC estimate. We can always improve our processes for estimating and using the SCC, but getting rid of it would be a mistake. A well-functioning democracy needs transparency about the economic benefits of investments driven by public policy – as well as the benefits we give up when we walk away from making these investments.
As a result of human activities since the Industrial Revolution, carbon dioxide levels have increased to 400 parts per million, higher than any time in at least the last one million years. US Global Change Research Program

The value of avoiding hurricanes and wildfires
Scientists widely agree that carbon dioxide emissions, primarily from burning fossil fuels, pose significant risks to Earth’s climate. Intuitively, it makes sense that reducing carbon emissions benefits society by reducing risks of flooding, wildfires, storms and other impacts associated with severe climate change.
We can estimate the benefits of many goods and services, from pop music to recreation, from the prices people pay for them in markets. But valuing environmental benefits is not so simple. Americans can’t go to the store and buy a stable climate.
Carbon pollution drives global warming that causes many different impacts on the natural and built environment and human health. Because carbon emissions have such broad and diverse impacts, scholars have developed models to characterize the economic benefits (or costs) of reducing them.
Current U.S. government practice draws from three peer-reviewed integrated assessment models. An integrated assessment model represents a chain of events, starting with economic activities that involve fossil fuel combustion. This generates carbon emissions, which contribute to climate change.
And climate change causes outcomes that can be measured in monetary terms. For example, rising carbon pollution will increase the likelihood of lower agricultural yields, threaten public health through heat stress and damage infrastructure through floods and intense storms.
Flooding in Hoboken, New Jersey after Superstorm Sandy in 2012. Climate change is predicted to increase the frequency and severity of coastal storms. acarrino/Flickr, CC BY-ND

Thousands of scenarios
The social cost of carbon represents the damages of one ton of carbon dioxide emitted into the air. To estimate it, economists run models that forecast varying levels of carbon dioxide emissions. They can then model and compare two forecasts – one with slightly higher emissions than the other. The difference in total climate change damages represents the social cost of carbon.
Carbon pollution can remain in the atmosphere for up to 200 years, so these models are run over a century or more in order to account for long-term damages that carbon emissions impose on society.
SCC estimates are based on chains of events that include many uncertainties – for example, how many tons of carbon will be emitted in a given year, the amount of warming that will result, and how severely this warming will exacerbate risks like floods and heat waves. Since we cannot predict any single scenario with certainty, the U.S. government has modeled hundreds of thousands of different scenarios to produce its SCC estimates.
Some model scenarios, based on admittedly extreme assumptions, produce negative SCC estimates – that is, they find that carbon pollution is good for the planet. But the vast majority of scenarios show that carbon pollution is bad for the planet, and that on average, every ton of carbon dioxide emitted into the atmosphere imposes damages equal to about $40 in today’s dollars.

Balancing costs and benefits of regulations
The federal government began calculating a social cost of carbon after the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled in 2007 that the Department of Transportation had to account for climate benefits from its regulations to improve automobile fuel economy. Environmental groups and a dozen states challenged the regulations, in part because the Bush administration had valued the benefits of cutting carbon dioxide emissions at zero.
In response, the Obama administration created a working group in 2009 with officials from 12 agencies to develop the federal government’s first official SCC estimate. Our initial figure of $25 for 2010 was updated in 2013, 2015 and 2016, reflecting updates in the underlying models.
Agencies have used these estimates in benefit-cost analyses for scores of federal regulations, including the Environmental Protection Agency’s Clean Power Plan, the Department of Transportation’s medium and heavy-duty vehicle fuel economy standards, and the Department of Energy’s minimum efficiency standard for refrigerators and freezers. Some of these studies were required only by executive order, but others were required by law. Unless the authorizing statutes are amended, the Trump administration will have to produce analyses accounting for carbon pollution reduction benefits if it wants to issue new regulations that can withstand legal challenges.
Fuel economy label for gasoline-powered vehicle. Federal agencies have have factored the social cost of carbon into regulations governing vehicle fuel economy and other issues. www.fueleconomy.gov
The Trump administration could continue to use SCC estimates in regulatory evaluations, but water them down. For example, some scholars have called for focusing only on domestic benefits – as opposed to total global benefits – of reducing carbon pollution in the United States. Emitting a ton of carbon imposes damages in the United States and around the world, just as a ton emitted in Beijing imposes damages on the United States and other countries around the world. Considering only the domestic impacts of carbon pollution could lower the SCC by three-quarters.
But if the United States ignores the benefits of reducing carbon pollution that other countries enjoy, then those other countries may follow suit and consider only how cutting emissions will benefit them internally. This approach ignores the strategic value that serves as the primary motivation for countries to work together to combat climate change. The world would achieve much greater emissions reductions and greater net economic benefits if countries implement policies based on the global social cost of carbon instead of a domestic-only SCC.
As climate change science and economics continue to evolve, our tools for estimating benefits from reducing carbon pollution will need to evolve and improve. In January the National Academies of Sciences published a report that lays out an extensive research agenda for improving the estimation and use of the social cost of carbon.
The federal government has used used benefit-cost analysis to calculate society’s bottom line from regulations for decades. So far, the Trump administration appears to be focused solely on costs – an approach that maximizes the corporate bottom line, but leaves the public out of the equation.

Links

Monday, March 13, 2017

Earth's Oceans Are Warming 13% Faster Than Thought, And Accelerating

The Guardian - 

Our new study improves estimates of the rate of ocean warming - a critical component of climate change
An Argo float is deployed into the ocean Photograph: CSIRO
New research has convincingly quantified how much the Earth has warmed over the past 56 years. Human activities utilize fossil fuels for many beneficial purposes but have an undesirable side effect of adding carbon dioxide to the atmosphere at ever-increasing rates. That increase - of over 40%, with most since 1980 - traps heat in the Earth’s system, warming the entire planet.
But how fast is the Earth warming and how much will it warm in the future? Those are the critical questions we need to answer if we are going to make smart decisions on how to handle this issue.
At any time the direct effect of this blanket is small, but the accumulated effects are huge and have consequences for our weather and climate. Over 90% of the extra heat ends up in the ocean and hence perhaps the most important measurements of global warming are made in the oceans.
But measuring the ocean temperature is not straightforward. Since about 2005 a new type of sensing device has been deployed (the Argo float system). These floats (approximately 3500 in total at any time) are spread out across oceans where they autonomously rise and fall in the ocean waters, collecting temperature data to depths of 2000 meters.
When they rise to the ocean surface, they send their data wirelessly to satellites for later analysis. Hence we can now map the ocean heat content quite well. But what about the past, when we mainly had measurements from expendable bathythermographs deployed mainly along major shipping routes and largely confined to the northern hemisphere? Putting data from these various sensors together has been a struggle and has been a major impediment to an accurate quantification of the ocean’s temperature history.
Fortunately, a paper just published today in Science Advances uses a new strategy to improve upon our understanding of ocean heating to estimate the total global warming from 1960 to 2015. I was fortunate to co-author the study, which uses several innovative steps to make improvements.
First, we corrected past data for known biases in measurements. Second, we related the temperature measurements to results calculated from advanced climate computer models. Third, we applied temperature knowledge to larger areas so that a single measurement was representative of a large space around the measurement site. Finally, we used their knowledge of recent and well-observed temperatures to show that the method produced excellent results.
We were able to extend our techniques back to the late1950s and show that the rate of global warming has changed significantly in the past 60 years. One main outcome of the study is that it shows we are warming about 13% faster than we previously thought. Not only that but the warming has accelerated. The warming rate from 1992 is almost twice as great as the warming rate from 1960. Moreover, it is only since about 1990 that the warming has penetrated to depths below about 700 meters.
Prior work by the same team compared climate models to measurements, and there was excellent agreement on average. There are a few other more subtle issues that the new paper addresses. For example, the study shows that a large amount of warming occurred in the southern oceans. Only recently have the Atlantic and Indian Oceans began to heat up.

Lead author, Lijing Cheng says:
Drs. Lijing Cheng and Kevin Trenberth, September 2016 in Qing Dao China at the CLIVAR Conference. 
We know that ocean observations were very sparse until the Argo era. There were major gaps in data, particularly in the Southern Hemisphere. Our challenge was to assess the changes to global ocean heat and fill data gaps. A major issue is to ensure gap-filling is reliable. It is this issue that motivated the study. We proposed an advance gap-filling strategy and used it to attain near global coverage. We rigorously evaluated the reliability of our approach and as a result, we have much higher confidence that the ocean and the Earth are warming at a faster rate than previously thought.
One of the co-authors, John Fasullo added:
This study shows that more heat is likely to have been absorbed by the oceans over the past 50 years than had previously been reported. With upward revisions in our estimates of the climate’s sensitivity to greenhouse gases and the associated resultant sea level rise.
Our team’s press release noted:
we know the oceans are much warmer now and they contain the memory of climate change. Higher sea surface temperatures are continually reinforced by the extra heat beneath the ocean surface. The oceans are affecting weather and climate through more intense rains. This process is a major reason why 2016 was the hottest year ever recorded at the Earth’s surface, beating out 2015 which was the previous record. Additionally 2015 was a year with record hurricanes, heat waves, droughts, and wild-fires around the world.
The knowledge about how the ocean has warmed, and how the warmth has spread in depth and over the different oceans is consistent with theory and models, and grounds the theories of human-induced climate change. The memory of past warming is in the oceans, and even though there are weather events that alter the details daily, the atmosphere above the oceans is warmer and moister than it used to be.
It is these changes that affect storms, such as the deluges that have recently affected California, or which have led storms to produce “thousand year floods” as has been seen in the Carolinas with Hurricane Matthew, or the Louisiana floods in August last year, or the Houston floods in April, and so forth. This kind of knowledge and understanding has profound consequences.

Links

Shell CEO Urges Switch To Clean Energy As Plans Hefty Renewable Spending

Reuters - Ron Bousso

Ben van Beurden, chief executive officer of Royal Dutch Shell, speaks during a news conference in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, February 15, 2016. REUTERS/Sergio Moraes
The oil and gas industry risks losing public support if progress is not made in the transition to cleaner energy, Royal Dutch Shell Plc Chief Executive Ben van Beurden said on Thursday.
The world's second largest publicly-traded oil company plans to increase its investment in renewable energy to $1 billion a year by the end of the decade, van Beurden said, although it is still a small part of its total annual spending of $25 billion.
The CEO said that the transition to a low carbon energy system will take decades and government policies including putting a price on carbon emissions will be essential to phase out the most polluting sources of energy such as coal and oil.
"If we're not very careful, with all the good intentions and advocacy that we have, we may, as a sector and society, not make the progress that is needed," van Beurden said at the CERAWeek energy conference in Houston.
He said the "biggest challenge" the company faces is maintaining public acceptance of the energy industry.
"I do think trust has been eroded to the point that it is becoming a serious issue for our long term future," he continued. "If we are not careful, broader public support for the sector will wane."
The Anglo-Dutch company is one of the most vocal supporters of a carbon tax and has invested heavily in bringing on new supplies of natural gas, a cleaner burning fuel source.
"This is the biggest challenge as we have at the moment as a company ... The fact that societal acceptance of the energy system as we have it is just disappearing."
Shell said on Thursday that its directors will from this year be rewarded in part on how well the company manages its greenhouse gas emissions and how much free cash flow it generates.

Links

Elon Musk And Malcolm Turnbull Talk Battery Solutions For Energy Problems

The Guardian - 

Tesla boss speaks to South Australian premier and then Australian prime minister about issues with state and national supply
The chief executive of Tesla, Elon Musk, pledged to install the batteries needed to prevent blackouts in South Australia and have the situation fixed within 100 days. Photograph: Ringo HW Chiu/AP
Malcolm Turnbull has spoken to the Tesla founder, Elon Musk, about energy storage issues after the tech billionaire offered to supply battery technology to solve South Australia’s energy reliability problems within 100 days.
The prime minister’s office said the hour-long conversation on Sunday had occurred by mutual arrangement, given Turnbull’s longstanding commitment to exploring technological options to enhance storage.
“The pair had an in depth discussion about the value of storage and the future of the electricity system,” a spokesman for Turnbull said on Sunday, after the Australian prime minister took to Twitter to confirm the chat.
IMAGE
The tech billionaire characterised the conversation as “very exciting.”
IMAGE
The conversation was more broad-ranging than the South Australian proposal. Last week, Musk threw down a challenge to the South Australian and federal governments, saying he could solve the state’s energy woes within 100 days – or he’d deliver the 100MW battery storage system for free.
Turnbull and Musk discussed network issues and methods of improving battery technology, and resolved to keep in touch over the coming months.
Before talking to Turnbull, Musk spoke with the South Australian premier, Jay Weatherill, about a technological fix in the state, which has a high proportion of wind energy.
With high power prices and network reliability issues politically red hot in South Australia, the Weatherill government has been signalling for weeks it will shortly unveil a range of policy measures designed to boost energy security after the recent blackouts.
The policy announcements, which may include the construction of more base load power in the state, as well as options to improve storage, are understood to be very close to completion.
Musk’s offer is said to be complementary to the work already in train.
Federal Labor on Sunday cautioned there was still a way to go before Musk’s “exciting” proposal could become reality.
After a conversation with Weatherill on Saturday, the entrepreneur said: “Very impressed. Govt is clearly committed to a smart, quick solution.”
Labor’s federal energy spokesman, Mark Butler, said the proposal was still in its formative stage but was excited about the prospect. The cost of batteries was falling quickly, surprising even the most optimistic analysts, he said.
Some remote communities in Australia and beyond – in places like American Samoa – have already been able to use them to deal with the intermittency of solar and wind technology.
The biggest question was whether this sort of technology could operate within existing rules and outdated market structure, he said.
“[There’s] a bit of a way to go on this I think but a really exciting exercise of leadership by the South Australian government,” Butler told ABC TV on Sunday. “Further discussions between [Mr Musk] and the South Australian premier should be encouraged.”
The Australian billionaire Mike Cannon-Brookes has accepted the Musk overture, asking for seven days to sort out politics and funding.
The Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young believes battery technology would be the game-changer South Australia needs to solve its energy woes.
“He has thrown down the gauntlet here – I can’t see what there is to lose,” she told ABC TV on Saturday.
The Greens leader, Richard Di Natale, said the idea the transition to green renewable energy is a technological barrier is “nonsense”.
“It’s a political barrier, it’s a failure of planning, it’s a failure of investment in the right parts of the grid,” he told Sky News.
Noting the prime minister, Malcolm Turnbull, is having an energy “crisis meeting” this week, Di Natale said it just showed governments had been asleep at the wheel.
“We are having crisis meetings about a crisis that has been unfolding for decades,” he said.

Links

Sunday, March 12, 2017

This Climate Lawsuit Could Change Everything. No Wonder The Trump Administration Doesn’t Want It Going To Trial

Washington Post - Chelsea Harvey

The Justice Department building in Washington. (J. David Ake/AP)
A groundbreaking climate lawsuit, brought against the federal government by 21 children, has been hailed by environmentalists as a bold new strategy to press for climate action in the United States. But the Trump administration, which has pledged to undo Barack Obama’s climate regulations, is doing its best to make sure the case doesn’t get far.
The Trump administration this week filed a motion to overturn a ruling by a federal judge back in November that cleared the lawsuit for trial — and filed a separate motion to delay trial preparation until that appeal is considered.
The lawsuit — the first of its kind — argues the federal government has violated the constitutional right of the 21 plaintiffs to a healthy climate system.
Environmental groups say the case — if it’s successful — could force even a reluctant government to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and take other measures to counter warming.
“It would be huge,” said Pat Gallagher, legal director at the Sierra Club, who is not involved in the case. “It would upend climate litigation, climate law, as we know it.”

President Trump and many of his top aides have expressed skepticism about climate change, while others say human activity is to blame for global warming. So what's the administration's real position? (Peter Stevenson/The Washington Post) 

The landmark lawsuit was originally filed during the Obama administration. The 21 plaintiffs,  now between the ages of 9 and 20, claim the federal government has consistently engaged in activity that promotes fossil fuel production and greenhouse gas emissions, thereby worsening climate change. They argue this violates their constitutional right to life, liberty and property, as well the public trust doctrine, while holds that the government is responsible for the preservation of certain vital resources — in this case, a healthy climate system — for public use.
While legal experts are uncertain as to the lawsuit’s likelihood of success, few have disputed its pioneering nature. Similar cases have been brought on the state level, but this is the first against the federal government in the United States. And in November, the case cleared a major early hurdle when U.S. District Judge Ann Aiken denied motions filed by the Obama administration, as well as the fossil fuel industry, to have the lawsuit dismissed, ordering that it should proceed to trial.
The move allowed the case to join the ranks of climate lawsuits filed in other nations, which could upend the way environmental advocacy is conducted around the world. Just last year, a court in the Netherlands ordered the Dutch government to cut carbon emissions by a quarter within five years. Similar climate-related suits have been brought and won in Austria, Pakistan and South Africa.
Shortly after President Trump’s inauguration, the plaintiffs submitted a request that the Department of Justice preserve all documents that could be relevant to the lawsuit, including information on climate change, energy and emissions, and cease any destruction of such documents that may otherwise occur during the presidential transition. The request came just days after reports began to surface of climate information disappearing from White House and certain federal agency websites.
“We are concerned with the new administration’s immediate maneuver to remove important climate change information from the public domain and, based on recent media reports, we are concerned about how deep the scrubbing effort will go,”Julia Olson, chief legal counsel for the plaintiffs and executive director of the advocacy group Our Children’s Trust, said in a statement at the time. “Destroying evidence is illegal and we just put these new U.S. Defendants and the Industry Defendants on notice that they are barred from doing so.”
The Trump administration is combating this request in its motion to stay litigation, along with its motion to appeal. The administration charges that the United States could be “irreparably harmed” if the case’s proceedings are not halted pending consideration of its appeal, claiming that “the extraordinary scope of this litigation and the concomitant scope of discovery that Plaintiffs appear to be seeking set this case apart.”
“One of the things that the government argues is that the preservation of documents itself represents a burden on the government,” said Michael Burger, executive director of the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law at Columbia Law School. “What they’re arguing is that they’ll be irreparably injured by having to go through discovery here.”
This, he added, “sends kind of the wrong signal, or at least a very dangerous signal, in terms of what the government’s priorities are or what it’s thinking of doing. It shouldn’t be any kind of burden for the government to preserve documents that are already in existence.”
But given the broad implications of the case for U.S. climate action, especially if the plaintiffs prevail, “it’s not surprising that the Trump administration would want to quash it,” said Gallagher, the Sierra Club legal director.
If the case were successful, the federal government would be obligated to take meaningful action against climate change, probably through a planned reduction in greenhouse gas emissions. This type of order would run counter to the current administration’s priorities. On Thursday, Scott Pruitt, the EPA chief, rejected the underlying science of climate change, and the administration has indicated its intent to cancel a number of Obama-era climate and environmental regulations, including the Clean Power Plan, and withdraw from the Paris climate agreement.
Whether either of the federal government’s most recent motions will hold up remains to be decided. According to Burger, this largely depends on Aiken, the federal judge who ordered that the case proceed to trial, who essentially must sign off in order for the appeal to take place.
“In order to do that, the judge needs to basically agree that there are issues of law that could be determinative that the case would be better served if the Ninth Circuit [Court of Appeals] heard it now,” Burger said. Appeals most typically occur after a final opinion on a case has been reached through trial, he noted, pointing out that although it’s “common enough for parties to seek interlocutory appeal, it’s the exception rather than the rule that it be granted.”
A stay of the proceedings, pending appeal, is also subject to Aiken’s decision. This means there are multiple combinations of outcomes that could occur for the case’s proceedings.
“It’s conceivable that Judge Aiken could certify her order on the motion to dismiss for interlocutory appeal and not grant a stay on the proceedings,” Burger noted. In this situation, the case would be heard in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, which would essentially decide whether it should proceed on the basis of the claims the plaintiffs have already set forth, while at the same time continuing through discovery at the district court level, he said.
Regardless of the final outcome, legal experts have highlighted the lawsuit’s importance as a novel approach to the climate issue in the United States.  “It could spawn a whole new universe of litigation at both the state and the federal levels,” Gallagher said.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative