Friday, June 09, 2017

Low Emissions Target: On Carbon Schemes, No One Says The Same Thing For Long

Fairfax - Peter Martin

If you don't know the difference between a carbon tax and an emissions trading scheme, or a low emissions target and an emissions intensity scheme, it's time to wise up.
On Friday Malcolm Turnbull gets the report of the Finkel review of the electricity market and later this year the report of the official review of his government's climate change policies.

What he does next will affect how much we pay, how much we use, the types of electricity we use, how quickly we cut emissions and how often the system breaks down.
But if we don't even know what the words mean, we'll be in the dark.
So here's a quick (opinionated) guide. And a warning: no one seems to say the same thing for long.

Carbon tax
It had the advantage of being simple, so simple that Tony Abbott actually backed it in his early days as opposition leader before reversing course and opposing it, and being swept to power.
"If you want to put a price on carbon, why not just do it with a simple tax?" he asked back then. "It would be burdensome, all taxes are burdensome, but it could certainly raise the price of carbon, without in any way increasing the overall tax burden."
It's what Julia Gillard did, and was martyred for. Exemptions from the tax and overcompensation in the form of income tax cuts and direct payments meant every cent it raised was handed back. And it cut emissions. Each year for more than a century through two world wars and the great depression Australia had used more electricity than the year before, until the lead-up to the carbon tax when both electricity use and electricity emissions began to fall and then fell sharply until mid-2014 when the tax was abolished by Abbott himself.
Illustration: Matt Davidson 
Turnbull gets the argument for the tax. "If you want people to do less of something, you tax it," was how he described another measure during the 2016 election campaign.

Emissions trading scheme
It's like a carbon tax (in fact, the carbon tax was designed to transition into one) except that it uses carrots as well as sticks. The government issues a limited number of pollution permits, but then leaves the polluters free to buy and sell them from each other. If one manages to cut emissions easily and no longer needs its permits it can sell them to another who needs them more, perhaps for a profit. It means the market sets the price of the permits, and the price is no higher than it needs to be.
Chief Scientist Dr Alan Finkel will deliver his electricity market report on Friday. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen
US President George H. W. Bush issued tradeable sulphur dioxide pollution permits to cheaply halve the incidence of acid rain. In his last days in office John Howard promised to use tradeable permits to cheaply meet Australia's carbon emission reduction obligations. Kevin Rudd got to work on the details with the then opposition leader Malcolm Turnbull, then Turnbull was rolled, the Greens said no, and Rudd baulked at taking the plan to an election. It would be painted as a big new tax. Voters would remember the electricity price hike but not the compensating tax cut, as Gillard later discovered.

Emissions intensity scheme
Long championed by Turnbull and independent Nick Xenophon and Greg Hunt as environment minister, an intensity trading scheme would have the advantage of raising no money whatsoever, and not pushing up prices much. Each industry would be given a "baseline" for its emissions intensity. For the electricity industry it would be a certain number of tonnes emitted per megawatt-hour produced. Plants that were above the baseline would have to buy permits from plants that were below it. As a result coal-fired plants would become more expensive to run and get less business, and gas and wind-powered plants would become cheaper and get more. All without anything that looked like a tax.
What Malcolm Turnbull does next will affect how quickly we cut emissions and how often the system breaks down. Photo: Jonathan Carroll
Critics say it would give gas a leg-up when what's needed is to move straight to renewables. This year Turnbull ruled it out partly because it could be presented as the emissions trading scheme he promised not to introduce. The real downside is that it wouldn't be an emissions trading scheme. By not moving prices much, it would do little to reduce electricity demand, working only on the sources of supply.

Low emissions target
Described by the Climate Change Authority as a second-best alternative to its preferred option of an intensity scheme, a low emissions target would operate pretty much in the same way as the current renewable energy target. Electricity suppliers would be required to source a certain proportion of their power from renewables or other very low emission sources such as highly-efficient gas or even coal plants, should they ever be built.
Its biggest drawback is that if it's all there is, there's no guarantee it won't change. The government might be lobbied to weaken it (making lobbying a very cost-effective proposition) or another government might impose a grander scheme on top of it. Potential investors in new plants might be forgiven for holding back. Given the dizzying array of changes since Howard first proposed an emissions trading scheme 10 years ago, it would be hard to blame them.

Links

Climate Change Is Real. So Why Won’t The Right Admit It?

The Guardian - 

From hard Brexiters to Donald Trump, nationalists who deny the existence of manmade global warming will eventually have to face the facts
‘Nationalists, gripped by an isolationist logic, are unable or unwilling to face the reality of global warming’. A protest against Donald Trump’s decision to withdraw from the Paris climate agreement in Chicago.
Photograph: Scott Olson/Getty Images 
Around 97% of climate scientists confirm the existence of manmade global warming, and public opinion is steadily catching up. In the UK, a recent poll suggested 84% of British people want Theresa May to “convince Trump not to quit” the Paris climate agreement. According to a survey spanning 40 nations, 78% of people support their country joining the global agreement.
Consensus on manmade global warming has never been stronger. Yet climate denial remains strong among a particular ideological group. Donald Trump’s withdrawal from the Paris agreement last week provides the strongest evidence yet that nationalists, gripped by an isolationist logic, are unable or unwilling to face the reality of global warming.
Yet American nationalists are not the only ones to resist action on climate change. Ukip’s general election manifesto pledges to pull the UK out of the Paris accord. More concerning, however, is that Eurosceptic Conservatives include prominent climate sceptics such as Lord Lawson.
Theresa May closed the Department for Energy and Climate Change within 24 hours of becoming prime minister. Having received £390,000 in donations from senior oil executives since she came to power, her manifesto now pledges to “build on the unprecedented support already provided to the oil and gas sector”. An entire Conservative election campaign is premised on the brand of “strong and stable”, while May keeps quiet about climate change – described by the UN as a threat to global stability “unprecedented in scale”.
Climate denial extends from the Brexit ringleaders to the voters who support them. A ComRes poll found that leave voters are twice as likely to deny manmade climate change as those who voted remain. The same poll found that Brexiters exhibit a general “distrust towards scientists”. In other words, they’ve had enough of experts.
Across the world, nationalist programmes – the French Front National, the BNP, Donald Trump, the Danish People’s party – have tried to cripple credibility in climate science, which requires collective action between states and is thus, for them, what Al Gore and others have called an inconvenient truth.
But there’s another explanation for climate denial among leave voters. Climate sceptics and hard-Brexiters share the common denominator of right-leaning free-market ideology. Over the past decade, various studies have found that conservatives and economic liberals are considerably more likely than other people to reject anthropogenic global warming, presumably because this is a problem that the market cannot solve.
Eco-nationalism, woven with contradiction, turns environmental discourse into a geopolitical blame game
The true danger from nationalist framings of climate change, however, is not denial, but the weaponisation of the environment in the service of self-interest. Trump famously called global warming a Chinese “hoax”, but less well known is that climate denial in China also arises from a nationalist distrust, in this case towards the west. A study published in the journal Environmental Sociology found that climate scepticism resulted from a patriotic “conspiracy theory that sees climate change as a western plot to constrain China’s development”. Similarly in India, the nationalism of the prime minister, Narendra Modi, is tied to the continuation of dirty coal as well as the excuse that western countries aren’t pulling their weight.
But Marine Le Pen is perhaps the politician to have taken environmental nationalism the furthest. In 2014, the Front National leader launched what she called the New Ecology movement, promising to ban wind farms and reduce France’s dependence on oil, but condemning the environmental movement as a “communist project”.
This eco-nationalism, woven with contradiction, turns environmental discourse into a geopolitical blame game. Eventually, Brexiters must come to realise this dissonance, along with the unalterable reality that air – and the carbon dioxide in it – does not respect national borders.

Links

Australians Want Focus On Renewables Not Coal, Lowy Poll Finds

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

Australians overwhelmingly want governments to favour renewable energy over fossil fuels even if it costs more, and concerns about climate change are strengthening, a new Lowy Institute poll finds.
The survey of 1202 adults during the first three weeks of March found 81 per cent of respondents wanted policymakers to focus on clean energy sources such as wind and solar, even if it costs more to ensure grid reliability.
Fossil fuels deserve less government support than renewables, a Lowy poll finds. Photo: AP
Just 17 per cent backed a focus on "traditional energy sources such as coal and gas even if this means the environment may suffer to some extent".
The finding was one of Lowy's highest results for a two-option answer and "somewhat surprising" since the poll was conducted soon after blackouts in wind-power dominated South Australia and the heatwave that stretched power supplies in coal-dependent NSW, said Alex Oliver, Lowy's polling director.
No bull: Australians strongly support more renewable energy. Photo: AP
"I wasn't expecting the response to renewables to be so positive in the context of that very heated debate," he said. 
The poll results come just days before Alan Finkel, Australia's chief scientist, is due to release his review of Australia's energy security on Friday.
The report is widely tipped to offer a range of options to support the transition away from coal-fired power including a so-called low emissions target that would reward less polluting energy sources.
The Turnbull government has touted the need to provide energy that is reliable, affordable and sustainable, particularly the first two traits. Ms Oliver said this year's poll and those in recent years suggest the government would be at odds with public opinion if it downplayed environmental outcomes.
Solar panels: Demand is expected to continue to grow with 303 gigawatts installed globally at the end of 2016. Photo: Rob Homer
For instance, some 57 per cent of those polled this year listed climate change as "a critical threat", behind only international terrorism at 68 per cent and North Korea's nuclear program at 65 per cent.
"A majority think [climate change] is a critical threat to our national interest," Ms Oliver said. "It's a policy challenge that's not going to go away."
Climate's ranking as the third-most important threat is up from sixth spot in 2014. The 11 percentage-point jump since then has raised concerns about global warming above fears over cyber attacks, foreign investment in Australia and asylum seekers.

More bang, fewer bucks
The world's nations added a record 161 gigawatts of renewable energy in 2016. But falling prices of wind turbines and solar panels meant total investment in the sector retreated 23 per cent from 2015 to $US241.6 billion ($321 billion), according to the REN21 Global Status Report released on Wednesday.
Australia added 900 megawatts of new solar photovoltaic panels last year, the eighth-most in the world, behind China's leading surge of 34.5 GW.
By accumulated capacity, Australia had 5.8 GW of solar, ranking it ninth behind such nations as Germany, Italy, Britain and France. China was easily the largest, with 77.4 GW installed in a global total of 303 GW.
​About 30 per cent of dwellings in Queensland and South Australia had solar PV at the end of last year, the report noted.
A survey by Lowy in 2015 found 43 per cent of Australians expected solar to be "our primary source of electricity 10 years from now".
That compared with 17 per cent for coal, 13 per cent for nuclear, 10 per cent for gas and 7 per cent for wind. At the time of that 2015 survey, solar provided only about 2 per cent of Australia's electricity.

Links

Thursday, June 08, 2017

How Scientists Reacted To The US Leaving The Paris Climate Agreement

Nature - Jeff Tollefson | Quirin Schiermeier

US President Donald Trump wants to boost the US coal industry. Luke Sharrett/Bloomberg/Getty
Nature rounds up reaction from researchers around the world to US President Donald Trump's decision to pull the United States out of the Paris climate agreement.

Jane Lubchenco, marine ecologist at Oregon State University in Corvallis and former administrator of the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration:
Where to start? President Trump’s decision to withdraw from the Paris Agreement shows a blatant disregard for the wishes of most Americans and business leaders, an irresponsible and callous dismissal of the health, safety and economic well-being of Americans, a moral emptiness in ignoring impacts to the poorest people in the US and around the world, and gross ignorance about overwhelming scientific evidence. Far from “protecting America” as the president stated, withdrawing from Paris will make America more vulnerable and diminish its world leadership. It is terrifying that the individual who should be leading the rest of the world is so arrogant and irresponsible.
Our collective future and that of much of the rest of life on Earth depends in part on confronting climate change and ocean acidification. Doing so requires global collective action. It’s hard to imagine anyone consciously choosing to leave a legacy of impoverishment, economic disruption, increasingly bizarre weather, health impacts ranging from heat strokes to spread of diseases, rising sea levels and flooding — but that is just what the president has done. Moreover, the new path and the president’s proposed budget would forego significant economic opportunities.
Fortunately, mayors, governors, faith leaders, scientists and business executives understand what is at risk, respect the scientific evidence, and see the powerful economic potential and moral imperative in shifting to renewable energy, preparing to adapt to changes already under way, and investing in science and monitoring to guide future decisions. There is strong economic momentum to continue these actions, but they would have been accelerated and more effective with strong action and forceful leadership from the president. Alas, he has chosen instead to stick his head in the sand.

Jean-Pascal van Ypersele, climate scientist at the Catholic University of Louvain in Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium, and former vice-chair of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC):
President Trump's decision to introduce a request to leave the Paris agreement in 2020 is regrettable. It negates both the results of (1) serious scientific analyses (many made by US scientists) about the urgency to address the climate change problem; and (2) the rigorous assessment made by the IPCC about the technical and socio-economic aspects of response options, including their significant co-benefits in other areas like air quality, energy security, health or job creation.
President Trump's speech attempting to justify his decision was an amazing concentrate of some of the worst climate confusers' and fossil lobbyists' arguments.
The United States has played a very important role over the years to foster and nurture quality scientific research about the causes and processes of climate change, the potential risks and the response options. It is a shame that this leadership by the US is temporarily lost. Others in Europe, Asia and emerging economies will most likely compensate for this loss, transforming a difficulty into an opportunity.
Almost 150 countries, representing close to 85% of greenhouse-gas emissions, have now ratified the Paris agreement. Removing the US contribution from this total still leaves almost two-thirds of the emissions covered by the remaining countries, which have confirmed their plans to honour the agreement. This means that the transition to a low-carbon economy, now seen as an opportunity by many, will continue unabated, with or without the US.

Susanne Dröge, climate-policy researcher at the German Institute for International and Security Affairs in Berlin:
The US pull-out is bad news for the international climate process. The United Nations negotiations need to focus on implementation. This will become more difficult, also because it is unclear how Trump wants to renegotiate the agreement. Political attention is absorbed due to the US move, attention that is needed for much more important issues such as bringing climate action forward.

Thomas Stocker, former co-chair of climate science for the IPCC, and climate and environmental physicist at the University of Bern, Switzerland:
Trump’s decision to ignore scientific facts of climate disruption and the high risks of climate-change impacts is irresponsible not only towards his own people but to all people and life on this planet. The US administration prefers old technology over innovation and transformation. It is rejecting the enormous benefits and returns that leadership in the next industrial revolution — decarbonization — has to offer.
The United States is the second-biggest emitter of carbon dioxide worldwide (and has contributed, with Europe, 52% of the share of cumulative carbon emissions since industrialization). It is withdrawing from its historical responsibility to reduce greenhouse-gas emissions and lead the way forward. Given the continuous commitment of most countries to reduce emissions, and the firm leadership of Europe, China and Russia in shaping the transformation towards a decarbonized economy, the United States runs the risk of being left behind and missing one of the greatest economic opportunities of our time.

Susan Lozier, oceanographer at Duke University in Durham, North Carolina:
Trump’s decision is as short-sighted as it is disheartening. The oceans already hold about 35% of the carbon dioxide that has been released to the atmosphere since the Industrial Revolution. Nothing good for the ocean and the life it contains comes from this storage. Whether you simply admire marine life or count on it for your livelihood, this decision shouldn’t sit well. An already fragile ocean is further imperilled.

Kevin Anderson, deputy director of the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research in Manchester, UK:
Beneath the veil of the low-carbon rhetoric of the Paris agreement, there is no evidence of a mitigation agenda even approaching the scale of our international obligations. Trump’s ostensibly reckless decision can be used either as a further excuse for continued apathy or as a catalyst for transforming our comfortable rhetoric into meaningful and timely action. In that regard, Trump’s ignorant blunderings can inadvertently be a force for good. Channelled positively, it could yet oblige the rest of us to forego our increasing reliance on speculative technologies and incremental carbon prices and begin to shape a mitigation agenda that is fit for purpose.
We need to take Trump at face value. If he is successful in returning the US to a coal-based economy (and that looks unlikely), then the European Union needs to borrow his ‘protectionist’ cloak and put in place carbon standards for imported goods.
Finally, let’s keep Trump in context. US states and cities have considerable devolved powers — and many of their leaders continue to favour climate science.

Joeri Rogelj, energy researcher at the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis in Laxenburg, Austria:
The US withdrawing from the Paris agreement is damaging for international collaborative efforts to limit climate change, but will likely be most damaging to the US economy itself. The US has decided to sideline itself, internationally, diplomatically and morally — not to prepare itself for the future, but to gaze into the past for a few more years. Many other major economies, including China and the European Union, have indicated their strong commitment to implementing the climate agreement. This signal will spur innovation and business development in these regions. However, the US government refuses to give US businesses such a clear sense of direction and is disregarding the most robust scientific evidence by doing so. By setting research, innovation and business priorities based on misleading short-term political goals, the US will miss the boat and might become a laggard in the global technology and innovation landscape.
The climate issue is a global and a cumulative problem that was not solved in one go with the Paris agreement, but requires incremental updates and adjustments of climate action. To halt climate change, global carbon dioxide emissions need to be capped and annual emissions need to be brought to zero. One country failing on its commitments thus implies that deeper emissions cuts are required in other regions or later in the future. This makes the problem harder and less equitable to solve.

Oliver Geden, visiting research fellow at the Institute for Science, Innovation and Society, University of Oxford, UK:
The United States gave up climate leadership on the day of Trump's inauguration. In March, Trump announced his rollback of Obama-era climate regulations. So it’s been clear for some time that the US federal government is not going to act on climate change in the foreseeable future. Withdrawing from the Paris agreement is just another step, although a highly symbolic one.
For now, it seems that this step reunites the rest of the world, but only on the symbolic level. It is quite easy for a government to declare that it will stick to the Paris agreement. But in a regime of bottom-up climate policy that still aims to achieve top-down temperature targets, other governments would need to step up and declare that they increase their mitigation pledges — and act accordingly. That's obviously the harder thing to do.

Katharine Hayhoe, director of the Climate Science Center at Texas Tech University in Lubbock:
The biggest loser from the decision could be the United States itself. Why? Because although the Paris agreement is a climate treaty, a triumph for evidence-based decision-making, it’s also much more: a trade agreement, an investment blueprint and a strong incentive for innovation in the energy and the economy of the future.
Earlier this week, India broke its own record for the lowest bids for electricity from solar power. Last month, Ernst & Young listed its most attractive markets for renewables: the United States came third, behind China and India. And earlier this year, China announced a US$360-billion investment in clean energy to create 13 million new jobs. The US announcement shows that it will be doing its best to turn back the clock, while the rest of the world accelerates into the future.
It’s true that federal policy is only one piece of the pie, and not even the biggest one. Cities, states and private industry have arguably played an even more important role in shaping US technological innovation, energy mix and carbon emissions over the past ten years, even under proactive federal climate policy. But Trump’s announcement sends a strong message that the US would rather be one of only two nations in the world that is not interested in preventing “dangerous anthropogenic interference with the climate system”. That other nation? War-torn Syria. (Note that Nicaragua is also opting out of the agreement — but in that case it’s because it wants to do more, not less.)

Atte Korhola, climate-policy and environmental-change researcher at the University of Helsinki, Finland:
The US withdrawal from the Paris climate agreement is very disappointing and unfavourable for the United States and the rest of the world. Many climate scientists consider the Paris agreement insufficient for limiting warming to 2 °C, so the task will be all the harder now. However, international climate agreements have not been very effective so far in reducing emissions, so there is still hope that the United States will proceed on other fronts, such as through bilateral agreements, clean-tech development and investing in new ‘negative emissions’ technologies.
But the plans by the Trump administration to cut more than 30% from the Environmental Protection Agency’s budget and about 70% of the funding for renewable-energy research and development unfortunately don’t point in this direction. The situation in all respects is quite depressing. The only hope is that the US states, cities and companies will continue their effective work to cut emissions.

Benjamin Santer, climate scientist at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory in California:
In Shakespeare's Julius Caesar, Brutus said these famous lines: "There is a tide in the affairs of men. Which, taken at the flood, leads on to fortune; Omitted, all the voyage of their life is bound in shallows and in miseries."
Today, the United States pulled out of the Paris climate agreement and missed the rising tide. Far from "Making America Great Again", this decision condemns the United States to becoming one of the 'has-beens' of history. We will become increasingly irrelevant to the rest of the world. They are going forward; we are going backward.

Hans Joachim Schellnhuber, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research in Potsdam, Germany:
It will not substantially hamper global climate progress if the US really quits the Paris agreement, but it will hurt the American economy and society alike. China and Europe have become world leaders on the path towards green development already and will strengthen their position if the US slips back at the national level. Innovative states such as California, the world's sixth-largest economy, will keep going for climate action, however. The Washington people around Trump hide in the trenches of the past instead of building the future. They fail to recognize that the climate wars are over, while the race for sustainable prosperity is on.

David Victor, climate-policy expert at the University of California, San Diego:
The odds of other countries renegotiating Paris are low to zero. The whole structure of the Paris agreement is to allow countries to set their own commitments. So there is nobody to negotiate with if a country needs to adjust. This claim that the problem with Paris is that the deal wasn’t struck properly is a disingenuous argument that is not informed by how Paris actually works, nor by any reality about how the world actually crafts big complex deals.

Glen Peters, climate-policy expert at the Center for International Climate and Environmental Research in Oslo:
It seems that Trump and his advisers have completely misconceived what the Paris agreement is. All his reasons for pulling out were basically the concessions that forged the path to the creation of the Paris agreement. Paris is the agreement that Trump desires!
The genius of Paris is to allow countries to put forward emission pledges that they feel they can meet (Nationally Determined Contributions). The US pledge was put forward by the US, alone. Countries are already enacting their emissions pledges, and — as could be expected by the design of the Paris agreement — most countries show signs of exceeding their conservative emissions pledges. China looks like it may peak its emissions a decade earlier than pledged. India has slowed down on coal consumption and sped up on solar deployment. Even the US has made great strides in the past decade, and was poised to make more.
The irony is that Paris is working, because it is designed to be flexible to the national circumstances that Trump himself champions!

Myles Allen, climate scientist at the University of Oxford, UK:
The Paris agreement is far from perfect, and one of its problems, as we are seeing now, is the lack of any real penalty for pulling out. Talk of trade sanctions is pure hyperbole and the last thing the world needs right now. But perhaps it is time to think about a simple product label: “Made in and sourced from regions that support the Paris climate agreement.” With California and Oregon insisting they will abide by the terms of the Paris agreement anyway, we could then have an interesting discussion about whether and how this could be stuck on Californian orange juice — or computers containing Intel chips.
Painful though it may be for the agreement’s supporters, acknowledging that it isn’t perfect must also be part of the response to this proposal to renegotiate the US terms of participation. Some, no doubt, will see this as just a distraction tactic. Others would argue that even to begin to negotiate would be to deliver Trump an ill-deserved political “win”. But thinking beyond 2020, we will eventually need to work out how to make the agreement both more effective and more acceptable to nations, companies and individuals that own substantial fossil-fuel reserves — or the US won’t be the last to leave.

Benjamin Sanderson, climate modeller at the National Center for Atmospheric Research in Boulder, Colorado:
Today's announcement that the US will depart from the Paris agreement is unfortunate, but it is no time for fatalism. From this point forward, there are now large uncertainties in global mitigation efforts over the coming years. The long-term evolution of the climate hinges on what other countries, and agents both within and outside of the US, do in response to the US departure from the agreement.
A complete failure of the agreement at this point, with business-as-usual growth for another decade, would almost certainly commit the planet to significantly more warming than the Paris goals, and the human consequences of this would be catastrophic. However, some major remaining signatories have expressed a commitment to increasing mitigation goals, and within the US, many states, cities and some of the country's largest companies are committed to mitigation irrespective of the US participation in the agreement.
Decisions made today are made in the context of confident projections of future warming with continued emissions, but clearly there is more to do to better characterize the human and economic consequences of delaying action on climate change and how to frame these issues in the context of other concerns. The role of the scientific community is more important than ever, both to continue to provide the best possible research to inform decisions, and to communicate any risks associated with further emissions in a publicly accessible fashion.

Links

Adani's 'Green Light' On Carmichael Coal Mine More Mirage Than Reality

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

Sometimes, the lost desert wanderer does stumble into an oasis, replete with proverbial date palms and life-saving waters.
Most such visions, though, turn out to be mirages.


Adani coal mine gets go ahead
Approval has been given for the controversial Carmichael coal mine in central Queensland. Vision courtesy ABC News

And so it is with the latest bold announcement from Adani. Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk materialised in Townsville on Tuesday too, to hear the company declare it had approved a "final investment decision" for its Carmichael coal mine.
"Adani Project Gets Green Light", the Indian-owned miner trumpeted.
Indeed, "pre-construction work" on the Galilee Basin mine is to begin in the September quarter on a project that has so far cost the company $3.3 billion – including the purchase of Abbot Point coal port.
The Carmichael projects will generate 10,000 direct and indirect jobs, it said.
Interestingly, though, Adani omitted any number on the cost of the project. Is it $16.5 billion and Australia's biggest proposed coal mine, as so often claimed?
A lot else was left unsaid, not least that the mine is yet to receive definitive financial close.
Adani Group founder Gautam Adani says the company "is still facing activists".  Photo: AAP
Not so mega
That's why Downer EDI, one of the expected beneficiaries on Tuesday only said it had received "further clarification of the scope of work to be done and the process for negotiating a binding mining services contract".
The Queensland government is keenly aware what is being proposed so far by Adani is not a "megamine", as Treasurer Curtis Pitt noted last week. Carmichael "is certainly smaller than many mines around the world", Pitt said.
Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk.  Photo: Bradley Kanaris
True, the $4 billion-odd mine being discussed in the Queensland cabinet might one day be expanded towards the original 60 million tonnes-a-year monster that has fossil fuel fans drooling and environmentalists fuming.
But that "might" needs many unlikely factors to fall its way.
Adani not yet ready to roll. Photo: Glenn Hunt
Can Adani get a $900 million loan from the federal government for a 400-kilometre railway to link mine and port, for instance?
Can it get over remaining legal challenges, not to mention the protests from environmental groups determined to head off another giant source of greenhouse gases that will help cook what remains of the Great Barrier Reef, and all the tens of thousands of tourism jobs dependent on that?
"We have been challenged by activists in the courts, in inner city streets, and even outside banks that have not even been approached to finance the project," Gautam Adani, the company's chairman, intoned in Churchillian terms, omitting all but the beaches.
"We are still facing activists. But we are committed to this project."

Biggest hurdle
The highest hurdles, though, have always been thrown up by the investment and financial community. With Australian banks ruling out support, international investors are left to wonder what they know about the mine's viability.
Investment bank UBS's commodity team reviewed the prospects of Galilee coal in 2013. The team estimated then a $110 a tonne thermal coal price would be needed for the projects there to be viable.
Even assuming some costs may be lower now, the outlook for coal is, if anything dimming, further.
That sum compares with KPMG's forecast last month of Newcastle's benchmark coal trading below $US65 ($87) a tonne for years to come – even before a discount is applied to Carmichael's typically poorer quality coal. (See KPMG's forecast Newcastle coal benchmark price chart below.)
It's not only that the coal price remains nowhere near what would make Galilee's lower quality coal profitable, especially when compared with Hunter Valley's exports.
But also that the whole "pit to plug" plan Adani was touting – digging, shipping, and burning its own coal – is looking increasingly dubious.
Tim Buckley, a former Citi analyst and now director of the coal-sceptic Institute for Energy Economics & Financial Analysis, notes the news at home just gets worse for Adani.
Adani Power declared on Monday it was considering selling control of one of its biggest coal-fired power stations mostly because it could not compete with domestic coal. And India has vowed to ban imported coal within a year to save foreign exchange.
With Carmichael's prospects bad and getting worse, for Buckley the biggest question might be why Australian governments and the hopeful suppliers are being dragged along for the ride.
"What game are they playing because Adani is not getting to financial close today," Buckley says.

Links

Why The Fossil Fuel Companies Won't Defend the Government In Court On Climate

Pacific Standard - 

Twenty-one young Americans are suing the U.S. government for ignoring climate change—and industry groups now seem terrified.
President Donald Trump waves goodbye after announcing his decision to pull the United States out of the Paris climate agreement on June 1st, 2017. (Photo: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
Last week, the three major trade groups representing the fossil fuel industry dodged, just in time, being forced to defend their position on climate change in court. The Trump administration, despite its withdrawal from the Paris climate accord, will not be so lucky.
Last Thursday the American Petroleum Institute and the American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers filed motions to withdraw from their defense of the government in the groundbreaking case Juliana v. United States. Three days earlier the National Association of Manufacturers had done the same. Taken together, these three giants of American industry are retreating as fast as they can from a case that leaves the administration in a legal squeeze.
The administration and the trade groups have been backed into an extraordinary legal corner in the case brought by 21 youngsters, who allege that, for over five decades, the government promoted the use of fossil fuels while knowing that the resulting greenhouse gases would undermine quality of life for future generations. According to the lawsuit, such willfully destructive actions constitute a violation of the plaintiffs' rights to a healthy and safe world, and their ability to pass down a livable planet to their offspring. The young plaintiffs demand that the government impose limits on CO2 and other greenhouse gas emissions to slow atmospheric corrosion. "What we're looking at is for the court to set a constitutional standard for protecting these kids rights that's based on scientific evidence," says Julia Olson, the plaintiffs' chief counsel.

The fossil fuel intervenors may have just barely dodged a bullet from their own gun
The young plaintiffs, supported by a Eugene, Oregon group of environmental lawyers, Our Children's Trust, filed the initial suit in August of 2015 against the Obama administration. Later that year, the three trade associations requested that the court include them as intervenors in the case—a position akin to being co-defendants. The trade organizations feared that an adverse decision would negatively affect their industries, and that President Barack Obama's Department of Justice would not launch a sufficiently vigorous defense. That changed after the election of Donald Trump, who has reversed Obama's clean power initiative, defunded renewable energy initiatives, and shown his clear tilt toward fossil fuel-reliant industries. In a public statement last week, NAM Senior Counsel Linda Kelly explained the companies' reason for withdrawing from the government's defense: "As the dynamics have changed over the last several months," Kelly said, "we no longer feel that our participation in this case is needed to safeguard industry and our workers."*
But there are other forces at play, kicked into gear by a lawsuit that—despite repeated efforts by the companies and the government to have it dismissed and delayed—has been permitted to move forward by both federal judges who have had a chance to weigh in on the matter over the last two and a half years. These start with the "statement of facts" of the case that the plaintiffs alleged, and the Department of Justice conceded. Such statements are customary on large class-action suits, aimed at offering non-disputed terrain on which a case can be fought.
On January 18th, two days before Trump's inauguration, the Department of Justice formally agreed to 98 facts pertaining to climate change, humans' role in creating it, and its destructive future impacts. (The Obama administration opposed the plaintiffs' demand that the government be compelled to act on those facts with firm CO2 limits).

President Donald Trump's remarks appear on a television monitor as members of his administration and invited guests listen to him announce the decision to pull out of the Paris climate agreement at the White House on June 1st, 2017. (Photo: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
Imagine the implications for the companies' admitting to, say, fact number 31 in that list: "Climate change is damaging human and natural systems, increasing the risk of loss of life, and requiring adaptation on larger and faster scales than current species have successfully achieved in the past, potentially increasing the risk of extinction or severe disruption for many species."
Elsewhere, the facts start to look like a litany of the reasons Obama signed the Paris Agreement and largely reflect the global scientific consensus. They include:
  • That for over 50 years, scientists and policymakers in the U.S. government have been aware of the growing body of research suggesting the disruptive impacts of greenhouse gas accumulation in the atmosphere that will likely get worse over time.
  • That the human use of fossil fuels is a major source of CO2 emissions that are a major contributor to climate change, and "place our nation on an increasingly costly, insecure and environmentally dangerous path."
  • That emissions of CO2, methane, and nitrous oxide are at "unprecedentedly high levels compared to the past 800,00 years of historical data and pose risks to human health and welfare."
In a number of instances, the Obama-era defense team even clarified the plaintiffs' allegations upward, suggesting they had underestimated the likely consequences of climate change. For example, the youths alleged that atmospheric concentrations of CO2 exceeded 400 parts-per-million in 2013 for the first time in recorded history; the federal defendants, with two more days left in Obama's term, upped the stakes, clarifying that it was "the first time in millions of years." And, in another instance, the plaintiffs asserted that sea level has been rising 3.2 millimeters yearly since 1993; the government disagreed—it's 3.4 millimeters a year.

The government's objections foreshadowed by a day the decision by Trump to withdraw from the Paris climate accord
The deadline for the intervenors' response to these and other statements of fact was May 25th. That's last Thursday, the very same day that API and their counterparts the AFPM bailed from the case. The NAM bailed three days earlier. Coincidence? Agreeing to any of these or numerous other facts agreed upon by the Obama administration could have opened the door to liability for damages caused by industry products.
These factual statements, then, create a quandary. Since they were already agreed upon by the government defendant, disputing them would have been the burden of the intervenor defendants, in a federal district court in Eugene, Oregon, where there's a far higher standard of evidence than, say, in the U.S. Congress. By withdrawing, not only did these industry groups avoid having to go on the record before a judge challenging widely accepted science about climate change; they also avoided a potentially divisive situation within their ranks: Many members of the NAM—for example, Apple, General Electric, Nissan, and many others—actually agree officially with the overall scientific findings on climate change. On the other hand, if the trade associations agreed to the admissions of fact, their member-companies, including all of America's oil companies, could open themselves to liability for their own contribution to climate change.
Then there's the document question. Facing major discovery demands, the companies tried to shield themselves behind the trade associations: Their lawyer, Frank Volpe, argued that API had no authority over the decisions of its member companies to provide requested documents. On a May 18th teleconference between the parties, Judge Thomas Coffin was skeptical. He questioned whether the companies could, on the one hand, join the case in order to fight it, and, on the other hand, argue that their internal records were not fair game for the plaintiffs. "I don't think they should it have it both ways, quite candidly," Coffin stated, according to a transcription of the call.**
Had the case proceeded with the trade associations onboard, their ability to shield the companies may not have held up, and documents shedding light on their knowledge of climate change and contributions to it were at risk of being prodded from the shadows—as has been occurring with API's most prominent member, ExxonMobil. That company is currently being investigated by the New York attorney general for privately collecting scientific information about the risks of climate change from the company's own scientists but publicly denying the existence of climate change, while helping to finance institutions that promoted climate-change denial.
Now there is no easy way out for the government. The companies' retreat leaves Trump and his team alone to face the quandary of what to do about those difficult facts. On May 31st, one day before Trump announced his decision to abandon the Paris climate accord, the plaintiffs got their answer: The government objected to requests for admissions on 10 important issues. These includes such statements as:
  • "[G]lobal warming of 2 degrees C above the pre-industrial global average temperature threatens the public health and welfare of current and future generations;" and: 
  • "[C]urrent, valid, peer-reviewed and published climate science supports an atmospheric CO2 concentration target of 350 ppm or below by the year 2100 as having a high likelihood of avoiding unusually serious risk of harm and threats to public health and welfare of present and future generations." The Department of Justice has objected to each assertion of climate-change impacts on the grounds of executive privilege, and that by admitting to them they'd be "render[ing] a legal conclusion by virtue of the admission."
In other words, the government's objections foreshadowed by a day the decision by Trump to withdraw from the Paris climate accord.
Still, there's another slip awaiting the administration: Because the government has objected to those and other facts central to the plaintiff's climate claims, it is now vulnerable to discovery requests from the plaintiffs' legal team, which is seeking to document the government's evasion of responsibility for the impacts of climate change. The numerous facts to which the Obama administration agreed sent a strong signal that the government is in possession of documents backing up basic scientific assertions. As Olson commented shortly after the objections were filed on Tuesday night: "We will begin taking depositions of government witnesses … and move to compel substantive discovery responses from the government." The case is shaping up to be a battle over climate change in a courtroom in Eugene. "Trump can withdraw from Paris but not from our lawsuit," Olson said.
Meanwhile, Coffin is expected to rule on the companies' requests to withdraw within two weeks. It looks likely that the fossil fuel intervenors may have just barely dodged a bullet from their own gun.

Links

Wednesday, June 07, 2017

More Than 700 Species Facing Extinction Are Being Hit By Climate Change

The Independent - Ian Johnston

Humans’ closest relatives, the primates, are among those worst affected because their tropical habitats have had a stable climate for thousands of years
Eastern lowland gorillas are among the primates threatened with extinction. Rex
More than 700 mammals and birds currently threatened with extinction already appear to have been adversely affected by climate change, according to a major review of scientific studies.
Primates and marsupials are believed to have the most individual species suffering as a result of global warming, according to a paper in the journal Nature Climate Change.
Only two groups of mammals, rodents and insect-eaters, are thought to have benefited. This is partly because they have fast breeding rates, tend not to be specialists suited to a particular habitat, and often live in burrows which provide insulation against changes in the weather.
The figures are much higher than previously thought, making up 47 per cent of land mammals and 23 per cent of the birds on the International Union for Conservation of Nature’s Red List of species threatened with extinction.
According to the list itself, just seven per cent of the mammals and four per cent of the birds are described as being threatened by “climate change and severe weather”.
The researchers developed a model to compare the animals’ weight and other characteristics with changes in the climate, such as the temperature.
“Using this model, we estimated that 47 per cent of terrestrial [non-flying] threatened mammals (out of 873 species) and 23.4 per cent of threatened birds (out of 1,272 species) may have already been negatively impacted by climate change in at least part of their distribution,” the article in Nature Climate Change said.
“Our results suggest that populations of large numbers of threatened species are likely to be already affected by climate change, and that conservation managers, planners and policy makers must take this into account in efforts to safeguard the future of biodiversity.”
Primates and marsupials are more at risk than other animals partly because they have lived mostly in tropical parts of the world which have had a stable climate for thousands of years.
“Many of these [animals] have evolved to live within restricted environmental tolerances and are likely to be most affected by rapid changes and extreme events,” the paper added.
“In addition, primates and elephants are characterised by very slow reproductive rates that reduce their ability to adapt to rapid changes in environmental conditions.”
One reason why climate change is causing a problem for animals is changes in the distribution of plants.
“In areas with reduced precipitation and/or temperature seasonality, it is likely that plant species may have narrower climatic tolerances, and therefore that these areas may have already experienced vegetation changes with consequential loss of habitat for animals living there,” the paper said.
“A more specialised diet was also associated with greater probability of negative responses in mammals.
“Our findings are in agreement with previous studies on the predictors of general extinction risk, in which species with narrower diet breadths were associated with lower ability to exploit resources and adapt to new environmental conditions and selective pressures.”
Birds living in the world’s cold mountain regions appear to be particularly at risk.
“Populations of species living at high altitudes and in colder places have fewer opportunities to move towards cooler areas or upslope to avoid increasing temperatures, and hence may have increased extinction risk,” the paper said.
Another problem is that higher temperatures are inducing birds to lay eggs earlier.
“For animals living in these environments the effects of temperature changes may have been exacerbated, potentially leading to disruption in synchronisation between the timing of chick-feeding and peak food availability,” the paper said.
“A more specialised diet was also associated with greater probability of negative responses in mammals.
“Our findings are in agreement with previous studies on the predictors of general extinction risk, in which species with narrower diet breadths were associated with lower ability to exploit resources and adapt to new environmental conditions and selective pressures.”
Birds living in the world’s cold mountain regions appear to be particularly at risk.
“Populations of species living at high altitudes and in colder places have fewer opportunities to move towards cooler areas or upslope to avoid increasing temperatures, and hence may have increased extinction risk,” the paper said.
Another problem is that higher temperatures are inducing birds to lay eggs earlier.
“For animals living in these environments the effects of temperature changes may have been exacerbated, potentially leading to disruption in synchronisation between the timing of chick-feeding and peak food availability,” the paper said.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative