RenewEconomy - Giles Parkinson
The
“coal versus no new coal” debate has come to define the battle lines
over Australia’s energy future. It can basically be boiled down to one
concept: the assumption that we have to rely on baseload power for the
reliability and security of out electricity supply.
A new report from the US highlights how the concept of “baseload” is
really just an artefact of an old industry, and points out that baseload
should not be confused with reliability. The two do not go hand in
hand, and hanging on to the term is getting in the way of planning for
the future.
“Baseload power”, however, is a line encouraged by the fossil fuel
industry, happy that “baseload” has become a marketing tool, in the same
way that it has exploited the idea of “clean coal” and “energy poverty”
to pursue their interests.
The
Brattle Group report
was commissioned by the NRDC, a US-based NGO, just as the Trump
administration prepares its own battle over the future of “baseload” in a
rapidly changing energy market. It prompted this series of tweets.
As
in Australia, conservatives in the US are fighting back against
renewables – and variable sources like wind and solar in particular – on
the basis that baseload power should be protected at all costs.
It was the central theme of former prime minister and back-bench rabble-rouser
Tony Abbott’s latest salvo into Coalition party politics,
and his desire for the government to build a new coal-fired power
station, under the fantasy that this will somehow reduce costs.(It will
do the opposite).
He was followed by George Christensen, the Queensland MP wanting a
baseload coal generator in the north of the state, to give people “power
that they can rely on” and not have it derailed by “sacrifices to the
climate gods”.
Christensen clearly did not read the Finkel Review, or the latest
BNEF analysis, because he thinks coal is half the price of solar.
And it’s the line pushed by the Trump administration and its energy
secretary Rick Perry. It’s a coal industry marketing point. But it’s a
lousy argument that makes no sense in a world full of technology
alternatives.
Increasingly, more energy regulators, such as the head of the UK’s
National Grid, and other energy experts are accepting this point.
Perry’s comments were slapped down almost immediately by one of the
country’s senior energy regulator.
“It is absolutely not true,” she said on Perry’s false claims on wind and solar.
And energy users are starting to come to this idea too. The best
example is Nectar Farms, who were ready to abandon the building of the
country’s biggest glasshouse for vegetable growing, and build it
overseas, instead of western Victoria, before discovering that wind
energy and battery storage could deliver the same reliability at a
fraction of the cost of grid power and gas.
“Why would we do it any other way,”
says the CEO Stephen Sasse. Extraordinary,
this tale of a half a billion dollar investment, 1,300 jobs and 100 per
cent renewables was completely ignored by the mainstream media. You’d
think it would be a great story for prime minister Jobson Grothe.
And that explains the battle over baseload. The media runs with the
coal industry talking point, it is infused in their discussions. How
else could we deliver reliable energy, they ask.
Well,
by using smarter, cleaner, faster and more reliable technology for one
thing, would be the answer from the likes of AEMO boss Audrey Zibelman.
The new demand management recommendations coming from ARENA and the
Institute of Sustainable Futures shows how these concepts like demand
management can deliver the flexibility that the modern energy system
needs, and save heaps on the cost of poles and wires.
The key point is that it is important to have enough power to meet
demand at all times – but there are smarter ways of doing this than
simply relying on large, inflexible generators – that just happen to be
dirtier and more expensive than the alternatives.
The Brattle Report, like a similar analysis by the
Climate Policy Initiative, and so many others before it, tries to puncture some of the myth-making around baseload.
Just because a coal generator is big, and can go for 24 hours uninterrupted, does not make it reliable.
To start with, the they can and do have unexplained outages, and the
need for maintenance means that system planners have had to build in
significant system upgrades, back-up and transmission infrastructure to
spread generation over a larger region.
The planners also had to provide “contingency” management processes
to avoid blackouts when one or more of these large power plants
experienced unexpected outages. All the redundancy that critics
say have to be built for wind and solar, have already been built for
coal and gas.
Brattle points out events in Texas in 2011 when an unexpected cold
snap forced 7GW of coal and gas-fired generation offline as equipment
froze. Some 3GW of wind power was uninterrupted and helped keep the
lights on.
Similarly, during the 2014 “Polar Vortex,” many coal and gas plants
had difficulties generating power, as equipment froze and coal
deliveries were stopped. Wind resources in the Midwest consistently
produced power that helped to save electricity customers more than $US1
billion in two days.
In Australia, heat waves are having similar impacts. Reports into the
various outages, load shedding and price spikes in Australia this past
summer
almost always point to the loss of capacity at coal and gas plants due to heat stress as the heart of the problem.
But still, to many people, the basic premise of the traditional
utility planning processes developed over the last few decades remains
unchanged today, despite the fact that wind and solar are killing coal
on costs, and battery storage and other smart software has emerged to
provide faster and more efficient controls, and do things that big
coal-fired power stations could never do.
Brattle argues that system reliability is achieved through a mix of
resources, not by any single unit. “There is no special need for
continuous power supply to come from a single unit (when available and
not on outage) rather than a mix of resources,” it notes.
“It is a misconception that “baseload” plants (or any plants, for
that matter) are 100% reliable,” it says. “Coal and nuclear plants
periodically go on outage, and when they do, their outages tend to be
long.
“No generating plants operate 100% reliably in all hours of the year.
All generators are prone to occasional unexpected outages and must
regularly go offline for maintenance outages.
The report from CPI reached the same conclusion, affirming that
baseload is an outdated term and that “reliability is a
technology-neutral concept.”
“Electricity systems have always been managed ‘flexibly’,” it notes.
“Weather, work patterns, industry, or even sports schedules create
predictable or unexpected drops or spikes in demand.
“Sudden system failures, such as power station or transmission
outages, mean that backup generation has always been required to keep
the lights on. “
If
renewable generation and battery storage prices continue to fall in
line with forecasts, meeting demand in each hour of a year with 80 per
cent of electricity coming from wind and solar could cost as little as
$US70/MWh – even when accounting for required short-term reserves,
flexibility and backup generation.
In Australia, with even greater wind and solar resources, this is
expected to be around the same price, but in Australian dollars. Either
way, it is cheaper than what we have got now.
And the US modelling was done with cheap gas prices. Australia’s
Finkel Review came up with a much higher number because it assumed that
gas would be needed to replace coal, a highly contentious assumption
that seems to perpetuate the “baseload” myth.
The CPI looked at grids and energy mixes in the US, India, Europe and Scandinavia.
“A lack of flexible capacity is often cited as a constraint on the
amount of variable renewable energy we can add to the grid. But in our
report, we found that most systems already have enough latent
flexibility to meet over 30 per cent of their electricity demand from
solar and wind.”
That is exactly the conclusion of the CSIRO, which points out that in
Australia there is so much back-up already built into the grid, that
anything less than 50 per cent wind and solar might be considered
“trivial” in some areas.
And they both agree on the second point: “Moreover, technologies that
exist today could support much higher shares of wind and solar; 80% or
more.” That means little if any “baseload”. Reliability is they key.
Nectar Farms now understands this, it is time for politicians and
mainstream media to move on.
Links