Post Carbon Institute - Richard Heinberg
My
most recent essay,
in which I discussed a highly publicized controversy over the efficacy
of plans for a comprehensive transition to an all-renewable energy
future, garnered some strong responses.
“If you are right,” one Facebook
commenter opined, “we are doomed. Fortunately you are not right.” (The
commenter didn’t explain why.)
What had I said to provoke an expectation
of cataclysmic oblivion? Simply that there is probably no technically
and financially feasible energy pathway to enable those of us in highly
industrialized countries to maintain current levels of energy usage very
far into the future.
My piece happened to be published right around the same time
New York Magazine released a controversial article titled
“The Uninhabitable Earth,” in
which author David Wallace Wells portrayed a dire future if the most
pessimistic climate change models turn to reality. “It is, I promise,
worse than you think,” wrote Wells. “If your anxiety about global
warming is dominated by fears of sea-level rise, you are barely
scratching the surface of what terrors are possible, even within the
lifetime of a teenager today.”
Wells’s article drew rebukes from—of all
people—climate scientists, who pointed out a few factual errors, but
also insisted that scaring the public just doesn’t help. “Importantly,
fear does not motivate,”
responded Michael Mann with
Susan Joy Hassol and Tom Toles, “and appealing to it is often
counter-productive as it tends to distance people from the problem,
leading them to disengage, doubt and even dismiss it.”
It’s true: apocalyptic warnings don’t move most people. Or, rather,
they move most people away from the source of discomfort, so they simply
tune out. But it’s also true that people feel a sense of deep,
unacknowledged unease when they are fed “solutions” that they
instinctively know are false or insufficient.
Others came to Wells’s defense. Margaret Klein Salamon, a clinical psychologist and founder of the climate action group
The Climate Mobilization,
which advocates for starting a “World War II-scale” emergency
mobilization to convert from fossil fuels, writes, “it is OK, indeed
imperative, to tell the whole, frightening story. . . . [I]t’s the job
of those of us trying to protect humanity and restore a safe climate to
tell the truth about the climate crisis and help people process and
channel their own feelings—not to preemptively try to manage and
constrain those feelings.”
So: Are we doomed if we can’t maintain current and growing energy
levels? And are we doomed anyway due to now-inevitable impacts of
climate change?
First, the good news. With regard to energy, we should keep in mind
the fact that today’s Americans use roughly twice as much per capita as
their great-grandparents did in 1925. While people in that era enjoyed
less mobility and fewer options for entertainment and communication than
we do today, they nevertheless managed to survive and even thrive. And
we now have the ability to provide many services (such as lighting) far
more efficiently, so it should be possible to reduce per-capita energy
usage dramatically while still maintaining a lifestyle that would be
considered more than satisfactory by members of previous generations and
by people in many parts of the world today. And reducing energy usage
would make a whole raft of problems—climate change, resource depletion,
the challenge of transitioning to renewable energy sources—much easier
to solve.
The main good news with regard to climate change that I can point to (as I did
in an essay posted
in June) is that economically recoverable fossil fuel reserves are
consistent only with lower-emissions climate change scenarios. As BP and
other credible sources for coal, oil, and natural gas reserves figures
show, and as more and more researchers are pointing out, the worst-case
climate scenarios associated with “business as usual” levels of carbon
emissions are in fact unrealistic.
Now, the bad news. While we could live perfectly well with less
energy, that’s not what the managers of our economy want. They want
growth. Our entire economy is structured to require constant, compounded
growth of GDP, and for all practical purposes
raising the GDP means using more energy.
While fringe economists and environmentalists have for years been
proposing ways to back away from our growth addiction (for example, by
using alternative economic indices such as Gross National Happiness),
none of these proposals has been put into widespread effect. As things
now stand, if growth falters the economy crashes.
There’s bad climate news as well: even with current levels of
atmospheric greenhouse gases, we’re seeing unacceptable and worsening
impacts—raging fires, soaring heat levels, and melting icecaps. And
there are hints that self-reinforcing feedbacks maybe kicking in: an
example is the release of large amounts of
methane from thawing tundra and oceanic hydrates,
which could lead to a short-term but steep spike in warming. Also, no
one is sure if current metrics of climate sensitivity (used to estimate
the response of the global climate system to a given level of forcing)
are accurate, or whether the climate is actually more sensitive than we
have assumed. There’s some
worrisome evidence the latter is case.
But let’s step back a bit. If we’re interested in signs of impending
global crisis, there’s no need to stop with just these two global
challenges. The world is losing 25 billion tons of topsoil a year due to
current industrial agricultural practices; if we don’t deal with that
issue, civilization will still crash even if we do manage to ace our
energy and climate test. Humanity is also over-using fresh water:
ancient aquifers are depleting, while other water sources are being
polluted. If we don’t deal with our water crisis, we still crash.
Species are going extinct at a thousand times the pre-industrial rate;
if we don’t deal with the biodiversity dilemma, we still crash. Then
there are social and economic problems that could cause nations to
crumble even if we manage to protect the environment; this threat
category includes the menaces of over-reliance on debt and increasing
economic inequality.
If we attack each of these problems piecemeal with technological
fixes (for example, with desalination technology to solve the water
crisis or geo-engineering to stabilize the climate) we may still crash
because our techno-fixes are likely to have unintended consequences, as
all technological interventions do. Anyway, the likelihood of
successfully identifying and deploying all the needed fixes in time is
vanishingly small.
Many problems are converging at once because society is a complex
system, and the challenges we have been discussing are aspects of a
systemic crisis. A useful way to frame an integrated understanding of
the 21
st century survival challenge is this:
we humans have overshot Earth’s long-term carrying capacity for our species. We’ve
been able to do this due to a temporary subsidy of cheap, bountiful
energy from fossil fuels, which enabled us to stretch nature’s limits
and to support a far larger overall population than would otherwise be
possible. But now we are starting to see supply constraints for those
fuels, just as the side effects of burning enormous amounts of coal,
oil, and natural gas are also coming into view. Meanwhile, using cheap
energy to expand resource-extractive and waste-generating economic
processes is leading to biodiversity loss; the depletion of soil, water,
and minerals; and environmental pollution of many kinds. Just
decarbonizing energy, while necessary, doesn’t adequately deal with
systemic overshoot. Only a reduction of population and overall resource
consumption, along with a rapid reduction in our reliance on fossil
fuels and a redesign of industrial systems, can do that.
Economic inequality is a systemic problem too. As we’ve grown our
economy, those who were in position to invest in industrial expansion or
to loan money to others have reaped the majority of the rewards, while
those who got by through selling their time and labor (or whose common
cultural heritage was simply appropriated by industrialists) have fallen
behind. There’s no technological fix for inequality; dealing with it
will require redesigning our economic system and redistributing wealth.
Those in wealthy nations would, on average, have to adjust their living
standards downward.
Now, can we do all of this without a crash? Probably not. Indeed,
many economists would regard the medicine (population reduction, a
decline in per-capita energy use, and economic redistribution) as worse
than whatever aspects of the disease they are willing to acknowledge.
Environmentalists and human rights advocates would disagree. Which is to
say, there’s really no way out. Whether we stick with business as
usual, or attempt a dramatic multi-pronged intervention, our current
“normal” way of life is toast.
Accepting that a crash is more or less inevitable is a big step, psychologically speaking. I call this
toxic knowledge:
one cannot “un-know” that the current world system hangs by a thread,
and this understanding can lead to depression. In some ways, the
systemic crisis we face is analogous to the individual existential
crisis of life and death, which we each have to confront eventually.
Some willfully ignore their own mortality for as long as possible;
others grasp at a belief in the afterlife. Still others seek to create
meaning and purpose by making a positive difference in the lives of
those around them with whatever time they have. Such efforts don’t alter
the inevitability of death; however, contributing to one’s community
appears to enhance well-being in many ways beyond that of merely
prolonging life.
But is a crash the same as doom?
Not necessarily. Our best hope at this point would seem to be a
controlled crash that enables partial recovery at a lower level of
population and resource use, and that therefore doesn’t lead to complete
and utter oblivion (human extinction or close to it). Among those who
understand the systemic nature of our problems, the controlled crash
option is the subject of what may be the most interesting and important
conversation that’s taking place on the planet just now. But only
informed people who have gotten over denial and self-delusion are part
of it.
This discussion started in the 1970s, though I wasn’t part of it
then; I joined a couple of decades later. There is no formal membership;
the conversation takes place through and among a patchwork of small
organizations and scattered individuals. They don’t all know each other
and there is no secret handshake. Some have publicly adopted the stance
that a global crash is inevitable; most soft-pedal that message on their
organizational websites but are privately plenty worried. During the
course of the conversation so far, two (not mutually exclusive)
strategies have emerged.
The first strategy envisions convincing the managers and power
holders of the world to invest in a no-regrets insurance plan. Some
systems thinkers who understand our linked global crises are offering to
come up with a back-pocket checklist for policy makers, for moments
when financial or environmental crisis hits: how, under such
circumstances, might the managerial elite be able to prevent, say, a
stock market crash from triggering food, energy, and social crises as
well? A set of back-up plans wouldn’t require detailed knowledge of when
or how crisis will erupt. It wouldn’t even require much of a systemic
understanding of global overshoot. It would simply require willingness
on the part of societal power holders to agree that there are real or
potential threats to global order, and to accept the offer of help. At
the moment, those pursuing this strategy are working mostly covertly,
for reasons that are not hard to discern.
The second strategy consists of working within communities to build
more societal resilience from the ground up. It is easier to get
traction with friends and neighbors than with global power holders, and
it’s within communities that political decisions are made closest to
where the impact is felt. My own organization, Post Carbon Institute,
has chosen to pursue this strategy via a series of books, the
Community Resilience Guides; the
“Think Resilience” video series; and our forthcoming compendium,
The Community Resilience Reader. Rob Hopkins, who originated the
Transition Towns movement,
has been perhaps the most public, eloquent, and upbeat proponent of the
local resilience strategy, but there are countless others scattered
across the globe.
Somehow, the work of resilience building (whether top-down or
bottom-up) must focus not just on maintaining supplies of food, water,
energy, and other basic necessities, but also on sustaining social
cohesion—a culture of understanding, tolerance, and inquiry—during times
of great stress. While it’s true that people tend to pull together in
remarkable ways during wars and natural disasters, sustained hard times
can lead to scapegoating and worse.
Most people are not party to the conversation, not aware that it is
happening, and unaware even that such a conversation is warranted. Among
those who are worried about the state of the world, most are content to
pursue or support efforts to keep crises from occurring by working via
political parties, religious organizations, or non-profit advocacy orgs
on issues such as climate change, food security, and economic
inequality. There is also a small but rapidly growing segment of society
that feels disempowered as the era of economic growth wanes, and that
views society’s power holders as evil and corrupt. These
dispossessed—whether followers of ISIS or Infowars—would prefer to
“shake things up,” even to the point of bringing society to destruction,
rather than suffer the continuation of the status quo. Unfortunately,
this last group may have the easiest path of all.
By comparison, the number of those involved in the conversation is
exceedingly small, countable probably in the hundreds of thousands,
certainly not millions.
Can we succeed? It depends on how one
defines “success”—as the ability to maintain, for a little longer, an
inherently unsustainable global industrial system? Or as the practical
reduction in likely suffering on the part of the survivors of the
eventual crash? A related query one often hears after environmental
lectures is,
Are we doing enough? If “Enough” means “enough to
avert a system crash,” then the answer is no: it’s unlikely that anyone
can deliver that outcome now. The question should be, What
can we do—not to save a way of life that is unsalvageable, but to make a difference to the people and other species in harm’s way?
This is not a conversation about the long-term trajectory of human
cultural evolution, though that’s an interesting subject for
speculation. Assuming there are survivors, what will human society look
like following the crises ensuing from climate change and the end of
fossil fuels and capitalism? David Fleming’s
Surviving the Future and John Michael Greer’s
The Ecotechnic Future offer
useful thoughts in this regard. My own view is that it’s hard for us to
envision what comes next because our imaginations are bounded by the
reality we have known. What awaits will likely be as far removed from
from modern industrial urban life as Iron-Age agrarian empires were from
hunting-and-gathering bands. We are approaching one of history’s great
discontinuities. The best we can do under the circumstances is to get
our priorities and values straight (protect the vulnerable, preserve the
best of what we have collectively achieved, and live a life that’s
worthy) and put one foot in front of the other.
The conversation I’m pointing to here is about fairly short-term
actions. And it doesn’t lend itself to building a big movement. For
that, you need villains to blame and promises of revived national or
tribal glory. For those engaged in the conversation, there’s only hard
work and the satisfaction of honestly facing our predicament with an
attitude of curiosity, engagement, and compassion. For us, threats of
doom or promises of utopia are distractions or cop-outs.
Only those drawn to the conversation by temperament and education are
likely to take it up. Advertising may not work. But having a few more
hands on deck, and a few more resources to work with, can only help.
Links