Expanding access to lithium is crucial to meet demand for new green technologies to reduce carbon emissions
Electric car cables plugged into a charging point of the car sharing
company Zen Car are seen in Brussels, Belgium August 10, 2017.
REUTERS/Francois Lenoir
TORONTO - Scientists have found
an unexpected new source for lithium, a key component in battery-powered
electric cars and other renewable energy technologies: supervolcanoes.
Most of the world's lithium comes from Chile and Australia, and
expanding access to the mineral is crucial for meeting demand for new
green technologies to reduce carbon emissions, Stanford University
scientists said on Wednesday.
"The demand for lithium has outpaced the scientific understanding of
the resource, so it's essential for the fundamental science behind these
resources to catch up," Stanford University researcher Thomas Benson,
the study's lead author, said in a statement.
"Now we have a way to easily find more of these lithium deposits."
The discovery comes as more companies, including large carmakers
whose products cause significant carbon emissions, work to develop
climate-friendly technologies.
Electric cars, which use lithium ion batteries, are gaining traction as an emission-free alternative to conventional cars.
"We're going to have to use electric vehicles and large storage
batteries to decrease our carbon footprint," Gail Mahood, a professor of
geological sciences at Stanford University and the study's co-author,
said.
Supervolcanoes are much larger than ordinary volcanoes and erupt at least 1,000 cubic kilometres of material in one eruption.
Scientists studied the contents of craters left by supervolcanoes in
Oregon, Nevada and other parts of the United States, which erupted
millions of years ago.
They sliced through tiny bits of volcanic magma, which were trapped
in crystals in the craters, and analysed them to find the valuable
silvery-white metal.
Sweden-based Volvo pledged last month that all new cars it launches after 2019 will be electric vehicles or hybrids.
Other automobile firms are also planning to increase production of
electric vehicles, which will boost the demand for lithium, considered a
strategic resources by some governments.
The number of electric vehicles on roads worldwide rose to a record
high of 2 million last year, according to the International Energy
Agency (IEA), accounting for 0.2 percent of the global count. Links
The Solomon Islands are an archipelago filled with idyllic beaches and
perfect waves, but as temperatures and sea levels rise, much of their
pristine coast is disappearing FROM the window seat of our small aircraft, the
islands 13,000 feet beneath us looked like uncut emeralds poking out of a
vibrant azure pool. I pressed my nose up against the Plexiglas to study
the contours of each one. Dense forests blanketed the isles, bisected
by brown, winding rivers. On their perimeters sat palm-fringed,
white-sand beaches. The only signs of human development here in this
remote, northern region of the Solomon Islands — a 1,000-island
archipelago located just northeast of Australia, between Papua New
Guinea and Vanuatu — were small clusters of houses settled along the
coastlines, their corrugated tin roofs reflecting the sun back up at us.
Across
the aisle from me, surfers Torren Martyn and Leila Hurst and
photographer Ryan Craig had their eyes glued on trails of whitewater
below. They were pointing out the seemingly endless number of breaking
waves, feverishly tapping on the windows at the sight of any potential
setup.
"Mate, look at that one over there," yelled Martyn over the
roar of the engine, spotting an offshore reef pass that was reeling
amid the solid north swell. Whitewater spilled over a chunk of reef,
tracing what looked to be an empty A-frame.
Much of the Solomon
Islands are remote and hard to access, leaving large swaths of
coastlines — mainly along two of the biggest north-facing islands,
Choiseul and Santa Isabel — empty, unexplored and full of surf
potential.
From cruising altitude, the Solomon Islands looked like a Technicolor
slice of untouched paradise, a tropical playground for visiting
surfers. But as plentiful as the waves appeared to be, getting barreled
in empty lineups was only half the reason we were here. The other was to
visit these islands before any more of them disappeared into the ocean.
A
few months prior to our visit, I came in contact with Dr. Simon Albert,
a marine scientist at the University of Queensland. He and his
colleagues had recently discovered, using time series and satellite
imagery, that five Solomon Islands had been swallowed by the sea over
the last 70 years, and another six islands had severely eroded. The
cause was determined to be accelerated sea-level rise.
The landscape of the Solomon Islands is the stuff of travel brochures.
But as beautiful as the scenery may be, the country is steadily losing
land to rising sea levels. Not far from this island, five other islands
have been completely swallowed by the ocean.
"Over the last 20 years, the rates of sea-level rise in the Solomon
Islands have been three times higher than the global average," said
Albert. "That's about an 8 or 9 millimeter rise each year." Half of that
number, he explained, is the result of El NiƱo cycles, which naturally
siphon the world's water into the South Pacific. The other culprit is
climate change.
In some parts of the country, this rapid sea-level
rise, combined with high wave intensity, has eroded beaches and
destroyed people's properties. Even over the short span of five years,
many have watched the ocean come into their villages and carry homes
away.
"The changes have been really swift," said Albert. "People
living on those islands are feeling very physically and psychologically
insecure because they're feeling like their entire foundation of life is
washing away."
Albert sent me two photos to help illustrate the
problem. One was a snapshot of a thatched-roof house tipped over on its
side, collapsing into the ocean, the high tide rushing into where the
living-room windows used to be. The other was an aerial shot of
Beneamina, a small, circular island near Santa Isabel jam-packed with
about 30 houses, many of them sitting on the water's edge. This island,
Albert explained, is now only half the size it was 10 years ago. "When I
was there in December, an island nearby had one house on it," he said.
"By the time we returned in February, that house had been washed away."
The majority of seaside villages in the Solomon Islands, explained
Albert, are fairly young. Before the 20th century, most natives were
fierce headhunters and engaged in intense tribal warfare. They lived in
the hills for security, so they could easily spot invading tribes. But
when Christian missionaries arrived in the early 1900s, they encouraged
the Solomon Islanders to come down to the coast, build churches and live
their lives by the ocean. Now almost 85 percent of the population lives
along the coastline, and, ironically, many communities are now being
chased back up into the hills — not by spear-wielding warriors, but by
an intruding ocean.
Most people talk about sea-level rise and
other consequences of climate change using the future tense — as
something our coastal-dwelling grandchildren will have to deal with 100
years from now. But according to Albert, that dystopian future has
already arrived in parts of the Solomon Islands. "The rates we're seeing
there are the rates we're likely to see over the next 50 years around
the world as things get worse," says Albert. "In a way, the Solomon
Islands provide a window into the future."
Throughout the Solomon Islands, many homes skirt the shoreline and are vulnerable to impending sea level rise. During extreme high tides, this dock becomes level with the water line.
OVER the course of his life, the ocean will likely
chase Jeremy Baea farther and farther inland. But for now, the
25-year-old spends most of his days running toward it.
We first
met Baea inside the mobile phone store where he works, located along the
main road in Gizo, a bustling tourist and commercial center in the
southwestern region of the Solomon Islands. The chatter of vendors
selling fresh fish and vegetables nearby at the lively waterfront market
poured into the store, along with the whirrs of motorboats unmooring
from the wharf.
Behind the counter, two surfboards leaned against
the wall near the shop's computer. When Baea, who is half Solomon
Islander and half Australian, isn't busy at the shop, he serves as the
founding president of the nascent Western Solomon's Surfing Association,
which he established a few years ago with his younger brother Shemiah.
One
morning before work, Baea, along with Shemiah and their father, Patson,
took us surfing at Titiana, a hollow, freight-train left that breaks
over shallow reef. The sun had just peaked over the horizon and the
soft, pastel colors of dawn still
lingered in the sky. The waves were only about chest high — small by
Solomon standards — but the conditions were oil glass and the lefts
perfectly shaped.
This region of the South Pacific hosts a bevy of waves and many of them remain unsurfed.This particular left, commonly referred to as Titiana, is home turk for the Western Solomon Island’s Surfing Association and is one of the more populated breaks in the country. Martyn, sitting stylish on a low-tide runner.
Shemiah had broken his board a few months prior, and since surf gear
is nearly impossible to come by in this corner of the world, he and Baea
were taking turns on an old, rockered-out 6’2″. While Shemiah was in
the water schooling our crew with his local knowledge, I asked Baea and
his father about the effects of sea-level rise in the local area.
According
to Baea, although Gizo has suffered less-drastic coastal erosion than
islands in the northern region of the country that are exposed to larger
surf, this area has still seen its fair share of change. "I think in
the next 10 years things will look completely different," he explained.
Baea's
family owns a small bed-and-breakfast on a tiny island not too far from
Gizo. Back in the 1950s, Baea's grandfather purchased their island,
along with two others, for a mere 15 British pounds. All three of their
islands are now smaller than they were back then, and they're shrinking
more each year. "We're starting to look at other options, like building
seawalls or moving to the mainland," said Baea.
It wouldn't be the
first time Baea and his family were forced to flee their home. Back in
2007, a massive earthquake triggered a tsunami that struck the Solomon
Islands and wiped out more than 13 villages, killing 52 people. "It was
about seven in the morning," said Baea, remembering the day. "We had
just woken up and I was sitting outside by the water when everything
started shaking."
Located along the Pacific Ring of Fire, the
Solomon Islands are seismically active and they experience half a dozen
tremors each year. Baea initially thought it was just a small quake,
"but it wouldn't stop shaking," he said. "It just kept going
and going and going. When it stopped, that's then we noticed the water started sucking out."
Baea
and his family quickly piled into their boat. They picked up his
grandmother, who lives on a neighboring island, raced out to deep waters
and waited for the first surge to pass. "Riding out the tsunami was
very scary," said Baea. "The water out
there is usually very calm, but it was like a washing machine, with really strong currents, waves and whitewater everywhere."
“If we stop being friendly to the environment, the future is going to be really bleak,” said Patson Baea, a 58-year-old local who’s lived in the Solomon Islands his entire life. “But one island or country can’t really do anything about it. It has to be all of us.”
Once the first surge passed, they made a mad dash to Gizo, where they
could run for higher ground before the next surge. "The boat ride to
Gizo was surreal," said Baea. "We watched entire houses float by in the
water; rubbish was everywhere. The whole time, we knew that we had
probably lost our home too."
When Baea and his family finally
returned to their island, their beautiful wooden bungalows were
completely demolished. It took them three years to rebuild.
Patson
remembers the community's collective fear following the tsunami. "Even
three months after, people still weren't out fishing or doing things in
the ocean," he said. "We never thought about the sea that way before,
that it could come up and take all of your belongings. It was the first
time we looked at the ocean differently. We've always known that the sea
belongs out there; it doesn't belong up here on land."
Patson,
who's 58 and sporting a full head of salt-and-pepper hair, has also seen
the ocean engulf entire islands, one in particular where he would take
the kids when they were little.
After our session, Patson took us
to this vanishing island. As we neared it, Shemiah jumped off the boat
and paddled up to what was just a tiny sand bank. The island, Patson
told me, used to be the size of a football field and was filled with
large trees that were surrounded by a pristine ivory beach. They would
camp out, play soccer and picnic beneath the trees' shade. Now, less
than a decade later, the island was no bigger than an end zone, with
rotting tree trunks lying in the middle.
"If we don't behave in
the next 50 years, all these islands will be gone," Patson said,
motioning to the 10 or so small islands in our view. "I'm always trying
to picture what the scenario will be when the kids are older. But I
think it's very hard to imagine."
Just a couple decades ago, this tiny, barren sandbank was a tree-laden island the size of a football field.
BY Solomon standards, the people living in Gizo are
the lucky ones. The town and surrounding villages are built along the
coast of a mountainous island, so when oceans expand and storms become
more frequent as a result of climate change, people can move to higher
ground. But not everyone in the Solomon Islands has an easy escape
route. For the 600 residents that inhabit Taro Island, a low-lying,
kilometer-long atoll that sits no higher than 6 feet above sea level,
their only option is relocating their entire village, which is exactly
what they plan to do.
Despite its small footprint, Taro Island
serves as the capital of Choiseul province and contains a hospital,
grass airstrip, courthouse, schoolyard, police station, government
buildings and a few churches. The leaders of Taro have developed plans
to build a similar town from scratch on the nearby mainland — one that
will be better positioned to survive the future perils of sea-level rise
and climate change. But according to Taro's deputy provincial
secretary, Geoffrey Pakipota, relocating an entire town, even a modest
one like Taro, is easier said than done.
We met Pakipota in front
of the main government administration building, a raised, single-story
wooden structure encompassing a manicured courtyard. Across the dirt
road, a school bell rang and throngs of children poured out of their
classrooms into the large grass field that sits in the center of town.
The midday heat was sweltering, so he led us into an air-conditioned
conference room.
Pakipota, who is soft-spoken and has an affinity
for Hawaiian-print shirts, told me he's been working on the plans to
relocate the island since 1994, when the town decided to expand to
accommodate a growing population. But after the 2007 tsunami, the
leaders of Taro realized a more urgent reason to move: their
vulnerability to extreme weather events and rising sea levels.
From this perspective, Taro’s quickly changing coastlines can be difficult to detect. But in the next century, these homes could be entirely underwater. To prepare for that day, the local government is planning to relocate the island’s residents.
"There's nowhere to escape on this island," said Pakipota. During
tsunami events, like the one in 2007, it takes about two hours to
evacuate everyone and get them across the bay to the mainland, a process
that would leave them little chance of survival if the tsunami were
more intense or originated closer to their island.
In the time
that Pakipota has been in government, he's noticed huge changes to the
shape of Taro. He led us out of the conference room and toward the
shore, just a short distance from his office. We stood on the beach next
to a huge fallen tree with gnarled roots sticking up out of the ground,
the latest victim of saltwater intrusion. He pointed to a string of
buoys about 20 feet out to sea. "Fifteen years ago, that's where our
main market was," he said. It was completely submerged and a small dock
had been built in its place.
Pakipota then pointed across the bay,
toward the mainland. "That's where the new township will be," he said.
"It takes about three minutes by boat to get there." Taking into account
future sea-level predictions, the proposed settlement will sit about 1
or 2 miles inland. "It will be away from the sea," explained Pakipota.
"We're trying to build a modern, green, climate proof town. The whole
coastal strip will be preserved as a buffer."
The plans for the
proposed new settlement had recently been approved by the national
government, but securing the property was a huge hurdle. The majority of
the land in the Solomon Islands, Pakipota explained, is owned by
villages or families and is passed down only within communities. In
other villages that have been forced to hastily relocate because of
rising sea levels — like an island nearby that had been split into two
by water — arguments over rightful land ownership have caused internal
strife. For Taro, it took them almost 20 years of negotiations and
roughly $1.1 million to acquire the land they needed.
Even though
the plans have been rubber-stamped and the project is moving forward,
everything will likely come to a standstill if Taro can't procure enough
financial support (an estimated $50 million will be needed for the
construction of the new settlement and relocation of Taro's residents)
from the national government, which will be the biggest obstacle yet.
"We
love this place, but people are getting impatient and are pressing the
government to do something," said Pakipota. "Whatever the investment,
people need to be safe. If we spend billions of [Solomon] dollars on
taking care of this town where
it sits, if anything happens, it will all be gone. Instead, we need the government to invest money in a safer place."
The majority of Solomon Islanders depend on the sea for their food and their livelihood, which makes moving farther inland uphill or more difficult for residents.
THE global sea level is now 5 to 8 inches higher
than it was in 1900, primarily due to man-made climate change, and it's
rising at a faster rate than it has in the previous 6,000 years. In the
Solomon Islands, sea level is rising even quicker. Just in the past 25
years, the ocean surrounding the Solomon Islands has risen about 6
inches.
Those numbers might not seem significant at a glance, but
one vertical inch of sea-level rise equates to about 100 inches of land
loss on a flat beach. And according to scientists like David Boseto, who
does environmental consulting and auditing
throughout the Solomon Islands, every inch means destruction throughout his home country.
I
met Boseto in his small, halogen-lit office tucked away from the main
road in Gizo. Science textbooks, nature manuals, a Ben Carson
autobiography and the Bible were piled on his desk. Old and current maps
of the Solomon Islands hung on the walls. He invited me to sit down and
explained the details of his job, which includes surveying the impact
of climate change throughout his country and helping people adapt to the
threat of sea-level rise.
"There are a lot of cross-sectional
issues we are facing throughout the country related to climate change,"
said Boseto. He began listing them off like a narrator in a late-night
infomercial citing all the side effects of a new medication: In the
Solomon Islands, climate change has caused an increase in malaria,
earthquakes, tsunamis and cyclones; it's led to more irregular seasons,
leaving people confused as to when they should plant crops; the soil
isn't as fertile as it used to be and crops are now yielding fewer fruit
and vegetables; fish are moving farther and farther from shore and are
less abundant than they were 10 years ago; coral reefs are dying. But
the most visible symptom of climate change is the rising ocean and the
littoral erosion that accompanies it.
Leila Hurst, banking hard off the bottom on one of the country’s finest gems.
"Most of the communities near the ocean are having to move back 10,
15 meters because their beach is eroding," said Boseto. "Village
drinking wells along the coast are becoming too salty to consume. Now
when there is an extended dry season, people have to boil their salty
well water and drink that."
To combat sea-level rise, people are
planting mangroves, constructing seawalls and moving to higher ground.
But none of these methods, Boseto explained, are perfect solutions.
Mangroves can be planted only in areas with low wave intensity. Seawalls
are good short-term solutions, but when built haphazardly, they protect
one man's property while transferring that blocked wave energy to a
neighbor's. Plus, seawalls prevent the natural buildup of sand during
storm events, which normally helps rebuild lost beaches.
Moving
uphill and building on steep, rocky land has its challenges as well.
"Low-lying areas are more suitable for island living because you have
access to the sea for transportation — to travel to school and clinics
and to have access to food sources," said Boseto. "But when people move
uphill, they're far from those things, and they're subject to landslides
during earthquakes and heavy rains."
The Green Climate Fund, a
financial reservoir created by the United Nations, was designed to
mobilize $100 billion a year to help developing countries like the
Solomon Islands cut emissions and adapt to the risks of climate change.
But in order for people in smaller villages to benefit from this fund,
they need their central government in the capital of Honiara to apply
for this money on their behalf. According to some, there's a substantial
disconnect between villagers on smaller islands and those who decide
how to best disburse the money from the Green Climate Fund.
A disappearing landscape.
In the early 2000s, Honiara was embroiled in ethnic violence and
political upheaval, which left the capital in a state of chaos and
economic disarray. Many believe that in the years since, Honiara has
been so focused on reassembling itself that it's overlooked the needs of
people in more-remote villages who are dealing with acute sea-level
rise. For example, just a month ago the Solomon Islands acquired an $86
million subsidy from the Green Climate Fund for a hydro-development
project that will provide cheap electricity for the capital's denizens.
Meanwhile, people in places like Taro, who are watching their coastlines
vanish, are having a difficult time procuring the necessary capital to
relocate.
As good-natured as it may seem for developed nations to
donate money to smaller nations that feel strangled by the chokehold of
climate change, Boseto believes the Solomon Islands need more than guilt
money.
"This is just a Band-Aid solution," said Boseto. "Bigger
countries are saying, 'OK, we've emitted this much, so we will pay you
this much money to help you adapt to what we've done.' But that's not
what we are saying we need."
What they need, Boseto explained, is
for big, industrialized countries to address the root problem and reduce
their output of greenhouse gasses. They need the rest of the world to
collectively commit to turning down the global thermostat.
Eric Waiara’a, at home with his family.
LIKE most Solomon Islanders, almost everything
30-year-old Eric Waiara'a does revolves around the ocean. After working
as a science teacher near the capital for many years, he moved to the
small coastal village of Kolipakisa to be with his wife and two sons.
Now he spends most of his time fishing, diving for sea cucumbers and
chauffeuring visiting surfers around in search of waves.
We
conscripted Waiara'a to help us hunt down one of the best breaks in the
region, near the island of Santa Isabel, where Dr. Simon Albert had
found the five sunken islands. A midday thundershower had just cleared
and billowy, soft-hued storm clouds hung in its wake like unfurling
cotton candy. With Waiara'a at the helm of the boat, we zipped through
the warm, glassy waters while flying fish skipped along the ocean's
surface next to us. In the distance, we could see whitewater lining
up on the horizon.
We arrived at a shallow offshore reef where
double-overhead waves were marching in from deep water, hitting a shelf
and folding over themselves, forming shifty, powerful tubes. It looked
every bit as good as the most popular Indonesian breaks, but without
another boatload of surfers anywhere in sight.
Martyn began
frantically waxing his board and screwing in fins. It took only about 20
seconds before he was over the side of the boat and scratching into the
lineup.
He passed on the first wave of a thundering set, trying
to gauge its power. When the next one came through, he paddled deep and
swung underneath it. Sucking up off the reef, the wave seemed to drop
out beneath Martyn, but his fins gripped the face and he stood tall with
his trailing hand skimming the inside of the crystal-clear cylinder. As
he kicked out amid a cloud of spit, Waiara'a let out a bellowing laugh
from the boat, exposing his gap-toothed smile.
Martyn, below sea level. Although the waves in the Solomon Islands are often perfect, there’s a chance that the waves here could change shape under forecasted sea levels. “We could definitely hypothesize that as sea levels rise faster than coral are able to grow–which is the case in the Solomon Islands–breaks are going to become deeper and wave intensity might decrease,” says scientist Javier Leon.
Watching the scene in the lineup, and the distinct natural beauty
that surrounded us, it was hard to reconcile the area's idyllic
appearance with the increasingly challenging reality the environment and
local communities face. The International Panel for Climate Change
reports that sea-level rise is likely to increase by 3.22 feet by the
end of this century. Greenland and Antarctica are melting quicker than
ever before. Recent studies point to a segment in Antarctica called the
Amundsen Sea sector that has gone into "irreversible decline." The body
of ice there holds enough water to raise sea levels by another 4 feet,
and its eventual melting could destabilize other parts of the adjoining
ice sheets. The effects of this would spell disaster not only for the
oceanfront settlements in the Solomon Islands, but for coastal areas
worldwide.
Experts believe curbing climate change will require
unified action from the international community, which has proven
difficult due to the politicization of the issue. Back in 2015, 197
countries signed the Paris Climate Agreement, promising to limit
emissions in an effort to keep global warming at or below 2 degrees
Celsius. But many critics believe that the Paris Climate Agreement is
nothing but empty promises, and that governments aren't taking
aggressive enough measures to stop the burning of fossil fuels. The Drowning Isles
Waiara'a told me about how much his village has changed over the
years, and how he and his neighbors have to wade through thigh-high
water during extreme tidal floods in order to get to their homes. Some
people even paddle their dugout canoes straight to their front doors.
I
asked if there was any controversy within his village about whether or
not climate change was real, explaining that in other parts of the
world, people are still skeptical about its actuality. Waiara'a furrowed
his brow and shook his head.
"Of course we believe in climate
change. We see our beaches eroding, we see the saltwater ruining our
coconut trees and we see the small islands beside us disappearing," he
said. "We see it happening all around us."
March for Science, Washington, D.C., April 29, 2017.
Shutterstock.com
This summer I worked on the Greenland ice sheet, part of a scientific
experiment to study surface melting and its contribution to Greenland’s
accelerating ice losses. By virtue of its size, elevation and
currently frozen state, Greenland has the potential to cause large and
rapid increases to sea level as it melts.
When I returned, a nonscientist friend asked me what the research
showed about future sea level rise. He was disappointed that I couldn’t
say anything definite, since it will take several years to analyze the
data. This kind of time lag is common in science, but it can make
communicating the issues difficult. That’s especially true for climate
change, where decades of data collection may be required to see trends.
A recent draft report on climate change
by federal scientists exploits data captured over many decades to
assess recent changes, and warns of a dire future if we don’t change our
ways. Yet few countries are aggressively reducing their emissions in a
way scientists say are needed to avoid the dangers of climate change.
While this lack of progress dismays people, it’s actually
understandable. Human beings have evolved to focus on immediate threats.
We have a tough time dealing with risks that have time lags of decades
or even centuries. As a geoscientist, I’m used to thinking on much
longer time scales, but I recognize that most people are not. I see
several kinds of time lags associated with climate change debates. It’s
important to understand these time lags and how they interact if we hope
to make progress.
Agreeing on the goal
Changing the basic energy underpinnings of our industrial economy
will not be easy or cheap, and will require broad public support. Today
nearly half of Americans – presumably including President Trump, based
on his public comments – do not believe
that humans are the primary cause of modern rapid climate change.
Others admit that humans have contributed, but may not support strict
regulations or big investments in response.
In part, these views reflect the influence of special interest groups
who benefit from our high-carbon “business as usual” economic system.
But they also reflect the complexity of the problem, and the difficulty
scientists have in explaining it. As I point out in my recent book
on how we think about disasters, statements made by scientists in the
1980s, 1990s and early 2000s about global warming were often vague and
full of caveats, which made it easy for climate change skeptics to
forestall action by emphasizing how uncertain the picture was.
Fortunately, scientists are improving at communication. The increasing frequency of coastal flooding, summer heat waves and droughts
could also help to change minds, but it may take a few more decades
before a solid majority of Americans supports high-level action.
Earth’s average temperature has risen
over 1 degree Fahrenheit in the past century. It is projected to rise an
additional 3°F to 10°F over the next 100 years. Designing cleaner technologies
It will also take time for technological developments to support our
transition to a low-carbon energy future. Here, at least, there is
reason for optimism. A few decades ago renewable energy sources such as
wind and solar seemed unlikely to replace a significant fraction of
carbon-based energy. Similarly, electric vehicles seemed unlikely to
meet a significant share of our transportation needs. Today both are
realistic alternatives.
This year wind and solar power hit 10 percent of U.S. electricity generation for the first time. Electric vehicles and hybrids are also becoming more common. The recent advent and rapid adoption of LED lighting could start to have an impact on our electrical consumption.
Thanks to these developments, humanity’s carbon footprint will look
quite different in a few decades. Whether that’s quick enough to avoid 2
degree Celsius of warming is not yet clear.
Funding the transition
Once we finally decide to make a low-carbon transition and figure out how to do it, it will cost trillions of dollars. Capital markets can’t provide that sort of funding instantaneously.
Consider the cost of upgrading just the U.S. housing market. The
United States has approximately 125 million households, of which about
60 percent (75 million) own their own homes. The majority of these are single-family residences.
If we assume that at least 60 million of these residences are
single-family homes, duplexes or townhomes where it is feasible for
residents to upgrade to solar photovoltaic power, then equipping just
half (30 million homes) with a standard solar energy package and battery
storage, at a cost of about US$25,000 per household, would cost nearly a
trillion dollars. Our economy can support this level of capital
investment over one or two decades, but for most of the world it’s going
to take longer.
Solar Charging Station for Electric
Vehicles at Phillips Chevrolet, Frankfort, Illinois. New energy
technologies require infrastructure to support them.Phillipschevy, CC BY-SA
The natural carbon cycle
Our ability to add carbon dioxide to the atmosphere greatly exceeds
nature’s ability to remove it. There is a time lag between carbon
emission and carbon removal. The process is complicated, with multiple
pathways, some of which operate over centuries.
For example, some atmospheric carbon dioxide at the ocean’s surface
dissolves into seawater, forming carbonate ions. Meanwhile, rainfall
weathers rocks on land, slowly breaking them apart and washing calcium
and magnesium ions into rivers and streams and on into the oceans. These
materials combine into minerals such as aragonite, calcite or dolomite,
which eventually sink and become entombed in sedimentary layers at the
bottom of the ocean.
But since this process plays out over many centuries, most of the
carbon dioxide that we put into the atmosphere today will continue to
heat the world for hundreds to thousands of years.
Earth’s carbon supply constantly
cycles between land, atmosphere and oceans. Yellow numbers are natural
fluxes, and red are human contributions in gigatons of carbon per year.
White numbers indicate stored carbon.NASA Earth Observatory
Today the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is just over 400 parts per million, rising by about 3 ppm yearly.
Given the political, technological and economic time lags that we face,
it’s likely that we will hit at least 450-500 ppm before we can
seriously curtail our carbon emissions. The last time Earth’s atmosphere
contained this much carbon dioxide was several million years ago,
during the Pliocene era. Global temperatures were much higher than 2°C above today’s average, and global sea level was at least 6 meters (nearly 20 feet) higher.
We haven’t seen comparable temperature or sea level increases so far because of time lags in Earth’s climate response.
It takes a while for our elevated carbon dioxide levels to trigger
impacts on this scale. Given the various time lags that are in play, it
is quite possible that we have already exceeded the 2°C rise over
preindustrial temperatures – a threshold most scientists say we should
avoid – but it hasn’t shown up on the thermometer yet.
We may not be able to predict exactly how much future temperatures or
sea levels will rise, but we do know that unless we curb our carbon
emissions, our planet will be a very uncomfortable place for our
grandchildren and their grandchildren. Large-scale social changes take
time: they are the sum of many individual changes, in both attitudes and
behaviors. To minimize that time lag, we need to start acting now.
Clean air and a livable climate are
inalienable human rights. And solving this crisis is not a question of
politics. It is a question of our own survival.
Climate change is real. Global warming
is the root cause of climate change. Far too often climate change is
dismissed as an issue for the future. Numerous studies have shown that
the earth’s temperatures are rising, and that’s already harming
countless humans.
According to the World Health
Organization (WHO), air pollution is responsible for the premature
deaths of over 7 million people worldwide per year. “Pollution kills
more people every year than wars, car accidents, and homicides
combined,” Arnold Schwarzenegger has noted.
Climate change is having devastating
impact on the lives of children in poorer countries like India and
Bangladesh — whose childhoods are being washed away. Over 50 children in
the age group of one month to 14 years die of cancer every day in
India, according to a recent study which also highlights the significant
monetary burden of the disease and lack of advanced treatment options
in the country.
Traffic in Delhi, India. Attribution Some rights reserved by Lingaraj GJ
A number of cities in the Persian Gulf
region may be unlivable by the end of the century due to global warming
if humans do not curb greenhouse gas emissions, according to new
research. Every year, we’re seeing new and undeniable climate events,
droughts, intensifying extreme weather events, Greenland ice sheets
melting at unprecedented rates — and all decades ahead of scientific
projections. Our oceans are acidifying, with methane plumes rising up
from the ocean floor. And unless we reverse course regarding the
fossil-fuel-burning path chosen, there will be even more such early
deaths attributed to the igniting of these fuels. Climate change is our
single greatest security threat. Pollution control should be the top
priority for India, as well as other countries.
The answers to climate change are very
simple. The world needs to create a future powered by renewable energy.
Renewable energy (especially solar and wind) is a game-changer for most
countries in the world. It has the potential to re-energize the world by
creating millions of new jobs, achieving energy independence, and
combating climate change. Even providing 100% renewable energy is not a
fantasy for someday, but a reality today. Many countries have already
set a target to reach 100% renewables in the very near future.
World leaders have it in their power to
make a real and measurable difference putting the planet on track. What
is needed now is a new focus and global efforts by governments,
corporations, citizens, and nonprofits to comply with the United Nations
Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). I urge them to do so
now. It is our moral and ethical obligation to prevent this human
tragedy because it is totally preventable. I remain unwaveringly
convinced that if the air-pollution crisis is resolved, we resolve the
climate-warming issue in the process. I call that a win-win proposition
for humanity.
Actions Needed to Reverse Climate Change and Global Warming in India
What we need in India is a bold new
climate and energy policy. And we need a whole new set of social and
technical knowledge to get us there. We need transformational thinking
and new policy tools. We also need major legislation such as putting a
price on carbon. However, we also need to know if those steps will even
be enough to keep us below the scientifically endorsed and aspirational
goal included in the Paris Agreement to limit global average temperature
increases between 1.5°C and 2°C by 2100. We need to immediately find
solutions to solve these pollution problems.
1. Introduce a carbon tax:
Capturing carbon and planting trees could help slow and eventually
reverse global warming trends. A carbon tax could be used to deter more
emissions and some of the cash could then be put into important
solutions on the other side of the coin, such as capturing carbon and
planting trees.
2. Exponentially increase the deployment of renewable energy:
Aggressively expand large-scale deployment of both centralized and
distributed renewable energy — including solar, wind, hydro, biomass,
and geothermal — to ease the strain on the present transmission and
distribution system — and to allow more off-grid populations to be
reached. Provide incentives to kickstart renewable energy programs for
massive solar rooftops — over 100 million — and with home energy storage
batteries.
3. Develop a national renewable energy (RE) policy:
Enact and deploy a comprehensive new energy roadmap with innovative RE
policies. In addition, set National RE Standards such as 20 percent by
2020, 40 percent by 2030 and 100 percent by 2050 — to create demand, new
industries and innovation, and a new wave of green jobs.
4. Electrifying transportation:
Expedite a move to electrify transportation by encouraging expanded use
of electric vehicles (EV) and plug-in hybrids, alongside deployment of
solar-powered EV charging stations around the country. Develop and
implement time-of-day pricing to encourage charging of vehicles at night
and other times when peak demand is low. Adopt nationwide charging of
electric cars from solar panels on roofs, carports, and solar-powered EV
charging stations around the country. In addition, like China
is doing, launch the public transportation system of the future with
“zero-emission” battery-powered electric buses in all major cities.
India must make a massive shift that will lead to widespread adoption of
EVs in the next 5 to 7 years.
5. Energy efficiency:
Promote energy efficiency in the economy, notably in industry,
transportation, buildings, and appliances. Make energy efficiency a high
priority by expediting the development and implementation of
cost-effective energy efficiency standards. To reduce the long-term
demand for energy, engage states, industrial companies, utilities, and
other stakeholders to accelerate energy efficiency investments such as
large-scale, nationwide use of LED lamps, etc.
6. Utility-scale projects:
Plan for the long term — phase out conventional energy subsidies and
develop a long-term plan to replace fossil with utility-scale renewable
generation. We can no longer ignore the effect of pollution and climate
change on health of our citizens.
7. Renewable Innovative Financing Solution:
Provide innovative financing (e.g., tax-free solar bonds or green
infrastructure bonds, etc.) to instill more confidence from potential
investors and decrease the cost of financing for renewable energy
projects. Create and fund a national smart infrastructure bank to
accelerate local demand for renewable energy.
8. Decentralized energy:
Avoid future fossil fuel investments in India and, instead, emphasize
nationwide deployment of community-scale solar projects and microgrids
with storage. India’s present 40 GW solar target should be extended to
include photovoltaic panels on the rooftop of every home in India,
generating enough power to reduce the country’s massive dependence on
fossil fuels.
9. Microgrids:
Aggressively invest in a smart, two-way grid and also microgrids. Invest
in smart meters, as well as reliable networks that can accommodate the
two-way flow of electricity.
10. Solar Roadways:
India should also take advantage of its vast network of roads across the
country and the sun that beats down on them and turn them into
energy-creating solar superhighways. The idea of solar panel roads is to
replace traditional asphalt roads with glass-based “solar panels that
you can drive on” in a bid to turn roads into sources of renewable
energy.
11. Develop energy storage:
This includes thermal storage, grid battery storage (e.g., Tesla
Powerwall home battery backup), compressed air/gas,
vehicles-to-grid/home, pumped hydro, fuel cells or other hydrogen
storage, flywheels, superconducting magnets, and supercapacitors.
Develop a “Hydrogen Economy” plan. India can export sunshine around the
world by converting solar energy into “Liquid Hydrogen Fuel.”
12. Transform India into a global solar manufacturing hub:
Establish R&D facilities within academia, research institutions,
industry, government, and private entities to guide technology
development.
India has the technical potential to
meet its current power needs more than 10 times over with solar energy
alone. There are no insurmountable technological or economic barriers to
tapping India’s vast potential to achieve 100% renewable energy.
India can easily build a 100% renewable
energy system at costs comparable to or less than what it would have to
spend to continue its reliance on fossil and nuclear power. There is no
downside to this transition. We can make India the world leader and
superpower in renewable energy, and eliminate the suffering of millions
of people in Delhi and many other cities from pollution problems.
*Darshan Goswami has more than 40 years of experience in the energy
field. He worked as a Project Manager for Renewable Energy, Micro-grid
and Smart Grid projects at the United States Department of Energy (DOE)
in Pittsburgh. Links
New challenges – and a science-dismissing US President – make Gore’s sequel to his 2006 film feel both cinematic and compelling
Northern exposure … Al Gore goes to Greenland in An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth To Power.
Photograph: Participant Media/Paramount Pictures
Eleven record-breaking summers on from An Inconvenient Truth, Al Gore
doubles down.
Bonni Cohen and Jon Shenk’s galvanising documentary
accompanies the former US vice-president throughout 2015 and 2016, by
which point he had pivoted from touring pro-bono slideshows to
addressing the Climate Reality Leadership Corps programme initiated by the first movie’s success.
Cohen and Shenk don’t deviate radically from that film’s formula.
Again, excerpts of Gore’s orations (manna for bar chart aficionados) are
bolstered with visits to natural disaster sites (as Irwin Allen
foresaw, extreme weather is inherently cinematic), while
behind-the-scenes diversions find our host battling to discuss
temperature hikes with an election-crazed media and an expert-intolerant
public.
Other climates have changed, then, and the sequel benefits
dramatically from its expanded sense of the challenges we face –
everything from the needs of developing nations to terrorism. One
under-discussed byproduct of climate change is an increasingly
hot-headed world.
Candidate Trump looms, dismissing science as a wussy liberal fetish.
An updated coda sees Gore abandoning his conciliatory rhetoric to swing
for an individual currently undoing much of the hard diplomatic work
observed herein.
Railing against rising tides, Gore emerges as a cannier
performer and a more compelling subject than he was in 2006; a message
that sounded critical then has become no less urgent with time.
Al Gore has a follow-up to his blockbuster documentary film, An Inconvenient Truth. However, An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth to Power was greeted with far less fanfare than the original.
This is not surprising given how the first movie dominated the international box office
and became one of the most successful documentaries of all time. The
film ultimately helped Al Gore win the 2007 Nobel Peace Prize for his
efforts in promoting action against climate change.
In addition to the many accolades it received, the movie undeniably raised the public awareness of climate change. According to a prominent climate scientist,
the movie “had a much greater impact on public opinion and public
awareness of global climate change than any scientific paper or report.”
However, 11 years after its release, there is also evidence that it
might have had an unintended consequence: serving as a catalyst in the
polarization of American public opinion on climate change.
We have studied in detail how the media covered the issue of climate
change since the 1980s and how it may have played a role in polarizing
the American public. The commonly observed pattern is that public opinion tends to follow, rather than lead, debate among political elites. This is of particular importance for our work.
Opinions dictated by political parties
Voters, particularly in America, tend to harbour strong positive and
negative attachments to political parties. These form critical
components of their social identities. When uncertain about novel
political issues, like climate change, they look for signals from
political elites for guidance. These signals are, more often than not,
carried to them by the mass media.
In our research, we examined the political signals that were present
in the coverage of climate change in major, high circulation daily
newspapers, like the New York Times, Wall Street Journal and USA Today, as well network television channels ABC, CBS and NBC, and cable news channel Fox News.
What we found is a nuanced story that sheds considerable light on why
the public polarized on climate change. First, politicians became
increasingly common in coverage, politicizing the issue as it grew in
importance. As a result, the public has been exposed to a growing number
of messages about climate change from party elites.
Second, Democratic messages have been more common in news coverage,
and, unsurprisingly, consistent in a pro-climate direction. Meanwhile,
Republican messages have been fewer in number, and, until the Obama
presidency, ambiguous in direction. Contrary to conventional wisdom,
only a small fraction of Republican messages on climate change
explicitly denied the scientific consensus on climate change.
When one side’s messages are clear and the other side’s are muddled, as was the case here, it’s plausible that Republican voters took their cues from Democrats. This should not be surprising. In an age of affective polarization
where Republicans and Democrats each increasingly dislike the other, it
makes sense that Republicans may have taken an oppositional stance on
climate change, at least partly, in response to signals from Democratic
elites.
In this January 2007 file photo, former Vice President Al Gore acknowledges spectators in Japan in front of a poster of his documentary film (AP Photo/Koji Sasahara)
An Inconvenient Truth
So, what about the role of Al Gore and An Inconvenient Truth
in this process? Al Gore was featured prominently in the news media
coverage of climate change. This was particularly true when climate
change was salient and Americans were significantly polarizing on the
issue.
For example, Al Gore was featured in 48 per cent of climate change stories on Fox News
in 2006 and in 57 per cent in 2007. There were explicit references to
the movie in 28 per cent of the stories in 2006 and 17 per cent of the
stories in 2007. On the other hand, a leading Republican climate change
denier, Sen. Jim Inhofe, was not featured in a single story on Fox News in 2006 and in only one per cent of the stories in 2007.
The traditional media also focused heavily on Al Gore. In 2006 and
2007, the former U.S. vice-president was featured in 13 per cent and 17
per cent of news stories in the highest circulation newspapers in the
United States, and in 16 per cent and 23 per cent of the network
broadcasts.
In other words, if you tuned in to news about climate change in that
time period, you were exposed to Al Gore and his message. And even
though that message was unabashedly pro-climate and for strong climate
action, it likely played a role in turning Republicans against that
message, since to them, Gore was simply a Democratic politician they
disliked.
It’s highly unlikely that the release of Al Gore’s sequel to An Inconvenient Truth will have an impact similar to the original. The movie is generating significantly less traction in the box office and in the media. Furthermore, climate change has already become one of the most polarized issues of the day.
Sadly, there is likely no way to turn back the clock. But it should
serve as a warning for the future. It is not only important to pick a
salient and informative message, but also an effective messenger to
deliver it. Links
The current presidential administration in the US has proposed to
almost completely eliminate funding for programs aimed at researching
and reducing the effects of climate change.
The Environmental Protection
Agency faces a cut of 31% or roughly $2.4 billion and almost 4,000
jobs.
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration could be cut
by a potential 17% which
would specifically eliminate $510 million (or ~22%) of their satellite
division.
These cuts would likely encompass climate programs like
EnergyStar, SmartWay, fuel emission standards, and weather warning
systems.
Let's look at 8 ways climate change poses risks, or potential risks, to our health and safety.
1. Extreme weather puts your safety at risk, especially when we cannot plan ahead.
Rising global average temperatures are linked to widespread changes
in weather patterns and an increase in the frequency and intensity of
weather events like heat waves, and rain or snow storms. Around 2.1 million acres
were burned by wildfires in the first 3 months of 2017, three times the
amount lost in the previous year. Massachusetts saw its first tornado since it began documenting weather patterns in the 1600s.
In many areas across the globe, like the northeastern US, we have
become accustomed to snowstorms that drop more than 20 inches of snow
each winter, but such blizzards
were once rare. Not only can extreme storms be inherently dangerous,
but their risk is compounded by cuts to satellite programs that are
tasked with tracking weather patterns. Without enough funding to
maintain existing satellites and for improving and adapting models of
weather phenomena, our ability to accurately forecast and thus plan
ahead for extreme weather events is significantly hindered.
2. Climate change puts our fresh water supply at risk.
As an astronomer, I can tell you that nothing is deemed more vital to our existence than water.
As an astronomer, I can tell you that nothing is deemed more
vital to our existence than water. When we discover a new planet, the
first question we ask is always, could there be water?
Rising temperatures and extreme weather events like droughts will
clearly place water supplies at risk. According to the US Geological
Survey, while surface water can recover
with just a few days of heavy rain, groundwater aquifers like those
tapped during the recent Californian drought can take decades to
replenish. Droughts also lead to drier conditions which put land at
higher risk for wildfires. In the US, you can check the level of fire danger in your area thanks to the National Park Service and the National Fire Danger Rating System.
But too much rain can also be a problem for our water supply.
Flooding from heavy rains can cause sewage to overflow and contaminate
drinking water. Earlier this year 1.5 million people were without water in Santiago
because mudslides and flooding caused by heavy rain contaminated the
Maipo River, a major source of drinking water. The rising sea levels
linked to rising global temperatures also threaten to groundwater used
for drinking with contamination from saltwater. One program that helps
US coastal communities in 33 states deal with flooding, the NOAA's Sea Grant program, faces drastic cuts in the newly proposed budget.
Let us also not forget that as water becomes scarcer, water bills
will go up, which may force some of us to make budget cuts in other
areas of our lives, even if that involves risk.
3. Food production could be disrupted leading to higher prices.
With some areas facing increased flooding and others enduring longer
droughts, food production could be significantly disrupted with the
onset of climate change. Some areas may become too hot for crops that
have grown there easily in the past. Too little water would cause
problems for irrigation while too much water in the form of rainstorms
could damage crops.
According to the National Resources Defense Council, 25% of the the honey bee population
has disappeared since 1990, in large part due to shrinking habitats,
or, in other words, a loss in areas with temperatures and conditions
suitable for bees to survive. Having fewer bees poses a further threat
to at least 30% of the world's crops which rely on bees for
cross-pollination, crops like apples, almonds, pumpkins, onions, and
avocados. On the flip side, some plants, like crop-harming weeds, as
well as certain pests that thrive in hotter temperatures may see
population booms, stealing resources from food crops.
4. Many allergens and disease carrying insects will thrive under the changing climate.
Among the pests that will thrive under the high temperatures and
higher levels of carbon dioxide that are associated with climate change,
ticks and poison ivy rank highly. Studies have shown that while the
average tree will grow 8% faster in a climate with high levels of carbon
dioxide, poison ivy grows 149% faster.
Scientists have already observed the poison ivy/oak/sumac populations
to be stronger, leading to more intense rashes. As a sufferer of poison
ivy myself, I know that each emergency trip to the doctor following an
encounter with the plant can also cost a pretty penny.
Tick populations are also booming in the US and the number of reported cases of Lyme disease has doubled since 1990. Warmer temperatures have lead to ticks moving farther and farther north expanding their geographic reach.
5. Microbes may be forced to adapt.
The impact climate change will have on microbes, including bacteria
and eukaryotes, is complex and, unfortunately, has not yet been
thoroughly studied. However, research
has shown that microbe communities tend to adapt rather than resist
rising temperatures and thus change their composition and function. We
know that microbes play critical roles in human health and the health of
certain plants, and so that adaptation may prove detrimental whether
the microbes are "good" or "bad" for us. They also produce much of the
air that we breathe, and so their possible extinction is worth
investigating.
6. Infrastructure and the safety it provides are at risk under extreme weather. $50 billion of federal aid was spent in the US to rebuild after Hurricane Sandy shook the northeastern US, Canada and the Caribbean and caused
at least 147 deaths.
Almost 164,000 residents in Connecticut, New York, and
New Jersey applied for federal assistance from FEMA.
Extreme weather
events threaten not only our personal property, but the roads, bridges,
sidewalks, highways, and other infrastructure that we rely on to keep us
safe.
7. Energy may be both more in demand and harder to produce.
We know
that our methods of energy production via coal and fossil fuels
increase the level of carbon dioxide in the air and thus contribute to
rising global temperatures. But, as reported
by the US Department of Energy in 2013, the effects of climate change,
including increasing temperatures, decreasing water supply, extreme
weather, and sea level rise, will in term affect our ability to produce
and transmit electricity from these and other, renewable methods.
For example, energy production from coal, nuclear power, natural
gas, and of course hydroelectric power, all require high water use and
may be significantly affected by drought. Drought, along with increasing
temperatures, also lead to increased consumption of energy, for
example, to run an air conditioner, and so can overload electrical grids
causing blackouts. Just as transportation infrastructure is at risk
from extreme weather, so is energy-related infrastructure like power
lines, transformers, and power plants.
8. Climate change poses a threat to national security.
Beyond our safety as individuals, climate change poses a potential threat to global and national security. In a 2010 report
from the US Joint Forces Command called the Joint Operating
Environment, climate change is named as a national security threat
likely to face the US military over the following 25 years.
According to officials of the United Nations,
"stronger storms, rising seas, drought, famine, and the migration these
events cause could each be the spark to ignite many potential conflicts
smoldering around the world, prompting wars and destabilizing
governments."
As part of his Senate hearing, US Defense Secretary James Mattis testified
that "climate change is impacting stability in areas of the world where
our troops are operating today." Humanitarian crises like typhoons and
famine due to drought also become more challenging to respond to in the
face of climate change.
And just as our infrastructure related to transportation and
energy production are at risk, so is that of our military. For example,
Hampton Roads, Virginia has the largest number
of military bases of any city in the world, but it is already
experiencing rapid sea level rise. Flooding could not only disrupt
operations, but also damage critical infrastructure.
The US is large and covers a range of climate diversity. Thus,
the impacts of climate change here will be many. However, our planet's
climate is globally shared and so the extent of climate change in the US
will ultimately depend on the strength cooperative efforts like those between European Union and China.