Thursday, September 14, 2017

The Guardian View On Climate Change: See You In Court

The Guardian - 

It is possible to determine which nations and companies are responsible for damaging the climate. It’s only a matter of time before courts decide they must pay for global warming
Storms clouds move in over the skyline of downtown Orlando as Hurricane Irma makes its way up the Florida peninsula. Photograph: Joe Burbank/AP
Recent days have seen Houston, Texas literally sunk under sheer weight of rain, Carribbean islands battered by powerful storms barrelling across the Gulf and now Florida homes blasted by Irma, the largest of three hurricanes churning in the Atlantic basin. It seems almost certain that man-made climate change has a role in such events. Scientists used to be circumspect at attributing any single extreme event to global warming. No longer. Now scientists make the link between climate change and droughts in Kenya, record winter sun in Britain and torrential downpours in south-west China.
The unmistakeable fingerprint of extreme weather at the crime scene of global warming seems intuitively obvious: consider that Houston is reckoned to have been hit by three “500-year floods” in three years. A 500-year flood does not have to happen only twice a millennium. But a run of three indicates that past climate is no longer a reliable guide to the present weather. The explanation is that the climate itself is changing.
Such thinking should be a wake up call for the world, which has to understand how profoundly we must make a shift in the way we produce, distribute and consume energy, and how disruptive this will be for the real economy. While governments have, via the Paris agreement, signalled the end of the fossil-fuel era, the political processes by which states will decide how to meet their mitigation targets have been hijacked and influenced by Big Carbon.
Fossil-fuel companies, hydrocarbon billionaires and their allies, particularly in the west, have for years now been funding a massive and sophisticated campaign to mislead voters about the environmental harm caused by carbon pollution. They have good reason to: a landmark study released earlier this year revealed 50 corporations account for more than one-fifth of all carbon released into the atmosphere since the industrial revolution began. The groundbreaking research not only helps establish legal accountability for climate change, it also weakens any corporate defence of wilful blindness. A major polluter cannot say it was going ahead with its activities because it was unaware its products caused great harm. Corporations have made handsome profits as the globe ended up a degree warmer than it should be. These polluters privatised the fossil-fuel profits and socialised the cost to the world’s poor, global taxpayers and future generations. Big Carbon entities and individuals who claim their lobbying activities are just an expression of their democratic rights sound a lot like Big Tobacco when it was denying the health dangers of smoking.
Three major legal actions will test such thinking. First in the Philippines, where it is being determined whether polluters violated the human rights of Filipinos for their role in creating the conditions for Typhoon Haiyan, the strongest ever tropical storm to make landfall, which left more than 7,000 dead. Second in Germany, where a German utility company is being sued for costs associated with glacial lake flooding in Peru. Last in the US, where two California counties are suing 37 oil, gas and coal companies, claiming they knew their products would cause sea-level rise and coastal flooding, but failed to reduce their greenhouse gases.
Fossil-fuel companies should be held accountable for the effects of climate change. Legal warfare has a two-fold aim: to overhaul transgressors’ business models so that they are in line with the global commitment to phase out fossil fuels and limit temperature rises to 1.5°C; and to get them to pay for damages resulting from global warming. Climate litigation is the inevitable result of a failure of two decades of talks. But it is also an important way of reframing the climate crisis as a human rights emergency.

Links

Stop Talking Right Now About The Threat Of Climate Change. It’s Here; It’s Happening

The Guardian - 

Stop talking right now about the threat of climate change. It’s here; it’s happening. Hurricane Harvey, Hurricane Irma, flash fires, droughts: all of them tell us one thing – we need to stand up to the fossil fuel industry and fast.
Flooding caused by Hurricane Harvey, southeast Texas 31 August 2017. Photograph: UPI / Barcroft Images
For the sake of keeping things manageable, let’s confine the discussion to a single continent and a single week: North America over the last seven days.
In Houston they got down to the hard and unromantic work of recovery from what economists announced was probably the most expensive storm in US history, and which weather analysts confirmed was certainly the greatest rainfall event ever measured in the country – across much of its spread it was a once-in-25,000-years storm, meaning 12 times past the birth of Christ; in isolated spots it was a once-in-500,000-years storm, which means back when we lived in trees. Meanwhile, San Francisco not only beat its all-time high temperature record, it crushed it by 3F, which should be pretty much statistically impossible in a place with 150 years (that’s 55,000 days) of record-keeping.
That same hot weather broke records up and down the west coast, except in those places where a pall of smoke from immense forest fires kept the sun shaded – after a forest fire somehow managed to jump the mighty Columbia river from Oregon into Washington, residents of the Pacific Northwest reported that the ash was falling so thickly from the skies that it reminded them of the day Mount St Helens erupted in 1980.
That same heat, just a little farther inland, was causing a “flash drought” across the country’s wheat belt of North Dakota and Montana – the evaporation from record temperatures had shrivelled grain on the stalk to the point where some farmers weren’t bothering to harvest at all. In the Atlantic, of course, Irma was barrelling across the islands of the Caribbean (“It’s like someone with a lawnmower from the sky has gone over the island,” said one astounded resident of St Maarten). The storm, the first category five to hit Cuba in a hundred years, is currently battering the west coast of Florida after setting a record for the lowest barometric pressure ever measured in the Keys, and could easily break the 10-day-old record for economic catastrophe set by Harvey; it’s definitely changed the psychology of life in Florida for decades to come.
Oh, and while Irma spun, Hurricane Jose followed in its wake as a major hurricane, while in the Gulf of Mexico, Katia spun up into a frightening storm of her own, before crashing into the Mexican mainland almost directly across the peninsula from the spot where the strongest earthquake in 100 years had taken dozens of lives.
Leaving aside the earthquake, every one of these events jibes with what scientists and environmentalists have spent 30 fruitless years telling us to expect from global warming. (There’s actually fairly convincing evidence that climate change is triggering more seismic activity, but there’s no need to egg the pudding.)
That one long screed of news from one continent in one week (which could be written about many other continents and many other weeks – just check out the recent flooding in south Asia for instance) is a precise, pixelated portrait of a heating world. Because we have burned so much oil and gas and coal, we have put huge clouds of CO2 and methane in the air; because the structure of those molecules traps heat the planet has warmed; because the planet has warmed we can get heavier rainfalls, stronger winds, drier forests and fields. It’s not mysterious, not in any way. It’s not a run of bad luck. It’s not Donald Trump (though he’s obviously not helping). It’s not hellfire sent to punish us. It’s physics.
Maybe it was too much to expect that scientists’ warnings would really move people. (I mean, I wrote The End of Nature, the first book about all this 28 years ago this week, when I was 28 – and when my theory was still: “People will read my book, and then they will change.”) Maybe it’s like all the health warnings that you should eat fewer chips and drink less soda, which, to judge by belt-size, not many of us pay much mind. Until, maybe, you go to the doctor and he says: “Whoa, you’re in trouble.” Not “keep eating junk and some day you’ll be in trouble”, but: “You’re in trouble right now, today. As in, it looks to me like you’ve already had a small stroke or two.” Hurricanes Harvey and Irma are the equivalent of one of those transient ischaemic attacks – yeah, your face is drooping oddly on the left, but you can continue. Maybe. If you start taking your pills, eating right, exercising, getting your act together.


Hurricane Irma's path of destruction - video report

That’s the stage we’re at now – not the warning on the side of the pack, but the hacking cough that brings up blood. But what happens if you keep smoking? You get worse, till past a certain point you’re not continuing. We’ve increased the temperature of the Earth a little more than 1C so far, which has been enough extra heat to account for the horrors we’re currently witnessing. And with the momentum built into the system, we’re going to go somewhere near 2C, no matter what we do. That will be considerably worse than where we are now, but maybe it will be expensively endurable.
The problem is, our current business-as-usual trajectory takes us to a world that’s about 3.5C warmer. That is to say, even if we kept the promises we made at Paris (which Trump has already, of course, repudiated) we’re going to build a planet so hot that we can’t have civilisations. We have to seize the moment we’re in right now – the moment when we’re scared and vulnerable – and use it to dramatically reorient ourselves. The last three years have each broken the record for the hottest year ever measured – they’re a red flashing sign that says: “Snap out of it.” Not bend the trajectory somewhat, as the Paris accords envisioned, but simultaneously jam on the fossil fuel brakes and stand on the solar accelerator (and also find some metaphors that don’t rely on internal combustion).
This is a race against time. Global warming is a crisis that comes with a limit – solve it soon or don’t solve it
We could do it. It’s not technologically impossible – study after study has shown we can get to 100% renewables at a manageable cost, more manageable all the time, since the price of solar panels and windmills keeps plummeting. Elon Musk is showing you can churn out electric cars with ever-lower sticker shock. In remote corners of Africa and Asia, peasants have begun leapfrogging past fossil fuel and going straight to the sun. The Danes just sold their last oil company and used the cash to build more windmills. There are just enough examples to make despair seem like the cowardly dodge it is. But everyone everywhere would have to move with similar speed, because this is in fact a race against time. Global warming is the first crisis that comes with a limit – solve it soon or don’t solve it. Winning slowly is just a different way of losing.
Winning fast enough to matter would mean, above all, standing up to the fossil fuel industry, so far the most powerful force on Earth. It would mean postponing other human enterprises and diverting other spending. That is, it would mean going on a war-like footing: not shooting at enemies, but focusing in the way that peoples and nations usually only focus when someone’s shooting at them. And something is. What do you think it means when your forests are on fire, your streets are underwater, and your buildings are collapsing?

*Bill McKibben is a writer and the founder of the climate campaign 350.org

Links

Ignore Mt Piper's Tune: NSW Isn't About To Lose Its Newest Coal-Fired Plant

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

In Australia's self-induced and largely imagined energy crisis, it seems any ambit claim - particularly if it encourages coal - can generate immediate and unwarranted media and political attention.
For the past week or so, we have witnessed Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull's ill-considered elevation to national urgency the closure of the decrepit Liddell coal-fired power station in the Hunter Valley in 2022. Owners AGL had given all of seven years' notice.

MPs clash over Liddell power plant closure
Now, a News Corp publication has tossed into the debate furnace the "real risk" NSW's newest power station Mt Piper faces closure because of a "green activist" group that had the temerity of asking courts (at great financial risk) to uphold NSW law.
Time for a few facts before our leadership lemmings are panicked into, say, banning renewable energy, ditching Australia's Paris climate goals, or other nefarious scheme dreamed up in some coal lobbyist's backroom.
Back in August, the NSW government was posed a dilemma after the state's appeals court deemed a coal mine in Sydney's catchment was operating without an invalid licence, as Fairfax Media reported at the time.
In short, any development - and that includes coal - can only operate in the region if it has a neutral or beneficial effect on water quality. Makes sense if you care about the water supplied to five million people.
So Centennial Coal's Springvale mine should not pump millions of litres a day of untreated mine water into the Coxs River, the second largest supply of water to Sydney's main dam, the court found.
But as Springvale, near Lithgow, happens to be the only current source of coal to EnergyAustralia's Mt Piper plant, the judges in their wisdom said, in effect, go and sort out what you need to do to everybody's satisfaction.
For the past week or so, we have witnessed the PM's ill-considered elevation to national urgency the closure of the decrepit Liddell coal-fired power station in the Hunter Valley in 2022. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen
Satisfaction, though, will come at a cost for somebody. Submissions are due from this Friday in the NSW Land & Environment Court.
Hence, some early public lobbying is now underway, dovetailing nicely with our contrived energy frenzy.
Mt Piper power station.  Photo: Supplied by Centennial Coal
The options at this stage are: Mt Piper looks for alternative coal supplies and builds a rail loader to access it; Springvale accelerates plans to pipe the waste water to a yet-to-built treatment plant; the government changes the legislation that would harm Sydney's water supplies and open the door wider to similar projects in the future.
Naturally, most money is betting on the latter outcome, with the cost borne by a largely unwitting public.
The NSW government is rightly watching the outcome of the submissions in the Land & Environment and not keen to comment. But even if it were to pursue that last option, it won't be able to do so a vacuum.
As Fairfax Media has revealed this week, a new study commissioned by the state government has found underground coal mining is having a more detrimental impact on the catchment than previously thought.
Cracks were likely reaching from the surface all the way down to the coal seam 400 metres below, permanently diverting flows to who knows where, and killing endangered wetlands above.
Indeed, WaterNSW, the government agency, is understood to be very unhappy with the findings. They confirm many of its fears about the wisdom of allowing mining in the catchment at all.
Nobody knows of another major city that allows it.
Sue Higginson is chief executive of the NSW Environmental Defender's Office which led the successful appeal against Springvale on behalf of the 4nature group. She says those seeking a quick corporate fix for Mt Piper would prefer to ignore the rule of law.
"It's as if environmental law doesn't matter," Higginson says.
In the intense heat of the wider energy debate, it's plausible that result sits happily with those keen to promote coal at any cost.

Links

Wednesday, September 13, 2017

Wetlands Discovery Opens New Doors For Australian Climate Research

Fairfax - Tony Moore

Scientists say the surprising discovery that North Stradbroke Island's Ferngully Lagoon dated back more than 200,000 years, and other wetlands on the island more than 40,000 years, could reshape climate change research on the Australian continent.
Researchers from the University of Queensland and the University of Adelaide made the discovery after they took core samples from the 16 wetlands on North Stradbroke Island.
John Tibby and Cameron Barr take core samples from Duck Lagoon, North Stradbroke Island. Photo: Tony Moore
Previously, scientists believed Australian wetlands date back to the Ice Age, about 15,000 to 20,000 years ago.
The discovery showed North Stradbroke Island was an exception.
Researchers John Tibby, Lydia McKenzie, Jonathan Marshall and Cameron Barr take core samples from Duck Lagoon, North Stradbroke Island. Photo: Tony Moore
The science is published in the Journal of Quaternary Science, which studies Australian wetlands.
The South Australian lead researcher John Tibby released the results on Monday, with Queensland government scientist Jonathan Marshall.
Dr Marshall, the principal scientist with the Queensland Department of Science, Information Technology and Innovation, said the research demonstrated North Stradbroke Island was "an Australian exception" during those dry times.
"We cored and dated 16 wetlands on the island and found six dating to the ice age or earlier, with one being more than 200,000 years old," Dr Marshall said.
Dr Tibby, from the University of Adelaide, said there were more wetlands on North Stradbroke Island dating back to the Ice Age than anywhere else in Australia.
"Australia was much drier during the last Ice Age than it is today, as most of the water was held in large ice sheets in the Northern Hemisphere," he said.
“Right across Australia, there were few wetlands during this time, which raises the question: Where and how did plants and animals survive that needed permanent water?
"The island, and possibly even the region itself, may have been a refuge from dry climates.”
The Moreton Bay side of North Stradbroke Island has a string of wetlands.
Dr Tibby said their research showed Ferngully Lagoon, to the north of Blue and Brown Lakes on the bay side of North Stradbroke Island, was 200,000 years old.
"The instinctive thing is that you would expect that lakes and swamps that exist on sand, because North Stradbroke Island is a sand island, is that they are likely not to have existed for a long period of time," he said.
"So the fact that these lakes and swamps have existed for a long time suggests that on average it has been wet in the region for most of that period of time, which is in contrast to what we think we know about the rest of the Australian continent.
"We have very, very few locations where we have wetlands that have persisted through since the end of the last Ice Age."
The Ice Age began slowly about 100,000 years ago, reached its peak between 15,000 and 20,000 years ago and gently warmed.
The discovery would allow researchers to study the history of vegetation changes, eventually over the past 200,000 years, by looking at fossilised pollens.
This research would be compared to other research, which was "inferring" past rainfall in the region.
Dr Tibby said researchers would use core samples to look into the impact of human arrival in south-east Queensland and the impact on vegetation.
"Whether those two things together had a role in causing the extinction of the giant animals, the megafauna and then what happened to fire practices with Indigenous people using the landscape," he said.
"It has been hard to get good answers to those questions because we have had so few good sites."
The science suggested the island may have had permanent wetland areas when Australia’s climate was at its driest.
Dr Tibby said the persistence of these wetlands were linked to the island’s groundwater systems, which acted as water reservoirs during periods of rainfall deficit.
“During what was otherwise a particularly dry period in Australia’s ancient past, these persistently moist regions are thought to have played a unique role in maintaining biodiversity,” he said.
Dr Tibby said being able to research the North Stradbroke Island wetlands further would help understand longer-term climate change.
“It will greatly improve our understanding about the drivers of both local and regional climate variability.”
Quandamooka Yoolooburrabee Aboriginal Corporation traditional owner Darren Burns said the new scientific evidence confirmed the existence of local natural resources – local spring and water supplies - which the Quandamooka people used to live on the island they knew as Minjerribah.
Science Minister Leanne Enoch, herself a Quandamooka women from Minjerribah, said the research had the potential to change thinking about how climate changed in south-east Queensland.
“Until now, few Australian sites had offered detailed information about what was happening at wetlands since the last great ice age, which peaked around 15,000 years ago,” Ms Enoch said.
“...The significance of this research is that it greatly adds to our understanding of the ancient climatic changes that shaped our country, our wildlife and our first peoples.”

Links

For Energy Security, The Failing Liddell Coal Plant Is The Last Thing We Need



Confusion reigns over whether the government will, or can, keep the ageing power station going. But there’s a much better way to ensure grid reliability
‘Throughout 2016-17 the 45-year-old power station’s average capacity was only 54%.’ Photograph: Tim Wimborne/Reuters
Coal fails in the heat. And so it did on 10 February 2017, as the heatwave that sparked South Australia’s blackout rolled across into NSW and emergency load-shedding was required in Australia’s biggest state. The Liddell power station failed to perform and could only operate at below half-capacity. In fact, throughout 2016-17 the 45-year-old power station’s average capacity was only 54%. It almost never operates at peak performance.
To increase grid reliability, the last thing you would want to do is rely upon an underperforming, old power station prone to failure during heatwaves.
But the good news is that Australia does not have to wait until after 2022 to put in place an energy security solution. Consumers can pay less, pollution can be cut and the grid made more reliable without waiting to keep a coal plant open which may or may not have a seller or a buyer.
Demand response technology reduces peak demand to keep the grid stable. Cloud computer software is used to control a potential fleet of millions of domestic and commercial devices, from smelters to residential air conditioners, aggregating them into what the CSIRO calls a “virtual power plant”. From the consumer’s perspective, it is as easy as taking a selfie on a tram.
A recent Australia Institute report into demand management showed this emerging industry will be worth US$36bn by 2025, more than tripling from 39 GW to 144 GW. The International Energy Agency benchmark is that demand response can mitigate about 15% of peak demand. Australia is at less than 1%.
In 2002 Warwick Parer, who previously had been John Howard’s energy minister, recommended to state and federal energy ministers that “negawatts” (negative megawatts) of saved energy should be able to compete in the wholesale energy market with megawatts of generated energy. Fifteen years later we are still waiting for this simple market reform, which would allow companies and consumers to provide demand response, without any government subsidies.
Rather than letting modest measures such as demand response compete, politicians are too easily captured by grand designs for fixing the national electricity market. If they ever happen, like Snowy Hydro 2.0 or keeping open Liddell, they would come online by some time in the 2020s.
But by next summer, demand response “negawatts” could deliver. In March EnerNOC committed to providing 100MW to South Australia by 1 December 2017, if the market was open to negawatts, as Parer recommended. Greensync, an Australian start-up, said it could deliver 300MW of negawatts across the National Electricity Market.
Frydenberg has promoted the fact that the Australian Renewable Energy Agency is funding a project with the Australian Energy Market Operator, aimed at delivering 160MW of demand response by this summer. The tenders for this DR Round trial proposed 1,938MW of capacity could be delivered by December 2018. By way of comparison, Liddell has a capacity of 2,000MW – and even that has been drastically reduced due to its age.
If the grid is under stress when the mercury rises this summer, every megawatt counts and this trial could be expanded. Australia is in the midst of a massive and inevitable transition. Ten coal plants have closed in less than a decade and this economic decline is irreversible.
In the short term, to provide stability and lower prices the Australian Energy Market Commission should get on with implementing the five-minute rule. Reforming the market so that wholesale electricity is traded every five minutes would help level the playing field between megawatts and “negawatts”, spur big investment in battery storage and help to stabilise the grid.
In the longer term, energy and climate policy will need to be fully integrated. Already the Australian Energy Council, which represents coal and gas generators, calculates that the political bickering on energy has led to an investment drought that is costing consumers the equivalent of a $50 a tonne carbon price. This policy stalemate is not just pushing up prices; it is pushing the grid to its limits and creating the risk of blackouts.
But there is something we can do about power prices and reliability for this summer and it is not by debating what an ageing coal plant in NSW will or will not be doing in six summers’ time.

*Ben Oquist is executive director of the Australia Institute

Links

Pope Francis Slams 'Stupid' Climate Change Deniers

Al Jazeera

Pontiff calls on politicians to take scientists' advice as he raises alarm over global warming after major storms.
Pope Francis is one of the world's most high-profile campaigners on environmental issues [Andrew Medichini/Pool/Reuters]
Pope Francis has sharply criticised climate change deniers as "stupid" in the wake of a spate of powerful hurricanes that have wreaked havoc in the US, Mexico and the Caribbean.
"Those who deny it [climate change] should go to the scientists and ask them," the pontiff said on Monday during an in-flight press conference on the return leg of a five-day Colombia trip. "They speak very clearly."
As his charter plane flew over some of the recently devastated areas en route to Rome, Francis added: "I am reminded of a phrase from the Old Testament, I think from the Psalm: 'Man is stupid, he is stubborn and he does not see.'"
The pope's comments came as Hurricane Irma, one of the most powerful Atlantic storms in a century, caused widespread destruction across the French Caribbean islands, Cuba, Dominican Republic, Puerto Rico, Haiti and the US state of Florida. At least 38 people have been killed so far from the Category 5 superstorm.
Meanwhile, Hurricane Katia bore down on the east coast of Mexico, leaving at least two dead.
Far out in the Atlantic, Hurricane Jose, a Category 2 storm, having brushed past the Caribbean also poses a potential threat to the US east coast.
Last month, Hurricane Harvey, one of the worst storms to hit the US mainland in 12 years, led to unprecedented flooding in the southern US state of Texas.

'Moral responsiblity'
Francis is one of the world's most high-profile campaigners on environmental issues, actively supporting efforts to combat climate change and its consequences.
He said individuals and politicians had a "moral responsibility" to act on advice from scientists, who had clearly outlined what must be done to halt the course of "catastrophic" warming.
"These aren't opinions pulled out of thin air," he said. "They are very clear. They [world leaders] decide and history will judge those decisions."
Recalling last month's news that a ship crossed the Arctic without an icebreaker for the first time, Francis said: "We can see the effects of climate change, and scientists clearly say what path we should follow."
While regularly criticising politicians, the pope has made caring for the environment a hallmark of his papacy.
He wrote an entire encyclical about how the poor in particular are most harmed when multinationals move in to exploit natural resources.
During his visit to Colombia, Francis spoke out frequently about the need to preserve the country's rich biodiversity from overdevelopment and exploitation.
Among world leaders, US President Donald Trump has repeatedly made a case against climate change.
In June, Trump pulled the United States out of the Paris Agreement, which binds countries to national pledges to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.


What's behind world's recent extreme weather events?

Links

Tuesday, September 12, 2017

Energy Crisis Worsened By Rushed Government Interventions, Grattan Institute Warns

ABC News - Peter Ryan

AGL has committed to eventually dump coal-fired power generation entirely. (ABC News: Dean Faulkner)
Governments could be making the nation's energy security crisis worse through rushed interventions to soothe voter concerns about surging energy bills, the Grattan Institute warns.
The warning comes as the Prime Minister prepares to meet AGL chief executive Andy Vesey today over the planned closure of the Liddell power station in the NSW Hunter Valley by 2022.
The Grattan Institute's Tony Wood urged against the Government "arm twisting" Mr Vesey to keep Liddell open in the face of the company's commitment to eventually dump coal-fired power generation entirely.
"I think there's almost certainly a deal to be done there, but I think AGL would have a very strong view that their corporate position and their advertising says they're getting out of coal," Mr Wood said.
The Prime Minister will meet AGL chief executive Andy Vesey (L) later today. (ABC News: Nick Harmsen)
"It's quite possible that a commercial arrangement that suits AGL and satisfies the concerns the Government has is the way forward. But it's going to be a tricky pathway to follow."
Treasurer Scott Morrison said he was prepared to help AGL sell Liddell to a "responsible party" but repeated the importance of keeping it open to ensure future power supplies.
But Mr Wood counselled against any plan for the Government to intervene and possibly buy a guarantee to keep Liddell open, warning any perception of nationalisation would destabilise the market.
"I think it is always a bad idea for governments to intervene because then we're heading back towards re-nationalisation," he said.
"It is understandable that governments feel the need to do something, but the danger is they will rush in and make things worse. What Australia needs now is perspective, not panic."

Cost of energy security is higher prices: report
Instead, the Grattan Institute report said all sides of politics should work with energy companies and regulators on new ways to ensure reliable and affordable electricity supplies years ahead.
It suggests work needs to begin now on a "capacity mechanism" to encourage companies to invest in new power generation to reduce the growing threat of shortages and blackouts as early as this summer.
With such a mechanism, according to the report, energy companies could be paid for committing to providing power years into the future rather than only meeting the current demand.
However, the report warns the price of peace of mind for energy security would ultimately fall on consumers through higher energy prices.
"Eventually the customer pays for all of this. That's why it's very important to get this right to ensure we have the insurance we need to make sure we have the capacity in the future," Mr Wood said.
Last week, the Australian Energy Market Operator urged "a longer-term approach" in a bid to ensure electricity supplies.
The Grattan Institute report urged the Government to implement the recommendations of the Finkel Review, including a clean energy target to put a price on greenhouse gas emissions.
It also wants a more comprehensive assessment of future energy adequacy of generated supply and if capacity cannot be met, AEMO should introduce a new capacity mechanism.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative