Saturday, October 21, 2017

Australia Only Wealthy Nation Still Breaking Energy Emissions Records

Climate Home -  Adam Morton

How did a country that launched one of the world’s first major carbon pricing schemes become a rogue polluter in just five years?
Around three-quarters of Australia's electricity comes from coal power plants such as Bayswater Power Station (Photo: Commons)
Australia prides itself on punching above its weight on the global stage, but a recent achievement received less-than-usual attention in the halls of parliament and the country’s parochial rightwing press.
According to a think-tank analysis, it is the sole wealthy nation where greenhouse gas emissions from energy combustion are at a record high.
Among what are known as Annex 1 countries, only Turkey – which straddles a grey zone between developed and developing status – joins Australia in having energy combustion emissions higher in 2017 than at any point since 1990, the baseline year under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.
The analysis by progressive think-tank the Australia Institute found the country’s energy emissions kicked up sharply this southern winter due to increased sales of petroleum products – particularly diesel, but also petrol.
Energy analyst Hugh Saddler, an honorary associate professor at the Australian National University, found it pushed the total above the previous record set in 2009, a recent decline in emissions from electricity generation notwithstanding.
Saddler told Climate Home it was extraordinary that an industrialised country’s energy emissions continued to climb.
“The rise now is due to increased use of petroleum, but a distinctive feature about Australia compared with other Annex 1 countries is that it continues to have a heavy reliance on coal,” he said. “We’re not doing enough quickly enough to reduce that heavy reliance.”
Saddler’s analysis, published in the thinktank’s quarterly audit of national energy emissions, found Australia’s energy emissions in June reached 383.3 million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent – a 49.5% increase since 1990.
Enele Sopoaga, prime minister of climate-vulnerable neighbour Tuvalu, told Fairfax Media last week: “While the rest of the world is moving ahead to renewable energy, Australia is stuck in the dark ages with its reliance on dirty fossil fuels. This is bad news for the Pacific”
Despite this, the country is on track to meet its 2020 Kyoto Protocol target – a 5% reduction below 2000 levels. This is largely due to a reduction in land clearing that had already happened when the target was announced, and generous carbon accounting rules that let it count carry over credits from beating its lenient target in the protocol’s first period.
Some European countries, including Germany and Britain, volunteered to cancel their carryover credits so meeting their targets reflected actual emission cuts. Australia declined.
Transport emissions have received relatively little political attention in Australia. In response to questions from Fairfax Media, the government said it had a ministerial forum on vehicle emissions to consider reforms on fuel efficiency and quality.
(Source: TAI)
Coal, on the other hand, is at the centre of heated political debate. The Liberal-National coalition government, which has a centre-right leader in prime minister Malcolm Turnbull but relies on the support of hardline conservative backbench MPs given voice by former leader Tony Abbott, is divided over whether it should be subsidising new coal generation or adopting policies that would support renewable and low-emissions technology.
Black coal and lignite still provide about three-quarters of national electricity, but a dozen old and failing coal generators have closed in the past five years. Amid concerns about potential supply shortages, business groups have led calls for a long-term national climate and energy policy to drive investment in new power plants.
Australia’s only existing policy to encourage private investment is a renewable energy target. Under Abbott in 2014 and 2015, the government reduced that target and abolished a 2012 carbon price scheme – described colloquially by opponents as a “carbon tax”, but actually a national emissions trading scheme that was one of the first of its kind. As yet, there is nothing to replace the renewable target when it lapses in 2020.
Earlier this year, a government-commissioned review by the nation’s chief scientist, Alan Finkel, recommended a new policy – a clean energy target – that would effectively replace the renewable target, but broaden it to encourage other low-emissions technologies. The level of support available would be weighted by emissions intensity, with clean fuels receiving more.
Months on, it is unclear whether the government will adopt it. Turnbull and environment and energy minister Josh Frydenberg have voiced support for Finkel, but face the challenge of crafting a policy that government MPs will vote for. Those who reject climate science – including Abbott, a vocal critic of Turnbull since being deposed by his party two years ago – have vowed to cross the floor to vote against any policy that subsidises clean energy ahead of coal.
While senior government members say they would welcome private investment in new coal power, they have softened expectations they will explicitly support it. In February, treasurer Scott Morrison brandished a lump of coal in Parliament, saying it had delivered prosperity for more than a century. By August, he was delivering a series of speeches warning the era of cheap coal-fired power was coming to an end. He warned new plants would be expensive and take years to build.
Instead, the government attempted to pressure energy company AGL to extend the life of the giant Liddell coal plant – 46-years-old and running below capacity due to operational problems – beyond its scheduled closure in 2022. The company resisted, instead promising to come up with a plan in 90 days to replace the 2-gigawatt capacity using other technologies.
AGL’s position on coal is consistent with the overwhelming majority of Australia energy companies and financiers. They consider coal power unbankable and, given Australia’s commitment to the Paris climate agreement, say the future is cleaner generation.
Australia’s pledge at Paris was a 26-28% emissions reduction below 2005 levels by 2030. Several analyses have found they currently have no path to meet the existing goal, let alone the eventual increased target Turnbull and Frydenberg have acknowledged is implied under the global deal.
The Australia Institute analysis is not based on official emissions data, but drawn from monthly government agency statistics for national petroleum use and electricity and gas consumption in eastern states. Saddler’s assessment that Australia and Turkey are the only Annex I countries (those considered industrialised or “economies in transition” in the 1990s) to have hit a record high for energy emissions is based on extrapolation from the most recent data submitted to the UNFCCC in 2015, when those from other countries were either in decline or well below an earlier peak.
Turkey has seen a dramatic surge in energy combustion emissions in recent years, easily outstripping other Annex I countries. Heavy investment in coal power has seen its emissions from the energy industry rise 260% since 1990, from 38m tonnes in 1990 to 137m tonnes in 2015.
The country pledged at Paris only to reduce emissions 21% below business as usual by 2030, rather than an outright cut. In July, president Recep Tayyip Erdogan said he would not be ratifying the agreement, citing Donald Trump’s announcement the US would abandon the deal.
Saddler said Turkey’s per capita emissions were less than a quarter of Australia’s, and its GDP per head less.

Links

In China, The War On Coal Just Got Serious

Fairfax - 

Beijing: In Australia, politicians continue to debate the existence of climate change. Donald Trump's Environment Protection Agency declared this week that the "war on coal is over".
In China, the outlook could not be more different.


China drives for clean coal
China is the world's biggest coal producer and carbon dioxide emitter, but is trying to take the lead in cleaner technology.

The war on coal reached fever pitch here this month. As a deadline looms to achieve clean air targets by the end of 2017, October has seen unprecedented measures come into force to curb air pollution and reduce emissions.
Steel production has been halved in major steel cities, coal banned in China's coal capital, factories closed down for failing pollution inspections, and hundreds of officials sacked for failing to meet environmental targets.

Beijing Oriental Petrochemical Plant is demolished on September 27, 2017, as part of a pollution crackdown.  Photo: Sanghee Liu
The complete shutdowns, or 50 per cent production cuts, will stay in place for an unprecedented five months.
The winter heating season in China is approaching, when coal use has traditionally spiked, worsening northern China's notorious air pollution.
But cities are under pressure to meet important domestic targets for clean air, set five years ago by the State Council in response to a public outcry over pollution.China can't allow a repeat of last winter, when, after several years of improvement, air quality suddenly worsened in some cities.

A woman wears a mask as she walks on a street in Beijing. Photo: Bloomberg
For a few days in January 2016, the sky darkened and it looked possible that the "airpocalypse" of 2013 – which first drew global attention to Beijing's severe air pollution – was back. Social media went into overdrive.
The 'airpocalypse' of winter 2013. Smog hangs in the air around buildings in Shenzhen. Photo: Bloomberg
Fighting air pollution is a matter of social stability, Environment Protection Minister Li Ganjie said a fortnight ago.

So now the Chinese government has brought out the "iron fist"
That was the phrase used by the environment protection bureau in China's most polluted province, Hebei, as 69 government officials were sacked and 154 handed over to police for investigation last month for failing to implement pollution control measures.
Meeting emissions targets has become a key performance indicator for local Communist Party bosses and mayors alike.
Local governments that don't enforce the pollution controls will have environmental assessments for new property developments suspended by the Ministry for Environment Protection, effectively blocking deals.
A battle plan has been drawn up by the ministry to cover 28 northern cities, including Beijing and Tianjin, where 7000 pollution inspectors will be deployed to expose violations and look for data fraud.
The curbs on industry, particularly steel making, are hitting world resources prices, including Australia's biggest exports, as demand for iron ore and coal fall.
Nev Power, chief executive of the world's fourth-largest iron ore producer, Fortescue Metals Group, whose share price has fallen 18 per cent, describes it as a "seasonal impact".
"We recognise that considerable efforts have been made by China in recent years to find the right balance between economic development and environmental protection," he says.
But Chinese environmental policy observers have told Fairfax Media the restrictions put in place this month, which will stay in place for five months and not the usual few weeks, are unprecedented.
The demolition of Beijing Oriental Petrochemical Plant late last month. Photo: Sanghee Liu
Ma Tianjie, managing editor of the environmental policy website China Dialogue, says the reason for the tougher approach is the 2017 deadline for the State Council action plan on air pollution, which is a "crucial policy document".
Multinationals and Chinese companies have complained the shutdowns and factory closures will hurt business and raise prices.
But, unlike what happens when polluting industries push back against government policy in Australia and the US, they have been given short shrift by China's Ministry for Environment Protection.
The ministry's director of environmental impact assessment, Cui Shuhong, held a press conference a fortnight ago to debunk the complaints, saying polluting companies will be phased out because they "disrupt the market order".
"Healthy and faster economic growth can happen along with an improved environment," he said.
The ministry released data it claims shows five polluted cities targeted by environment inspection teams have already emerged with stronger economic growth after shutting down steelmaking, removing boilers, curbing coal use and investing in energy efficient technology.
Yuan Xu, associate professor with the Chinese University of Hong Kong's Institute of Environment, Energy and Sustainability, says there has been a major change in the Chinese government's understanding of the relationship between economic growth and environmental protection.
"In the past, the two were taken as tradeoffs ... China has been more and more benefiting from newly created industries and jobs due to environmental protection and especially climate mitigation," he says.
Renewable energy has created several million jobs and multiple world-leading industries.
Clean Air Asia, a non-profit organisation set up with funding from the World Bank and Asian Development Bank, has been tracking the progress of 338 Chinese cities in meeting the five-year pollution targets.
Clean Air Asia's China director, Dr Fu Lu, says its latest report shows 84 cities attained national air quality standards in 2016. Clean Air believes 74 key cities can achieve the targets in 2017, although this will be hard for Beijing.
"The bad news is some cities failed to attain the targets they set for themselves, or even worse, their emissions rose," Fu says.
The detailed and stringent measures imposed this month are a response to the public outcry in January as severe air pollution returned to Beijing, she says: "There was heated debate on the internet. It affects public health."
Zero tolerance on smaller companies caught polluting, who will be forced out of business, shows the government's "political will" on the issue, Fu adds.
"They will cut their electricity, stop the water supply and they will disappear from the market. They won't be allowed to move elsewhere."
Four cities, including Beijing and Tianjin, will introduce "coal-free zones".
Polluting trucks will be targeted, with the major port of Tianjin banning trucks from entering to transport goods on heavy pollution days, she says. Only trucks that meet emission standards will be allowed to enter on other days.
The fight against air pollution is driving the Chinese government's emergence as a world leader on climate change, and prompted the dramatic shift in China's position in 2012 to accept binding targets, says Ma.
"Without domestic pressure from the urban middle class to tackle air pollution we wouldn't see the action on the global stage from China," he says.
Under the 2015 Paris Agreement, China said it will cut carbon dioxide emissions by 60-65 per cent by 2030.
China's special representative on climate change, Xie Zhenhua, has said: "The cause of air pollution and climate change is the same - the burning of fossil fuels. Many of the policies and measures to solve the two issues are the same."
The first scientific study to show a link between global climate change and northern China's severe winter air pollution was published in March.
The Georgia Institute of Technology's research suggests Arctic sea ice loss and increased Eurasian snowfall have changed China's winter monsoon, reducing winds and trapping pollution over northern Chinese cities.
The 2013 "airpocalypse", and last winter, saw the same unusual weather conditions, with no ventilation and severe haze.
This finding emphasises the importance of cutting greenhouse gases to alleviate winter pollution, said the study's author, Yuhang Wang, professor of earth and atmospheric sciences at Georgia Tech.
But it also suggests the success of China's big campaign to fight air pollution this winter will depend on weather conditions, he told Fairfax Media.
"There have been many extreme weather events around the world this year, such as the heatwave in early summer in China, the large number of category 4 hurricanes hitting the US, or the ongoing California fires.
"It is definitely the winter to watch from both emission and climate perspectives."

How China is "waging tough war against air pollution" and tackling climate change:
Coal

A coal-fired power plant spews emissions in Taiyuan, China. Photo: Bloomberg
When Treasurer Scott Morrison visited Beijing last month, he was told China was shutting coal mines because they "aren't consistent with the government's environmental objectives".
China's biggest coal hub, Taiyuan in Shanxi province, banned the sale, transport and use of coal on October 1. The city produces a quarter of China's coal output, but the ban will stay in place over winter to reduce coal use by 2 million tonnes.
Across northern cities, 44,000 small coal-fired furnaces will be shut by the end of October, and 72 coal-fired generators will close.
China has stopped construction on 150 gigawatts of planned new coal-fired power generation capacity until 2020.
Another 100 gigawatts will be "upgraded" to reduce emissions.

Steel
Workers take a break while sitting on a pile of steel wires at a stockyard run by the Shanghai Yirong Trading Co. Photo: Qilai Shen
Half of China's iron and steel production occurs in the 28 cities in the action plan.
Tianjin, along with the cities of Tangshan, Handan, Shijiazhuang and Anyang will cut steel mill production by 50 per cent from October.
Western analysts estimate 6 per cent of China's annual crude steel output will be lost.
Emission standards for iron and steel have also been lowered.

Household heating
Three million households using coal for heating will be provided with electricity or natural gas heating.

Factory closures
176,000 companies who failed to meet emission targets were to be closed by October 1.

Accountability
Party chiefs will be accountable if a district fails to meet air pollution goals, and will be summoned to Beijing. If major media report more than five times that a province has failed to implement pollution controls, the party chief will be charged with dereliction of duty and punished.
Companies will be shamed in the media, and a WeChat tipline set up for the public to report polluters.

ETS
A national emissions trading scheme is expected to begin by the end of 2017, starting with power generators, after seven pilots in major cities.

Renewable energy
China's National Energy Administration plans to spend $US360 billion ($486 billion) by 2020 on renewable energy including solar and wind, to account for half of new generated capacity, and create 13 million jobs. China is already the world's largest renewable energy employer, with 3.5 million people working in the sector. It added 21 gigawatts of solar capacity in the past six months.

Vehicles
China says it will set a timetable to phase out fossil fuel cars. A 10 per cent minimum sales target for electric cars will be imposed on large car manufacturers from 2019. A car maker producing 1 million cars annually will have to produce and sell 25,000 electric vehicles.
Of a total 205 million registered cars, 1 million are "new energy" vehicles.

Beijing
Beijing closed its last major coal-fired power plant in March, and will replace coal heating in factories and households by the end of the year. Coal consumption fell to 9.5 million tonnes last year, down from 30 million in 2005.
Beijing said it would "rectify" 5500 "scattered, chaotic and polluting" companies by October. The Beijing Oriental Petrochemical Plant was demolished on September 27 and will become a park.

Links

Australia Needs Electric Vehicles More Than Any Other Nation

ABC - Behyad Jafari*

A paltry 0.1 per cent of new vehicle sales in Australia last year were recorded as electric. (ABC: Spence Denny)
Every major nation can benefit from a swift switch to electric vehicles, but Australia's very existence may rely on it.
If that sounds dramatic, consider the facts.
Australia is now heading towards 100 per cent import dependency on fuel, primarily from the Middle East and through Asia.
As an Iranian refugee, I know something about being imported to Australia from the Middle East and I can tell you: it's not smooth sailing.
We're now dependent on this route, traversed by foreign-owned vessels, primarily via the South China Sea.

Two weeks of fuel reserve
Last year, the former Deputy Chief of the RAAF, Air Vice Marshall John Blackburn, was commissioned by the NRMA to provide strategic advice on Australia's fuel security.
He found Australia's food, water, and medicine distribution was reliant on imported transport fuel and our supply operated on a "just in time" approach for logistical efficiency.
Long story short: at any given time, Australia has no more than two weeks' worth of imported fuel in the country.
After that, everything grinds to a complete and catastrophic halt.
Today, instability around North Korea and territorial conflicts in the South China Sea make the shipping routes more insecure than ever.
If any real conflict breaks out in the area, what priority would fuel imports to Australia take?
Would foreign-owned ships risk travelling through a conflict zone to satisfy contractual arrangements with Australian entities?
Would foreign suppliers even be willing to continue exporting?
The NRMA has estimated even a 20 to 40 per cent cut in Australia's fuel supply, "would quickly lead to a situation whereby the country would start running out of food and medicines, while the economy would start to shut down".


Individually owned cars are underutilised and costly. Autonomous vehicles are already in use in Australia. We could be on the cusp of the fastest, deepest disruption in transportation history.

The world's great electric vehicle laggard
There's obviously plenty to be worried about with this scenario. Yet we should also be angry. Because the simple fact is there is no reason for our fuel security situation to be this precarious.
Australia could easily produce enough electricity to power millions of vehicles, providing greater demand for investment in renewable energy.
Yet somehow Australia, despite having the most to gain, is the world's great electric vehicle laggard.
A paltry 0.1 per cent of new vehicle sales in Australia last year were recorded as electric.
In other comparable nations, electric vehicles have become the norm: 29 per cent of new vehicles sold in Norway are now electric. Major vehicle markets such as China, France, and Britain have announced they will ban the sale of petrol and diesel vehicles. Countries and companies around the world have made clear the future of the market is electric.

Benefits besides fuel security
Even if you are somehow completely sanguine about the situation in the South China Sea, Australia's slowness to move is costing us on myriad other levels.
Electric vehicles are, for example, an efficient way for Australia to reduce carbon emissions.
An electric vehicle charged from the existing power grid already produces fewer emissions than the average petrol engine vehicle. This advantage will increase rapidly as the electricity sector moves toward renewables.
Electric vehicles would also clear air and noise pollution in our major cities. Major points of community anger, like smoke stacks in residential areas, could vanish.
Electric vehicles would also free Australian households from the tyranny of the bowser. With solar panels on your roof, most nights you could plug your car at home and fill up free. Music to the ears of those in our outer suburbs and regions, especially.

Send consumers a message
Here's the kicker: moving Australia towards electric vehicles would not require a massive commitment from government.
The benefits are so clear, we just have to dislodge the boulder from the top of the mountain.
The latest research shows most Australians would consider buying an electric vehicle, but are put off by the idea it is niche and unsupported by national infrastructure.
So, all that's needed is a clear, unambiguous message to consumers and industry that the government supports electric.

A step to build momentum
One easy, revenue-neutral step would be to provide a short-term exemption for electric vehicles from fringe benefits tax.
Half a million fleet vehicles are bought by the government and companies in Australia every year.
If we can help encourage a decent proportion of these sales to be electric it would kick start the transition.
The foregone revenue could easily be made up by only slightly increasing the impost on conventional vehicles.
In addition, governments might provide short-term exemptions to costs like stamp duty, registration and other taxes levied on the car market. Incentives could be provided for the mass installation of charging infrastructure.
The point is that once the momentum towards electric vehicles starts, it will be unstoppable.
A few small but important steps is all Australia needs to be a cleaner, healthier and more secure nation.

*Behyad Jafari is chief executive of the Electric Vehicle Council.

Links

Friday, October 20, 2017

September 2017 Was Fourth Warmest September On Record

NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies

A global map of the September 2017 LOTI (land-ocean temperature index) anomaly, relative to the 1951-1980 September average. View larger image.
September 2017 was the fourth warmest September in 137 years of modern record-keeping, according to a monthly analysis of global temperatures by scientists at NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies (GISS) in New York.
Last month was +0.80 degrees Celsius warmer than the mean September temperature from 1951-1980. The warmest months of September according to the analysis happened in 2016 and 2014 (+0.87 degrees Celsius) and 2015 (+0.82 degrees Celsius).
The GISTEMP monthly temperature anomalies superimposed on a 1980-2015 mean seasonal cycle. View larger image or PDF. 
The monthly analysis by the GISS team is assembled from publicly available data acquired by about 6,300 meteorological stations around the world, ship- and buoy-based instruments measuring sea surface temperature, and Antarctic research stations.
The modern global temperature record begins around 1880 because previous observations didn't cover enough of the planet. Monthly analyses are sometimes updated when additional data becomes available, and the results are subject to change.

Links

Doctors Call On Health Super Funds To Pull $1.7 Billion Out Of Coal And Oil Companies

Fairfax - Adam Carey

Hundreds of Victorian doctors and medical staff are pressuring their super funds to quit investing in coal and oil for the sake of health, as they did with tobacco five years ago.
The group, which includes some of Australia's leading health experts, says there is overwhelming evidence that climate change is already making people sick and causing thousands of deaths.
Hundreds of medical staff in Victoria are pressuring their super funds to divest from corporations that are based on fossil fuels. Photo: Jason South
They want the two largest health super funds, HESTA and First State, to divest from fossil fuel-based companies, arguing the nest eggs of the medical profession should not be built on industries that make people sick.
Combined, the two default health super funds have about $1.72 billion invested in these heavily fossil fuel-based companies, according to Market Forces, an environmental investment advisory group.
They point to fatal thunderstorm asthma attacks in Melbourne last year and the 45-day Hazelwood mine fire as recent local examples.
More than 650 health professionals nationwide have signed up to the cause so far, including former Australian of the year Professor Fiona Stanley, celebrated for her achievements in child health, and Dr Grant Blashki, associate professor in global health at the University of Melbourne's Nossal Institute.
The pro-divestment group, called Healthy Futures, have called on HESTA and First State to abandon their investments in companies including Caltex, Woodside Petroleum, Exxon and Origin.
Co-founder Kate Lardner, a Melbourne-based surgical resident, said health workers in the group did not want their retirement savings to support carbon-intensive industries.
"As health professionals, we don't want to see our money invested in fossil fuels that cause air pollution in places like the Latrobe Valley and contribute to climate change that we're already seeing locally," Dr Lardner said.
The Andrews government has commissioned a study into the long-term health effects of the Hazelwood coal mine fire, which blanketed the town of Morwell in smoke and ash for several weeks in 2014.
It also spent $15 million on a thunderstorm asthma warning system after Melbourne's ambulances and hospitals were overwhelmed by people suffering intense asthma attacks last spring.
Dr Lardner said thunderstorm asthma could not be directly attributed to climate change, but more frequent and violent storms could be.
The Hazelwood Health Study has already produced evidence that Morwell residents are at much greater risk of having a heart attack than other Gippsland communities.
The two super funds said they had no plan to divest from the companies targeted by Healthy Futures.
Liza McDonald, First State's Head of Responsible Investments, said the fund preferred to engage with emissions-intensive industries on climate change rather than cut them loose.
"However, if we do have concerns about long-term sustainability issues with an individual company, we would consider a range of options, which may include divestment," Ms McDonald said.
HESTA said it would only divest from a company as a last resort.
In a letter to the Doctors Reform Society,  a medical think tank that has joined the campaign, HESTA said that to divest would limit the ability to encourage coal and oil-based corporations to reform.
"The aim is to accelerate the move to a less carbon intensive future. Ownership provides leverage which greatly increases the impact of our engagement," HESTA wrote.

Links

Jobs Bonanza? The Adani Project Is More Like A Railway To Nowhere

The Guardian - *

The Carmichael coal mine was once pitched as a choice between jobs and the environment. So where are the jobs?
‘The construction of the rail line connecting the mine site to the Abbot Point port (pictured) depends on getting a loan of around $900m from the Northern Australia Infrastructure Facility.’ Photograph: Tom Jefferson/Greenpeace 
The dispute over the Adani Group’s proposed Carmichael mine and the associated port at Abbot Point has long been cast as a choice between jobs and the environment. Climate change is already well on the way to destroying the Great Barrier Reef, among many other things, and the development of the massive coal reserves of the Galilee Basin would make it almost impossible to stabilise the global climate.
On the other hand, we are promised an economic bonanza with 10,000 jobs and billions of dollars in royalties and taxes. For hard-pressed cities like Townsville and Rockhampton and for governments with a chronic shortage of funds, this seems too good to turn down.
It’s becoming increasingly evident, however, that the choice is a false one. In all probability, neither the jobs nor the revenue will ever materialise. Rather, the whole project will turn into a sink, into which public money is poured for no return.
In June this year, when Adani announced the establishment of a regional headquarters in Townsville, expected to employ 500 people, the commencement of pre-construction works in the September quarter, and the reiteration of the 10,000 jobs claim. To address the task of filling all those positions, Adani created a “jobs portal”.
By September, nothing had happened. The Townsville headquarters was staffed mainly by about 80 workers transferred from Brisbane. The start of pre-construction was re-announced, this time for October. The jobs portal had advertised less than a dozen Adani jobs (at the time of publishing, there are seven jobs on offer). The contractor supposed to begin work on the site was similarly invisible.
Then came the revelations from the Guardian, and then Four Corners, on Adani’s environmental and financial practices, revealing that the chain of companies through which the project is controlled stretches back through the Cayman Islands to an even more opaque tax haven in the British Virgin Islands.
As usual, Adani’s response was to play the jobs card, announcing that the fly-in, fly-out (Fifo) workforce for the mine would be divided between the two leading claimants, Townsville and Rockhampton. The response was predictably enthusiastic, with the Queensland premier. Annastacia Palaszczuk, describing it as “great news for those regional communities that have been struggling”. The euphoria surrounding the announcement obscured the fact that the promised job bonanza had been scaled back, with the mine now expected to employ about 2,000 workers and the regional headquarters only 150.
Even bigger news was buried, or ignored altogether. In return for their selection as the Fifo hubs, the Townsville and Rockhampton councils agreed to pay $18.5m each over the next two years to build an airstrip at the mine site.
The use of local government money to build infrastructure for Adani epitomises the entire project. The construction of the rail line connecting the mine site to the port depends on getting a loan of around $900m from the commonwealth government’s Northern Australia Infrastructure Facility. Publicly owned export-import banks in Australia and elsewhere are also being pushed to fund the project.
Adani upped the pressure to fund the project last week, announcing that it would break ground on the rail line “within days”. With construction already underway, what government would dare to pull the plug? However, a closer reading suggests that the ground breaking will be of the kind seen on an episode of Utopia, in which assorted dignitaries use ceremonial shovels to “mark the official start” of the project (which already had its first “official start” back in June). This was confirmed by the announcement that the official start, planned for Friday, had been postponed indefinitely because of a forecast of rain.


Fact v fiction: Adani's Carmichael coal mine – video explainer 

Even with generous public support, it seems unlikely that the Carmichael mine can be made economically viable. Why then, does Gautam Adani, the ultimate owner of the Adani Group, continue to push the project? It could be simply the hubris of a wealthy and powerful man, unaccustomed to defeat.
More likely, however, is that the manoeuvres around this project are part of a more complex strategy. As analysis by the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis has shown, Adani needs to refinance its Abbot Point coal terminal by by November 2018. In the absence of Galilee Basin coal, the export volumes through the port won’t be sufficient to service the debt.
So, it’s in Adani’s interest to keep the Carmichael project alive as long as possible. On the other hand, any Adani money invested in the project, beyond the large sum that has already been spent, is likely to be lost.
Fortunately for Adani, it seems, both national and local governments appear willing to use public money to finance the supporting infrastructure (air and rail links) needed before the mine itself can begin operations. The result is that if the mine does not go ahead, Adani’s losses will be minimised. The Australian public will be the proud owners of a railway to nowhere, with an airstrip at the end.

*John Quiggin is an economist at the University of Queensland

Thursday, October 19, 2017

Why Turnbull’s Plan Could Be Disaster For Renewables, Climate, Prices

RenewEconomy - 

(AAP Image/Mick Tsikas)
On the face of it a twin-pronged system focusing on reliability and environmental outcomes could have appeal. But we just don’t know because the details of Malcolm Turnbull’s National Energy Guarantee (NEG), and even the basics of how it will work, have not been explained.
As one clean energy advocate said on Tuesday: “We’re still trying to understand whether we love or hate the NEG”. Part of that hesitation is based around the oft-made assumption that it might be better to have something, rather than nothing. But that remains to be seen.
The mainstream media certainly embraced it, but analysts see red flags all over the place – it is potentially bad news for renewables, bad news for emissions, and bad news for prices. It is potentially Turnbull’s energy trilemma turned upside down.
Most of all, the proposal appears to be the most ill-considered, poorly detailed and potentially useless policy that anyone can remember – the work of Australia’s so-called “energy mafia” hungry to defend the power of the incumbent oligopoly, commercial interests and their ideology.
Here’s a list of reasons why people should be concerned.

Did anyone tell the Coalition party room that this is a de-facto carbon price?
Energy analysts say it is a little early to tell, because there are no actual details, but it looks variously like a emissions intensity scheme, which Turnbull has been pushing for in various forms since 2008, or a mix of a baseline and credit scheme and a capacity market.
Market analysts Reputex describe it is a de-facto carbon price. “The attributes of the NEG will, in effect, establish a de-facto price on greenhouse gas emissions from the power sector, and provide a robust source of demand for Australian Carbon Credit Units (ACCU),” it says.
Little wonder, then, that Tony Abbott is not impressed. “Tony is a conscientious objector,” says energy minister Josh Frydenberg. But he’ll apparently hold his tongue for the moment.

But this carbon price will be invisible
Not only will it be a de-facto carbon price, it will also be invisible,  because the “market” will be hidden by the complexity of energy price caps and hedges. That is a major concern.
There is absolutely no transparency in this market, which is why the big gen-tailers are in favour of it, because it hands them absolute control and discretion over the market and investments.
The scheme will, ostensibly, be monitored by the same useless regulators that allowed the networks – and latterly the generators and retailers – to gouge consumers over the last 10 years, and enabled them, more recently, to “play” the market for certificates in the renewable energy target.
It’s hardly reassuring for the consumer. The power of the energy oligopoly is simply reinforced.

The emissions target are manifestly inadequate
The emissions reduction target that the ESB was asked to work with – a 26 per cent cut in electricity emissions from 2005 levels by 2030 – is manifestly inadequate, for even Australia’s current climate commitment (it loads a lot of effort on to other sectors), but also to the ultimate goal of capping global warming well below 2°C.
Even Origin Energy recognises this, noting the cavernous gap between the Paris target and the current emissions trajectory, a trajectory made worse by the government’s hint that any emissions targets will be “back-ended” to 2030.
But as with Finkel, the low target might be deliberate, so as not to scare the horses and the climate deniers. (Note the IPA came out again on Tuesday and argued for no emission cuts).
Had Finkel couched his review in terms of what needed to be done, like the Climate Change Authority, his conclusion would likely have been a renewables share approaching 70 per cent by 2030, not the 42 per cent in his document.

And those emissions targets may have been largely met, already
The big question is how much new investment the scheme will pull in. Not a lot. That’s because, as David Leitch tells us, the current build-out of renewables under the renewable energy target, and the closure of the Hazelwood power station has already got the country much of the way there.
Leitch says that, on his numbers, only around 4,000MW of new large-scale renewables would be required between 2020 and 2030 to meet the current emissions target. That’s not much. The scheme would only work if there were serious reduction targets. And he doesn’t hold out much hope of that, in the current political environment.
Worse, he notes of Snowy 2.0: “(The government) is funding a very expensive project designed to supply a reliability rule that they have expressly forced onto retailers. In essence it is making a rule that requires retailers to buy the output from its own project. The mafia would approve.”

It could mean zero additions to large-scale renewables
Even Leitch’s analysis could be optimistic. The advice from the ESB suggests a range of 28-36 per cent renewables by 2030, and 18-24 per cent wind and solar share. This estimate includes rooftop solar, according to ESB chair Kerry Schott.
Given the anticipated, and one would suspect, unstoppable uptake of rooftop solar by households and businesses in response to high power prices that are not coming down, it means that at the bottom end of their range, the ESB is predicting virtually no new wind and solar projects in the country between 2020 and 2030.
And given that anticipated surge in rooftop solar, even the top end of the forecast allows for little in the way of new renewables, which seems extraordinary given the recognition by Schott and even the Coalition about the falling cost of wind and solar.

Fancy investing in a Peru landfill gas mine rather than an Australia wind farm?
The market component even has an international flavour. The advice from the ESB includes the possibility of retailers meeting their environmental obligations through international credits.
That likely means that rather than investing in an Australian wind or solar farm, the likes of Origin, AGL and EnergyAustralia could invest in a third-world project that generates cheap credits – like the Peruvian landfill gas plant and other facilities supported by the UN’s Clean Development Mechanism that small retailer PowerShop invests in so it can claim to be “carbon neutral”.

And it may not lead to investment certainty
Many are defending the NEG on the basis that any sort of policy is better than nothing. That reminds us of Turnbull’s last major achievement, the bastardisation of the CPRS before he was rolled by Abbott in 2009.
Morgan Stanley’s Rob Koh notes that, on the detail presented so far, the government will set emissions reductions pathway (rather than that being done by an independent body).
“The risk of political interference in the targets may reduce investor confidence in the scheme, particularly where there is no explicit linkage to Australia’s Paris Agreement commitments,” Koh writes. And because no one else has done this sort of scheme, it will inevitably have to be fine-tuned.

The price cuts are trivial, so consumers will find own way with solar and storage
The promised price reductions of around $100 a year have not been modelled, may be as low as 50c a week, and may just be a figment of Pierce’s imagination. It just hasn’t been modelled. Given the absurdly high price of electricity in Australia and the competing forces of rooftop solar and storage, that offers nothing to consumers.
“Regardless of what Turnbull and his mates decide, shaving between $25-$100 off someone’s bill is meaningless compared to the difference that behind the meter PV, storage and demand management can make,” says Adrian Merrick from EnergyLocals.
“While they focus on gaining votes from policy headlines, we’re quietly making the change a reality.” Tomorrow, on One Step Off The Grid, another example will be published of how consumers will do this.

What does it mean for the states?
No one is too sure. The Labor states have targets ranging from 40 per cent by 2025 (Victoria), to 50 per cent by 2030 (Queensland and the NT) and 100% by 2020 (ACT). South Australia is already at more than 50 per cent.
But after what has been described as a testy phone hook-up between Frydenberg and the state ministers, the states say they have been gobsmacked by the lack of detail, and the apparent back-flip by the Coalition, who having once damned the states for “going it alone” now want them to do the heavy lifting.
The Coalition needs state approval for the changes, because they involve alterations to the market rules.

A victory for the energy mafia?
This is the question everyone is asking. An eight-page letter with no detail and some fuzzy ideas, ostensibly from the Energy Security Board, comprising two new independent directors (Schott and Clare Savage) and the heads of AEMO, AEMC and the AER.
This is the sort of scheme that the energy oligopoly and their attendants in various consultancies and think tanks (some call them the energy mafia) have been busting to do for years. See our first point about the lack of transparency in the markets and the control by the incumbents.
And all fingers are pointing to John Pierce, the head of the AEMC, the rule-maker that has fought so hard against renewable targets, and rule changes, and has been a staunch defender of fossil fuel markets.
He appears to have seized an opportunity, with impeccable timing, and was clearly joined by key players in the major utilities who have been quick to give their imprimatur. There is a body of opinion in the energy market that Pierce has outflanked his rivals and peers.
It was noticeable that Turnbull deflected to Pierce during the various briefing – indeed, Turnbull has been using the heads of the various agencies as some sort of human shield to deflect attacks, defending the policy’s expediency through their “expertise”.
Schott further added to this view of the role of Pierce, suggesting it was the culmination of a “year of work”. But the ESB only met for the first time a month ago. And the only member of the ESB “around for years” is Pierce.

Schott’s quick change on renewables
The fact that the heads of the other agencies were willing to put their names on such a vague document has surprised many in the industry, particularly in the case of Schott, admired for being a no-nonsence administrator.
Here, Schott has signed her name to a document apparently condemning renewables to zero or limited growth in the next decade. Yet it was just a few months ago that Schott was chair of Transgrid, a major transmission company that said decarbonising the grid with a very high penetration of renewables was not only doable within a few decades, but would also lower prices.
See this story Transgrid: 100% renewables is feasible and affordable. That’s not the story that the ESB is telling us now. What do they know that the boffins at the networks and the CSIRO do not?

Is AEMO confusing the role of system security and dispatchability?
The role of AEMO is also curious. On Tuesday at the behest of the prime minister, AEMO CEO Audrey Zibelman talked about the recent interventions by AEMO into the South Australia market, which included limiting the amount of wind if not enough gas generation was present.
But this immediately raised questions about what these interventions – largely about the level of “fault current” – have got to do with dispatchability and the recommendations of the ESB. The CEC’s policy wonk, Tom Butler, tweeted this after the Tuesday press conference:
IMAGE
There is normally plenty of dispatchable generation in South Australia, it’s just that the plant operators have to be given a boot up the backside by the market operator to switch them on. System security is one thing, dispatchability is another. It is not clear how the NEG would address that.
We asked AEMO and were advised to talk to the ESB. But, we said, the ESB is just the heads of the agencies, of which AEMO is one. Finally we got a reply:
“The NEG provides the opportunity to signal what the system requires to ensure reliability. AEMO has been consistent in its position that we require a portfolio of resources that meet all the objectives (such as frequency, inertia, voltage control etc) to maintain power system security and reliability.”
They suggested we talk to Schott. But Schott’s office said that wasn’t possible until next week at the earliest.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative