Friday, November 24, 2017

South Australia And ACT Outvoted On National Energy Guarantee

The Guardian - 

Government secures agreement to continue work on its proposed mechanism without direct comparison with alternative schemes
SA’s Jay Weatherill and the ACT were one vote short of a majority over the energy guarantee. Photograph: Mark Brake/AAP
The government has secured agreement for further work to be carried out on the national energy guarantee despite resistance from South Australia and the ACT.
As flagged by Guardian Australia on Thursday, some of the Labor states wanted a detailed comparison with alternatives such as the chief scientist’s clean energy target and an emissions intensity trading scheme.
But at a meeting of energy ministers in Hobart on Friday the commonwealth, New South Wales, Victoria and Tasmania said further work should be undertaken without the side-by-side comparisons.
Jay Weatherill’s South Australian government and the ACT wanted the direct comparisons, but were outvoted. Queensland was not present at Friday’s meeting because the state is in caretaker mode ahead of Saturday’s state election. Western Australia and the Northern Territory were not represented as they are not part of the national electricity market.
The Turnbull government’s proposed national energy guarantee, unveiled last month, would impose new reliability and emissions reduction guarantees on energy retailers and large energy users from 2020.
A review of the national electricity market by Australia’s chief scientist, Alan Finkel, recommended a clean energy target for the electricity sector – but that recommendation was dumped by the government largely because of opposition within the Coalition.
Friday’s meeting agreed that the Energy Security Board would undertake work on the national energy guarantee only as directed by the energy ministers’ council within the Council of Australian Governments, with the detail of the scheme to be considered next April.
The meeting considering the nuts and bolts of the guarantee will therefore happen after the state election in South Australia, which is due in March. The Weatherill government has led the resistance to the guarantee on the basis the policy is not sufficiently friendly to renewables.
After Friday’s meeting, the South Australian energy minister, Tom Koutsantonis, told reporters that he and the ACT’s energy minister, Shane Rattenbury, had simply sought proof the national energy guarantee was the best policy option.
“We sought proof ... and they refused,” Koutsantonis said. He said the government’s refusal to benchmark the policy against viable alternatives indicated there was something to hide.
“Why are we choosing the third best option?”
Koutsantonis said South Australia and the ACT would proceed with their own modelling providing the direct comparison sought at the meeting.
Rattenbury said he was frustrated by the commonwealth’s position. “It is clear that the jurisdictions are lining up to push the national energy guarantee through, and we will need to work hard to make sure that the rules are designed in a way that does not freeze out renewables, and does not lock in coal.
“We need to make sure that does not happen.”
Koutsantonis said there was a schism in the energy council between coal states and states that wanted “to move forward with a real solution”.

Links

'Worst Fears': States Prepare To Highlight The Negatives In Turnbull's Energy Plan

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

The Turnbull government's national energy guarantee is set for a rocky reception when energy ministers meet in Hobart, with one state declaring new modelling confirmed its "worst fears", and another saying it was "deeply disappointing".
Federal Environment and Energy minister Josh Frydenberg will front the dinner on Thursday night and is expected to release a paper during Friday's talks that has yet to be shared with state and territory counterparts.


Which is Australia's most renewable state?
With states taking the lead in the renewable energy push, a report by the Climate Council puts each state's efforts against one another.

The federal government provided a summary of its modelling for the energy guarantee on Wednesday, claiming wholesale prices would be as much as 23 per cent lower than business usual under the dual "guarantee" to cut emissions while improving reliability of the nation's ailing electricity grid.
South Australia Energy Minister Tom Koutsantonis indicated his state would reject the plan, which needs consensus from all parties to proceed. For historical reasons, changes to the National Electricity Market also need to pass the SA parliament.
The energy guarantee modelling released so far "confirms my worst fears", Mr Koutsantonis told reporters, adding the scheme "is designed to guarantee more coal".
Of particular concern to South Australia's Labor government is that the scheme would bolster the clout of the big "gentailers", AGL and Origin Energy, which dominate generation and retailing in the state.
"We need to smash their monopoly power into a thousand pieces, not entrench it," he said, adding any future consolidation would "quite frankly [be] a disaster".
Victoria was more circumspect, as the Labor government there continues to analyse the information provided by Canberra.
A spokesman for Lily D'Ambrosio, Victoria's Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change, said the state was again "deeply disappointed" in the manner the energy guarantee modelling was "announced without consultation with the states".
Sunrise or sunset for coal-fired power: NEG would extend the life of aging fossil fuel plants. Photo: AP
"Josh Frydenberg is more interested in briefing newspapers than COAG partners," the spokesman said.
"We won't commit to a political fix for Malcolm Turnbull - we will deliver an energy policy that ensures Victorian families and businesses get the affordable, reliable and clean energy they deserve."
The NEG is designed to aging coal plants in operation longer. Photo: AAP
Mr Frydenberg was unavailable to comment.

'Unanswered questions'
One senior state official told Fairfax Media the federal government's handling of the energy issue continued to flout any standard of policy process.
"We don't know where it's going to go," the official said, adding, "what is the curve as far as emissions go?"
The federal government is supposed to release its review of climate policies before the end of 2017.
Queensland's Energy Minister Mark Bailey, meanwhile said the NEG as proposed "still has too many unanswered questions - the impact on jobs in our booming renewables industry and how Queenslander's bills will be affected".
"We have concerns that bill savings for Queenslanders could be much less than $120 [per year], which is an average across the NEM," he said​. "While any savings from the NEG wouldn't flow for two years, our Affordable Energy Plan will deliver savings from 1 January 2018."
Queensland will be represented at the Hobart talks by a senior bureaucrat, ahead of Saturday's state elections.

'Thought bubble'
Hopes of a bipartisan federal agreement on the energy guarantee also appear to be fading, with Labor's climate spokesman Mark Butler saying the modelling released for the government's "latest energy policy thought bubble confirms their attack on renewable energy will continue".
"The modelling shows the NEG will crush investment in solar PV with no additional solar – including rooftop – expected until 2028," Mr Butler said.
The renewable energy mix is only expected to reach 36 per cent by 2030, Mr Butler said, a mere 0.5 per cent increase above already committed investment every year over the 2020s.
In exchange, the best the modelling could offer in terms of price savings amid rocketing power bills was the equivalent of $2.30 a week in three years' time, he said.
Don Harwon, NSW's Energy Minister, declined to comment ahead of the Hobart gathering, a spokesman said.

Links

Thursday, November 23, 2017

Report Shows Boom In Solar As Electricity Price Rises Start To Bite

NEWS.com.au - Charis Chang

Solar panels installed on roofs in South Australia. Source:Supplied
ELECTRICITY price rises have driven a boom in rooftop solar with installations at their second highest levels.
Green Energy Markets’ Renewable Energy Index, funded by GetUp, shows more than 100 megawatts of rooftop solar was installed across Australia’s main grids in October.
It’s only the second time installations have passed more than 100MW in a single month. The first time was in June 2012 when much higher solar subsidies were available.
Across the country about 15,736 solar systems were installed in October.
The boom comes as a report released on Tuesday found gas prices were up 16 per cent in Victoria and electricity prices had surged by 5 per cent in 2016-17.
GetUp’s environmental justice director, Miriam Lyons, said people were sick of being ripped off by power companies and were taking matters into their own hands.
“It’s quite clear that crippling electricity bills are driving people to install more panels, to take
advantage of the free, clean energy the sun provides every day,” she said.
“This should be a wake up call to both governments and energy companies. People who have the ability to install solar, are doing it in droves. Those who don’t are being slugged with high wholesale prices and unreasonable retail mark-ups.”
The 106MW installed in October will produce enough energy to power 28,000 homes and is
expected to save households $195 million on power bills over the next 10 years.


South Australia could have the cheapest power in Australia

The Victorian Energy Market report found some customers were still struggling to pay their power bills despite companies offering “bigger and bigger” discounts.
“In other words, bigger discounts don’t necessarily mean cheaper bills,” Essential Services Commission chair, Dr Ron Ben-David, said.
“As a result, the advertised discount rate is a poor measure of the amount a customer can expect to pay for their electricity or gas.”
Dr Ben-David said the combined impact of rising prices and bill shock from not meeting discount conditions left many people struggling.
The report found increases in penalties for failing to keep up with discount conditions and steep energy price rises were forcing many customers into hardship programs.
The findings reinforced the need to push ahead with changes to energy rules to make sure those struggling to pay their bills received timely, flexible and meaningful assistance, Dr Ben-David added.
Those rules will come into effect in January 2019.

Links

Australia Facing Climate Disaster On Its Doorstep, Government's White Paper Warns

The Guardian - 

Foreign policy paper says climate-related conflict and migration could put Australia’s economic interests under pressure
Malcolm Turnbull and Julie Bishop at the launch of the foreign policy white paper. The foreign affairs minister said Australia would resist the ‘false hope of protectionism and isolationism’. Photograph: Lukas Coch/AAP
Climate change is creating a disaster on Australia’s doorstep, with environmental degradation and the demand for sustainable sources of food undermining stability in some countries, especially “fragile states”, according to the Australian government’s first foreign policy white paper in more than a decade.
The new white paper, released on Thursday, contains warnings over the disruptive effects of climate change in Australia’s immediate region, noting that many small island states will be “severely affected in the long term”, and the coming decade will see increased need for disaster relief.
The white paper notes the demand for water and food will rise, with the world’s oceans and forests under intense pressure. It notes climate change and pressure on the environment could contribute to conflict and irregular migration, impacting specifically on Australia’s economic interests.
Despite the obvious challenges for Australia and the world posed by Donald Trump’s presidency, and a live debate in this country about whether Australia needs to rethink the American alliance, the white paper makes a strong case for the United States to remain engaged in the region to counterbalance China’s increasingly assertive posture.
It notes that the postwar alliance with the US “is central to Australia’s security and sits at the core of our strategic and defence planning”.
While the white paper makes the case that it is in Australia’s interests to pursue a cooperative relationship with China, it contains language critical of China’s military posturing. It characterises the disputes that have emerged in the South China Sea as “a major fault line in the regional order”.
“Australia is particularly concerned by the unprecedented pace and scale of China’s activities,” the paper says. “Australia opposes the use of disputed features and artificial structures in the South China Sea for military purposes.
“Elsewhere in the region, Australia is concerned about the potential for the use of force or coercion in the East China Sea and Taiwan Strait.”
With strategic tensions in the region on the rise, the white paper foreshadows a more activist Australian engagement with the democracies of the Indo-Pacific, meaning Japan, India, Indonesia and Korea – and more active support for the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (Asean) countries, where China is attempting to assert diplomatic dominance.
It also underscores the “grave and growing” threat posed by North Korea, characterising the behaviour of the Pyongyang regime as the most immediate security challenge for the region – while referencing the ongoing global threat from terrorism and insurgencies. Australia has been active in countering Isis-linked militants in the southern Philippines.
The white paper also references the political challenges of the age, charting rising anti-globalisation and populist sentiment. “Doubts about openness has grown, as have concerns about the effect of globalisation, mainly immigration, on cultural identity and social cohesion”.
It notes that politics in some countries has become more fragmented and “volatile”, with nationalism and protectionist sentiment on the rise, with global governance and the rules-based order now contested.
It notes that a more inward-looking world is a world less likely to rise collectively to meet collective security challenges.
“We will be living in a more contested and competitive world,” the foreign affairs minister, Julie Bishop, said Thursday.
“Technological advances will disrupt the way we live and work and interact. There will be shifts in relative power between nations and the international rules-based order will continue to be challenged by some nations seeking short-term gain.”
She said Australia would step up support for “our neighbourhood, where we have distinct responsibilities” and resist the “false hope of protectionism and isolationism”.
In signalling a more activist role for Australia in the Indo-Pacific, the prime minister said that, in the past, “we could safely assume that the world worked in a way that suited Australia”.
“Now power is shifting and the rules and institutions are under challenge.”
Malcolm Turnbull said the world was experiencing unprecedented prosperity and opportunity “but the liberal, rules-based order that underpins it all is under greater stress than at any time since its creation in the 1940s”.
He noted that Australia had entered a period where its dominant security partner, the United States, was not its dominant trading partner, China. “We must see this as an opportunity, not as a risk,” he said.
The prime minister said the white paper provided “a framework for securing our own future, while sharing the burden of collective leadership with trusted partners and friends”.
Turnbull said Australia had no intention of degrading the postwar alliance with the US but the contemporary climate meant “pursuing our interests as much in San Francisco as in Shanghai, and always on our own terms”.
“Our alliance with the United States reflects a deep alignment of interests and values, while never being a straitjacket for Australian policymaking,” the prime minister said. “Our friendship and partnership with China enriches our economy and society, while not preventing us from vigorously advancing our own interests.”
Turnbull said the US would remain a significant presence in the region, “leaving aside one administration or one president”, because it was “manifestly in America’s long-term national interest today, tomorrow and as it has always been”.

Links

Why Climate Change Is A Key Issue In The Queensland Election

Huffington Post - Andrew Picone

I have no doubt that every Queenslander wants the Great Barrier Reef to be there for future generations.
"Both parties need to respond because increasing numbers of people from diverse walks of life are speaking out in support of our clean air, clean water and liveable planet."  Wayne Taylor/Fairfax Media
Too often commentators fail to recognise climate change and nature are critical concerns in the minds of voters when they head to the ballot box. But the Queensland election is once again proving these are vote-changing issues.
We are currently witnessing an intense campaign, with the debate about whether we will continue to enjoy a safe climate and thriving planet at its heart -- Adani's dirty coal mine project being no exception.
The problem is that in the world of the Tim Nicholls-led LNP you can apparently save the Great Barrier Reef and cut greenhouse gas emissions by building a new coal-fired power station and allowing massive land clearing.
I have no doubt that every Queenslander wants the Great Barrier Reef to be there for future generations. But as we endlessly equivocate on ways to save the reef, it is suffering a slow death under our watch.
While two consecutive bleaching events hit the Great Barrier Reef in 2016 and 2017, Queensland continues to export more than 60 million tonnes of thermal coal every year.
Governments need to be agile and adaptive, and capitalise on the natural advantages of the Sunshine State.
If the Galilee Basin is opened by Adani's massive dirty coal mine and other projects, it has the potential to add more than 700 million tonnes of climate pollution to the atmosphere each year of its operational life. Enough to cook the Great Barrier Reef.
The idea that taxpayers might help this environmental disaster with a Commonwealth loan is an affront to both transparent government and all future generations of Australians. To use public funds to underwrite the private destruction of our climate, clean water and precious reef is indefensible.
On climate, land clearing and now a loan to Adani there are major points of difference between the major parties.
While the Palaszczuk Government wrongly supports the mine, it has ruled out any state funding for the Carmichael rail line or support for a Commonwealth loan. A Nicholls-led LNP not only supports the mine, it has vowed to provide ongoing support for the coal industry and support the opening of the Galilee Basin with taxpayer dollars.
On clean energy, the LNP is devoid of any ambition and has vowed to scrap Queensland's existing targets, whereas the Palaszczuk Government has committed to delivering 50 percent of Queensland's energy from the sun and the wind by 2030.
The Palaszczuk Government's innovative clean energy projects include solar-hydro hybrid systems in abandoned mine sites. In stark contrast, a new coal-fired power station of dubious economic merit appears to be the LNP's answer to the Sunshine State's future energy needs.
The LNP also appears happy to continue Queensland's appalling track record as one of the world's worst offenders for deforestation.
It is a national disgrace that more than 1 million hectares of Queensland forests and woodlands have been cleared in four years under the Newman Government's changes to vegetation laws. This legacy includes approvals to clear around 70,000 hectares of native forest within catchments of the Great Barrier Reef and the habitat for many threatened species including koalas.
While the Palaszczuk Government has vowed to again try to fix Queensland's land clearing laws, the Nicholls-led LNP is perfectly happy to see more critical habitat for our wildlife destroyed. The promise by the LNP to plant 3 million trees is like reaching for a band aid when you just lost your leg.
Sadly, the prognosis for Queensland's environment should the LNP form government is grim.
Queensland can prosper without destroying our forests, rivers and reefs. Governments need to be agile and adaptive, and capitalise on the natural advantages of the Sunshine State.
The parties need to respond because increasing numbers of people from diverse walks of life are speaking out in support of our clean air, clean water and liveable planet.
Climate change is the single-most important issue facing our planet and will remain so for decades. Coal is tired and toxic energy and the way of the future is innovation, adaptation and new jobs in the expanding clean energy sector.
These are truths that all parties in the Queensland election must recognise. If only because increasing numbers of Queensland voters do.

Links

Australia Is A Global Top-Ten Deforester – And Queensland Is Leading The Way

The Conversation - Noel D Preece | Penny van Oosterzee

A chain used for land clearing is dragged over a pile of burning wood on a drought effected property near St George, Queensland. AP Image/Dan Peled
When you think of devastating deforestation and extinction you usually think of the Amazon, Borneo and the Congo. But eastern Australia ranks alongside these in the top 10 of the world’s major deforestation fronts – the only one in a developed nation. Most of the clearing is happening in Queensland, and it is accelerating.
Only last year a group of leading ecologists voiced their alarm at new data which showed the clearing of 296,000 hectares of forest in 2013-14. This was three times higher than in 2008-09, kicking Australia up the list as one of the world’s forest-clearing pariahs. At the 2016 Society for Conservation Biology Conference, a Scientists’ Declaration was signed by hundreds of scientists, expressing concern at these clearing rates.
But the latest snapshot, Queensland’s Department of Science report on land cover change published last month, showed a staggering 395,000ha of clearing for 2015-16: an increase of one third on 2014-15. As far as we can tell this rate of increased clearing is unmatched anywhere else on the globe.
showed a staggering 395,000 of clearing for 2015-16: which is an increase of one third on 2014-15, or 133% over the period
Strong vegetation management laws enacted in Queensland – the Vegetation Management Act 1999 – achieved dramatic reductions in forest and woodland loss. But the subsequent Liberal National state government, elected in 2012, overturned these protections.
The current government, elected in 2015, has tried and failed to reinstate the protections. In response, “panic clearing” caused clearing rates to shoot up, in anticipation that the state election will deliver a government that will reintroduce the much-needed protection of forests.
The Queensland Parliament is now in caretaker mode ahead of the November 25 election. The Queensland Labor Party has pledged to reinstate laws to prevent wholesale clearing, while the LNP opposition has vowed to retain current clearing rates.
Forest cleared by bulldozers towing massive chains. Noel Preece
Australian community and wildlife lose
Whichever way you look at it, there is not a lot of sense in continued clearing. Australia already has some of the highest extinction rates on the planet for plants and animals. With 80% of Queensland’s threatened species living in forest and woodland, more clearing will certainly increase that rate.
Clearing also kills tens of millions of animals across Australia each year, a major animal welfare concern that rarely receives attention. This jeopardises both wildlife and the A$140 million invested in threatened species recovery.
This rate of clearing neutralises our major environment programs. Just one year of clearing has removed more trees than the bulk of 20 million trees painstakingly planted, at a cost of A$50 million. Australia’s major environment programs simply can’t keep up, and since 2013 are restoring only one-tenth of the extent of land bulldozed just last year.
Restoration costs to improve the quality of waters running onto the Great Barrier Reef are estimated at around A$5 billion to A$10 billion over 10 years. Nearly 40% of the land cleared in Queensland is in reef catchments, which will reverse any water quality gains as sediment pours onto the reef.

Climate efforts nullified
Since 2014, the federal government has invested A$2.55 billion on reducing emissions in the Carbon Farming Initiative through the Emissions Reduction Fund. Currently 189 million tonnes of abatement has been delivered by the Emissions Reduction Fund. This – the central plank of the Australian government’s climate response – will be all but nullified by the end of 2018 with the current clearing rates, and will certainly be wiped out by 2020, when Australia is expected to meet its climate target of 5% below 2000 emissions.
Ironically, this target will be achieved with the help of carried-over results from the first commitment period of the Kyoto Protocol, which Australia was only able to meet because land clearing had decreased between 1990 and 1997.

Why is this happening?
Most of the clearing in Queensland since 1999 has been for pasture. Most good cropping land was cleared decades ago. Removing trees in more marginal lands can increase the carrying capacity for a short time with an immediate, and usually short-lived, financial reward. These rewards come at the expense of long-term sustainability, which future landholders and government will bear.
Large areas of the cleared lands have been subject to substantial erosion and nutrient loss from the newly cleared lands, and land degradation over time, and some areas have suffered massive woody weed incursions.
This is playing out today across the north where pastoralism is a marginal activity at best, with declining terms of trade of about 2% per year, with no net productivity growth, high average debts and low returns, and many enterprises facing insolvency. Clearing vegetation won’t change that.
A recent preliminary valuation of ecosystem services, on the other hand, estimated that uncleared lands are worth A$3,300-$6,100 per hectare per year to the Australian community, compared with productivity of grazing lands of A$18 per hectare.
With a clear divide between the policies Labor and the LNP are taking to the election, now is a good time to give land clearing’s social, economic and environmental impact the scrutiny it deserves.

Links

Wednesday, November 22, 2017

Geologists Just Discovered 260-Million Year Old Forests In Antarctica

Huffington Post - Lara Pearce

And they could provide a glimpse into a climate-changing future.
The 260 million-year-old tree fossils provide an insight into a warmer, greener Antarctica. Erik Gulbranson
Antarctica wasn't always a barren and largely uninhabitable landscape of snow and ice.
Almost 260 million years ago, the world's coldest and driest continent was awash with lush, thriving forests -- and a group of geologists have just found one.
The University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee paleoecologists spent last summer climbing Antarctica's Transantarctic Mountains.
High above the ice fields, they combed the mountain's gray rocks for fossils from the continent's green, forested past.
By January, they had found the fossil fragments of 13 trees.



"People have known about the fossils in Antarctica since the 1910-12 Robert Falcon Scott expedition," explained research team leader and paleoecologist, Assistant Professor Erik Gulbranson.
"However, most of Antarctica is still unexplored. Sometimes, you might be the first person to ever climb a particular mountain."
The trees are estimated to be around 260 million years old -- older than the world's first dinosaurs.
And even though the trees died out many millennia before our ancestors were swinging through the treetops, they could provide some clues into how our landscape will alter as a result of human-induced climate change.
Geologist Erik Gulbranson is studying the tree fossils to see how they survived Antarctica's harsh landscape. UWM Photo/Troye Fox
The researchers believe the trees proliferated in Antarctica at the end of the Permian Period, when the continent was warmer and more humid than today.
At the time Antarctica was part of Gondwana, a supercontinent spanning the Southern Hemisphere that included Australia as well as South America, Africa and India.
But around 251 million years ago, the Permian Period ended as the planet rapidly moved from icehouse to greenhouse conditions, bringing about a mass extinction which killed more than 90 percent of species on Earth, including the polar forests.
Many scientists now believe this mass extinction was caused by a massive increase in greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide and methane, from a huge number of volcanic eruptions in Siberia.
"This forest is a glimpse of life before the extinction, which can help us understand what caused the event," Gulbranson said.
"The geologic record shows us the beginning, middle and end of climate change event. With further study, we can better understand how greenhouse gases and climate change affect life on Earth."



The geologists also hope to get an insight into how the hardly plant species survived months of sunlight followed by months of complete darkness in the polar region.
"There isn't anything like that today," Gulbranson said.
"These trees could turn their growing cycles on and off like a light switch.
"We know the winter shutoff happened right away, but we don't know how active they were during the summertime and if they could force themselves into dormancy while it was still light out."
In other Antarctica-related news, NASA has just released the first photographs of the enormous Larsen C iceberg since it split from mainland Antarctica in July, becoming one of the largest icebergs in recorded history.
The jaw-dropping images are a sobering reminder of what is in store for the world's coldest continent as we face a warmer future.
IMAGE

IMAGE

IMAGE


Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative