MIT Technology Review - James Temple
Fires ravaged the West, hurricanes battered the East—and still emissions continued to rise.
 |
| The Whittier fire burned nearly 20,000 acres in Santa Barbara County, California, last summer. GLENN BELTZ | FLICKR |
For decades, scientists have warned that climate change would make
extreme events like droughts, floods, hurricanes, and wildfires more
frequent, more devastating, or both. In 2017, we got an up-close look at
the raw ferocity of such an altered world as high-category hurricanes
battered the East and Gulf coasts, and wind-whipped fires scorched the
West (see “
Did Climate Change Fuel California’s Devastating Fires? Probably”).
We’re also seeing with greater clarity how these dangers are
interlinked, building upon one another toward perilous climate tipping
points. And yet for all the growing risks, and the decades we’ve had to
confront them, we have yet to address the problem in a meaningful way
(see “
Trump’s Five Biggest Energy Blunders in 2017”).
In fact, despite all our climate policies, global accords, solar
advances, wind farms, hybrid cars, and Teslas, greenhouse-gas emissions
are still moving in the wrong direction. And as long as we’re emitting
any at all, we’re only making the problem worse.
Here are the five most worrisome climate developments we saw in 2017.
Emissions are rising again
After three relatively flat years, greenhouse-gas emissions from
fossil fuels and industry picked up again in 2017, rising an estimated 2
percent, according to the
Global Carbon Project.
The shift was driven by rising carbon pollution in China and India,
which more than offset a slight decline in the United States.
The news punctured tentative hopes that the recent flattening was
solidifying into a trend. Among other things, it means that our
collective climate efforts haven’t even prevented greenhouse-gas levels
from increasing, at a point when we need to be radically cutting them.
Keeping temperatures from rising beyond a dangerous 2 °C will require
slashing emissions as much as 70 percent by midcentury, according to the
U.N.’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
At more than 400 parts per million, we’re already well beyond
dangerous levels of carbon dioxide concentrations in the atmosphere,
as climbing temperatures, melting ice caps, and extreme weather events
have made clear.
 |
| Caleb Woods | Flickr |
In early November, the World Meteorological Organization
declared
that 2017 was likely to end up as “one of the three warmest years on
record,” and the warmest one altogether that wasn’t influenced by an El
Niño event. That also makes the global average temperature during
2013-2017 the hottest five-year average recorded.
Carbon dioxide can remain in the atmosphere for
thousands of years and takes about
a decade
to reach its maximum warming effect. In other words, even with all the
changes we’ve already seen, we have yet to experience the full impact of
the carbon we spewed in 2008 and every year since. Each additional ton
we emit going forward only increases the dangers of climate change,
multiplying the economic, environmental, and human toll.
Worst-case scenarios look increasingly likely
The most alarming projections for global warming this century also
seem to be the most reliable, according to a December study in
Nature that compared climate models against what’s already happening in the atmosphere (see “
Global Warming’s Worst-Case Projections Look Increasingly Likely”).
The
paper
concluded that worldwide temperatures could rise nearly 5 °C by the end
of the century, 15 percent higher than the previous central estimate
under the “business as usual” emissions scenario outlined by the U.N.
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
The authors collected more than a decade’s worth of "top of
atmosphere" satellite observations, measuring factors such as how much
infrared radiation is escaping from Earth and how much sunlight clouds
and snow reflect away. In turn, they compared that data with the results
of earlier climate models to determine which ones most closely forecast
what the satellites actually saw. It turned out to be the ones that
predicted the most warming.
That suggests the risks of climate change are greater than feared,
and that we’ll have to cut emissions even deeper to prevent dangerous
levels of warming.
Hyperactive hurricanes
 |
| The view of Hurricane Harvey from the International Space Station. NASA GODDARD SPACE FLIGHT CENTER | FLICKR |
Hurricane Harvey crossed the shorelines of southern Texas on August
25, marking the first major hurricane to make landfall in the United
States in a dozen years. The storm hovered over the coast for days,
dumping more than 60 inches of rain in some areas, killing more than 80
people and displacing thousands (see “
Our Hurricane Risk Models Are Dangerously Out of Date”).
Irma and Maria added to the toll of destruction, making the hyperactive 2017 Atlantic hurricane season the
most expensive ever, racking up more than $200 billion in damages.
Several recent studies concluded that shifting climate conditions
significantly increased the odds of an extreme event such as Harvey.
Among other climatic factors, warmer air holds more moisture, and higher
sea levels raise the height of storm surges, both of which can increase
the destructive power of storms.
A
study published in
Environmental Research Letters in December concluded that global warming made an event like Harvey around three times more likely. Meanwhile, a
report in
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
by Kerry Emanuel, a prominent hurricane researcher and professor of
atmospheric science at MIT, found that events of similar magnitude will
become far more likely as the climate warms further.
“We see probabilities of Harvey-type rainfalls going up by factors
of 10 by the late 20th century and early 21st” under a “business as
usual” greenhouse emissions trajectory, he says.
The melting Arctic
In December, NOAA released an unsettling
Arctic report card
declaring that the North Pole had reached a “new normal,” with no sign
of returning to a “reliably frozen region.” Rising temperatures have
locked in a long-term trend of shrinking glaciers, receding sea ice, and
warming permafrost.
Between October 2016 and September 2017, the area above the 60th
parallel north experienced the second-warmest air temperature anomaly
since 1900. In March, satellites recorded the lowest sea-ice winter
maximum on record.
Melting glaciers and sea ice are particularly worrisome trends
because they trigger critical secondary effects, notably including
increasing rates of sea-level rise.
This development also sets up dangerous climate feedback loops as
reflective white snow and ice turn into heat-absorbing dark-blue water.
It means the Arctic will send less heat back into space, which leads to
more warming, more melting, and more sea-level rise still.
“We see a major increase in temperatures in the high latitudes, in
the area and coasts around the Arctic Ocean, so it seems like this
process has already started,” says Vladimir Romanovsky, a professor of
geophysics at the Permafrost Laboratory at the University of Alaska,
Fairbanks.
He says another cause for concern is that permafrost is warming,
approaching thawing temperatures in parts of the Alaskan interior. The
problem there is that permafrost traps massive amounts of greenhouse
gases beneath the surface. As it melts, those gases are released,
forming a separate self-reinforcing cycle.
In early December, Lawrence Livermore National Lab researchers
highlighted
yet another potential effect of declining Arctic sea ice, concluding it
may have played a crucial role in California’s extended drought this
decade and could exacerbate future ones. Finally, though it seems
counterintuitive, the warming Arctic could also
amplify cold spells, much like the winter storm now enveloping the East Coast.
Massive wildfires
The West was engulfed in flames this year, as millions of acres
burned across California, Montana, Oregon, and elsewhere, adding up to
the
most expensive fire season on record.
California alone battled blazes that covered more than a million acres, according to
data
from the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection. The
Thomas Fire near Santa Barbara ripped across 280,000 acres, making it
the state’s largest wildfire ever. The wine country fires in Northern
California were even more destructive, burning down nearly 9,000
structures and killing 44 people.
Climate change doesn’t “cause” wildfires, which can be ignited by
campfires, lightning strikes, downed power lines, or arson. Other human
actions, including decades of fire suppression, have also increased the
risk and magnitude of these fires. But global warming does seem to be
making the events worse.
Human-influenced climate change has doubled the area affected by
forest fires during the last 30 years across the American West,
scorching an additional 16,000 square miles, according to a 2016 study
in
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Higher temperatures suck moisture out of soil, trees, and plants,
turning forests into tinderboxes. In California, the added heat has been
compounded by the prolonged drought from 2012 to 2016, which dried out
vast swaths of wilderness and opened the door to a devastating beetle
bark infestation. The twin forces have killed some 129 million trees
across nearly nine million acres, building up a massive amount of fuel
and significantly raising wildfire risks,
according to the state fire department.
As both the highest-cost fire year and the highest-cost hurricane
year, 2017 was very likely “the most expensive weather year ever,”
according to a convincing case in
the Atlantic.
“Both the wildfires and the unprecedented Atlantic hurricane season
are similarly profound and troubling,” wrote Michael Mann, director of
the Penn State Earth System Science Center, in an e-mail to
MIT Technology Review. “I see them as twin climate change–exacerbated weather phenomena.”
The added danger of wildfires is that they can convert forests from
sponges to sources of carbon dioxide, forming yet another climate
feedback cycle. In fact, California’s forests emitted more carbon than
they absorbed between 2001 and 2010, and two-thirds of the loss was
attributable to wildfires, according to a 2015
study by researchers at the National Park Service and the University of California, Berkeley.
Tracing through this list, it becomes increasingly clear how the
links between distant events lock into self-reinforcing loops: rising
emissions, higher temperatures, shrinking sea ice, additional warming,
extended droughts, bigger wildfires, and higher emissions still. That
means it will become increasingly difficult to pull out of this spiral,
making it increasingly urgent that we begin serious efforts to do so
soon.
Links