Friday, April 20, 2018

'Cooked': Study Finds Great Barrier Reef Transformed By Mass Bleaching

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

Corals in the Great Barrier Reef have a lower tolerance to heat stress than expected, contributing to a permanent transformation of the mix of species in some of most pristine regions, a team of international researchers has found.
The scientists examined the impact of the 2016 marine heatwave that alone caused the death of about one-third of the Great Barrier Reef corals, mostly centred on the northern third section.
They studied how much abnormal heat triggers bleaching, the additional heat that killed the corals, and the accumulation needed to cause "an ecological collapse in the transformation of species", said Terry Hughes, Director of the ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies at James Cook University, and the lead of author of the paper published Thursday in Nature.
The thresholds "are lower than we thought they would be", Professor Hughes told Fairfax Media.
Bleaching in the northern part of the Great Barrier Reef in 2016 triggered widespread mortality of corals within weeks, scientists found. Photo: AAP
A key guide is the number of so-called degree-heating weeks (DHW), such as waters a degree above average for a certain period. If reefs had DHWs of six or more - as about 29 per cent of the reefs suffered - the loss of corals reached 60-90 per cent, Professor Hughes said.
Some species, such as staghorns and tabular corals, were particularly susceptible, while dome-shaped porites corals were relatively resilient.
"The 2016 marine heatwave has triggered the initial phase of that transition [to heat-tolerant reef assemblages] on the northern, most pristine region of the Great Barrier Reef, changing it forever as the intensity of global warming continues to escalate," the paper said.
The fact the northern section - with fewer people, little fishing and almost no water quality issues - was hit so hard was notable.
"There’s almost nowhere to hide from extreme temperatures," Professor Hughes said. "Even the best-managed, most remote place is vulnerable.”
The Nature paper is one of a series being prepared or already published by Professor Hughes and colleagues at James Cook University that examine the unprecedented back-to-back mass bleaching of the Great Barrier Reef in the summers of 2016 and 2017.
Upcoming papers will examine the impacts of the latter event - which mainly hammered the middle section of the Reef - and the scope for recovery.
Fish species are adjusting to the mass mortality of corals - some better than others. Photo: University of Wollongong
Just as coral species responded differently to the heat stress, so too have fish species that depend on them.
Butterfly fish, for instance, feed on only a couple of coral species. “If their diet disappears, so do they," Professor Hughes said. Parrot fish, though, eat mostly seaweed, and will fare better.
Still, most fish depend on branching corals as a nursery - the type of corals that suffered high mortality in the heatwave.
"People have long predicted there will be significant fisheries impact from losing juvenile habitat and we expect that to unfold over the next five years," Professor Hughes said.
Most of what researchers know about reef recovery has come from the study of the aftermath of cyclones.
Such events, though, tend to carve a swathe through the reef, perhaps 50 to 100 kilometres wide, with patchier damage than mass bleaching. Coral larvae come into the void from either side, typically taking a decade for branching corals to recover.
“The scale of the damage from back-to-back bleaching is vastly bigger," Professor Hughes said. "We don’t know yet where the larvae are going to come from, and in what numbers.”

Links

A Decade Of Lost Opportunities

Sydney Morning Herald - Editorial

Back in 2007, Kevin Rudd famously declared climate change ''the great moral challenge of our generation''. Moral or not, that challenge has been met in the intervening years with policy paralysis and blame-shifting. And like a political grim reaper, it has cut a swathe through the leadership of the major parties.
As the fire front approaches an RFS crew asseses the perimeter at Barden Ridge, Sydney. Photo: Kate Geraghty
During this whole lost decade of fighting the ''climate wars'' rather than climate change, the challenge has only become steeper. Under the 2015 Paris climate deal, Australia agreed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by at least 26 per cent by 2030. Yet Australia's carbon pollution has risen in each of the past five years.
And if that is not a sufficient wake-up call, how about the fact our bushfire season this year looks like stretching to Anzac Day?
The good news is that an end is in sight, just possibly, to this dismal period of politics being allowed to trump the national and global interest. On Friday, Federal Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg will meet his state counterparts in Canberra for a Council of Australian Governments meeting that will decide if work is to continue on the Turnbull Government's National Energy Guarantee.
The NEG is far from perfect but it is the most promising compromise that has appeared for a long time on the horizon of the interlocking climate and energy debates. It imposes a twin obligation on energy retailers to reduce carbon emissions and at the same time maintain reliability standards. If it works properly, it promises to drive investment in baseload energy supply, support the transition to renewables, prevent avoidable blackouts, and short-circuit soaring household energy bills.
But obstacles remain and COAG is one of them. Thanks to political leaders at all levels placing loyalty to their party above their constituencies, COAG has frequently been the place where reform goes to die. There is almost always an election looming up somewhere to derail bipartisanship and the present moment is no exception, with Victoria, NSW, and possibly the Commonwealth all set to go to the polls over the next 12 months.
On the other side of the ledger, Steven Marshall's recent South Australian Liberal victory removes one obstacle, in the form of that state's headlong rush to renewables under former Premier Jay Weatherill.
The most promising sign of all is that federal Labor is edging towards the NEG tent. Labor wants deeper cuts to emissions than those agreed under Paris but has realised the NEG, far from being an obstacle, may be a tool towards achieving those cuts. This is because, with parliamentary backing, the emissions targets under the NEG could be ratcheted up under a future Government. Other imperfections of the scheme – including too-intermittent reviews, or the possibility states could be punished for pursuing more ambitious targets – could likewise be rectified.
A breakthrough on the NEG would be a major victory for Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull, as well as burnishing Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg's future leadership credentials. But Labor leader Bill Shorten could also gain stature by showing he is capable of recognising a moment when real progress beckons and grasping it. Such sweet reasonableness could even become a template for tackling the unanswered problem of how to reduce greenhouse emissions in other parts of the economy without imposing unnecessary costs and hitting jobs.
So let's be clear: if ever there was a time for state and federal political leaders to rise above partisanship, this is it.

Links

Renewable Energy Capacity Set To Exceed Target Federal Government Said Was Impossible

ABC News - Stephen Letts

Renewable energy capacity of 41,000GWh was deemed to be "impossible", but is now in reach. (Fabrizio Bensch, file photo: Reuters)
Key points
  • Renewable energy capacity is set to exceed 41,000GWh by 2020, a level the coalition government deemed as impossible before it slashed the RET
  • Market already delivered the government's 2030 emission reduction target, rendering the NEG meaningless: Green Energy Markets
  • Business-as-usual under the NEG will lead to 118 million tonne shortfall in the government's CO2 reduction commitment
Australia's renewable energy capacity is set to exceed a target the Federal Government said was impossible to reach by 2020, according to new research from Green Energy Markets.
In its quarterly Renewable Energy Index, GEM said the amount of renewable energy generated in 2020 was set to exceed the original 41,000 Gigawatt hour (GWh) Renewable Energy Target (RET) that was in place before being scrapped in 2015 by the federal government led by then prime minister Tony Abbott.
The original RET was put in place to help Australia meet its 2030 climate change commitment to cut emissions by 26 to 28 per cent from 2005 levels.
It was replaced by a less ambitious target of 33,000 GWh after the Abbott government characterised the original RET as impossible to achieve, while arguing there was already too much generating capacity.
The GEM study — funded by activist group GetUp — found estimated eligible generation would hit 41,381 GWh by 2020, not only exceeding the current RET, but the original RET as well.
"The Coalition's argument that we can't go any further than the target they've proposed without imposing some kind of huge economic shock and threat to reliability is obviously not true because we're pretty much already there," Green Energy Markets director Tristan Edis said.
"[Energy and Environment minister] Josh Frydenberg himself is saying that all the extra renewable energy that is about to enter the system will substantially push down power prices."
NEG 'meaningless': report
Mr Edis said the Government's National Energy Guarantee (NEG) would in effect deliver no meaningful emission reduction benefit, as projects already under construction and contracted exceed what is needed to achieve its established emission targets.
"According to economic modelling undertaken by Frontier Economics for the Energy Security Board, from 2017 onwards we'd need to install 9,271 megawatts [MW] of wind and solar in the NEM [National Electricity Market] to achieve the Government's 2030 emission reduction target," he said.
"Yet we already have 9,691 MW of projects that will be delivered in the NEM based on what has been committed to construction and what is being contracted under procurement processes currently underway."
Those commitments include 650MW from the GFG consortium to power the Whyalla Steelworks in South Australia, a 500MW wind expansion from AGL, renewable energy auctions conducted by the Victorian and Queensland governments and a series of other contracts drawn up by generators such as Origin and AGL.
"We have already achieved what the NEG said it would do, it doesn't add anything or do anything meaningful," Mr Edis said.
Huge shortfall in CO2 reduction remains

What is the Paris Agreement?
Here's a simple explanation of the agreement, and what it means for Australia.

Mr Edis said the NEG in its current form would deliver a result that is almost 120 million tonnes of carbon dioxide short of Australia's commitment to the 2030 Paris Agreement.
"The maths on the Government's emission target is pretty basic," Mr Edis said.
"According the latest emissions projections from the Government's own Department of Environment, the Government needs to find 128 million tonnes of CO2 abatement in 2030 to achieve its economy-wide 2030 Paris emissions target.
"Even if Frontier Economics' modelling was right, it means the NEG delivers just 10 million tonnes in 2030 compared to business as usual.
"Where the hell is the other 118 million going to come from?"
The Energy Reduction Fund is running low limiting the government's options in meeting its 2030 Paris accord commitments. (Brett Worthington)
Mr Edis said none of the options the Government had to make up the shortfall seemed likely to work.
"If the Government was to adopt the most stringent vehicle emission standard they've contemplated in their consultation paper — which is a big if — then the Government's own estimates are it would deliver 11.7 million in 2030.
"The Emission Reduction Fund is almost out of money.
"Agriculture? Somehow I can't see a Government made up of the Nationals regulating to control emissions from cows and sheep or land-clearing.
"They could pay for abatement but where's the money coming from?"

Record solar PV installation
The Renewable Energy Index found renewables accounted for 19.7 per cent of the electricity generated on Australia's main grids, or enough energy to power 8.7 million homes.
According to Green Energy Markets, rooftop solar installations in March were the highest monthly total ever, and over the first three months of the year are running at levels 50 per cent above those anticipated in economic modelling of the NEG.
"Households and businesses are continuing to install solar PV on rooftops at record rates in order to reduce their electricity bills. March installs set a new monthly record of 127 megawatts which will produce power equivalent to the consumption of 36,710 homes," the report said.
"On top of the underestimates of large scale renewables, it suggests that the emission reduction target could be substantially strengthened at minimal economic cost."

Links

Wednesday, April 18, 2018

Latest Legal Fight Accusing Oil Companies Of Climate Change Launched In Colorado

Reuters - Sebastien Malo

The city of Boulder is one of the Colorado communities filing climate lawsuits, demanding Exxon and Suncor pay for climate impacts. Photo credit: Andrew Burton/Getty Images
NEW YORK - Three Colorado communities filed a lawsuit against oil companies on Tuesday, launching the latest legal battle seeking damages for what they claim are the costs of adapting to climate change.
The lawsuit, filed in Colorado by the city of Boulder and the counties of San Miguel and Boulder, accuses Suncor and Exxon Mobil Corp of creating a public nuisance by producing and selling fossil fuels that cause climate change.
Scientific consensus holds that carbon dioxide pollution from burning fossil fuels such as oil, gas and coal is the main cause of climate change.
Suncor and Exxon “sold and promoted fossil fuels knowing that climate impacts were substantially certain to occur if unchecked fossil fuel use continued,” the communities said in the complaint.
Exxon spokesman Scott Silvestri called the lawsuit part of a misplaced effort to pin the global phenomenon of climate change on oil producers alone. Exxon is the world’s largest publicly traded oil producer.
“Reducing greenhouse gas emissions is a global issue and requires global participation and actions,” he said in emailed comments.
A spokeswoman for Suncor, one of Canada’s biggest oil producers, said the company could not comment because it had not yet seen a copy of the lawsuit.
Both Exxon and Suncor have operations in Colorado, the complaint said.
The lawsuit is the latest in a growing body of legal action against oil companies over climate change.
However, earlier cases have been filed by coastal communities including California and New York, and this is the first to be brought in the nation’s interior, officials behind the lawsuit said.
Their region of Colorado is vulnerable to a wide range of climate threats, from droughts that imperil farming to warm winters that harm the ski industry, they said.
“Climate change is not just about sea level rise. It affects all of us in the middle of the country as well,” said Elise Jones, a Boulder County commissioner, in a statement.
The case is part of a growing trend, said Michael Burger, executive director of the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law at Columbia University in New York.
“This is now, I think, the tenth lawsuit of the sort that has been filed in the United States against fossil fuel companies seeking damages for costs associated with climate change impacts,” he told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.
In January, the San Francisco suburb of Richmond filed a similar climate change-related public nuisance lawsuit against 29 oil companies including Exxon.

Links

Tuesday, April 17, 2018

40 Degrees In April: Why This Autumn Has Felt More Like Summer

ABC Weather - Ben Deacon

Sydneysiders are still waiting for a cool change after a hot summer. (AAP: Dean Lewins)
The southern states of Australia have been experiencing unseasonably hot weather this autumn.
Instead of enjoying a cool change after a harsh summer, in the first two months of autumn we have seen record-breaking temperatures, bushfires, and blistering days equivalent to those endured in the height of summer.
"I would bet my house on it, that there's a climate change signal in this most recent heatwave," University of New South Wales climate scientist Sarah Perkins-Kirkpatrick said.
Dr Perkins-Kirkpatrick has not hedged her bets on what she believes is influencing March and April's record-breaking heatwave, but said the occurrence of this type of weather event was increasing.
"There's no other way of slicing and dicing or sugar-coating it," she said.
"We've seen quite a significant increase in heatwave frequency, particularly in southern Australia."
Maximum temperature anomalies March 29 to April 12 
Last month Australia recorded temperatures of 45 degrees Celsius in late March for the first time in history.
Sydney, Adelaide and many other locations had their hottest or equal-hottest April days on record, as did the states of South Australia, Victoria and New South Wales.
Bushfires have raged across the outskirts of Sydney, country Victoria, and in Tathra on the far south coast of NSW, weeks after the end of the usual fire season.
Sydney is experiencing severe bushfires weeks after the fire season ended. (ABC News)
In a special climate statement, senior climatologist Blair Trewin from the Bureau of Meteorology said the conditions had been more like mid-summer than mid-autumn.
"A lot of those averages for the first 10 days of April were reasonably close to, or even slightly above January averages," Dr Trewin said.
The autumn heatwave was exceptional not only in extremes of temperature, but also in the extent of the country affected and the persistence of the heat.
Almost the entire continent had maximum temperatures above average on most of the first 10 days of April.

Heatwave started in the desert
The Pilbara in north-west Western Australia endured more than two weeks over 40 degrees in mid-March, ending with several days over 45 degrees — temperatures never before seen in Australia at that time of year.
Then at the start of April, a high pressure ridge and a cold front pushed that warm air east, bringing the first wave of record temperatures to New South Wales.
In an ordinary heatwave, the passing front would bring cooler temperatures and end the event.
But instead, temperatures started building up in WA again in early April before a new front sent a second blast of hot, West Australian air across southern Australia.
On April 9, temperatures reached 35 degrees in the Sydney region. This was the latest date into the first half of the year that temperatures had ever reached 35 degrees in Sydney.
The autumn heatwave started in the Pilbara. (Supplied: Annabelle Coppin)
On April 11, the heat shifted south, breaking records in almost a third of Victorian locations, smashing the Victorian state temperature record by one and a half degrees.
"When you're breaking a record over a whole state by that sort of margin, that's a significant event," Dr Trewin said.
Dr Trewin, who has an uncanny memory for weather, said this heatwave resembled one in April 1986, which he remembered because it was the day of his school cross country race.
"I remember one of the race winners finished in a state not too dissimilar to the Scottish guy in the [Commonwealth Games] marathon this weekend."
Dr Trewin said this April heatwave was hotter and farther reaching than the 1986 event.

Heatwaves becoming more common outside summer
Dr Perkins-Kirkpatrick said Australia was seeing more heatwaves in the cooler months.
"Extreme temperature events in the shoulder seasons are actually warming faster than extreme temperature events in summer," she said.
"And April's heatwave fits exactly with that trend."
Spring heatwaves are increasing, researchers say. (Supplied: Sue Belperio)
Dr Trewin agreed, pointing out that spring heatwaves were increasing faster than events in autumn.
"In the past five years, we've seen two particularly significant heatwaves in September in 2013 and 2017," Dr Trewin said.
"We've seen a major one in October 2015. We haven't seen quite the same clustering in autumn."
Dr Trewin and Dr Perkins-Kirkpatrick said this year's autumn heatwave was consistent with climate change.
"The influence of climate change is that it shifts beyond," Dr Trewin said.
"So the types of events you might have seen once in 50 or 100 years in the climate of the mid-20th century, you might see once in five years or once in 10 years in what we have now."

Links

March 2018 Was One Of Six Warmest Marches On Record

NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies

A global map of the March 2018 LOTI (land-ocean temperature index) anomaly, relative to the 1951-1980 March average. View larger image.
March 2018 was +0.89 °C warmer than the average March of the 1951-1980 period.
This value is lower than the two hottest years of the record — March 2016 (+1.30 °C) and March 2017 (+1.12 °C) — and is comparable with the years 2002, 2010, and 2015, which cluster tightly around +0.9 °C.
 The corresponding number for all other years in our 138 years of modern record-keeping is at or below +0.77 °C.
The GISTEMP monthly temperature anomalies superimposed on a 1980-2015 mean seasonal cycle. View larger image or PDF. 
The monthly analysis by the GISS team is assembled from publicly available data acquired by about 6,300 meteorological stations around the world, ship- and buoy-based instruments measuring sea surface temperature, and Antarctic research stations.
The modern global temperature record begins around 1880 because previous observations didn't cover enough of the planet. Monthly analyses are sometimes updated when additional data becomes available, and the results are subject to change.

Links

Florida Kids Sue Gov. Scott Over Climate Change: You Have 'Moral Obligation' To Protect Us

InsideClimate News - Georgina Gustin

The case, connected to the federal Our Children’s Trust climate lawsuit, is one of nine pressuring states to take action on global warming and fossil fuels. 
Warming ocean water contributes to sea level rise and can strengthen hurricanes. Hurricane Irma's storm surge last year was the latest to flood Jacksonville, Florida. Credit: Sean Rayford/Getty Images
Eight young Floridians, ages 10 to 19, sued their state and its climate-policy-averse governor on Monday for failing to protect residents from the impacts of a warming climate.
They say they already see signs of climate change around them—from powerful hurricanes to extreme heat waves to tidal flooding that now regularly washes into coastal roads and parks as sea level rises—and they want the state to do something about it.
The lawsuit filed Monday is the latest in a wave of legal cases filed by children against states and the federal government that accuse government of depriving them of the fundamental right to a stable climate.
The Florida plaintiffs accuse the state of violating their constitutional rights by "perpetuating an energy system that is based on fossil fuels."
"The plaintiffs are asking the state of Florida to adhere to its legal and moral obligation to protect current and future generations from the intensifying impacts of climate change," the group said in a statement.
Their lawsuit asks that state officials "prepare and implement an enforceable comprehensive" plan to phase out fossil fuel use and "draw down excess atmospheric CO2 through forest and soil protection so as to stabilize the climate system."

Gov. Rick Scott and Climate Change
The lawsuit names the state, Republican Gov. Rick Scott, state agencies and the heads of those agencies as defendants.
In 2015, journalists in Florida reported that Scott had placed a gag order on the terms "climate change" and "global warming" within state's Department of Environmental Protection—an especially notable move, given the state is among the most vulnerable to climate change, with 1,000 miles of coastline and millions of people living in low-lying areas.
Scott has also ducked questions about climate change, using the response: "I'm not a scientist."
The governor's office responded to questions about the lawsuit in an emailed statement: "The Governor signed one of the largest environmental protection budgets in Florida's history last month—investing $4 billion into Florida's environment," said McKinley Lewis, a spokesperson for Scott. "The Governor is focused on real solutions to protect our environment—not political theater or a lawsuit orchestrated by a group based in Eugene, Oregon."

Florida Teens Fight for Their Future
Delaney Reynolds, 18, a fourth-generation Floridian who has become a prominent advocate and is a plaintiff in the lawsuit, wrote to the state's environmental regulators in 2014, asking what the department was doing to address climate change.
She said the agency response was: not much.
In a blog post Monday, Reynolds wrote that the response was "unacceptable" and a reason she decided to sue the state.
"Our climate change crisis is the biggest issue that my generation will ever face, and it's up to us, today's children, to fix this problem," Reynolds wrote. "It is my hope that the court will rule to require that Florida enact and enforce laws to reduce and eliminate carbon emissions so that our state and citizens can have a future here."

Kids' Federal Climate Case Gets a Court Date
Our Children's Trust, a group that advocates for science-based climate policy, is supporting the federal case and other youth-led legal efforts across the country.
In 2015, Our Children's Trust and 21 young people from across the country sued the federal government on the same legal grounds, saying the government was violating the public trust by failing to protect a common resource. The fossil fuel industry has repeatedly, but unsuccessfully, attempted to keep the case from advancing. (Levi Draheim, a 10-year-old Floridian, is a co-plaintiff in that case, as well as in the lawsuit filed Monday.)
Last week, a federal magistrate judge set a trial date for the federal case: Oct. 29, 2018, in federal district court in Oregon.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative