Wednesday, June 06, 2018

'Carbon Bubble' Could Spark Global Financial Crisis, Study Warns

The Guardian - 

Advances in clean energy expected to cause a sudden drop in demand for fossil fuels, leaving companies with trillions in stranded assets
A sudden drop in demand for fossil fuels could happen before 2035, a new study shows. Photograph: Florian Gaertner/Photothek via Getty Images
Plunging prices for renewable energy and rapidly increasing investment in low-carbon technologies could leave fossil fuel companies with trillions in stranded assets and spark a global financial crisis, a new study has found.
A sudden drop in demand for fossil fuels before 2035 is likely, according to the study, given the current global investments and economic advantages in a low-carbon transition.
The existence of a “carbon bubble” – assets in fossil fuels that are currently overvalued because, in the medium and long-term, the world will have to drastically reduce greenhouse gas emissions – has long been proposed by academics, activists and investors.
The new study, published on Monday in the journal Nature Climate Change, shows that a sharp slump in the value of fossil fuels would cause this bubble to burst, and posits that such a slump is likely before 2035 based on current patterns of energy use.
Crucially, the findings suggest that a rapid decline in fossil fuel demand is no longer dependent on stronger policies and actions from governments around the world. Instead, the authors’ detailed simulations found the demand drop would take place even if major nations undertake no new climate policies, or reverse some previous commitments.
That is because advances in technologies for energy efficiency and renewable power, and the accompanying drop in their price, have made low-carbon energy much more economically and technically attractive.
Dr Jean-François Mercure, the lead author, from Radboud and Cambridge universities, told the Guardian: “This is happening already – we have observed the data and made projections from there. With more policies from governments, this would happen faster.
But without strong [climate] policies, it is already happening. To some degree at least you can’t stop it. But if people stop putting funds now in fossil fuels, they may at least limit their losses.”
By moving to a lower-carbon footing, companies and investors could take advantage of the transition that is occurring, rather than trying to fight the growing trend. Mercure said fossil fuel companies were likely to fight among each other for the remaining market, rather than have a strong impact on renewable energy businesses.
Prof Jorge Viñuales, co-author, said: “Contrary to investor expectations, the stranding of fossil fuel assets may happen even without new climate policies. Individual nations cannot avoid the situation by ignoring the Paris agreement or burying their heads in coal and tar sands.”
However, Mercure also warned that the transition was happening too slowly to stave off the worst effects of climate change. Although the trajectory towards a low-carbon economy would continue, to keep within 2C above pre-industrial levels – the limit set under the Paris agreement – would require much stronger government action and new policies.
That could also help investors by pointing the way to deflation of the carbon bubble before they make new investments in fossil fuel assets.
The paper supports the view of some policy and investment experts that economics and technology are now driving action on climate change, where before impetus was all from policymakers.
Former UN climate chief Christiana Figueres told the Guardian, a year after Donald Trump announced the withdrawal of the US from the Paris agreement: “There is a big difference between the economics of climate change and the politics of climate change. Is Trump going to stop that advance [by businesses towards low-carbon technologies]? I don’t think so.”
Frédéric Samama, of Europe’s biggest asset manager Amundi, also believes investors have reached a “tipping point”, in relation to taking action on greenhouse gases through their portfolio management. He told Bloomberg last month that “until recently, the question” of climate change was “not on their radar screen”.
Separately, an analysis in Nature Energy forecast that global energy demand would be about 40% lower than today by 2050, despite rises in population and income, and a growing global economy. The authors found that such a scenario would allow the world to stay within 1.5C of warming, the aspirational goal set under the Paris agreement.

Links

Limiting Global Warming To 2 Degrees Now 'Aspirational': Scientists

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

The chance of limiting human-induced global warming to less than 2 degrees is rapidly disappearing as carbon emissions again ramp up in China while reductions in the US and elsewhere stall, scientists say.
Data from the CSIRO's Global Carbon Project indicates greenhouse gas emissions in China accelerated to 1.5 per cent growth last year. China is now responsible for about a third of the world's carbon emissions.
China's emissions are again on the rise, making global climate targets even harder to meet. Photo: Reuters
"That was quite significant growth for China because we had seen almost three years of little or no increase," the project's director, Pep Canadell, told Fairfax Media.
Early indications are that 2018 could see an even larger rise, with China's carbon emissions in the first quarter jumping 4 per cent alone, according to a Greenpeace analysis.
2017's increase was partly caused by a revival of China's reliance on heavy industrial growth to prop up the economy, and a drop in hydro electric generation amid poor rainfall, Dr Canadell said.  This year's growth, though, is also being spurred by a pick-up in the global economy.
Dramatic surge in China carbon emissions
*2018 for first three months of the year. Source: Greenpeace
Given China's emissions are roughly double the next largest polluter - the US - and triple the European Union's, its acceleration means there is a fast-diminishing chance that the rise in global average temperatures can be restricted to the range of 1.5 to 2 degrees, as agreed at the 2015 Paris climate conference.
"Most climate scientists think 2 degrees [compared with pre-industrial levels] to be aspirational," said Andy Pitman, director of the ARC Centre of Excellence for Climate Extremes.
Even if emissions ceased globally, it is probable warming would still reach at least 1.5 degrees given the longevity of carbon-dioxide and other heat-trapping gases in the atmosphere, he said.
With increasing evidence of extreme weather events even at the roughly 1 degree of warming so far - including compounding risks of bushfires, heatwaves and droughts - societies can expect impacts to worsen, Professor Pitman said: "The notion that 1.5 degrees is somehow safe is totally incompatible with the evidence."

'Not a pretty picture'
News in recent days that the Trump administration plans to bolster the ailing US coal-fired power industry by intervening in markets would worsen the global emissions picture.
The CSIRO's Dr Canadell said while US carbon emissions had fallen for a decade, last year's decline will likely be much smaller because of quickening economic growth at home and abroad.
The European Union, too, was likely to register a slower emissions drop. Australia, meanwhile, is on course to increase its carbon pollution for a fourth year in a row, a "remarkable" result for a rich nation, he said.
"If you put all the blocks together, it's not coming together as a pretty picture for 2018," Dr Canadell said.
Recent annual falls in carbon emissions are slowing in the US and the EU. Photo: AP
Bill Hare, director of non-profit science think tank Climate Analytics, said the planet is currently on course for 3.4 degrees warming, although planned but as-yet unimplemented climate action could trim that to 3.1 degrees.
One cause for optimism includes the shift away from fossil fuels, which is speeding up because of tumbling prices for solar and wind.
"China is moving massively into renewables and electric vehicles, and despite some short term increase in coal use, this trend will continue," Mr Hare said.
Bruce Nilles, a former head of the Sierra Club's "Beyond Coal" campaign, who is visiting Australia, said President Trump's "brazen efforts" to help coal in US would likely be stymied by a flurry of lawsuits from other energy suppliers.
The US had seen 266 coal-fired power plants shut or set closure dates since 2010, and these "were continuing at the same rate as during the last few years of the Obama administration", he said.
Filling the gap were more than 10,000 megawatts of new wind and solar capacity each year, a process likely to continue as their technology becomes even cheaper, Mr Nilles said.

Links

Tuesday, June 05, 2018

Number Of African Migrants Will Double By 2050 And Climate Change Will Make It Worse

Newsweek - 



The number of Africans leaving their home country to move to other parts of the globe is expected to more than double in upcoming years, with climate change acting as a main accelerator of this expected migration.
Although an imminent mass exodus is not expected, new findings do show the real-life effects of changing weather patterns.
A European Commission report aimed to identify past and present migration patterns in Africa and use these models to predict how future migration may look.
Results revealed that although the number of Africans leaving their country of birth for long periods of time or for good is currently about 1.4 million a year, by 2050 this number is expected to reach between 2.8 million to 3.5 million a year.
More than half of these future African migrants are expected to remain on the African continent, simply moving to African nations different than that of their birth.
North African migrants are more likely than other Africans to leave the continent and head overseas. The remaining 40 percent of migrants will most likely move to Europe, but also North America and Western Asia.
However, the report emphasized that the U.S. and Canada are not a main target destination for most African immigrants.
Extreme weather changes may be a leading factor behind increased African migration. African immigrants sit at a center for migrants in Libya. Mahmud Turkia/AFP/Getty Images
According to the report, climate change is expected to accelerate this future migration. Climate change has long been recognized as a contributor to global migration.
For example, climate change-driven droughts in Syria helped to push the social unrest that led to conflict in 2011, and continues to drive Syrian refugees to the U.S. and beyond, the US Climate and Health Alliance reported.
In Africa, extended heat waves and increased temperatures, as well as more droughts, are expected to increase tensions in already fragile regions. This may drive Africans away from their birthplace.
Climate change may also contribute to unrest and political violence in Africa, as individuals fight for control over scarce food, water, and fertile land.
 This would also contribute to African migration.
The US Climate and Health Alliance warned that climate change is not just affecting African migration—extreme weather has significantly reduced food availability in Central America, particularly in Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador. This continues to drive residents in search of more food stability.
In addition, unlike other parts of the globe, Africa has not experienced a significant decrease in the number of children born per woman. However, infant mortality has drastically decreased, the report revealed. As a result, Africa’s total population is expected to double from 1.2 billion inhabitants in 2017 to 2.5 billion in 2050.
The study also suggested that increased investment in Africa and improved living conditions for many Africans may increase their ability to move outside their birth countries.
More than half of Africans who will leave their home country have completed higher education.
African immigration has slowly been increasing since the 1960s, with 8.1 million Africans living outside of their birth country in the early 1960s to almost 36.3 million doing so in 2017, Phys.Org reported.

Links

It’s Time To Think Seriously About Cutting Off The Supply Of Fossil Fuels

Vox - David Roberts

A new paper makes the case for supply-side climate policy.
Shutterstock
There is a bias in climate policy shared by analysts, politicians, and pundits across the political spectrum so common it is rarely remarked upon. To put it bluntly: Nobody, at least nobody in power, wants to restrict the supply of fossil fuels.
Policies that choke off fossil fuels at their origin — shutting down mines and wells; banning new ones; opting against new pipelines, refineries, and export terminals — have been embraced by climate activists, picking up steam with the Keystone pipeline protests and the recent direct action of the Valve Turners.
But they are looked upon with some disdain by the climate intelligentsia, who are united in their belief that such strategies are economically suboptimal and politically counterproductive.
Now a pair of economists has offered a cogent argument that the activists are onto something — that restrictive supply-side (RSS) climate policies have unique economic and political benefits and deserve a place alongside carbon prices and renewable energy supports in the climate policy toolkit.
“In our experience,” the authors write, “the climate policy community has for too long been excessively narrow in its preference for certain kinds of policy instruments (carbon taxes, cap-and trade), largely ignoring the characteristics of such instruments that affect their political feasibility and feedback effects.” I have written the same thing many times, so I think a climate policy argument that takes politics seriously deserves a close look.
To understand it, it helps to have a framework for classifying climate policies.

The four quadrants of climate policy
Climate policies can apply to the supply side (production of fossil fuels) or the demand side (consumption of FF), and they can be restrictive or supportive. That creates a grid with four quadrants:
  1. Restrictive supply side: policies that cut off FF supply, including declining quotas, supply taxes, and subsidy reductions
  2. Restrictive demand side: policies that restrict demand for FF, including carbon prices and declining emission caps
  3. Supportive supply side: policies that support the supply of FF alternatives, like renewable energy subsidies and mandates
  4. Supportive demand side: policies that support demand for FF alternatives, like subsidies for purchase of energy-efficiency appliances or favorable government procurement policies
Here it is as a visual:
Climatic Change
As the authors — Fergus Green of the London School of Economics and Richard Denniss of the Australia Institute — point out, virtually all climate policy discussion and analysis has focused on quadrants 2 through 4. In surveys of the toolkit available to climate policymakers, quadrant 1 is almost always omitted entirely.
On its face, this doesn’t make much sense. In other areas of policy, demand- and supply-side policies are routinely mixed and considered mutually reinforcing. As an example, Green and Denniss focus on attempts in Australia to reduce smoking.
Those efforts, which have won acclaim around the world, are a wide-ranging mix of tactics. Supply is restricted through taxes, licensing requirements, and prohibitions on advertising and sponsorships. Demand is restricted through consumption taxes, public education campaigns, and warnings on packs.
It isn’t a single, clean instrument, an “optimal” policy, but a portfolio approach. And it isn’t considered a muddle or a redundant mess, but a sensible way to approach a complex problem. And it has worked.
In fact, portfolios of demand and supply measures have worked in plenty of policy areas, including environmental policy (lead in gas, chlorofluorocarbons, etc.).
So quadrant 1’s absence in climate discussions is, the authors say, “anomalous.” And they argue that it is impoverishing the discussion, because restrictive supply-side policies have unique economic and political benefits.
Let’s start with the economic benefits.

Cutting off fossil fuel supply has unique economic benefits
Green and Denniss list four economic benefits of restrictive supply-side policies.

1) RSS policies are easier to administer.
“Both carbon taxes and cap-and-trade schemes,” they write, “require detailed and complex rules, procedures and regulatory institutions for the monitoring, reporting and verification (MRV) of greenhouse gas emissions at facility/installation level (e.g. power plants, steel mills), often across hundreds or even thousands of facilities/installations.”
All this complicated monitoring and reporting reduces economic efficiency, creates an informational asymmetry (facilities will always know more about their emissions than regulators do) and thus incentive to game the system, and generally restricts such systems to major emitters, leaving substantial swaths of emissions unregulated.
By contrast, RSS policies target a relatively small number of sources, rely on data that is already gathered for other purposes, and by definition cover all downstream consumers. They are much easier to verify, which makes them politically potent both domestically and internationally (see below).

2) RSS policies cover the weaknesses in demand-side policies.
Climate wonks and economists are very taken with the fact that, in theory, the “least cost” way to reduce emissions is to pass technology-neutral, sector-neutral pricing policies that cover the entire global economy, allowing distributed, profit-maximizing actors to find the cheapest ways to cut CO2.
In the real world, considerations like MRV costs and “leakage” (any jurisdiction that passes a pricing policy threatens to drive some consumption to neighboring jurisdictions) mean that pricing policies are never economy-wide or entirely neutral.
Pricing policy that isn’t universal — like all current and foreseeable pricing policies — threatens, by lowering demand for fossil fuels, to also suppress FF prices and thus increase consumption outside policy barriers. Areas that aren’t covered by pricing policy will use more fossil fuels and the industrial shift to clean energy will be slowed.
“Restrictive supply-side policy has an important role to play in limiting countervailing price effects” from non-universal pricing policies, the authors write. “The combination of supply-side and demand-side policies will thus hasten the industrial transformation required to meet climate mitigation objectives.”
Keep it in the ground.
Photo by Mario Tama/Getty Images
3) RSS policies can avoid infrastructure lock-in.
I will let the authors explain “lock-in”:
When production processes require a large, upfront investment in fixed costs, such as the construction of a port, pipeline or coalmine, future production will take place even when the market price of the resultant product is lower than the long-run opportunity cost of production. This is because rational producers will ignore “sunk costs” and continue to produce as long as the market price is sufficient to cover the marginal cost (but not the average cost) of production. This is known as “lock-in.”
Basically, once a big piece of fossil fuel production infrastructure is built, it keeps producing in perpetuity (or until it runs dry), even if subsequent developments render the original investment foolish. Even if the original owner goes bankrupt, someone will buy the fixed asset and use it to produce “so long as the market price covers the marginal cost of production.”
That means every build-or-don’t-build decision for a piece of FF infrastructure is an inflection point, a “lump” of future FF supply that becomes almost guaranteed even in the face of substantial reduction in demand.
Given the danger of lock-in, complementary RSS policies send a signal to investors to “avoid inefficiently high levels of investment in the production capacity for goods of which policymakers are determined to reduce consumption in the future.”

4) RSS policies can short-circuit the dreaded “green paradox.”
The threat of policy growing more stringent over time (as in a rising carbon tax) is that it will push producers to move up their production schedules — to get while the getting’s good — which could suppress prices and boost short-term consumption. Restrictive supply-side policies passed now can help avoid this so-called “green paradox.”

Cutting off fossil fuel supply has unique political benefits
While economic arguments are familiar in climate policy circles, analyses that grapple with politics — the political economy in which policies are generated, supported, and implemented — are quite rare. (I have lamented this before.)
That seems to be changing a bit lately, though. Green and Denniss commend “the emerging literature on policy instrument interactions that ‘endogenizes’ political constraints.” In non-nerd-speak, “endogenizing” political constraints means making them internal to the analysis, recognizing that political constraints affect policies — and, crucially, that policies can in turn affect political constraints. (Policies that drive down the price of renewable energy, for instance, make higher renewable energy targets more palatable.)
One thing that recent political science has highlighted is that “overcoming political constraints to ambitious climate mitigation is best done by sequencing policies in such a way as to engineer feedback effects that expand the politically feasible set of climate policies over time.”
Rather than jumping straight to, say, an economy-wide carbon tax, it might be better to use more targeted policies to build the case against fossil fuels, improve the economics of key technologies, get the public more familiar with alternatives, and thus prepare the ground for more ambition. (I wrote a post about that too.)
Green and Denniss argue that RSS policies have some unique political benefits that should earn them a place early in that sequence. They cover three.

1) It is easier to organize public support around RSS policies.
This is the key argument. As the authors acknowledge, a great deal of recent study has gone into what kinds of features the public prefers in climate policies, but there’s not been much analysis of public preferences regarding “whether the instrument targets the supply side or the demand side.”
Attempting to fill that gap, the authors argue that supply-side policies will often be more conducive to building public support.
Political science has traced support for climate policies to, roughly speaking: “(i) the perceived benefits of the policy, (ii) the perceived personal and public costs of the policy, and (iii) the perceived distributional fairness of the policy.”
On all three scores, they say, RSS policies do well. First, where demand-side policies typically foreground carbon reductions, the benefits of which are widely spread in time and space, RSS policies target fossil fuel reductions, with a wider range of benefits — air and water pollution reductions, health improvements, and punishment for big fossil fuel companies, which are politically unpopular.
This broader portfolio of benefits is more likely to mobilize public support. It “enables proposals to be framed in ways that are more resonant with voters and more resilient to counter-attack by opposing interest groups; facilitates alliance-building among diverse groups with wide-ranging concerns about fossil fuels; and facilitates network-building among groups at different advocacy- and policy-relevant scales.” All those effects build political strength for future battles. (I’ve written about this too.)
Protestors marching against the Dakota Access Pipeline, in March 2017. 
Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
Second, where demand-side policies tend to place the costs visibly on consumers, the perceived costs of RSS policies fall on fossil fuel companies themselves. Of course, those costs are at least partially passed downstream to consumers eventually, but they are relatively more “hidden” that way, and thus more politically palatable. “Accordingly,” Green and Denniss write, “we would expect that people would perceive the costs to themselves of supply-side policies to be lower, or the distribution of the costs to be fairer, or both — and thus support for such policies to be higher.”

2) RSS can divide fossil fuel companies against one another.
As a sector, fossil fuels are well-organized and well-funded. United, they will almost always overpower civil society groups and politicians.
But they can be turned against one another. RSS policies can divide them along temporal lines — set incumbents against new entrants, for instance, with a ban on new extraction — or by “sub-industry” lines, say, coal from natural gas. “Rational fossil fuel producers perceiving a risk of a tightening carbon budget constraint,” they write, “will support policies that require emissions reductions from other sectors, including other fossil fuel sub-industries, but which exclude their own sector.”
As climate policy becomes more stringent, fossil fuel companies will adopt the philosophy of the campers attacked by a bear — you don’t have to be faster than the bear, just faster than the other campers.
Given the difficulty of building a winning coalition behind climate policies, the potential to win over FF sub-industries is a mark in RSS policies’ favor.

3) RSS policies can aid international cooperation.
The globally harmonized, independently verified, legally binding climate policy framework that climate activists have been dreaming about for decades has never materialized, and the Paris climate agreement marks the death of that aspiration. The Paris framework makes very little attempt to harmonize demand-side policies across countries, and most verification is done via self-reporting. That creates a different kind of policy environment and a different set of challenges for international cooperation. Green and Denniss argue that RSS policies are well-suited to the task.
First, economics tells us that if the “price elasticity” of a fossil fuel — the ability of consumers to find alternatives if prices rise — is higher than the “supply elasticity,” then demand-side policies would produce more “leakage” than supply-side policies. In those circumstances, “unilateral domestic supply-side policies would be more effective at reducing global emissions than their demand-side equivalents.” (Coal arguably fits this bill.)
“The emergence of international cooperation on fossil fuels is likely to be contingent on a coalition of early-movers taking unilateral steps to limit or reduce fossil fuel supply,” Green and Denniss write. “Low international leakage rates associated with supply-side policies would encourage the necessary unilateral action.”
The second feature that encourages international cooperation is the relative ease of measuring and verifying RSS policies relative to demand-side policies (as described above in the economics section). Transparency builds trust and makes further cooperation easier.
“Since the Paris Agreement’s success is predicated on states’ gradual escalation of their commitments over time,” they write, “commitments to implement supply-side policies offer major advantages as a ‘currency’ of international climate cooperation.”

It’s time to apologize to activists and make FF supply restrictions part of the climate policy toolkit
As Green and Denniss say over and over, no one is arguing that RSS policies are better than demand-side policies, or a substitute for them. The exact economic and political effects of any set of policies will always depend on context-dependent factors; different portfolios will be appropriate for different times and places.
But RSS policies are an excellent complement to demand-side policies, with economic and political strengths that help fill in the gaps. They are simple, transparent, easy for the public to grasp, and unmistakable signs of good faith in international climate negotiations.
It’s easy enough to understand why the political establishments of most countries are leery of RSS policies, given the ubiquitous influence of the fossil fuel industry. But it’s time for climate analysts and wonks to get past the sneering attitude they’ve traditionally had toward such policies and the activists who support them.
Yes, at this point, everyone gets it: An economy-wide, steadily rising, fuel- and technology-agnostic price on carbon is the optimal policy. But we don’t live in an optimal world, so yacking on about it isn’t much help. We live in this world, where a variety of political constraints means that no such policy has passed or seems likely to pass anytime soon. In this world, limited (thus suboptimal) demand-side policies need supplementing.
In this world, it makes sense to draw on all four quadrants — to use the portfolio approach taken for granted in so many other areas of policy. Climate change is a big problem. We can’t afford to leave any tools in the toolbox.

Links

Monday, June 04, 2018

Investors With $26 Trillion In Assets Urge G7 Leaders To Act On Climate Change

Deutsche Welle - David Martin | Reuters

Several huge investment firms, including Germany's Allianz Global Investors, have urged G7 leaders to increase their fight against climate change. The pleas will likely fall on deaf ears in the Trump administration.

Institutional investors boasting some $26 trillion (€22.3 trillion) in assets urged leaders from the Group of Seven nations to double down on their pledge to cut down greenhouse gas emissions by phasing out coal power entirely.
"The global shift to clean energy is under way, but much more needs to be done by governments," the group of 288 investors said in a statement ahead of the upcoming G7 summit in Canada, slated for June 8-9.
Signatories included leading investment firms such as Allianz Global Investors, Aviva Investors, DWS, HSBC Global Asset Management, Nomura Asset Management, Australian Super and HESTA.


What if the earth gets two degrees warmer?

Investors warned that pledges agreed on the back of the 2015 Paris climate summit did not go far enough to limit global warming. Governments, they said, needed to phase out coal power and fossil fuel subsidies worldwide to make any tangible progress in the fight against climate change. Coal power continues to account for almost 40 percent of all generated electricity.
Leading nations also needed "put a meaningful price on carbon," investors wrote in their statement, which was delivered to each of the G7 governments and the United Nations.
Stephanie Pfeifer, CEO of the Institutional Investors Group on Climate Change, one of the signatories, said Sunday's statement marked the first time such a broad group of leading investment firms has called for a phase-out of thermal coal used in power generation.
"There is a lot more momentum in the investor community" to put pressure on governments, she told the Reuters news agency.


What future for coal workers?

Trump's climate policy poses obvious roadblock
However, investors' calls for stricter climate policy risk being ignored by the US.
President Donald Trump has made clear he favors bolstering the US' fossil fuel industry and has voiced his doubts over the scientific findings on climate change.
Trump also announced a year ago that the US would pull out of the Paris climate accord, citing the supposedly "draconian financial and economic burdens" the agreement imposed on American jobs and the US economy.
Investors sought to counter those claims in Sunday's letter, writing that countries and firms that implement the Paris agreement's climate goals "will see significant economic benefits and attract increased investment."
The US along with Germany and Japan, is also not a member of the "Powering Past Coal" alliance, a group of almost 30 countries founded last year seeking to halt all coal power usage by 2030. G7 nations Canada, Britain, France and Italy are among the alliance's members.

Links

Government's $500m Great Barrier Reef Package May Have Limited Impact Amid Climate Change

ABC Science - Joanna Khan

Coral bleaching is caused by higher than normal water temperatures. (Supplied: Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority)
At the end of April a $500 million package to help the Great Barrier Reef was announced by the Federal Government.
It didn't take long for questions to be raised about the decision to give $444 million in funding to the Great Barrier Reef Foundation, a small charity with a revenue of only $8 million in 2016.
The funding will be split between improving water quality, supporting reef restoration science, increasing crown-of-thorns starfish control, community engagement and reef monitoring.
But there is no acknowledgement of what scientists argue is the biggest threat facing the reef: climate change.
Without climate action, can this package actually do anything to help the reef?
The answer is no, according to many involved in reef research, management and conservation, including University of Queensland coral biologist Sophie Dove.
"Unless we mitigate the CO2, a lot of the other solutions such as cleaning the water and removing crown of thorns are somewhat immaterial," Dr Dove said.
"All of those things can assist in helping any coral reefs that remain to survive and prosper in the future — but without climate mitigation, I think that's an issue."

Local reef actions must be met halfway
While the funding is a step forward for addressing local pressures on the reef like water quality, it must go hand in hand with national and global emissions reductions, according to Russell Reichelt from the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority (GBRMPA).
"We're very clear that it is absolutely critical to achieve action globally on climate change, but we're focused on what we can do as the Marine Park Authority in the local region," he said.
The funding was not designed to work on its own, said Dr Reichelt, who chairs the GBRMPA.
"The real solution in the long run is to address rising greenhouse gas concentrations in our atmosphere," he said.
"But we're still left with things that will happen inevitably now, because of the amount of greenhouse gases already in the atmosphere. So there was never a greater imperative that we look for ways to relieve local pressures."
However, some scientists have expressed concern that the funding is targeting some local measures that have not yet been proven effective.
Research fellow Jon Brodie from the ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies wrote in The Conversation that "one concern with the package is that it seems to give greatest weight to the strategies that are already being tried — and which have so far fallen a long way short of success".

Reef already changed by warming
If the water temperature doesn't drop after bleaching, corals starve and die, and get overgrown with algae. (Supplied: Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority)
Across the entire Great Barrier Reef 30 per cent of corals died after the 2016 bleaching event. In the northern third of the reef, where up to 50 per cent of shallow water corals were lost, some corals actually "cooked" because the underwater heatwave was so severe.

The government is avoiding dealing with the root cause of this, which is climate change, said Great Barrier Reef campaigner Imogen Zeethoven from the Australian Marine Conservation Society.
"I wake up at night thinking, what will it take for this Government to respond effectively, if losing 50 per cent of the shallow water corals on the reef isn't enough?" she said.
"They can invest $500 million over six years, but if they do nothing about climate change then it will all be wasted in the end."
Coral ecosystems have already been radically transformed by climate change.
The loss of corals due to the 2016 bleaching has forced some northern reefs to transition to new compositions of corals with less diversity — dominated by slow-growing species with more simple physical structures.
And scientists have already documented changes in reef fish diversity as a result of the coral loss.

New funding is still critical
Echoing these sentiments, CEO of the Australian Institute of Marine Science Paul Hardisty said the $500 million was a good start, but emissions also needed to be addressed.
Where is the urgency in Australia's climate policy?
Australia needs to stop pretending we're tackling climate change.
"On the business-as-usual trajectory … in a few decades there won't be any reefs, or at least reefs as we know them today," Dr Hardisty said.
"If you don't get greenhouse gas emissions under control then no amount of money is any use."
But Dr Hardisty said that didn't mean we should stop funding other local reef protection measures.
"We're past the point where we can say that getting emissions under control will be enough," he said.
"To have healthy reefs that provide trillions of dollars in ecosystem services to humans every year, then you've got to do both, there isn't another option."
By relieving other pressures on the reef such as poor water quality and crown-of-thorns starfish, the reefs of the future will have a better shot at surviving — no matter that form they take.

So where is the simultaneous climate action?
Spending on climate issues was cut in the 2018 budget from $3 billion to $1.6 billion in 2019, and it will be reduced further to $1.25 billion by 2022.
On top of that, the National Energy Guarantee (NEG) has an emissions reduction target of 26 to 28 per cent by 2030, which reef campaigner Imogen Zeethoven said was insufficient.
"A 26 per cent reduction, as proposed by the NEG, matched by all the countries in the world would result in all coral reefs in the world dying," Ms Zeethoven said.
"They need to dramatically upscale their emissions reduction target to match the funding investment that they're putting into the reef."
Dr Reichelt said that advocating for both global and local solutions for the reef was like walking a tightrope.
He said it was a balance between "making sure people understand the underlying cause and the need for global action, as well as not giving up on the reef locally".
"If the reef does survive until the end of the century we'll have a better, more diverse coral reef if we take all these local actions now," he said.

Links

Don't Turn To The Military To Solve The Climate-Change Crisis

The Guardian - *

Warning about conflicts, wars and mass migration is the wrong way to approach things
The heat waves and fires in recent years have shown that climate change will have a big impact on Australia. Photograph: Tracey Nearmy/AAP
The Australian Senate’s declaration last month that climate change is a “current and existential national security risk” was clearly intended to inject much-needed urgency into the country’s climate policy stalemate.
Bringing together the unusual bedfellows of military generals and environmentalists to warn about the dangers of climate change, it has the possibility to break though Australia’s culture wars on the issue.
 However, by framing climate change as a security matter, it also has significant consequences in shaping how we respond to a warming planet.
 As the climate crisis unfolds, is the military the institution we want to turn to for solutions?
The Australian Senate inquiry was initiated by the former Greens senator Scott Ludlam and heard from diverse actors, including humanitarian agencies and defence strategists.
 It examined the likely impacts of extreme weather on military infrastructure, the economy and the wider region. It concluded that “climate change is exacerbating threats and risks to Australia” and called for improved military preparedness, better studies of “risks” to Australia, and enhanced coordination between government agencies.
The question rarely asked is whose security are we talking about - security of what, for whom and from whom?
In this, Australia is following a well-worn path forged by the European Union and the United States. The Pentagon in 2003 was the first to talk about climate security, framing climate change as a “threat multiplier” that would exacerbate conflict, terrorism, mass migration and social instability.
In 2008, the EU concurred saying that global temperature increases of more than 2 degrees (current predictions suggest we are heading for more than 3 degrees) would “lead to unprecedented security scenarios”.
Security is a modern day weasel word – who can be against security? The question rarely asked is whose security are we talking about - security of what, for whom and from whom? The US, EU and now Australian strategies, though, clearly state they are talking about the security of their respective nations in the face of “threats” usually coming from the consequences of climate change in neighbouring countries.
The submission from Australia’s Department of Defence to the inquiry put it this way: “When climate impacts are combined with ethnic or other social grievances, they can contribute to increased migration, internal instability or intra-state insurgencies, often over greater competition for natural resources. These developments may foster terrorism or cross-border conflict.”
They argued that this “could lead to an increase in the demand for a wide spectrum of Defence responses including maintaining law and order following disasters”.
The image they paint is a dystopian one, which assumes that climate change disruptions will lead to a dog-eat-dog world, causing conflicts and wars, and prompting millions to migrate – and this will require the military to deal with the ensuing chaos.
The effect of this approach is to turn the victims of climate change into potential threats and to make a militarised response to the impact of climate change the default response.
The Australian Senate report is more nuanced than some US Pentagon reports in advocating for a range of strategies, including additional climate finance and better disaster resilience planning.
But by blurring the distinction between the military’s ideas of security and other “human security” approaches, it embraces and reinforces a military response to climate change.
This can be seen in the report’s strong appeals to the military to expand its role in disaster relief, even though this typically is the most costly form of relief and can end up militarising humanitarian disasters as the world witnessed graphically in New Orleans in the aftermath of hurricane Katrina where deployed National Guards ended up shooting at flood victims.
The Senate report has less focus on the way the impacts of climate change will vary dramatically depending on the level of poverty and vulnerability of the affected community. Nor does it challenge the economic structures or laws that have led to this inequality and vulnerability, such as the role of Australia’s trade policies in undermining rural livelihoods and disrupting food systems.
This is not surprising. After all, the essence of “security” is to secure what already exists. This means securing a world order in which Australia’s per capita income is 25 times that of nearby Kiribati or Solomon Islands and where even in Australia 2.9 million people live under the poverty line.
 It is an approach that seeks to build walls to exclude the dispossessed rather than tackle the underlying causes that cause people to migrate – shown today most visibly in Australia’s inhumane treatment of refugees in Nauru.
Australia’s experience of unprecedented heat waves and fires in recent years has already shown that climate change will have a big impact on the country and the wider region. But how those impacts play out will depend to a great degree on how we choose to respond.
An approach that relies on military forces and barbed wire will worsen the crisis and create a world no one wants to live in.
Real security emerges from recognising our interdependence, tackling injustice and inequality, and working together to protect those who are most vulnerable.

*Nick Buxton works at the Transnational Institute based in the Netherlands and is co-editor of The Secure and the Dispossessed: How the Military and Corporations are shaping a climate-changed world (Pluto Books, 2015)

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative