Saturday, August 25, 2018

Climate Change Policy Toppled Australia’s Leader. Here’s What It Means For Others.

New York Times - Somini Sengupta

The departing prime minister, Malcolm Turnbull, delivering his farewell address on Friday. Sam Mooy/EPA, via Shutterstock
Climate change policy toppled the government in Australia on Friday.
How much does that really matter?
It is certain to keep Australia from meeting its emissions targets under the Paris climate agreement.
It’s also a glimpse into what a potent political issue climate change and energy policy can be in a handful of countries with powerful fossil fuel lobbies, namely Australia, Canada and the United States.
In Australia, the world’s largest exporter of coal, climate and energy policy have infused politics for a decade, helping to bring down both liberal and conservative lawmakers.
This week, the failure to pass legislation that would have reined in greenhouse gas emissions precipitated Malcolm Turnbull’s ouster as prime minister. He was elbowed out by Scott Morrison, an ardent champion of the Australian coal industry who is known for having brought a lump of the stuff to Parliament.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau of Canada expects to face a powerful challenge in elections next year from politicians aligned with the country’s oil industry. Christinne Muschi/Reuters
It could be a bellwether for next year’s Canadian elections, expected in October, in which Prime Minister Justin Trudeau faces a powerful challenge from politicians aligned with the country’s oil industry. Conservatives have pledged to undo Mr. Trudeau’s plans to put a price on carbon nationwide if they take power. At the provincial level, conservatives won a majority in Ontario after campaigning against the province’s newly enacted cap-and-trade program.
The Australian parallels with the United States are striking. The Trump administration has promised to revive the coal industry, rolled back fuel emissions standards and announced the country’s exit from the Paris pact altogether. Climate change is not a driving issue in the United States midterm election campaign, though it is for liberal Democrats, a recent study by the Yale Program on Climate Change Communication has shown.
Environmental policy and global warming are top priorities for those who describe themselves as liberal Democrats, the study found, after health care and gun control.
Democrats in Congress suffered sweeping losses in the 2010 midterms after trying and failing to pass a cap-and-trade program for carbon dioxide emissions. A few studies by political scientists have suggested that the cap-and-trade votes may have hurt some incumbents who voted for the measure, though economic factors and the health care debate played a large role.
Robert C. Orr, dean of the School of Public Policy at the University of Maryland, pointed to another parallel: In both Australia and the United States, local leaders have embraced renewable energy even as national politicians promote fossil fuels.
“Australia is a lot like the U.S.,” said Dr. Orr, who is also the special adviser on climate change to the United Nations secretary general. “Climate policy has really been driven from below, from the state, local and business level. That is not going to change.”
Most Australian states have renewable energy targets, and Australians are powering their houses with solar energy at one of the highest rates in the world. But Australia’s emissions have continued to rise.
Australia is among several industrialized nations that are not on track to reduce greenhouse gas emissions to keep global warming below two degrees Celsius as the Paris accord promises, according to independent analyses.
Climate Action Tracker, an alliance of European think tanks that tracks countries’ climate pledges under the agreement, concluded recently that “if all other countries were to follow Australia’s current policy settings, warming could reach over 3°C and up to 4°C.” Those are levels that climate scientists consider “highly insufficient” to stop the worst effects of climate change.

Links

NASA Launching Advanced Laser To Measure Earth’s Changing Ice

NASA

NASA’s Ice, Cloud and land Elevation Satellite-2 (ICESat-2) spacecraft arrives at the Astrotech Space Operations facility at Vandenberg Air Force Base in California ahead of its scheduled launch on Sept. 15, 2018. Credit: U.S. Air Force/Vanessa Valentine
Next month, NASA will launch into space the most advanced laser instrument of its kind, beginning a mission to measure – in unprecedented detail – changes in the heights of Earth’s polar ice.
NASA’s Ice, Cloud and land Elevation Satellite-2 (ICESat-2) will measure the average annual elevation change of land ice covering Greenland and Antarctica to within the width of a pencil, capturing 60,000 measurements every second.
“The new observational technologies of ICESat-2 – a top recommendation of the scientific community in NASA’s first Earth science decadal survey – will advance our knowledge of how the ice sheets of Greenland and Antarctica contribute to sea level rise,” said Michael Freilich, director of the Earth Science Division in NASA’s Science Mission Directorate.
ICESat-2 will extend and improve upon NASA's 15-year record of monitoring the change in polar ice heights, which started in 2003 with the first ICESat mission and continued in 2009 with NASA’s Operation IceBridge, an airborne research campaign that kept track of the accelerating rate of change.

A technological leap
NASA’s Ice, Cloud and land Elevation Satellite-2 (ICESat-2) will measure height with a laser instrument that features components designed to provide precise data. LARGE IMAGE Credit: NASA/Adriana Manrique Gutierrez
ICESat-2 represents a major technological leap in our ability to measure changes in ice height. Its Advanced Topographic Laser Altimeter System (ATLAS) measures height by timing how long it takes individual light photons to travel from the spacecraft to Earth and back.
“ATLAS required us to develop new technologies to get the measurements needed by scientists to advance the research,” said Doug McLennan, ICESat-2 project manager at NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center. “That meant we had to engineer a satellite instrument that not only will collect incredibly precise data, but also will collect more than 250 times as many height measurements as its predecessor.”
ATLAS will fire 10,000 times each second, sending hundreds of trillions of photons to the ground in six beams of green light. The roundtrip of individual laser photons from ICESat-2 to Earth’s surface and back is timed to the billionth of a second to precisely measure elevation.
With so many photons returning from multiple beams, ICESat-2 will get a much more detailed view of the ice surface than its predecessor, ICESat. In fact, if the two satellites were flown over a football field, ICESat would take only two measurements – one in each end zone – whereas ICESat-2 would collect 130 measurements between each end zone.
As it circles Earth from pole to pole, ICESat-2 will measure ice heights along the same path in the polar regions four times a year, providing seasonal and annual monitoring of ice elevation changes.


NASA’s Ice, Cloud and land Elevation Satellite-2 (ICESat-2) will provide scientists with height measurements that create a global portrait of Earth's third dimension, gathering data that can precisely track changes of terrain including glaciers, sea ice, and forests. Credit: NASA/Ryan Fitzgibbons 

Tracking ice melt
Hundreds of billions of tons of land ice melt or flow into the oceans annually, contributing to sea level rise worldwide. In recent years, contributions of melt from the ice sheets of Greenland and Antarctica alone have raised global sea level by more than a millimeter a year, accounting for approximately one-third of observed sea level rise, and the rate is increasing.
ICESat-2 data documenting the ongoing height change of ice sheets will help researchers narrow the range of uncertainty in forecasts of future sea level rise and connect those changes to climate drivers.
ICESat-2 also will make the most precise polar-wide measurements to date of sea ice freeboard, which is the height of sea ice above the adjacent sea surface. This measurement is used to determine the thickness and volume of sea ice. Satellites routinely measure the area covered by sea ice and have observed an Arctic sea ice area decline of about 40 percent since 1980, but precise, region-wide sea ice thickness measurements will improve our understanding of the drivers of sea ice retreat and loss.
Although floating sea ice doesn’t change sea level when it melts, its loss has different consequences. The bright Arctic ice cap reflects the Sun’s heat back into space. When that ice melts away, the dark water below absorbs that heat. This alters wind and ocean circulation patterns, potentially affecting Earth’s global weather and climate.
Beyond the poles, ICESat-2 will measure the height of ocean and land surfaces, including forests. ATLAS is designed to measure both the tops of trees and the ground below, which – combined with existing datasets on forest extent – will help researchers estimate the amount of carbon stored in the world’s forests. Researchers also will investigate the height data collected on ocean waves, reservoir levels, and urban areas.
Potential data users have been working with ICESat-2 scientists to connect the mission science to societal needs. For example, ICESat-2 measurements of snow and river heights could help local governments plan for floods and droughts. Forest height maps, showing tree density and structure, could improve computer models that firefighters use to forecast wildfire behavior. Sea ice thickness measurements could be integrated into forecasts the U.S. Navy issues for navigation and sea ice conditions.
“Because ICESat-2 will provide measurements of unprecedented precision with global coverage, it will yield not only new insight into the polar regions, but also unanticipated findings across the globe,” said Thorsten Markus, an ICESat-2 project scientist at Goddard. “The capacity and opportunity for true exploration is immense.”
​ICESat-2 is scheduled to launch Sept. 15 from Vandenberg Air Force Base in California.

Links

Scientists Are Finally Linking Extreme Weather To Climate Change

Wired - Matt Reynolds

Until now scientists have been cagey about linking extreme weather events such as this summer's heatwave to climate change. An emerging field is changing all that
Patrik Stollarz/AFP/Getty Images
The summer of 2018 has not been a normal summer. Throughout June and July an extended heatwave set record-breaking high temperatures across the northern hemisphere.
In Japan, more than 22,000 people were taken to hospital with heat stroke as the country recorded its highest-ever temperature of 41.1 degrees Celsius. In California, Portugal and as far north as the Arctic Circle huge wildfires, encouraged by months of unusually dry conditions, followed the searing heat.
For years, climatologists asked to explain these kind of extreme events have fallen back on a well-worn phrase. “It’s impossible to attribute a single weather event to climate change,” the refrain goes. And they’re right. Weather is by its very nature unpredictable – extreme events will always happen in one place or another, regardless of global temperature levels, and they’re not necessarily tied to one particular cause.
For Friederike Otto, deputy director of the Environmental Change Institute (ECI) at the University of Oxford, this response has its drawbacks. “If scientists don’t answer, someone else gives an answer and it’s usually people who aren’t interested in the size and have their own agenda,” she says. Instead, Otto wondered if scientists could start saying whether climate change had made certain extreme weather events more or less likely.
Now Otto is right at the heart of a growing scientific movement called extreme event attribution. Her aim? To be able to point to an extreme weather event and use climate modelling to say whether that same event would have been more or less likely to happen in a world where humans hadn’t caused global temperatures to rise by a whole degree over the last 120 years.
Up until a few years ago, it wasn’t possible to draw that link with any degree of accuracy, Otto says. But in 2004, Pete Stott at the UK Met Office published a paper in the scientific journal Nature showing that climate change had at least doubled the risk of the 2003 European heatwave that killed tens of thousands of people.
Twelve years later the Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society dedicated an entire issue to the new field of extreme event attribution. In the introduction, its editors argued that it was now possible to detect the effects of climate change on some events with high confidence. “That was really the first time we could say that we can attribute events to anthropogenic climate change,” Otto says.
In late 2014, Otto helped set up the World Weather Attribution (WWA) initiative – a collaboration between the ECI, the Netherlands-based Red Cross Red Crescent Climate Centre and Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute. The aim of the project wasn’t just to draw a link between extreme events and climate change, but to provide this analysis in real-time so they’d have answers while the extreme weather event was actually happening.
In July, while most of Europe was still sweltering under unusually high temperatures, Otto released her analysis of this year’s heatwave. She looked at temperature measurements in seven locations in Ireland, Denmark, the Netherlands, Norway, Sweden and Finland and used different climate models to estimate how likely it was that those same temperatures would occur in a world without climate change.
To do this, Otto ran hundreds of simulations on a pair of climate models. These are the same kind of models used for weather reports that take into account variables like rainfall, wind, temperature and air pressure. The only variable changed in the two models is the concentration of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, as these are main drivers of climate change.
One model represents our present-day atmosphere while the other models the kind of world we’d be living in if the concentration of greenhouse gases hadn’t ramped up post-1900. By simulating hundreds of years of weather using these two models, Otto and her colleagues are able to compare what the weather might be like in a world with or without climate change.
When it comes to the northern European heatwave, the analysis was unequivocal. Climate change caused by humans has made these kinds of temperatures at least twice as likely to happen. In other words, if we were living in a world where humans hadn’t heated up the planet by a whole degree, this summer heatwave would have been half as likely.
In Copenhagen, Denmark, which saw temperatures of just below 31 degrees Celsius, climate change made the likelihood of those temperatures occurring five times higher. In Linköping, Sweden, it was six times higher. This is weather attribution in action, in real-time. “What climate change can do, and in the case of this heatwave what it has done, is change the likelihood of an event occuring,” she says.
Although the language of likelihood and chance may sound imprecise, this is a great deal more certain than anything researchers would have been able to identify a decade. Otto compares her analyses to studies into smoking and cancer. Although it’s impossible to definitively say that an individual case of lung cancer was caused by smoking, we can draw a direct link between smoking and the likelihood of someone developing cancer.
So far, Otto and her colleagues have analysed a raft of extreme weather events including extreme rainfall in Japan in early July 2018 that killed 200 people and the unusually cold winter across North America last year. And the analyses don’t always turn up a link between climate change and extreme weather events. In a study into the 2015 Ethiopian drought that affected nearly 10 million people across the country, Otto and her colleagues found no influence of climate change.
And finding examples where climate change isn’t behind an extreme weather event is just as worthwhile as finding cases where it is. Otto’s hope is that individuals and governments use her analyses to futureproof themselves against the impact of climate change.
 “One of the main motivations behind this project is that climate change is already happening today and it’s having an impact on our day to day life,” she says. In the UK, extreme event attribution has already been used to help assess the risk of flooding in local areas, and Otto expects this kind of analysis to be used more widely as the field becomes more established.
“For a large part of the world it’s still a very new science,” she says. But this emerging field could help governments to start making their decisions on what might happen on the future instead of thinking about what has happened in the past. “If you have a changing climate and you only look at the past you will not get the right answer,” Otto says.
At the moment the WWA’s analyses compare a world with no warming to a world with one degree of warming, but Otto also runs models that look at how the weather will change if the world warms by a further one degree, as is projected to happen by the end of this century. If that happens, the temperatures in Copenhagen we saw this summer will be four times more likely to happen in the future.
And it’s these extreme weather events that we should be paying attention to – not just the headline figures of global temperature increases. “Global mean temperature doesn’t kill anyone,” Otto says. “It’s extreme events that kill people.”

Links

Friday, August 24, 2018

'Absolutely Daft': How Did We End Up Getting Climate Policy So Wrong?

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

With the apparent combustion of the Turnbull government expected on Friday, the parallels with Emperor Nero supposedly playing his lyre as Rome blazed around him are unmistakable.
Having our federal political leaders consumed with the Liberal Party's infighting is precisely not what's needed for our country. Just ask agencies battling to prepare for real-life conflagrations that threaten the eastern seaboard in coming months.
Standing back and watching climate change is not going to be an option. Photo: AAP

It's certainly ironic Malcolm Turnbull's ditching of carbon emissions as a goal of the National Energy Guarantee last week precipitated the crisis that has almost certainly ended his time as Prime Minister.
What is especially disturbing is the risk his successor - whether it is Peter Dutton or Scott Morrison or Julie Bishop or whoever else - will downgrade climate action as a priority in order to secure right-wing MP support.
Rather than taking up the national interest and cutting carbon emissions - the Turnbull government effectively has no climate policy - the next PM will likely be under pressure to back new coal-fired power stations.
The move would further embed fossil fuels in an economy that must fully decarbonise - along with the rest of the world - by mid-century or soon after to avoid dangerous climate change.
Conservative MPs and pundits have been clamouring to pull Australia out of the Paris Climate Agreement, ignoring mounting evidence of the threat we face from more extreme weather, and soon.
Australia, year to date, is running at a record for maximum temperatures, according to the Bureau of Meteorology's ACORN-surface air temperature network.
Subtle shifts in temperature can be hard for people to appreciate. How many of us have thought the current winter seems annoyingly long as we awoke on yet another frosty morning?
Look out, though, for reports early next month that will confirm many of us have just experienced one of the mildest winters on record.
Visual aids, such the colour scales created by Ed Hawkins, a professor at the National Centre for Atmospheric Science at the UK's University of Reading, can help us understand how Australia has warmed.
In Australia's case, taking mean temperatures from 1910 to 2017 and mapping the coolest year (20.7 degrees) as dark blue and the hottest (23 degrees) as dark red, it should be obvious which way the mercury is trending.
How Australia's average annual mean temperatures have changed between 1910 and 2017, with the dark blue showing the coldest at 20.7 degrees and 23.0 degrees the darkest red, according Ed Hawkins, a UK-based climate scientist. Photo: Ed Hawkins/University of Reading.
As Fairfax Media reported this week, evaporation across eastern Australia is not only at record levels for the first seven months of 2018, but there's bright, unstinting daylight between the nearest rival year when it was this bad.
Fire authorities prefer not to stir alarm but they are quietly preparing for what could be a catastrophic season of bushfires in eastern states.
NSW is entirely drought-declared and the outlook is for a drier and hotter than normal spring for many areas - all this as crews have fought dozens of fires across the state even before spring arrives.


100 per cent of New South Wales is being affected by drought, leading to crop failure and the off-loading of livestock in record numbers.

Places such as Richmond on Sydney's north-west fringe are showing vegetation moisture readings as low as the time of the last big bushfires to threaten the Harbour City.
And those readings are in late August - not December 2002 when that previous high was marked. Those conditions are true for most of the forests around Sydney.
Remember how Turnbull and Josh Frydenberg, the current environment and energy minister, told us lowering power prices had to be "the main game in town" when it came to the now defunct National Energy Guarantee?
Robyn Eckersley, an expert in climate policy at Melbourne University, is as bemused as any that a government has again foundered on global warming.
"Everyone's fascinated by the sharpening of knives - it's all very Machiavellian," she says. "But no-one is talking about the problem of climate change.
"No one is talking about the cost not to act. If you put those in the balance sheet, you'd be absolutely daft not to take anticipatory action as fast as possible."

Links

US And Australia Are Dysfunctional: Hyper-Partisanship Is Killing Two Great Democracies

ABC News - Bruce Wolpe

The answer lies in enlightened leadership, or we can continue the politics of mutual assured destruction. (Facebook: Malcolm Turnbull)
 If there were a single defining moment of the leadership crisis that engulfed Malcolm Turnbull this week it was his backdown over his Government's core energy and climate legislation, the National Energy Guarantee.
The Prime Minister was forced to capitulate because he did not have the votes inside his own Coalition to pass the bill on the floor.
Paradoxically, had he forged a compromise with Labor, which was open to a deal that would settle a decade of bitter conflict on the climate wars, Mr Turnbull could have had the votes to pass the bill — easily.
But hyper-partisanship won out — again.
"We propose bills in the House when we believe we can carry them, and so at the moment we don't have, because it is a one-seat majority, and that's a fact of life — we don't have enough support to do that."
Mr Turnbull adjudged it too painful to have Labor vote for a government bill at the expense of losing some votes in his party and Coalition in the process — even if that meant a continuation of the ugly, bitter wars over energy and climate that have plagued political debate here for over a decade, a war that most voters, and certainly industry — a backbone of the conservative government — want solved with bipartisan legislation.
So the pro-coal, anti-global warming rump inside the Government could trump the majority sensibility to bring the climate wars to a close and advance the national interest.
As a result, Mr Turnbull looks likely to becoming the fourth prime minister in 11 years to lose his job.
All eyes have been on Peter Dutton, now a Liberal backbencher, in Parliament this week. (ABC: Matt Roberts)
 The Washington mantra
This hyper-partisanship is also ascendant in Washington.
For over 20 years, since Newt Gingrich, a conservative from Georgia, became Speaker of the House after leading a Republican assault on the power structure, a relentless political culture of us-versus-them has prevailed in Washington.
In their forensic study of the politics that led to the ascendance of Mr Trump, titled One Nation After Trump, scholars Norm Ornstein, EJ Dionne and Thomas Mann cite the Gingrich rule that still applies today:
"It is a war for power … Don't try to educate. That is not your job. What is the primary purpose of a political leader? To build a majority."
This became the Washington mantra.
Under the Westminster system governing Australia, the hyper-partisan power of the elected majority can work its will in Parliament, to great effect — even taking into account a recalcitrant Senate.
So a government that controls the House of Representatives controls the agenda and can apply maximum pressure to get their bills through, with little concern for the opposition and with some attention to independents in the Senate.
The governing party decides the agenda, their votes hold, the Opposition opposes — and loses. Laws are enacted. Hyper-partisanship rules.
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull is not giving up his leadership without a fight. (ABC News: Matt Roberts)
 Rise of endless gridlock
In Washington, what has happened is that culture of Westminster hyper-partisanship has been imposed on the American constitutional system of checks and balances between three co-equal branches of government: Congress, the presidency and the judiciary.
The American system puts a premium on compromise to get things done. Indeed, to pass legislation, a supermajority — 60 votes — is required in the Senate.
The Republicans today only have 51, so only if enough Democrats agree can bills get passed.
Hyper-partisanship paralyses Congress, leading to bitter, endless gridlock. Whatever Barack Obama wanted, the Republicans in Congress were determined to stop. Whatever Mr Trump wants, the Democrats in Congress are determined to kill.
Issues that require a bipartisan solution — gun control, health care, immigration — are roadkill.
What that means is that on some of the major issues of our times, issues that beg for bipartisan work — gun control and health care in America, immigration and global warming in both countries — hyper-partisanship, by its definition and political nature, means no compromise, no consensus. No working together in the national interest.
Two great democracies dysfunctional, and in danger.
On some of the major issues of our times, issues that beg for bipartisan work, hyper-partisanship means no compromise, no consensus (Reuters: Leah Millis)
People want their leaders to work together
The answer lies in enlightened leadership — in both major parties — so some semblance of a working relationship that can tackle such vexed issues.
A recognition that, in fact, the people want their leaders to work together, and can find a way to agree on common-sense, middle-of-the-road policies, that will serve the national interest, the common interest, the public good.
Or we can continue the politics of mutual assured destruction.

*Bruce Wolpe worked with the Democrats in Congress in Barack Obama's first term as president

Links

Thursday, August 23, 2018

Australia Is Devastated By Drought, Yet It Won't Budge On Climate Change

CNN - Angela Dewan

Farmer Ash Whitney cuts off branches to feed his cattle in a drought-affected paddock in Gunnedah, Australia.
Australia is suffering its worst drought in living memory, as dozens of bushfires are blazing out of control. It's hard to believe that it's winter "down under." Summer is yet to come.Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull on Sunday committed 1.8 billion Australian dollars ($1.3 billion) in relief funds for farmers, whose livelihoods are disappearing down the cracks of their dry, barren land. The very next day, he announced he was dropping a national policy to cut carbon emissions from the energy sector that was supposed to help Australia fulfill its obligations under the Paris climate change agreement.
The vast majority of Australians accept human-induced climate change is real and scientists have linked the current record-slashing drought to global warming, yet the subject is still highly controversial in Australian politics, and climate change skepticism is still given political space.
Australia is suffering from a record-breaking drought.
Turnbull is now facing a renewed leadership challenge from MP Peter Dutton. If Turnbull loses, he would be the third Australian prime minister to be ousted over climate policy in the past decade. A Dutton-led Australia would mean even less hope for those who want action on climate change.
It's difficult to comprehend why Australia -- a wealthy, developed nation that has long experienced crippling weather events -- has failed time and time again to get a coherent climate change plan together.
All the signs are there. The UNESCO heritage-listed Great Barrier Reef, a 2,300-kilometer stretch rich in biodiverse marine life, is under threat, having lost more than half its coral in two mass bleaching events in 2016 and 2017.
Australia's Great Barrier reef is under threat.
Australia clocked record heat in the first half of this year. The whole of New South Wales, the country's most populous state, is now 100% in drought, with some areas seeing less than 10mm of rain in July, right in the middle of winter.
It's so dry that animals are being forced to migrate -- a group of emus recently swarmed the town of Broken Hill, running down the street and gate crashing football matches in search of water and food, the Australian ABC reported.

Political survival
Political wrangling is one reason for the slow progress. Turnbull scrapped his climate policy in order to ensure his survival as prime minister.
"The history of Australian politics is that climate policy has proven in the past to be so controversial that it has resulted in prime ministers losing their jobs," said Bob Ward, policy director at the Grantham Research Institute at the London School of Economics.
"Australians can see for themselves what's going on at the moment. They're facing a series of weather events linked to climate change -- droughts, heatwaves, fires -- and Australia's scientific communities have been telling politicians for a long time what's going on."
Instead of talking about global warming, the ruling Liberal Party's conservative faction, that has long resisted climate action, has framed the debate around electricity prices. Dutton said Tuesday that should he became leader he would set up an inquiry exploring why power was so pricey.
Australia has long battled bushfires, but scientists say climate change has made them more severe.
A study published in the journal Nature Climate Change found that Australians who identify with the country's conservative party are more likely to be predisposed to climate change skepticism. Of all 25 nations studied, only the United States had a stronger correlation between political ideology and belief in global warming.
It also found that link between political leaning and climate change skepticism was typically present in countries with strong fossil fuel industries, including the US, Australia, Canada and Brazil, indicating the power of industry lobbying.
Much of that lobbying happens through think tanks funded by the mining and energy industries, said John Cook, from the Center for Climate Change Communication at George Mason University.
"The broad picture in Australia is that in the '80s the issue was much less polarized. It was in the early 1990s that conservative think tanks began attacking climate science for ideological reasons, because the consequence of climate change meant regulating industry," Cook said.
That combination of ideology and climate change skepticism is most apparent in former prime minister Tony Abbott, now a backbench MP but the most vocal critic of Turnbull's carbon reduction policy.
Abbott pointed to the US President Donald Trump's announcement to withdraw the US from the Paris agreement as a reason for Australia to scrap its own emissions targets, saying last week, "it's time to get out of Paris."
Tony Abbott, right, during his time as prime minister, with Malcolm Turnbull, who ousted Abbott from the premiership.
Abbott gave a speech to a climate-skeptic think tank in London last year, in which he made the remarkable claim that climate change was "probably doing good, or at least, more good than harm," and likened climate change action to "primitive people" who killed goats to appease volcano gods.
He has even called for new coal power stations to be built by the federal government.

Australia's coal addiction
Turnbull's energy policy was aimed at bringing the country in line with its commitment to cut carbon emissions by 26% by 2030, from 2005 levels, as Australia pledged in the Paris climate change agreement.
Australians support the agreement and climate change action more broadly -- until it hits their wallets, polls show.
A Newspoll survey published in The Australian newspaper in October 2017, for example, found almost half of those polled would support dropping out of the Paris climate change agreement if it lowered energy prices.
"(Climate action) has taken too long because of the political influence of the coal industry, and as a result ... a significant rump of the current government either don't believe in climate change or don't believe Australia should do anything," Ian Lowe, Emeritus Professor at Griffith University's School of Science, told CNN.
Coal sits at the Hay Point and Dalrymple Bay Coal Terminals south of the Queensland town of Mackay in Australia.
Australia is regularly referred to at the world's biggest coal exporter, and it depends heavily on the fossil fuel in its own energy mix, as well as for jobs and economic prosperity. Mining has contributed significantly to the country's record-breaking 26 consecutive years of economic growth.
Much of Australia's coal is exported to China, to fuel the Asian powerhouse's rapid development. But even China is starting to wean itself off dirty fossil fuel and is looking increasingly to renewable energy.
Australia is getting a renewable energy program off the ground, but a lack of political will has meant progress has been incredibly slow, said Harald Heubaum, an energy and climate policy expert at the University of London. The huge potential in the sunny country for solar energy is still largely unrealized.
"So a question Australia could ask is, does it really just want to be a quarry for Asia? To take the coal and gas and iron ore, and whatever precious metals it can find and export them?" Heubaum said.
"Or does it want to diversify away from that?"

Links

Rising Seas Will Displace Millions Of People – And Australia Must Be Ready

The Conversation -  | 

MONIRUL ALAM/EPA
Sea-level rise is already threatening some communities around the world, particularly small island states, as it exacerbates disasters resulting from storm surges and flooding.
If greenhouse gas emissions continue unabated, by 2100 the world could see sea-level rise of a metre – or even more if there is a larger contribution from the Antarctic ice sheet, as some recent findings suggest.
Even without a larger Antarctic response, the rate of rise at the end of the 21st century for unmitigated emissions is likely to be equivalent to the rate of rise during the last deglaciation of the Earth, when sea level rose at more than a metre per century for many millennia. For all scenarios, sea-level rise will continue for centuries to come.
Without significantly more effective mitigation than currently planned, the rise will ultimately be many metres, or even tens of metres – the question is not if there will be large rises, but how quickly they will happen.

Forcing people from their homes
As well as causing seas to rise, climate change may also increase the severity of events like cyclones and rainfall, which may force people from their homes in many regions.
Global statistics on the risk of disaster displacement were not systematically collected until 2008, but already they offer stark figures. In 2017, 18.8 million people were internally displaced by natural disasters, with floods accounting for 8.6 million. By contrast, 11.8 million were displaced by conflict. Many more people are displaced each year by disasters than by conflict. Climate change intensifies this risk.
Roughly 100 million people live within about a metre of current high tide level. (Double these numbers for a five-metre sea-level rise, and triple them for 10 metres.)
Many of the world’s megacities are on the coast and vulnerable to sea-level change. Without adaption, it is estimated that by 2100 some of these areas will flood, displacing in the order of 100 million people.
While the vast majority of those people will never cross an international border, some will – and their legal status will be precarious because they will not qualify as refugees under the UN Refugee Convention (people with a well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, political opinion or membership of a particular social group).
In the current political climate, governments are reticent to create a new legal status for such people, and it would be difficult to encapsulate the complexity of climate change and disaster-related movement in a treaty definition anyway. Many factors drive people to leave their homes – such as poverty, resource scarcity and lack of livelihood opportunities – but climate change becomes the straw that breaks the camel’s back.

Good policy is essential
The most effective way to reduce the number of displaced people is strong global mitigation of emissions. In Australia, a successful NEG policy that included emissions reduction would cover about a third of Australia’s emissions. Mitigation policies also need to be developed to cover all emission sectors.
However, even with strong mitigation, adaptation will be essential. The evidence tells us that most people want to remain in their homes for as long as they can, and to return as quickly as possible. We therefore need laws and policies that permit people to remain in their homes where possible and desirable; that enable them to move elsewhere, before disaster strikes, if they wish; and to receive assistance and protection if they are displaced.
Coastal communities could live more effectively with rising sea levels by developing infrastructure, adopting and enforcing appropriate planning and building codes, and controlling flooding to allow sediment deposition. Storm-surge shelters and storm-surge warnings have already saved thousands of lives in countries like Bangladesh.
Good policy is essential. Studies of floods in Bangladesh showed that when people received prompt and adequate assistance, they were more likely to stay and rebuild than to move on in search of work to survive. By contrast, a year after Typhoon Haiyan struck the Philippines, tens of thousands of people remained displaced because the authorities said it was unsafe to go home but could not offer any alternative. This is likely to be a growing challenge with on-going climate change.
We are going to see more and more climate related disasters. We can do better in the way we prepare for and respond to them. The nature and timing of policy interventions will be crucial in determining outcomes after a disaster, because together they affect people’s ability to cope and be resilient. We need a broad, complementary set of policy strategies to assist people and give them choices.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative