Tuesday, September 04, 2018

'Lip Service': Call For Investors To Step Up Action On Climate Risk

Fairfax - Ruth Williams

Investors have been urged to “step up the pressure” on companies to act on climate change as annual meeting season approaches, with a report arguing corporate Australia is paying lip-service to the issue.
Environmental non-profit Market Forces says many of Australia’s 100 biggest listed companies are continuing to take a "superficial" approach to disclosure and action on climate change and emissions, despite warnings by regulators and lawyers of potential business and legal risks.
Almost 40 per cent of companies examined had increased emissions over the past year, Market Forces said. Photo: Bloomberg

Market Forces research, to be released on Tuesday, suggests that of 74 ASX100 companies in sectors dubbed “high risk” for climate change impacts - as defined last year by a G20-led task force on climate risk disclosure - only 55 per cent identified climate change as a material business risk, and more than 80 per cent did not have a plan to reduce their own emissions.
Almost 40 per cent of ASX100 companies studied had increased their emissions over the past year, the Market Forces research said.
The NGO - which is affiliated with Friends of the Earth - has urged investors to “escalate” climate change as an issue in their discussions with companies, and divest shaes in companies that are “unable or unwilling” to align with the goals of the 2015 Paris climate agreement.
“There is a growing recognition of climate risk, but few companies are actually undertaking the hard yards to fully address the issue,” Market Forces analyst Will van de Pol said.
The Market Forces research comes as the new Morrison government grapples with internal divisions on its approach to climate change, emissions and the Paris agreement. New Defence Minister Marise Payne is attending the Pacific Islands Forum this week where climate change is expected to be a major topic of discussion.
Prime Minister Scott Morrison (right) and deputy Josh Frydenberg have grappled with internal divisions on carbon emissions. Photo: Mark Graham/Bloomberg
It also comes as regulators consider how climate change may impact the financial system, with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) assessing how ASX300 companies disclose climate change risks, and the Council of Financial Regulators - which includes ASIC, the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA), the Reserve Bank and federal Treasury - creating a working group on the issue.
ASIC has said company directors should take seriously warnings that they risk future legal action if they fail to consider risks related to climate change.

Risky business
A third of companies studied “explicitly encourage” emissions reductions through their executive or director bonus schemes, Market Forces said, a number that had doubled since Market Forces’ last examined the issue in March.
But just three companies – South32, AGL and Stockland – had started reporting climate risks in line with the so-called "TCFD" rules nailed down by the G20's task force last year, which have been endorsed by major companies and investors.
Another four companies - Commonwealth Bank, BHP, Westpac and ANZ - “came close” to fully adopting the TCFD recommendations, Market Forces said, while others had promised to do so for their 2019 reporting.
The TCFD recommendations are anchored on the Paris agreement's pledge to keep global warming to well below 2 degrees. In July, the Australian Securities Exchange's corporate governance council - in proposed new guidelines - said companies should boost their disclosure of climate change risk, including reporting with the TCFD rules if they had "material exposure".
The Market Forces research found that while 65 per cent of companies studied unequivocally accepted climate science, 27 per cent were unclear in their language and 8 per cent had not formally acknowledged the science of climate change.
In June, research from the Australian Council of Superannuation Investors found that 22 ASX200 companies had adopted or promised to adopt the TCFD rules while 10 more were "reviewing" them.

AGM focus
Mr van de Pol pointed to South32 as a company that was "getting it right, coupling detailed climate risk disclosures with action to reduce exposure".
But he questioned why ASX Ltd was not following the suggestions of its own corporate governance council in not disclosing detailed climate risk information, saying the listed company was exposed to climate risk because "high risk-exposed mining, materials and big financial companies dominate the ASX".
ASX Ltd said it was "difficult to conclude" the company had a material exposure to listed companies directly at risk to climate change, given ASX Ltd was a "diverse, service-based organisation". The technology sector was its fastest growing sector, it said.
It would comply with the corporate governance council's recommendations on an "if not why not" basis once they were finalised, ASX Ltd said.
Whitehaven Coal was among the lowest-scoring companies in the Market Forces research, which found that the coal miner - a vocal proponent of "High Energy Low Emission" (HELE) coal fired-power stations - had not disclosed any risks it may face from climate change or listed it as a material business risk.
Market Forces has launched shareholder resolutions against Whitehaven Coal ahead of its AGM in October, calling on the company to ensure its strategy was “consistent” with the Paris agreement. The vote would be a "litmus test" on investors' willingness to push companies on climate, Market Forces said.
Whitehaven has said it will recommend shareholders vote against the resolutions. "We are not going to pre-empt the proceedings of the AGM," a Whitehaven spokesman said when asked for comment. "We will recommend shareholders not support resolutions requisitioned by shareholders representing 0.0016 per cent of the company’s shares on issue for the sole purpose of supporting Market Forces’ ongoing anti fossil fuels campaign."
It did not comment on Market Forces' research.
In the past two years, Market Forces has coordinated a series of shareholder resolutions pushing companies including QBE, Santos and Oil Search to disclose more about climate risks. None of the resolutions have been successful, but they have won the backing of some major investors, with the QBE resolution in May attracting more than 18 per cent support.
The step up in the number of such agenda items, from Market Forces and others, has met with frustration from some boards and the body representing investor relations professionals, partly due to the time and resources they say it takes for companies to deal with them. Companies targeted have urged shareholders not to vote for them.

Links

'The Damn Thing Melted': Climate Change Sparks Scramble For The Arctic

Fairfax - Nick Miller

On Monday, a Danish container ship - the Venta Maersk - set off from Busan in South Korea packed with Russian fish and Korean electronics.
On September 22 it will dock at Bremerhaven in Germany.


This animation outlines research into the behaviour of the Arctic sea ice and shows how the quantity of older and thicker ice has changed between 1984 and 2016. Vision courtesy: NASA Climate Change. 

The bit in between could change the world.
Thanks to climate change, the Venta was able to take a short cut over the top of the globe – the first container ship to do so – through the Bering Strait between Russia and Alaska, above the desolate Siberian coast, past worried polar bears, melting permafrost and huge new Chinese-funded gas fields, through Arctic waters that Russia wants to control, and down past Norway, where this week a group of academics, analysts and policymakers were fretting over what it all means.
They gathered in Tromso, Norway’s northernmost city, 350 kilometres above the Arctic Circle. It’s dark here for 48 days in winter, but this week Tromso was warmer than Sydney.
The experts were invited to Tromso by Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung, a German think tank whose board of directors includes both German Chancellor Angela Merkel and her widely-touted successor Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer.
The one-day seminar, titled "Changes in the Arctic Security Landscape", announced it was time to look at “current and future security challenges in the Arctic”.
A visitor walks past an inflatable model of a TOR-M2DT Arctic short-range air defence missile system at the Army 2018 expo in Kubinka, Russia. Photo: Bloomberg
“We are moving into a new Cold War,” one attendee said (the seminar was held under the Chatham House Rule, to encourage frankness, so speakers cannot be identified). “The Arctic is caught between East and West … and it is moving to the East.
“We’re in a different territory now.”
Some talked about the effects of climate change on the nuclear deterrent, others about the temptation of mineral riches in Greenland. Many rued the US retreat from international affairs. All were concerned about the Arctic’s role in climate change. They pondered if treaties and multilateral forums will be enough to keep the great powers reined in as this new playground opens up.
Outside, the sun struck blue sparks off Tromso’s harbour, and a French navy patrol boat set out to sea after a friendly visit in this increasingly tense part of the world.
It’s not just commercial shipping making moves in the Arctic. The rapidly thinning sea ice is making way for warships, as the world’s great powers look north and see untapped wealth and strategic opportunities - or threats.
An iceberg melts in Kulusuk, Greenland, near the Arctic Circle. Photo: AP
Russia is modernising its Northern Fleet, the biggest of the country's four fleets, which includes Russia’s only aircraft carrier. In June it held its biggest "alarm exercise" in a decade off the coast of Norway (which it neglected to warn about the operation), sending 36 naval vessels steaming out of the Barents Sea including a missile cruiser, anti-submarine ship and destroyer, The Barents Observer reported, firing cruise missiles, mines and torpedoes.
The nuclear and diesel-powered warships were joined by 20 aircraft and 150 rocket and artillery weapons systems deployed along the Kola Peninsula, in a demonstration of how Russia would react to a massive enemy attack.
Norwegian fighter jets scrambled to meet the opposition off their north-east coast. Shortly after, NATO warships sailed north in a manoeuvre the alliance claimed had “long been planned”. The US Navy’s Arctic strategy, released in 2014 and intended to last 16 years, was updated this year because “the damn thing melted”, as Navy Secretary Richard Spencer put it.
And there’s another player in the game – potentially the biggest of all. In July, China’s Vice-Admiral Shen Jinlong met his Russian counterparts in Murmansk, where they discussed “existing threats in the world’s oceans [and] possible practical forms of co-operation”, the Northern Fleet’s press release said.
The Chinese research vessel and icebreaker Xuelong (Snow Dragon) in the Antarctic in December 2016. Photo: CCTV screen grab
Almost exactly a year ago China’s only icebreaker, the Snow Dragon, spent the northern summer deep in the western Arctic, on an 83-day mission that visited waters off Norway and Canada. It travelled far north of the Northern Sea Route ploughed by the Venta, in a part of the world some experts predict will be routinely navigable within a few decades.
When the Snow Dragon first sailed over the top of Russia from the Pacific to the Atlantic in 2012, expedition leader Huigen Yang told Reuters “to our astonishment … the most part of the Northern Sea Route is open”. Ever since, China’s interest in the region has intensified. It now has plans for a second, nuclear-powered icebreaker, and China is funding research on how submarines can function under the Arctic ice.
“The Arctic has always reflected the wider world,” says Rasmus Gjedsso Bertelsen, professor of northern studies at the Arctic University of Norway in Tromso.
“But the wider world before was Western-dominated.”
He warns against the trap of "presentism" – assuming that modern times are unique and there are no lessons in history. And he is wary of "Arctic exceptionalism", the idea that somehow this region is a special zone of science, exploration and peace.
In fact the Arctic has been a commercial and military zone for centuries. Catholic Europe ate Arctic dry fish on Fridays, the Napoleonic wars played out in part here, and manoeuvres during the Crimean War were arguably why Russia sold Alaska to the US in 1867 rather than Britain/Canada, Bertelsen says.
Russia under President Vladimir Putin behaves more like a super power. Photo: AP
Our view of a pristine, peaceful Arctic springs from recent history: the brief post-Cold War period.
“You had this omnipotent, unipolar America, a bankrupt Russia, and China biding its time,” he says. “We should not confuse Russian behaviour at that time with a reform of the Russian mind. Now, because of rising oil prices and the rule of Vladimir Putin, you have a Russia which behaves in a way much more to be expected from a great power.
“And great powers don’t behave very well – or rather they only behave as well as others force them to do.”
The seminar saw strong debate over how much Russia is seeking to rule the Arctic rather than share its stewardship. Some pointed to Russia’s friendly role in promoting coastguard and rescue cooperation, and in scientific fields. Others said the Arctic is the key to nuclear deterrence - the flight path for bombers and inter-continental ballistic missiles and home to key missile defence systems – and that issue will determine whether the region ends in “complete co-operation or going to hell in a handbasket”.
Security concerns often mirror economic concerns. And as climate change alters the physical landscape, the economic landscape of the Arctic is changing just as fast.
“Look carefully at the Yamal project,” Bertelsen says. It’s an extraordinary new LNG project on Russia’s Arctic coast – a $US27 billion ($37 billion) plant, to be serviced by 15 new ice-class tankers on order from Korea worth another  $US5 billion, tapping an immense gas reserve the equivalent of 4 billion barrels of oil. A lot of this is financed by Chinese money, as sanctions against Russia forced it to look east for cash.
“China and the other Asian countries are looking especially to the Russian Arctic as a source of energy,” Bertelsen says. “In the West we think of gas as a fossil fuel to be phased out. But air pollution in China is very serious and their big problem is coal. It’s obvious they have to do something about that, and replacing coal with gas is the quick fix.”
An LNG tanker sits at anchor outside Hammerfest, northern Norway, last year. Photo: Bloomberg
The Arctic is incredibly rich in fossil fuels: an area the size of Africa holds more than a fifth of the world’s oil and natural gas reserves. About 80 per cent is gas, and thanks to a quirk of geology most of the gas is above Russia.
This has already led to territorial disputes, as Russia tries to stake its claim to a continental shelf stretching almost to the pole. Both the US and China want to minimise Russia’s "exclusive" zone.
And there is a vicious circle here – the climate change making it easier to get the gas down to Asia will be accelerated by the carbon emitted by that gas.
One of the big concerns at the seminar was how climate change concerns are ignored or at least compartmentalised in the Arctic. Russia has been slow to acknowledge the scientific consensus, the US has performed a sudden U-turn, and China argues that it should not suffer for the ecological sins of the developed world.
“You’d think [the US and Russia] are members of the Flat Earth Society,” one attendee complained. “And in the worsening geopolitical climate it’s much more difficult to achieve cooperative efforts.”
One successful multilateral agreement in the Arctic has been on ‘black carbon’ – the pollution put out by shipping that stains the ice and accelerates climate change, among other ill effects.



The Venta is running on “ultra-low sulphur” fuel, mandated in the far northern seas, to reduce its pollution potential.
And the very fact of a northern sea route is a plus for the climate, some argue. As travel times decrease so do carbon emissions. Using the Northern Sea Route (NSR) rather than the Suez Canal to get from Asia to Europe would reduce emissions by between half and three-quarters.
Already, shipping data shows sailing times on the NSR have fallen from 20 days in the 1990s to 11 days, mainly due to there being less sea ice. After the 2050s all types of vessels should be able to go straight over the pole, saving even more time. Unescorted navigation in the high Arctic may even be possible as early as the 2030s, though winters will still require icebreakers.
According to one forecast, by 2020 up to 15 per cent of China’s international trade will go through the NSR.
But Bertelsen warns not to get carried away.
He points out there’s a difference between "destination shipping" – the trucking of oil and gas down from the Arctic – and "transit shipping" of containers around the world.
“Container shipping is like a bus line,” he says. “It has stops along the way and very few passengers go from end to end. The old trunk line via the Malacca Strait, the Indian Ocean, the Suez Canal and the Mediterranean passes a lot of people, a lot of economic activity. But with the passage north of Russia - there’s nobody there.”
There are other practical problems. Dedicated satellites now track sea ice to send warnings down to ships in the Arctic, but significant Titanic-style risks remains and only Russia currently has a decent fleet of icebreakers. And the Bering Strait is not very deep, restricting the size of ship that can access the Arctic from Asia.
Maersk itself insisted it did “not see the Northern Sea Route as an alternative to our usual routes”, saying the Venta’s voyage was “a trial to explore an unknown route for container shipping and to collect scientific data”.
But when China is involved, there are always more than just commercial considerations.
In January Beijing staked its claim in clear terms, issuing its first White Paper on the Arctic.
The paper described China as a "near-Arctic state" and said countries south of the Arctic Circle had the right to engage in scientific research and navigation, resource extraction, fishing and the laying of cables and pipelines.
It was a clear marker, and a warning, that it intends to be a major player.
The paper discussed a “Polar Silk Road”, anticipating that China would make extensive use of the new shipping routes to Russia and northern Europe – as well as the North-West Passage into the Canadian Arctic, and even the polar route straight over the top.
Some point to Greenland as a destination China has in mind.
A 2007 US diplomatic cable published by WikiLeaks predicted “Greenland is on a clear track towards independence”, and as the Danish protectorate’s ice sheets melt, mineral riches are being exposed.
There is not just oil (but there is a lot of that – more than Alaska, perhaps) but also diamonds, rubies, uranium, zinc and rare earths, the minerals essential to the electronics boom that powered China’s renaissance.
Greenpeace activists prepare to scale an oil rig off the coast of Greenland. Photo: Greenpeace
And China is starting to open its pockets in Greenland, offering money to expand airports, to explore and exploit mineral deposits. It even tried to buy an abandoned US naval facility, only to be blocked at the last minute.
If Chinese money is the catalyst for Greenland’s independence, finally weaned off its big Danish subsidy, then gratitude could give China a lot of influence in the fledgling country.
But this could prove another Arctic flashpoint: the US Air Force base at Thule in Greenland plays a crucial role in missile defence.
Elisabeth Bauer, head of the Nordic Countries Project at Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung, has been interested in the Arctic for a decade, but her ears really pricked up in 2015 at a discussion on when the Arctic might be ice-free.
“That really causes a lot of challenges to the Arctic and I thought that might be really important for the future of the economy, of security, the future of East-West trade and so on,” she says.
“So I thought we have to do something on that topic.”
She’s cautious about making any bold predictions.
“At the moment you really can’t see what will happen in the future,” she says.
She points to this week's seminar, with some of the world’s most knowledgeable Arctic experts disagreeing on central issues.
“It shows we have to be careful to look at this. It is a struggle of interests on one end, and a struggle on principles and values on the other end. We don’t know at the moment who will be the winner.”

Links

200 Stars Urge 'Serious' Action On Climate Change In Letter To Le Monde

France 24

This illustration picture taken in Paris on August 20, 2018 shows a figurine of a worker with a jackhammer on an earth globe. Joël Saget, AFP
Two hundred of the world’s most prominent artists and scientists signed an open letter in French daily Le Monde on Monday calling for urgent political action to address the “global catastrophe” facing mankind and other species.
The letter, penned by actress Juliette Binoche and astrophycist Aurélien Barrau, called on politicians to act “firmly and immediately” in tackling climate change and the “collapse of biodiversity”, described as the “greatest challenge in the history of mankind”.
“It is time to get serious,” the signatories said. “The sixth mass extinction is taking place at unprecedented speed. But it is not too late to avert the worst.”
The letter said it was up to politicians to take all necessary measures, however unpopular they may be.
Binoche was joined by fellow French actresses Isabelle Adjani, Marion Cotillard and Catherine Deneuve as well as artist Anish Kapoor; actors Bradley Cooper, Willem Defoe, Ethan Hawke, Ralph Fiennes, Jude Law, Charlotte Rampling and John Tuturro; directors David Cronenberg and Wim Wenders; and many others.
Prominent scientists who signed on included astrophysicist Françoise Combes, climatologist Jean Jouzel, mathematician Mikhaïl Gromov and physicist Carlo Rovelli.
The letter comes as French President Emmanuel Macron is under pressure to do more to deliver on his green promises after his high-profile ecology minister, Nicolas Hulot, suddenly resigned, citing his disappointment with progress on the environment.
A popular figure, Hulot resigned live on-air during a radio interview last week, saying he felt "all alone" in the government on environmental issues and blasting lobbies and big business for hindering the fight against climate change.

Signatories
Isabelle Adjani, actrice; Laure Adler, journaliste; Pedro Almodovar, cinéaste; Laurie Anderson, artiste; Charles Aznavour, chanteur; Santiago Amigorena, écrivain; Pierre Arditi, acteur; Niels Arestrup, acteur; Ariane Ascaride, actrice; Olivier Assayas, cinéaste; Yvan Attal, acteur, cinéaste; Josiane Balasko, actrice; Aurélien Barrau, astrophysicien (Institut universitaire de France); Nathalie Baye, actrice; Emmanuelle Béart, actrice; Xavier Beauvois, cinéaste; Alain Benoit, physicien (Académie des sciences); Jane Birkin, chanteuse, actrice; Juliette Binoche, actrice; Benjamin Biolay, chanteur; Dominique Blanc, actrice; Gilles Boeuf, biologiste; Mathieu Boogaerts, chanteur; John Boorman, cinéaste; Romane Bohringer, actrice; Carole Bouquet, actrice; Stéphane Braunschweig, metteur en scène; Zabou Breitman, actrice, metteuse en scène; Nicolas Briançon, acteur, metteur en scène; Irina Brook, metteuse en scène; Valeria Bruni Tedeschi, actrice, cinéaste; Florence Burgat, philosophe; Gabriel Byrne, acteur; Cali, chanteur; Sophie Calle, artiste; Jane Campion, cinéaste; Isabelle Carré, actrice; Emmanuel Carrère, écrivain; Anne Carson, auteure et professeure; Michel Cassé, astrophysicien; Laetitia Casta, actrice; Bernard Castaing, physicien (Académie des sciences); Antoine de Caunes, journaliste, cinéaste; Alain Chamfort, chanteur; Boris Charmatz, chorégraphe; Christiane Chauviré, philosophe; Jeanne Cherhal, chanteuse; François Civil, acteur; Hélène Cixous, écrivaine; Isabel Coixet, cinéaste; Françoise Combes, astrophysicienne (Collège de France); François Cluzet, acteur; Gregory Colbert, photographe, cinéaste; Bradley Cooper, acteur; Brady Corbet, acteur; Béatrice Copper-Royer, psychologue; Marion Cotillard, actrice; Denis Couvet, écologue; Camille Cottin, actrice; Clotilde Courau, actrice; Franck Courchamp, écologue (Académie européenne des sciences); Nicole Croisille, chanteuse; David Cronenberg, cinéaste; Alfonso Cuaro, cinéaste; Willem Dafoe, acteur; Philippe Decouflé, chorégraphe; Sébastien Delage, musicien; Vincent Delerm, chanteur; Alain Delon, acteur; Catherine Deneuve, actrice; Claire Denis, cinéaste; Philippe Descola, anthropologue (Collège de France); Alexandre Desplat, compositeur; Manu Dibango, musicien; Hervé Dole, astrophysicien (Institut universitaire de France); Valérie Dréville, actrice; Diane Dufresne, chanteuse; Sandrine Dumas, actrice, metteuse en scène; Romain Duris, acteur; Lars Eidinger, acteur; Marianne Faithfull, chanteuse; Pierre Fayet, physicien (Académie des sciences); Ralph Fiennes, acteur; Frah (Shaka Ponk), chanteur; Cécile de France, actrice; Stéphane Freiss, acteur; Thierry Frémaux, directeur de festival; Jean-Michel Frodon, critique, professeur; Marie-Agnès Gillot, danseuse étoile; Pierre-Henri Gouyon, biologiste; Julien Grain, astrophysicien; Anouk Grinberg, actrice;Mikhaïl Gromov, mathématicien (Académie des sciences); Sylvie Guillem, danseuse étoile; Arthur H, chanteur; Ethan Hawke, acteur; Christopher Hampton, scénariste; Nora Hamzawi, actrice; Ivo Van Hove, metteur en scène; Isabelle Huppert, actrice; Agnès Jaoui, actrice, cinéaste; Michel Jonasz, chanteur; Camelia Jordana, chanteuse; Jean Jouzel, climatologue (Académie des sciences); Juliette, chanteuse; Anish Kapoor, sculpteur, peintre; Mathieu Kassovitz, acteur; Angélique Kidjo, chanteuse; Cédric Klapisch, cinéaste; Thierry Klifa, cinéaste; Panos H. Koutras, cinéaste; Lou de Laâge, actrice; Ludovic Lagarde, metteur en scène; Laurent Lafitte, acteur; Laurent Lamarca, chanteur; Maxence Laperouse, comédien; Camille Laurens, écrivaine; Bernard Lavilliers, chanteur; Sandra Lavorel, écologue (Académie des sciences); Jude Law, acteur; Patrice Leconte, cinéaste; Roland Lehoucq, astrophysicien; Gérard Lefort, journaliste; Nolwenn Leroy, chanteuse; Peter Lindbergh, photographe; Louane, chanteuse; Luce, chanteuse; Ibrahim Maalouf, musicien; Vincent Macaigne, metteur en scène, acteur; Benoît Magimel, acteur; Yvon Le Maho, écologue (Académie des sciences); Andreï Makine, écrivain de l’Académie Française; Abd al Malik, rappeur; Sophie Marceau, actrice; Virginie Maris, philosophe; André Markowicz, traducteur; Nicolas Martin, journaliste; Vincent Message, écrivain; Wajdi Mouawad, metteur en scène; Nana Mouskouri, chanteuse; Jean-Luc Nancy, philosophe; Arthur Nauzyciel, metteur en scène; Safy Nebbou, cinéaste; Pierre Niney, acteur; Helena Noguerra, chanteuse; Claude Nuridsany, cinéaste; Michael Ondaatje, écrivain; Thomas Ostermeier, metteur en scène; Clive Owen, acteur; Corine Pelluchon, philosophe; Laurent Pelly, metteur en scène; Raphaël Personnaz, acteur; Dominique Pitoiset, metteur en scène; Denis Podalydès, acteur; Pomme, chanteuse; Martin Provost, cinéaste; Olivier Py, metteur en scène; Susheela Raman, chanteuse; Charlotte Rampling, actrice; Raphaël, chanteur; Régine, chanteuse; Cécile Renault, astrophysicienne; Robin Renucci, acteur; Jean-Michel Ribes, metteur en scène; Tim Robbins, acteur; Muriel Robin, actrice; Isabella Rossellini, actrice; Brigitte Roüan, actrice, cinéaste; Carlo Rovelli, physicien (Institut universitaire de France); Eric Ruf, directeur de la Comédie-Française; Céline Sallette, actrice; Rodrigo Santoro, acteur; Marjane Satrapi, cinéaste; Kristin Scott Thomas, actrice; Albin de la Simone, musicien; Abderrahmane Sissako, cinéaste; Marianne Slot, productrice; Patti Smith, chanteuse, écrivaine; Sabrina Speich, géoscientifique; Marion Stalens, réalisatrice; Kristen Stewart, actrice; Tom Stoppard, dramaturge; Peter Suschitzky, chef opérateur; Malgorzata Szumowska, cinéaste; Béla Tarr, cinéaste; Gilles Taurand, scénariste; Alexandre Tharaud, musicien; James Thierrée, danseur, chorégraphe; Mélanie Thierry, actrice; Danièle Thompson, cinéaste; Melita Toscan du Plantier, attachée de presse; Jean-Louis Trintignant, acteur; John Turturro, acteur; Hélène Tysman, pianiste; Pierre Vanhove, physicien; Karin Viard, actrice; Polydoros Vogiatzis, acteur; Rufus Wainwright, chanteur; Régis Wargnier, cinéaste; Jacques Weber, acteur; Wim Wenders, cinéaste; Sonia Wieder-Atherton, musicienne; Bob Wilson, metteur en scène; Lambert Wilson, acteur; Jia Zhang-ke, cinéaste; Elsa Zylberstein, actrice

Links

Monday, September 03, 2018

Government Inaction Puts World On Track For 'Catastrophic' Climate Change, U.N. Warns

Newsweek - 

Firefighters battle flames near Yosemite National Park, California, U.S., on August 6, 2018. This year's extreme weather events are believed to be linked to global climate change. Courtesy USFS/Yosemite National Park/Handout via REUTERS 
A senior United Nations (U.N.) official has warned that government inaction has put the world on track to a catastrophic climate change situation, in which the global community fails to keep temperature rises below the vital 2 degree Celsius (3.6 degree Fahrenheit) cap.
The warning comes ahead of climate-change discussions in Bangkok, Thailand, this week. Patricia Espinosa, who is head of the Executive Secretary of the U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), said nations have been too slow to reach to the threats posed by global warming.
In an interview with Reuters on Sunday, Espinosa said this year’s extreme weather is just a taste of what is to come, and that she hopes the heat waves, floods and forest fires seen across the globe “will create a bigger sense of urgency.”



In 2015, the Paris climate deal agreed to limit global warming to “well below” 2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels. The pact also said signatories would continue “pursuing efforts” for the more challenging target of 1.5 degrees Celsius.
Espinosa explained, “1.5 is the goal that is needed for many islands and many countries that are particularly vulnerable to avoid catastrophic effects. In many cases it means the survival of those countries. With the pledges we have on the table now we are not on track to achieve those goals.”
The 2015 agreement, while a landmark achievement, was somewhat vague on the details of how such a cap would be achieved. Signatories will meet again in December in Poland to agree rules for how to achieve its the goal of ended the fossil fuel era this century.
Espinosa said she hopes the week-long talks in Bangkok will produce a draft text for negotiation on the deal’s rulebook. “This is a process that has been ongoing for some time. One of the reasons why this is so complex is because we are talking about... many different areas,” she explained. “One of those areas that countries need to take action on is to reduce their emissions.”
Both private and government financing is required, Espinosa said. While a pledge from rich nations to commit $100 billion each year is important, more will be needed. “There is a clear view that the $100 billion is only one part of the broad transformation of our societies that we are talking about,” she told Reuters.
The Paris agreement, signed by 195 countries and ratified by 180, faced opposition from the U.S. since President Donald Trump took office. In June 2017, Trump withdrew from the deal, claiming it would undermine the country’s economy and puts the U.S. at a “permanent disadvantage.”
Espinosa suggested such behavior demonstrates how some nations are not taking the threats of climate change seriously enough. But ignoring the problem does nothing to help. The vast majority of scientists and institutions agree that man-made global warming exists, and is getting worse.
This year, extreme weather events have been reported across the globe, and average temperatures have been significantly higher than previous years. “It really does make the evidence clear that climate change is having an impact on the daily lives of people,” Espinosa said.

Links

The Swedish 15-Year-Old Who's Cutting Class To Fight The Climate Crisis

The Guardian - 

Following Sweden’s hottest summer ever, Greta Thunberg decided to go on school strike at the parliament to get politicians to act
Greta Thunberg leads a school strike and sits outside of the Swedish Parliament, in an effort to force politicians to act on climate change. Photograph: Michael Campanella for the Guardian 
Why bother to learn anything in school if politicians won’t pay attention to the facts?
This simple realisation prompted Greta Thunberg, 15, to protest in the most effective way she knew. She is on strike, refusing to go to school until Sweden’s general election on 9 September to draw attention to the climate crisis.
Her protest has captured the imagination of a country that has been struck by heatwaves and wildfires in its hottest summer since records began 262 years ago.
Every day for two weeks, Thunberg has been sitting quietly on the cobblestones outside parliament in central Stockholm, handing out leaflets that declare: “I am doing this because you adults are shitting on my future.”
Thunberg herself is a diminutive girl with pigtails and a fleeting smile – not the stereotypical leader of a climate revolution.
“I am doing this because nobody else is doing anything. It is my moral responsibility to do what I can,” she says. “I want the politicians to prioritise the climate question, focus on the climate and treat it like a crisis.”
When people tell her she should be at school, she points to the textbooks in her satchel.
“I have my books here,” she says in flawless English. “But also I am thinking: what am I missing? What am I going to learn in school? Facts don’t matter any more, politicians aren’t listening to the scientists, so why should I learn?”
Thunberg’s protest might come as a surprise to anyone seduced by Sweden’s reputation as a climate pioneer and champion of the environment. This year the country enacted “the most ambitious climate law in the world”, aiming to become carbon neutral by 2045 and comfortably beating the 2015 Paris climate targets along the way.
“This is too little too late, it needs to come much faster,” Thunberg says. “Sweden is not a green paradise, it has one of the biggest carbon footprints.”
Her parents want her to give up her protest and go back to school. “My teachers are divided,” Thunberg says. “As people they think what I am doing is good, but as teachers they say I should stop.”
One teacher to have downed tools to join her protest is Benjamin Wagner, 26. He expects to lose three weeks’ wages – and his job – as a result of his strike.
“Our inability to stop climate change is like the efforts to stop world war one – we knew for years it was coming, they arranged all sorts of conferences, but still they didn’t prevent it,” Wagner says.
A forest fire burns near Sarna in central Sweden on July 26, 2018. Photograph: Maja Suslin/TT News Agency/AFP/Getty Images
“Greta is a troublemaker, she is not listening to adults. But we are heading full speed for a catastrophe, and in this situation the only reasonable thing is to be unreasonable.”
There are signs that more Swedes are listening. The Green party, a partner in the centre-left coalition government, was languishing in the polls before the country was hit by more than 60 forest fires, which raged for weeks through a rural tinderbox created by the unprecedented drought. Now the party’s support is up by half to about 6%.
“I am very impressed by Greta’s courage and determination,” says Janine Alm Ericson, a Green member of parliament.
“But I am also sad that she feels she has to be there – the political parties in Sweden have not done enough. Thanks to the hot summer it has become easier for people to imagine what climate change can mean for us and others in Europe if we continue to ignore what is happening.”
Outside parliament, Stella d’Ailly, 45, an art director, has come to join Thunberg’s protest.
“I feel like I am dying inside if I don’t protest,” she says. “Sweden may be well organised to recycle our trash, for example, but we do nothing to cut the amount of plastic bottles and packaging in the first place. We need drastic change.”
Thunberg’s own awakening to the climate crisis a few years ago caused upheaval in her family. Her mother, the well known opera singer Malena Ernman, has given up her international career because of the climate effects of aviation.
“Greta forced us to change our lives,” says her father Svante. “I didn’t have a clue about the climate. We started looking into it, reading all the books – she has read them too.”
Greta Thunberg and friends outside the Swedish parliament. Photograph: Michael Campanella for the Guardian
Her teachers were telling her to turn off the lights and save paper, then flying off to New York for a holiday. For Greta, this was just not good enough: “Everyone believes that we can solve the crisis without effort, without sacrifice,” she wrote in an article widely circulated on social media and translated into English.
While on strike, she has done a lot of homework and read three books, her father says.
“She is supposed to be in school, we cannot support her action. But we respect that she wants to make a stand. She can either sit at home and be really unhappy, or protest and be happy.”
Greta has Asperger’s syndrome, which in the past has affected her health, he says. She sees her condition not as a disability but as a gift which has helped open her eyes to the climate crisis.
“The best thing about my protest has been to see how more and more people have been coming and getting involved,” Greta says.
“I don’t care if I get into trouble at school. I believe that one person can make a difference.”

Links

We Cannot Fight Climate Change With Capitalism, Says Report

Huffington Post - Laura Paddison

The world's economies are totally unprepared for rapid climate change, rising social inequality and the end of cheap energy.
Flames roll over a hill toward homes near Lakeport, California, on Aug. 2. The effects of rapid climate change are being felt across the world. Fred Greaves/Reuters
As access to cheap, plentiful energy dries up and the effects of climate change take hold, we are entering a new era of profound challenge ― and free market capitalism cannot dig us out. This is the conclusion of a report produced for the United Nations by Bios, an independent research institute based in Finland.
Signs of a world in turmoil are not hard to find. People are increasingly feeling the effects of rapid climate change. Cities boil in more than 120-degree heat, California burns and the Arctic thaws. Meanwhile, biodiversity loss is reaching terrifying levels, with animals going extinct at about 1,000 times the natural rate. In addition, as societies, we’re facing increased inequality, unemployment and soaring personal debt levels.
The New York Stock Exchange in New York City. Traditional ways of economic thinking aren't sufficient to deal with the coming challenges we face, according to a new report. Andrew Kelly/Reuters
Faced with these interconnected crises, says the report, our economies are woefully underprepared: “It can be safely said that no widely applicable economic models have been developed specifically for the upcoming era.”
The paper, commissioned by the U.N. to feed into its 2019 Global Sustainable Development Report, looks specifically at the next 20 to 30 years as a key transition period during which the world must radically cut emissions and consumption to have a hope of stopping climate change.
Traditional ways of economic thinking have been based on the assumption we will continue to have access to cheap and plentiful sources of energy and materials, says the report, but the “era of cheap energy is coming to an end.”
The thrust of the authors’ argument is that, for the first time, economies are moving to sources of energy that are much less efficient ― meaning more and more effort is needed to get smaller amounts of energy. There are plenty of fossil fuels that can still be pulled from the ground but doing so would shoot through climate commitments and accelerate global warming. In addition, we have used up the planet’s capacity to handle the waste generated through all our material and energy use.
In other words, we are at an ecological crunch point and we don’t have the economic tools to deal with it.
“Trusting that the free market capitalist dynamics will get us there, that of course is not going to happen,” report co-author Paavo Järvensivu, an academic who specializes in economics and culture at Bios, says in a phone call with HuffPost. Economies that rely on the power of markets, notes the report, don’t even recognize the problem as they’re too focused on short-term profits to take account of longer-term issues like climate change and environmental destruction.
But Järvensivu is also keen not to fuel an argument about whether capitalism is dead.
“I think it’s harmful to think of capitalism as this one big lump, or capitalism as this kind of ‘either, or’ question: that we either have capitalism or something totally different,” Järvensivu says.
“The social and material need for this transformation [away from cheap energy and mass consumption] is so acute and societies have to go through a very dramatic shift over 20 to 30 years to get their emissions dramatically lower,” he adds, “so we are past this discussion of should we have capitalism or should we have something else.”
People commuting by bike in Copenhagen, Denmark. Some cities are already well set up for cleaner transportation options such as cycling. william87 via Getty Images
Instead, he says, we need to find new ways of thinking about the economy to meet these challenges. It’s asking the question, he says, “Do we aim for more consumption or do we aim for liveable environments in the future?”
Around 80 percent of global energy comes from fossil fuels ― oil, coal and gas, which powered industrialization but have a heavy toll through their climate change impact. While we need to wean ourselves off these, renewables are not efficient enough yet compared to conventional energy and the infrastructure is not in place for it, the report says. “Meeting current or growing levels of energy need in the next few decades with low-carbon solutions will be extremely difficult, if not impossible,” it notes.
What’s needed, says the report, is to combine developing clean energy sources with lowering energy use. And it has some suggestions about how to achieve this without compromising people’s opportunity for a decent life.
The report calls for an overhaul of transportation away from a focus on car ownership. In cities, this would mean changes in city planning to focus on biking and walking, combined with an electric public transit system. This “could be beneficial for people in a larger sense,” says Järvensivu, as it “means less transport, less owning private cars, but not necessarily a less good quality life.”
President Donald Trump at a political rally in Charleston, West Virginia, on Aug. 21. His administration announced a plan to weaken environmental regulations on coal plants. MANDEL NGAN via Getty Images
International freight transportation and aviation would need to be slashed, says the report, as they “cannot continue to grow at current rates” because of the need to cut emissions as well as the lack of low carbon alternatives.
Food systems also need to be rethought. Both rich and poor countries should focus on self-sufficiency, advises the report, to produce a diverse selection of food for their own populations. As for diets, it advocates that dairy and meat, which have a big climate impact, be replaced by largely plant-based diets.
Housing is the third area slated for transformation. Construction using steel and concrete is hugely carbon intensive. The report authors suggest moving to wooden structures, which could provide carbon storage.
All these changes require concerted political action. “There must be a comprehensive vision and closely coordinated plans. Otherwise a rapid system level transformation towards global sustainability goals is inconceivable,” says the report.
Which is all well and good, but doesn’t exactly jibe with what’s been happening on the political scene. President Donald Trump is hellbent on cutting environmental regulation and has withdrawn from the Paris climate agreement. Even the countries that remain in the agreement are failing on their commitments to curb climate change.
There has been interest in introducing a carbon price, which means charging polluters for the carbon they emit ― a key pledge Canada Prime Minister Justin Trudeau made in his campaign. But the report argues this measure is nowhere near good enough: “As a policy tool, carbon pricing lacks the crucial element of coordinating a diverse set of economic actors toward a common goal.”
Järvensivu believes the push for action will come from the fact that people are starting to genuinely worry about their future security and looking for collective action. “These kind of things might actually start to matter quite a bit more than caring about a new iPhone or a yearly trip to Thailand,” he says. “We are actually looking for a sense of security and not in a way that we would just aim for more consuming power in terms of money and so on.”
He cites Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) as an example of someone seeking transformational economic change, along with professor Stephanie Kelton, whose work argues sovereign governments cannot run out of money, thus debunking the argument that economies cannot afford to make the transformations needed to address climate change.
Järvensivu insists the report isn’t advocating for an economy that would be unrecognizable from what we have now, at least not in the short term. Rather, he says, it seeks to identify the material and energy crises approaching us and the kinds of economic tools and policies we need to meet them.
“After 20 to 30 years, we don’t know what this [economy] would look like, if we actually managed to achieve radically lower emissions and still secure possibilities for a good life ... are we then even concerned whether this was capitalism or not, or are we looking for other things,” he says. “Probably we are.”

Links

Sunday, September 02, 2018

This Government Is Not Even Pretending To Act On Climate Change Any More

The Guardian - *

We have gone from at least trying to look like aiming to reduce emissions to apparently deciding to do nothing
Prime Minister Scott Morrison (right) and energy minister Angus Taylor at Government House in Canberra. Photograph: Lukas Coch/AAP 
With the appointment of Angus Taylor as minister for energy, Scott Morrison has clearly signalled that he has no care about reducing greenhouse gas emissions. So utterly bereft of reason on the issue and so completely consumed by climate change denial the government is now at the point where even the pretence of doing something to reduce emissions is viewed with distrust.
Perhaps somewhat surprisingly I have a degree of sympathy for members of the public who are climate change deniers. I have this sympathy because I was once one of them.
I don’t mean I was a climate change denier in the sense of believing it all was some gigantic hoax perpetrated by the deep state and the UN. I mean denying in the sense of doing my level best to deny it was happening.
Because it scared the bejeezus out of me.
In the late 1980s and early 1990s when I was finishing high school and studying at university I was of course well aware of climate change. As a politically engaged, super-serious youth who listened to Midnight Oil and U2 and read every newspaper and news magazine I could afford, I was across all the news about the impacts of greenhouse gas emissions.
And it didn’t sound good.
So subconsciously I wanted to ignore it. I would read articles spelling out the dire future ahead and would spend the rest of the day in a depressed funk, because the problem with facing up to the reality of climate change is to face up to the fact that your life thus far has played a role. Your preference for driving a car, the aerosol sprays you used, the food you consumed, or heck, the generation of the electricity you depend upon had all contributed to producing greenhouse gases.
It is real, it is happening, it is getting worse and we need to act
It brought with it a level of guilt my 18-year-old self could do without, and even worse, a fear of having to change my lifestyle that I didn’t want to face.
And so I would hold on to anything that would suggest it was not so bad. I would cling to those who suggested that each individual couldn’t really make much of a difference (so I can keep those lights switched on). I would inwardly cheer when a friend would (wrongly) suggest he’d read that it was all due to natural factors and things would balance out; or when another would (wrongly) say he’d heard that ironically the hole in the ozone layer apparently cancelled out the impact of global warming, or yet another who would (also wrongly) assert that the changes would in reality be so small that we wouldn’t notice it.
And if all else failed I just sighed and thought, well, the impact was likely to happen only by around 2050 or so, and in 1990 to an 18-year-old that meant there was ample time and opportunity for something to get done. Surely a fix would occur – we always end up finding a fix.
And yet ... and yet. I knew I was burying my head in the sand. I was not so much denying the science as wanting to deny reality. The more I read the less able I was to do so. But even now I still get a faint glimmer of hope when I read some dumb article suggesting some research has found evidence that it’s all fine.
Because I don’t want climate change to be a real thing. I would love it to all be a hoax.
But it is not.
And so I understand why people choose to believe those who say climate change is not the issue, that the issue is power prices and thus we need to fire up the coal furnaces.
Denial is a very easy way out of guilt that your lifestyle is leaving your children and grandchildren an awful legacy. Denial is a good way to throw away concerns that you might have to actually wear a cost – either through lifestyle changes or monetary loss.
It is a scary thing to hear talk of the impacts of climate change and the suggestions that it might be too late to do anything. It is so much easier to live in denial, especially when you have charlatans in the media and politics who have seen this fear and have sought to profit from it.
So I have some sympathy for those who feel overwhelmed by it all.
But I have none for those in the media and politics who seek to profit from this fear.
There is no excuse for those trying to lull people into believing it is all a great scam, that there is nothing to worry about, or no need for concern, or that little can or should be done.
According to NASA, of the 1,663 months since January 1880, the top 100 for temperature anomaly have all occurred since 1990, and every month since December 2014 is in the top 100.
2018 is on track to be the third-hottest year behind 2016 and 2017; fourth is 2015.
It is real, it is happening, it is getting worse and we need to act.
And yet this week Taylor gave a speech that made zero mention of wind power – the main renewable energy in Australia – and in which he declared he wasn’t sceptical of climate change, just of subsidies for renewable energy, the Gillard government’s emissions trading scheme and of “excessive renewable energy targets.” This is despite that fact that renewable energy not only reduces our emissions, it also provides cheaper electricity.
It’s a bit like the health minister saying she is not an anti-vaxxer, she is just sceptical of the merits of the National Immunisation Program.
But don’t worry, it’s unlikely the Morrison government will withdraw from the Paris agreement, because, why bother? It just won’t do anything to actually ensure our emissions targets are achieved. Rather than risk offending those lunatics in his party who would rather destroy a prime ministership than have a policy with even a slight reference to reducing greenhouse gas emissions, Morrison appears to have decided to do nothing.
The costs of responding to climate change increase, the longer it is put off by those whose wilful ignorance sees them continue to proffer policy based on the premise that climate change is fake.
We have gone from a government under Malcolm Turnbull that at least tried to look like it was aiming to reduce emissions (even if it wasn’t) to one under Scott Morrison that is making no pretence about the fact it is beholden to the charlatans in the party who want to scam votes by lying about the facts of climate change.
And a political party that refuses to act on climate change is not fit to govern.

*Greg Jericho is a Guardian Australia columnist

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative