Friday, October 12, 2018

Vietnam's Children And The Fear Of Climate Change

BBC - David Shukman*

The threat of climate change exercises the minds of even the youngest in Vietnam
Can Tho Province, Vietnam
One little girl draws a nightmarish picture of people calling for rescue as they drown in rising water.
Another sketches a huge snake with sharp teeth to show the power and danger of flooding.
These disturbing images are the work of children at a primary school in Can Tho province, a region of Vietnam that is regularly swamped.
They live in the Mekong Delta, a huge plain of rivers and rice-fields that's popular with tourists but lies only just above the surface of the ocean.
The land itself is sinking and, at the same time, the level of the sea is rising, as global warming causes the water to expand and the ice caps to melt.
That's why the delta, one of the world's greatest centres for rice production and home to 18 million people, is recognised as especially vulnerable to the effects of climate change.
Florence Halstead wants to find out more about young people's attitudes to global warming


Prof Dan Parsons: "Silt and sands delivered from upstream offset relative sea-level rise"

The children were asked to draw their pictures as part of a project run by Florence Halstead from the University of Hull, a researcher into young people's attitudes on global warming.
At a primary school, which was itself flooded three years ago, she asked the pupils to close their eyes and think about flooding and then to describe what was on their minds.
Loi, a 10-year-old, leapt to his feet and came out with a shocking image - "people on their houses screaming for help".
His classmate, To Nhu, used crayons to depict a small girl drifting on her own in a boat towards what looked like a whirlpool or tornado.
"I think the flood is so scary," she told me, "and I hope that we will not be swept away in the flood season."
At a neighbouring desk, another pupil, Chau, created a scene that seemed far too horrific for someone so young: bodies were in the water and, below the surface, lurked a monstrous snake. I asked her why.
"Because the snake can live under the water and is very scary so it makes me think about the flood," she said.
The Mekong Delta southeast of Ho Chi Minh City. Copernicus Data 2018/Sentinel-2
Flooding is routine in the delta. Over the centuries, it has played a beneficial role delivering nutrient-rich silt to the fields to make them exceptionally fertile.
But, in recent years, the floods have become more damaging; the projections are for more severe and frequent inundations to come.
Regular flooding was part of the story of why these soils became so productive
Barriers are being built, but on one stretch of coastline more than 100 homes have been lost, along with big areas of precious farmland.
A farmer who saw fields vanish beneath the waves, Lam Van Nghia, said the water level was rising so fast that "there wasn't enough time to build sea defences".

Rice volumes reduced
Getty Images
To add to the stress, seawater pushing inland poisons the soil with salt, either reducing yields of rice or making it impossible to grow this vital part of the food supply.
Many farmers are turning to other crops like hay, which is more tolerant of salt, or shrimp which can cope with more of it, all of which reduces the volume of rice produced.
A leading farming expert even warned that the days of rice may be over for the Mekong Delta, with huge implications for food security and national income.
Thomas Rath, Vietnam director of the UN's International Fund for Agricultural Development, told the BBC that "this is all under threat".
"Rice production is under threat and 80% of the rice is for exports, so it's a big economic risk for Vietnam," he told the BBC.
This is why Vietnam, along with several dozen other developing countries, argues that the main target of the Paris Agreement on climate change - to limit the rise in global average temperature to 2C above the pre-industrial level - does not go far enough. It is pressing for a lower target of 1.5C.
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the UN's climate body, is releasing a report on the benefits of keeping global warming in check and on what is needed to achieve it.

Measuring the sediment
To try to understand how rapidly the region is changing, UK and Vietnamese scientists are studying the flows of the rivers and of the sediment they carry.
When silt is deposited on the fields, it raises the level of the land, the one thing that helps to build it up and counteract the effect of a rising sea.


David Shukman looks into how worried we should be about melting polar caps

I met Prof Dan Parsons, of the University of Hull, on a boat carrying sonar equipment to measure the river bed and the quantity of sediment in the water.
Measurements over the past 20 years have shown a marked drop in the amount of sediment being delivered - the water looks clearer than in the past - and this is the result of dams upstream trapping everything in the flow.
"One clear risk is a heightened threat of flooding," Prof Parsons said. "The saline intrusion that's driven by that relative rise in sea level combines to create a perfect storm of issues for people living here."
While he and his colleagues are investigating the physical changes under way, his student, Florence Halstead, is exploring the social implications, particularly for a generation that will grow up having to face more threatening conditions.
She described some of the children's pictures as "harrowing" but said it was important to prepare them for what lies ahead.
"They live in a water world, and that's only going to increase - the water's not going to go away and they need to learn how to adapt."
A flood in Can Tho City. Damaging floods along the delta are increasing

*David Shukman is BBC Science Editor.


Links

Bangladesh Kids Turn The Tide On Climate Change Aboard Floating Schools

AFP

Bangladeshi students at a floating school operated by the Shidhulai Swanirvar Sangstha (SSS) charity in Chalan Beel -- one of a range of initiatives to adapt to the challenges brought on by climate change. AFP / Munir UZ ZAMAN
CHALAN BEEL, BANGLADESH - Mosammat Rekha's older cousins grew up unable to read and write, their tiny village so frequently cut off from the nearest school by floods that would rise suddenly in their remote corner of disaster-prone Bangladesh.
But seven-year-old Mosammat is learning her ABCs aboard a boat fitted with a classroom and play equipment that is helping children thrive even as climate change alters the world around them.
"We can attend classes even during the rainy season, when our homes are barely above water," the seven-year-old told AFP aboard the vessel in Chalan Beel, some 175 kilometres (around 110 miles) northwest of Dhaka.
Climate change is already taking its toll across Bangladesh, a densely populated and impoverished country the United Nations has identified as among the most vulnerable to a warming planet.
Millions in the low-lying nation are being forced to adapt to overflowing rivers, rising seas and increasingly extreme weather in a country frequented by destructive storms and cyclones.
In Chalan Beel, more than 20 floating schools chug along rivers and lakes swollen by floods, bringing education to students long denied a chance to learn in one of Bangladesh's poorest locations. AFP / Munir UZ ZAMAN
Twenty million people there could be made "climate refugees" by the end of the century, a UN panel has warned, turfed out of their homes as rivers swallow towns and seas encroach on coastal communities.
In villages like Kalidaskhali on the banks of the Padma River, these forces are already reshaping lives by the hour.
As much as five metres (16 feet) of riverbank can disappear in a single day, consuming everything in its path, local government official Azizul Azam told AFP.
More than 9,000 people have been displaced by the Padma in just five years, as the main tributary of the Ganges encroaches further and further inland.
"Today my backyard is gone. I had a cowshed over there... now it is just water," said Rukaiya Khatun, watching helplessly as chunks of earth disappeared into the turbid water inching towards her home.
"The Padma has devoured everything."
More than 9,000 people have been displaced by the Padma river in just five years, as the main tributary of the Ganges encroaches further and further inland. AFP / Munir UZ ZAMAN

River erosion -- though long a phenomenon in the delta nation -- is rapidly accelerating due to climate change, said Atiq Rahman, a member of a Nobel Peace Prize-winning UN climate panel.
A warming planet has made monsoon rainfall more unpredictable across Bangladesh and melted Himalayan glaciers to the north, turbocharging the waterways that criss-cross the country.
Many have struggled to adapt as the river has turned, in the words of one villager, "wild and furious".
- Full steam ahead -
But elsewhere, local ingenuity is finding ways around the turbulent and unpredictable forces of nature.
River erosion -- though long a phenomenon in the delta nation -- is rapidly accelerating due to climate change, experts say. AFP / Munir UZ ZAMAN
Students at BRAC University in Dhaka last month unveiled a model for a floating bamboo home, one that could survive a flood or be easily relocated elsewhere in case of inundation.
In Chalan Beel, floating schools chug along rivers and lakes swollen by floods, bringing education to students long denied a chance to learn in one of Bangladesh's poorest locations.
"Now, they have year-round education," said Mohammad Rezwan, head of the Shidhulai Swanirvar Sangstha charity that runs the pioneering project.
Today they run more than 20 "floating schools" in the Chalan Beel area. Other charities have replicated the idea in different parts of Bangladesh, where the world's largest river delta empties into the Bay of Bengal.
The more elaborate floating schools are twin-storey designs boasting slides, monkey bars and swing sets for playtime, while banks of solar panels atop the boats power the school’s laptop computers. AFP / Munir UZ ZAMAN
Smaller models are equipped with desks, libraries and blackboards while more elaborate, twin-storey designs also boast slippery slides, monkey bars and swing sets for playtime.
Children even learn to use laptop computers, all powered by banks of solar panels atop the boats.
At night, once school is over, adults come aboard to learn new techniques for farming in an extreme climate.
A man walks through the remains of a home next to the eroding banks of the Padma river in Bangladesh's Rajshahi district. AFP / Munir UZ ZAMAN
Rezwan said farmers were being taught how to plant flood-resistant crops in floating seed beds, a possible lifeline for rural communities who can lose a year's harvest when the waters suddenly rise.
Bangladesh has invested more than $400 million into a new special agency for adaptation projects, including flood embankments, floating farm technology and mobile water-purification stations.
"It shows how seriously we are taking this," said Mukhlesur Rahman Sarker, deputy chief of the government's Bangladesh Climate Change Trust, of the new fund.
Simple local innovations have changed lives in a generation in Chalan Beel.
Mosammat Jharna, a mother of two, spent her youth hemmed in on all sides by water as unpredictable storm surges and fast-rising floods made walking to the nearest school impossible.
She now beams at the floating school anchored near her home -- a symbol of hope for her children, no matter how the landscape changes in the future.
"My dream of educating my children, including my daughter, has come true," she told AFP. "I don't want to see them end up illiterate like me."

Links

Climate Change Leading To 'Solastalgia', The Feeling You Get When Your Home Is Wrecked

ABC - Richard Yin*

Solastagia is what happens when you remain within the same locality, but that sense of "home", that sense of place, is lost through the destruction of the landscape. (Supplied: Rachael Webster)
Place is important to all of us. It speaks to our identity, our community, our mortality and our destiny argues, social researcher and author Hugh Mackay.
American writer Rebecca Solnit describes it as "the sixth sense, an internal compass and map, made by memory and spatial perception, together".
In 2004, in response to the changing landscape of the Upper Hunter Valley from open-cut coal mining, power station pollution and prolonged drought, Glenn Albrecht, an ecological philosopher and professor of sustainability at Murdoch University, went on to describe an unrecognised form of psychological distress in residents that he called solastalgia.
The word has its origins in the word "nostalgia" and is defined as "the distress that is produced by environmental change impacting on people while they are directly connected to their home environment".
While in nostalgia that pain relates to leaving one's home, in a sense solastagia is what happens when you remain within the same locality, but that sense of "home", that sense of place, is lost through the destruction of the landscape; "it is the homesickness you have when you are still at home".
Symptoms included feelings of grief, trauma, nostalgia, alienation, depression, anxiety and loss.
While we tend to focus on the tangible losses of weather events, the intangible impacts — the psychological distress and grief underlying the loss of sense of place — can be profound and long-term. (ABC Open contributor Rod Evans)
The word has also entered the public arena with the likes of Australian pop artist Missy Higgins, using it to name her recent new album.
Since the early writings of Dr Albrecht, we have had an increasing number of publications that speak to the psychological impacts of a rapidly changing world.
As Dr Albrecht wrote in 2012, the built and natural environments are now changing so rapidly that our language and conceptual frameworks have to work overtime just to keep up. Some of these regional impacts relate to war, terrorism, gas fracking, mining, agribusiness.
But of particular concern are the interwoven impacts of globalisation, population growth and climate change with the disruption to climatic and ecological systems. As the earth warms, so more frequently are local environments destroyed through extreme weather events.

What happens when we lose our inner compass
Despair is one side of the coin, but the other is the acknowledgement of the value and strength to be had when we connect to place and community. (ABC News: Alison Branley)
So what happens when that sense of place is lost or destroyed, when we lose our compass and map?
While we tend to focus on the tangible losses, the intangible impacts from floods, wildfires and droughts due to psychological distress and the grief underlying the loss of sense of place can be profound and often long-term.
Research in the Latrobe Valley following the Black Saturday fires highlight the complexity of emotions in the context of acute loss. Following the fire and escaping from temporary accommodation and rebuilding a new home, one resident aged in his 40s writes:

"But it's sterile, it's still sterile now. The worst thing about — I don't know, everyday it's a different worse thing, but one of the most difficult things about losing everything in a fire, and I guess people lose to house fires all the time, but it totally changed everything about our place, not just the inside, not just the house, not just our stuff, but all our history. Basically it just wiped us, for the last 14 years, off the planet."

But some impacts such as those in relation to drought or greater climatic uncertainty, are more akin to chronic stressors, a natural disaster occurring over a longer time. Recent research findings within the wheatbelt community of Newdegate south-east of Perth, reveal that changes in climatic patterns have compounded farmers' worries about the weather, undermined notions of identity, and contributed to cumulative and ongoing forms of place-based distress. And accompanying this has been a heightened perceived risk of depression and suicide.

'All farmers are good farmers'
Not surprisingly the study has highlighted the intimacy of relationship between ecosystem health and human health.


Drought relief evaporates

Participants' anxieties over the weather were linked to the health of their land. For example, chronically dry conditions can exacerbate the risk of wind erosion (lifting or blowing soil). Wind erosion was perceived emotively by the participants, with many describing it as "horrible", "terrible", "heart-wrenching" and "depressing".
A farmer, who also worked as a nurse at the local hospital, provided an example of the distress caused by wind erosion.

"Years ago we had a really bad dust storm. Had a guy come in for an X-ray at the hospital and he was stressed out of his mind — and it was just the wind, it really bothered him. Farmers just hate seeing their farm lift; it somehow says to them, 'I'm a bad farmer'. And I think all farmers are good farmers. They all try their hardest to be. They all love their land.''

Identity linked to knowledge of the land
For those with a close relationship to the land, their identity is linked to not only its physical features but uses and knowledge of it. The loss of local knowledge, or traditional ecological knowledge, may be a key trigger for ecological grief.
Some Australian farming groups have reported having lost confidence in the seasonal rhythms of the weather and in their ability to know it. Often the loss of confidence is associated with anxieties about their long-term future.
Prolonged drought can adversely affect Aboriginal communities whose identity is intimately linked to their connection and caring of the land.
Aboriginal participants in a study on how prolonged drought in rural NSW had affected their social and emotional wellbeing reported concern that traditional men's roles were threatened by drought-related loss of habitat and wildlife and its impact on seasonal work. This compounded existing socio-economic disadvantages and existing vulnerabilities.
Children represent a uniquely vulnerable group and currently those under the age of five carry 88 per cent of the burden of disease from climate change impacts. (ABC North West Queensland: Harriet Tatham)
Children carry burden of climate change
More recently there has been a focus on the mental health impacts of climate change on children.
Children represent a uniquely vulnerable group and currently those under the age of five carry 88 per cent of the burden of disease from climate change impacts.
Direct psychological impacts caused primarily through extreme weather events are easy to appreciate and can be understood to potentially predispose to adverse future adult mental health outcomes.
But there is a growing body of research for an indirect mental health impact, showing that older children and youths in both developing and developed countries have a higher level of interest and concern about climate change than adults.
Surveys show that many young people express worry, fear and anxiety about its impact on future lives and believe that the world may end in their lifetime because of climate change and other global threats.
Meaning-focussed psychological interventions were cited as being important in promoting wellbeing and environmental engagement.

Our one home is under threat
In 2017, the American Psychological Association published a report, Mental Health and our Changing Climate: impacts, implications and guidance, that sought to draw attention to the diverse psychological impacts of climate change. Furthermore, the report provided recommendations to support individual and community resilience.


A conversation for another day

In the context of climate change, most work around adaptation has focussed on technological solutions and infrastructural solutions, but there requires an acknowledgement of the psychological impacts and a focus also on the "adaptive capacity" of individuals and communities and how this may be supported.
How do we put a value on the land, ecosystems and species as objects that contribute to mental health and wellbeing, community flourishing, and culture?
For Dr Albrecht, while acknowledging the negative impacts of environmental transformation within local and regional communities, his greater concern was for the bigger picture, this one Earth, our one home, under threat by an increasingly hostile climate due to man-made climate change.
For him, the despair was one side of the coin, the other was the acknowledgement of the value and strength to be had when we connected to place and community.
From the strength founded on this sense of place was our capacity to move beyond despair and to respond with head and heart to the destruction happening around us.

*Dr Richard Yin is a Perth GP and a member of Doctors for the Environment Australia.

Links

Thursday, October 11, 2018

The Economic Case For Climate Action Is Strong

Sydney Morning Herald - Editorial

If you do not trust the International Panel on Climate Change you should probably not trust the Nobel Prize for economics.
Yale economist William Nordhaus has just won the highest honour in his profession partly for his work on the economics of climate change.
His modelling calculated the costs of investing to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and then compared them to the social and economic costs of doing nothing and just allowing temperatures to rise. The bottom line was that investment in emissions reduction was a lot better value.
By coincidence, Professor Nordhaus' work provided the economic foundation for the International Panel on Climate Change report also released on Monday which urged the world to take more "rapid and far reaching" measures to cut emissions.
The IPCC report found that it still worth taking the fairly drastic action required to limit the increase in global temperatures to a rise of 1.5 degrees by 2050 as a result of global warming as compared to going slow and allowing for a bigger rise in temperature.
“Limiting global warming to 1.5°C compared with 2°C would reduce challenging impacts on
ecosystems, human health and wellbeing," the IPCC report found.
The obvious big cost for Australia is that if the rise in global temperatures can be kept to below 1.5 degrees as much as a third of the Great Barrier Reef could still be alive in 2100 but if it rises by 2 degrees the reef will die.
So when Prime Minister Scott Morrison claims to be arguing from a  hard-headed economics perspective in dismissing the IPCC, the Nobel committee respectfully disagrees.
Yale University Professor William Nordhaus. Credit: AP
Mr Morrison's response to the IPCC report confirms that the next election will pose one of the clearest choices on climate change policy in over a decade.
This will be the first election since 2004 where one of the major parties  will campaign without even the skimpiest fig leaf of a policy on climate change.
Mr Morrison has responded by repeating his nonsense claim that Australia will meet targets for cutting emissions under the Paris treaty "at a canter" despite data from his own Ministry of Environment that emissions are rising and not falling as the government has promised.
While he is wary of the science, Mr Morrison appears to believe in magic. It is unclear why he thinks emissions would fall without any policy to do so. The government has ditched the National Energy Guarantee, its only emissions control policy.
The ALP's policy is for cuts in emissions which are at least in the ball park for the rapid and far-reaching target advocated by the IPCC. If they were serious, they would follow Professor Nordhaus' prescription of putting a price on carbon.
Government ministers responded to the IPCC by deploying the straw-man argument that Australia cannot survive without coal. True. It is is impossible to do it tomorrow. But that choice is false. Australia's old coal-fired electricity generators will inevitably give up the ghost over the next few decades. The issue is how fast they drop out of operation and what they are replaced with. With a time horizon of a couple of decades drastically reducing coal emissions is very possible.
Unfortunately, because Australia and the world have been slow to act, greenhouse gases have built up and it has become more expensive to stop global temperature rising at a dangerous pace. But the costs of doing nothing are ever more onerous. The smartest economist in the world says so.

Links

Can We Quit Coal In Time? IPCC Warns World Has Just 12 Years To Avoid Climate Change Catastrophe

ABC - Angela Lavoipierre | Stephen Smiley

China hopes coal-fired power plants will become a thing of the past. (ABC News: Brant Cumming)

The IPCC issued its bleakest report yet this week, saying that without drastic changes, the world doesn't have a hope of avoiding uncontrollable climate change.
Unless emissions are halved within 12 years and virtually eliminated by 2050, temperature increases will likely exceed 2 degrees Celsius.
Beyond 2 degrees, scientists predict temperature increases may spiral as the climate breaches a series of unique tipping points, such as the melting of the permafrost.
The top culprit is fossil fuels, and the instructions to Australia and the rest of the world are clear: Quit coal by 2050.
Specifically, the report's authors say that coal usage needs to drop to between 0 and 2 per cent of existing levels.
At the moment, the countries responsible for the bulk of the world's emissions are scaling down their reliance on coal, but developing countries in South-East Asia are moving in the exact opposite direction, even going so far as to build new coal-fired power plants with the help of foreign finance.
If they're all built, Australian coal is likely to be used to keep those generators running for decades into the future.
So with all that in mind, is it possible for the world to quit coal in time?

Australia's coal habit
Much has been written about Australia's love affair with coal.
The bulk of Australia's coal is mined in Victoria, New South Wales and Queensland, with the most polluting coal — also known as brown coal — coming predominantly from Victoria.
Australia has more than 21 coal-fired power stations in operation, and still relies heavily on coal for electricity.
There are no new coal-fired power stations currently being built in Australia, but Energy Market Analyst Tim Buckley has told The Signal 80 per cent of Australia's coal is exported.
He said he believes "it's entirely possible, [but] it's entirely improbable" that Australia will manage to wean itself off coal by 2050, if the current policy settings remain.
The Government's own figures, released two weeks ago, reveal Australia's emissions are currently rising.
But Prime Minister Scott Morrison says he's confident Australia will meet its 2030 Paris targets to cut emissions 26-28 per cent on 2005 levels.
While there are no new coal-fired power stations being built in Australia, 80 per cent of Australia's coal is exported to other countries. (Supplied: Clean Energy for Eternity)
Who's quitting coal

New coal power is not the answer
The tipping point's been reached: the cold, hard numbers show that new renewable energy is supplying cheaper electricity than new coal-fired power plants could and will continue do so, writes Stephen Long.

In responding to the IPCC report, Scott Morrison has been quick to point out that Australia's emissions are only a fraction of the world's overall carbon output, coming in between 1 and 2 per cent.
By contrast, the US, China, Japan, and India are the world's biggest emitters.
Tim Buckley said Japan has been slow to act, but has had a recent change of heart.
"Japan is definitely pivoting. They've gone from being a world laggard — Japan is going in the other direction".
China and India on the other hand, have been investing heavily in renewables.
"What happens in China drives the world when it comes to coal.
"China is half the world's coal production, half the world's coal consumption — it's the biggest importer of coal, and for the last five years the chinese central leadership has been on an absolute mission to decarbonise their economy".
"India is really exciting. Prime Minister [Narendra] Modi was elected on a solar platform.
"They are saying that 40 per cent of their electricity generation capacity by 2027 will be renewable energy, up from maybe 10 per cent three years ago, so it's just a huge transformation."
US President Donald Trump has expressed enthusiasm for coal, and long threatened to pull America out of the Paris Climate Agreement.
But Tim Buckley said the transformation set in motion during the Obama years was significant.
"Coal went from being 50 per cent of US electricity system a decade ago, but it hit a record low last year of 30 per cent and it's gone even lower this year".
Of Australia's reliance on coal as an export, he said: "We can turn the ship around. Our biggest customers are turning the ship around."

Which countries are doubling down
Not every country is bailing out of coal.
In fact, Australian coal miners are likely to have markets in the region for decades to come.
"South-East Asia is still on a coal-fired power station expansion program, that's really the last bastion of growth".
Tim Buckley says the rest of the world's cuts won't be enough to compensate for further increases in coal use in South-East Asia. (Supplied: Rio Tinto)
Vietnam, Thailand, Indonesia and the Philippines are all planning to build new power plants.
Tim Buckley said if all those plans come to pass, the rest of the world's cuts won't be enough to compensate for that increase.
"Therefore we have to assume that the world is going to go off the climate cliff.
"We are going to have a climate catastrophe if Asia continues to get foreign subsidies finance to build these coal plants, because once you build a coal plant, you're locking in 45 years of coal burning.
"So if Asia goes and replicates the same sort of industrialisation that Australia, America, Europe and China have all done, we all go off the cliff".

How to get coal under control
Tim Buckley said each of those power plants will cost $2-$3 billion dollars to build, and require government subsidies.
He says the capital subsidies supporting those planned projects are coming primarily from Japan, South Korea and China.
He's hopeful that finance will fall through.
"If South Korea and Japan stop providing those subsidies, China is now the last man standing.
"If China moves, and pulls the subsidies, there is no way new coal plants will be built in South-East Asia, they will pivot to renewables."
Links

Australia Doesn’t Care To Break Its Coal Habit In The Face Of Climate Change

Ars Technica - 

US not the only nation with a complicated relationship with coal.
Coking coal.
Luke Sharrett/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Earlier this week, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) issued a dire warning about climate change: unless governments of the world coordinate to implement multiple long-term changes, we risk overshooting the 2°C warming scenario that countries strived to target in the Paris Agreement. This would lead to ecosystem damage, increasingly dramatic heat waves and previously-irregular weather patterns in different regions, and subsequent health impacts for humans.
Retiring coal-fired power plants is a significant action that could limit our race toward an unstable future. But Australia's officials don't quite care. According to The Guardian, the country's deputy prime minister, Michael McCormack, said that Australia would "'absolutely' continue to use and exploit its coal reserves, despite the IPCC's dire warnings the world has just 12 years to avoid climate-change catastrophe."
McCormack also reportedly said that Australia would not change its coal policies "just because somebody might suggest that some sort of report is the way we need to follow and everything that we should do."
The country's previous prime minister, Malcolm Turnbull, abandoned emissions reductions targets that the nation had agreed to, and Australia's renewable energy targets are set to expire in 2020. In September, government analysis showed that Australia's greenhouse-gas emissions increased last year, and independent analysts said the country would likely not meet the greenhouse-gas emissions reductions that it committed to under the Paris Agreement. Unlike the US, Australia has not exited the Paris Agreement, but the country's current prime minister has declined to add any more money to the global climate fund.
McCormack said on Monday that coal provides 60 percent of Australia's electricity and coal mining operations support 50,000 jobs. Australia exports significantly to other Pacific countries. One of those countries is China, which is the world's largest consumer of coal products.
Australia's operating black and brown coal mines as at December 2012.
Source: Geoscience Australia.

But what about the big battery?
Despite Australia's coal habit, the country is also home to the world's largest grid-connected battery, a Tesla system connected to a wind farm in South Australia. The Australian Energy Market Operator recently praised the system for its quick response to frequency abnormalities on the grid. After the success of that grid-connected battery, Tesla seemed keen to install a "virtual power plant" made of distributed solar panels on Housing Authority homes. But the new South Australian premier has cast doubts about whether the plan would go forward.
On Monday, "McCormack said he 'understands the concerns' expressed in the IPCC report, but admitted he hadn't read it yet," The Guardian wrote. McCormack added in a Monday interview that coal-fired power stations would be around in Australia "for more than just 10 years."
Environment Minister Melissa Price seemed just as unconcerned as McCormack, saying that "it would be 'irresponsible' to commit to phase out coal by 2050 because clean coal technology could be available by then," the Guardian reported. Carbon Capture and Storage has not yet been proven to be an economic solution—without a price penalizing carbon emissions, adoption of CCS techniques are prohibitively expensive.
Still, Australia ranks only fourth for economic coal resources, with the US, Russia, and China ahead of it. In the US, which has the world's largest economic coal resource, the Trump administration has had a difficult time fighting to save coal. On Wednesday, US coal supplier Westmoreland filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in the face of $1.4 billion in debt. That makes the company the fourth major US coal supplier to file for bankruptcy in recent years due to the significant decline in coal use.
Although coal production in the US increased slightly in 2017 after years of punishing loses, 2018 is shaping up to show more declines according to the Energy Department's most recent Quarterly Coal Report. The first and second quarter of this year showed less coal produced than in each of the similar quarters last year.

Links

Wednesday, October 10, 2018

How To Understand The UN's Dire New Climate Report

The Atlantic - 

It tries to find hope against a backdrop of failure.
Men perform a ceremony on the drought-stricken bed of Poopo, a lake in Bolivia. David Mercado / Reuters
People must be burnt out on major climate reports, and can you really blame them? Every year, it seems, yet another group of scientists compiles what we know about climate change. And every year, with few exceptions, the broad outlines of that knowledge seem worrying. But nothing ever really changes—and so our ongoing apocalypse becomes not only all the more terrifying, but all the more tedious.
That burnout is understandable, but I urge you to pay attention to—yes—a new report, released this week by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the UN-convened coalition of climate scientists from around the world. Where previous assessments have warned of our hideous overheated future, this one does something different: It tries to sketch a better one.
The report articulates what seems, from the vantage point of 2018, like a best-case scenario for climate change. It describes what the world will look like if it warms by only 2.7 degrees Fahrenheit, or 1.5 degrees Celsius, by the end of this century. Meeting that target would require humanity to abandon coal and other fossil fuels in the next decade or two: an economic transition so abrupt that, in the IPCC’s words, it “has no documented historic precedents.”
This lukewarm world would still suffer many of the consequences of climate change. There would be more deadly heat waves, more heavy rainstorms, and more intense and frequent droughts. Yet some of the phenomenon’s most catastrophic symptoms—including dozens of feet of sea-level rise and planet-wracking extinctions—might be averted.
The report, in other words, lays out humanity’s last best hope for managing climate change. But it does so against a backdrop of generational failure.
More than a quarter-century ago, the countries of the world hammered out the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change. In language signed by President George H. W. Bush and ratified by the Senate, that document—which later gave rise to both the IPCC’s reports and the Paris Agreement—laid out the goal for all of the UN’s future work on climate change. “The ultimate objective,” it said, was to cut greenhouse-gas emissions so as to “prevent dangerous anthropogenic interference with the climate system.”
“Climate scientists have made it abundantly clear, over the past few years, that we’ve already passed that goal. We’ve already dangerously interfered,” says Christopher Field, the director of the Stanford Woods Institute for the Environment who has worked on previous UN reports, but was not involved in this one.
The new report confirms his contention. It finds that the world has already warmed by 1.8 degrees Fahrenheit, or 1 degree Celsius, since humans began sending industrial pollution into the atmosphere. The costs of this warmth can be seen around the world: This decade alone, sweltering heat waves have killed thousands; engorged floods have ravaged cities from Houston to North Carolina; and half of the coral in the Great Barrier Reef has died.
The question is what happens next. “The international community is struggling with how to address the climate challenge … [while] not being able to meet the ultimate objective,” Field told me. “We’ve already seen dangerous interference—now the question is, how do we deal as effectively as we can with that?”
The new 2.7-degree plan tries to lay out such a strategy. Written by 91 researchers from around the world, it summarizes the findings of more than 6,000 different scientific studies. It argues that humanity must begin rapidly switching away from fossil fuels if it hopes to avoid ecological upheaval. But almost every step of its prescription sits at odds with current policy.
Under its plan, the level of carbon pollution released into the atmosphere every year must begin to fall immediately. (Instead, it hit a record high last year.) By 2030, the world would need to have cut its annual emissions by about half. (Even the Obama administration’s now-cancelled climate policies only cut U.S. emissions by about a quarter by that year.) By 2050, the world must get 80 percent of its electricity from renewable or nuclear power. (Today, only about 20 percent of electricity comes from those sources.)
Additionally, humanity would need to start removing more carbon dioxide from the atmosphere than it emitted by 2050. But even in that world, humanity would probably overshoot the 1.5-degree target for a few decades.
Nowhere are its prescriptions more glaring than around coal. By 2050, it warns that coal must generate no more than 7 percent of global electricity. Today, coal generates about 40 percent of the world’s power.
But more than 1,600 new coal plants are due to come online worldwide in the next few decades, most under contract from Chinese companies. The Trump administration, meanwhile, has tried to create new subsidies for coal companies. It has also moved to weaken or repeal pollution regulations limiting airborne neurotoxins, as well those reducing greenhouse-gas emissions—rules that attracted the ire of coal companies.
“Many will dismiss the [2.7-degree] target as unrealistic, if not laughable,” said Kim Cobb, a professor of climate science at Georgia Tech, in an email. “It is not our job as scientists to give the world a ‘pass’ in the face of damaging delays in tackling climate change.”
She added that its authors “spent months of their lives outlining a path that is entirely justified, from a cost perspective, and urgently needed.”
This report is the first time that the IPCC has examined a 2.7-degree warming “target.” For more than a decade, every nation on the planet has pledged to limit warming to 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit, or 2 degrees Celsius. This goal remains as notional as its newer and more ambitious peer: Even if every country met its obligations as they stand today under the Paris Agreement, the world would emit too much carbon dioxide and shoot past the goal.
But that less ambitious target of 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit has started to look more and more dangerous. In particular, increasing Earth’s temperature by that amount seems like it might greatly increase the risk of destabilizing ice sheets in Antarctica and Greenland.
“We know there’s a threshold somewhere—probably in the vicinity of [3.6 degrees Fahrenheit]—where we’re very likely committed to more than [30 feet of sea-level rise] over centuries,” Field told me. It may be possible to preserve those large stores of ice at 2.7 degrees, scientists have found.
Katharine Hayhoe, a climate scientist at Texas Tech, told me that the report as a whole should be seen as a re-appraisal of where we’re heading as a planet. “It’s like we had a medical issue. The physician had diagnosed it. But now they’re worried it might be worse than we thought,” she said. “So we go back and do a complete work over, every type of test we can imagine.”
The new prognosis is stirring. A world that warms by 3.6 degrees—and not 2.7 degrees—will find that its problems metastasize out of scale with that seemingly small difference. In the hotter world, the number of people affected by water scarcity will double. Twice as many corn crops will perish in the tropics. The size of global fisheries will drop by 50 percent. And 99 percent of the world’s coral reefs will perish.
Plants and animals will also have a much harder time. If the world warms 3.6 degrees, the number of species projected to lose half their habitat will double as compared to the 2.7-degree world. These effects are particularly acute for the Arctic. In the 2.7-degree world, the sea ice in the Arctic Ocean will entirely melt about once a century. In the 3.6-degree world, the Arctic Ocean will go ice-free about once a decade—a potentially cataclysmic moment for polar bears, seals, and other high-latitude mammals.
“A lot of the reason it’s been so challenging to turn the corner on climate change is it will mean that some of the folks who are in positions of power and privilege won’t maintain that privilege,” Field said. “We have a huge number of special interests that benefit from making the transition slower rather than faster.”
Even lacking that clause, the new report might set the stage for the next stage of the climate challenge. As every climate scientist will tell you, the battle to prevent climate change entirely has already been lost. But the battle to blunt its effects—to manage it, as humanity manages the threats of hunger, poverty, war, disease, and other afflictions, and to choose a better, cooler future—has just begun.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative