Thursday, October 18, 2018

There’s Grim News On Climate Change. Will It Lead To Mass Migration And Conflict?

Washington Post - Gabriele Spilker* | Vally Koubi* | Lena Schaffer* | Tobias Böhmelt*

An Afghan boy pumps water in Sakhi village on the outskirts of Mazar-i-Sharif on July 19. Thousands of farmers are migrating to cities as Afghanistan experiences its worst drought in at least a decade. (Farshad Usyan/AFP/Getty Images)
This week’s United Nations climate report, drawing on almost 100 leading scientists around the world, keeps climate change in the headlines — as do Hurricanes Florence and Michael, Typhoon Mangkhut, and the heat waves and wildfires in the United States and Europe in 2018.
With the intensified debates on the consequences of climate change comes a renewed concern about climate-change-induced migration. Will the effects of climate change prompt large flows of environmental migrants and, in turn, increase the risk of violence and conflict?
While few, if any, migrants are directly or deliberately associated with conflict, it could occur because newcomers increase competition for jobs, public services and other scarce resources such as housing. The inflow of migrants can also undermine social cohesion, especially when the arrival of migrants upsets an “unstable” ethno-political balance.

We interviewed people in five countries about environmental change and migration
But the likelihood of more migration and subsequent conflict depends in part on the people affected by climate change and the way the environment will change. In our research, we interviewed more than 3,500 individuals, both migrants and non-migrants, in five developing countries about their perceptions of environmental change and their experiences.
We talked to individuals to focus in on whether it is environmental change that triggers internal migration and then conflict. The existing literature tends to use more aggregated data to study how environmental changes affect migration and conflict. This implies investigating whether regions that received more environmental in-migration also saw more conflict. The challenge here is to show that environmental change indeed triggers migration in the first place and that these kinds of migrants then contribute to actual violence in their new host regions.
Here are takeaways from our research:

1. People affected by climate change often try to adapt — to avoid migrating.
We observe that climate-induced environmental change does not necessarily lead to more migration. On the contrary, individuals/families usually try their best to adapt to environmental changes, if this is possible.
But adaptation often is possible only with slow-onset and prolonged environmental changes — like droughts or changes to water/soil salinity. In such cases, environmental degradation builds up gradually over months and years and thus gives individuals time to react and, possibly, adapt. Sudden-onset and rapid environmental events, such as hurricanes or floods, on the other hand, rarely leave people any other option than to migrate — chances to adapt tend to be small, at least in the short run.
So why do people choose adaptation over migration when their environment deteriorates? The main reason is that individuals are typically strongly attached to their location because of physical assets — their houses or farmland — and social ties to family and friends. And migration is usually a costly alternative, as people need the resources necessary to undertake the move. Thus, if mitigation and/or adaptation to a given environmental problem is possible, people tend to take that path.

2. For those who migrate, the type of environmental event they experienced matters.
We then focused on migrants and learned that the type of the environmental event they experienced also matters for whether they perceive conflict at their new location. We study conflict perceptions, because at the individual level it is hardly possible to gather data on actual conflict behavior, e.g., fighting.
In particular, we asked migrants whether they faced any challenges at their new locations. These perceived challenges varied from unemployment to labor exploitation to actual violent conflict in their new location. While some of these perceptions might not necessarily be directly related to real conflict (e.g., economic hardship), other types of conflict perceptions, like reported actual conflict, in their new location do.
We find that migrants who experienced gradual, long-term environmental events in their former locations are more likely to perceive conflict in their new location, compared with those having experienced sudden, short-term environmental events.
Here’s why this happens. We believe that long-term environmental events hit some people harder than others. Think of how farmers vs. civil servants might be differently affected by gradually deteriorating environmental conditions because of climate change. Such environmental events exacerbate actual or perceived inequalities in a society.
The key concept linking inequality to conflict is relative deprivation. This means the extent to which people become discontent by the widening gap between their actual level of economic achievement and the level they feel they deserve — and could have achieved under better environmental conditions.
These feelings of suffering typically develop over a long period and arise because individuals differ in their adaptive capacities and their exposure to these environmental changes. Consequently, some individuals can become frustrated because some segments of the affected population can better adapt and thus are able to maintain their standards of living despite declining environmental conditions.
In contrast, sudden, short-term environmental events are less likely to foster feelings of relative deprivation — many individuals are affected equally, and exposure to these events is typically limited to a short time. Therefore, despite their potential to cause immense, absolute amounts of destruction and harm, short-term environmental events do not seem to lead to heightened conflict perceptions among migrants at their new location.

What does this mean for policies to deal with climate change and migration?
Responses to climate change vary from general pleas to the international community to cut greenhouse gases now and concrete plans to reduce emissions, to suggestions to enhance resilience to weather-related events for rural inhabitants. All of these are important responses, though our research emphasizes the relevance of promoting adaptation opportunities for those affected by climatic changes.
Many governments agree and increasingly incorporate climate-adaptation plans into broader regional development policies. A recent World Bank report on climate change and migration reveals that, given adequate development opportunities, including adaptation measures, internal migration in sub-Saharan Africa, South Asia and Latin America triggered by climate change could be reduced by up to 80 percent.
This prediction is in line with our findings on the impact of environmental change on internal migration. Furthermore, the World Bank report warns that the consequences of increasing internal migration for the development of these regions, if no countermeasures are taken, could be dire — infrastructure and social support systems could come under immense stress with potential adverse effects on the political stability of these regions. Again, this echoes our analysis of how environmental changes affect conflict perceptions.
  • *Gabriele Spilker (@gabi_spilker) is associate professor of international politics at the Department of Political Science and Sociology of the University of Salzburg, Austria.
  • *Vally Koubi is a professor at the Center of Comparative and International Studies (CIS), ETH Zurich and Department of Economics, University of Bern, Switzerland. 
  • *Lena Schaffer is assistant professor of inter- and transnational relations at the University of Luzern, Switzerland. 
  • *Tobias Böhmelt is professor of political science in the Department of Government at the University of Essex, U.K.
Links

'No More Hiding': Morrison Government Set Emissions Data Deadlines

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

The federal government will be less able to delay the release of embarrassing national carbon pollution figures after the Senate approved rolling deadlines for the quarterly data.
The Greens secured Labor and crossbench support of a so-called order of continuing effect that requires the government to table the Greenhouse Gas Inventory figures within five months of the end of each quarter, or provide an explanation for any delay.
Regular emission updates in the winds: AGL's Bayswater black-coal-fired power station in the Hunter Valley. Credit: Glen McCurtayne
The motion, passed by 33-27 votes, follows an erratic series of releases of the key climate data since the Abbott government took office in September 2013.
The average delay between the end of each quarter and the publishing of the pollution figures went from about four to five months under the Gillard government, to as long as seven months at the start of the Abbott term. At least one case involved sitting on almost a year's worth of data.
The Morrison government stirred controversy by releasing its March 2018 quarterly pollution figures late on September 28, the eve of a busy weekend of football grand finals and a day dominated by the news of the interim banking royal commission report.
The report showed emissions jumped to their highest level since 2010, spurred by increased LNG production. Emissions have been rising for four years, placing them on a trajectory at odds with Australia's Paris climate commitment to cut 2005-level pollution by 26-28 per cent by 2030.

'Unacceptable'
Adam Bandt, the Greens climate spokesman, said the data was some of the most important collected by the government, and they shouldn't "get to hide it from the public".
“We wouldn’t let the Treasurer hide the unemployment figures because they were going in the wrong direction, but that’s what the Environment Minister [Melissa Price] is getting away with," Mr Bandt said.
“It’s unacceptable that a document with significant public importance is released whenever the government feels like no one will notice it."
Fairfax Media sought comment from Ms Price. Ms Price on Wednesday told question time in Parliament that Australia had met previous climate emissions commitments and would meet the Paris one as well.
Mark Butler, Labor's climate spokesman, said the Abbott-Turnbull-Morrison governments had "all deliberately delayed the release of damning figures which highlight that under their leadership carbon pollution is rising".
"We know the government sat on the latest emissions data for seven weeks before trying to bury the figures by sneaking it out late on a Friday evening on the weekend of the AFL and NRL grand finals," he said, adding another tactic had been to release such data during the week around Christmas.
The Australian Conservation Foundation, which has used freedom of information laws to prise out data, welcomed the move towards more consistent information flows.
“Ultimately, ACF believes the government should set a release schedule that specifies a time and date for the public release of this data, as happens with the Australian Bureau of Statistics’ release on the National Accounts," Kelly O'Shanassy, the foundation's chief executive officer, said.
“One of the well-equipped independent bodies working on climate change, like the Clean Energy Regulator or the Climate Change Authority, should have the responsibility of preparing and releasing this data."
Of the crossbenchers, Tim Storer, Derryn Hinch and the Centre Alliance senators supported the motion.

Links

Wednesday, October 17, 2018

Cultural Heritage Has A Lot To Teach Us About Climate Change

The Conversation -  |  | 

Ahu on Easter Island. Bryan Busovicki/Shutterstock.com
Museums, archaeological sites and historical buildings are rarely included in conversations about climate change, which tend to focus on the wider impact and global threats to our contemporary world. Yet these threats impact everything, from local cultural practices to iconic sites of outstanding universal value. In light of this, it’s worth exploring the relationship between our heritage and the changing global climate in more detail.
More powerful storms, flooding, desertification and even the melting of permafrost are already destroying important sites at an alarming rate. While we race to preserve or record these places before they are lost forever, it is also the case that some sites – especially those that are or have been highly adaptable and flexible – can also be assets in understanding adaptation strategies more generally.
These questions are currently being explored by an expert working group, which we are part of. Our aim is to unpack the intersection between our changing climate and the world’s cultural heritage, specifically world heritage sites. Building on the Paris Agreement, which notes the importance of traditional and indigenous knowledge when thinking about adaptation strategies, we are exploring how global heritage can be used not only to stress urgency about the dangers and risks of climate change, but also as an asset to enforce community resilience and develop adaptation strategies for the future.

Melting permafrost
Take Russia’s Treasures of the Pazyryk Culture. Located in the Altai mountains, this landscape of burial mounds (kurgans) and rock carvings derive from the Scythian nomadic culture of 2,500 years ago. A few of the two- to four-metre tall stone mounds have been excavated in the past. They reveal an incredible array of artefacts, complex funerary practices, and (most famously) tattooed individuals – all preserved due to the sub-zero conditions.
Pazyryk male mummy with preserved hair and shoulder tattoos. © V L Molodin
The melting of permafrost due to rising temperatures is expected to significantly impact frozen tombs at the site by the middle of this century. The chemical and biological deterioration of the organic and inorganic contents, previously inhibited by the freezing conditions, is likely to accelerate rapidly, while associated ground movement could cause structural damage to the tombs themselves.
The threat to these tombs from rising temperatures has been met with efforts to survey and protect them. While many indigenous people and heritage conservators aim to preserve the burials without disturbing them, it is not yet clear if this can be achieved.
Archaeological excavations on the site of ancient Scythian burials of Pazyryk culture in the Altai mountains, Siberia, Russia. Alexander Demyanov/Shutterstock.com
Rising waters
Elsewhere, rising sea waters and erosion are having a similarly disastrous impact. The Ruins of Kilwa Kisiwani in Tanzania, for example, are at considerable risk from the impact of increased surf, exacerbated by the loss of mangrove forestry on the island.
This site was founded in the ninth century and became a major trading centre by the 13th century. It was inscribed as a UNESCO world heritage site in 1981 as an exceptional testimony to the expansion of Swahili coastal culture, and to the spread of Islam in Africa in this period. Ongoing efforts are being made here to strengthen the sea wall protecting the site, and to encourage alternate land use strategies to increase natural protection. The area’s iconic heritage is helping to deliver important messages concerning climate change.
Kilwa Kisiwani Fort. Gustavgraves/Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA
In Easter Island, meanwhile, rising sea levels and increasing storm surges are eroding the platforms (ahu) upon which famous statues (moai) are stood. Almost all of these statues are on the coast. It is very clear that climate change is having an adverse and worsening impact on these sites. This damage will destroy parts of the archaeological resource, including subsurface archaeological deposits that are particularly under-researched. The loss of these statues could have a significant negative impact on the tourism economy of Easter Island, affecting the livelihoods and resilience of the islanders.

Lessons from heritage
But we can learn a lot from some communities’ response to threat at such sites in the study of climate change resilience. While increased flooding and extreme weather conditions represent a considerable challenge globally, coastal and river communities have been living with (and adapting to) similar events for centuries.
A good example of this localised adaptation can be found on the river island of Majuli in the Brahmaputra River in Assam, India. Majuli is a landscape of both natural and cultural significance. The island is also home to over 30 ancient monasteries, known as sattras, which are repositories of both tangible and intangible culture.
Image of an example of a stilted building constructed using local materials on Majuli Island, Assam.
Photo: Hidden Landscapes of Majuli Project 2018
Here, annual flooding has led to significant erosion of the river and the displacement of communities, many of which live outside of the protective levees constructed in recent years. Over hundreds of years, communities on Majuli have developed modular and portable building techniques using local materials including building on stilts. The river and its annual flooding have become part of the everyday experience of living on Majuli and is a part of the local worldview.
More permanent structures of the sattras are not immune to the impacts of the river and some have been moved up to five times over the last 300 years. These places and their associated cultural heritage have evolved to be portable, a valuable skill in a landscape which changes regularly.
It should be stressed that, even with these adaptations, the current pace of climate change is unprecedented and its impact on river and coastal communities will be disastrous. Yet, by better understanding places like Majuli, we will learn much about resilience and adaptation to the inevitable impacts of climate change.

Links

States And Territories Lead Way On Renewables, Climate

RenewEconomy - Greg Bourne | Petra Stock


We Aussies love our sport. And with our boundless sunny plains and breezy hills, making us one of the sunniest and windiest places in the world; we love our renewables, too. So, why not combine the two in a bit of cheeky competition?
The Climate Council has released its fourth scorecard that measures state and territory progress on renewable energy.
States and territories are judged on a range of criteria, such as how much renewable energy they generate, the proportion of houses with solar, whether they have renewable energy targets, or plans to reduce greenhouse gas pollution.
Federal climate and energy policy has made so many false starts this year that it’s out of the race altogether.
Instead, it’s Australia’s states and territories who have seized the baton and taken the lead in the national renewables relay.


Our new report provides a snapshot of renewables action happening all across Australia’s states and territories, in spite of current federal inaction:

The renewable energy boom is accelerating in Australia, and across the world. State and territory governments are leading Australia’s electricity transition from fossil fuels to renewable energy and storage.
Powering Progress: States Renewable Energy Race rates states and territories based on their performance across a range of metrics. These include each state’s percentage of renewable electricity, the proportion of households with solar and policies that support renewable energy.

  1. A whopping 69 wind and solar plants are under construction in Australia right now, creating almost 10,000 jobs in the renewable energy industry. All up, this will add almost seven times more energy capacity than the now closed Hazelwood coal power station.
  2. Not counting Western Australia, all states and territories have now committed to renewable energy and/or net zero emissions targets.
  3. And in Queensland, the aptly named ‘sunshine state’, 33% of all households have rooftop solar, closely followed by South Australia, at 32%. SA is also on track for 73% renewable energy in just two short years.
Federally, Australia still isn’t doing enough when it comes to tackling greenhouse gas pollution.Based on our current track record, it doesn’t even look like we’ll meet our woefully low emissions reduction target of 26-28% below 2005 levels by 2030.
And as the recent Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) special report has warned us, we need a tremendous global effort to keep temperature rise below 1.5˚C, wind back worsening extreme weather events aggravated by climate change, and protect lives and livelihoods now, and tomorrow.
Which is why we have to keep our eyes on the prize. Focus on the victories to be had. And never settle for second best.
Here are a few more stats from the report:
  • Tasmania, ACT and SA are equal winners of this year’s renewables race, across a range of renewable energy measures – based on each state’s proportion of renewable energy, wind and solar capacity per capita, proportion of households with solar, and renewable energy targets and policies.
  • Western Australia, the Northern Territory and New South Wales are lagging behind the other states and territories.
  • Western Australia’s share of renewable energy is low, however the state has the third highest proportion of households with rooftop solar.
  • The Northern Territory has a low share of renewable electricity and solar households, but is set to implement its plan to reach 50% renewable energy by 2030.
  • New South Wales does not have a renewable energy target and has no plan to replace its ageing and unreliable coal power stations.
  • With the exception of Western Australia, all states and territories have committed to renewable energy targets and/or net zero emissions targets.
  • South Australia continues to have the largest amount of installed wind and solar capacity (1,831MW), closely followed by New South Wales (1,759MW) and Victoria (1,634MW). On a per capita basis, South Australia, the ACT and Tasmania are the leaders.
  • Queensland and South Australia have the highest proportion of households with rooftop solar, at 32.9% and 32.3% respectively. Western Australia is in third place with 26.7% of households with rooftop solar.
  • Queensland has more renewable energy projects under construction than any other state.
  • Almost 10,000 jobs are being created in the renewable energy industry across Australia with 69 wind and solar plants under construction. Queensland, Victoria and New South Wales are home to the vast majority of these projects.
  • South Australia has at least eight new projects under construction and is on track for 73% renewable electricity in just two years.
  • More solar PV capacity was added around the world than coal, gas and nuclear combined. Almost three-quarters of new energy generation capacity added globally was renewable in 2017.
  • Electricity generation from coal and gas fell for the fifth consecutive year.
  • Approximately 17 countries generated more than 90% of their electricity with renewable energy in 2017. Australia was not one of them.
Links

Leaders Move Past Trump To Protect World From Climate Change

The Guardian - 

Far more must be invested in adapting to warming, says new global commission that aims to rebuild political will after US withdrawal from Paris agreement
Bill Gates and former UN secretary general Ban Ki-moon (right) are among the leaders of the new Global Commission on Adaptation. Photograph: Evan Schneider/UN Photo 
Far too little is being done to protect people from the heatwaves, storms and floods being supercharged by climate change, according to a high-level international commission. It aims to rebuild the political will to act that was damaged when US president, Donald Trump, rejected the global Paris agreement.
The Global Commission on Adaptation is being led by Ban Ki-Moon, Bill Gates and Kristalina Georgieva, CEO of the World Bank. It involves 17 countries including China, India, South Africa, Indonesia, Canada and the UK.
Much more money is being invested in cutting carbon emissions than preparing for the climate change impacts that are already inevitable. More than $380bn (£287bn) was spent on reducing CO2 in 2015-16, compared with just $20bn boosting protection from extreme weather.
Former UN secretary general Ban said a step change in adaptation can and must be achieved: “Climate change is happening much, much faster than one may think. [But] where there is political will, anything can be done.”
However, he said the international consensus to fight global warming had been damaged by Trump’s actions. On Sunday, Trump questioned whether global warming was caused by human activities, contradicting the long-established conclusions of the world’s scientists.
“We were very much united until December 2015 in Paris,” Ban told the Guardian. “Now unfortunately the level of solidarity is being loosened, especially by the Trump administration. Even though it is just one country, it has caused big political damage.”
Adaptation measures to safeguard people’s homes, food, water and energy are being implemented in some places, but at far too small a scale, the commissioners said.
“Continued economic growth and reductions in global poverty are possible despite these daunting challenges – but only if societies invest much more in adaptation,” said Ban. “The costs of adapting are less than the cost of doing business as usual and the benefits are many times larger.”
“We are at a moment of high risk and great promise,” said Bill Gates, co-chair of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. “If everyone does their part, we can reduce carbon emissions, increase access to affordable energy, and help farmers everywhere grow more productive crops.”
“Our climate has already changed. Dramatic weather events and volatile seasons are the new normal,” said Georgieva. “We face a choice: business as usual and hope for the best. Or we act now and build for a resilient future.”
The new group is comprised of 28 commissioners, including two national presidents, representing all regions of the globe and all sectors of development and industry. The US administration is not represented but Francis Suarez, the mayor of Miami, is a commissioner.
The commission will produce a major report on adapting to climate change for the UN climate summit in September 2019, followed by a year of action to implement its recommendations.
“Scientists and economists believe the cost of adaptation could rise to $500bn per year by 2050 and, in the mid-term, $300bn by 2030,” said Ban. This money is available, he said: “I don’t think it is a matter of [getting the] money. The money can be mobilised. If there is political will, I think we can handle this matter.”
In particular, the trillions of dollars held by investment managers and insurers should be put to work, Ban said: “We should not expect all this money to come from governments. The private sector has to be fully engaged.” He said 63% of the $380bn invested in cutting emissions in 2015-16 was from the private sector.

Links

We’re Covering Heritage Sites Threatened By Climate Change. The List Just Got Longer.

New York Times - Kendra Pierre-Louis

LEFT: Cedars grow sparsely in the mountains near Jaj, Lebanon. RIGHT: Children swim by moai statues off the coast of Easter Island. Photos Josh Haner/The New York Times
One of the cruelties of global warming is that it threatens humanity’s past as well as its future.
That was brought into sharp focus by a study issued Tuesday. It says that some of the most important ancient sites in the Mediterranean region — the Greek city of Ephesus, Istanbul’s historic districts, Venice’s canals — might not survive the era of climate change.
Those places joined a list of others that we’ve covered extensively here at The Times. Our series on cultural heritage has looked at the Cedars of Lebanon, the Stone Age villages of Scotland and the statues of Easter Island, all of which are threatened by climate change.
Rising ocean levels are causing waves to break on the statues and platforms built a thousand years ago. 
The island risks losing its cultural heritage. Again.
March 14, 2018
 In the case of Scotland and Easter Island, the menace is from rising seas. Many civilizations of the past, much like many present-day cities, were centered on coastal areas. As sea levels rise — both because warmer water takes up more space than cooler water, and because of melting glaciers — these heritage sites face sharply increased risks from both coastal erosion and flooding.The new study, published in the journal Nature Communications, analyzed 49 Unesco heritage sites in the Mediterranean region in terms of end-of-century sea level rise projections that assume we don’t mitigate climate change.
Saving Scotland’s Heritage From the Rising Seas
Citizens and scientists on the Orkney Islands are racing to protect
thousands of ancient structures threatened by climate change.
Sept. 25, 2018
 In Lebanon, the danger is shrinking habitat. The conditions the cedar trees need to live are becoming more and more rare as the Middle East heats up.
Climate Change Is Killing the Cedars of Lebanon
Global warming could wipe out most of the country’s
remaining cedar forests by the end of the century.
July 18, 2018
The researchers concluded that of the 49 sites, 46 will be threatened by coastal erosion and 40 by flooding if greenhouse gas emissions continue to rise.
If you haven’t seen our heritage series, or if you missed an article, this might be the occasion for a virtual journey to Lebanon, the Orkney Islands, or Easter Island. The images are stunning and the stories are gripping.

Links

Tuesday, October 16, 2018

Our Leaders Are Destroying Our Future. Wentworth Must Be A Referendum On Climate Change

The Guardian -  |

In the face of sustained government stupidity, many feel powerless. Voters in Wentworth can lead the way
Get Up protest in the seat of Wentworth at a byelection forum on Monday.
Photograph: Carly Earl for the Guardian 
If a bricklayer builds a wall that falls over 12 years later, killing someone, the bricklayer can be sued and even jailed. If a doctor finds some old packets of thalidomide in their surgery and, in spite of the overwhelming scientific evidence of its horrific effects, dispenses it to pregnant women, they would go to jail. The example can be multiplied endlessly: the reality of our world is that we are responsible for our acts.
Unless, that is, you are an Australian politician.
A politician can destroy our future, a politician can ignore the best evidence and be responsible for decisions that lead to deaths of many and the suffering of all, and still be free until the end of their days to milk the legal corruption that is Australian public life, picking up highly paid sinecures as ambassadors, board directors and lobbyists for the corporations they were once meant to regulate in our interest.
Last Monday there came the unbelievable news contained in the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report. If large-scale action is not taken now we will face a global warming catastrophe.
The report was a nightmarish scream heard through a spithood of formal scientific language. Any rise above 1.5C is highly likely to be disastrous, with millions of people displaced by rising seas, the extinction of numerous species, and the loss of most coral reefs. At 2C the rate of crop loss doubles, as does the decline in sea fisheries. Almost all coral reefs will be dead. Diseases such as dengue and malaria will be far more widespread, extreme droughts and floods far more common, while security and economic growth will be imperilled.
One of the report’s lead authors, the geographer Adelle Thomas, said, “The scientific consensus is really strong. It’s not just a political slogan: ‘1.5 to stay alive.’ It’s true.”
The report was specific in how long we have to keep warming at 1.5C: until 2030.
Twelve years.
This Saturday the voters of Wentworth have the opportunity to turn their byelection into a referendum on climate change. If you are a Wentworth voter, consider the historic responsibility you have and how in the past you have used it to good effect. Last year it was Wentworth, after all, that voted 80.8% yes for marriage equality, the fourth-highest yes vote in the nation.
Marriage equality, as many have since noted, was not given to us by enlightened politicians. It was forced on a recalcitrant government by the countless acts of individual courage shown by those who stood up in their workplaces, families, in their kitchens, cafes, sporting clubs, for their dignity and freedom; it was made possible by organisation and a passion that transcended party loyalties, and could not finally be refused. Marriage equality was won by the people, in other words, not gifted by the politicians.
Our prime minister, a man with a wit that would make Kenny look like Oscar Wilde, once thought it funny to wave a lump of coal in parliament during the middle of one of eastern Australia’s worst heatwaves. Luckily he had Barnaby Joyce there to laugh. With a similar bro and brio he dismissed the IPCC report while speaking to Alan Jones, saying he wouldn’t be bound by its recommendations. His deputy, Michael McCormack, declared the government would not change policy “just because somebody might suggest that some sort of report is the way we need to follow”.


Scott Morrison Brings Lump of Coal Into House of Representatives

That “some sort of report” – the findings of 91 of the world’s most eminent climate change scientists surveying more than 6,000 studies of the most recent research – didn’t trouble McCormack because he hadn’t read the report. Neither had our environment minister, Melissa Price, who told ABC radio the IPCC report, whatever the shared judgment of its global expertise, was “drawing a long bow” by calling for an end to coal by 2050.
But then, of course, this is the same government that offers total political support for the Adani coalmine at a time when the IPCC says coal must be phased out. This is the same government that granted $440m to a foundation that never asked for the cash, to deal with water runoff and the crown-of-thorns starfish on the Great Barrier Reef when the science is clear that climate change is what will kill the reef.
We have shown that we are large, that we care, and that we think
And this is the same government that has no policies to meet Australia’s commitments to the Paris climate agreement. This is the same government that hides shameful greenhouse emissions reports showing our pollution increasing by releasing them in the days before Christmas, without publicity.
And its leader, our prime minister, is the man who says that “we’re doing well” when the government’s own figures show that our pollution is increasing.
The Liberal candidate Dave Sharma echoes the same smug complacency of the Liberal government he expects to join next Monday.
“I do think we are doing enough,” Sharma has said, “and I do think we have had a good record on climate change. Emissions are at their lowest levels in 28 years,” he said. The evidence is otherwise: absolute emissions continue to rise and are among the highest in the OECD.
Like our prime minister, who claims we will meet our Paris agreement targets “in a canter”, Sharma says: “We are on track to meet the Paris commitments and I believe we will address the Paris commitments and we will be addressing affordability and sustainable and coherent energy policy.”
Sharma’s diplomatic wording cloaks the truth: the Liberal government is the Aleppo of energy policy. It has none, only the shell-shocked ruins of a once great party. As for the Paris climate targets, according to consultants, NDEVR Environmental, Australia is on a trajectory that will see it fail to reach them.
In the face of such sustained stupidity by our leaders many Australians have felt an overwhelming sense of powerlessness.
But we should not.
If you are a Liberal voter, consider the voices of true conservatism and business
As the marriage equality vote showed, as the Sydney Opera House controversy revealed, if we choose to exercise our power we discover that we are not as we have so often been told, small and mean and self-serving, cast in the shrivelled image of our politicians. To the contrary, we have shown that we are large, that we care, and that we think – and that when we dare to exercise it, that the power is ours.
In evading their responsibilities on climate change, our politicians have been irresponsible to the point of what would be, in any other sphere of life, criminality.
If you are a Liberal voter, consider the voices of true conservatism and business.
Mark Carney, the governor of the Bank of England, recently warned “of the catastrophic impacts that climate change could have for the world financial system”.
“We accept the IPPC assessment of climate change and that human influence is clear and that the physical impacts are unavoidable,” Jac Nasser, the former chairman of BHP, the world’s biggest resource company, declared, while Eric Schmidt, the former chairman of Google, said: “The facts of climate change are not in question. People who oppose it are hurting our children and making the world a worse place. They’re just simply lying.” Listen to Fiona Simson, the president of the National Farmers’ Federation, who has stated “We’ve turned a corner on climate change … overwhelmingly, I think it’s got to a point where the science is very acceptable.”
These are hardly the lunatic voices of the far left. It is clear that the traditional constituencies of the Coalition, business and farmers, support major action on climate change – as do the majority of Australians according to all published research, as do the majority of people in Wentworth.
Yet the government, from the prime minister down, dismisses the issue. Indeed, both the government and Sharma, state that they are “doing enough” on climate change.
The very phrase drips with the contempt of our political class for Australian citizens who they take for passive fools, easily manipulated. As with marriage equality we see a polity determined to do nothing.
Since 2013, the Coalition government in its various incarnations has lied, laughed and destroyed when it comes to this most fundamental matter: that of our future. Their record is one of deceit, obfuscation and craven capitulation to the fossil fuel industry. It is a party that has evaded its most fundamental responsibility to our land and our people, and the time for a reckoning has arrived.
This Saturday, voters of Wentworth can lead Australia as they did in the marriage equality survey. They can make the byelection a referendum on climate change by voting the candidate they believe has the best climate policy number 1, any who might have a reasonable policy from 2 to 15, and put Dave Sharma at 16.
“We have presented governments with pretty hard choices,” Prof Jim Skea, co-chairman of the IPCC panel has been quoted as saying. “We show it can be done within laws of physics and chemistry. Then the final tick box is political will.”
The most important thing a voter can do on election day is demonstrate that this threat to our future must be our politicians’ number one priority, and give our politicians the political will to act now.
There is so much beauty in this world. Sometimes it is hard to believe this life that is given us. Sometimes it is hard to believe that it is possible to change it for the better, or save it from the worst. But from today we must, and we can.
If we take our compass from power we will know only despair. But if we take our compass from those around us and their actions we discover hope. It is time we rediscovered not partisan division but a common humanity ready to take on our gravest crisis. It is time we acted, and the Wentworth byelection is the first chance Australians have. Our tomorrows are running out. We have only today.


Australia's climate wars: a decade of dithering

*Richard Flanagan is the Man Booker prize winning Australian author
*Businessman Geoff Cousins is a former Howard government adviser


Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative