Sunday, December 23, 2018

Market-Oriented Economic Belief System Incompatible With Climate Change Mitigation

International Business Times - * | *


Climate scientists are loudly sounding the alarm bells. Even if global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions are drastically reduced, a series of self-reinforcing bio-geophysical feedback loops could still lock the planet into a cycle of continued warming and a pathway to final destination: “Hothouse Earth.”
To avoid these risks and keep warming below 1.5° Celsius, humanity will have to reduce GHG emissions to net zero by 2050. Scientists show that limiting the global mean temperature increase to 1.5° Celsius is neither a geophysical impossibility, nor a technical fantasy. The engineering solutions to bring about deep de-carbonization—including quick fixes and negative-emissions technologies—are available and are beginning to work.
Rather remarkably, the distinctly alarmist tone of the climate scientists stands in contrast to more upbeat economic reports that there has been a delinking between economic growth and carbon emissions in recent times, at least in the world’s richest countries. The view that decoupling is already happening in real time is a popular position in global and national policy discourses. In a widely read 2017 article in “Science”, former President Barack Obama argued that the U.S. economy could continue growing without increasing GHG emissions, thanks to the rollout of renewable energy technologies.
Is the “Yes, We Can” optimism warranted? The economists’ equivalent of Obama’s optimism is the “Carbon Kuznets Hypothesis”, the idea that industrialization raises GHG emissions initially, but as the economy becomes technologically more sophisticated and energy efficient, and as people become richer and demand stricter environmental regulations, GHG emissions fall. In other words, growing the economy and saving the planet go hand in hand.
In our recent working paper published by the Institute for New Economic Thinking, we systematically evaluate the “Yes, We Can” optimism by carefully looking at the historical data on GHG emissions and growth for a sample of 61 countries.
What we observe is that the data do not support this harmonious view of economic growth. The generally used production-based GHG emissions data ignore the highly fragmented nature of global production chains and are unable to reveal the ultimate driver of increasing CO2 emissions: consumption growth.
It is true that some rich countries have managed to reduce GHG emissions while increasing their consumption levels, but these are exceptions, there is no general trend. In today’s global economy, higher consumption leads to higher GHG emissions. So far, there is no systematic decoupling of material standards of living and GHH emissions.
This picture shows a small globe surrounded by smoke to illustrate global warming, taken in Paris, Nov. 10, 2015. Photo: LIONEL BONAVENTURE/AFP/Getty Images
To prevent potentially catastrophic warming, the link between consumption and GHG needs to be severed, but halfhearted tinkering will not do the job. Deep de-carbonization cannot be brought about by slightly modifying business-as-usual policies, which rely on price signals, technological fixes on the supply side and voluntary or “nudged” behavior change on the demand side.
Current policies are bound to extend current unsustainable production, consumption and emission patterns into the future and put us all on the one-way path to Hothouse Earth. Climate stabilization requires a fundamental disruption of hydrocarbon energy, production and transportation infrastructures, a massive upsetting of vested interests in fossil-fuel energy and industry, and large-scale public investment — and all this should be done sooner than later. What is required is a massive mobilization in the face of an existential threat.
The problem for most economists is that it suggests directional thrust by state actors, smacks of planning, coordination, and public interventionism, and goes against the market-oriented belief system. “Economists like to set corrective prices and then be done with it,” writes Jeffrey Sachs, adding that “this hands-off approach will not work in the case of a major overhaul of energy technology.”
The real problem therefore is not a technical one. The real problem is that available solutions go against the economic logic and the corresponding belief system that have dominated the world economy for last few decades — a logic aimed at scaling back (environmental) regulations, pampering the oligopolies of big fossil-fuel corporations, kowtowing to the automotive industry, giving free rein to financial markets and prioritizing short-run shareholder returns.
The biggest barrier to averting going down the path to “Hothouse Earth” is the present market-oriented belief system. We will only be able to phase out greenhouse gas emissions before mid-century if we shift our societies and economies to a “wartime footing.”

*Dr. Enno Schröder and *Dr. Servaas Storm are economists at Delft University of Technology, the Netherlands.

Links

Stalling On Clean Energy Leaves Australia In The Dust

Fairfax - Crispin Hull

As Hyundai demonstrated its latest pollution-reversing hydrogen car in London this week, it is worth looking at how the policy impasse on climate change – caused by the actions of the troglodyte right of the Coalition – threatens Australia’s economic wellbeing.
It is difficult to change the selfish view that Australia can do little on its own to reverse climate change.
Credit: Julian Smith
We first have to understand the troglodytes’ beliefs by following the money trail.
It is wrong to assume they believe the climate is not changing or that humans are not causing it and therefore coal is okay to use. Rather it is the other way around. Their financial backers in the coal industry want to be able to continue to profit from coal, therefore the troglodytes must either deny climate change is happening or that coal has anything to do with it.
Of course, proselytising and propaganda have caused a lot of people to believe that there is no human-made climate change, in the same way that people have been convinced of a religious belief that, say, God made the earth in a week a few thousand years ago. But it is not science.
It is difficult to shift belief. It is also difficult to change the selfish view that Australia can do little on its own. We should therefore look at economics and how much these beliefs will cost Australia in the near future.
The Coalition troglodytes should contemplate over this yet-again record-breaking hot summer how their dogged determination to stick with coal and other fossil fuels is denying Australia a leading role in new industries and billions in savings by using new technology.
Climate change aside, we should be embracing renewable energy from solar and wind with battery and hydro storage because they will make our lives materially better.
Hyundai’s hydrogen car is a good example. It splits hydrogen into two positively charged protons and two negatively charged electrons. The electrons are drawn off to run the car’s electric motor. Then they and the protons are combined with oxygen from the air to form harmless water.
The oxygen has to be free of pollutants, so the incoming air is filtered. The net result is that the hydrogen car removes as much pollutant from the air per kilometre as petrol and diesel cars emit.
Hydrogen-powered cars are driven by electric engines, just like ordinary electric cars, but their energy source is stored in hydrogen fuel cells. Other electric cars use batteries, usually lithium. Both need electric power, usually from the grid, to charge them.
These cars are already here, but in the next few years, sales will boom. We do not make any cars in Australia so we will be forced to follow international trends as petrol and diesel cars are phased out. They will go the way of the film camera with the onslaught of vastly cheaper and instantly satisfying digital cameras. It took about eight years for almost the whole of the world’s camera inventory to be replaced.
Electric cars have very few moving parts, not even a gearbox. They do not emit poisonous gases into the atmosphere. And even with Australia’s inexplicably high electricity prices are far cheaper to run than petrol or diesel cars.
A battery car uses about 18kWh of electricity for 100km, say $4. A hydrogen car uses about double that, and, incidentally, unless that improves it may mean that hydrogen cars do not take off, though hydrogen trucks and buses will still make sense. A petrol or diesel car, on the other hand, costs about $10 per 100km and requires much more servicing and lubricants than electric cars do.
But if the federal government is so scared of the coal lobby that it will not develop an innovative energy and transport policy, Australians will not get these benefits, or get them later and at a greater cost.
Our national government should not be contemplating subsiding or owning new coal power plants but be leading the charge. It should not be passively waiting for industry, the states and individuals to take up the technology in a haphazard way. Our government should be promoting nationwide charging stations for electric cars.
At present Australia imports about 90 per cent of its liquid fuel for transport, at a cost of about $50 billion a year.
If the Coalition is really interested in jobs and growth and running the economy, it would be helping Australian industry innovate with more renewables and better battery and other storage technologies.
We should be replacing the $50 billion worth of polluting fuel with electricity from our abundant sun and wind.
This brings us to transport policy. Roads are funded directly or indirectly through registration fees and the fuel tax.
This has got to change. We should be intelligently planning for that change. In the inevitable transition to electric vehicles, the $11 billion-a-year fuel tax will dry up.
As it does so, there will be obvious unfairness. A 10-year-old petrol car costs almost 5 cents a kilometre in tax. An electric car costs nothing. Also, registration is a flat fee irrespective of how far you travel or where or when you travel or how much you contribute to costly congestion and pollution in cities.
Trucks are already using telematics to work out how far they travelled and where and when they travelled so a road-use charge can be levied.
We should phase in the same technology for cars and do away with registration fees and fuel tax. In doing so, the road-use charge would be higher for higher-polluting or heavier cars.
We should also recognise that for every person who walks or cycles, it is one less car on the road, saving governments lots of taxpayers’ money. Investment in cycleways and footpaths should not be seen as pandering to cyclists and pedestrians but as helping motorists have freer roads.
However, the Coalition troglodytes do not think about these things because they are so hung up about coal that all principles about state ownership, user-pays, innovation, good economic management and smart industry policy go out the window and too bad about the wellbeing of a majority of Australians.
And that is irrespective of anything to do with climate change. Bad climate change policy is just collateral damage in what will become a major self-inflicted economic injury on Australia just so that the troglodytes’ mates and funders in the coal industry can be looked after.

Links

Climate Change And The Risk To Civilisation: The Doctors' Prescription

Fairfax - Colin Butler*

The 2018 State of the Climate report, released yesterday, again highlights the risk to human wellbeing from our love affair with fossil fuels. Coal, oil and gas have underpinned the incredible advances in affluence, population size, and health since development of the steam engine. But fossil fuel use has an optimum dose, which is now well past.
We are metaphorically drowning in carbon dioxide, the invisible, odourless waste product of burning fossil fuel. As the report notes, this is increasing heatwaves, acidifying the oceans and raising the sea level. It is also lowering the micronutrient concentrations of food.

An evacuation during the November bushfires, near Mount Larcom, Queensland. Credit: AAP
The report cites growing effects on human and animal health, including from increased fires and flooding, and says extreme heat days are rising alarmingly. This month, dozens of Australians were rescued from the Hume Highway, stranded by intense rainfall. Record heat and fire ravaged north Queensland. A third of the spectacled flying fox population died from heat, possibly exposing animal rescuers to viral diseases.
In November, San Francisco air was worse than Delhi, due to fires that ruined the Californian city of Paradise, recently home for 30,000 people.
Earlier this month, at the Katowice conference, held in the heartland of Polish coal seams, David Attenborough called climate change the greatest threat to humanity in thousands of years. He warned that, without action, “the collapse of our civilisations, and the extinction of much of the natural world, is on the horizon”.
Attenborough’s warnings have a distinguished pedigree. In 2010, Frank Fenner, the great Australian scientist who helped eradicate smallpox, warned that humans risked total extinction due to overpopulation, resource over-consumption, environmental destruction and climate change. Martin Rees, a past president of the world’s oldest scientific organisation, the Royal Society, has warned this century might be our last.
It might be comforting to dismiss these warnings as the fantasies of old men, and some wise old women, such as Jane Goodall. Optimists might argue that a rise of even 2 degrees in average global temperature is trivial, or point out that you could walk to Tasmania during the Ice Age. The sea-level rise of 10 thousand years ago was easily adapted to, and today our technological and social capacity is immeasurably greater. A fever of 2 extra degrees is uncomfortable, but we have paracetamol.
Such responses are deceptive and dangerous. The unprecedented complexity, connectivity and power of modern civilisation is also its weakness. Sea-level rise on the US east coast is already depressing the market value of homes and could help trigger a future financial crash. The UN’s Food and Agricultural Organisation is increasingly concerned about climate change, conflict and future food security. The 2010 heatwave and drought in Russia, which led to the temporary banning of Russian wheat exports, helped spark the Arab Spring and the Syrian civil war. The Australian winter harvest of 2018 was poor, especially from the eastern states, due not only to drought, but heat, reduced soil moisture and a lengthening frost season.
But the collapse of civilisation is not inevitable. Collapse might be avoided by a strong dose of preventive medicine, such as replacing coal with wind and solar, an electric bus revolution and reduced meat consumption (also good for health).

The threat of sea-level rise ... erosion at Old Bar, NSW. Credit: Shane Chalker
As with a real vaccine, which requires a tiny dose of something potentially harmful (technically known as an antigen) we seem to need a dose of poison (in this case fear) before we act; but too much fear is paralysing. We also need hope, such as provided by the NSW government’s recognition of our overdose on fossil fuels.
The physical climate is changing, so fast that more and more people, including many children, can now recognise it. If we can harness the internet, new technology, and the common sense of ordinary people then we will we at least have a reasonable chance. Recognising the validity of these warnings is a vital step if we are to survive.

*Colin Butler is an epidemiologist and member of the scientific advisory committee of Doctors for the Environment, Australia. He is an honorary professor in public health at the Australian National University.

Links

Saturday, December 22, 2018

Are Carbon Emissions Coming Down In Australia?

RMIT ABC Fact Check - Sushi Das | Ellen McCutchan

Former Howard government minister Amanda Vanstone says that emissions are coming down in Australia. (ABC News)
The claim

During a recent episode of the ABC's Q&A program, former Liberal minister Amanda Vanstone claimed "emissions are coming down" in Australia.
Her comment came a few days before a major UN climate summit, COP24, held in Katowice, Poland.
Other panellists on Q&A contradicted Ms Vanstone, saying emissions were rising. This prompted many viewers of the program to call on RMIT ABC Fact Check to investigate Ms Vanstone's claim.

The verdict
Ms Vanstone's claim is misleading.
Latest federal government figures suggest that although greenhouse gas emissions have fallen over the past 10 years, emissions started trending upwards again about four years ago.
The upturn, since 2014, has coincided with the Abbott government's removal of the carbon tax.
Also, while emissions from electricity production have been falling, the decrease has been outweighed over the past four years by rising emissions in other sectors of the economy, such as transport, where emissions are associated with increased LNG production for export.
Emissions can be measured in different ways: for example, as total emissions or emissions per capita or per GDP.
In the past year, Australia's total emissions have been rising. But emissions per capita or per dollar of real GDP have been falling, mainly due to Australia's rapid population growth.
However, it is worth noting that Australia's progress in cutting emissions under its international obligations (the Paris Agreement) is measured by changes in total emissions rather than by other measures.
As one expert put it: "The atmosphere doesn't care how many people are contributing to emissions; it's the total quantity of emissions that matters."

The context
Ms Vanstone made her claim during a discussion on Q&A about a protest by Australian schoolchildren titled 'Strike 4 Climate Action'.
She was speaking about the climate policies of Australia's two major political parties, and in the broader context of greenhouse gas emissions and their impact on the environment, as perceived by young people.
Emissions in the transport sector have increased over the long term. (AAP Image: Melanie Foster)
Ms Vanstone did not specify which kind of emissions she was talking about. Nor whether she was referring to simple totals or ratios.
Fact Check invited her to clarify this. She said she had not been expecting to talk about emissions: "I can't tell you that I had a particular tight construct in my head at the time," she said.
"I think I was just making a general remark about emissions generally over a long period of time."
Fact Check considers it reasonable to assume that her claim refers to Australia's total greenhouse gas emissions over the past 10 years — the length of time examined by the Government's most recent report on emissions.

What others are saying
Ms Vanstone is not alone in claiming emissions in Australia are decreasing, though other speakers have been more specific.
Liberal senator Linda Reynolds, also on Q&A, said carbon emissions per capita and by GDP were at their lowest levels in 28 years.
The electricity sector has seen emissions decreased in the year to September 2018. (ABC News: Jane Cowan)
Federal Environment Minister Melissa Price also highlighted this low in a press release announcing the Government's latest quarterly emissions data.
Nonetheless, she acknowledged that total emissions had risen over the year to June 2018.
Others have also pointed to the rise in total emissions.
Labor senator Lisa Singh, another of the recent Q&A panelists, argued that "emissions have continued to go up since 2011".
And on ABC radio the same week, Richie Merzian, the climate and energy director for think tank the Australia Institute said: "For the last four years, Australia's greenhouse gas emissions have been increasing."

Measuring emissions
The Australian Department of the Environment and Energy collects and publishes a series of reports and databases, known as the National Greenhouse Accounts.
The accounts track greenhouse gas emissions from 1990 onwards, and fulfil Australia's international reporting obligations under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and Kyoto Protocol.
Quarterly reports, released as part of the accounts, track total emissions as well as emissions by sector, per capita and per GDP.
The latest report, released three days before Ms Vanstone's Q&A appearance, provides estimates of Australia's national inventory of greenhouse gas emissions up to the June quarter of 2018.
The report examines emissions produced by eight sectors: electricity, stationary energy, transport, fugitive emissions (for example, leakages), industrial processes and product use, agriculture, waste, and land use, land use change and forestry.

Emissions from electricity production are falling
The report shows emissions in the electricity sector have fallen by 3.6 per cent in the year to September 2018.
This was driven by a 13 per cent reduction in brown coal supply and a corresponding 14 per cent increase in supply derived from renewable sources, it says.
But emissions from other sectors, such as transport, have been rising.
Hugh Saddler, an honorary associate professor at ANU's Crawford School of Public Policy, told Fact Check:
"Significant increases in emissions from petroleum and diesel consumption in transport, and gas consumption associated with LNG, have outweighed the decrease in emissions from the electricity sector."
What's going on with total emissions?
Over the year to June 2018, Australia's total greenhouse gas emissions rose in each quarter, according to the report.
Specifically, seasonally adjusted total emissions rose 1.3 per cent in the June quarter and by 0.6 per cent in the year to June 2018.
While emissions have fluctuated over the past four years, they have been trending upwards since late 2014, as the graph below shows. The data shows emissions have risen 5 per cent over this time.
Emissions touched their lowest point in March 2013, but have since rebounded to 2011 levels.
Under the Paris Climate Agreement, Australia has committed to a reduction in total greenhouse gas emissions of between 26 per cent and 28 per cent on 2005 levels by 2030.
According to the national greenhouse audit, total emissions are down 11.7 per cent on 2005 (the Paris Agreement base year) and 7.5 per cent since 1990 (the base year for Kyoto Protocol calculations). Why are people saying emissions are falling?
As shown above, total greenhouse emissions when measured quarterly over the past year, or by trend data over the past four years, have been rising.
So, why are some people arguing that emissions are going down?
Because, when emissions are measured per capita or per dollar of GDP, they are lower. This is because Australia is experiencing rapid population growth.
The Department of the Environment and Energy highlights this fall in both the preface to its latest quarterly greenhouse report and on its website.
The report states that emissions per capita and the emissions intensity of the Australian economy were at their lowest levels in 28 years, falling 37 per cent and 60 per cent respectively since 1990.

Are emissions per capita and per GDP useful measures?
Put simply, no.
Dr Saddler said focusing on emissions per capita was meaningless, since the measure used in international agreements was the more crucial total emissions.
"The atmosphere doesn't care how many people are contributing to emissions; it's the total quantity of emissions that matters," he said.
Professor David Karoly, an internationally recognised expert on climate change, said the emissions per capita was a useful measure when it allowed for country by country comparisons.
"The Australian per capita share at the moment is higher than any other developed country in the world — higher than the US. Yes, it's coming down, but it is still the highest."
Both Dr Saddler and Professor Karoly confirmed the fall in emissions per capita and GDP were due to rapid population growth in Australia.

Experts assess the claim
Professor Karoly said if Amanda Vanstone's claim was made in reference to total Australian emissions, "they are going up".
He noted that the start of the recent rebound in emissions from mid-2014 coincided with the dumping of the carbon tax by the Abbott government in July of that year.
Professor Mark Howden, the director of ANU's Climate Change Institute, told Fact Check: "I think it is correct to say that Australian emissions were coming down, but are now rising steadily."
He said an argument could be made that emissions have come down, given they are lower now than at their peak between 2005 and 2008.
"However, this is a problematic argument," he said.
"Under the current mix of policies and economic activities, emissions are clearly not coming down but instead are rising steadily."
Pep Canadell, a senior principal research scientist in the CSIRO Climate Science Centre, and the executive director of the Global Carbon Project, suggested that 1990 was a good reference year for gleaning a long-term view of changes to emissions.

"Good annual data only starts from 1990, which is the reference year of the Kyoto Protocol and why the Government started the good quality data then," Dr Canadell said.
Emissions per capita have fallen 37 per cent since 1990.
However, Dr Canadell added:
"Given Ms Vanstone's statement is present tense, I disagree [that emissions are falling]. According to the data, emissions have been going up since 2013, with ups and downs, and, if anything, accelerating recently."
Links

Australia’s Carbon Emissions Highest On Record, Data Shows

The Guardian - 

If emissions continue at current rate, Australia will miss Paris target by 1.1bn tonnes, Ndevr Environmental predicts
The Bluescope steel works at Port Kembla, Wollongong. Australia is still on track to miss its Paris target of a 26%-28% cut to carbon emissions on 2005 levels by 2030. The latest data show emissions are again the highest on record. Photograph: Ashley Cooper pics / Alamy/Alamy
Australia’s carbon emissions are again the highest on record, according to new data from the emissions-tracking organisation Ndevr Environmental.
Ndevr replicates the federal government’s national greenhouse gas inventory (NGGI) quarterly reports but releases them months ahead of the official data.
Data it has produced for the year up to September 2018 shows Australia is still on track to miss its Paris target of a 26%-28% cut to emissions on 2005 levels by 2030.
Matt Drum, the managing director of Ndevr, said if emissions continued at their current rate, Australia would miss the target by a cumulative 1.1bn tonnes.
When excluding unreliable land use data, Australia’s emissions for the year to September reached 558.3m tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent, an all-time high.
Land use data refers to emissions from activities such as land clearing and forest management, as well as removal of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere through activities such as reforestation.
Ndevr excludes land use data because the methodology the government uses to calculate these figures is opaque and there have been questions about whether the scale of land-clearing in Queensland is being accurately represented.


“There’s still no policy in place to ratchet them down which is why they’re increasing,” Drum said.
Electricity sector emissions were stable, but fugitive emissions, and emissions from stationary energy and transport are all still trending sharply upwards.


Release of the report comes as the environment minister, Melissa Price, addressed global COP24 climate change talks in Katowice, Poland.
Both the Coalition government and Labor have not ruled out using controversial carryover credits from the Kyoto protocol to help meet Australia’s obligations under the Paris agreement.
Labor has promised that if it wins the election it will increase Australia’s target to 45% on 2005 levels, in line with recommendations from the independent Climate Change Authority.
Ndevr’s analysis said this would require a reduction of 197.1m tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent based on current emissions levels, which would be equal to taking 75m cars off the road for a year.
In comparison, the Coalition’s emission reduction target would require an 80.8m tonne reduction.
Breaking up Labor’s target across sectors, Ndever suggests a range of reductions will be necessary in several industries, including 61.2m tonnes from the electricity sector, 33.4m tonnes from the stationary energy sector, 23.7m tonnes from agriculture and 34.2m tonnes from transport.
“If Labor come into government we can’t afford a policy vacuum,” Drum said. “It’s looking grim. We need policy levers and we need them quickly.”
Drum said the need for action was so urgent there would be no time for a full redesign of policy if there was a change of government.
Instead, he said existing policies, such as the safeguard mechanism, should be amended.
“They need to utilise existing policy like the safeguard mechanism and tweak it so it achieves what it is intended to achieve, which is reduce emissions,” he said.
On Thursday, the Greens environment spokesperson, Sarah Hanson-Young, said Australia was using “creative emissions accounting” to try to meet its Paris targets.
“Counting Kyoto credit towards Paris cheats our environment and the rest of the world,” she said.
“Our emissions are going up, yet our environment minister is telling the world we are doing our bit to meet our Paris targets.”

Links

Australia To Miss 2030 Emissions Target By Massive Margin

Fairfax - Eryk Bagshaw

Australia is set to fall significantly short of its Paris climate change targets, undermining claims by the Morrison government that the economy will meet its international obligations "in a canter."
Official figures released by the Department of Environment and Energy on Friday show that on current trends Australia will only reach an emission reduction target of 7 per cent on 2005 levels by 2030, a massive 19 percentage points or two thirds of the way short of the minimum target mandated by the Paris agreement.
But the government will argue that under UN accounting rules, Australia is eligible to carry forward credit for targets it has met since 2008 - a move ruled out by Britain, Germany and New Zealand - slashing in half the emissions reductions required to meet our international obligations.
Environment Minister Melissa Price. Credit:Alex Ellinghausen
Hours after the release of the figures Prime Minister Scott Morrison confirmed the government would carry forward the credits and said the "significant progress highlights Australia is going to meet our 2030 target in a canter".
"The suite of policies our government has put in place support the environment while also delivering on our plan for a stronger economy," he said.
Up until last week, neither the Coalition nor Labor would rule out counting Australia's expected credits from beating its 2020 goal under the Kyoto Protocol against its 2030 Paris pledge.
Greens climate change spokesman Adam Bandt accused the government of "cooking the books" and shirking their environmental obligations.
"Because they can't reduce emissions, the government is resorting to dodgy accounting to meet our measly Paris targets," he said.
The new figures, released on the Friday before Christmas, show Australia is on track to beat its Kyoto commitments for 2020 by at least 240 million tonnes of carbon dioxide.
But a boom in LNG production, a population driven transport surge and an increase in beef production means it would fall short of the 2030 target by as much as 695 million tonnes on current projections.
Barring international objections to the Morrison government's decision, the UN accounting rules are expected to halve that task, with the 26 to 28 per cent target effectively turning into a 15 per cent cut on 2005 levels.
Environment Minister Melissa Price said the figures were a "great result for the environment".
"We have over-achieved on our 2020 target and are well on our way to meeting our commitment to the Paris Agreement 2030 target, all while maintaining a strong economy," she said.
The electricity sector has led the 73 million tonnes in projected reductions since the 2017 report, with an increase in demand from a growing population is expected to be met by continued growth in rooftop solar and thermal generation.
Still way off target
Australia’s 2018 emissions trends compared with 2017 projections.
Source: Department of Environment, December 2018

The reductions mean emissions from the national electricity market are on track to be 26 per cent below 2005 levels - a claim frequently made by Mr Morrison and Energy Minister Angus Taylor. Electricity only accounts for 34 per cent of Australia’s emissions, with transport and stationary energy accounting for 19 per cent and agriculture 13 per cent.
"There is no electricity emissions target in Australian or international law," said the Australian Conservation Foundation’s economics program manager, Matt Rose.
"Australia has an economy-wide 2030 goal that takes in electricity, transport, heavy industry and other sectors."
The report shows the drought affecting much of the east coast will restrict agriculture activity, leading to a short-term 1 per cent drop in emissions, mostly from fewer cows emitting methane gas.
The fall is only expected to be temporary as grain-fed cows increasingly replace pasture-based cows.
"The projections have accounted for an assumed increase in grain-fed beef cattle in feedlots due to these cattle being less susceptible to drought," the department's report said.
"Grain fed cattle are more emissions intensive, due to increased energy intake and increased concentration of manure in feedlots."
Minerals Council chief executive Tania Constable said addressing climate change required a diverse future energy mix that balances affordability, reliability and emissions reduction.
"This is why a measured response is critical to reducing greenhouse emissions in a way which does not damage the economy, destroy jobs and hurt Australian businesses and families," she said.
Environmental experts have warned that the 26 to 28 per cent reduction target still won't be enough to keep the world from warming by more than 2 degrees by the middle of the century.
Labor will take its policy of a 45 per cent reduction target on 2005 levels by 2030 to the next election.
"It is clear the Liberals are burying their heads in the sand and ignoring the vast majority of Australians who are crying out for desperate action on climate change," said Labor's climate spokesman Mark Butler.
The government claims a 45 per cent target will hurt workers and businesses.

Links

Friday, December 21, 2018

Australia Experiencing More Heat, Longer Fire Seasons And Rising Oceans

The Guardian - 

State of the climate report points to a long-term increase in the frequency of extreme heat events, fire weather and drought
Australia’s fire seasons are longer and more severe, the Bureau of Meteorology and CSIRO’s state of the climate report has found. Photograph: Qfes Media/PR image
Australia is experiencing more extreme heat, longer fire seasons, rising oceans and more marine heatwaves consistent with a changing climate, according to the Bureau of Meteorology and CSIRO’s state of the climate report.
The report, published every two years, measures the long-term variability and trends observed in Australia’s climate.
The 2018 report shows that Australia’s long-term warming trend is continuing, with the climate warming by just over 1C since 1910 when records began.
That warming is contributing to a long-term increase in the frequency of extreme heat events, fire weather and drought.
“Australia is already experiencing climate change now and there are impacts being experienced or felt across many communities and across many sectors,” said Helen Cleugh, the director of the CSIRO’s climate science centre.
The report’s key findings include:
  1. Australia’s fire seasons have lengthened and become more severe. In some parts of the country, the season has been extended by months.
  2. The number of extreme heat days continues to trend upward.
  3. There has been a shift to drier conditions in south-eastern and south-western Australia in the months from April to October.
  4. Rainfall across northern Australia has increased since the 1970s, particularly during the tropical wet season in north-western Australia.
  5. Oceans around Australia have warmed by about 1C since 1910, which is leading to longer and more frequent marine heatwaves that affect marine life such as corals.
  6. Sea levels around Australia have risen by more than 20cm since records began and the rate of sea level rise is accelerating.
  7. There has been a 30% increase in the acidity of Australian oceans since the 1800s and the current rate of change “is ten times faster than at any time in the past 300 million years”.
Karl Braganza, the bureau of meteorology’s manager of climate monitoring, said the increase in average temperature was having an impact on the frequency or amount of extremes Australia experienced in any given year.
“In general there’s been around a five-fold increase in extreme heat and that is consistent whether you look at monthly temperatures, day time temperatures or night time temperatures,” he said.
Annual mean temperature anomaly, Australia
Temperature anomaly is the difference between the average temperature from 1961–1990 and the average temperature in a given year. Guardian graphic | Source: Bureau of Meteorology
He said there had been a reduction in rainfall of 20% in south-western Australia and in some places that was as high as 26%. In south-eastern Australia, April to October rainfall had fallen by 11%.
The report also highlights an increase in the number of extreme fire danger days in many parts of Australia, particularly in southern and eastern Australia.
Extreme heat days per year in Australia
Number of days each year where the Australian area-averaged daily mean temperature is extreme. Extreme days are those above the 99th percentile of each month from the years 1910–2017 Source: State of the Climate report
Braganza said there was a “clear shift” towards a lengthened fire season, more fire weather during that season and an increase in its severity.
“Often the worst fire weather occurs when you’ve had long-term drought, long-term above-average temperatures, maybe a short-term heatwave and then the meteorology that’s consistent with severe fire weather and the ability for fire to spread,” he said.
“It’s those types of compound events that are going to be most challenging going forward in terms of adapting to climate change in Australia.”
Change in fire weather conditions
Trends from 1978 to 2017 in the annual (July to June) sum of the daily Forest Fire Danger Index — an indicator of the severity of fire weather conditions. Positive trends, shown in the yellow to red colours, are indicative of an increasing length and intensity of the fire weather season. Source: State of the Climate report
David Cazzulino, the Great Barrier Reef campaigner for the Australian Marine Conservation Society, said the report confirmed what many Australians already knew about the rising risks of climate change.
“The big line around oceans warming one degree since 1910 is a huge wake-up call,” he said.
“It’s undeniable that warming oceans lead to more marine heatwaves, coral bleaching and coral mortality.”
He said the impact of climate change on the Great Barrier Reef, and climate change policy generally, would be a key campaign issue ahead of the 2019 federal election.
“We are running out of time to keep warming to a safe degree for the reef to have a future,” Cazzulino said.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative