1,123 jurisdictions in 20 countries have declared a climate
emergency.
Populations covered by jurisdictions that have declared a
climate emergency amount to 285 million citizens, with 47 million of
these living in the United Kingdom.
This means in Britain now roughly 70
per cent of the population lives in areas that have declared a climate
emergency.
In New Zealand, the percentage is even higher: 74 per cent of
the population.
It’s around 25 per cent in countries like Switzerland
and Italy.
National Declarations
On 29 April 2019, the first parliament in the world to declare a climate emergency at the national level was the Welsh Parliament. Some say it was Scotland, though, because on 28 April 2019, the First Minister of Scotland declared a climate emergency on behalf of her government at an annual Scottish National Party conference.
On 1 May 2019, the United Kingdom Labour Party got unanimous support for a non-binding motion in favour of a climate emergency declaration in the House of Commons, claiming Britain thereby was the first country in the world where a bipartisan parliament had declared a climate emergency.
On 3 May 2019, the Gibraltar Parliament followed, and the government of the Republic of Ireland announced their declaration on 9 May. The next day, the Isle of Man parliament declared a climate emergency as well.
The Parliament of Portugal declared a climate emergency on 7 June 2019, the Canadian House of Commons followed on 17 June 2019, and the French parliament a climate emergency on 27 June 2019. Argentina followed on 17 July 2019.
Local Governments
On the list below are only included jurisdictions that have passed a binding
motion declaring a climate emergency. As such, the non-binding motion
instigated by UK Labour, for example, is not included in this data.
Typical resolutions include setting up a process to develop an action
plan and report back to council within three to six months.
Australia
In Australia, where the climate emergency declaration mobilisation and
petition was launched in May 2016, over 60 jurisdictions representing
roughly 6 million people – a quarter of the population – have declared a
climate emergency, including the government of the Australian Capital
Territory, based in the capital Canberra.
More than 100 of the candidates in the 18 May 2019 federal
election had signed the Climate Emergency Declaration petition.
Julian Cribb is a distinguished science writer with more than thirty
awards for journalism. He was a newspaper editor, founder of the
influential ScienceAlert website and is the author of 10 books:
In all the sound
and fury over climate change, too little public and media attention
has been devoted to the ‘methane gun’ – and yet this terrifying phenomenon could usher humans
unceremoniously off Earth’s stage for good.
Like CO2, methane
(CH4) is a greenhouse gas that helps trap the sun’s heat within the
Earth’s atmosphere. The big difference is that it is 25-84 times
more potent at doing so.
The planet has
massive stores of methane, locked as frozen ice in the seabed (the
world’s largest natural gas reserve), in the frozen soils of the
Canadian, US and Russian Arctic, and buried in the sediments of
tropical swamps and peatlands. Like the bubbles in a stagnant pond,
the gas is mostly the work of bacteria digesting organic matter over
millions of years.
How large these
reserves of methane are is still a matter for scientific debate –
but estimates fall between 1.5 and 5 trillion tonnes. Very, very
large indeed. If released suddenly, these are thought more than
capable of driving the Earth’s temperature up by another 7-10
degrees, on top of the 2-5 degrees likely to result from human
emissions from burning fossil fuels and clearing land (currently
rising at record rates).
The worst-case
scenario – a large-scale, rapid release of trapped gas known as the
‘methane gun’ – could potentially render the Earth
uninhabitable by humans and other large animals. This is why we need
to pay attention. Now.
What has some
scientists concerned – and others frightened – is that
atmospheric levels of methane which have doubled since the Industrial
Revolution and have been rising for steadily for the past 30 years,
began to rise more steeply in the past five years, as the following
graph shows:
Atmospheric methane concentrations up to October 2019: Mauna Loa Observatory, USA.
The source of the
new methane is debated. Is it mainly caused by the mining of natural
gas, petroleum and coal – as several lines of evidence suggest? Is
it released by expanding world cattle and rice production, the
draining of tropical swamps and burning of tropical forests? Is it
the frozen gas seeping out of the oceans and tundra as the planet
warms and its ice vanishes? Or is it all of the above? The evidence
is starting to favour the latter view – but the scientific jury remains undecided.
We know that a
mass-release of methane can be catastrophic for life on Earth,
because that’s exactly what took place 55 million years ago in an
event known as PETM - the Palaeocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum - when
global temperatures shot up by 5-10 degrees, wiping out a number of
species. There were no humans round then to release carbon, so it was probably
due to one or more of the natural sources rapidly giving up its gas.
Recently opinion has narrowed in favour of tropical swamps and
peatlands drying out and catching fire during a warming cycle, as the
main source. The frozen methane, apparently, remained largely
undisturbed in the ocean and tundra.
But that is not
the case today. Not only are tropical forests burning and swamps
being drained, but scientists have observed major escapes of methane
from the Arctic tundra in the form of exploding pingos – mounts of
frozen methane, mud and water – and the eruption of melted methane
ice from the seabed. In October 2019 veteran Russian researcher Igor
Semiletor, from Tomsk Polytechnic University, reported “the most
powerful seep I have ever been able to observe” venting in a potent
eruption of gas bubbles in the East Siberian Sea.
Two years
earlier, in June 2017, Russian reindeer herders reported a violent
explosion that left a 50- metre deep crater in the tundra of the
Yamal Peninsula, Siberia, which scientists attributed to a methane
blast. In recent years researchers have reported numerous craters
left by explosions across Siberia, the Canadian and Alaskan tundra –
and even craters in the seabed. Many are recent – but some are up
to 12,000 years old, and still leaking gas. Therein lies the
uncertainty: are the methane explosions observed today part of a
process that occurs more or less constantly through Earth history –
or do they represent the start of a sudden release, ramping up to
runaway global warming? The scientific jury is at odds.
Methane hydrate, a frozen form of methane gas, at one of the many cold seeps off the U.S. Atlantic coast. Hydrate is widespread in the deep ocean and sequesters as much as 20% of all carbon on Earth. NOAA Office of Ocean Exploration and Research
Pennsylvania
State climate scientist Prof Michael Mann, for instance,
characterises the methane bomb idea as “catastrophism” and claims
it is being exploited by the climate denial lobby to discredit
climate theory generally. He says the amount of methane released will
be “small compared to human emissions” of carbon. Other scientists, like Gavin Schmidt of the NASA Goddard Institute,
argue that it is highly unlikely that a large volume of seabed
methane would be released suddenly, i.e. over a period less than
thousands of years, because it did not do so in past warming events.
Instead it will continue to trickle out.
Oceanography and
ice expert Prof Peter Wadhams disagrees. He says loss of Arctic sea
ice from the shallow continental margins could trigger such a release
which “could happen very suddenly and … is the greatest single
threat that we face”. He says that mainstream science, represented
by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), does not
generally recognise the threat.
Australian
National University earth scientist Prof. Andrew Glikson cites the
Global Carbon project finding that there are 1.4 trillion tonnes of
accumulated methane stored on land and 16 trillion tonnes in the
ocean, available for release if the planet grew warm enough, and this
‘could have catastrophic effects on the biosphere’. He points
out there is already clear evidence for the explosive release of
methane, on land and at sea. With Arctic temperatures already 3-8
degrees warmer due to global warming, the risks of a sudden methane
release “have not yet been fully accounted for in climate projections.”
At temperatures
above +4 degrees, many scientists now consider the risk is increasing
of the planet becoming partly or wholly uninhabitable to humans and
large animals. Certainly, such heat and climate instability would
destroy most of our current food production systems, spilling
billions of climate refugees across the planet and causing wars to
break out between and within nation states.
How many would
die in such an event is not knowable, because we cannot predict how
humans will respond, how many wars we will start, or how many nukes
we will unleash in the ensuing chaos. Potsdam Institute climatologist
John Schellnhuber has said: “At 4 C Earth’s... carrying capacity
estimates are below 1 billion people.” Prof Kevin Anderson of the
U.K.’s Tyndall Centre for Climate Change concurs: “Only about 10
per cent of the planet’s population would survive at 4 C.”
Several scientists have voiced the view that the human population
will be reduced from 9-10 billion to around 1-3 billion in the long
run.
We already know
that our physical survival is in jeopardy in extended periods above
35 degrees Celsius – that is, where daytime temperatures constantly
reach 40-50 degrees C or more. Such temperatures will occur
frequently with +7 degrees of global warming and will render large
parts of the earth uninhabitable – including the most heavily
populated. Above +12 degrees of global warming, human survival
becomes physically impossible. However long before our heat tolerance limits are reached, local and
global food and water supplies will collapse, prompting mass
migration and war. Without urgent worldwide action, the global
economy – and with it civilized society – are predicted to go
down as we approach +4 degrees. Such warnings come, not from ‘radical
greens’, but from authorities no less conservative than Bank of
England governor Marc Carney,
who states that the global financial system is currently investing in
catastrophe by backing new fossil fuel projects. These numbers represent the current most-informed estimates of the
impact of the unfolding climate crisis, should world efforts to halt
it fail and should the climate deniers triumph.
Methane bubbles out of the seafloor off the coast of Virginia, north of Washington Canyon. NOAA Office of Ocean Exploration and Research
The risk for
humanity posed by the ‘methane gun’ is that rapid global
mass-release may be ‘locked and loaded’ and firing before we
have sufficient scientific data to confirm it. It is, as they say, an
event of low probability – but very high impact. Is it a risk that
a rational person would take?
Once the gun has
begun to fire, there is practically nothing humans can do to stop it.
It will unleash other dangerous feedbacks, potentially leading to
runaway warming. It will shift the planet from its present warming
state to a ‘hothouse Earth’ state where human survival comes into question.
The only viable
strategy – possibly – is preventative: to move civilization far
faster towards total elimination of all fossil fuels and land
clearing worldwide – and plant billions of trees as quickly as
possible, to slow the global warming trend before it triggers the
methane gun.
This means that
countries like America, Australia, Brazil and Russia must cease their
dangerous do-nothing policies, and stop mining coal, oil and gas, and
clearing land. Countries like India and China need to cease building
coal-fired power stations immediately. And every country needs to
scale back carbon emissions on an accelerated time-scale from
transport, agriculture, concrete and industry.
While some
scientists urge geoengineering solutions, such as the artificial
release of sulphate aerosol particles to erect a giant sunshade over
the Earth, this represents a counsel of despair. It means allowing
the atmosphere to attain virtual temperatures that would cook humans,
then trying to chill them down with a planet-sized ‘air-conditioner’.
The consequences, should our air conditioner fail, would be terminal.
That really only leaves us with the option of trying to contain
global warming by eliminating human carbon emissions – before the
methane gun fires.
In the end, the
worst that can happen by banning fossil fuels and regreening the
planet is that we get a new clean energy system, cheaper energy,
renewed economic growth and a more sustainable Earth.
If the climate
deniers – fifty huge energy corporates and their political and
media cheer squad – get their way, the worst that can happen is
human extinction.
Which risk do you
prefer?
A farmer who installed solar panels to power his irrigation
systems on the family farm walks by the panels near Claresholm, Alta.,
in June 2019.
THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
There is a simple irony in dealing with climate change. To get a
handle on the problem means that, at a certain level, the conversation
has to move away from climate change. What does that mean?
The secretary general of Amnesty International shed some light on
this apparent contradiction ahead of September’s United Nations climate
change conference in New York.
“I think one of the catastrophic mistakes we made in 1992, when the
Rio Earth Summit happened, was framing our response to the threat of
climate change solely or primarily as an environmental issue,” Kumi Naidoo said on the news program Democracy Now!
“I think we needed to have done then what we are trying to do now …
which is to ensure that we bring a cross-cutting understanding of
climate change and bring a more human-centric approach to addressing
(it).”
This means, Naidoo said, dealing with climate change by focusing on human rights and on reducing inequality.
Broadening the climate conversation
When it comes to climate-related economic issues, news narratives
typically focus on the trade-off between jobs and protecting the
environment.
That was one of the findings of a December 2018 study
by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives. “Although they tend to
choose different sides, mainstream and alternative media both frequently
reinforce the assumption that there is an inevitable trade-off between
environmental protection and job creation,” the study concluded.
What if the discussion in the news media, and in politics, instead
focused on what a post-carbon economy would actually look like, and,
crucially, how such an economy would actually thrive? It’s the vision of
a society and of a prosperous, modern economy that has climate change baked into it.
But how does the world actually get there, especially when mitigating
climate change is still largely seen as an impediment to economic
growth?
Better climate change communication is a good place to start.
Making the uncomfortable comfortable
Mitigating climate change is often seen in the context of making
choices that can be undesirable: flying less, buying less, ditching the
car.
Instead, the choices people must make to fight climate change can be
framed as enjoyable, desirable or even moral, instead of avoidable. In
other words, things that people actually want to do.
To make that shift, University of Michigan sustainability professor Andy Hoffman argues for a “consensus-based”
approach to climate change. Such an approach treats climate change as a
cultural issue instead of simply as a scientific and environmental
problem. It “frames climate change mitigation as a gain rather than a
loss to specific cultural groups,” Hoffman writes. He adds:
“To be effective, climate communicators must use the language of the cultural community they are engaging.”
It’s important to speak to people about climate change through values that make sense to them.
Stories of people taking action that others around them can relate to
also have a huge impact. A neighbour enjoying their electric vehicle
(and saving on gas) has a far more persuasive influence over other
residents on the block than an expert on the news telling people they
need to drive less.
A neighbour’s love of her electric car is likely a lot more compelling than experts urging people to drive electric vehicles. Shutterstock
A different narrative
When it comes to climate change coverage, doom and gloom is usually the lead. There is also a heavy emphasis in conventional climate journalism on individual lifestyle changes.
Instead, climate journalism can play a much more important role in
painting the picture of how a post-carbon economy might actually work.
That process can begin with a conversation around solutions that are
already being implemented, especially those that are happening through
collective action and a sense of empowerment.
A great example is a recent Global News report on the T’Sou-ke Nation on Vancouver Island, a community that is taking renewable energy production into its own hands. Or a story in Maclean’s magazine about an Ontario town that is working toward a greener future.
These forms of storytelling
are crucial for the conversation to shift toward a new default
position: climate change as the current upon which the economy rides.
Ultimately, it will require political will for the world to get there.
But support is building, and it’s the masses who are leading the way.
“If you actually look at the most beautiful parts of our histories,
it’s mass movements, it’s collectives, it’s groundswells,” author and
activist Rebecca Solnit recently said on CBC Radio’s The Current.
“We need a framework in which maybe everybody is potentially a hero,
and it’s not the exceptional but the ordinary people who change the
world.”
As stories about collective action become a more prominent feature of
climate journalism, so too will climate change start to feel more
accessible and less scary. In the near future, climate change will not
be something big, distant and seemingly impossible to overcome.
Instead, it will just be a fact of life around which everything else
revolves, including human rights, jobs and the economy. The best climate
change story, in other words, may very well not be a climate change
story at all.
Climate science can be complex, and misinformation in politics and the media can make it difficult to sort fact from fiction. Here, we’ve answered eight common climate change questions, including what’s causing climate change, what scientists are saying and what we can do about it. Read on to get up to speed.
1. What is climate change? Climate is different from weather. When we talk about the Earth’s climate, we are referring to the average weather conditions over a period of 30 years or longer. Weather, on the other hand, refers to what you see and feel outside from day to day (e.g. sunny, rainy). So climate change is any change in the climate, lasting for several decades or longer, including changes in temperature, rainfall or wind patterns.
And according to science, our climate is changing quite dramatically – it’s getting hotter.
Long-term air and ocean temperature records clearly show the Earth is warming. The global average temperature has already risen by 1.1°C since the pre-industrial period. This might not sound like a lot, but 1.1°C represents a massive amount of extra heat and energy – the equivalent of four Hiroshima bomb detonations per second.
While the earth’s climate has changed throughout history, scientists agree that the significant changes we’ve seen over the past hundred years or so have been due to human activities. Recent warming is also happening at a rate that is much faster than previous climatic changes.
Temperature Anomalies by Country 1880-2017 based on NASA GISTEMP data. By Antti Lipponen.
2. What is causing climate change?
The short answer is, the excessive amount of greenhouse gases entering the Earth’s atmosphere due to human activity is causing our climate to change dramatically. But there’s more to it than that.
Let’s break it down. A certain amount of greenhouse gases (like water vapour, ozone, carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous dioxide) occur naturally. For example, carbon dioxide is produced by plants, or decaying organic matter (biomass). These greenhouse gases act like a blanket in our atmosphere, trapping some of the sun’s heat close to the Earth’s surface. This is known as the ‘greenhouse effect’ – and it makes the planet warm enough for us to live.
But since the Industrial Revolution (which began in the mid to late 1700s), greenhouse gases have built up in the atmosphere, which is trapping more heat close to the earth’s surface. This is because humans began digging up and burning coal, oil and gas, as well as scaling up agriculture and tree-clearing (deforestation), and increasing waste (landfill), which are all processes that produce greenhouse gases.
As more greenhouse gases are added to the Earth’s atmosphere, more of the sun’s heat is trapped and this causes the Earth’s average temperature to rise.
Carbon dioxide is the most significant of all the greenhouse gases, followed by methane. Carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere have increased by more than 45% since the Industrial Revolution and are now the highest they have been for at least 800,000 years.
3. How is climate change affecting Australia?
Australia is one of the most vulnerable developed countries in the world to the impacts of climate change, which include:
Increased frequency and/or severity of extreme weather events including floods and droughts
More frequent, more intense and longer-lasting heatwaves. Heatwaves are deadly, having killed more people than all other extreme weather events in Australia combined.
Greater risk and severity of bushfires and earlier, longer bushfire seasons
Impacts on wildlife due to heat stress, drought and habitat changes, which have flow-on effects down the food chain. Australia holds the first record of a mammalian extinction due to climate change.
More frequent marine heatwaves, which impact marine ecosystems such as the Great Barrier Reef. After the back-to-back marine heatwaves in 2016 and 2017, 50% of the coral on the Great Barrier Reef died.
Impacts on health due to changes in air pollution and aeroallergens (such as pollen), vector-borne diseases, extreme weather events and other factors
Increased pressure on emergency services and health systems, as the fire seasons of states and territories increasingly overlap which stretches resources, and the health impacts of climate change worsen
Agricultural impacts from more frequent droughts, floods and heatwaves
We are already experiencing these impacts today, at a rise in temperature of just 1.1 ̊C since the pre-industrial period. In 2019, Australia has seen devastating floods in Townsville, an early start to the bushfire season damaging properties and burning through untouched rainforests in NSW and QLD, and an ongoing drought which has threatened the food and water security of Australians for many years.
The risks to our wellbeing and livelihoods, and to other species and ecosystems, become much more profound as temperatures continue to rise.
Read more about droughts, bushfires and other extreme weather events in Australia here.
4. Why do only a few degrees of warming matter? A few degrees of warming is incredibly significant.
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) strongly recommends limiting the global temperature increase to 1.5°C, to avoid the impacts of climate change steeply escalating. Even at 1.5°C of global warming, times will be tough. But the impacts amplify rapidly between just 1.5°C and 2°C of temperature increase, as visible in the following infographic.
To avoid the impacts we’d experience at 2 degrees warming, we have no other choice but to limit our warming to 1.5 ̊C. It is still possible, but only if we act now. If nothing changes, we are on track for a rise in temperatures of between 4-6 ̊C. To put this in context, the difference in temperatures between now and the last ice age was around 4 ̊C. The Paris Agreement (a universal agreement involving over 190 countries committing to limit global warming to well below 2°C and to pursue efforts to limit warming to 1.5 ̊C) is an important step towards addressing the global challenge of climate change. But with the current pledges that countries have put forward, the world is on track for at least 3.2 ̊C of warming by the end of the century. Read more about limiting temperature rise to 1.5 degrees here.
5. How do scientists know the climate is changing? Scientists collect data about the climate by testing a number of things: air and ocean temperature, precipitation (rain, snow), sea level, ocean salinity and acidity, tree rings, marine sediments, and pollen, to name a few.
Ice cores from Antarctica are incredibly helpful in showing how the climate has changed over time, because they can provide a record of what the level of greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide and methane were in our atmosphere in the past, as well as providing clues about past temperatures. Ice core data stretches back 800,000 years and shows that the concentration of greenhouse gases in our atmosphere over this period never increased so quickly, or by so much, as during this era of human influence.
Carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere over the past 800,000 years, based off data from ice cores. C02 levels have never been as high as they are now. Source: NOAA
Pulling all of this data together, scientists have concluded that humans have been driving the significant changes in climate that we are currently experiencing. The evidence that supports anthropogenic (human-caused) climate change is vast and includes many lines of evidence published in tens of thousands of peer-reviewed journal articles.
6. What are the main sources of greenhouse gas emissions in Australia?
There are eight major areas (sectors) in Australia responsible for our greenhouse gas emissions:
Electricity (emissions from burning coal and gas to power our lights, appliances and more)
Transport (emissions from petrol and diesel used to power cars, trucks and buses, and emissions from aviation fuel used to power planes)
Stationary energy (fuels like gas consumed directly, rather than used for electricity, in industry and in households)
Agriculture (greenhouse gases such as methane and nitrous oxide produced by animals, manure management, fertilisers and field burning)
Fugitive emissions (gases leaked or vented from fossil fuel extraction and transportation)
Industrial processes (emissions produced by converting raw materials into metal, mineral and chemical products)
Waste (methane from decaying organic matter)
Land use, land use change and forestry (LULUCF) (emissions and removals mainly from forests, but also from croplands, grasslands, wetlands and other lands).
Australia’s greenhouse gas emissions by sector, 2019. Electricity is the largest source of greenhouse gas emissions in Australia, responsible for 32% of emissions. This is mainly because 84% of our electricity comes from burning fossil fuels, the large majority of which (62.3%) comes from coal. Fortunately, Australia is the sunniest and one of the windiest countries in the world, which means we are perfectly placed to generate our electricity from renewable energy sources, like solar and wind. Updating Australia’s energy system with renewables and storage is crucial for cutting our greenhouse gas emissions and combating climate change. Source: March 2019 quarterly updates.
7. What can Australia do to combat climate change?
Although we are already experiencing the consequences of climate change today, we also have the solutions to address it. Australia urgently needs to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions as part of a strong global effort. But currently, emissions in Australia and globally are still rising.
The IPCC has suggested that the world must cut carbon dioxide emissions to net zero by no later than 2050 to have a chance of limiting warming to 1.5 ̊C. This means that global carbon dioxide emissions have to start dropping now, and be on a path to fall by at least 45% below 2010 levels by 2030. Methane and other greenhouse gas emissions must drop steeply as well. For this goal to be achievable, we have to start driving down all emissions across all sectors now.
Australia’s greenhouse gas emissions (excluding land use) have been rising consistently for five years since 2014, and are at the highest levels on record.
Here are the easiest, most efficient and cost-effective ways for Australia to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions:
Electricity Rapidly transitioning away from fossil fuel generated electricity to renewable energy and storage technologies is the quickest and cheapest way to reduce emissions. In Australia and many other countries, new renewable energy is now cheaper than new coal (over its lifetime), and global investment in coal has plummeted by 75% in three years.
Transport Avoiding dangerous climate change doesn’t start and end with changing electricity. We also need to electrify our transport systems – like buses, cars, trains and trams – and power them with 100% renewable electricity too. Transport makes up around 19% of Australia’s greenhouse gas emissions, but these emissions can be reduced by: improving public transport’s quality, efficiency and accessibility, encouraging active transport (such as cycling and walking), and building infrastructure (like vehicle charging stations), to encourage people to use electric vehicles.
Agriculture Agriculture contributes roughly 13% of Australia’s emissions, and deforestation accounts for around 9% of Australia’s emissions. But climate solutions like reforestation and regenerative agriculture can increase how much carbon is stored in soils and vegetation, removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.
Fossil fuels Australia needs to actively transition away from fossil fuels like coal, oil and gas, including those we export. As the second largest exporter of both thermal coal (which is burned to generate electricity) and gas, Australia has a huge influence on global emissions and the fossil fuel market. If we include all the fossil fuels that Australia exports, Australia is the fifth biggest polluter in the world – so we’re a big deal when it comes to climate change. Australia should not approve any new fossil fuel projects, and must actively phase out existing projects to reduce emissions. This process has to support fossil fuel-dependent communities and workers – and make sure that they have opportunities to move into other industries.
8. Where can I find out more?
The Climate Council has created a range of science-backed materials to further explain the causes, impacts and solutions to climate change. Take a look at our Reports,Videos and Infographics. Links
National Geographic - Peter Schwartzstein
Farmers around the world rely on millennia-old wisdom to guide their planting. Scrambled weather and seasons are forcing them into uncharted territory.
A farmer on the Hopi Indian Reservation in Arizona inspects his corn crops amidst a summer drought. The tribal lore that sustained Hopi farming practices isn't working anymore, as climate change shifts seasons. Photograph by George H.H. Huey, Alamy
The Hopi tribesmen of northern Arizona are born meteorologists.
When snake weed blooms in the spring, they know they’re in for bumper
summer rains. When the desert stays largely barren, they prepare for
drought. As far back as tribal lore goes, Hopi farmers have sustained
themselves and their crops by diligently reading their arid mesa
surroundings.
This summer, however, their millennia-old forecasting techniques
failed them, and not for the first time in recent years. The weeds
sprouted in great numbers in April. The usual rains in August did not
come at all. Were it not for local grocery stores and the seed
stockpiles they maintain in anticipation of the occasional bad year,
many Hopi might well have gone hungry.
“These indicators have always been dang reliable. We have over 2000
years of replication. We know our fields, like many indigenous people,”
says Michael Kotutwa Johnson, a Hopi farmer who grows corn, beans,
squash, and melons on the tribal reservation several hundred miles north
of Phoenix. “But when I talk to my people, they say our winters are
getting longer, so people plant a little later, and that can wreak
havoc. Now we’re kind of in a bad situation.”
They’re not alone. Climate change is upending millions of people’s
lives, yet few communities are seeing their crops and worldviews crumble
quite like those that rely on indigenous weather forecasting. Dependent
in many cases on millennia-old trial and error, as well as analyses of
the landscape to gauge planting cycles, their fields are withering as
the conditions on which the calendars are predicated change. Without
that accumulated wisdom to fall back on—bird migrations, wind direction,
stars, and more—farmers are feeling particularly defenseless just as
other consequences of climate change complicate their lives.
As a measure of climate change’s severity, it’s a sobering one. Many of
these farming communities are unfamiliar with “climate change” as a
concept, and yet they’re all acutely aware that something’s horribly
awry. There’s no denial or skepticism here, only shock and dismay as
practices and traditions that have withstood thousands of years of
civilizational rise and fall are becoming obsolete. Wrapped up as these
growing patterns often are with local religious and cultural rites,
there can be a heavy psychological toll to this change as well.
But in practical terms, too, the implications of this failing
indigenous wisdom are extra grim, travels through traditional farming
areas reveal. Because many farmers have zero or limited access to modern
weather forecasting, they have nothing else to turn to when the rains,
temperatures, and wildlife behave in new and unexpected ways. And
because many of these calendars predominate in the parts of the world
that are bearing the brunt of climate change, notably tropical and
dryland areas, the value of their knowledge is shriveling fast. Failing
crops and hence hunger are increasing. Meteorologists fear that those
losses and that suffering will only intensify unless help arrives in a
hurry.
“People used to forecast weather/climate just by observing natural
phenomena,” says Tsegaye Kedema, director of the National Meteorological
Agency of Ethiopia, in an email. “However, due to climate change these
phenomena also changed and the forecasters lost their credibility and
status within the community. This creates a big problem for the
communities to perform their informed farming activities.”
Crumbling calendars
The trauma spans almost every continent.
In southern Iraq, farmers work much the same land as the Sumerians,
the civilization that pioneered irrigated agriculture in about 6000 BCE,
and still abide by much of the ancient planting timetable. But as
summers become longer and hotter and other seasons shift, many farmers
have been left bewildered, angry, and scared.
“The old people have the same mindset as in the past. They feel
there’s a continuity because there’s been no development and we have the
same tools and same ways of agriculture,” said Jaafar Jotheri, a
geoarchaeologist at Iraq’s Al-Qadisiyah University whose father and
brother still farm to the south of Baghdad. “Now they’re seeing the
climate change, though, and some of the older people don’t know what and
when to grow.”
Southern
Iraqi farming is rich with millennia-old idioms that no longer hold
true. ‘August is for reducing the grapes and producing the dates,’ goes
one, but the grapes and dates have started to come at irregular times in
recent years. ‘September is the month of moving the buffalo from the
water,’ goes another, but Septembers are so hot that water buffalo must
be grazed in the marshlands of southern Iraq until later in the year for
fear of overheating them.
Iraqi farmer Raed al-Jubayli checks dates at his palm tree nursery in the southern Iraqi city of Basra. Iraqi farmers are also facing challenges as their traditional farming wisdom no longer holds true. Photograph by Haidar Mohammed, ALI/AFP/Getty
In southern Egypt and northern Sudan, many farmers still depend on
the Coptic calendar, a variation of the ancient pharaonic calendar.
They, too, however, are finding that reality no longer conforms to
thousands of years of Nile-side wisdom. These days, it’s often too hot
to plant wheat at the end of Masry, which roughly corresponds
with August, and it can derail the rest of the winter planting cycle if
the delay drags on long enough.
Until 20 years ago, this calendar was “almost perfect,” says Ismail
Elgizouli, a Sudanese scientist and former acting chair of the UN’s
Inter-governmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). But now “due to
climate change there is variability from one year to another.”
As in Iraq and other parts of the region, Sudan’s farmers are fleeing
the countryside en masse. It’s a wretched end for a calendar that
anchored ancient Egypt’s vital agricultural sector and enabled its
pharaohs to measure the length of their reigns and to time celebrations.
And in large swathes of sub-Saharan Africa, things are also going very wrong. The Nganyi people
of Western Kenya have traditionally used everything from grasshopper
swarms to the winds that whip in off Lake Victoria to predict rains, but
deforestation and biodiversity loss have put paid to their longstanding
success.
It’s a similar situation in Eastern Kenya, where the Atharaka’s
usual forecasting measures—the flowering of various plants, the
croaking of frogs—have crumbled amid drought. From insect-reading
communities in northern Benin, to Nigeria, where some farmers read stars
to predict crop yields, the utility of these traditional measures is
evaporating fast.
According to several studies,
older farmers and geographically isolated farmers are particularly
vulnerable to the changes because they’re less likely to be offered help
transitioning to other types of forecasting. So, in a cruel yet common
twist, it’s the poorest of the poor who are suffering most.
Rolling out modernity
But as desperate as the situation might look in places, this is at
least one consequence of climate change that is, in theory, within our
capacity to tackle. Farmers in richer parts of the world, like
Australia, have overcome a number of climate challenges by tweaking
their agricultural calendars and sowing earlier. By successfully rolling
out modern forecasting to areas that have had none, developmental
organizations have already enjoyed some success.
Farmers in West Africa saw a 20 percent rise in millet yields after
they gained access to modern meteorological information, according to
World Meteorological Organization (WMO) data.
“Farmers need to know: When do I plant? What do I plant? If a farmer
usually has a mix of 60 percent corn and 40 percent millet, they’ve got
to make a judgement,” says Robert Stefanski, Chief of the Agricultural
Meteorology Division at WMO. “Corn might be more profitable, but it uses
more water, so if there's a drier season, perhaps they'll make a
decision based on that forecast.”
Even seven-day forecasts can allow farmers to assess whether they
have long enough dry periods to weed their fields or spray their crops.
Causes and Effects of Climate Change
What
causes climate change (also known as global warming)? And what are the
effects of climate change? Learn the human impact and consequences of
climate change for the environment, and our lives.
The challenges are still considerable, of course. Agricultural
assistance is shrinking in many of the places it’s most needed as
developing countries redirect resources toward more profitable
industries. Given the religious and cultural components of indigenous
knowledge, there will be insurmountable costs no matter what. It will
require finesse, too. “You can’t go into a place and say: your traditional knowledge is not
valid. You can’t be adversarial since a lot of it is based on science,”
Stefanski says.
But if we’re smart, we might even see this as something of an
opportunity, farmers and meteorologists say. After all, indigenous
forecasting relies on a careful reading of the natural landscape,
something many societies appear to have lacked as environmental
practices have deteriorated. If nothing else, we might learn something
from many indigenous communities’ fortitude.
“We’ve
seen our crops die before, so we’re prepared for the psychological
impact of climate change,” said Michael Kotutwa Johnson, the Hopi
farmer. “We can handle it.”
Most registered voters are in favor of spending trillions on weatherized buildings and renewable-energy infrastructure.
Young people protest outside the San Francisco Federal Building during a Climate Strike march. Kate Munsch / Reuters
For the first time in years—and maybe ever—Democrats are getting
ambitious about climate change. Several presidential candidates have
proposed $1 trillion plans that variously nudge, cajole, and force the
economy to reduce carbon pollution. The largest plan, from Senator
Bernie Sanders, calls for $16.3 trillion in public investment over 10
years, which would be the biggest economic stimulus package since the
New Deal.
These plans confront a confusing array of public views. Voters are more worried about climate change than ever before, but they also seem to dislike the Democratic Party’s move to the left. So how do voters feel about this new set of progressive policies?
A
new survey finds: They like it. At least five aggressive and left-wing
climate policies are supported by most registered voters in the United
States. Americans seem particularly fond of large spending packages, as Sanders has advanced, and climate policies with a populist bent, such as Senator Elizabeth Warren’s proposed climate import fee and her “economic patriotism” plan.
The
poll was conducted by YouGov Blue and Data for Progress, a liberal
think tank. While I try to avoid explicitly ideological surveys, I trust
this data because YouGov is a reputable, nonpartisan firm that also
conducts polls for CBS News and The Economist. Leah Stokes,
a political scientist at the University of California at Santa Barbara,
also told me that the poll’s findings are in line with other research.
“Climate policy is very popular,” she said. “If you highlight the cost,
it’s less popular. If you highlight new taxes, it’s less popular. But if
you highlight job creation or the air-pollution benefits, it’s more
popular.”
She added that many climate policies are especially
favored now because the public tends to take views opposite those of the
sitting president, a concept known as thermostatic public opinion.
“With Trump being president, you’re going to find people want more
environmental protection now than when Obama was in power,” she said.
These
results also align with those of conservative-leaning surveys. The
American Action Network, an advocacy group tied to the House GOP, recently asked
Americans in 30 congressional districts—including 12 “battleground”
districts and 10 Donald Trump–supporting districts—if they liked the
idea of a Green New Deal that would move the United States “from an
economy built on fossil fuels to one driven by clean energy.”
Shockingly, the idea was more popular than not,
with 48 percent of respondents in support and 7 percent undecided. Only
when pollsters told people that a Green New Deal could cost $93
trillion did support for the idea collapse. But according to the GOP
group’s own math, a Green New Deal that focused only on climate change could cost only $13 trillion.
Results
from the new YouGov Blue/Data for Progress poll find majority support
for spending along those lines, though the poll never uses the term Green New Deal. Here are the five climate policies with the most support:
1. A national recycling program for commodities
During
World War II, the federal government encouraged Americans to save and
pool commodities—including paper, steel, and rubber—so that they could
be recycled and turned into new ships, planes, and guns. Sanders proposes
launching a similar program today for clean energy. It would seek to
reduce the cost and blunt the environmental impact of the huge build-out
of wind turbines, solar panels, and batteries that he proposes.
The
idea is overwhelmingly popular, with 64 percent of registered voters in
support and only 16 percent opposed. Americans of every race, age, and
religion overwhelmingly support the idea. So do six in 10 white men, and
a majority of self-described born-again Christians.
Data for Progress/YouGov
2. $1.3 trillion to weatherize every home and office building in the United States
At least three different Democratic climate plans—proposed
by Senator Amy Klobuchar, Governor Jay Inslee (whose plan has been
largely adopted by Warren), and Sanders—have promised to boost federal
spending on weatherizing homes and buildings. Sanders’s plan calls for
more than $2 trillion in grants to help families improve their home’s
energy efficiency.
The idea is very popular. Six in 10 voters support
spending more than $1 trillion “to weatherize homes and buildings to
make them more energy-efficient and reduce energy bills.” A smaller
majority of voters older than 65 also support the proposal.
Data for Progress/YouGov
3. $1.5 trillion for a massive federal build-out of renewable energy
Sanders promises
to build out enough wind, solar, and geothermal energy to power every
home and business in the United States by 2030. Such a plan would cost
$1.5 trillion, he says, and it would be possible to execute under the
existing legal powers of the Energy Department.While the poll
didn’t ask Americans if they would support that legal maneuver, a large
majority of voters said they were ready to foot the bill for the plan.
Fifty-nine percent of respondents said they would strongly or somewhat
support $1.5 trillion in federal spending to build out renewables. Among
white voters without a college degree—a group that normally breaks Republican—the idea found 52 percent in support.
Data for Progress/YouGov
4. A climate adjustment fee on environmentally destructive imports
Warren has proposed
imposing a “border carbon adjustment” on imports that require high
levels of carbon emissions. This policy could help American climate
policy from “offshoring” carbon pollution into China and India,
supporters say, and it would encourage American cement- and steelmakers
to invest in greener ways to make their products.
For
now, at least, Americans love the idea. Sixty percent of respondents
strongly or somewhat supported the idea, while only 23 percent opposed
it. (About one in five Americans still aren’t sure what to think.)
But
among working-class voters, the idea was one of the most popular
proposed. Fifty-five percent of people without a college degree liked
the idea, a level of support that did not change across white and
nonwhite respondents. Voters from families making less than $60,000 a
year also supported the idea at about that level.
5. “Economic Nationalism for Climate Change”
This summer, Warren announced her plan for “economic patriotism,” a policy agenda that actively aims to boost American jobs and industry. Its first plank is a green-manufacturing scheme that pledges $2 trillion over the next 10 years. In short, Warren seeks to revive industrial policy.
This
poll asked about “economic nationalism,” which it described as a plan
to “aggressively encourage large American manufacturing firms to
specialize in solar panels, wind turbines, and other climate-friendly
technologies.”
The
proposal commanded majority support, with 53 percent overall in support
and 30 percent in opposition. It also won a majority of voters who said
they lived in a suburb or rural area. Among white voters without a
college degree, the idea was above water at 46 percent and an
eight-point support gap.
But 15 percent of that group said they
weren’t sure what to think of the proposal. That may suggest that the
group could reject it overall if Republican leaders turn against it. Or
perhaps not: Among deeply Republican segments of the electorate—such as
white, self-identified born-again Christians—the idea is already 20
points underwater.
Data for Progress/YouGov
Not every idea was so popular.
Sanders
has proposed to fund his $16.3 trillion Green New Deal “by imposing new
taxes, fees, and lawsuits on fossil-fuel companies.” Forty-three
percent of voters approved that idea, making it more popular than
unpopular. But nearly a third of respondents “strongly opposed” it,
suggesting that any backlash could be widely and deeply felt.
Stokes
wondered if voters were responding primarily to the “taxes” line in
Sanders’s pitch. In a recent poll she ran with other researchers,
funding climate policy through lawsuits against fossil-fuel companies
was one of the most popular options.
Electric-vehicle policy seems
particularly tricky. In his plan, Sanders proposes a $2 trillion grant
program for low- and middle-income families to buy new electric cars.
Yet nearly half of voters oppose that idea outright. A majority of
voters also reject Sanders’s proposal to end the sale of gas-burning
cars by 2030. That plan attracts the special ire of white voters, 42
percent of whom “strongly oppose” it. Warren, Senator Kamala Harris, and
Mayor Pete Buttigieg have all proposed similarly timed bans.
The
only other proposal opposed by a majority of voters was a plan to
nationalize and shut down fossil-fuel companies such as Exxon while
making sure workers “laid off by this closure would be fairly
compensated.” No Democratic candidate has supported this idea, but it is
a goal of some activists and researchers on the American far left.
Finally,
YouGov and Data for Progress polled the popularity of a carbon tax of
$100 a ton. Carbon prices are widely seen as a possible centrist
solution to climate change. They win the support of most mainstream
economists. As such, there is plenty of good polling on them. It shows
that a majority of Americans often, but not always, support the general idea of a carbon price.
But
this poll aimed to explore more radical policies, so it asked about a
$100-a-ton carbon price. This is very, very high. Only two countries,
Sweden and Switzerland, levy carbon taxes of at least $100 a ton. In the United States, state-level carbon prices range from $5 to $15 a ton. The Climate Leadership Council, a bipartisan advocacy group backed by major oil companies, endorses a federal carbon price of $40 a ton.
Yet
such a high price may find some support in climate science. Last year,
the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change said that carbon prices might need to start at $135 a ton—and then keep rising—to keep global temperature rise from exceeding 1.5 degrees Celsius.
But
there isn’t yet public support for that kind of policy. Nearly half of
voters, 47 percent, oppose such a high price, according to the poll. The
38 percent of voters who support the policy in any way is only
moderately larger than the 33 percent of voters who say they “strongly
oppose” it. The one bright spot for supporters: About 15 percent of
respondents were not sure.
All respondents were told that the $100 carbon tax could increase gas prices by about 88 cents a gallon, an estimate based on data from Resources for the Future, a nonpartisan think tank.