Tuesday, December 10, 2019

(AU) About 100 Countries At UN Climate Talks Challenge Australia's Use Of Carryover Credits

The Guardian - 

COP25 delegates from developing countries try to ban the emissions accounting measure in a clause described as an ‘anti-Australia option’
Extinction Rebellion protesters at the COP25 UN climate talks in Madrid where Australia’s use of carryover credits has been challenged by about 100 countries. Photograph: Pablo Blázquez Domínguez/Getty Images
Australia’s plan to use an accounting loophole to meet its international emissions targets has been formally challenged at UN climate talks, with about 100 countries wanting the practice banned under the Paris agreement.
Delegates from developing countries led by Belize and Costa Rica have introduced a ban on using carryover credits from the Kyoto protocol into the text of the rulebook for the Paris climate agreement, which is being debated at a meeting in Madrid.
It is a crucial debate for the Morrison government as it relies on using the accounting measure to meet its commitment under the Paris deal. The emissions reduction minister, Angus Taylor, arrived in Madrid on Sunday to make Australia’s case at the second week of the talks.
Emissions projections released as Taylor left Australia suggested the Morrison government was on track to meet its 2030 target (at least a 26% emissions cut below 2005 levels), but only if it used carryover credits. Without them it expected emissions to achieve just a 16% cut. Government advisers found Australia’s fair share under a meaningful global deal would be at least 45%.
Carryover accounting rules allow countries to claim credit for exceeding previous targets against future targets. They were allowed under the soon-to-be-obsolete Kyoto protocol to encourage countries to be as ambitious as possible. They were not mentioned in the original text of the Paris agreement.
The introduction of a ban on what are described as “Kyoto units” into the negotiating was the clearest sign that countries that had expressed opposition to their use were determined to follow through. Some observers at the talks described the clause as an “anti-Australia” option.
Bill Hare, the chief executive of Climate Analytics in Berlin and a long-time adviser to developing countries at climate talks, said using carryover credits was opposed by three major negotiating blocs – the alliance of small island states, the least developed countries group and the independent alliance of Latin America and the Caribbean – as well as Canada, Switzerland and Norway.
“There [are about] 100 countries supporting this [challenge],” Hare said from Madrid.
The government has said it earned the right to use the credits through previous efforts. Opponents say it could claim access to the credits only because Australia set unambitious targets under the Kyoto protocol, including allowing emissions to increase by up to 8% between 1990 and 2012.
They say using the credits was at odds with the Paris agreement, which committed countries to escalating action that reflected their “highest possible ambition”.
Officials told Senate estimates earlier this year that as far as they were aware Australia was the only country planning to use carryover credits. Several developed countries had explicitly ruled out using them.
Hare said the European Union, South Africa and Papua New Guinea, representing a group known as the coalition of rainforest nations, had not embraced an outright ban in Madrid but supported a time limit on their use.
Some major countries including China, India and Brazil have sided with Australia in opposing the ban, at least in part because as written it would also outlaw using Kyoto protocol-era offsets generated in their countries that can be sold to developed nations in lieu of reducing their own pollution.
Richie Merzian, a former Australian climate negotiator and now climate energy director with the Australia Institute, said it was possible the wording of the text would be altered to ban just carryover credits but not carbon offsets. He said China, India and Brazil were far more influential with developing countries than Australia and had a specific interest that could be catered for without allowing carryover credits.
“Australia has a single issue that could be targeted and that’s always risky,” Merzian said. “It means the minister has to start the week on the defensive.”
Australian officials have indicated the government’s position is that using the credits is non-negotiable. As decisions at UN climate talks are by consensus, Australia could stand alone to block a ban, although it would be expected to face significant pressure if isolated.
Faced with objections from the British high Commission at a meeting with business groups last month, Australian officials said there would need to be a diplomatic solution to the standoff.
Official data shows Australia’s emissions have not come down and several analysts have found it was not on track to meet its Paris target.
But the government released two sets of data over the past 10 days to support the argument that Taylor will make at the conference: that the country has “a track record of which all Australians can be proud”.
The first new report used newly adjusted emissions data to suggest national pollution was flat, and had dipped slightly over the past two years, rather than increasing year-on-year as official greenhouse accounts had previously shown. The second updated projections of how much pollution would be released to 2030 and found, contrary to other evidence, the country was expected to meet its Paris target by using the accounting loophole.
The department projections suggested Australia would exceed its 2020 target (a 5% cut compared with 2000) by 411m tonnes of carbon dioxide. This is 44m tonnes more than a year ago.
As analysts have pointed out, 44m tonnes is about 8% of Australia’s annual pollution. It is equivalent to the annual emissions of Switzerland, or 10 times the emissions of Lesotho.
On Saturday Taylor said the improvement in the projections was primarily a result of the government’s $3.5bn climate solutions package and emissions cuts in the electricity sector. “Our commitment is achievable, balanced and responsible, and is part of coordinated global action to deliver a healthy environment for future generations while keeping our economy strong,” Taylor said.
The projections are based on a range of assumptions, including that renewable energy will provide 50% of Australia’s electricity by 2030. When this amount of clean energy was proposed by Labor before the election, the government suggested it would be reckless and damage the economy.

Links

What Kenneth Hayne Says About Climate Change - Transcript

AFR - Kenneth Hayne

Learned helplessness and short-termism suit those who still see climate change as a matter of belief or ideology, but the obligations directors have for the good of their companies are very clear.
A director acting in the best interests of the company must take account of, and the board must report publicly on, relevant climate-related risks and issues. David Rowe
Kenneth Hayne
The Hon Kenneth Hayne AC QC was a Justice of the High Court of Australia from 1997 to 2015.
Prior to this, he was appointed as a Justice of the Supreme Court of Victoria in 1992, later serving on the Victorian Court of Appeal until his appointment to the High Court.
In 2002 he was appointed a Companion in the General Division of the Order of Australia for service to the judiciary, to the law and the community in both legal and general education.
On his retirement from the High Court he was appointed as a professorial fellow at the Melbourne Law School, University of Melbourne.
On 14 December 2017, Kenneth Hayne was appointed Royal Commissioner into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry.
This is an edited transcript of remarks Kenneth Hayne, QC, made at the Centre for Policy Development’s Business Roundtable on Climate and Sustainability on November 21:

Previous speakers have emphasised the need for system-wide response. Systemic response is essential. But for the moment, I want to stand the issue on its head and look at it from the individual entity’s point of view.
Three things are clear. First, I think the relevant law is clear. Directors must act in the best interests of the company.
'Best interests' is not one-dimensional – it is not determined only by share price movement or 'total shareholder return' over a period.
'Best interests' does not present a binary choice between the interests of shareholders and the interests of others (whether customers, employees or society more generally).The longer the period of reference, the more the interests of all affected by a company’s actions will converge in pursuit of the long-term financial advantage of the enterprise. Second, international opinion is also clear.
International opinion is now firmly behind the need for all entities with public debt or equity to respond to climate change issues in their governance, their strategy, their risk management and their metrics and targets and, importantly, to record their responses to the issues in their financial reports.
The work of the Bank of England and the Financial Stability Board’s Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures both forms and reflects that opinion.
Third, the position of Australian regulators is clear. ASIC, APRA and the Reserve Bank have all recently made plain the significance each of those bodies attaches to climate-related issues.

Learned helplessness
The inevitable consequence of the three points I have made about the law, international opinion and domestic regulators is that, in Australia, a director acting in the best interests of the company must take account of, and the board must report publicly on, climate-related risks and issues relevant to the entity.
As the 2019 Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures status report shows, the speed at which changes are needed to limit the rise in the global average temperature obliges more companies to consider the potential impact of climate change and disclose their material findings than are now doing so.
The entities and their boards must ask at least two questions:
• What is the potential financial impact of climate-related issues?
• What is now, and what will be, our strategic response?
All this being so, what is the issue?
Political debates (do) not distract from what is clear: directors have a duty to respond to climate-related risks.
Directors have their duties; there are clear statements of what those duties require; regulators have said plainly that they expect the duties to be performed.
What is there left to debate?
I wonder whether there may be two related points to consider – learned helplessness and entrenched short-termism.
The issue, of course, is global. What we are now considering is individual response by entities and by their directors (separately and collectively).
A response often seen in Australian political discourse is that: 'The issue is large; Australia is comparatively small; nothing we do will affect the outcome if the big emitters do not act'.
That is, the response is 'We can do nothing that will help'. By making that response, we are persuading ourselves that we are helpless.
Boards will reinforce that sense of helplessness if they put climate risk into a bucket marked 'non-financial risks'.
Both learned helplessness and short-termism yield a result that fits comfortably with those who still see climate change as a matter of belief or ideology. David Rowe
And boards might think that they can do that if they see the risk as not being immediately realised in the next financial period.
But as recent events in the financial services industry should have shown, the notion of 'non-financial' risks can be very misleading.
The distinction between financial and non-financial risk to the entity is anything but clear.
Conduct and regulatory risk were seen by some financial services entities as
non-financial risks less important than other risks to the financial performance of the entity.
But the realisation of conduct and regulatory risks has had large and continuing effects on, not only the reputation of the entities, but also their profitability.

Short-termism
Helplessness is then coupled with short-termism. At the national level short-termism is expressed as: 'Doing something now will have adverse effects on employment in some part or parts of the country. That would be bad for the national economy. Therefore, we will do nothing.'
Both learned helplessness and short-termism yield a result that fits comfortably with those who still see climate change as a matter of belief or ideology.
Framing the most recent debates provoked by the bushfire emergencies as part of the 'culture wars' reinforces the notion that climate science is a matter of belief, not scientific observation and extrapolation.
No less importantly, because the debate remains framed as a debate about belief, learned helplessness and short-termism can be translated into the nativist-populist terms that now have such currency in many political systems.
But neither helplessness (whether that is learned or real) nor short-termism provides any answer to the director’s duty to act in the best interests of the company.
Indeed, each points plainly towards the need for boards:
• to recognise both the nature and extent of climate-related risks and the speed with which change will have to be made;
• to develop strategic plans in response; and
• to report to shareholders and the wider market about what they have done, are doing and will do in response.
I say that any sense of helplessness points to those results because the choice for a board is between responding or having a response thrust upon the company.
And boards simply cannot confine their attention to the short-term. As I have said, entities which did not look beyond short-term profit have recently suffered very large financial and non-financial losses.
Learned helplessness and short-termism may explain how our political debates are being framed.
If they do, we must be careful that the framing of the political debates does not distract from what is clear: that directors have a duty to respond to climate-related risks and that the continuing work of the  Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures shows directors what they should do.

Links

(AU) Hayne Rebukes Directors On Climate Risk Failure

AFR - James Fernyhough

The former High Court judge says directors cannot hide behind "learned helplessness" as an excuse not to act, and lashed the "short-termism" of national debate. 
Justice Kenneth Hayne says a sense of helplessness and short-termism is no excuse for inaction on climate risk. AFR
Former High Court judge and royal commissioner Kenneth Hayne has warned directors they have a legal duty to act on climate change risk, include it in corporate strategies and report on it to shareholders, raising the real prospect that boards failing to act could end up in court.
In a private address to business leaders, regulators and government officials hosted by think tank, the Centre for Policy Development, Mr Hayne also took a swipe at the Morrison government, which has come under criticism for its unambitious emissions reduction policies.
He said both "learned helplessness" and "short-termism" yielded "a result that fits comfortably with those who still see climate change as a matter of belief or ideology".
"Framing the most recent debates provoked by the bushfire emergencies as part of the 'culture wars' reinforces the notion that climate science is a matter of belief, not scientific observation and extrapolation," he said.
"No less importantly, because the debate remains framed as a debate about belief, learned helplessness and short-termism can be translated into the nativist-populist terms that now have such currency in many political systems."Mr Hayne said in the remarks released exclusively to The Australian Financial Review, that international expert consensus was now clear that climate change risk was a matter of fact and boards could not hide behind excuses for inaction. "International opinion is now firmly behind the need for all entities with public debt or equity to respond to climate change issues in their governance, their strategy, their risk management and their metrics and targets and, importantly, to record their responses to the issues in their financial reports," Mr Hayne said.
He said the financial regulators – the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority and the Reserve Bank of Australia – were all clear that climate change posed real and measurable financial risks.
"The inevitable consequence [of this consensus] is that, in Australia, a director acting in the best interests of the company must take account of, and the board must report publicly on, climate-related risks and issues relevant to the entity," he said.
He said more companies would need "to consider the potential impact of climate change and disclose their material findings than are now doing so", and dismissed the argument that the magnitude of the problem left directors helpless to act, referring to that position as "learned helplessness".
Mr Hayne's remarks come three years after barristers Noel Hutley, SC, and Sebastian Hartford Davis published a landmark opinion, which argued boards that failed to consider climate change risks could be found liable for breaching their duty of care and diligence.
Mr Hayne's opinion will add new force to the view that boards have clear legal obligations on climate risk.
As commissioner of the 2018 financial services royal commission, his recommendations on the treatment of non-financial risks, particularly cultural risks, have already sparked a radical rethink of directors' responsibility for areas previously considered outside their remit.
Alluding to the findings of the royal commission, Mr Hayne told the CPD roundtable: "As recent events in the financial services industry should have shown, the notion of 'non-financial' risks can be very misleading."
He said companies might take the view that the size and global nature of global warming – which is predominantly caused by the burning of fossil fuels, and the resulting emission of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere – left them helpless to act. But he said this excuse would not stand up under the law.
"A response often seen in Australian political discourse is that 'The issue is large; Australia is comparatively small; nothing we do will affect the outcome if the big emitters do not act.' That is, the response is, 'We can do nothing that will help.'
"By making that response, we are persuading ourselves that we are helpless," Mr Hayne said.
"Helplessness is then coupled with short-termism. At the national level, short-termism is expressed as: 'Doing something now will have adverse effects on employment in some part or parts of the country. That would be bad for the national economy. Therefore, we will do nothing.'"
He said directors must not be distracted by the "framing of the political debates", urging them instead to look at standards set out by the international business-led Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures, which has been endorsed by Australian regulators.
Mr Hayne's remarks were made at a closed roundtable discussion hosted by the Centre for Policy Development late last month in Sydney. Also present were RBA deputy governor Guy Debelle, Bank of England executive director Sarah Breeden, APRA executive board member Geoff Summerhayes, and ASIC commissioner John Price.
Representatives from big business, including ANZ, Macquarie, QBE, AustralianSuper, Coles and UBS, were also present.
Government representatives who attended were from the Department of Environment and Energy, the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet, and Treasury. Greg Combet, the Labor environment minister who oversaw the Gillard government's short-lived carbon tax, was also present in his capacity as chairman of industry super-owned fund management colossus IFM Investors.
The roundtable concluded: "First, the climate crisis is upon us, and decision-makers across the Australian economy have a clear and increasing obligation to address the risks and opportunities it presents. It is clear climate change is a ratcheting risk, a trend change that is highly interactive, systemic and irreversible, and one which will impact every aspect of Australian society.
"History is no guide to its future impacts, meaning that forward-looking scenario analysis is needed to manage the physical and transition risks it will generate. Australia’s economy and financial system is particularly exposed given the significant physical risks the country faces and its profile as a commodity exporter. Australian business is at increasing risk of retaliatory action from other countries because of a perceived view that Australia is not pulling its weight when it comes to reducing emissions."
The conclusions from the roundtable were prepared by the CPD and are not meant to represent individual policy positions of the participants.

Madrid meeting
The release of Mr Hayne's remarks coincide with the second week of the United Nations COP25 meeting in Madrid, at which government ministers from around the world, including Energy Minister Angus Taylor, will discuss details of the Paris climate agreement including potential carbon trading rules, and the use of Kyoto carryover credits.
The government confirmed on the weekend that it intends to use Kyoto carryover credits – that is, credits from its over-achievement of emissions goals under the Kyoto protocol – to meet its Paris goals. In real terms, that means Australia's emissions by 2030 will be 16 per cent below 2005 levels, not the 26 to 28 per cent below set out in the Paris agreement.
The Paris agreement does not mention the use of Kyoto carryover credits, and many nations are pushing for the practice to be formally banned.

Links

Monday, December 09, 2019

Climate Change Now 'The Most Significant Threat' To Australia's Wet Tropics

The Guardian - 
Wet Tropics Management Authority offers grim assessment of impacts on region’s biodiversity and economy
The Wet Tropics Management Authority warns climate change is likely to result in ‘substantial ecological change’ in north Queensland. Photograph: Maria Grazia Casella/Alamy Stock Photo
Climate change is escalating as “the most significant threat” to Australia’s wet tropics world heritage area, with an update to parliament reporting the outlook for the bioregion is a cause of “great concern”.
The grim assessment of the critical north Queensland rainforest region is outlined in an annual snapshot of the protected area prepared by the Wet Tropics Management Authority, which urges greater national and international effort to address the causes of climate change.
The wet tropics world heritage area spans 450km of tropical north Queensland coastline between Cooktown and Townsville and comprises the world’s oldest living rainforests and the largest area of rainforest in Australia.
It also supports the highest level of biodiversity of any region in Australia, being home to 36% of Australia’s mammals, 29% of Australia’s frog species, 60% of Australia’s butterfly species and 50% of Australia’s bird species.
Of over 173,000 protected areas, the Wet Tropics World Heritage Area was rated as the second most ‘irreplaceable’ natural World Heritage Area on earth and the sixth most irreplaceable protected area by a team of international scientists. Although it represents only 0.12% of the total area of the Australian landmass, the Area is home to an exceptionally high proportion of the nation’s biodiversity.
The agency’s two annual reports, one specifically on the state of the world heritage area, both warn that the conservation outlook for the region is deteriorating, with climate change seen as “likely to result in widespread and substantial ecological change”.
“Climate change is escalating as the most significant threat to the wet tropics long-term outlook, including changes to the distribution and density of endemic and specialised cool adapted rainforest species,” the report says.
“Changes to endemic and specialised cool adapted rainforest species distribution and density having already been recorded – and some somber predictions of modelled effects are already being realised.”
The agency reports that after receiving new evidence of the “accelerated decline of unique, endemic wet tropics animals”, such as the lemuroid ringtail possum which is at risk of imminent extinction, the board released a climate impact statement and a 10-point plan for climate adaptation.
“The board’s call is for urgent action and investment to improve resilience and protection to give the area the best chance of withstanding extreme events and climate impacts, pending a reduction in global emissions,” it said.
The snapshot also warns that “more extreme and unplanned bushfires” will occur in the future, posing a significant threat to the old-growth rainforest.
“Although not directly attributable to climate change, our rapidly warming climate, driven by human activities, is exacerbating every risk factor for more frequent and intense bushfires,” the report says.
Other threats reported by the authority include the damage being inflicted by invasive species, with feral pigs, yellow crazy ants, invasive weeds and pathogens such as myrtle rust all having an impact.
Funding cuts are also listed as a threat, with the authority reporting a “significant decline in research and monitoring of the property”.
“Despite previous historical investment in research in the area, research funding has significantly declined over recent years,” the report says.
Under the current National Environmental Science Program (2015-2021) commonwealth research funding investment into wet tropics rainforests was not a priority.
The final threat listed by the agency is the increased demand for infrastructure like roads, dams and energy supply, “caused by a growing urban population and tourist visitor numbers, distributing visitation across a wider area”.
The wet tropics area, which was declared protected in 1988, was also examined in 2017 by the International Union for the Conservation of Nature which carries out regular assessments of the world’s 241 natural world heritage sites.
The 2017 Outlook Report reported that the wet tropics region was under direct threat from “invasive plants, animals and diseases, and the high risk posed by the predicted impacts of climate change”.
The authority is concerned that the threat to the region’s ecology could also threaten the world heritage listing, which would have a knock-on effect to the Queensland economy.
“Climate change is one of the most significant threats to the area and is likely to result in widespread and substantial ecological change,” the report says.
“This change will impact the biodiversity values underpinning the world heritage listing of the area and has the potential to affect the region’s economy.”
A spokesman for environment minister Sussan Ley said the wet tropics was an “incredibly important area and one that receives significant funding.”
“In addition to its annual funding, the government has further invested $9m in crazy ant eradication and the formation of a Tourism Destination Development Plan to enhance opportunities for Indigenous cultural tourism enterprises and grow appropriate eco-tourism.
“We will continue to work with Queensland to protect this very important place.”

Links

We Really May Have Just 11 Years To Save The Climate

Climate Home News - 

“Eleven years to save the world” reads a common sign at the global Fridays for Future climate strikes.
(Photo: Pixabay)

Thomas Hale
Thomas Hale is associate professor in public policy (global public policy) at the Blavatnik School of Government, University of Oxford.
This article was published in the fourth issue of the Oxford Government Review, published in November 2019 by the Blavatnik School of Government.
Millions of people in over 100 countries, many of them too young to vote, have taken to the streets to demand governments radically increase efforts to fight climate change over the next decade.
But do we really have until just 2030 to avert climate catastrophe? While emphasising the importance of urgent action, scientists have tried to caveat this crude message. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) says we need to halve global emissions by 2030 in order to have at least a one in two chance of limiting warming to 1.5C, the goal set by the 2015 Paris Agreement.
The world will not “end” in 2030. But if we are not on a rapidly falling emissions pathway by that point, we are likely to blow through the 1.5C limit around 2040.
By that time, the climate strikers on the streets today will be entering middle age, starting families, rising up in their careers, and outvoting their irresponsible forebears. So can they not just solve the problem then?
Geophysically speaking, perhaps. Because carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases linger in the atmosphere for decades or longer, what matters most is the total stock of emissions over time. That means sluggish action today could, in theory, be compensated for by aggressive action in the future. Accordingly, some oil and gas companies have shifted from denying climate change altogether to accepting incremental steps like modest carbon prices.
But anyone advocating an incremental approach – which most governments are now following – is making a strong assumption not just about climate models, but about the politics of climate change in the middle of the 21st Century. In joint work with Jeff Colgan at Brown University and Jessica Green at the University of Toronto, my research is exploring how, as both climate change and decarbonisation advance over the next decades, climate politics will be increasingly existential. This change will shift governments’ focus from prevention to reaction.
To date, contestation over climate policy resembles what political scientists call ‘distributional politics’. Policies like carbon taxes or renewable energy deployment benefit some economic sectors and populations and impose costs on others. Interest groups that stand to win or lose from these changes advocate for their preferred policies.
But as we push the climate system to further extremes, the costs of climate change will become much more intense and widespread. Not just small islands, but whole coastal regions will be inundated. Droughts will cut off vital water supplies from hundreds of millions of subsistence farmers as well as those that feed global supply chains. Deadly heat will render whole regions uninhabitable. Under these conditions, climate politics will not just be a question of ‘who gets what, when, how’, as the political scientist Henry Laswell famously put it. Rather, climate politics will become a question of who gets to survive.
At the same time, the advance of decarbonisation will pose a similar existential threat to companies, workers, regions and regimes whose economic survival is linked to fossil fuels. Already, hundreds of coal plants and mines have shuttered across the world, taking investments, jobs and pensions with them. For this reason, a key demand of climate protestors today is for governments to provide a ‘just transition’ for workers in carbon-dependent sectors. Oil and gas companies may follow coal, and countries and political regimes based on the exploitation of these resources may follow. Those that have managed to diversify or channel resources into sovereign wealth funds may adapt. Others – cruelly, it will be those least able to manage – may discover that the only thing worse than the ‘resource curse’ is the curse of lack of resources.
In other words, the advance of both climate change and decarbonisation efforts will not just change the distribution of resources; it will threaten the very existence of large swathes of the global economy and population. How can we expect political leaders in the middle of the century – the young people who are today demanding action in the streets – to react?
In the face of urgent survival needs, it may be substantially more difficult to invest political effort and resources in preventing further climate change by reducing emissions. Instead, governments will face increasing, and in some cases overwhelming, pressure to limit the harm climate change and decarbonisation are causing in the short term.
Imagine you are the mayor of a Middle Eastern city in which the night time temperature has been over 50C for the last week. Will you spend the city budget on climate-saving electric cars or climate-destroying air conditioners?
Broadly, there are four strategies we can take to counter climate change. We can mitigate it by reducing emissions. We can adapt to it by taking steps like building seawalls or developing drought-resistant crops. We can compensate those who are hurt by its effects to reduce suffering. Or we can, perhaps, develop geoengineering technologies to limit temperature change or suck carbon from the atmosphere. To date we have focused mainly on mitigation. But as climate politics get existential, political incentives may shift to more defensive approaches.
Indeed, we are already seeing a growing emphasis on such strategies. When the countries of the world pledged, in the 1992 UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, to “prevent dangerous changes in the Earth’s climate,” they meant reducing emissions. Since that time, vulnerable nations and ‘frontline communities’ have pushed adaptation onto the global agenda. We are already being affected by climate change, they argue, so we need to not just prevent but also treat the current harm being done.
More recently, the most affected countries and populations have pushed for compensation. Not only have we failed to prevent climate change, they argue, but its impacts are already so great they cannot be adapted to. Low-lying islands, for whom even a small degree of climate change is existential, have been strong advocates for so-called ‘loss and damage’ measures in international climate policy, demanding that those who have contributed most to climate change pay the reparations. In the future, expect these claims to grow.
And as climate change proceeds, what was previously unthinkable may become widely demanded. Today, many climate advocates reject geoengineering techniques (such as building machines to suck carbon from the air, or seeding clouds to reflect more sunlight back into space) as an unproven distraction from mitigation efforts. But if the impacts of climate change continue to accumulate, governments may come to see such technologies as vital components of national security.
All of these strategies will be far more costly, and far less effective, than mitigation. But by the time today’s climate strikers are watching their own children take to the streets, they might be the only options left.
The good news is that these trends are not inevitable. The more we can prevent climate change now, while also making sure that those dependent on fossil fuels are not left behind, the less existential climate politics will be in the future. In other words, the urgency of action today is demanded not only by climate science, but also by political science. We will certainly be dealing with climate change for longer than the next 11 years, but we may have only the next decade to prevent it.

Links

UN Climate Talks: What's On The Agenda In Madrid And What It Means For Australia

The Guardian - 

Angus Taylor heads to COP25 next week, where Australia has already twice been given the ‘fossil of the day’ award
 UN Climate Change Conference COP25 in Madrid, on 2 December, 2019. Photograph: Jose Maria Cuadrado Jimenez/AFP via Getty Images 
For two weeks at the end of every year, the world’s governments meet to work on a global response to climate change. This year is the 25th meeting of what is known as the conference of the parties under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Those who attend know it as COP, or COP25.
Here’s what you need to know about this year’s talks, which started on Monday in Madrid, and what they could mean for Australia.

What does Australia stand coming into the talks?
There are nearly 190 countries represented at the UN climate talks and, contrary to some perceptions, Australia is not just a bit player.
Under UN greenhouse accounting, Australia is responsible for about 1.3% of annual pollution, which places it 16th on a ladder of polluting nations. It emits more each year than 40 countries with larger populations, including G7 members Britain, France and Italy.
On other measures Australia performs worse. It emits more per person than any other developed country (and far more than most developing countries), and a recent analysis found it was third for exported emissions.
It is the world’s biggest seller of coal, particularly metallurgic coal used in steel-making, and either number one or two for natural gas. It is easily the largest emitter in the south Pacific, and has been increasingly drawing criticism from Pacific leaders for not doing more to tackle the issue.
As the talks began last week, Australia was at the forefront of the climate emergency in other ways, as drought and bushfires made global headlines. Scientists say both are unprecedented and in line with climate projections.
Observers such as Howard Bamsey, the country’s former special envoy on climate change, say events in Australia are noticed and could be used to influence other countries to do more. But the government’s message focuses on its own actions: that it has set a 2030 emissions reduction target, that it more than met previous targets it set for itself and that it will meet this one.

Who is representing Australia?
Australia has a 21-strong delegation from the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, led by Jamie Isbister, a senior diplomat who was appointed environment ambassador less than three weeks ago.
In the second week’s political stage, Australia will be represented by Angus Taylor, the minister for energy and emissions reduction. It is his first time at climate talks. He arrives under pressure on several fronts, including a bizarre public spat with American author Naomi Wolf.

How is Australia positioning itself?
Australia is a member of what is known as the umbrella group of countries – a coalition of mostly developed nations outside the EU, including Canada, Japan, New Zealand, Norway, Russia, Ukraine and the US (which has a big delegation despite planning to leave the Paris agreement next year). The group doesn’t agree on everything but works together when like-minded.
Observers say the first week of talks has been slow. Australia is in a camp that does not want the meeting to focus on increasing the ambition of targets volunteered under the Paris deal and emphasises the need to implement what has already been agreed.
Australia, Brazil and Japan win the Fossil of the Day award during the second day of the climate conference. Photograph: Pablo Blázquez Domínguez/Getty Images 
Non-government groups say it is a concerning sign ahead of the next summit in Glasgow at the end of 2020, when countries are meant to come armed with new commitments to move the world closer to the goals agreed in Paris: limiting industrial global warming to well below 2C and as close to 1.5C as possible.
According to a UN report published before the talks, global emissions must fall by about 7.6% a year for the next decade to give a chance of meeting the 1.5C goal. Current targets would result in more than 3C warming, considered a disastrous scenario that would trigger dangerous tipping points.
Scott Morrison has indicated Australia has no plan to increase what it is doing beyond its 2030 target of a 26-28% cut compared with 2005 levels, which is less than what government advisors found would be Australia’s fair share or it could afford to do.
The prime minister has not acknowledged what groups representing business, unions, farmers, investors and the social policy sector this week spelled out in a joint statement – that the goals of the Paris agreement mean Australia will need to plan to stop emitting any carbon dioxide.
Australia’s emissions are not coming down and most experts believe it is not on track to meet its target. But the government released two sets of data before Taylor left for Madrid to buttress his argument that the country has “a track record of which all Australians can be proud”. The first used newly adjusted emissions data to suggest national pollution was basically flatlining, and had dipped slightly over the past two years, rather than increasing year-in-year as the greenhouse accounts had previously shown.
The second updated projections of how much pollution will be released to 2030 and found, contrary to other evidence, the country was expected to meet its Paris target. It did this by including an accounting loophole known as carryover credits. More on that in a moment.
Environment and other civil society groups at the conference have highlighted Morrison’s language on climate change. They twice last week awarded Australia a “fossil of the day” award, the climate talks equivalent of a Razzie. One was for a tweet he sent from the cricket about the fires. Are carryover credits a big issue at the talks?
Potentially.
Beyond holding the line on targets, Australia’s most prominent negotiating position is using these credits.
They are an accounting measure that allows countries to count emissions cuts from exceeding previous targets against future targets. They were allowed under the soon-to-be-obsolete Kyoto protocol. They are not mentioned in the Paris agreement and Australia is the only country planning to use them under it.
Australia accrued the credits after setting unambitious targets, including that it would increase national emissions by up to 8% between 1990 and 2012. The government says it will have credits equivalent to 411m tonnes of carbon dioxide to use against its Paris target, effectively cutting what it needs to do in new emissions reductions by more than half.
Critics say it is exploiting a loophole. Under UN rules, the carryover credits can only be banned through consensus, and the Australian delegation made clear in pre-COP briefings that it would not agree to that. But this may not be the end of the discussion. Several countries, including Britain, the European Union, Canada and Pacific nations, have either raised doubts or said outright they should not be used.
Analysts say use of the carryover would be at odds with other clear principles set out in the Paris deal. The text of the agreement says countries will make national commitments that are more ambitious through time and reflect the “highest possible ambition”. Some groups, such as the Investor Group on Climate Change, representing institutional investors with $2tr in funds, say use of carryover credits is inconsistent with the agreement because it reduces the action taken.
A potential scenario is that developing countries introduce an effective ban on using Kyoto carryover credits into the draft text that governments are negotiating over.
Richie Merzian, a former government climate negotiator, now director of the climate and energy program with The Australia Institute, says the Morrison government has yet to formally declare to the UN that it plans to use carryover credits. They do not appear in the statement submitted under the Paris deal explaining how Australia would meet its target.
“If the government is gung-ho on this, then it should back itself,” Merzian says from Madrid.

What else is on the agenda?
A major issue is what is known as Article 6, the part of the Paris rulebook that aims to revive a global carbon market that would help countries cut emissions by paying for measures that reduce pollution in developing countries. The credits generated through these markets differ from carryover credits, as they are tied to actual emissions cuts.
Debate over Article 6 is looking at carbon market design and operation and what to do about concerns that some countries led by Brazil are trying to “double count” by claiming emissions reductions for credits sold to wealthy nations.
The Australian business community has been concerned in the lead-up to the talks that Article 6 may not be resolved. The government’s position is arguably contradictory. Morrison was a frequent pre-election critic of Labor’s plan to use international credits, but supports their use in negotiations.
But Bill Hare, the chief executive and scientist at Climate Analytics and an adviser to small developing countries, says Australia is not working to ensure the rules guarantee that the use of offsets always results in real emissions reductions. “I think it’s all about having the ultimate flexibility in what countries want to do, rather than rigorous or accountable oversight,” he says.

What happens at the conclusion?
However the conference ends, the negotiations push on. Next year will be a major test of whether many countries are prepared to deliver on the pledge made in Paris and ramp up commitments before meeting again in to Glasgow.
In Australia, the environment department has been quietly working on a long-term climate strategy that is expected to be released for feedback in the new year. Thus far the government has said little to indicate what that might involve.

Links

Sunday, December 08, 2019

'Overwhelmed' Greta Thunberg Leaves Climate March Early After Rockstar Welcome

Sydney Morning Herald - Aritz Parra | Frank Jordans

Madrid: Activists of all ages and from all corners of the planet demanded concrete action Friday against climate change from leaders and negotiators at a global summit in Madrid.
The march was led by dozens of representatives of Latin America's indigenous peoples - a mark of deference after anti-government protests in Chile, the original host of the summit, resulted in the the talks suddenly being moved to Europe for the third year in a row.
Celebrity climate activist Greta Thunberg declared from a stage that "change is not going to come from the people in power, it's going to come from the masses."
A crowd of thousands responded chanting "Greta! Greta!"
Thunberg was surrounded by supporters and police after arriving in Spain by train from Lisbon. Credit: Getty Images
Organisers claimed 500,000 people turned out for the march, but authorities in Madrid put the number at 15,000 without an immediate explanation for the disparity in the count.
Thunberg addresses a demonstration in Madrid. Her placard translates as "Strike for Climate".  Credit: AP
The Swedish teen was followed on her first day in Madrid by a swarm of cameras and reporters, as well as curious members of the public wanting to film her on their smartphones, from the very first step she took out of an overnight train from Lisbon.
Two young activists earned cheers as they abseiled from a bridge and strung out a banner saying: "Just 8 years till 1.5 degrees C. HOW DARE YOU?" - a reference to scientists' forecasts of rising temperatures and what activists complain is a lack of a convincing political response to the threat.
The crush as people tried to get a glimpse of Thunberg led her to pull out shortly after the start of the march, saying police had advised her to leave for safety's sake, and she climbed into an electric car.
A Madrid police spokeswoman who spoke on condition of anonymity because she wasn't authorised to be named in media reports said that it had only been "suggested" to that Thunberg leave after she appeared "overwhelmed" by the attention and that police never ordered the activist to abandon on safety grounds.
Earlier in the day, the 16-year-old had said at a press conference that calls for real action against climate change are still being "ignored" by political leaders despite their continuous praise of the global environmental youth movement she helped create.
Thunberg hoped the COP25 summit would lead to "something concrete" and "increasing awareness among people in general," but she said that after more than one year of student strikes"still basically nothing has happened."
"The climate crisis is still being ignored by those in power," she added.

Consensus proving 'difficult'
During the talks, which run from December 2-13, nearly 200 countries are meant to streamline the rules on global carbon markets and agree on how poor countries should be compensated for destruction largely caused by emissions from rich nations.
An official directly involved in the negotiations said that despite a few setbacks, the technical negotiations were progressing, although many issues were being left for ministerial-level meetings in the summit's second and final week.
The official, who spoke on condition of anonymity given the sensitivity of the discussions, added that a political declaration on greater "ambition" - a buzzword at the summit - was shaping to be "difficult to achieve."
"A summit that doesn't end with enhanced ambition would be something that nobody would understand if we take into account what the streets and science are telling us," the official said.


Swedish climate change activist Greta Thunberg is just 16 years old, but she has gained global attention for her frank pleas for action from the world's most powerful leaders.

The talks came as evidence mounts about disasters that could ensue from further global warming, including a study published Friday predicting that unchecked climate change could devastate fishery industries and coral reef tourism.
The study commissioned by 14 nations whose economies rely heavily on the sea says climate change could cause hundreds of billions of dollars in losses by 2050, adding that limiting global warming would lessen the economic impact for coastal countries, but that they also need to adapt to ocean changes.

Tipping point for an 'uprising'
Johan Rockstrom, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, said social scientists believed that when roughly 3.5 per cent of a nation's population joins "civil and non-violent uprisings" it can be enough to force change, even in a dictatorship.
In Germany, numbers at the climate demonstrations on September 20 were estimated at nearly 2 per cent of the population, and in New Zealand at 3.5 per cent, he said.
"If you start seeing an uprising ... there will be an enormous pressure for the political leadership to step up and start acting," Rockstrom said - though he noted it "can also be quite challenging along the way".
Climate activists march in silence during a 'Fridays For Future' protest in Madrid during the COP25 climate talks. Credit: Getty Images
He questioned whether, at some point, it would start to become morally unacceptable to cause people's deaths with car exhaust, as happened with cigarette smoking.
In New Delhi, at some times of the year, young people are inhaling toxic pollution equivalent to smoking 10 cigarettes a day, killing over 7000 people a year in the city, he noted.
On Friday morning, eight-year-old Indian climate striker Licypriya Kangujam, of New Delhi, headed to her country's pavilion at the Madrid talks, clutching a hand-written poster calling on India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi to pass a flagship climate change law in the current parliament session.
She said she had been protesting in front of the parliament building regularly on Fridays to press for the legislation.
She said she had come to the climate talks with her father to tell politicians and others, "you must change your way of thinking".

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative