Thursday, February 27, 2020

Revealed: Quarter Of All Tweets About Climate Crisis Produced By Bots

The Guardian - 

Draft of Brown study says findings suggest ‘substantial impact of mechanized bots in amplifying denialist messages’
The researchers examined 6.5m tweets posted in the days leading up to and the month after Trump announced the US exit from the Paris accords on 1 June 2017. Photograph: Oliver Berg/AFP/Getty Images
The social media conversation over the climate crisis is being reshaped by an army of automated Twitter bots, with a new analysis finding that a quarter of all tweets about climate on an average day are produced by bots, the Guardian can reveal.
The stunning levels of Twitter bot activity on topics related to global heating and the climate crisis is distorting the online discourse to include far more climate science denialism than it would otherwise.
An analysis of millions of tweets from around the period when Donald Trump announced the US would withdraw from the Paris climate agreement found that bots tended to applaud the president for his actions and spread misinformation about the science.
The study of Twitter bots and climate was undertaken by Brown University and has yet to be published. Bots are a type of software that can be directed to autonomously tweet, retweet, like or direct message on Twitter, under the guise of a human-fronted account.
“These findings suggest a substantial impact of mechanized bots in amplifying denialist messages about climate change, including support for Trump’s withdrawal from the Paris agreement,” states the draft study, seen by the Guardian.
On an average day during the period studied, 25% of all tweets about the climate crisis came from bots. This proportion was higher in certain topics – bots were responsible for 38% of tweets about “fake science” and 28% of all tweets about the petroleum giant Exxon.
Conversely, tweets that could be categorized as online activism to support action on the climate crisis featured very few bots, at about 5% prevalence. The findings “suggest that bots are not just prevalent, but disproportionately so in topics that were supportive of Trump’s announcement or skeptical of climate science and action”, the analysis states.
Thomas Marlow, a PhD candidate at Brown who led the study, said the research came about as he and his colleagues are “always kind of wondering why there’s persistent levels of denial about something that the science is more or less settled on”.
The researchers examined 6.5m tweets posted in the days leading up to and the month after Trump announced the US exit from the Paris accords on 1 June 2017. The tweets were sorted into topic category, with an Indiana University tool called Botometer used to estimate the probability the user behind the tweet is a bot.
In terms of influence, I personally am convinced that they do make a difference, although this can be hard to quantifyStephen Lewandowsky
Marlow said he was surprised that bots were responsible for a quarter of climate tweets on an average day. “I was like, ‘Wow that seems really high,’” he said.
The consistent drumbeat of bot activity around climate topics is highlighted by the day of Trump’s announcement, when a huge spike in general interest in the topic saw the bot proportion drop by about half to 13%. Tweets by suspected bots did increase from hundreds a day to more than 25,000 a day during the days around the announcement but it wasn’t enough to prevent a fall in proportional share.
Trump has consistently spread misinformation about the climate crisis, most famously calling it “bullshit” and a “hoax”, although more recently the US president has said he accepts the science that the world is heating up. Nevertheless, his administration has dismantled any major policy aimed at cutting planet-warming gases, including car emissions standards and restrictions on coal-fired power plants.
The Brown University study wasn’t able to identify any individuals or groups behind the battalion of Twitter bots, nor ascertain the level of influence they have had around the often fraught climate debate.
However, a number of suspected bots that have consistently disparaged climate science and activists have large numbers of followers on Twitter. One that ranks highly on the Botometer score, @sh_irredeemable, wrote “Get lost Greta!” in December, in reference to the Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg.
This was followed by a tweet that doubted the world will reach a 9-billion population due to “#climatechange lunacy stopping progress”. The account has nearly 16,000 followers.
Another suspected bot, @petefrt, has nearly 52,000 followers and has repeatedly rejected climate science. “Get real, CNN: ‘Climate Change’ dogma is religion, not science,” the account posted in August. Another tweet from November called for the Paris agreement to be ditched in order to “reject a future built by globalists and European eco-mandarins”.
Twitter accounts spreading falsehoods about the climate crisis are also able to use the promoted tweets option available to those willing to pay for extra visibility. Twitter bans a number of things from its promoted tweets, including political content and tobacco advertising, but allows any sort of content, true or otherwise, on the climate crisis.
Research on internet blogs published last year found that climate misinformation is often spread due to readers’ perception of how widely this opinion is shared by other readers.
Stephan Lewandowsky, an academic at the University of Bristol who co-authored the research, said he was “not at all surprised” at the Brown University study due to his own interactions with climate-related messages on Twitter.
“More often than not, they turn out to have all the fingerprints of bots,” he said. “The more denialist trolls are out there, the more likely people will think that there is a diversity of opinion and hence will weaken their support for climate science.
“In terms of influence, I personally am convinced that they do make a difference, although this can be hard to quantify.”
John Cook, an Australian cognitive scientist and co-author with Lewandowsky, said that bots are “dangerous and potentially influential”, with evidence showing that when people are exposed to facts and misinformation they are often left misled.
“This is one of the most insidious and dangerous elements of misinformation spread by bots – not just that misinformation is convincing to people but that just the mere existence of misinformation in social networks can cause people to trust accurate information less or disengage from the facts,” Cook said.
Although Twitter bots didn’t ramp up significantly around the Paris withdrawal announcement, some advocates of action to tackle the climate crisis are wary of a spike in activity around the US presidential election later this year.
“Even though we don’t know who they are, or their exact motives, it seems self-evident that Trump thrives on the positive reinforcement he receives from these bots and their makers,” said Ed Maibach, an expert in climate communication at George Mason University.
“It is terrifying to ponder the possibility that the Potus was cajoled by bots into committing an atrocity against humanity.”

Links

Wednesday, February 26, 2020

(AU) 'Extraordinary' Fires Burnt At Historical Size, Beyond Climate Projections

Sydney Morning Herald - Peter Hannam

Australia's bushfires were not only "extraordinary" in scale but also exposed deficiencies in the climate models that are struggling to identify changes in rainfall and fire weather trends.
In a series of papers in Nature Climate Change published on Tuesday, scientists found the size of fires in NSW and Victoria were larger than any recorded since European settlement in Australia.
This season's bushfires were not only unprecedented in their size, they were also not well captured by climate models, scientists said. Credit: Alex Ellinghausen
They were also far bigger than similar forest fires elsewhere globally in at least the past two decades.
"In terms of the mid-latitude forests, this was a phenomenal event," said Ross Bradstock, head of the University of Wollongong's Centre of Environmental Risk Management of Bushfires, and an author of one of the papers.
Two fires - the Gospers Mountain and Currowan fires - each burnt more than half a million hectares, a "quite extraordinary" outcome for blazes caused by a single ignition point, Professor Bradstock said.
The paper estimated that 21 per cent of Australia's so-called temperate broadleaf and mixed forests had been burnt. That proportion was most likely an under-estimation because the tally only counted losses to the end of January and excluded those in Queensland, South Australia and Tasmania.
By contrast, average annual burnt areas for other continental forests were "well below 5 per cent" over the past 20 years. Taking Asian and African tropical and sub-tropical dry broadleaf forests alone, median annual losses were 8-9 per cent and the largest event about 13 per cent - well short of Australia's big event.
However, identifying the link between climate change and Australia's fires remains complicated, other papers showed.
Andrew King, a climate researcher at Melbourne University and lead author of one of the reports, said the dry conditions that preceded the fires were unusual and not well captured by climate models.
His team found the unusually long period since the last wet year was "the primary reason for the long-lasting dry conditions".

The Prime Minister has announced a royal commission into the bushfires in a bid to improve government response at all levels.

The 3½-year absence of rain-favouring La Nina events in the Pacific and the Indian Ocean equivalent - the negative phase of the Indian Ocean Dipole - was crucial for the dry set-up going into this season.
"Climate models have issues just simulating what's going on in the Indian Ocean and the Pacific Ocean to a slightly less degree," Dr King told the Herald. "How much can we trust them? We can't say much with any strong conviction."
While the science was clear that a warming world is ramping up temperatures almost everywhere - including in the region hard-hit by this season's blazes - it is less settled about how rainfall patterns have changed and what's to come.
"We don't currently have the capacity to make robust statements about what will happen in the future," Dr King said.
That knowledge gap could leave Australia under-prepared should drought become worse in the future, he said, adding, "It's holding us back in terms of adaptation."
A third paper, led by Benjamin Sanderson from France's CERFACS institute, argued climate models were failing to keep pace with improved fire models that were better at capturing "the evolution of fire risk".
"For NSW (the Australian state in which the fire extent is the most unprecedented), the scale of the fires is unmatched" in the latest generation of climate models, Dr Sanderson's paper said.
For instance, the sixth generation of so-called Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP6) only simulated similar fire extents at 4 degrees of warming, the paper found. (Warming since pre-industrial times is slightly more than 1 degree.)
"The fact that Australia has experienced damages that go beyond what is currently simulated highlights that current syntheses may be missing major risks," it said.

Links

(AU) Government Urged To Set 'More Aggressive And Ambitious' Climate Goals

Sydney Morning Herald - Mike Foley

The Morrison government has been urged to up its climate goals to protect the country's international reputation and for global humanitarian reasons.
Kylie Porter, the executive director of United Nations affiliate Global Compact Network Australia, said the federal government must set "more aggressive and ambitious" climate targets before the 2020 United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP26) in Glasgow in November.
Save the Children chief executive Paul Ronalds, who returned from Bangladesh this week, said "thousands and thousands" of climate refugees were pouring into the capital, Dhaka. Credit: AP
"If we don't come up with some pretty strong policy before the next international climate change conference ... it's highly likely that Australia's reputation will get worse," Ms Porter said.
Australia drew international criticism at last year's UN climate talks when it avoided tougher emissions reduction targets by banding together with a small group of nations to oppose a measure that would have stopped it using controversial "carry-over credits" to meet its climate goals.
Global Compact Network Australia is an arm of the UN Global Compact for sustainable development, with more than 12,000 corporate signatories including a number of leading Australian companies such as BHP, ANZ, Coles and Australia Post. It is calling for a commitment to limit warming to 1.5 degrees, which would be tougher than the Paris target, which requires signatory countries to aim for between 1.5 and 2 degrees.
"We think it's very important that business in particular start taking a position on their climate change strategy and consider their responsibility to respect human rights," Ms Porter said.


The RBA is warning climate change could lead to the next global financial break down.

Save the Children chief executive Paul Ronalds, who returned from Bangladesh this week, said the "thousands and thousands" of climate refugees pouring into the capital, Dhaka, was an example of the upcoming disruption likely across the Asia-Pacific region.
"The humanitarian impact of climate change will be huge but they'll be particularly significant in our region," Mr Ronalds said.
Australia was in the middle of "the most disaster-prone region in the world", surrounded by many Pacific and Asian countries that were susceptible to rising sea levels and extreme weather, he said. This meant we could expect to see "many, many millions more climate refugees and Australia is going to be increasingly attractive for them".
There was "no question" climate change was driving refugees off the land among the Bangladeshi parliamentarians he spoke with, Mr Ronalds said. "They make the comparison with Australia to say 'just like Australia, our two countries are on the frontline of climate change'," he said.
Australian contributed $200 million to the Green Climate Fund between 2015 and 2018, which was set up by the UN to help developing nations and small island states cope with the impacts of climate change. The Morrison government ceased funding in December with a final payment of $19.2 million, sparking criticism from developing nations.
Australia is also facing climate headaches on the diplomatic front.
Last week, European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen, speaking to the World Economic Forum, proposed a "carbon border adjustment mechanism", which would protect European businesses from goods produced in countries without a carbon price.
Europe is Australia's second-biggest trading partner and the scheme would impose import tariffs on Australian steel, cement, aluminium and potentially coal. In December, France proposed tying a free-trade deal to Australia adopting climate change targets.

Links

A Security Threat Assessment Of Global Climate Change: How Likely Warming Scenarios Indicate a Catastrophic Security Future

Washington — In a comprehensive report released by the “National Security, Military and Intelligence Panel (NSMIP)” of the Center for Climate and Security, experts warn of High-to-Catastrophic threats to security from plausible climate change trajectories – the avoidance of which will require “quickly reducing and phasing out global greenhouse gas emissions.”
The panel, made up of national security, military and intelligence experts, analyzed the globe through the lens of the U.S. Geographic Combatant Commands, and concluded that:
“Even at scenarios of low warming, each region of the world will face severe risks to national and global security in the next three decades. Higher levels of warming will pose catastrophic, and likely irreversible, global security risks over the course of the 21st century.”
The report, titled “A Security Threat Assessment of Global Climate Change: How Likely Warming Scenarios Indicate a Catastrophic Security Future,” is a first of its kind, bringing together a panel of security professionals to analyze the security implications of two future warming scenarios (near term: 1-2°C and medium-long term: 2-4+°C).
It identifies major threats, including heightened social and political instability, and risks to U.S. military missions and infrastructure, as well as security institutions, at both warming scenarios and across all regions of the world.
Highlighting the key findings of the report, members of the National Security, Military and Intelligence Panel (NSMIP) stated:

  • “It’s the job of the U.S. intelligence community to anticipate risks to national security, and provide strategic warning to appropriate policymakers. The science has long been clear, and the security community is adding compelling analysis of the threats climate change pose to people and nations. It’s long past time for vigorous action to address them.”
    – Dr. Rod Schoonover, Advisory Board Member, Center for Climate and Security; Founder and CEO, Ecological Futures Group; Former Senior Analyst and Senior Scientist, Bureau of Intelligence and Research, U.S. Department of State and Former Director of Environment and Natural Resources at the National Intelligence Council (NIC)

  • “The assessment is clear – climate change is a pressing risk to national and global security, and will evolve to become a severe and systemic threat the more we allow global temperatures to rise. Our Panel’s analysis shows that no region of the world will be left unaffected, and climate impacts will interact in dangerous ways in even near-term, lower levels of warming.”
    – Hon. Sherri Goodman, Senior Strategist and Advisory Board Member, Center for Climate and Security; Former Deputy Undersecretary of Defense (Environmental Security), U.S. Department of Defense

  • “The negative consequences of continued climate change across the next century will affect security institutions and infrastructure. We must recognize the resulting dire implications for global stability. Without leadership and swift action to prepare for and prevent these scenarios, American interests are at risk.”
    – Ambassador Richard Kauzlarich, Distinguished Visiting Professor, George Mason University; Former National Intelligence Officer for Europe and former U.S. Ambassador to Azerbaijan and Bosnia and Herzegovina

  • “During my time at the Department of Defense, I saw the U.S. military take the threats posed by climate change seriously, in both its planning and operations. But there is so much more to be done. If we don’t come together to mitigate this threat, soon, American interests and security are on the line.”
    – John Conger, Director, Center for Climate and Security; Former Principal Deputy Under Secretary of Defense, (Comptroller), U.S. Department of Defense (DoD)

  • “We don’t always have the benefit of seeing clearly the security challenges that are coming our way. As this report shows, we know that the global risks of climate change will be serious— possibly catastrophic. We have a responsibility to act with urgency to address these threats.”
    – Christine Parthemore, CEO of the Council on Strategic Risks

  • “It is our hope that this analysis can be used by security professionals and policymakers alike to better understand how climate change will impact U.S. security interests and objectives. But even more importantly, hopefully these assessments will convince all decision-makers that we must act swiftly to avoid the worst of these threats to global security.”
    – Kate Guy, Panel Chair and Principal Investigator, Center for Climate and Security

  • “Though we are facing unprecedented risks from climate change, as the report shows, we also possess unprecedented foresight about those risks. This underscores a responsibility to prepare for and prevent the security consequences of a changing climate. And you don’t have to take our word for it. Scientists and national security, military and intelligence professionals agree: the risks are potentially catastrophic, and there’s a narrowing window of opportunity to do something about it.”
    – Francesco Femia and Caitlin Werrell, Co-Founders and Directors of Research, The Council on Strategic Risks/ The Center for Climate and Security

  • “Through this report, the security community is calling out loud and clear for policymakers to take the threats posed by climate change seriously. The best way to prevent the most dangerous impacts of climate change is to reach global net-zero emissions as soon as possible. Any further denial and delay will only make the lives of our children and grandchildren even less secure.”
    – Craig Gannett, President, Henry M. Jackson Foundation

A Security Threat Assessment of Global Climate Change: A Product of the National Security, Military and Intelligence Panel on Climate Change
The climate security risks posed to each region of the world are assessed in the report through the lens of the U.S. Geographic Combatant Commands. Topline risks for each area of responsibility are summarized below.

  • AFRICOM - U.S. Africa Command (all of Africa except Egypt)
    Under a near-term, 1-2°C/1.8-3.6°F warming scenario, this region will likely see rapid loss of rural livelihoods, disease, resource stress, and migration. In this scenario, violent extremist groups bolster their numbers, and security threats spiral into nearby fragile areas.
    • Under a medium-to-long term, 2-4+°C/3.6-7.2+°F warming scenario, this region would experience new and renewed interstate conflict over water resources, and severe humanitarian crises resulting from migrating populations, weather disasters, and economic shocks. Security institutions may not be able to preserve stability in the region.

  • CENTCOM - U.S. Central Command (Middle East, including Egypt in Africa, and Central Asia)
    Under a near-term, 1-2°C/1.8-3.6°F warming scenario, this region will likely experience dangerous levels of temperature rise, drought, and dwindling water supplies that intensify already tense resource, political, and territorial competition. 
    • Under a medium-to-long term, 2-4+°C/3.6-7.2+°F warming scenario, this region would experience temperatures levels that render many areas of the region uninhabitable, competition over water resources, large-scale populations displacement, and social unrest leading to enduring conflicts and state failure.

  • EUCOM - U.S. European Command (Europe, Russia, Greenland, and Israel)
    Under a near-term, 1-2°C/1.8-3.6°F warming scenario, this region will likely experience severe weather that threatens destabilization of its key economic sectors, rising regional inequality, migration and ethno-nationalist responses, and negative impacts on civil and military infrastructure.
    • Under a medium-to-long term, 2-4+°C/3.6-7.2+°F warming scenario, this region would experience prolonged drought and rising seas, significant internal displacement, and an influx of migrants from neighboring areas. A breakdown in regional political, institutional, and security cohesion becomes more likely.

  • INDOPACOM - U.S. Indo-Pacific Command (U.S. West Coast to the west coast of India, and from the Arctic to the Antarctic)
    Under a near-term, 1-2°C/1.8-3.6°F warming scenario, this region will experience water scarcity in some areas and precipitation inundation in others, posing risks to security infrastructure, social stability, and tensions between regional powers. 
    • Under a medium-to-long term, 2-4+°C/3.6-7.2+°F warming scenario, this region would experience devastating sea level rise threatening its megacities, infrastructure, and populations, and the resulting displacement and securitization of state borders.

  • NORTHCOM - U.S. Northern Command (Puerto Rico, Canada, Mexico, The Bahamas)
    Under a near-term, 1-2°C/1.8-3.6°F warming scenario, this region will experience more intense, extreme events like storms and wildfires, with significant impacts on life, property, security infrastructure, and democratic institutions.
    • Under a medium-to-long term, 2-4+°C/3.6-7.2+°F warming scenario, this region would experience extreme heat, sea level rise, and disaster events, with severe impact on critical and security infrastructure. The region would become increasingly divided, and potentially entangled in resource competitions.

  • SOUTHCOM - U.S. Southern Command (Central and South America, the Caribbean)
    Under a near-term, 1-2°C/1.8-3.6°F warming scenario, this region will likely experience extreme heat and drought, forcing communities to migrate in search of new opportunities, with transnational criminal groups, and narcotics and human traffickers taking advantage of growing destabilization.
    • Under a medium-to-long term, 2-4+°C/3.6-7.2+°F warming scenario, this region would experience even more acute weather instability, crop collapse, and spreading disease. These issues, along with failing agriculture, will increase the likelihood of violent conflict, drive significant internal and cross-border migration, and increase political instability.
Links

Tuesday, February 25, 2020

(AU) Anthony Albanese Says Coal Mining Could Continue In Australia In A Net Zero Emissions World

ABC News - Anna Henderson


Coal mining could continue beyond 2050 even if Australia adopts a net zero emissions target, Opposition Leader Anthony Albanese says.

Key points
  • Anthony Albanese says all energy sources will need to be part of the process to reach the net zero-emissions target
  • Mr Albanese said Labor did not believe a carbon price would be necessary to achieve this
  • Mr Albanese is opposed to the Government's investment in new brown coal but agreed there was still likely to be coal mining in Australia post-2050
Labor's shadow cabinet has agreed to move with 73 other nations, and every state and territory, to embrace a carbon-neutral target by the middle of the century.
It is the same overarching target Labor took to the last election.
Mr Albanese is opposed to government investment in new thermal coal mining — the type of coal that is used in coal-fired power stations.
But under questioning by Insiders host David Speers, he agreed there was still likely to be coal mining in Australia post-2050.
"I suspect we will," Mr Albanese said.
"[The target is] net, that's the point."
He argued there was no replacement for metallurgical coal, which is used to make steel and is a major export out of Queensland.
The Labor leader also agreed thermal coal mining for export could continue under the commitment.
"Yes, we could," he said.
"It will be determined by global action."

Climate and economy linked
The Morrison Government risks being stranded at the intersection of climate change-related disasters and their economic fallout, writes Ian Verrender.
The Australian coal sector employs more than 50,000 people.
Mr Albanese said exported coal was not counted in Australia's greenhouse gas budget.
"You don't measure the emissions where the original product comes from. I mean Japan isn't responsible for the emissions of every vehicle that's built in Japan," he said.
Albanese: Net zero will be 'economy wide'
The Opposition Leader confirmed Labor's 2050 net-zero emissions policy would apply to all industries.
He told Insiders transport and agriculture would not have any special considerations.
That's different to the position taken by his predecessor, Bill Shorten, before the last election.
"Emissions are about energy, they're about transport," Mr Albanese said.He said the net-zero target was not just about driving down emissions, but also compensating for them.

What do we really think
about taking climate action?

A majority of Australians believe climate change is driving more droughts and floods, and that higher power prices are the result of "excessive profit margins".
"It's also about practices that can make a difference in going negative emissions, if you like," he said.
"You can do that through agriculture, through forestry, through a range of measures."
Mr Albanese was pressed repeatedly to confirm whether Labor would be open to a price on carbon as a way to incentivise industries to reduce emissions.
"We don't believe that is necessary," Mr Albanese replied.
"We didn't go to the last election with that commitment."
Labor is yet to confirm whether it will ditch the shorter-term, 2030 climate-change target the party took to last year's election.
Privately, many opposition MPs expect it to be changed and pushed back.
Mr Albanese said Labor was committed to "interim" measures ahead of 2050, but he said the timeframe and details of those measures were yet to be settled.

Links

(AU) New CSIRO, AEMO Study Confirms Wind, Solar And Storage Beat Coal, Gas And Nuclear

RenewEconomy - 

Actually, I'd rather a big banana

An updated study on current and future generation costs by the CSIRO and the Australian Energy Market Operator confirms that wind, solar and storage technologies are by far the cheapest form of low carbon options for Australia, and are likely to dominate the global energy mix in coming decades.
The first report, GenCost 2018, identified that wind and solar were by far the cheapest forms of new generation technologies, clearly cheaper than coal, and even when  combined with storage, remained easily the cheapest form low carbon electricity options.
A draft of the updated study, GenCost 2019-20, has been quietly posted on the AEMO website and confirms that wind and solar and storage remain the cheapest technologies, now and into the future, and much cheaper than the technologies promoted by the Australian government – gas, carbon capture, and nuclear.
The study is jointly funded by the CSIRO and AEMO, although CSIRO took carriage of the report, along with advisors Aurecon, who succeeded GHD which did the first version.
Its capital cost estimates – which assume continue cost reductions for solar, wind and dramatic falls for batteries, remain little changed from the 2018 version, although wind cost reductions are lower than expected last year.


And despite ferocious criticism by the nuclear lobby, its estimates for nuclear remain unchanged, largely because it says there have been no technology advances since the last report. It does recognise the potential for small nuclear reactors in certain scenarios, but these are heavily qualified: they are at least a decade away, and would still deliver a levellised cost of energy at least twice that of wind and solar and storage.
“The global generation mix is expected to be dominated by wind and solar photovoltaic (PV) by 2050 in all three scenarios explored in this report: Central, High CRE and Diverse technology,” the report says.
“The implementation of scenarios that include a broader set of global technology drivers has resulted in a wider range of potential capital cost reduction paths for wind and solar PV. The new scenarios also indicate that in some scenarios carbon capture and storage and nuclear small modular reactors could play a larger role than previously projected.”
The other changes in capital costs have been upward revisions for gas generators, mainly because investors are looking at smaller plants and so the costs per unit are higher, and for solar thermal technology – which is no surprise given the hiccups in that technology’s development and the cancellation of a proposed large project in South Australia.



For generation costs, expressed as the levellised cost of energy (LCOE),  it notes that wind and solar are clearly the cheapest form of bulk energy, at half the cost of fossil fuel alternatives, and one fifth the cost of nuclear. Even with storage – shorter duration batteries or longer duration pumped hydro – wind and solar match fossil fuels, and are one third the cost of nuclear.
In coming years, the costs of wind and particularly solar are expected to continue to fall. And storage too, so their cost advantage of renewables and storage is expected to increase.


So, by 2030, nuclear is still well out of the money, and wind and solar have increased their cost advantage over fossil fuels, particularly those with a carbon price attached.
In virtually every scenario, the CSIRO study envisages a world dominated by wind and solar by 2050. Nuclear may play a slightly increased role in the “diverse technology” scenario, but this is only with artificial limits placed on the deployment of wind and solar.


The nuclear question is interesting, given the increasing calls from sections of the government to pursue the technology. CSIRO says there have been no new developments in the last year to change its estimated capital costs for coal or nuclear. And it is clear that many of these plants would be too big, and not flexible enough, in a modern grid with high renewables and distributed generation.
On small modular reactors, it says there is no hard evidence on costs because none have been built, and the main source of estimates has been from technology vendors, and “past experience has indicated that vendor-based estimates are often initially too low,” it writes.
“Constructing first-of-a-kind plant includes additional unforeseen costs associated with lack of experience in completing such projects on budget. SMR will not only be subject to first-of-a-kind costs in Australia but also the general engineering principle that building plant smaller leads to higher costs.”
But it only sees SMRs entering the equation in more than a decade’s time if governments get serious about the 2°C target, if they impose a limit on the renewable energy share, and if there is a significant carbon price.
Given that even the Coalition government expects the share of renewables to reach 50 per cent by 2030, and AEMO expects that to be higher by 2030 and heading to at least 74 per cent to 90 per cent by 2040, then that does not appear to leave much room for either carbon capture and storage or nuclear in this country.
And, of course, there is no enthusiasm for a carbon price from the main nuclear lobbyists, primarily the Minerals Council of Australia and the LNP politicians who are also pushing coal.


The CSIRO study says that in some scenarios the cost of carbon capture and storage and nuclear could be lower than previous estimations, particularly if small modular reactors achieve a reduction in nuclear capital costs after 2030.
Even then, as this graph shows, the cost of nuclear in 2040 will still be considerably more expensive than the combination of wind and solar and storage, and likely to be more than three times more expensive across different scenarios. A similar cost disparity remains for 2050. And investors, it notes, will go for value for money.

Links

(AU) Australia Says Climate Change Targets Can’t Risk Economy, Jobs

Bloomberg - 

▶ Nation to prepare long-term plans ahead of key Glasgow meeting
▶ Coal exports likely to continue, opposition Labor Party says
Emissions billow from cooling towers in Australia. Photographer: Carla Gottgens/Bloomberg
Australia’s government will work to set new long-term plans on reducing greenhouse gas emissions ahead of a key global summit this year, though signaled it won’t pursue policies that pose risks to jobs or growth.
Prime Minister Scott Morrison, who has faced pressure over his climate and energy strategy in the wake of Australia’s deadly wildfires, has criticized opponents for pledging to target net zero emissions by 2050 without detailing how they’ll safeguard economic expansion.
“If we make the wrong decisions, not only would we be harming the Australian economy, harming Australian workers, we would also be harming the global environment,” Finance Minister Mathias Cormann said in an interview on Sky News.
Australia’s plans will need to account for the production of materials including liquefied natural gas, which is exported to markets like China or Japan and typically displaces more polluting energy sources, Cormann said. “We know that that helps reduce global emissions by more,” he said.Following the fires, Morrison, who won a national election in May and won’t face a new poll until late 2022, has appeared to signal he’ll resist any quick shift to more extensive cuts to carbon emissions. His Liberal-National coalition government also remains cautious over the impact on a coal sector that employs about 50,000 workers, according to the Minerals Council of Australia, an industry group.
Morrison’s government will finalize long-term emissions reduction proposals ahead of the United Nations climate summit in Glasgow in November, Cormann said.
Australia may continue to be an exporter of thermal coal in 2050, according to Anthony Albanese, leader of the main opposition Labour Party, that’s targeting net zero emissions by that date.
“That will be determined by the market and by international agreements,” Albanese told ABC Television in an interview. “You don’t measure the emissions where the original product comes from -- Japan isn’t responsible for the emissions of every vehicle that’s built in Japan.”


Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative