The Guardian - Jonathan Watts
Exclusively compiled data from the Hadley Centre’s supercomputer shows alarming climate trajectory
 |
Scientists at the Hadley Centre, which has been on the global frontline of climate monitoring, research and modelling since 1990, say their early theories have been proven by facts. Photograph: Hadley Centre
|
The human fingerprint on the climate is now unmistakable and will
become increasingly evident over the coming decades, the UK Met Office
has confirmed after 30 years of pioneering study.
Since the 1990s, global temperatures have warmed by half a degree,
Arctic sea ice has shrunk by almost 2 million km2, sea-levels have risen
by about 10cm and carbon dioxide in the atmosphere has increased by 60
parts per million (17%), according to figures exclusively compiled for
the Guardian to mark the 30th anniversary of the Met Office’s Hadley
Centre for climate science and services.
The data highlights how a young generation has grown up in a climate
unprecedented in a millennium. Future projections suggest that by
mid-century a 60-year-old Briton is likely to be living in a climate
1.2C warmer than when they were born.
Scientists at the Hadley Centre, which has been on the global
frontline of climate monitoring, research and modelling since it opened
in 1990, said early theories about fossil-fuel disruption have been
proven by subsequent facts.
“The climate now is completely different from what we had 30 years
ago. It is completely outside the bounds of possibility in natural
variation,” said Peter Stott, a professor and expert on climate
attribution science at the centre.
 |
Margaret Thatcher, with Sir John Houghton, opening the Hadley Centre. She said the UK needed a world-leading climate centre to assess the “serious consequences” of greenhouse gas emissions. Photograph: Hadley Centre
|
In
the Hadley Centre’s early projections, he said, scientists forecast
0.5C of warming in the UK between 1990 and 2020 as a result of emissions
from oil, gas and coal: “We got it spot on.”
With new heat records being broken with increasing frequency, he said
global temperatures were now above any level in the Met Office
measurements since 1850, or indirectly calculated through tree rings
going back thousands of years.
Carbon dioxide concentrations in the
atmosphere are also higher than anything seen in million-year-old ice
cores.
“We are seeing an unprecedented climate,” Stott said. “The human
fingerprint is everywhere.”
The impact was less obvious in 1990, when the centre opened in
conjunction with the publication of the first report by the UN
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change - both were overseen by the UK
scientist John Houghton,
who died earlier this year.
Change in September Arctic sea ice extent
Million sq km, relative to the 1981-2010 average
 |
Guardian graphic. Source: Met Office 2020. Observed figure for 2019 not yet available. Full source notes are included at the end of the article.
|
At the inauguration, the then prime minister, Margaret Thatcher, said
the UK needed a world-leading climate centre to assess the “serious
consequences” of greenhouse gas emissions. “What it predicts will affect
our daily lives. Governments and international organisations in every
part of the world are going to have to sit up and take notice and
respond,”
she said.
Thatcher,
who studied science at Oxford, needed little convincing, but she had to
overcome a sceptical cabinet. Atmospheric physicists
had been warning oil companies and policymakers about the dangers of fossil fuels for decades,
but the “greenhouse effect” was still a relatively novel concern for
the broader public. Nobody felt a change. The world had already warmed
by about half a degree from pre-industrial levels, but this was low
enough to be within natural variation.
Few people knew the difference between short-term “weather” and the
“climate”, which is usually measured over a much longer period of 30
years.
Back then, there was also considerable scepticism about the ability
of meteorologists to forecast change, even on a daily basis. Memories
were fresh of the BBC weatherman Michael Fish infamously reassuring
viewers that fears of a hurricane were unfounded, just hours before the
fiercest storm in generations hit the UK.
Change in global annual mean sea level Centimetres difference, compared with 1981-2000 average
 |
Guardian graphic. Source: Met Office 2020. Full source notes are included at the end of the article.
|
“It was unglamorous” recalls James Murphy, a science fellow who was posted to the Hadley Centre from the beginning. “But the mood in the first decade was one of great excitement, because it was a chance to do a lot of pioneering research in a growing field.”
As
acceptance and importance grew, so did scepticism. Critics, often
funded by oil firms, pushed back against climate science because they
did not like its political and economic implications. Ahead of the
climate summits in Kyoto (1997) and Copenhagen (2009), fossil fuel
companies funded misinformation campaigns to cast doubt on climate
models.
The Hadley Centre remained focused on science. Researchers expanded
and refined their models by incorporating new knowledge on biological
carbon cycles and the likely impact of fossil fuels not only on
temperature, but on Arctic ice, sea-level rise, flooding, storms,
droughts and other atmospheric phenomena.
Supercomputer advances enabled much greater precision. Early models
mapped the impact on grid cells of 300km on each side. Today that is
down to 2.2km, which allows detailed predictions of which stretches of
river basins and coastlines will need the most protection.
Researchers are discovering the impacts go far beyond the initial
focus on average temperature. Heat records are being set with increasing
frequency. Rainfall patterns are noticeably shifting beyond natural
variation. Arctic ice is shrinking faster than expected. The rising seas
have already left some places, such as
Fairbourne in Wales, below spring-tide levels.
Global average temperature change
Celsius change, compared with pre-industrial conditions
 |
Guardian graphic. Source: Met Office 2020. Full source notes are included at the end of the article.
|
By
2050 – the year the UK plans to achieve carbon neutrality – the direct
impact on Britain will be moderated by the surrounding ocean and there
may be opportunities to plant new crops, but these benefits will be
dwarfed by trade disruption, migration, humanitarian disasters and
shifting ecosystems.
“Overall it’s bad. The negatives outweigh the positives,” said
Richard Betts, a Met Office scientist who is leading scientific analysis
for the next UK climate change risk assessment. “It stands to reason
that if the world keeps gets hotter and hotter, sooner or later we’ll
reach the point where it is first uncomfortable and then hard to
function. This won’t be seen in the UK, but in parts of the world that
are already hot and humid it could increasingly get too hot to
function.”
The Hadley supercomputer calculates myriad possible pathways
depending on how much carbon dioxide, methane and other greenhouse gases
enter the atmosphere. The good news is that the worst-emissions
scenario, known as RCP 8.5, is considered less likely than before
because the global coal industry has not grown as feared. The bad news
is current emissions trends (which lie between the RCP 4.5 and RCP 6
pathways) could take the planet to 2C warmer than pre-industrial levels
by mid-century, which will increase storm damage, heatwaves, sea-level
rise and the already great risk that the Arctic will be ice-free in
summer.
The climate trends are based on multiple-year averages rather than
year-on-year comparisons, which are more subject to natural variation.
Even the current best-case scenario – RCP 2.6, which is roughly in
line with the Paris agreement – would leave the world hotter than today.
“What stands out is that even in the lowest current scenario, we get
warming. We’ll need to prepare and adapt,” says Jason Lowe, the head of
climate services at Hadley. He predicts extreme summer heatwaves, such
as those seen in 2018, will become the norm rather than an exception.
Changes in UK temperature
Celsius, based on annual average temperature
 |
Guardian graphic. Source: Met Office 2020. *2019 figure for observed temperature is provisional. Full source notes are included at the end of the article.
|
“As
a scientist, I want to narrow the uncertainty so the information is as
good as possible so we can plan. I think of the generations to come. I
have a nine-year-old daughter. I find myself wondering which of these
pathways we will be on when she is 80 or 90.”
More extreme results are possible at both ends of the spectrum. The
next set of climate assessments will introduce a more ambitious
best-case scenario (RCP 1.9) that would mean a faster transition to
zero-carbon energy and a greater chance of holding temperature rises
below 1.5C. But the situation could worsen rapidly if the climate hits
tipping points, such as the collapse of the west Antarctic ice sheet.
“There are still dangers out there that we don’t fully understand,”
said Stott. “Much of the uncertainty lies on the bad side. It could be
terrifying. Can we grow enough crops to feed the population? Can we cope
if some places are battered by storm after storm?”
Such concerns explain why the anniversary cannot be entirely
triumphant. Despite growing evidence of climate risks, governments have
been slow to act. Apart from downward blips such as the 2008 financial
crisis and the coronavirus lockdown, emissions have steadily increased.
The Hadley Centre’s work now is not only about predicting impacts, but
preparing for them.
“Reality has proven that what we were saying 20 to 30 years ago was
right. As scientists, that is vindication. But on a personal level, I
hoped we would track a different emissions trajectory from where we are
now,” Stott said.
“The worry is that we are now taking risks globally that we don’t
fully understand ... there will be no winners of climate change if we
continue. Scientific evidence has been around for a while. It is time it
was taken seriously.”
Data source notes
- Observed September Arctic sea ice extent from HadISST.2.2.0.0 (selected as single source from Met Office climate dashboard.) Emission scenarios are the mean averages for climate scenarios SSP1-2.6 (low), SSP2-4.5 (medium-low) and SSP5-8.5 (high).
- Observed changes in global mean sea level (GMSL) in metres from
Nasa satellite data relative to 1981-2000 average. Emissions scenarios
are 50th percentile projections from UKCP18 estimates, RCP2.6 (low),
RCP4.5 (medium-low), and RCP8.5 (high).
- Observed annual global temperature data from HadCRUT4. Emissions scenarios as above.
- Annual temperature for the UK based on HadUK-Grid observations. Emissions scenarios as above.
- All hindcast data omitted.
Links