New York Times
- Christopher Flavelle | Brad Plumer
|
Hiroko Tabuchi
Continent-spanning storms triggered blackouts in Oklahoma and
Mississippi, halted one-third of U.S. oil production and disrupted
vaccinations in 20 states.
|
Traffic at a standstill on Interstate 35 in Kileen, Texas, on
Thursday. Credit...Joe
Raedle/Getty Images
|
Even as Texas struggled to restore electricity and water over the past
week, signs of the risks posed by increasingly extreme weather to
America’s aging infrastructure were cropping up across the country.
The week’s continent-spanning
winter storms triggered blackouts in Texas, Oklahoma, Mississippi and several other states. One-third of oil
production in the nation was halted. Drinking-water systems in Ohio were
knocked offline. Road networks nationwide were paralyzed and vaccination
efforts in 20 states were disrupted.
The crisis carries a profound warning. As climate change brings more
frequent and intense storms, floods, heat waves, wildfires and other
extreme events, it is placing growing stress on the foundations of the
country’s economy: Its network of roads and railways, drinking-water
systems, power plants, electrical grids, industrial waste sites and even
homes. Failures in just one sector can set off a domino effect of
breakdowns in hard-to-predict ways.
Much of this infrastructure was built decades ago, under the expectation
that the environment around it would remain stable, or at least
fluctuate within predictable bounds. Now climate change is upending that
assumption.
“We are colliding with a future of extremes,” said Alice Hill, who
oversaw planning for climate risks on the National Security Council
during the Obama administration. “We base all our choices about risk
management on what’s occurred in the past, and that is no longer a safe
guide.”
While it’s not always possible to say precisely how
global warming influenced any one particular storm, scientists said, an overall rise in extreme weather creates sweeping
new risks.
Sewer systems are overflowing more often as powerful rainstorms exceed
their design capacity. Coastal homes and highways are collapsing as
intensified runoff erodes cliffs. Coal ash, the toxic residue produced
by coal-burning plants, is spilling into rivers as floods overwhelm
barriers meant to hold it back. Homes once beyond the reach of wildfires
are burning in blazes they were never designed to withstand.
|
A broken water main in McComb., Miss. on
Thursday. Credit...Matt
Williamson/The Enterprise-Journal, via Associated Press
|
Problems like these often reflect an inclination of governments to
spend as little money as possible, said Shalini Vajjhala, a former
Obama administration official who now advises cities on meeting
climate threats. She said it’s hard to persuade taxpayers to spend
extra money to guard against disasters that seem unlikely.
But climate change flips that logic, making inaction far costlier.
“The argument I would make is, we can’t afford not to, because
we’re absorbing the costs” later, Ms. Vajjhala said, after
disasters strike. “We’re spending poorly.”
The Biden administration has talked extensively about climate
change, particularly the need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions
and create jobs in renewable energy. But it has spent less time
discussing how to manage the growing effects of climate change,
facing criticism from experts for not appointing more people who
focus on climate resilience.
“I am extremely concerned by the lack of emergency-management
expertise reflected in Biden’s climate team,” said Samantha
Montano, an assistant professor at the Massachusetts Maritime
Academy who focuses on disaster policy. “There’s an urgency here
that still is not being reflected.”
A White House spokesman, Vedant Patel, said in a statement,
“Building resilient and sustainable infrastructure that can
withstand extreme weather and a changing climate will play an
integral role in creating millions of good paying, union jobs”
while cutting greenhouse gas emissions.
And while President Biden has called for a major push to refurbish
and upgrade the nation’s infrastructure, getting a closely divided
Congress to spend hundreds of billions, if not trillions of
dollars, will be a major challenge.
Heightening the cost to society, disruptions can
disproportionately affect lower-income households and other
vulnerable groups, including older people or those with limited
English.
“All these issues are converging,” said Robert D. Bullard, a
professor at Texas Southern University who studies wealth and
racial disparities related to the environment. “And there’s simply
no place in this country that’s not going to have to deal with
climate change.”
Many forms of water crisis
|
Flooding around Edenville Township, Mich., last year
swept away a bridge over the Tittabawassee
River. Credit...Matthew Hatcher/Getty Images
|
In September, when a sudden storm dumped a record of more
than two inches of water on Washington in less than 75
minutes, the result wasn’t just widespread flooding, but
also raw sewage rushing into hundreds of homes.
Washington, like many other cities in the Northeast and
Midwest, relies on what’s called a combined sewer overflow
system: If a downpour overwhelms storm drains along the
street, they are built to overflow into the pipes that
carry raw sewage. But if there’s too much pressure, sewage
can be pushed backward, into people’s homes — where the
forces can send it erupting from toilets and shower
drains.
This is what happened in Washington. The city’s system was
built in the late 1800s. Now, climate change is straining
an already outdated design.
DC Water, the local utility, is spending billions of
dollars so that the system can hold more sewage. “We’re
sort of in uncharted territory,” said Vincent Morris, a
utility spokesman.
The challenge of managing and taming the nation’s water
supplies — whether in streets and homes, or in vast rivers
and watersheds — is growing increasingly complex as storms
intensify. Last May, rain-swollen flooding
breached two dams in Central Michigan, forcing thousands of residents to flee their homes and
threatening a chemical complex and toxic waste cleanup
site. Experts warned it was unlikely to be the last such
failure.
Many of the country’s 90,000 dams were built decades ago
and were already in dire need of repairs. Now climate
change poses an additional threat, bringing heavier
downpours to parts of the country and
raising the odds that some dams could be overwhelmed
by more water than they were designed to handle. One
recent study
found that most of California’s biggest dams were at
increased risk of failure as global warming advances.
In recent years, dam-safety officials have begun grappling
with the dangers. Colorado, for instance,
now requires dam builders
to take into account the risk of increased atmospheric
moisture driven by climate change as they plan for
worst-case flooding scenarios.
But nationwide, there remains a backlog of thousands of
older dams that still need to be rehabilitated or
upgraded. The price tag could ultimately stretch
to more than $70 billion.
“Whenever we study dam failures, we often find there was a
lot of complacency beforehand,” said Bill McCormick,
president of the Association of State Dam Safety
Officials. But given that failures can have catastrophic
consequences, “we really can’t afford to be complacent.”
Built for a different future
|
Crews repaired switches on utility poles damaged
by the storms in Texas. Credit...Tamir Kalifa for The New York Times
|
If the Texas blackouts exposed
one state’s poor planning, they also provide a warning for the nation: Climate
change threatens
virtually every aspect
of electricity grids that aren’t always designed to handle
increasingly severe weather. The vulnerabilities show up in
power lines, natural-gas plants, nuclear reactors and myriad
other systems.
Higher storm surges can knock out coastal power
infrastructure. Deeper droughts can reduce water supplies
for hydroelectric dams. Severe heat waves can reduce the
efficiency of fossil-fuel generators, transmission lines and
even solar panels at precisely the moment that demand soars
because everyone cranks up their air-conditioners.
Climate hazards can also combine in new and unforeseen ways.
In California recently, Pacific Gas & Electric
has had to shut off electricity
to thousands of people during exceptionally dangerous fire
seasons. The reason: Downed power lines can spark huge
wildfires in dry vegetation. Then, during a record-hot
August last year, several of the state’s natural gas plants
malfunctioned in the heat, just as demand was spiking, contributing to blackouts.
“We have to get better at understanding these compound
impacts,” said Michael Craig, an expert in energy systems at
the University of Michigan who recently
led a study
looking at how rising summer temperatures in Texas could
strain the grid in unexpected ways. “It’s an incredibly
complex problem to plan for.”
Some utilities are taking notice. After Superstorm Sandy in
2012 knocked out power for 8.7 million customers, utilities
in New York and New Jersey invested billions in flood walls,
submersible equipment and other technology to reduce the
risk of failures. Last month, New York’s Con Edison
said
it would incorporate climate projections into its planning.
As freezing temperatures struck Texas, a glitch at one of
two reactors at a South Texas nuclear plant, which serves
2 million homes, triggered a shutdown. The cause: Sensing lines connected
to the plant’s water pumps had frozen, said Victor Dricks, a
spokesman for the federal Nuclear Regulatory Agency.
It’s also common for extreme heat to disrupt nuclear power.
The issue is that the water used to cool reactors can become
too warm to use,
forcing shutdowns.
Flooding is another risk.
After a tsunami led to several meltdowns at Japan’s
Fukushima Daiichi power plant in 2011, the U.S. Nuclear
Regulatory Commission told the 60 or so working nuclear
plants in the United States, many decades old, to evaluate
their flood risk to account for climate change. Ninety
percent showed at least one type of flood risk that
exceeded what the plant was designed to handle.
The greatest risk came from heavy rain and snowfall
exceeding the design parameters at 53 plants.
Scott Burnell, an Nuclear Regulatory Commission spokesman,
said in a statement, “The NRC continues to conclude, based
on the staff’s review of detailed analyses, that all U.S.
nuclear power plants can appropriately deal with potential
flooding events, including the effects of climate change,
and remain safe.”
A nation’s arteries at risk
|
A section of Highway 1 along the California
coastline collapsed in January amid heavy
rains. Credit...Josh Edelson/Agence France-Presse — Getty
Images
|
The
collapse of a portion of California’s Highway 1
into the Pacific Ocean after heavy rains last month
was a reminder of the fragility of the nation’s roads.
Several climate-related risks appeared to have
converged to heighten the danger. Rising seas and
higher storm surges have intensified coastal erosion,
while more extreme bouts of precipitation have
increased the landslide risk.
Add to that the effects of devastating wildfires,
which can damage the vegetation holding hillside soil
in place, and “things that wouldn’t have slid without
the wildfires, start sliding,” said Jennifer M.
Jacobs, a professor of civil and environmental
engineering at the University of New Hampshire. “I
think we’re going to see more of that.”
The United States depends on highways, railroads and
bridges as economic arteries for commerce, travel and
simply getting to work. But many of the country’s most
important links face mounting climate threats. More
than 60,000 miles of roads and bridges in coastal
floodplains are already vulnerable to extreme storms
and hurricanes, government estimates show. And inland
flooding could also threaten at least 2,500 bridges
across the country by 2050,
a federal climate report warned in 2018.
Sometimes even small changes can trigger catastrophic
failures. Engineers modeling the collapse of bridges
over Escambia Bay in Florida during Hurricane Ivan in
2004
found that
the extra three inches of sea-level rise since the
bridge was built in 1968 very likely contributed to
the collapse, because of the added height of the storm
surge and force of the waves.
“A lot of our infrastructure systems have a tipping
point. And when you hit the tipping point, that’s when
a failure occurs,” Dr. Jacobs said. “And the tipping
point could be an inch.”
Crucial rail networks are at risk, too. In 2017,
Amtrak consultants found that
along parts of the Northeast corridor, which runs from
Boston to Washington and carries 12 million people a
year, flooding and storm surge could erode the track
bed, disable the signals and eventually put the tracks
underwater.
And there is no easy fix. Elevating the tracks would
require also raising bridges, electrical wires and
lots of other infrastructure, and moving them would
mean buying new land in a densely packed part of the
country. So the report recommended flood barriers,
costing $24 million per mile, that must be moved into
place whenever floods threaten.
Toxic sites, deepening peril
|
A worker checked efforts to prevent coal ash from
escaping into the Waccamaw River in South Carolina
after Hurricane Florence in 2018. Credit...Randall Hill/Reuters
|
A
series of explosions at a flood-damaged chemical
plant
outside Houston after Hurricane Harvey in 2017
highlighted a danger lurking in a world beset by
increasingly extreme weather.
The blasts at the plant came after flooding knocked
out the site’s electrical supply, shutting down
refrigeration systems that kept volatile chemicals
stable. Almost two dozen people, many of them
emergency workers, were treated for exposure to the
toxic fumes, and some 200 nearby residents were
evacuated from their homes.
More than 2,500 facilities that handle toxic chemicals
lie in federal flood-prone areas across the country,
about 1,400 of them in areas at the highest risk of
flooding,
a New York Times analysis
showed in 2018.
Leaks from toxic cleanup sites, left behind by past
industry, pose another threat.
Almost two-thirds of some 1,500 superfund cleanup
sites across the country are in areas with an elevated
risk of flooding, storm surge, wildfires or sea level
rise,
a government audit warned in 2019. Coal ash, a toxic substance produced
by coal power plants that is often stored as sludge in
special ponds, have been particularly exposed. After
Hurricane Florence in 2018, for example, a dam breach
at the site of a power plant in Wilmington, N.C.,
released the hazardous ash
into a nearby river.
“We should be evaluating whether these facilities or
sites actually have to be moved or re-secured,” said
Lisa Evans, senior counsel at Earthjustice, an
environmental law organization. Places that “may have
been OK in 1990,” she said, “may be a disaster waiting
to happen in 2021.”
|
East Austin, Texas, during a blackout on
Wednesday. Credit...Bronte Wittpenn/Austin
American-Statesman, via Associated
Press
|
Links