New York Times - Somini Sengupta
A surprising mix of environmentalists, pension fund managers and big
money investors have scored startling victories against oil and coal,
opening new battle fronts in the climate fight.
|
Activists outside an annual shareholder meeting of Royal Dutch
Shell in Scheveningen, the Netherlands, in 2019. Credit...Piroschka Van
De Wouw/Reuters
|
A nun, an environmental lawyer, pension fund executives, and the world’s
largest asset manager. These were among the unusual collection of rebels who
claimed a series of startling victories this week against some of the
world’s biggest and most influential fossil fuel companies.
From Houston to The Hague, they fought their battles in shareholder meetings
and courtrooms, opening surprising fronts in an accelerating effort to force
the world’s coal, oil and gas companies to address their central role in the
climate crisis. And even as they came with strikingly disparate points of
view — corporate shareholders, children’s rights advocates,
environmentalists, thousands of Dutch citizens — they delivered a common
underlying message: The time to start retreating from the fossil fuel
business is no longer in the future, but now.
“These companies are facing pressure from regulators, investors, and now the
courts to up their game,” said Will Nichols, head of environmental research
at Maplecroft, a risk analysis firm. “That’s a big chunk of society, and
it’s not a great look to be pushing back against all of that.”
The most dramatic turning point came in the Netherlands, where a court
instructed
Royal Dutch Shell, the largest private oil trader in the world and by far the largest
company in the Netherlands itself, that it must sharply cut greenhouse gas
emissions from all its global operations this decade. It was the first time
a court ordered a private company to, in effect, change its business
practice on climate grounds.
The symbolism was inescapable: The Netherlands, famously built on land
reclaimed from the sea, faces the immediate threat from a warming climate
caused by the burning of Shell’s own products — oil and gas.
In another example this week, at the annual shareholder meeting of
Exxon Mobil, the biggest American oil company, the message was framed sharply in terms
of profits: A tiny new hedge fund led an investor rebellion to diversify
away from oil and gas — or risk hurting investors and the bottom line.
Chevron’s shareholders voted to tell the company to reduce not only its own
emissions, but also, remarkably, the emissions produced by customers who
burn its oil and gasoline. And in Australia, a judge warned the government
that a proposed coal mine expansion, a project challenged by eight teenagers
and an 86-year-old nun, would need to ensure that it wouldn’t harm the
health of the country’s children.
The timing was significant. This week scientists also concluded that, in the
next five years, the average global temperature will at least
temporarily spike beyond a dangerous threshold, climbing more than 1.5 degrees Celsius, or 2.7 degrees Fahrenheit, warmer
than in pre-industrial times. Avoiding that threshold is the main objective
of the Paris Accord, the landmark global climate agreement among the nations
of the world to fight climate change.
Of course, none of these actions represents an immediate threat to the
fossil fuel industry. For a century and a half, the global economy has
been fueled by oil and coal, and that won’t change immediately.
Nevertheless, rulings like the one in the Netherlands could be a harbinger
for similar legal attacks against other fossil fuel companies and their
investors, experts said. Kate Raworth, an economist at Oxford University,
called Shell’s loss in court
“a social tipping point
for a fossil-fuel-free future.”
Shell said it found the ruling, by a district court in The Hague,
“disappointing” and intended to appeal. That process could take years to
reach the country’s supreme court, delaying action but also drawing
continued public attention.
|
Donald Pols, director of Milieudefensie, a Dutch environmental
group, reacting to the Shell ruling in The Hague on
Wednesday. Credit...Remko De
Waal/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
|
If the ruling of the lower court stands, though, analysts said, Shell
would most certainly have to reorient its business to reduce oil in its
portfolio and halt its growth in liquefied natural gas, in which Shell is
an industry leader.
That is a matter of concern for the investors who have
their money in the oil and gas reserves of companies like Shell, said
Patrick Parenteau, a professor at Vermont Law School. “A decision telling
a company, ‘You’ve got to get out of the oil business.’ For cautious
individuals within the financial community, that’s got to cause them
serious concerns.”
Dangerously for Shell, the national judiciary of the Netherlands in the
past has shown itself to be among the most out-front on climate
litigation.
In 2019, the Supreme Court of the Netherlands ordered
the government to cut greenhouse gas emissions because of a lawsuit filed
by Urgenda, an environmental group. It was the first case in the world to
force a national government to address climate change in order to uphold
its human rights commitments.
That case, too, began in a district court in The Hague, before making its
way up the judicial ladder. The lawsuit against Shell marked an escalation
in that strategy.
Having sued the government and won, environmental advocates decided to
take on one of the country’s most influential companies. The case was
brought in 2019 by Milieudefensie, the Dutch branch of Friends of the
Earth, as well as Greenpeace and 17,000 residents of the Netherlands. The
complainants argued that the company has a legal duty to protect Dutch
citizens from looming climate risks. The district court agreed.
“The consequences of this case for the fossil fuel industry will be
systemic and immediate,” Tessa Khan, the lawyer who had sued the
government on behalf of Urgenda, said on Twitter. She predicted that it
would spur other cases and “escalate the perception of risk among
investors.”
Shell had already begun to see the writing on the wall. It said earlier
this year that global oil demand had likely
reached a peak in 2019
and would slowly wane in the coming years.
And at least compared to some of its American peers, Shell had set
relatively more ambitious climate targets. It had already promised to
reduce the carbon intensity of its operations, which means that it could
still continue to expand oil and production, but with lower emissions for
every barrel it produced.
The district court on Wednesday instructed the company to cut its absolute
emissions by 45 percent by 2030, relative to its 2019 levels. The ruling
applies to Shell’s global operations. But, that said, even if it is upheld
on appeal, enforcing it, say, in Nigeria, where Shell is the biggest oil
producer, could prove to be “impractical,” said Biraj Borkhataria, an
analyst at RBC Capital Markets, an investment bank.
“However,” he said separately, in a note to clients on Thursday, “it is
another example of society asking more from oil companies.”The Shell
ruling is particularly notable because private companies have been targets
of climate litigation in the United States and elsewhere, but courts have
rarely ruled against them.
|
Protests against BlackRock, the giant asset manager, in
Manhattan on Tuesday. Credit...Carlo
Allegri/Reuters
|
The Dutch case opens a potentially new front, emboldening climate
advocates to pursue more cases in a wider variety of countries,
particularly where national laws enshrine the right to a clean
environment.
Several European and Latin American courts, including in the
Netherlands, have interpreted their national laws in this way.
A farmer in Peru is suing a German energy giant
over the effects of global warming on a glacier in his country. About 20
American cities, counties and states have sued the fossil fuel industry
since 2017, seeking damages for the local costs of climate change.
Governments are also on the hook.
Germany’s highest court recently told the government to tighten its climate targets because they
did not go far enough to ensure that future generations would be
protected.
In the Australian case,
eight teenagers, joined by Brigid Arthur, the nun, went to court to stop the government from expanding an enormous coal
mine called Whitehaven. The court on Thursday stopped short of issuing an
injunction against the mine, as the plaintiffs had sought.
But in ordering the government to take “reasonable care to avoid personal
injury to the children,” it recognized climate change as an
“intergenerational crime,” said Michael Burger, executive director of the
Sabin Center for Climate Change Law at Columbia University and a lawyer
who represents several U.S. cities and states suing fossil fuel companies.
“The actions we take today with respect to climate change can consign our
children, our children’s children, and other future generations to a world
that is fundamentally livable or a world that is not,” he said. “Courts
recognize that.”
The most closely watched case in the United States, filed on behalf of
young people against the United States government, seeks to establish a
constitutional right to a sound environment. After recent setbacks in the
federal courts, a federal judge has ordered the parties
to enter settlement discussions.
The actions against Chevron and Exxon are notable because they reveal the
extent to which shareholders are quickly awakening to the risk to their
investments if energy companies don’t dramatically start changing their
business models.
A significant chunk of shareholders demonstrated that they were
increasingly distrustful that the companies could deliver the financial
performance they expected without diversifying away from oil and gas.
Exxon this week lost a battle against a small new hedge fund, Engine No.
1, which rallied big investors like Blackrock and the New York state
pension fund to force the company to change course. The hedge fund won at
least two seats on Exxon’s 12-member board.
Tensie Whelan, director of the New York University Stern Center for
Sustainable Business, called it “a pivotal moment for board
accountability.” Activist shareholders have traditionally taken on company
executives over financial issues, not social issues like climate change,
she said. “Shareholders are deeply concerned about the financial risks
posed by climate change and increasingly willing to hold the board to
account,” Ms. Whelan said.
Links