14/08/2018

Coalition Signs Off On NEG But Tony Abbott Continues Internal Dissent

The Guardian

Malcolm Turnbull and Josh Frydenberg announce the Coalition’s backing for the national energy guarantee after a party room meeting. Photograph: Mike Bowers for the Guardian 
The Coalition party room has signed off on the government’s national energy guarantee, but conservatives remain resistant, with a group of MPs flagging they could cross the floor when the proposal comes to parliament, potentially killing the policy.
The emissions reduction components of the scheme were debated by government MPs for more than two hours on Tuesday morning, with the former prime minister Tony Abbott continuing to lead an internal rebellion on the proposal – to the irritation of many colleagues.
While the majority of government MPs spoke in favour of the NEG, five MPs reserved their right to cross the floor once the legislation comes to parliament: Tony Abbott, Andrew Hastie, Eric Abetz, Craig Kelly, and the National George Christensen.
Another group expressed concerns: Tony Pasin, Kevin Andrews and the National MP Andrew Gee. The former Nationals leader Barnaby Joyce – who, like Abbott, has been campaigning publicly against the NEG – said he would support the policy but has flagged moving an amendment during parliamentary debate.
There was some internal blowback against the dissidents. A couple of marginal seat holders, Ann Sudmalis and Sarah Henderson, were overtly critical of Abbott’s wrecking campaign during Tuesday’s debate, and called on the critics to show unity.
The government will bring the legislation giving effect to the emissions reduction components of the NEG during the current sitting fortnight.
The dissent is small but potentially significant. The group of Coalition ​rebels is large enough to kill the proposal before it leaves the House of Representatives if Labor refuses to vote for the legislation with a 26% target.
At a press conference after the party room discussion, Malcolm Turnbull declared it was time for Labor to support the NEG in the interests of providing certainty and lowering power prices.
“The Labor party has to decide whether they want to support cheaper and more reliability electricity,” Turnbull told reporters.
“You know, we have got to bring an end to the years of ideology and idiocy which have been a curse on energy policy for too long and that is why industry – whether you’re talking about big industrial consumers or small business – consumer groups are calling on government, governments and oppositions to get behind this policy.
“We need to get a certain environment so that people will invest and that’s really the question for Bill Shorten.”
Turnbull said Labor should pass the current framework with its emissions reduction target of 26% and then argue the case for additional ambition in the scheme after the next federal election, rather than torpedo the mechanism in this parliament.
With the fate of the policy in the balance, the prime minister declined to criticise the group of backbench dissidents overtly, but he emphasised the policy had “overwhelming” support from a majority of stakeholders.
Underscoring the lingering hostility, after Tuesday’s meeting, Abbott took to social media to decry the leaking that took place while the Coalition party room debate was still underway.
IMAGE
The battle on the NEG is far from over. The energy minister Josh Frydenberg has to secure backing from his state and territory counterparts on Tuesday night to release legislation required in the states to implement the policy.
That deliberative process will stretch for at least a month, and it is not clear whether the states will back the NEG before Victoria moves into caretaker mode ahead of the looming November state election.
The shadow climate change minister, Mark Butler, was critical about the lack of ambition in emissions reduction after the party room meeting, and he foreshadowed an attempt by Labor to delay resolution of the policy.
While Butler was positive about the NEG mechanism, he said Labor could not support a 26% target. He said if the legislation came on for debate in the parliament, Labor would push for a higher target of 45%, attempting to amend the government’s package.
But he also pointed out that the states had not yet signed on to the scheme, and “without that framework, the commonwealth has no work to do”.
“It would seem strange to debate legislation without knowing whether or not the framework to which that legislation attaches, which activates that legislation, hasn’t even been agreed yet by Coag”.
Butler said Labor federally would not be putting Victorian Labor under pressure to resolve its stance. “Victoria and the others are sovereign governments, they need to make decisions according to their proper processes”.
He said Labor would welcome a fight with the Turnbull government at the next federal election over the degree of ambition in emissions reduction.
“We are happy to have a strong debate within the community in the context of an election about the need for real ambition on renewable energy investment,” Butler said. “We know from modelling released in recent weeks that this is the way to get downward pressure on wholesale power prices.”

Links

Halfway To Boiling: The City At 50c

The Guardian |

It is the temperature at which human cells start to cook, animals suffer and air conditioners overload power grids. Once an urban anomaly, 50C is fast becoming reality
 In a city at 50C, the only people in sight are those who do not have access to air conditioning. Illustration: Kevin Whipple
Imagine a city at 50C (122F). The pavements are empty, the parks quiet, entire neighbourhoods appear uninhabited. Nobody with a choice ventures outside during daylight hours. Only at night do the denizens emerge, HG Wells-style, into the streets – though, in temperatures that high, even darkness no longer provides relief. Uncooled air is treated like effluent: to be flushed as quickly as possible.
School playgrounds are silent as pupils shelter inside. In the hottest hours of the day, working outdoors is banned. The only people in sight are those who do not have access to air conditioning, who have no escape from the blanket of heat: the poor, the homeless, undocumented labourers. Society is divided into the cool haves and the hot have-nots.
Those without the option of sheltering indoors can rely only on shade, or perhaps a water-soaked sheet hung in front of a fan. Construction workers, motor-rickshaw drivers and street hawkers cover up head to toe to stay cool. The wealthy, meanwhile, go from one climate-conditioned environment to another: homes, cars, offices, gymnasiums, malls.
Asphalt heats up 10-20C higher than the air. You really could fry an egg on the pavement. A dog’s paws would blister on a short walk, so pets are kept behind closed doors. There are fewer animals overall; many species of mammals and birds have migrated to cooler environments, perhaps at a higher altitude – or perished. Reptiles, unable to regulate their body temperatures or dramatically expand their range, are worst placed to adapt. Even insects suffer.
Melting asphalt cause road markings to distort in New Delhi
Maybe in the beginning, when it was just a hot spell, there was a boom in spending as delighted consumers snapped up sunglasses, bathing suits, BBQs, garden furniture and beer. But the novelty quickly faded when relentless sunshine became the norm. Consumers became more selective. Power grids are overloaded by cooling units. The heat is now a problem.
The temperature is recalibrating behaviour. Appetites tend to fade as the body avoids the thermal effect of food and tempers are quicker to flare – along, perhaps, with crime and social unrest. But eventually lethargy sets in as the body shuts down and any prolonged period spent outdoors becomes dangerous.
You could see the physical change. Road surfaces started to melt …
Dev Niyogi, American Meteorological Society
Hospitals see a surge in admissions for heat stress, respiratory problems and other illnesses exacerbated by high temperatures. Some set up specialist wards. The elderly, the obese and the sick are most at risk. Deaths rise.
At 50C – halfway to water’s boiling point and more than 10C above a healthy body temperature – heat becomes toxic. Human cells start to cook, blood thickens, muscles lock around the lungs and the brain is choked of oxygen. In dry conditions, sweat – the body’s in-built cooling system – can lessen the impact. But this protection weakens if there is already moisture in the air.
A so-called “wet-bulb temperature” (which factors in humidity) of just 35C can be fatal after a few hours to even the fittest person, and scientists warn climate change will make such conditions increasingly common in India, Pakistan, south-east Asia and parts of China. Even under the most optimistic predictions for emissions reductions, experts say almost half the world’s population will be exposed to potentially deadly heat for 20 days a year by 2100.
A motorcyclist is sprayed with water in Karachi
Not long ago, 50C was considered an anomaly, but it is increasingly widespread. Earlier this year, the 1.1 million residents of Nawabshah, Pakistan, endured the hottest April ever recorded on Earth, as temperatures hit 50.2C. In neighbouring India two years earlier, the town of Phalodi sweltered in 51C – the country’s hottest ever day.
Dev Niyogi, chair of the Urban Environment department at the American Meteorological Society, witnessed how cities were affected by extreme heat on a research trip to New Delhi and Pune during that 2015 heatwave in India, which killed more than 2,000 people.
“You could see the physical change. Road surfaces started to melt, neighbourhoods went quiet because people didn’t go out and water vapour rose off the ground like a desert mirage,” he recalls.
“We must hope that we don’t see 50C. That would be uncharted territory. Infrastructure would be crippled and ecosystem services would start to break down, with long-term consequences.”
Hajj pilgrims in Mecca are sprayed with cool water
Several cities in the Persian Gulf are getting increasingly accustomed to such heat. Basra – population 2.1 million – registered 53.9C two years ago. Kuwait City and Doha have experienced 50C or more in the past decade. At Quriyat, on the coast of Oman, overnight temperatures earlier this summer remained above 42.6C, which is believed to be the highest “low” temperature ever recorded in the world.
At Mecca, the two million hajj pilgrims who visit each year need ever more sophisticated support to beat the heat. On current trends, it is only a matter of time before temperatures exceed the record 51.3C reached in 2012. Last year, traditionalists were irked by plans to install what are reportedly the world’s biggest retractable umbrellas to provide shade on the courtyards and roof of the Great Mosque. Air conditioners weighing 25 tonnes have been brought in to ventilate four of the biggest tents. Thousands of fans already cool the marble floors and carpets, while police on horseback spray the crowds with water.
The blast of furnace-like heat ... literally feels life-threatening and apocalyptic
Professor Nigel Tapper
Football supporters probably cannot expect such treatment at the Qatar World Cup in 2022, and many may add to the risks of hyperthermia and dehydration by taking off their shirts and drinking alcohol. Fifa is so concerned about conditions that it has moved the final from summer to a week before Christmas. Heat is also why Japanese politicians are now debating whether to introduce daylight saving time for the 2020 Tokyo Olympics so that marathon and racewalk athletes can start at what is currently 5am and avoid mid-afternoon temperatures that recently started to pass 40C with humidity of more than 80%.
At the Australian open in Melbourne this year – when ambient temperatures reached 40C – players were staggering around like “punch-drunk boxers” due to heatstroke. Even walking outside can feel oppressive at higher temperatures. “The blast of furnace-like heat ... literally feels life-threatening and apocalyptic,” says Nigel Tapper, professor of environmental science at Melbourne’s Monash University, of the 48C recorded in parts of the city. “You cannot move outside for more than a few minutes.”
French tennis player Alize Cornet falls to the ground suffering from the heat during the Australian Open
The feeling of foreboding is amplified by the increased threat of bush and forest fires, he adds. “You cannot help but ask, ‘How can this city operate under these conditions? What can we do to ensure that the city continues to provide important services for these conditions? What can we do to reduce temperatures in the city?’”
Those places already struggling with extreme heat are doing what they can. In Ahmedabad, in Gujarat, hospitals have opened specialist heat wards. Australian cities have made swimming pools accessible to the homeless when the heat creeps above 40C, and instructed schools to cancel playground time. In Kuwait, outside work is forbidden between noon and 4pm when temperatures soar.
But many regulations are ignored, and companies and individuals underestimate the risks. In almost all countries, hospital admissions and death rates tend to rise when temperatures pass 35C – which is happening more often, in more places. Currently, 354 major cities experience average summer temperatures in excess of 35C; by 2050, climate change will push this to 970, according to the recent “Future We Don’t Want” study by the C40 alliance of the world’s biggest metropolises. In the same period, it predicts the number of urban dwellers exposed to this level of extreme heat will increase eightfold, to 1.6 billion.
Workers take a break at a building site in Kuwait City, where work is forbidden between noon and 4pm
As baselines shift across the globe, 50C is also uncomfortably near for tens of millions more people. This year, Chino, 50km (30 miles) from Los Angeles, hit a record of 48.9C, Sydney saw 47C, and Madrid and Lisbon also experienced temperatures in the mid-40s. New studies suggest France “could easily exceed” 50C by the end of the century while Australian cities are forecast to reach this point even earlier. Kuwait, meanwhile, could sizzle towards an uninhabitable 60C.
How to cool dense populations is now high on the political and academic agenda, says Niyogi, who last week co-chaired an urban climate symposium in New York. Cities can be modified to deplete heat through measures to conserve water, create shade and deflect heat. In many places around the world, these steps are already under way.
The city at 50C could be more tolerable with lush green spaces on and around buildings; towers with smart shades that follow the movement of the sun; roofs and pavements painted with high-albedo surfaces; fog capture and renewable energy fields to provide cooling power without adding to the greenhouse effect.
But with extremes creeping up faster than baselines, Niyogi says this adapting will require changes not just to the design of cities, but how they are organised and how we live in them. First, though, we have to see what is coming – which might not hit with the fury of a flood or typhoon but can be even more destructive.
“Heat is different,” says Niyogi. “You don’t see the temperature creep up to 50C. It can take people unawares.”

Links

You Can't Help Farmers If You Won't Tackle Climate Change, Farmer Tells Government

AFR - Ben Potter

Goondiwindi grain and cattle producer Peter Mailler says heat and inconsistent rain have made farming so tough he thinks his parents' five MW solar farm could be a better bet. Wayne Pratt
Peter Mailler, a third-generation grain and cattle grower who sent pregnant cows for slaughter this week because he can't feed them all, has a message from drought-stricken northern NSW to the Turnbull government.
It is aimed especially at the Nationals and their former leader Barnaby Joyce – against whom Mr Mailler ran in last December's byelection – as well as ex-PM Tony Abbott and other coal power-friendly Coalition figures.
First, don't pretend to champion drought-struck farmers if you're not prepared to tackle climate change – because the increasing frequency of extremely hot, dry weather is compounding the effects of drought by impairing crops' ability to use what rain they do get.
Second, don't talk about giving coal-fired power "a free kick" in the National Energy Guarantee (NEG) when a full accounting of its environmental costs will tell you not that we can't afford to close coal plants but that "we can't afford to run one tomorrow".
Peter Mailler says agriculture is working towards becoming carbon neutral but it is a challenge because it uses so much diesel fuel for machinery and transport. Wayne Pratt
Third, don't lean on high-risk, struggling industries like agriculture for deeper carbon emissions cuts when the stable, regulated electricity industry can obviously bear a larger share of the burden.
Last, the impacts of climate change on farming families threaten the survival of the Nationals' support base in rural and regional Australia, so it is time for the Coalition to dispense with "undermining science" and have an honest debate about climate change.
"In a normal year we produce enough grain to feed about 7000 families and I am flat out educating my kids," Mr Mailler tells The Australian Financial Review from his near 2420-hectare property near Goondiwindi on the NSW-Queensland border.
"I actually don't see a pathway for my kids to come back – and some of them want to." His parents built a five-megawatt solar farm on their property when they retired and he thinks this could be a better bet.
Mr Mailler says the conversation needs to be more robust. "If Turnbull and his cohort are nor prepared to diligently install some truth in the debate then what's the point?" he says.
Coal-friendly coailtion MPs Craig Kelly, Eric Abetz, Tony Abbott, Barnaby Joyce and Kevin Andrews are doing farmers no favours, Peter Mailler says. Alex Ellinghausen
First, "you cannot fix the energy problem if you are going to ignore climate ... because you are working on the wrong set of assumptions", says Mr Mailler, who trained as an agricultural scientist before returning to his parents' farm and then striking out on his own.

A 'free kick' for electricity
That makes it "disingenuous" and "hypocritical" for Mr Joyce to stand shoulder to shoulder with farmers and say "we have got to do something about the drought and not say we have got to do something about climate change".
Mr Mailler says politicians have the resources to find out the truth "yet we have politicians who spend all their time trying to undermine science and create doubt".
Moree in northern NSW sweated through an unprecedented heatwave in January and February of 2017. Supplied
"The science [of man-made global warming] is pretty unequivocal and the idea that you can subvert it and create doubt is not just irresponsible, it's diabolical," he says.
"They are talking about trying to claw back more emissions from agriculture and they are talking about giving electricity a free kick. It's ridiculous."
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull and Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg will propose a "coal-friendly" side deal for the NEG at Tuesday's party room meeting to try to win over climate change sceptics.
Critics say the NEG is already too coal-friendly because it only requires a pro rata 26 per cent carbon emissions cut from the electricity sector. CSIRO advised the government that grid emissions would have to be cut by 52 per cent to 70 per cent for Australia to meet the government's Paris pledge for an economy-wide 26 per cent cut because it is much more costly to cut emissions in other industries. 
Environment and Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg and Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull will try to win backbench sceptics over the NEG with a coal-friendly side-deal. Alex Ellinghausen
Mr Mailler says agriculture is itself working towards becoming carbon neutral but it is a challenge because agriculture uses so much diesel fuel for machinery and transport.
"The hardest thing to solve is transport. The simplest thing to change is static electricity. If you look at it, coal-fired power generators are coming to the end of their life. The idea that you could have politicians effectively saying we should build more of them and have them for another 50 years is absurd."

Heat and rain: Double whammy
Mr Mailler's position is influenced by bitter experience as well as science. In January 2014, the nearest Bureau of Meteorology station at Moree recorded a record high of 47.3 degrees Celsius, and everyone said it was "a one-in-a-hundred year event".
Yallourn coal-fired power station in Victoria's Latrobe Valley. Carla Gottgens
That one day wiped out crops and cost the region hundreds of millions of dollars in production, he says. But it didn't get the same attention as losses from cyclones, which are more visible.
In February last year the one-in-a-hundred year event happened again, only this time it came with a record run of days over 35 degrees.
Biochemical reactions like photosynthesis are optimised at 37-38 degrees. But at extreme high temperatures plants go into shock and the photosynthesis process is degraded.
As well, rain is increasingly coming in big dumps followed by dry spells, which make it harder for young plants to get going than if less rain falls more frequently.
"In some of those scenarios we have adequate moisture but we can't handle the heat. People are unable to get ahead. Even though some of those years before we have had significant rainfall, the way it's fallen in big dumps has been problematic and the heat has meant we are not able to use that rainfall as effectively as we have in the past."
Recent analysis in the McIntyre Valley indicates that irrigators' water use efficiency is down 30 per cent, and for dryland farmers 60 per cent, Mr Mailler says. Another measure is the inability to get consecutive good years or even one in five – the minimum to build resilience – for more than 20 years.
The last really good year in his region was 1996, Mr Mailler says – which gave him the confidence to strike out on his own.
"I have no doubt that in my lifetime weather patterns have shifted significantly. I don't know many farmers who would dispute that the climate has changed," he says.
"And it's obviously going to get worse."

Links