Climate Target May Be Insufficient to Protect Polar Ice Sheets - Lethal Heating Editor BDA

Key Points

• New research suggests 1.5°C may not protect ice sheets
• Durham University calls for 1°C target
• Ice loss from Greenland and Antarctica quadrupled
• Millions at risk from sea level rise
• Coastal adaptation costs could be extreme

New research suggests that the world's most ambitious climate target may already be too high.

New findings from Durham University suggest that even if global temperatures are held to the 1.5°C target set by the Paris Agreement¹ and the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change², polar ice sheets could still suffer catastrophic loss.

This could accelerate sea level rise far beyond what nations are prepared to manage.

Scientists argue that the safe threshold for ice sheet stability may be closer to 1°C above pre-industrial levels.

The implications are stark: the current target may fall short of protecting hundreds of millions of coastal residents.

Study Findings

Professor Chris Stokes³ analysed decades of glaciological and climate data.

Their findings show that even modest warming can destabilise the polar ice sheets.

The researchers argue for reducing global temperature rise to 1°C, not just 1.5°C, to prevent long-term sea level commitments.

This would require dramatic global decarbonisation, beyond current pledges.

These findings align with the IPCC Special Report on 1.5°C⁴, highlighting the urgency of limiting warming.

Current Ice Loss Crisis

Greenland and Antarctica⁵ have quadrupled their annual ice loss since the 1990s.

Annual losses now total 370 billion tonnes⁶ — enough to flood California under over a metre of water.

This meltwater is the primary driver of modern sea level rise.

With current warming already at 1.2°C⁷, we are fast approaching the 1.5°C limit.

The remaining carbon budget is shrinking rapidly.

Impacts of Overshooting 1.5°C

Warming of 1.5°C could lock in several metres of sea level rise⁸ over centuries.

Such increases would be irreversible for generations.

Melting would result from both atmospheric and oceanic warming mechanisms.

Current coastal infrastructure¹⁰ is not built for multi-metre rises.

The costs to adapt would exceed the GDP of many nations.

Global Consequences

230 million people⁹ live within one metre of sea level.

Fast-rising seas could make adaptation unmanageable.

Developing countries are particularly vulnerable.

Belize¹¹ has already moved its capital inland due to sea level threat.

Many small island nations may cease to exist entirely.

Expert Warnings

Professor Stokes¹² has advised at three major COP climate meetings.

He warns that meeting the 1.5°C goal alone may not be enough to save the ice sheets.

Recent studies published in Nature Climate Change¹³ further support this concern.

The study urges policymakers to reconsider what constitutes "safe" warming.

The Path Forward

To truly prevent ice sheet collapse, researchers call for revised targets closer to 1°C.

They recommend further study of negative emissions and long-term restoration strategies.

The findings highlight the urgency of acting even faster and more ambitiously than current climate plans dictate.

References

• 1. UNFCCC Paris Agreement
• 2. UN Framework Convention on Climate Change
• 3. Durham University — Prof. Chris Stokes
• 4. IPCC Special Report on 1.5°C
• 5. NASA Climate Evidence
• 6. World Glacier Monitoring Service
• 7. IPCC Sixth Assessment Report
• 8. NOAA Sea Level Viewer
• 9. World Bank Climate Portal
• 10. Global Sea Level Observing System
• 11. Caribbean Climate Tool
• 12. UN Climate COP
• 13. Nature Climate Change

Back to top