Wednesday, July 20, 2016

Climate Change: Advisers Warn Of Climate Change Domino Effect

BBC - Roger Harrabin



Climate change could have a domino effect on key infrastructure in the UK, government advisers have warned.
In a 2,000-page report, the Climate Change Committee says flooding will destroy bridges - wrecking electricity, gas and IT connections carried on them.
The committee also warns that poor farming means the most fertile soils will be badly degraded by mid-century.
And heat-related deaths among the elderly will triple to 7,000 a year by the 2050s as summer temperatures rise.
The UK is not prepared, the committee says, for the risks posed by climate change from flooding and changing coasts, heatwaves, water shortages, ecosystem damage and shocks to the global food system.
The projections are based on the supposition that governments keep promises made at the Paris climate conference to cut emissions - a pledge that is in doubt.
The committee says if emissions are allowed to spiral, London summer temperatures could hit 48C (118F) in an extreme scenario, although the advisers say they don't expect that to happen.
The report from 80 authors is the most comprehensive yet on the potential impact of climate change on the UK.

'Cascade of risks'
It identifies 60 risks and opportunities - many of them happening already as the climate has warmed.
Its conclusions on the inter-linking nature of threats to infrastructure is based on recent research.
The chairman of the committee's adaptation sub-committee, Prof Sir John Krebs, told BBC News: "Infrastructure could be affected in a way that interacts.
There are a few opportunities hidden in the mix but the future is clearly one of increased risk that we need to prepare for now
Piers Forster, University of Leeds
"So, if you take electricity supply, the delivery of fuel to power stations might be affected by flooding which would then affect electricity.
"Then look at flooding… if bridges are affected then they carry electricity cables and communications infrastructure, so we have to look not just at how each piece of infrastructure works but how they interact together.
"There could be a cascade of risks."

Higher food prices
On food and farming, the committee warns that UK shoppers could face higher food bills as imported crops like soya are harmed by heat or drought.
It says farming in the UK might benefit from more warmth but warns that soils are likely to dry out quicker, and that rain is more likely to arrive in unhelpful downpours.
The committee also says some of the UK's most fertile land - the peat fields of the East Anglia fens - are suffering badly from decades of intensive farming.
Prof Krebs said 85% of the peat had been washed or blown away, and the rest would follow in coming decades unless farmers were more careful.

On over-heating, the committee forecasts a risk to the health of elderly people in homes, hospitals and care homes.
Prof Krebs said he had tried to insert rules in recent housing legislation to oblige builders to ensure adequate ventilation, but the government deemed these onerous to business.
Dr Sari Kovats, from the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, said: "We are far from prepared to deal with these changes.
"More heatwaves in the UK are also likely, yet there are no comprehensive policies in place aimed at reducing the risk of overheating in new and existing homes."

Risks and opportunities
Among the other risks needing more action the committee mentions:
• Coastal change risks to communities, businesses and infrastructure
• Risk of shortages in public water supply with impacts on freshwater ecology, water for agriculture, energy generation and industry
Opportunities for the UK from climate change include:
• Economic opportunities for UK businesses from an increase in global demand for adaptation-related goods and services, such as engineering and insurance
• Milder winters should reduce the costs of heating, helping to cut winter cold deaths.

Prof Piers Forster, from the University of Leeds, said: "The UK gets off lighter than many countries but this important report confirms that we are already seeing damage to homes, businesses and livelihoods.
"There are a few opportunities hidden in the mix but the future is clearly one of increased risk that we need to prepare for now."
The report will inform the government's climate change adaptation strategy, due in 2018. Ministers are about to publish their National Flood Resilience Review.
A government spokesman said: "We are committed to making sure the UK is prepared for the challenges of climate change.
"That is why we are investing record amounts in flood defences, developing a long-term plan for the environment and reviewing planning legislation so new construction projects are sustainable and resilient."

Links

World Bank To Focus Future Investment On Clean Energy

The Guardian - 

World Bank will only fund coal projects in cases of ‘extreme need’ due to the risk climate change poses to ending world poverty, says Jim Yong Kim
Solar panels being cleaned at the Ain Beni Mathar Integrated Combined Cycle Thermo-Solar Power Plant in Morocco. The World Bank provided technical assistance and managed the overall project. Photograph: Dana Smillie/World Bank
The World Bank will invest heavily in clean energy and only fund coal projects in “circumstances of extreme need” because climate change will undermine efforts to eliminate extreme poverty, says its president Jim Yong Kim.
Talking ahead of a UN climate summit in Peru next month, Kim said he was alarmed by World Bank-commissioned research from the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research in Germany, which said that as a result of past greenhouse gas emissions the world is condemned to unprecedented weather events.
“The findings are alarming. As the planet warms further, heatwaves and other weather extremes, which today we call once­-in­-a-century events, would become the new climate normal, a frightening world of increased risk and instability. The consequences for development would be severe, as crop yields decline, water resources shift, communicable diseases move into new geographical ranges, and sea levels rise,” he said.
“We know that the dramatic weather extremes are already affecting millions of people, such as the five to six feet of snow that just fell on Buffalo, and can throw our lives into disarray or worse. Even with ambitious mitigation, warming close to 1.5C above pre­-industrial levels is locked in. And this means that climate change impact such as extreme heat events may now be simply unavoidable.”
But the bank, which has traditionally been one of the world’s largest funders of fossil fuel projects and has been accused of adding to the problem of climate change, said it could not ignore the poorest countries’ need for power.
“We are going to have to focus all of our energy to move toward renewable and cleaner forms of energy. But on the other hand we believe very strongly that the poorest countries have a right to energy and that we not ask these energy ­poor countries to wait until there are ways of ensuring that solar and wind power can provide the kind of base load that all countries need in order to industrialise,” said Kim.
“The stakes have never been higher.We cannot continue down the current path of unchecked growing emissions. The case for taking action now on climate change is overwhelming, and the cost of inaction will only rise,” he said.
Kim was backed by Rachel Kyte, World Bank group vice president and special envoy for climate change. “It will only be in circumstances of extreme need that we would contemplate doing coal again. We would only contemplate doing [it] in the poorest of countries where their energy transition as part of their low-carbon development plan means that there are no other base load power sources available at a reasonable price,” she said.
“The focus is on being able to ramp up our lending and the leveraging of our lending into all forms of renewable energy. That’s the strategy. It includes everything from all sizes of hydro through to wind, to solar, to concentrated solar, to geothermal. I think we’re invested in every dimension of renewable energy. That is what we’re concentrating on.”
The bank’s report showed that with a 2C warming, soya and wheat crop yields in Brazil could decrease 50-70%. “In the Middle east and north Africa, a large increase in heatwaves combined with warmer average temperatures will put intense pressure on already scarce water resources with major consequences for food security. Crop yields could decrease by up to 30% at 1.5-2C and by almost 60% at 3-4C. Pressure on resources might increase the risk of conflict,” it said.
Climate change posed a substantial risk to development and cutting poverty, the report said, adding that action on emissions need not come at the expense of economic growth.
But the bank made no commitment to cut funding for oil or other fossil fuel exploration. Analysis earlier this year by Washington-based NGO Oil Change International showed that the bank had funded $21bn (£13bn) of fossil fuel projects since 2008, including $1bn of oil and other fossil fuel exploration in 2013.
“The bank has taken an important first step in essentially stopping its support for coal-fired power plants, but climate change is caused by more than just coal,” said Stephen Kretzmann, director of Oil Change International. “The vast majority of currently proven fossil fuel reserves will need to be left in the ground if the world is to avoid dangerous climate change, but last year the bank provided nearly $1bn in support for finding more of these unburnable carbon reserves.”

Links

Australia Appoints “Mr Coal” As New Climate Change Minister

Desmog - Graham Readfearn


Australia’s new climate change minister is an MP once dubbed “Mr Coal” who believes the climate polluting fossil fuel is the secret to lifting the world's poorest countries out of poverty.
Re-elected conservative Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has put Liberal Party MP Josh Frydenberg, the former resources minister, in charge of the country’s climate policy.
Frydenberg replaces MP Greg Hunt who, as environment and climate change minister, was responsible for approving the largest coal mine in Australian history — the giant Adani Carmichael mine in the country’s Galilee Basin.
The burning of coal is the world's single biggest contributor to greenhouse gas emissions causing claimate change.
In September 2015, shortly after after being appointed Minister for Resources, Energy and Northern Australia, Frydenberg was described by conservative political commentator Andrew Bolt as “Mr Coal”.
In an interview with Bolt, who is a climate science denialist, Frydenberg said: “I certainly believe in the moral case that (former Prime Minister) Tony Abbott and others have put, that our coal, our gas, our energy supplies do lift people out of energy poverty and that will be an important theme of my term in this role.”
The idea that coal can be an answer to “energy poverty” in the world’s poorest countries is a talking point developed by the coal industry, in particular Peabody Energy, which has filed for protective bankruptcy in the United States.


Frydenberg is one of several conservative Australian MPs and Senators to have embraced the coal industry spin.
Conservation groups had mixed reactions to Frydenberg’s appointment and the newly created climate and energy ministry that goes with it.
Nikola Casule, a senior climate and energy campaigner at Greenpeace, said Frydenberg’s appointment was a “huge blow” to the Great Barrier Reef, which has just undergone its worst recorded mass bleaching event, killing almost a quarter of the reef’s corals.
She said: “Frydenberg’s views on climate change are an embarrassing relic from a different era. Australians have been clear in asking their government to choose the Great Barrier Reef over the coal industry.
“For Malcolm Turnbull to appoint a minister who still believes that there is still a strong moral case for coal even during the worst coral bleaching in the Great Barrier Reef’s history is clear show of contempt for the Australian public.”
Miriam Lyons, climate campaigns director at community advocacy group GetUp!, said combining energy and climate into one portfolio was potentially a chance to clean up Australia’s energy sector.
But she warned: “Our 1 million members will be watching carefully to see if Minister Frydenberg is ready to tackle the big polluters who are crushing climate progress and holding back the renewables boom.
“If Josh Frydenberg has drunk too much coal industry Koolaid to deliver a fast, fair and affordable transition to renewable energy, we’ll be ready to hold him to account.”
The Australian Conservation Foundation “welcomed” Frydenberg to the role and said that it “made sense” to have the two portfolios combined.
ACF CEO Kelly O’Shanassy said: “The single biggest thing Minister Frydenberg can do for our beautiful environment and the people and the places Australians love is to establish a national plan to rapidly clean up Australia’s energy supplies.”
Frydenberg’s replacement as resources minister is Liberal National Party Senator Matt Canavan, who in 2015 said he thought climate change science was becoming “more uncertain”, that climate models were not reliable, and that sea level rises were not accelerating.
He also said polar ice was not melting at an “unnatural rate” meaning this disappearing ice was not evidence of human influence on the climate.
Canavan has also been pushing for environment groups to have their charitable tax status revoked.

Links

Matthew Canavan Says There Is 'Uncertainty' Around Impact Of Climate Change

The Guardian - Gabrielle Chan

New resources minister describes Adani Carmichael coalmine as ‘incredibly exciting’ for Australia
The resources minister, Matthew Canavan, accused ‘certain interest groups’ of exaggerating the effects of carbon emissions. Photograph: Mick Tsikas/AAP
The new resources minister, Matthew Canavan, has warned there is still a level of uncertainty about the impact of carbon emissions on global warming and described the Adani Carmichael coalmine as an “incredibly exciting project” for Australia.
Canavan, who has previously called for funding for climate change sceptic scientists, is also responsible for the Northern Australia Infrastructure Facility, which will decide whether to recommend the Queensland government’s application for a federal loan for the Adani railway link.
He said while he had the final decision on projects recommended by the NAIF, the body had only come into being on 1 July and had yet to make any recommendations to him as minister.
Canavan is the biggest winner of the ministry reshuffle, elevated to cabinet and given the resources portfolio to add to his northern Australia outer ministry position. He said he accepted the warming impact of carbon dioxide, notwithstanding a level of uncertainty. He accused “certain interest groups” of exaggerating the effects of carbon emissions.
“There is a level of uncertainty about the impact of carbon emissions,” Canavan told Sky News. “Indeed, in the last IPCC [Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change] report, the level of confidence reduced in the forcing effect of carbon emissions.
“There is a lot about the climate system we don’t understand, a lot of assumptions we have to make with projections of course. I just feel we should all be a little more humble about our climate and our system.
“To think that we know it all and exactly how to finetune the temperature, to talk of half a degree of temperature that we could somehow manage that and hit that target, we don’t understand all the impacts.”
Canavan said climate policy changes impacted “real people’s lives” and moving to 100% renewables was naive.
“We do understand that making some policy changes have real world impacts on real people’s lives, it would cause people to be very poor if we completely cut fossil fuels out of the world economy,” Canavan said.
“There is still more than a billion people without access to electricity in our world and these are real world issues we need to be adult about.”
Canavan said there were “great advances” in the coal industry, including ultra-critical and supercritical power plants, which produce less emissions but are more expensive.
“Talk of moving to 100% renewables is not only quite naive at the moment – maybe that is something that can happen but we can’t bank on it,” Canavan said. “It is also something that will imperil our prosperity and welfare.”
He described the Adani project, which has been delayed by financing issues, a global coal slump and legal challenges by traditional owners and environmental groups, as “an incredibly exciting project for our country”.
He said as minister he saw his primary job as facilitating the project to “make it easy as possible” while ticking the boxes on environmental, health and safety and community impacts.
Canavan, who lives within a few hundred kilometres of the mine, said the project was an opportunity for Australia to improve its relationship with India.
Asked whether the coalmine was at odds with the Coalition government’s commitment to the Paris targets to reduce carbon emissions, Canavan said: “There is nothing inconsistent between our coalmining industry and the targets we are aiming for through the Paris agreement.
“The idea that we can only meet our targets through innovation in renewables – which certainly can happen and there is a big future for solar and other things – the idea that that is the only area that we can meet our targets is kind of narrow.
“Why wouldn’t we also think about improvements in fossil fuel technologies ... I am not someone who is going to be anti-fossil fuels for the sake of it.”
Canavan, an economist who has previously worked at the Productivity Commission, was also asked if he still supported income splitting, which allows a main earner to split income with a partner for tax purposes.
Canavan said he believed in a very strong family support system and evoked John Howard as a believer in income splitting.
“We do have a system that does provide benefits but it’s largely through the welfare system and family tax benefit system,” he said. “I am concerned about the increasing gap between the choice to stay at home and look after one’s child and putting them in childcare.
“I mean, particularly when they are young, the evidence is so stark that full time or close to full-time care from a mum or a dad makes a big difference to a child’s development. This is OECD data, this is not something as extreme. For a kid below the age of one, it makes a big difference.”

Links

Tuesday, July 19, 2016

Muddying The Waters On The Great Barrier Reef

ABC Media Watch

An article in The Australian suggests there is division among scientists on the danger posed to the Great Barrier Reef. But who is making these claims? But now to the Great Barrier Reef, where the worst-ever outbreak of mass coral bleaching has killed a quarter of the coral on one of the world's natural wonders.
Last month, some 2500 of the world's coral reef experts met in Hawaii and agreed to send a letter to Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull, warning him that:
Coral reefs ... are threatened with complete collapse under rapid climate change.
— 13th International Coral Reef Symposium, Letter to Malcolm Turnbull, 25 June, 2016
And urging the Australian government to:
... stop endorsing the export of coal, and specifically to stop or revoke the approval of new mines, including those in Queensland ...
— 13th International Coral Reef Symposium, Letter to Malcolm Turnbull, 25 June, 2016
That letter was widely reported by the Australian media, including:
  • The Guardian
  • The Daily Mail
  • SBS
  • Nine News
  • and Buzzfeed.
While overseas,
  • The LA Times
  • The Jakarta Post
  • Canada's CBC
  • and Mashable
also thought it a big enough story.
But surprise, surprise, one place you couldn't read it was in The Australian whose Environment Editor Graham Lloyd has written several recent stories suggesting coral bleaching ain't as bad as many have claimed:
Great Barrier Reef spared worst of coral bleaching wipe-out
— The Australian, 22 March, 2016
Great Barrier Reef: scientists 'exaggerated' coral bleaching
— The Australian, 4 June, 2016
Great Barrier Reef management top class, says UN chief
— The Australian, 7 June, 2016
Graham Lloyd's latest article on the subject, which appeared just as the Hawaii symposium ended, was headlined:
GREAT BARRIER BATTLEGROUND
— The Australian, 24 June, 2016
With a subtitle to explain that:
The bleaching of parts of the reef is dividing the scientific world
— The Australian, 24 June, 2016
But was this actually right?
Those coral reef experts meeting in Hawaii say no.
Indeed, Professor Ruth Gates, president of the International Society for Reef Studies, which co-organised the symposium, told Media Watch:
Almost every single member of the conference of 2500 people stood up saying that they felt that bleaching and climate change pose a significant threat to the existence of coral reefs. There's really no discussion about whether or not it's serious. It is very serious. There is no debate about it.
— Professor Ruth Gates, President, International Coral Reef Symposium, 30 June, 2016
Graham Lloyd found a debate nevertheless.
Thanks firstly to Professor Peter Ridd of James Cook University, whose views Lloyd has written about before.
Ridd told Lloyd that reef science can't be trusted, because it's only peer reviewed.
Which is a bizarre claim, and one that one of Australia's leading coral reef scientists Professor Ove Hoegh-Guldberg told Media Watch was:
... just ridiculous.
— Ove Hoegh-Guldberg, Professor of Marine Science, University of Queensland, 29 June, 2016
Adding that peer review is:
... the same process we use when we're studying aeronautics, which produces planes that we travel on ...
— Ove Hoegh-Guldberg, Professor of Marine Science, University of Queensland, 29 June, 2016
Lloyd's report then rehashed a couple of his other recent themes.
That fears about the health of the Barrier Reef have been exaggerated.
And that coral is resilient and can recover from bleaching.
Which, one of his experts assured us, is just:
... "part of a natural selection process from which better-adapted populations can emerge".
— The Australian, 24 June, 2016
One of the two people telling Lloyd that the Barrier Reef will repair itself is an American biologist called Jim Steele.
So, is he regarded as an expert on coral? Answer, No.
Is he known to be an expert on oceans? No, again.
So is he a famous climate scientist? No he is not.
Indeed, when we asked Professor Gates about him, she told us:
I don't know who this person is and if they were anyone serious in the field, I should know them.
— Professor Ruth Gates, President, International Coral Reef Symposium, 30 June, 2016
A little bit of digging reveals that Jim Steele is ex-director of the Sierra Nevada Field Campus of San Francisco State University, where, according to his bio:
He has taught the World of Plants, Nature Study, Natural Sciences for Teachers, Bird Banding, and Bird Identification by Song classes ...
— San Francisco State University
His bio also tells us:
Jim taught at Everett Middle School and Wallenberg High School as a science teacher ...
— San Francisco State University
But possibly of more interest to The Australian than those modest qualifications is the fact that Steele is known to be a climate sceptic and has self-published a book on the subject.
But how and why does someone like him get to be quoted as an authority on coral and the Great Barrier Reef?
We put that to The Australian's Graham Lloyd ... and he pointed us to Watts Up With That, the world's most popular climate sceptic website, where Steele recently published an essay on coral bleaching, in which, according to Lloyd:
... he analyses and synthesizes peer-reviewed coral literature some of which suggests sustained bleaching during the early 20th century.
— Graham Lloyd, Environment Editor, The Australian, Email to Media Watch, 3 July, 2016
But wasn't Jim Steele just a fringe player in the coral debate, we asked Lloyd. To which he replied:
The papers presented by Steele are not fringe.
— Graham Lloyd, Environment Editor, The Australian, Email to Media Watch, 3 July, 2016
Adding
His bird watching expertise is irrelevant.
— Graham Lloyd, Environment Editor, The Australian, Email to Media Watch, 3 July, 2016
Now those who are familiar with Graham Lloyd's work will know that it's not the first time Media Watch has ripped into some of his climate science reporting
And we've often criticised him for giving too much weight to fringe science and dissenting views.
And according to Professor Ove Hoegh-Guldberg, Lloyd's recent work on the Barrier Reef also fits this pattern.
What he's doing is taking a sniff of there being something different to the scientific perspective and promoting it as a widely held belief. It's scandalous. To have someone in such a position of power in the Murdoch press saying these sorts of things is really shocking.
— Ove Hoegh-Guldberg, Professor of Marine Science, University of Queensland, 29 June, 2016
Looking at Lloyd's latest coral bleaching report from her base in Hawaii, the president of the International Society for Coral Reef Studies, Professor Ruth Gates, reaches a similar conclusion, telling Media Watch:
It feels politicised for me and it's not balanced and it's worrying. It feels disingenuous at some level to be putting these views forward which aren't representative of the science.
— Professor Ruth Gates, President, International Coral Reef Symposium, 30 June, 2016
So we asked Lloyd if he believed his reporting should reflect the views of mainstream science. And he told us bluntly:
It clearly does.
— Graham Lloyd, Environment Editor, The Australian, Email to Media Watch, 3 July, 2016
Well, I guess that's a matter of opinion. And it must be said that in his latest report Lloyd does put forward the mainstream view as well.
But he doesn't tell readers for example, that Jim Steele's real expertise is not in coral but in birds.

Rooftop Solar Power To Be Mandatory In Dubai By 2030

CleanTechnica - Jake Richardson

The political leader of Dubai, Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid, recently announced the Dubai Clean Energy Strategy 2050, which includes a number of renewable energy targets.
Perhaps most notable is that all rooftops in the city will have solar panels by 2030.
Some might say, however, it's the goal of solar generating 75% of the city's energy by 2050 that is more remarkable.
On the way to achieving this goal is the requirement that 25% is generated by solar by 2030.
Others might say the biggest story is the low-interest financing for clean energy that will be available because of a $27 billion investment to create the Dubai Green Fund.
The size of the Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum Solar Park project has also been increased to 5,000 MW by 2030.
Imre Solt, Wiki Commons
"The strategy we are launching today will shape the energy sector over the next three decades. Our goal is to become the city with the smallest carbon footprint in the world by 2050," explained Sheikh Mohammed. Most of Dubai's electricity currently is generated by burning natural gas.
The United Arab Emirates has about one-tenth of the world's oil reserves, so it is very striking that such an emphasis would be placed on the growth of new solar power. Dubai has about 4 billion gallons of oil reserves and a population of approximately 2.1 million. The UAE's population is 9.3 million.
It is very commendable to set such large, yet achievable, renewable energy goals. In a sense, vigorously supporting clean, renewable energy seems to mesh well with Dubai's ethos, which seems to be "building rapidly and in an impressive fashion."
Of course, increasingly, solar power makes sense economically as well as environmentally. "When you have vast amounts of open land and an incredible solar resource like these countries do, the underlying structural driver is to conserve oil and gas for export and produce power from other alternative sources, even in the context of recent declines in commodity prices," explained Stephen J. Auton-Smith, director at Ernst & Young.
Energy storage wasn't mentioned, but it often makes sense to add battery systems to fill in gaps in electricity production.

Links

Are Seawalls The Best Answer To Rising Sea Levels – Or Is Retreat A Better Option?

The Guardian - 

While barriers are the most widely used methd of protecting coastal homes and infrastructure in Australia, landscape architects must consider other options
June's devastating storms damaged beachfront homes on Sydney's northern beaches. Some are calling for a seawall to be put in place. Photograph: Dean Lewins/AAP
 The extraordinary pictures of subsumed gardens and a swimming pool wrenched from the ground by the giant waves that battered Sydney's northern beaches last month have revived debate about seawalls and the impact of human attempts to keep the rising ocean from our doors.
Given their spectacular locations, the homes in the frontline of raging waves are usually valuable property. Attempts to fortify them are met with resistance from ecologists and other beach users, who say the houses should not have been built there in the first place.
They object to seawalls because they stop the beach from being a dynamic system, in which wind and waves continually reshape the shore. Natural processes will usually redeposit much of the lost sand back on to beaches in the weeks after a storm. But where there is a seawall, heightened waves run up the shore and slam against it. The beach can't move backwards, so the sand disappears.

Sydney storm damage on northern beaches captured by drone

But seawalls, like dykes, levees and berms, have been used across the world for centuries to protect homes and other assets. From Sydney to São Paulo to New York, a sea-level rise of even a few centimetres can threaten to swallow homes and highways, inundate sewage treatment plants, and contaminate water supplies. Whether faced with king tides or swelling rivers and lakes, planners in coastal and estuarine urban settings must find a way to brace against the impacts of climate change.
Some schemes address the wider landscape. New York's Big U, an ambitious berm project, will effectively raise the bank of the East river almost three metres – well above Hurricane Sandy's high-water mark. Others approaches consider making individual structures more adaptive, such as buildings on stilts, or houses that float – either permanently or when the land is inundated.
In Australia, seawalls are the most widely used method of protecting waterfront properties and infrastructure. While many object to their use, moves to minimise their visual and ecological impact are continually being refined.
David Rissik, deputy director of the National Climate Change Adaptation Research Facility which supports decision makers in managing sea-level rises, says while Australians have become used to being able to hold back the ocean, the location, structure and materials used for seawalls are under much greater scrutiny than in the past.
"Where people have taken over places where there is natural migration of riverbanks or open coast, seawalls have allowed them to live," he says.
Rissik is sanguine about the concentration of infrastructure around Australia's coast. "From a pathway from the beach, a local economy grows and, once that is established, it anchors people to that area and change is very difficult."
The row about whether a seawall should be built on a stretch of coast in Collaroy has raged since the shoreline of the northern Sydney suburb was subdivided more than 100 years ago. When the beach retreated during high seas, the then beach shacks were undermined. Records show major erosion occurred in 1920, seven shacks fell into the sea in 1945 and one was washed away in 1967. But, as Rissik says: "People forget and they build there again."
While Collaroy is among few beaches worldwide where researchers have a 40-year unbroken record of the changes to the coast through survey techniques, Rissik says coastal experts don't have a great knowledge of where sediment supplies and erosion are in many other parts of the country.
Queensland's Gold Coast is an exception. Maintaining the beach's amenity is so vital for tourism that planners have established a comprehensive strategy for coastal management. Under its A-line scheme, the city council allows seawalls under strict regulation. When developers want to build one it must be effectively behind the dunes, acting as a last line of defence, but buried by sand and hidden from view. The costs of dredging and distribution of sediment are enormous but compliance keeps protests to a minimum.
David Hatherly, a landscape architect whose company Vee Design has won acclaim for its redesign of the waterfront at Yeppoon on Queensland's central coast, says the prospect of rising sea levels was completely ignored in his brief from the council that commissioned him. "I don't think we in Australia have done a very good job of understanding our coastal environment," he says.
Cyclone Sid in 1998 caused the worst floods in Townsville's history, destroying much of the infrastructure on the Strand, the city's foreshore focal point. As part of the restructure, artificial headlands were built to hold the sand and prevent longshore drift. It's a typical response, Hatherly says. "We're coming up with these hard engineering solutions to fight nature. Artificial headlands, seawalls … they are Band-Aid solutions. The most cautious thing to do would be to maintain proper buffer zones."
Responses to sea-level rises fall under the three broad categories, Rissik says: defence, accommodate and retreat. Seawalls and levees are the most obvious defences, along with "soft options" such as mangroves and vegetation. Human-made dunes can be used to lessen wave energy.
Accommodation approaches include the development of areas in cities that allow us to continue to live, work and play where we do now, while rising seas and occasional floods take place around us. Futuristic versions of this could see communities built on piled foundations, where structures are screwed into the ground, surrounded by wetlands and beaches.
Rissik describes the retreat option as the point when we recognise we cannot cope with the impacts of a rising ocean and move to areas better suited to habitation. Hatherly points to the 2011 Queensland floods as an example of an extreme weather event which he expected would make a strong case for the retreat option.
"But people are already flocking back to the river's edge with limited concern for the possibility of flood," he says. "They won't relinquish those locations as long as governing authorities allow rebuilding."

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative