Thursday, December 01, 2016

Will The Latest Electricity Review Bring Climate And Energy Policy Together At Last?

The Conversation -  | 

The Australian government is reviewing our electricity market to make sure it can provide secure and reliable power in a rapidly changing world. Faced with the rise of renewable energy and limits on carbon pollution, The Conversation has asked experts what kind of future awaits the grid.
Australia's National Electricity Market brings power to millions of people. Power image from www.shutterstock.com
Australia's National Electricity Market (NEM) is under review following the state-wide blackout that hit South Australia in September.
The review, led by Chief Scientist Alan Finkel, will "develop a national reform blueprint to maintain energy security and reliability".
Importantly, the Council of Australian Governments (COAG) specifically agreed that the review would consider Australia's commitment under the Paris climate agreement, and how climate and energy policy can be integrated.
Before we consider how the NEM might need to change, it is important to understand how it came about.

State responsibility
Electricity supply began as a state responsibility. Originally, state-based utilities owned and operated the entire supply chain, from generation to transmission, distribution and retail. With the exception of the Snowy Hydro Scheme, there were no interstate transmission lines.Accessibility and affordability were (and still are) key concerns for the states. As such, electricity prices were equal for all citizens, irrespective of their location or the actual cost of bringing electricity to them. This is still partly reflected in network tariffs today.
In the late 1980s, concerns about rising costs to government, but also a worldwide ideological move towards privatisation of public services, drove a shift away from publicly owned utilities. This began with a New South Wales inquiry, which found that NSW could avoid billions of dollars in new investment by connecting its network with Victoria.
This set the scene for the development of a more interconnected grid and more general reform. In particular, this was followed by a report from the former Industry Commission in 1991 and the Hilmer Review on National Competition Policy in 1993. These reports were dominated by market logic. They argued that competition would make the system more efficient.
Governments specifically agreed to reforms that would lead to a fully competitive national electricity market. This involved breaking up and selling the three layers of the electricity sector: generation, networks and retail.
The network businesses were seen as natural monopolies, and were to be regulated as such. Generators and retailers were to compete within their own layer, increasing efficiency and keeping prices down.

The national system

Following these preparatory measures, the state and federal governments agreed to pass the National Electricity Law (NEL) under a cooperative national arrangement. This provided the legal basis to create the National Electricity Market (NEM). The NEM is the national electricity market governed by the NEL and includes the wholesale markets as well as network regulation.
In 2001, the state and federal governments established the Ministerial Council on Energy with the broad aim of overseeing and coordinating national energy policy. In 2002, the council commissioned an independent review of energy markets, which highlighted many deficiencies, including governance and regulation.
The review found that the state-based regulators' responsibilities overlapped with those of the national regulators and led to costly inconsistencies. It also found that greenhouse policy responses were "ad hoc and poorly targeted".
The ministerial council subsequently proposed a package of reforms. This led to the formation of the Australian Energy Market Commission for developing market rules, and the Australian Energy Regulator for enforcing them, which governments endorsed through the Australian Energy Market Agreement.
This agreement contains a commitment to reducing greenhouse gas emissions. However, this remained outside the National Electricity Objective, which was introduced in 2005 and is the highest point of reference for policy setting. The National Electricity Objective is to:
…promote efficient investment in, and efficient operation and use of, electricity services for the long-term interests of consumers of electricity with respect to price, quality, safety, reliability and security of supply of electricity; and the reliability, safety and security of the national electricity system.
Parallel to these regulatory developments, the states participating in the market became increasingly intertwined. Five new interconnectors were added between 1990 and 2006.
The competitive layers of the industry also began a period of consolidation, leading to the emergence of the so-called "gentailers". The wholesale market is now dominated by three gentailers (Origin, AGL and Energy Australia), which collectively supply 71% of all retail customers.

The new review

Shortly after the blackout in South Australia, Federal Energy and Environment Minister Josh Frydenberg called for harmonisation of state renewable energy policies, and announced the latest review.
The Finkel Review is a review into the "security and reliability" of the NEM. However, its scope is wide enough to allow for a fundamental rethink of the role of the electricity sector in addressing climate change.
The blackout provides a great example of the kind of challenge the NEM will face in the future. On one hand, climate policies, especially the RET and state-based renewable energy goals, put pressure on the networks and influence the wholesale electricity market.
On the other hand, climate change is expected lead to more frequent and increasingly severe storm events, such as the one that destroyed transmission towers in South Australia. Networks, markets and their governance framework under the NEM aren't necessarily prepared for these changing conditions.
As shown by the 2002 review, the overlap of state energy policies and ad hoc climate policies is not a particularly new phenomenon. But market governance frameworks have so far kept climate policies separate from the narrow efficiency concerns of the electricity market and network regulation.
Clearly, in the age of climate change, the NEM and its regulatory and institutional frameworks will need to take account of these new and increasing climate mitigation and adaptation pressures.
Recently, South Australian Energy Minister Tom Koutsantonis called for the federal government to "get serious about bringing climate policy and energy policy together".
With the energy and environment portfolios combined in some governments (including now the federal one), perhaps the Finkel Review can support a convergence of climate and energy policy on a national level.

For more details on the history of reforms in the electricity market see Environmental norms and electricity supply: an analysis of normative change and household solar PV in Australia and A Barrier for Australia's Climate Commitments? Law, the Electricity Market and Transitioning the Stationary Electricity Sector.

Why Land Rights For Indigenous Peoples Could Be The Answer To Climate Change

The Guardian - 

Preventing deforestation is central to curbing carbon emissions – and a case study on the Amazon shows the most cost-effective way of doing it
Munduruku Indians demonstrate in front of the offices of the Brazilian ministry of mines and energy in Brasilia. Photograph: Lunae Parracho/REUTERS
I've spent a lot of time with indigenous peoples in remote places. So when I argue that the best way – or at least the cheapest way – to stop climate change is to grant land rights to indigenous communities, you might suspect I'm not coming from an entirely objective viewpoint. You've probably also heard various industry spokespeople saying the best and cheapest way to stop climate change is through windfarms, solar panels, electric cars and cavity wall insulation. But while I may be biased, and may even have "gone native" now and then, I'm not trying to sell you anything.
On a global scale, one of the main causes of climate change is land-use change, and particularly changing land from forest to agriculture. Stopping deforestation is the most economically efficient way of preventing carbon emissions because, in simple terms, all it amounts to is not flooding forests for dams or cutting down and burning them for agriculture.
The efficiency of not cutting down trees as a climate change mitigation strategy is fairly well-established. The UN is pushing the international community to cooperate on an agreed plan to stop deforestation and its associated emissions, which add up to about the same level as road transport and haulage emissions.
But this is where a beautifully simple idea becomes complicated. How exactly do you stop deforestation? How do you compensate industries reliant on the agriculture that entails deforestation? And how do you compensate them in a way that doesn't create perverse incentives and unforeseen consequences?
What is the value of a forest and the land it stands on? There's the value of the timber it can produce, and after that, the crops that could be grown. Or the value of an Amazonian valley flooded for a hydroelectric dam.
Then there's the forest's value if we don't chop it down. Its value as a carbon sink, its value as a biodiversity reservoir, its value as a weather maker and regulator, its value as a source of oxygen and air purifier. All the things that are invisible to accountants but vital to humans.
And forests also have a value that even environmental scientists can miss, but is very, very real to forest peoples. As the environmentalist David Suzuki says: "The way we see the world shapes the way we treat it. If a mountain is a deity, not a pile of ore; if a river is one of the veins of the land, not potential irrigation water; if a forest is a sacred grove, not timber; if other species are biological kin, not resources; or if the planet is our mother, not an opportunity – then we will treat each other with greater respect."
This is why indigenous peoples are the forests' greatest conservationists. They can cut through the Gordian knot of the UN's interminable processes. They see and understand the value that enlightened, developed cultures are blind to, and which modern science is only beginning to rediscover.
Translating that value into the hard currency we value is difficult. The World Resources Institute has taken a step in that direction, with a study of the environmental and economic costs and benefits of governments granting indigenous land rights in Brazil, Bolivia and Colombia. It reports that giving indigenous people land rights leads to the preservation of forests as carbon sinks. And, as a means of storing carbon, it is between five and 42 times more cost-efficient than fitting carbon capture and storage systems to fossil-fuel power stations.
If we are unwilling to spend money on protecting rainforests, their spectacular biodiversity, indigenous cultures, their ecosystems and their ineffable beauty and meaning, then we'll have to spend a lot more sucking from the atmosphere what was once a rainforest, and burying it in the ground.
There is a test case going on right now in Brazil, home of the world's biggest rainforest. The country's official body for looking at indigenous people's land rights, FUNAI, is due to decide this month on whether to grant them to the Munduruku people. They live in the Tapajos basin, an area in the heart of the Amazon being eyed up for the construction of more than 40 hugely destructive mega-dams.
The Munduruku can protect their bit of the Amazon for us, as they have done for centuries, preserving its amazingly varied flora and fauna and saving us the money we'd have to spend on taking carbon out of the atmosphere if industry is allowed turn it into carbon emissions.
The Munduruku have been campaigning for their rights for decades. The Brazilian constitution says they should be given them. A cold, hard, financial cost/benefit analysis says they should be given them. And if the Munduruku don't get their land rights, there's an industrial-scale queue of people waiting to trash their beautiful home. While many of us have yet to fully understand this, the truth is, their home is also our home.

Links

Wednesday, November 30, 2016

Farmers Demand The Coalition Government Do More On Climate Change

Fairfax - Fergus Hunter

A thumping majority of Australian farmers have concluded they are witnessing the effects of climate change, urging the Coalition government to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and prepare the country for a future that is drier, less predictable and more prone to bushfires.
This is according to a survey of 1300 primary producers across states and agricultural sectors, conducted by advocacy group Farmers for Climate Action with the co-operation of the National Farmers Federation.

It found 88 per cent of respondents want rural and regional politicians to start advocating for stronger climate change action. Two thirds have seen changes in rainfall over their time on the land and half have seen an increase in droughts and floods.
Nine in 10 are concerned about damage to the climate and eight in 10 support Australia moving towards 100 per cent renewable energy.
A delegation of six farmers visited Parliament House on Monday and Tuesday to convey the findings, meeting with politicians of all persuasions to make their case for emissions reductions, global leadership and boosted research on new technology.
Derek Blomfield, a beef producer from the Liverpool Plains in Nationals leader Barnaby Joyce's New South Wales electorate, has observed increasing unreliability of weather.
He now finds managing his property more difficult and wants to see "strong leadership" from the Coalition government and thinks farmers shouldn't be scared of initiatives like emissions trading schemes and carbon taxes.
"For our industry, it's critical that we don't let this thing get out of hand. When I say for our industry, it actually means for everyone. Because we all need a farmer three times a day."
Victorian dairy farmer Karrinjeet Singh-Mahil and Liverpool Plains beef farmer Derek Blomfield at Parliament House in Canberra on Tuesday. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen
To  some of the MPs more sceptical of climate change, including Mr Joyce and other Nationals, "we just try and point out how critical this is for our industry," he said.
The survey found changes to rainfall had been observed by 67 per cent of respondents, more frequent and worse droughts by 47 per cent, floods by 46 per cent, increased temperatures by 42 per cent, changing planting times by 41 per cent and more frequent and worse bushfires for 22.5 per cent.
Victorian cattleman Craig Porter takes his cattle for grazing on the roadside due to the 2007 drought. Photo: Justin McManus
They were most concerned about less reliable rainfall, higher temperatures that increase evaporation, heatwaves, pollution from mining, bushfires, rising costs and invasive species.
Karrinjeet Singh-Mahil, a dairy farmer from Crossley in Victoria, wants boosted climate change research funding and improved access to the Emissions Reductions Fund for farmers to pursue new initiatives.
Dried up vineyards near Menindee, NSW hit by drought in 2016.  Photo: Edwina Pickles
"We want them to get over the ideology and to accept that change is happening, for whatever reason, and we want them to have a consistent message that it is and that it is affecting farms," she told Fairfax Media.
Ms Singh-Mahil said her property is suffering from increased erosion and pastures not surviving the season. She is satisfied with the reception from Canberra MPs, especially the understanding of those who have real experience on farms.
Climate change, which scientific consensus has found to be a unique threat driven by the human-generated increase in greenhouse gas emissions, gradually lifts air and ocean temperatures, making weather more unpredictable, raising sea levels and undermining critical environmental processes.
The average global temperature has already risen one degree celsius above pre-industrial levels and 2016 is set to knock off 2015 as the hottest year on record.

Links

Fossil Fuel Giants Using Questionable Deductions To Shrink Tax Bills: Auditor-General

Fairfax - Heath Aston

A damning investigation has found multinational companies are claiming billions of dollars in questionable deductions while exploiting the nation's natural riches, using accounting tricks allowed to flourish under a hands-off government approach that is dudding Australian taxpayers of royalties.
And in a stunning disclosure, the probe by Auditor-General Grant Hehir found nearly two decades had passed since a federal government audited the self-assessed royalty payments from the North West Shelf, a giant project located in the lucrative oil and gas region off the West Australian coast and jointly owned by Woodside, Shell, Chevron and BHP Billiton.

How some companies cut billions off their tax bill
Underlining rising concerns over whether the $200 billion liquefied natural gas industry is paying its fair share of tax, Mr Hehir's report discovered a $5 billion bonanza of deductions claimed by the project in just one 18-month period.
Some of the Auditor-General's most damning criticism was reserved for a single $705 million cost deduction that helped reduce royalties owed to the taxpayer by $88 million. Mr Hehir argued the $705 million deduction may not have been technically valid.
Auditor-General Grant Hehir warns his review may only scratch the surface. 
The multibillion-dollar deductions - which are still being taken despite the project being fully mature after 25 years in operation - dwarf the $1.9 billion in royalties it paid in the same 18-month period.
Mr Hehir warned his review may only scratch the surface.
"There has been limited scrutiny of the claimed deductions...the available evidence indicates that the problems are much greater than has yet been quantified," he found.
Among the most concerning findings were:
  • It has been 17 years since the government audited the self-assessed royalty payments from North West Shelf;
  • One of the meters relied on to measure gas output, and therefore royalties due, was broken for five years;
  • The Royalty Schedule which governs payment calculations has not been updated in 10 years, and;
  • The West Australian government engaged audit firm Ernst & Young to conduct a 2014 "external review" of deductions even though the firm is also the long-time auditor of the North West Shelf's financial accounts.
Mr Hehir found deductible costs, which include operating and capital expenditure, depreciation and crude oil excise, can represent up to 90 per cent of the gross value of the gas produced.
"There are some significant shortcomings in the framework for calculating North West Shelf royalties," he found.
North West Shelf has already paid $8.6 million in underpaid royalties as a result of the Auditor-General's investigation.
Mr Hehir also made a withering assessment of the hands-off approach of bureaucrats in the federal Department of Industry, Innovation and Science and the state Department of Mines and Petroleum, which oversees the royalty system.
"Given the actual and potential size of allowable deductions being claimed by NWS producers on a monthly basis, it would be reasonable to expect [the departments] to have developed and implemented a robust compliance strategy and included strong controls around verifying the validity of deductions being claimed," he wrote.
He said there were no agreed procedures and no assurances sought that deductions are being claimed correctly.
Mr Hehir recommended the state and federal governments work together to ensure deductions claimed by the North West Shelf producers in 2015 are valid, as well as work to "verify the validity" of deductions claimed prior to 2014.
A Woodside spokeswoman said the company had "robust compliance processes with regard to royalty obligations" and had assisted audits in an "open, transparent and cooperative manner".
Woodside pointed to a reference in Mr Hehir's report about underpaid royalties totalling "$11.6 million" but that total was in direct relation to a 2014 external audit, which the Auditor-General described as "limited in scope".
Resource tax expert Diane Kraal, a lecturer from Monash University, said it was hard to know just how much has been lost from the North West Shelf without a forecast for how much royalty revenue had been expected.
In its response to the Auditor-General's report, the federal department agreed the system could be 'improved" but argued it was nonetheless "robust".
For historical reasons, the North West Shelf pays royalties but also comes under the petroleum resource rent tax (PRRT).
Newer LNG export projects like Chevron's massive Gorgon and Wheatstone ventures are not required to pay royalties at all but are only assessed for the profits-based PRRT.
Fairfax Media has revealed over recent months that just 5 per cent of 150 oil and gas ventures are paying any PRRT, despite Australia being poised to eclipse Qatar as the world's single biggest exporter of LNG by 2020.
The industry has built up a mountainous $187 billion in exploration and development tax credits, which continue to rise sharply and will be used to insulate companies from paying PRRT for years to come.
Last week, Craig Emerson, one of the architects of the PRRT in the Hawke government backed calls for a parliamentary inquiry into why the boom in LNG exports shows no sign of delivering any meaningful contribution to the wealth of Australia.
On Monday, Greens senator Peter Whish-Wilson accused the government of getting things "arse-about" by focusing on tax paid by backpackers before the giant fossil fuel companies.
"They have been trying to penny-pinch from backpackers and some of the lowest-paid workers in the country, and yet they have been blind to potentially multi-billion-dollar rorts from massive multinational corporations," he said.

Links

Great Barrier Reef Suffered Worst Bleaching On Record In 2016, Report Finds

BBC News - Hywel Griffith

Warmer waters has led to the worst destruction of coral ever recorded on the Great Barrier Reef. ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies
Higher water temperatures in 2016 caused the worst destruction of corals ever recorded on Australia's Great Barrier Reef, a study has found.
Some 67% of corals died in the reef's worst-hit northern section, the ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies report said.
The situation was better in the central section, where 6% perished, while the southern reef is in good health.
But scientists warn recovery could be difficult if climate change continues.
Coral bleaching happens when water temperatures rise for a sustained period of time.
In February, March and April, sea surface temperatures across the Great Barrier Reef were the hottest on record, at least 1C higher than the monthly average.
"Some of the initial mortality was down to heat stress," said study leader Professor Terry Hughes.
"The coral was cooked."

How bleaching occurs
Far more has been lost through gradual starvation, after the coral expelled the colourful algae zooxanthella, which turns sunlight into food.
This is what leads to the white, skeletal appearance of the coral, which is left without its main source of energy.
For three months, sea temperatures were a degree higher than average. ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies
The study also found that the coral which survived the bleaching have now come under greater threat from predators such as snails and crown of thorns starfish.
This year's mass bleaching was the worst-ever recorded on the Great Barrier Reef, following two previous events in 1998 and 2002.
Professor Hughes is certain that the increased water temperature is the result of carbon emissions, and warns that climate change could bring annual bleaching within 20 years.
"Most of the losses in 2016 have occurred in the northern, most pristine part of the Great Barrier Reef," he said.
"This region escaped with minor damage in two earlier bleaching events in 1998 and 2002, but this time around it has been badly affected."

Where is the damage?
One of the worst-hit areas is around Lizard Island in Far North Queensland, where around 90% of the coral has died.
Dr Andrew Hoey, whose team charted the area, said the impact was far worse than feared after an initial survey in April.
"It's devastating to get in the water somewhere you've been coming for almost 20 years, and it's just knocked it on its head," he said.
Bleaching is caused when water temperatures rise for a sustained period. ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies
"There's very little coral cover left there. It was dominated by the acropora - the branching corals - but we lost most of them."
Lizard Island is home to a research station, where scientists from across the world have come for decades to study marine life
One of its directors, Dr Anne Hogget, said this was by far the worst event to hit the Great Barrier Reef since she started working there in 1990.
"We had bleaching here in 2002," she said. "We thought this was bad at the time, but this has blown it completely out of the water."
She is hopeful that the reef is capable of recovery, but fears it may not be give an opportunity, as sea temperatures continue to rise.
Dr Andrew Hoey (pictured) said the loss was far worse than feared
"The trajectory is not good," Dr Hogget explained.
"We keep pumping carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, and this happened absolutely because of that."

What happens next?
On the central and southern parts of the Great Barrier Reef, where bleaching was not as prevalent, there is concern that it has been misreported, with one magazine even publishing an obituary of the reef earlier this year.
Tourism operators like Michael Healey from the Quicksilver Group are keen to point out that many sites were unaffected, but there is concern for the reef's long term health.
"Without the Great Barrier Reef, we wouldn't survive," he said.
"So it is absolutely of the utmost importance that we ensure that our politicians and everyone else in our community and around the world are doing what they can."
ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies
The Australian Government has published a long-term sustainability plan for the reef, and pledged financial support for research into coral bleaching.
The 2050 plan identifies the need to help make the reef more resilient to climate change in the future, while trying to lower carbon emissions.
Mr Healy argued even those not financially involved had a stake in the reef.
"I'd say every human on the planet does," he said.

Links

Tuesday, November 29, 2016

Bigger, Hotter ‘Firestorms To Become The New Normal’ In Australia

NEWS.com.au - Debra Killalea

The Glen Cromie Caravan Park in Drouin pictured during the 2009 Victorian Black Saturday bushfires.
MEGAFIRES will become the new normal with the intensity and frequency of deadly disasters increasing as Australia becomes hotter and drier.
And fire crews will struggle to contain the firestorms which will not only claim more lives but destroy ecosystems and property while wreaking havoc and destruction in the process.
The dire prediction, forecast in journal Climatic Change, found the time between such megafires, also called firestorms, is shrinking while the conditions under which they develop are worsening.
In ‘Natural hazards in Australia: Extreme bushfire’, published last month, researchers also warn that by 2070 megafires in Australia are 30 per cent more likely to occur.
Australian Firefighters Climate Alliance spokesman Jim Casey said the reality was this phenomenon was becoming the “new normal” and it was the frightening future the country faced.
Mr Casey said the megafires not only destroyed everything in their path but became so fierce crews could do nothing to stop them.
A CFA fire truck leaves a blaze burning near Pakenham in Bunyip State Forest, east of Melbourne, during Victoria’s Black Saturday Bushfires in February 2009. Picture: Alex Coppel Source: Supplied
“Essentially these fires are just so big and so fuel loaded they act more like a storm than a fire,” he told news.com.au.
“With shorter winters and less time to do hazard reduction burning, it creates perfect conditions for fires like this.”
While acknowledging bushfires are and will always be part of the Australian way of life, Mr Casey said megafires were a nightmare for authorities.
“Their real danger is their size, they are unfightable,” he said.
“When fire crews are faced with fire fronts stretching across 50km and it’s 10m high, the only option is to leave.”
Mr Casey, who was a candidate for The Greens at the recent federal election, said it was obvious climate change was creating hotter conditions and you only had to look at rising insurance costs over the past 20 years to see fires were occurring more regularly.
In 1987-1996 there was $88 million in insurance claims recorded as a result of megafires.
According to Insurance Council of Australia figures, this jumped to $491 million between 1997 and 2006, and more than doubled to $1.179 billion between 2007-2016.
Megafires will not only become more frequent but more intense, researchers predict. Source: Supplied
Mr  Casey said the research and cost findings from the Insurance Council of Australia came as no surprise to firefighters on the frontline.
“They know first-hand that they are unlike anything they have faced before — fires like Black Saturday bushfires in Victoria, or the Yarloop fire in Western Australia that destroy everything in their path,” he said.
“These are the sort of fires that can’t be fought in the way you would a traditional bushfire — they are too large, and too intense. You can only get people out of the way.”
Megafires have been fought in Victoria, Western Australia, New South Wales and the ACT during the past decade.
The Black Saturday bushfires saw more 400 blazes recorded across the state affecting 78 communities and claiming 173 lives and 2029 houses lost.
Images of the Black Saturday disaster remain etched in many people’s memories with the fires resembling that of a nuclear explosion.
Just last year, four people lost their lives in bushfires to the north of Esperance in Western Australia.
Mr Casey warned that unless there was real leadership shown on climate change, such disasters would continue to occur.
Grace Wilson pictured holding a garden sunflower she salvaged from ruins of her parents’ house at Mudgegonga. John and Sue died when their house was destroyed in the Black Saturday fires. Picture: Renee Nowytarger Source: News Limited
“We can take all the steps to try and get ready that we can,” he said.
“But at the end of the day it’s like sticking a Band-Aid over a wound that is rapidly becoming gangrenous.”
The Australian Firefighters Climate Alliance warn everywhere west of the Great Dividing Range face higher risks of such firestorms than ever before.
The group is also concerned about the increased risk their members will face in the line of duty and said it was clear climate change could no longer be denied.
“It’s no longer a question of belief,” Mr Casey said.
“It’s just a question of whether you can read and a question of scientific research.”
Mr Casey also said while houses could be replaced, ecosystems and lives couldn’t and the time for taking action was now.
“The cost of not addressing the root cause of worsening bushfires is high, and growing ever higher,” he said.
“This is a real threat because it has the potential to be so catastrophic.”












Links

'Nowhere On Earth Safe' From Climate Change As Survival Challenge Grows

Fairfax - Peter Hannam

As if humans weren't making it hard enough for the world's creatures great and small.
Evidence continues to mount that global warming is having an impact on ecosystems across the planet in a myriad of ways, altering both individual species and ecological communities.

Thirty years of Arctic ice decay
Incredible animated video released by NASA shows the drastic change of the Arctic ice shelves over thirty years.

"There's really nowhere on earth where the natural systems are not being affected by climate change," Lesley Hughes, a professor of biology at Macquarie University, said.
"Climate change is simply an additional stress on already stressed ecosystems," Professor Hughes said, listing habitat loss, pollution and over-exploitation among the existing challenges.
A recent paper in Science surveyed research on 94 core ecological processes and found 82 per cent were already revealing climate change impacts as temperatures warmed.
James Watson, a conservation biologist at the University of Queensland and one of the paper's authors, said people often fixated on polar bears, penguins or another emblematic species.
"They think, 'that's miles away from me; it's a pity but it doesn't affect me'," Professor Watson said. "It's everything that's affected."
Here are six key areas of change:

Physiology
Warming temperatures alter the sex ratio of offspring of certain marine and terrestrial species.
Polar bears get much of the media attention about how climate change is affecting species - but the struggles extend far wider, scientists say. Photo: SeppFriedhuber
As  Fairfax Media reported, sea turtle eggs incubate at a uniform 29 degrees, with the male-female ratio changing according to temperature. If temperatures reach 30.5 degrees all offspring will be females. (Should the species survive long enough without males, 33 degrees is enough to ensure no embryos make it.)
The oceans are home to some other big changes, such as increasing acidity as waters absorb more carbon dioxide.
Corals are among the species in the firing line, as are creatures with shells, such as tiny pteropods, the Science paper said.
"Severe levels of shell dissolution" were reported for some Antarctic pteropods, according to a paper in Nature Geoscience.
"As deep-water up-welling and CO2 absorption by surface waters is likely to increase as a result of human activities, we conclude that upper ocean regions where aragonite-shelled organisms are affected by dissolution are likely to expand," the paper said.
These kinds of changes "have the capacity to undermine and change dramatically the structure of marine food webs, which ultimately underpin much of the protein sources for humans", Professor Hughes said.

Genetics
Species with short generation spans, such as phytoplankton, are changing fast, but not fast enough.
In the Gulf of Cariaco, off Venezuela, phytoplankton have managed to adjust their ecological thermal niche by 0.45 degrees over a 15-year period. The response, though, lagged the 0.73-degree warming of waters over that time.
For others, such as the southern flying squirrels on North America, hybridisation with "cousin species" the northern flying squirrel is one response. (See image below of northern flying squirrel, via www.nature.ca )
Since 1995, a series of unusually warm winters has marked the start of a northward surge of 240 km in the range of the southern squirrel, the Daily Climate reported, based on work published in Global Change Biology.
Similar hybridisation is evident elsewhere, generating other concerns.
"The interbreeding has several consequences, none well understood: It could increase genetic diversity, helping species weather rapid ecosystem changes," the Daily Climate said. "It also could dilute the genetics of at-risk animals such as polar bears, perhaps even diluting them beyond recognition. And the changes threaten to wreak havoc with conservation efforts."

Morphology
Individuals of some species are shrinking in size, as scientists have expected, as creatures with larger surface-to-volume ratios are favoured as temperatures rise.
The body size of six woodland salamander species in the US Appalachian Mountains has shrunk an average of 8 per cent over the past 50 years, Science said.
Species of butterflies, dragonflies and birds are also changing colour, other studies showed, with some becoming darker or lighter, depending on local advantages. The skull shape of alpine chipmunk has "revealed significant changes" in California over the past century as its ranges narrow and its diet changes.

Phenology
The timing of many life processes of species – such as the budding of plants, the hatching of birds and migration timings – is closely tied to climate variation. Climate shifts are throwing such processes out of whack.
"Across marine, freshwater, and terrestrial ecosystems, spring phenologies have advanced by 2.3 to 5.1 days per decade, the Science paper said. "A combination of climate warming and higher atmospheric CO2 concentrations has extended the growing period of many plant populations."
Examples include reduced fledging success of tawny owls in the UK as hatchings over the past 27 years have become synchronous with its principal prey, the field vole.
Another predator-prey mismatch is evident among blooms of spring diatoms, which have advanced more than 20 days since 1962, triggering declining populations of its main grazer, the water flea.

Distribution
A shift in species' location is one of the most rapid responses observed especially for marine creatures with fewer connectivity issues compared with land-based ones, Science said.
Professor Watson said changing seasonal rains mean Australia's savannah regions are experiencing more intense fires later in the season, killing off grasses. The result is that rainforests are expanding to fill the ecological gap
Elsewhere, corals around Japan have shifted their range by as as much as 14 km per year over the past 80 years, the paper noted.
In the mountains of New Guinea, birds have shifted their distributions, moving up the slopes by as much as 152 metres between 1965 and 2013, according to other research.

Inter-species relations
As species are becoming redistributed, existing interactions between species are being disrupted.
Off Western Australia, for example, overgrazing of subtropical reefs by the pole-ward spread of tropical browsing fish hampered the recovery in 2013 of kelp killed by a previous heatwave event, according to research published by Ecology Letters.
Feeding rates by the browsing fish were about three times higher than previously observed on coral reefs.
Elsewhere, woody plants are invading arctic and alpine herb-dominated communities in response to rapid warming in recent decades, triggering secondary shifts in distribution of other plants and animals, Science said.
In  one example from Sweden, resident birds, such as the great tit, had become better able to adapt to warmer temperatures and out-compete with the pied flycatcher, the sole long-distance migrant.
In general, movements of many species are becoming more erratic and harder to predict, Professor Watson said.

'Almost incomprehensible'
"The frightening thing is that we have only had a degree of warming so far [since pre-industrial times], Professor Hughes said, adding that the rate of warming will be three times even if nations "perfectly kept" promises made in the 2015 Paris climate agreement.
"The changes that would go along with 3 degrees are almost incomprehensible," she said.
A paper out this week published by The Royal Society examined how fast ecological niches occupied by various species were adapting and how much they would need to change over the next 55 years.
The analysis of 266 populations of plants and animals showed rates of change in climatic niches to be dramatically slower than rates of projected climate change, in the order of 200,000-fold for temperature.
Species in the tropics – typically the most various on earth – were less capable of adjusting than those at higher latitudes, the authors led by the University of Arizona found.
Professor Hughes said species in the Darwin region might only need to tolerate a temperature range over the year of about 30-35 degrees, while those in the Sydney region might endure a 0-40 degree range.
"Those species in the tropics probably have a far narrower range of variability that they can cope with," she said. "That predisposes them to being more vulnerable" in a warming world.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative