New York Times - Justin Gillis
We know. Global warming is daunting. So here’s a place to start: 17 often-asked questions with some straightforward answers.
 |
| Jon Han |
Part 1 What Is Happening?
1. Climate change? Global warming? What do we call it?
Both are accurate, but they mean different things.
You can think of global warming as one type of
climate change. The broader term covers changes beyond warmer
temperatures, such as shifting rainfall patterns.
President Trump has claimed that scientists
stopped referring to global warming and started calling it climate
change because “the weather has been so cold” in winter. But the claim
is false. Scientists have used both terms for decades.
2. How much is the Earth heating up?
Two degrees is more significant than it sounds.
As of early 2017, the Earth had warmed by
roughly 2 degrees Fahrenheit (more than 1 degree Celsius) since 1880,
when records began at a global scale. The number may sound low, but as
an average over the surface of an entire planet, it is actually high,
which explains why much of the world’s land ice is starting to melt and
the oceans are rising at an accelerating pace. If greenhouse gas
emissions continue unchecked, scientists say, the global warming could
ultimately exceed 8 degrees Fahrenheit, which would undermine the
planet’s capacity to support a large human population.
3. What is the greenhouse effect, and how does it cause global warming?
We’ve known about it for more than a century. Really.
In the 19th century, scientists discovered that
certain gases in the air trap and slow down heat that would otherwise
escape to space. Carbon dioxide is a major player; without any of it in
the air, the Earth would be a frozen wasteland. The first
prediction
that the planet would warm as humans released more of the gas was made
in 1896. The gas has increased 43 percent above the pre-industrial level
so far, and the Earth has warmed by roughly the amount that scientists
predicted it would.
4. How do we know humans are responsible for the increase in carbon dioxide?
This one is nailed down.
Hard evidence, including studies that use
radioactivity to distinguish industrial emissions from natural
emissions, shows that the extra gas is coming from human activity.
Carbon dioxide levels rose and fell naturally in the long-ago past, but
those changes took thousands of years. Geologists say that humans are
now pumping the gas into the air much faster than nature has ever done.
5. Could natural factors be the cause of the warming?
Nope.
In theory, they could be. If the sun were to
start putting out more radiation, for instance, that would definitely
warm the Earth. But scientists have looked carefully at the natural
factors known to influence planetary temperature and found that they are
not changing nearly enough. The warming is extremely rapid on the
geologic time scale, and no other factor can explain it as well as human
emissions of greenhouse gases.
6. Why do people deny the science of climate change?
Mostly because of ideology.
Instead of negotiating over climate change
policies and trying to make them more market-oriented, some political
conservatives have taken the approach of blocking them by trying to
undermine the science.
President Trump has sometimes claimed that scientists are engaged in a worldwide hoax to fool the public, or that global warming was invented by China
to disable American industry. The climate denialists’ arguments have
become so strained that even oil and coal companies have distanced
themselves publicly, though some still help to finance the campaigns of
politicians who espouse such views.
Part 2 What could happen?
1. How much trouble are we in?
Big trouble.
Over the coming 25 or 30 years, scientists say,
the climate is likely to gradually warm, with more extreme weather.
Coral reefs and other sensitive habitats are already
starting to die.
Longer term, if emissions rise unchecked, scientists fear climate
effects so severe that they might destabilize governments, produce
waves of refugees, precipitate the
sixth mass extinction
of plants and animals in the Earth’s history, and melt the polar ice
caps, causing the seas to rise high enough to flood most of the world’s
coastal cities. The emissions that create those risks are happening now,
raising deep
moral questions for our generation.
2. How much should I worry about climate change affecting me directly?
Are you rich enough to shield your descendants?
The simple reality is that people are already
feeling the effects, whether they know it or not. Because of sea level
rise, for instance, some 83,000 more residents of New York and New
Jersey were flooded during Hurricane Sandy than would have been the case
in a stable climate, scientists have calculated. Tens of thousands of
people are already dying in heat waves made worse by global warming. The
refugee flows that have destabilized politics around the world have
been traced in part to climate change. Of course, as with almost all
other social problems, poor people will be hit first and hardest.
3. How much will the seas rise?
The real question is how fast.
The ocean has accelerated and is now rising at a
rate of about a foot per century, forcing governments and property
owners to spend tens of billions of dollars fighting coastal erosion.
But if that rate continued, it would probably be manageable, experts
say.
The risk is that the rate will increase still
more. Scientists who study the Earth’s history say waters could rise by a
foot per decade in a worst-case scenario, though that looks unlikely.
Many experts believe that even if emissions stopped tomorrow, 15 or 20
feet of sea level rise is already inevitable, enough to
flood many cities
unless trillions of dollars are spent protecting them. How long it will
take is unclear. But if emissions continue apace, the ultimate rise
could be 80 or 100 feet.
4. Is recent crazy weather tied to climate change?
Some of it is.
Scientists have published strong evidence that the warming climate is making heat waves
more frequent and intense. It is also causing
heavier rainstorms, and coastal flooding is
getting worse as
the oceans rise because of human emissions. Global warming has
intensified droughts in regions like the Middle East, and it may have
strengthened a recent drought in California.
In many other cases, though —
hurricanes, for example
— the linkage to global warming for particular trends is uncertain or
disputed. Scientists are gradually improving their understanding as
computer analyses of the climate grow more powerful.
Part 3 What can we do?
1. Are there any realistic solutions to the problem?
Yes, but change is happening too slowly.
Society has put off action for so long that the
risks are now severe, scientists say. But as long as there are still
unburned fossil fuels in the ground, it is not too late to act. The
warming will slow to a potentially manageable pace only when human
emissions are reduced to zero. The good news is that they are now
falling in many countries as a result of programs like fuel-economy
standards for cars, stricter building codes and emissions limits for
power plants. But experts say the energy transition needs to speed up
drastically to head off the worst effects of climate change.
2. What is the Paris Agreement?
Virtually every country agreed to limit future emissions.
The
landmark deal
was reached outside Paris in December 2015. The reductions are
voluntary and the pledges do not do enough to head off severe effects.
But the agreement is supposed to be reviewed every few years so that
countries ramp up their commitments. President Trump announced in 2017
that he would pull the United States
out of the deal, though that will take years, and other countries have said they would go forward regardless of American intentions.
3. Does clean energy help or hurt the economy?
Job growth in renewable energy is strong.
The energy sources with the lowest emissions
include wind turbines, solar panels, hydroelectric dams and nuclear
power stations. Power plants burning natural gas also produce fewer
emissions than those burning coal. Converting to these cleaner sources
may be somewhat costlier in the short term, but they could ultimately
pay for themselves by heading off climate damages and reducing health
problems associated with dirty air. And expansion of the market is
driving down the costs of renewable energy so fast that it may
ultimately beat dirty energy on price alone — it
already does in some areas.
The transition to cleaner energy certainly
produces losers, like coal companies, but it also creates jobs. The
solar industry in the United States now employs more than twice as many
people as coal mining.
4. What about fracking or ‘clean coal’?
Both could help clean up the energy system.
Hydraulic fracturing, or “fracking,” is one of a
set of drilling technologies that has helped produce a new abundance of
natural gas in the United States and some other countries. Burning gas
instead of coal in power plants reduces emissions in the short run,
though gas is still a fossil fuel and will have to be phased out in the
long run. The fracking itself can also create local pollution.
“Clean coal”
is an approach in which the emissions from coal-burning power plants
would be captured and pumped underground. It has yet to be proven to
work economically, but some experts think it could eventually play a
major role.
5. What’s the latest with electric cars?
Sales are still small overall, but they are rising fast.
The cars draw power at night from the electric
grid and give off no pollution during the day as they move around town.
They are inherently more efficient than gasoline cars and would
represent an advance even if the power were generated by burning coal,
but they will be far more important as the electric grid itself becomes
greener through renewable power. The cars are improving so fast that
some countries are already talking about
banning the sale of gasoline cars after 2030.
6. What are carbon taxes, carbon trading and carbon offsets?
It’s just jargon for putting a price on pollution.
The greenhouse gases being released by human
activity are often called “carbon emissions” for short. That is because
two of the most important gases, carbon dioxide and methane, contain
carbon. (Some other pollutants are lumped into the same category, even
if they do not actually contain carbon.) When you hear about carbon
taxes, carbon trading and so on, these are just shorthand descriptions
of methods to put a price on emissions, which economists say is one of
the most important steps society could take to limit them.
7. Climate change seems so overwhelming. What can I personally do about it?
Start by sharing this with 50 of your friends.
Experts say the problem can only be
solved
by large-scale, collective action. Entire states and nations have to
decide to clean up their energy systems, using every tool available and
moving as quickly as they can. So the most important thing you can do is
to exercise your rights as a citizen, speaking up and demanding change.
You can also take direct personal action to
reduce your carbon footprint in simple ways that will save you money.
You can plug leaks in your home insulation to save power, install a
smart thermostat, switch to more efficient light bulbs, turn off unused
lights, drive fewer miles by consolidating trips or taking public
transit, waste less food, and eat less meat.
Taking one or two
fewer plane rides
per year can save as much in emissions as all the other actions
combined. If you want to be at the cutting edge, you can look at buying
an electric or hybrid car or putting solar panels on your roof. If your
state has a competitive electricity market, you may be able to buy 100
percent green power.
Leading corporations, including large
manufacturers like carmakers, are starting to demand clean energy for
their operations. You can pay attention to company policies, support the
companies taking the lead, and let the others know you expect them to
do better.
These personal steps may be small in the scheme
of things, but they can raise your own consciousness about the problem —
and the awareness of the people around you. In fact, discussing this
issue with your friends and family is one of the most meaningful things
you can do.
Links
