22/03/2019

Study Shows IPCC Is Underselling Climate Change

Phys.org - University of Adelaide

Credit: CC0 Public Domain


A new study has revealed that the language used by the global climate change watchdog, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), is overly conservative – and therefore the threats are much greater than the Panel's reports suggest.
Published in the journal BioScience, the team of scientists from the University of Adelaide, Flinders University, the University of Bristol (UK), and the Spanish National Research Council has analysed the language used in the IPCC's Fifth Assessment Report (from 2014).
"We found that the main message from the reports—that our society is in climate emergency—is lost by overstatement of uncertainty and gets confused among the gigabytes of information," says lead author Dr. Salvador Herrando-Pérez, from the University of Adelaide's Environment Institute and Australian Centre for Ancient DNA.
"The IPCC supports the overwhelming scientific consensus about on climate change, so we would expect the reports' vocabulary to be dominated by greater certainty on the state of climate science—but this is not the case."
The IPCC assigns a level of certainty to climate findings using five categories of confidence and ten categories of probability. The team found the categories of intermediate certainty predominated, with those of highest certainty barely reaching 8% of the climate findings evaluated.
"The accumulation of uncertainty across all elements of the complexity means that the IPCC tends to be conservative," says co-author Professor Corey Bradshaw, Matthew Flinders Fellow in Global Ecology at Flinders University. "The certainty is in reality much higher than even the IPCC implies, and the threats are much worse."
"Uncertainty is to science what the score is to music—but it's a two-edged sword: what the IPCC and the majority of the scientific community regard as a paradigm of rigour and transparency is exactly what the 'merchants of doubt' put forward as a weakness," says Dr. Herrando-Pérez.
"However, climatic uncertainties are nothing but an expression of the climate risks we face, and should inspire action rather than indifference."
The team says the IPCC reports should incorporate a clear connection between the certainty of thousands of scientific findings and the certainty that humans are vastly altering the Earth's . The team recommends a new IPCC working group of communication specialists to oversee the language and effective dissemination, and convey the message accurately.
"Our tells us Earth will ultimately survive more aridity, more hurricanes, more floods, more , more extinctions and degraded ecosystems, but our society as we know it today might not unless we clearly articulate the magnitude of the threat it poses," says Dr. Herrando-Pérez.

Links

Tim Flannery: People Are Shocked About Climate Change But They Should Be Angry

The Guardian

The author and scientist, who has returned to his roots at the Australian Museum, says the world is about to see a major shift towards climate action
Tim Flannery: ‘We’re in a different world now, a world where people are living with climate change consequences’ Photograph: Carly Earl/The Guardian
Tim Flannery laments that young Australians today will never be able to experience in the same way the natural wonders he enjoyed in his youth.
He grew up in Melbourne on remnants of the sandplain flora, “one of the great floristic gems of Australia,” he says. Once smothered in flowers in springtime, it has now largely been lost through development and altered burning regimes. Flannery, 63, spent his youth swimming and scuba diving in northern Port Phillip bay, which he says is now also gravely deteriorated.
He further points to the Great Barrier Reef, which suffered unprecedented mass bleaching in 2016 and 2017 and the “serious questions” about whether it can now be saved. “Something like 70% of the reef that was there a century ago is now dead,” he says.
But without detailed records on species distributions, it’s impossible to map the losses due to climate change, explains Flannery, who recently returned to the 192-year-old Australian Museum in Sydney, where he was principal mammalogist from 1984–1999.
Rather than being “a fusty old relic” the museum is playing a vital role in this, he says. “The collections that say where things were, and when, are here – and that’s the most important asset we’ve got to understand the response of biodiversity to climate change … The people of New South Wales need to understand what a valuable asset they have.”
We can claw back some of the damage [from climate change]. We will go through 2C, but hopefully come out the other side
Tim Flannery
Flannery – who has named more than 30 new mammals over his career and was the Australian government’s climate commissioner from 2011–2013 – relocated to Sydney in January for the year-long role as a distinguished research fellow. This position, as the museum’s de facto climate change ambassador, was funded by anonymous private donors.
While species loss is heartbreaking, Flannery says what keeps him awake at night worrying are the human impacts.
“Global hunger has increased for the last three years because of extreme weather events, and that follows many decades of improvement,” he says. “To see that going backwards is terrifying, quite frankly. Nothing is more important than global food security.”
Bringing attention to the plight of those suffering the effects of climate change, such as Australia’s Pacific Islander neighbours, is one of a series of goals he has set for his time at the museum.
Tim Flannery: ‘The collections … are the most important asset we’ve got to understand the response of biodiversity to climate change.’ Photograph: Carly Earl/The Guardian
In 2018, Flannery sailed from the Solomon Islands to Vanuatu and the story was the same nearly everywhere. “Village after village was going underwater,” he says. Impacts ranged from lost soccer fields and crops through to devastation of villages and coral reef resources.
Younger islanders understand “Australia is partly to blame because we have done so little, and they are quite angry”, says Flannery. The goal, he says, is “a better understanding in Australia of the often-catastrophic impacts that climate change is having on our near neighbours – and with government and individual awareness we can start doing something”.
Inadequate action by governments has been brought into focus by ever-more alarming reports about the rate of warming, such as the recent long-term forecast from the UK Met Office that we might temporarily exceed 1.5C of average warming over preindustrial levels in the next five years.
Preventing warming from exceeding 1.5C in the long term was one of the targets agreed by the world’s nations in the UN’s 2015 Paris agreement.
“Sadly, I’ve been aware of [the urgency of] this for a long time,” says Flannery, who believes that breaching that threshold is inevitable in the next few decades, and that we are probably already committed to 2C of warming, “which is towards the catastrophic end of things”.
Instead of getting “dismayed and depressed”, he suggests we focus on damage that’s still within our power to avoid. “We have to reduce emissions as hard and fast as possible … [and] develop technologies that will get gigatons of carbon dioxide out of the air by 2050.”
Technologies to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere – such as giant seaweed farms and processes to accelerate weathering of silicate rocks – have been a focus of his of late. “We can claw back some of the damage. We will go through 2C, but hopefully come out the other side.”
While the debate over the science of climate change is long settled in Europe, political inertia has dogged Australia and the US, which notably pulled out the Paris accord following the election of Donald Trump.
But Flannery sees a shift in the air – particularly in the wake of climate-linked disasters including the mass bleaching events; mass fish kills on the Darling River; and droughts, heatwaves and bushfire seasons that are all increasing in duration and intensity.
“The speed and scale of impacts have been something that is really shocking,” says Flannery, who was on the Australian Academy of Science’s expert panel investigating the Darling River fish kills, and which this week laid the blame on the Murray-Darling Basin Authority for ignoring scientific advice and the threat from climate change.
“People are shocked, but … they should be angry,” he adds. “The consequences will grow year by year, and stuff we were warning people about 20 years ago is now coming to fruition and is impossible to deny, unless you are wilfully blind.
“Bullshit baffles brains, but only temporarily and we’ve gone through a period in Australia and the US where people have been able to lie … But we’re in a different world now, a world where people are living with climate change consequences, and bullshit is no longer baffling brains, and so we are about to see a big shift.”
One transformation he’s seen is farmers changing from being deniers to advocates for action. “People see extreme weather events and don’t just think this is an odd occurrence, they see it as part of the longer-term trajectory of change that’s going to bring about more and more adverse consequences unless something is done,” he says.
Earlier this year the Australian government formally noted the world’s first species to suffer extinction at the hands of climate change – the Bramble Cay melomys, a Torres Strait rodent that washed away in a storm surge caused by rising sea levels.
‘Something like 70% of the reef that was there a century ago is now dead,’ Tim Flannery says. Photograph: Climate Counciil 
Australia’s museums have a critical role to play in research and keeping collections and records that inform us about species such as this, so we can map changes and losses.
Despite this, a lack of investment has plagued many of our museums, including the Australian Museum, which put a freeze on capital expenditure in December to help cover costs of renovations to take larger touring exhibits, including one on Tutankhamun, slated for 2021.
Research staff numbers have fallen here and at other museums in recent decades “but the sort of skills that museums specialise in have never been more needed”, says Flannery, who was also previously the director of the South Australian Museum.
Examples of crucial records held at the Australian Museum include that there were once “rock wallabies on Middle Head, rufous bettongs at Rose Bay and – until the 1970s – eastern quolls at Vaucluse, the last colony on mainland Australia”, Flannery says.
He now hopes to muster the power of citizen scientists to gather data on the effects of climate change on the New South Wales environment. “Looking at the timing of when things happen – when plants bloom and when insects pupate … is one of the best ways of measuring climate change, and people can do it in their gardens,” he says.

Links

APRA Demands Banks, Insurers Act On Climate Risk

AFR - James Fernyhough

It is no longer good enough for banks, insurers and superannuation funds to disclose climate risks, they must take action to address them, the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority has warned.
APRA, the regulator charged with overseeing the soundness of Australia's financial system, said on Wednesday it would "increase its scrutiny" on how financial services companies were changing their businesses to protect themselves against the physical, regulatory and economic effects of climate change.
"The world is rapidly transitioning to a low carbon economy, driven principally by the decisions of governments, business leaders, investors and consumers. Companies that fail to respond to these forces risk being left behind," APRA's head of insurance Geoff Summerhayes said.
"Gaining an understanding of the risks is an important first step for entities, but APRA wants to see continuous improvement in how organisations disclose and manage these risks over coming years."
APRA's head of insurance Geoff Summerhayes said financial services companies must start acting to mitigate climate risk. Chris Pavlich
Mr Summerhayes' warning followed a survey of of financial services companies' attitudes to climate change. APRA probed 38 large banks, insurers and super funds on the issue. A third of respondents cited climate change as a material risk to their business, with reputational damage, flooding, regulatory changes and cyclones the top concerns.
It also closely followed a landmark speech by Reserve Bank of Australia's deputy governor Guy Debelle, in which he warned that a failure to act on climate climate change would lead to an "abrupt, disorderly" transition, with implications for monetary policy.

Links

21/03/2019

Labor To Tell Business It Won't Let Energy Policy Be Held 'Hostage'

The Guardian

Bill Shorten unveiled a 10-year plan to boost the share of renewable energy in the grid and retire coal generation.
Photograph: David Crosling/AAP 
Labor will use an energy summit convened by small business to declare it will not “be hostage to repeal politics” if it wins the coming federal election, warning it will press ahead with emissions reduction in the electricity sector even if the Liberal party won’t reconcile itself to the national energy guarantee.
Pat Conroy, the shadow assistant minister for climate and energy, will tell Wednesday’s summit Labor wants bipartisan agreement post-election, and will pursue the national energy guarantee developed by Malcolm Turnbull and Josh Frydenberg – a policy that remains popular with a number of stakeholders, including business groups, despite being dumped by Scott Morrison.
But Conroy will also use Wednesday’s outing to put business on notice, telling them an incoming Labor government will not delay policy action endlessly in a fruitless quest for bipartisanship.
“We will not allow the energy sector to be hostage to the repeal politics we saw at the turn of the decade,” Conroy will tell the summit. “Instead we will progress a 10-year energy investment plan that will deliver certainty to the energy sector through long-term contracts – contracts that will enable massive investment in new generation at the cheapest possible cost.”
Bill Shorten last November outlined Labor’s plan B in the event Labor wins the May election and the Coalition can’t be persuaded, post-election, to back its own policy with a higher emissions reduction target of 45%.
Pat Conroy will warn that Labor will press ahead with emissions reduction in the electricity sector even if the Liberal party won’t reconcile itself to the national energy guarantee. Photograph: Mike Bowers/The Guardian
Shorten committed to topping up the Clean Energy Finance Corporation to the tune of $10bn and unveiled a new $5bn fund to modernise ageing transmission infrastructure – the ramparts of a 10-year plan to boost the share of renewable energy in the grid and retire coal generation.
The Labor leader said he would use the Australian Energy Market Operator’s integrated system plan as the basis for transforming the energy system, with a Shorten government playing a hands-on role creating renewable energy zones, investing in new generation and transmission infrastructure and also in firming technologies, like batteries and gas peaking plants.
Moving away from the national energy guarantee, even though Labor has clearly telegraphed that possibility, will likely generate pushback in the business community which rallied in support of the policy which became a casualty of the conservative-led push against Turnbull’s leadership of the Liberal party.
While the Morrison government has been attempting to increase political pressure over Labor’s higher emissions reduction target, warning of the costs associated with a more rapid transition to low emissions technologies, Conroy will insist on Wednesday that Labor’s policies will deliver lower energy prices.
He says there has been an increase in wholesale electricity costs principally because of “the failure of the current government to establish and implement a stable and coherent climate and energy policy”.
“We have had nearly 5,200 megawatts of capacity retire in the last seven years, in fact nearly 4,000 megawatts of capacity has retired since August 2014,” Conroy will say.
“This has led to a tightening of the wholesale energy market as insufficient supply has been added, and this has led to black coal and gas generators increasing their share of time as the marginal generator, thereby setting the price.
“Beyond being more expensive forms of generation, the cost of black coal and gas has risen at the same time leading to higher wholesale prices.”
Conroy says Labor’s commitment to achieving 50% renewable energy and the associated investment in transmission infrastructure to make the renewable energy reliable, “will actually deliver lower power prices than what would otherwise be”.

Links

Indian Summer Monsoon Amplified Global Warming 130,000 Years Ago, Helping End Ice Age

The Conversation | 

Monsoon clouds approach in India.
Manoj Felix/Shutterstock
PhD Researcher in Climatology
The Open University
Lecturer in Ocean Biogeochemistry
The Open University
The past may be a surprisingly useful guide for predicting responses to future climate change. This is especially important for places where extreme weather has been the norm for a long time, such as the Indian subcontinent. Being able to reliably predict summer monsoon rainfall is critical to plan for the devastating impact it can have on the 1.7 billion people who live in the region.
The onset of India’s summer monsoon is linked to heat differences between the warmer land and cooler ocean, which causes a shift in prevailing wind direction. Winds blow over the Indian Ocean, picking up moisture, which falls as rain over the subcontinent from June to September.
The monsoon season can bring drought and food shortages or severe flooding, depending on how much rain falls and in what duration. Understanding how the monsoon responded to an abrupt climate transition in the past can therefore help scientists better understand its behaviour in the future.
Maharashtra, India on May 28 2010, during the dry season.
Arne Hückelheim/WikipediaCC BY
When we researched this weather system’s ancient past, we found it was highly sensitive to climate warming 130,000 years ago. Our new study published in Nature Geoscience showed that the Indian summer monsoon pulled heat and moisture into the northern hemisphere when Earth was entering a warmer climate around 130,000 years ago. This caused tropical wetlands to expand northwards – habitats that act as sources of methane, a greenhouse gas. This amplified global warming further and helped end the ice age.The rate at which today’s climate is changing is unprecedented in the geological record, but our study shows how sensitive the Indian summer monsoon was during a global transition into warming in the past and may still be.
The same view in Maharashtra, India on August 28 2010, during the monsoon season.
Arne Hückelheim/WikipediaCC BY
The monsoon rains of yesteryear
Over the last one million years, the climate fluctuated between a cold glacial – known as an ice age – and a warm interglacial as the Earth’s position relative to the sun wobbled in its orbit. The last transition from an ice age into the warm climate of the present interglacial – known as the Holocene – occurred around 18,000 years ago. This period of Earth’s history is relatively well understood, but how Earth system processes responded to these climate changes deeper in time is still something of a mystery.
A recent expedition to drill deep into the ocean floor of the Bay of Bengal gave an opportunity to reconstruct past Indian monsoon behaviour over hundreds of years before the last ice age.
Globigerinoides ruber – a species of 
microscopic foraminifera from the Indian Ocean.
Pallavi Anand, Author provided (No reuse)
Our study used these deep sea sediments from the northern Bay of Bengal to capture a direct signal of the Indian summer monsoon from 140,000 to 128,000 years ago, hidden in the fossilised shells of tiny microscopic creatures called foraminifera. These plankton species once lived in the upper ocean water column and captured the environmental conditions of the surrounding seawater in the chemical make up of their shells.
We detected the ocean surface water freshening from river discharge induced by the rains of the Indian summer monsoon from 140,000 to 128,000 years ago – a sign of the strengthening monsoon system. This occurred when the Earth was coming out of a glacial state and into the interglacial which occurred before the one we live in, separated by a single ice age. During this period – which we’ll refer to as the penultimate deglaciation – sea levels rose from six to nine metres worldwide.
Ice-core records show that Antarctica began to warm first during the penultimate deglaciation. Southern Hemisphere warming provided a source of heat and moisture which fuelled the strengthening of the Indian summer monsoon, as seen in our records of surface freshening and river runoff from the northern Bay of Bengal.
Wetland in Leh Ladakh, India.
The expansion of tropical wetlands further north released more methane to the atmosphere,
accelerating global warming.

WATHIT H/Shutterstock
During this warming period around 130,000 years ago, the Indian summer monsoon responded to southern hemisphere warming while the northern hemisphere and other monsoon systems, such as the East Asian summer monsoon – which affects modern day China, Japan and the Far East – remained in a glacial state.
The Indian summer monsoon pulled heat and moisture northwards, driving glacial melting in the northern hemisphere and helping tropical wetlands expand their range. These expanding tropical wetlands resulted in more methane release into the atmosphere which caused even more warming, setting changes in motion which ended the global ice age.
The Indian summer monsoon is an incredibly dynamic system. Though confined to the tropics, the system is sensitive to climatic conditions in both hemispheres. Due to its role in contributing to methane emissions, the Indian summer monsoon also has an outsize impact on the global climate. Monsoons should not be viewed in isolation, just as the polar ice sheets shouldn’t. Earth’s internal climate system is intrinsically linked and abrupt changes at one place can have significant consequences over time elsewhere.

Links

Climate Change To Blame For Mass Jindabyne Fish Death: Water Ecologist

FairfaxFinbar O'Mallon

A trout hatchery in the Snowy Mountains has lost 30,000 fish due to high river temperatures and low rainfall, which a water ecologist has blamed on the effects of climate change.
The NSW Department of Primary Industries, which oversees the Gaden Trout Hatchery outside of Jindabyne, confirmed the loss occurred when the Thredbo River hit temperatures of 28.5 degrees around January 26.
A Brown Trout in Lake Eildon. Credit: Justin McManus
Trout are a northern hemisphere fish and begin to stress and die at 24 to 26 degrees, a department spokeswoman said.
"Fish deaths on this scale at Gaden have not been experienced in the last 20 years," she said.
The department also blamed a lack of rainfall on the loss of the 30,000 fingerlings - baby fish - and 1000 broodstock fish, which are used for breeding.
University of Canberra Associate Professor Ben Kefford said it could be good news for native fish in the rivers who get eaten by the non-native trout.
"It will mean they have far less predation from the trout and competition for that matter," Dr Kefford said.
Dr Kefford said he had also witnessed dead trout in the Wellington River in the Victorian alps in January.
"It certainly doesn't surprise me," he said.
"It will be a consequence of a hot summer which is due to climate change and we've currently got very low flows in most of our rivers."
The low river flows were themselves attributable to a lack of rainfall.
He explained that less water meant it was easier for the heat in the air to warm that body of water up.
"If temperatures get hotter and we have increased periods of dry spells this is probably what's going to happen," he said.
Dr Kefford said trout were more susceptible to heat stress hence why they were placed out in mountain alpine streams.
While native fish had higher heat tolerances Dr Kefford said it wasn't well known what their limit was.
The department said the fingerlings lost in January represented three per cent of the entire department's annual stocking production.
"The fingerlings currently at the Gaden Hatchery are in good health and [the department's] fish stockings have continued across impoundments and streams across the state," the spokeswoman said.
"Gaden Hatchery staff did a fantastic job saving the remaining fingerlings by getting them into cooler water as soon as possible."
This summer was Australia's hottest on record with January beating previous heat records as Australians sweated through multiple heatwaves.

Links

20/03/2019

Climate Strike: Greta Thunberg Calls For ‘System Change Not Climate Change’ – Here’s What That Could Look Like

The Conversation

             Greta Thunberg leading a march in Hamburg, Germany. EPA-EFE/FOCKE STRANGMANN
Greta Thunberg, the 16-year-old Swedish climate activist, is calling for system change.
At a press conference in Brussels, she told the European Commission that in order to fight climate change we need to change our political and economic systems – a message that has been repeated on signs and in chants in the student climate strikes around the world.
The school climate strikes, which she started alone in August 2018, have become a social movement with 1,659 strikes planned for March 15 in 105 countries.
But what is system change? How do entire systems change? When we see “save the planet” initiatives, they often look like individual decisions that don’t cost much, like switching to a bamboo toothbrush or washing containers before you recycle them. By all means, do these things, but don’t confuse them with system change.


Most people don’t know how to change political, economic and social systems. They end up making token gestures instead that may even perpetuate the problem. There’s also the question of how to overcome powerful vested interests that benefit from the current system. But there is research that can help us understand system change.
Neo-institutional theory is one approach to understanding how and why people organise collectively. People create meaning, follow rules and reproduce structures – such as classrooms, businesses, offices and community halls – based on assumptions of what is right and proper. Classrooms look similar, not because each time we set one up we rationally decide how to do so, but because we make assumptions about what a classroom is supposed to look like.
Because we are part of these meaning structures, we reproduce existing norms and beliefs and resist change. System change happens when we don’t take our assumptions for granted, which allows more and more people to question the status quo.

Scanning the horizon
Thunberg is telling us that our current political and economic systems are no longer fit for purpose. She is pointing out that the emperor has no clothes.
Changing a system takes time. My research on the LGBT movement in Ireland documented efforts and achievements over 40 years. Homosexuality went from being a crime, to being celebrated in a progressive movement. While the referendum on marriage equality took one day in 2015, the efforts of many to change the system took decades.
The Three Horizons Framework can help explain the different factors that lead to changing systems. Horizon one is business as usual – the status quo – and the outgoing institution in times of change. Horizon three is the new institution – with newly legitimised structures and beliefs. The space between them is horizon two, which is occupied by people focused on social change – who lead the transition from an old system to the new.

Change can seem sudden, but usually it follows many years of changing beliefs. Sheila Cannon, Author provided

Most people recognise the problems with the present system and want to help society move to something more sustainable. Products like bamboo toothbrushes exist to monetise that concern, but because they’re sold in plastic and shipped around the world, their production and distribution still consumes fossil fuel and does nothing to change the existing economic or political system that is fuelling climate change. A collective challenge to political and economic elites is likely to be more effective in forcing this transition.
When aspects of horizon three appear – glimpses of a more sustainable system – they are usually rejected as illegitimate or too radical. When Rosa Parks sat down at the front of the bus in a move to promote civil rights in America in 1955, she was condemned. Looking back after system change has happened, these people are seen as leaders.

The end of capitalism?
The system that needs to be changed to avert climate disaster is capitalism, which is losing its legitimacy largely due to the system’s failure to respond effectively to climate change.
Applying all I’ve learned about how systems change, it’s possible to imagine that the current system which sustains business-as-usual capitalism – horizon one in the framework – is occupied by those who continue to produce, sell and consume products and services that rely on fossil fuels. That’s most of us, but horizon one is also maintained by climate deniers and investors in fossil energy, who, despite the scientific evidence, keep chugging along.
A more sustainable system could include policies we might currently consider “extreme”, like universal basic income. This is a guaranteed payment for all people regardless of their wealth which could help break the cycle of production and consumption that pollutes the atmosphere and fills the ocean with discarded plastic. Evidence suggests there is growing support for this, particularly among young people.

School students strike in Brisbane, Australia on March 15 2019. EPA-EFE/DAN PELED
Extending human rights to non-humans and even to ecosystems is another idea that seems radical today but is gaining traction and could define an alternative system in future. One thing is for sure, we’ll look back in horror one day at how humans treated the natural world, as many already do in the present.
If the climate strikers can continue to grow their movement and sustain momentum, their leadership could be an important part of society’s transition to a more sustainable system in horizon three.
Capitalism may seem permanent, but research shows that systems inevitably change over time, and are ultimately created and reinforced by us. But in order to change anything, people must question their own role in the system first.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative