Thursday, July 14, 2016

Insurers, Banks and Pensions Face Climate Change Risk: Institute

Bloomberg - 
  • Potential 'devastating risk' posed to investment portfolios
  • Banks should go green and pare ties to high carbon industries
The world's insurers, banks and pension funds are "inherently susceptible" to threats from climate change and must make adjustments, from shifting investment toward environmentally friendly industries to revamping strategies to reduce risk, said the Global Risk Institute.
"Climate change is a top priority that must be addressed systemically and without delay," concludes a report by the Toronto-based group that researches risks to the global financial services industry.
Climate change poses "a real and potentially devastating risk" to investment portfolios, including $35.4 trillion overseen by the world's pensions.
Global investment portfolios may lose up to 45 percent due to short-term shifts in climate sentiment, the institute said, citing a 2015 University of Cambridge study.
Half those losses could be avoided by reallocating portfolios, though half would be unhedgeable without system-wide action on climate change.
"To avoid financial liability and mitigate climate change-related risks, pension funds must diversify their portfolios across all sources of risk and increase allocations to low carbon technologies and green energy," the institute said.
Insurers, whose insurance losses from weather events swelled from an annual average of about $10 billion to around $50 billion in the past decade, face threats from physical events, risks tied to liability and "transition risk" from adjusting to a lower-carbon economy, the report said.
Climate change poses a direct risk to bank operations and lending, with real estate, infrastructure and agricultural businesses particularly threatened, the report said.
Banks should scale back exposure to "high carbon industries" and assets that may suffer in tackling climate change and pursue "new green opportunities" in commercial and investment banking, according to the report.

Links

93 Percent Of Public Companies Face Climate Risk; Only 12 Percent Have Disclosed It

Forbes - Jeff McMahon

Shutterstock

Almost all U.S. publicly traded companies face risk either from climate change itself or from the changes needed to fend it off, experts agreed Monday at the S&P Global offices in New York—but few companies have warned their investors.
Some executives seem to be in denial, while other executives may not have any idea how to assess climate risk, according to panelists convened by the international Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures.
"If you look at the boards maybe they don't have the expertise to assess climate risk and opportunities," said Diane Larsen, Americas assurance markets leader for Ernst & Young. "So then this is about good governance. How do we get that expertise, how do we bring it on board?"
The Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) chaired by Michael Bloomberg reported in December that 93 percent of American public companies face some degree of climate risk, and only 12 percent have disclosed it.
The SASB report was overlooked by news organizations at the time, perhaps with so much news breaking from the Paris Climate Conference. Bloomberg himself was in Paris, announcing the formation of the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures, which he also chairs.
"Make no mistake, climate change means business," wrote SASB CEO Jean Rogers. "It affects 93 percent of the U.S. equity market, representing $33.8 trillion market capitalization. As we've said before, because climate risk is systemic and embedded across a portfolio, investors can't diversify away from it."
Those 93 percent of companies could face "transition risks" as the world shifts to a low-carbon economy, including declining revenues, stranded assets, asset write-downs, impairment charges, and changes in cash flow.
To prepare for those risks, investors need information on companies' future emissions profiles, capital-expenditure plans and risk-management plans, the panelists said. Investors need to know who is responsible for assessing risk at each company, how they're doing it, and how far they've gotten.
Mike Wilkens of S&P called on companies to prepare carbon stress tests, calculating revenues and cash flows under different emissions limits and carbon prices.
Among the companies that seem to be in denial, Wilkens singled out American oil majors. Unlike their European counterparts, some American oil companies continue to predict, at least publicly, that oil demand will continue to grow, he said.
"I'm not entirely sure what planet they're living on because clearly there is a second- or possibly third-generation renewables revolution happening at the moment," said Wilkins, the global head of environmental and climate risk research for S&P Global.
If the world is to limit global warming to 2ÂșC, then fossil fuel demand has to fall, added Mark Lewis, the head of European utilities equity research for Barclays.
"Over the next 25 years the global fossil fuel industry in our view would stand to lose $33 trillion of revenue compared with a business-as-usual scenario," Lewis said, citing a Barclay's analysis that also came out last December. Most of those lost revenues, he added, are oil revenues.
The use of fossil fuels for energy, transportation and industry accounts for about 70 percent of anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions, Lewis said, so those sectors seem most vulnerable.
But climate risk is spread across the market, can come from unforseen directions, including storm damage and coastal flooding, and companies outside of the energy sector may be less prepared to assess it.
"I think the first step, in terms of baby steps, is to acknowledge the possibility that there is a risk or an opportunity out there—there could be opportunities," said Diane Larsen, "and then bake that into a process, you know, do an assessment, figure out what it means.
"There could be real significant financial impact to the organization, and the governance structure of that company needs to really understand that impact and when will that impact come home to roost."
If the companies don't do it, the panel suggested, it will get done another way.
"If you don't use a reasonable assumption for your climate policies and your climate risk, then the market will do it for you," Lewis said. "And then ultimately you're going to be at the mercy of the market, which most companies don't want to be."
The Dutch pension firm PGGM is shifting $20 billion in assets based on four "megatrends" that it believes will affect the value of companies going forward: climate change, water security, food security, and access to health care.
"We have started divesting from those companies with the highest carbon footprint," said Eloy Lindeijer, PGGM's chief of investment management, "and then reinvesting those funds on a country- and sector-neutral basis with those companies that have a better performance in that field."

Links

Australia’s Energy Sector Is In Critical Need Of Reform

The Conversation - 

Australia’s power policies still aren’t heading in quite the right direction. AAP Image/Mick Tsikas
Over the next few decades Australia, like many countries, faces the prospect of an energy transformation that will challenge every aspect of stationary and transport energy: from production, transmission and distribution to consumption and exports.
The ultimate imperative is to move our economy to a low-carbon footing, while ensuring that consumers don’t pay unnecessarily high costs. The COAG Energy Council, the decision-making body of federal and state energy and resources ministers, formally recognised the critical connection between energy and climate policy last July. Later that year the world’s governments brokered the Paris climate agreement, with Australia promising to cut emissions to 26-28% below 2005 levels by 2030.
Yet this need for wholesale transformation has emerged at a time when Australia’s policy structures are already struggling to maintain the delivery of affordable and reliable electricity, after the reforms of the 1990s lost momentum in the 2000s.
It also comes at the end of a three-year period in which the Coalition government’s actions to address these challenges made modest progress at best. Tony Abbott’s administration repealed the carbon price, wound back the Renewable Energy Target and established the Emissions Reduction Fund (ERF), which has contracted for more than 100 million tonnes of CO₂ emission reductions at less than A$14 per tonne. But it largely sidestepped the reforms needed to address emerging energy trends such as low demand growth, the rise of distributed wind power generation, the boom in domestic solar power and the dramatic growth of coal seam gas.
The upshot was that 2013-16 has left the energy industry with huge uncertainty about what is in store, at a time when it craves reassurance more than ever.
This leaves the new government with three key priorities. As elsewhere, its capacity to deliver will be constrained by the reality of the new parliament.
The first priority will be to build on its current climate change policy to create a stable, long-term approach that will lead the transition to a low-emissions economy. The government will be able to do this through a combination of administrative action and bipartisan support.
The second priority is to revive energy market reform through the COAG Energy Council. The third is to maximise the value of Australia’s gas resources and ensure continuity of supply.
These are not politically partisan issues but they do require galvanising cooperation across state and territory governments.
In addition, the government should develop a renewed reform agenda for the COAG Energy Council – one that addresses all these issues with a focus on outcomes, rather than being mired in process as it has been so far.

Climate policy
For most of this century Australia has lacked a credible, long-term climate policy. Instead we have had toxic debate, policy bonfires and a mishmash of unstable and unpredictable federal and state policies that have threatened industry investment, not to mention the environment itself.
Existing government policy (the ERF and its new safeguard mechanism, plus the reduced Renewable Energy Target) is likely to be enough to meet Australia’s 2020 emissions target – a 5% reduction on 2000 levels by 2020 – but far from enough to meet the stronger 2030 target, or indeed to get us to zero net emissions thereafter.

An economy-wide carbon market is the best way to cut emissions and meet Australia’s targets without excessive cost to the economy. But in the absence of the political will to implement this, we must work with what we have.
The government should therefore strengthen the safeguard mechanism, which puts pollution limits on 140 of Australia’s biggest-emitting businesses, so that it becomes an effective market mechanism. This approach has the potential to gain the bipartisan support that energy companies seek as they consider investments in long-lived assets.
Technologies that might produce plentiful low-emission electricity will still be expensive and risky in the short term. To overcome these market barriers, the government will need to expand its existing clean energy research funding to reduce the costs of moving to a low-emissions economy.

Electricity reform
Energy market reform began in the early 1990s but stalled in the 2000s. Privatisation became politicised and governments baulked at introducing electricity prices that more closely reflect the costs of producing power. Meanwhile, prices climbed by 60% in real terms for all customers.
The government should work through the COAG Energy Council to push for network privatisation and tariff reform, with the goal of delivering fairer and cheaper electricity bills.
In reforming power networks, two issues come first.
The process for defining the costs that networks can recover from customers takes too long and encourages networks to overspend. It must be overhauled.
Second, governments must decide who will pay for surplus network infrastructure that was built to meet overly cautious reliability standards and exaggerated demand forecasts. This “gold-plating” is one of the main causes of power price rises over the past decade.

Network infrastructure has been built to meet the peak demand that occurs only once every summer in most states, yet customers are charged on their year-round use. Pricing to reflect the cost of meeting this peak would make electricity prices fairer and cheaper for all consumers in the long term.
Federal and state governments have agreed to introduce new network tariffs from the start of 2017. But progress is slow, as the losers from policy changes have loud voices that have deterred risk-averse state ministers.
This lack of tariff reform is one of the factors (alongside the large subsidies on offer) that have prompted so many Australian households to install solar panels. By our analysis, the benefits have fallen far short of the costs so far.
Yet as solar panels and battery storage continue to get cheaper, cost-reflective network tariffs will encourage consumers to combine them fairly and effectively.
Since its creation in 1998, the National Electricity Market has helped to provide affordable, reliable and secure electricity supplies. But now it faces new challenges that were not envisaged when it was established.
Thanks to the surge in household solar and other factors, more and more electricity is now generated at zero or even negative marginal cost. A similar situation in European markets has led to serious financial losses for major energy companies in Germany. This is forcing governments in Britain, Germany and elsewhere to introduce supplementary markets for generation capacity even if it is not used.
Although Australia is not yet in this situation, the government should initiate a review of the National Electricity Market to avoid such threats arising.

Gas markets
Opening the east coast domestic gas market to international buyers has pushed up prices. These pressures are exacerbated by the lack of progress toward a transparent and liquid wholesale market and by patchwork regulation of unconventional extraction such as fracking.
The government should lead the implementation of recommendations from the recent Australian Competition and Consumer Commission’s East Coast Gas Inquiry to create a more effective and efficient market. Reverting to protectionism by reserving a proportion of gas for domestic use is not the answer; in the long run this would reduce the availability of domestic gas and drive up prices, while also reducing export revenue.

Fixing the COAG Energy Council
A recent review of how Australia’s energy markets are governed identified problems with the COAG Energy Council and the operation of the government agencies that implement its decisions.
In a way this serves as a neat illustration of the problems facing the government if it is going to get energy policy right. Governance, rules, regulations and policy settings are desperately dry issues. But if Australia gets them right, the problems people really care about – like expensive energy bills and climate change – will be much easier to solve.

Links

Post Poll: Climate & Energy Leadership Needed To Repair Trust & Seize Opportunities

Climate Institute



It is time for federal politicians to show leadership on climate change, not just because it is urgent and the vast majority of Australians, as well as mainstream business, see it as necessary, but because its politicisation is one of the main issues that have eroded public trust in our political process, The Climate Institute said today.
“It is critical that both major parties now act on community and business calls for maturity and leadership on climate and energy policy,” said Climate Institute CEO, John Connor. “Allowing climate and clean energy reforms to succumb to extreme views in the Senate, or to be relegated to the too hard basket, would be gross recklessness for Australia and is entirely avoidable.”
“The overwhelming majority of Australians, including Coalition and regional citizens, grasp the economic, social and environmental opportunities of tackling climate change and reforming the energy sector,” he said. “Politicians, business and the public can and must work better together to achieve solid, constructive progress that will be for the betterment and safety of our country.”
National polling in early June showed two thirds of Australians want our country to be a world leader in finding solutions to climate change, the highest since 2008. An overwhelming majority also think tackling climate change will create opportunities for jobs and investment. Concern about climate change among Coalition voters surged 50 per cent since the 2013 election from 41 to 62 per cent. Concern among regional Australians jumped from 48 per cent to 73 per cent. Tellingly, a mere 17 and 20 per cent of Australians think The Coalition and Labor, respectively, have effective plans to tackle climate change. Only 26 and 27 per cent of voters trust that Malcolm Turnbull and Bill Shorten, respectively, are concerned about addressing climate change.
“Mainstream business has joined welfare, environment and union groups in urging the integration of climate and energy policies, recognising the need for net zero emissions while citing legitimate concerns about international competitiveness and highlighting the costs of piecemeal action,” Connor said. “While this election has delivered a challenging Parliament, it hasn’t delivered an excuse for inaction – it has delivered a stark choice between a perhaps surprising political centre, including mainstream business, and extreme views on climate action.”
The Institute’s research during the 2016 election found that four out of the five lower house crossbenchers support credible climate action, with Bob Katter at least supportive of renewable energy projects. Like the Nick Xenophon Team, Derryn Hinch supports 2030 emission reduction targets recommended by the Climate Change Authority and a target of 50 per cent renewable energy by 2030. Hinch also supports a plan for the phase-out of coal-burning power before 2035, making sure affected workers and communities are supported in the transition.
“It is a matter of fact that The Coalition, Labor, The Greens and Nick Xenophon Team now all support emissions trading and renewable energy, albeit to varying degrees,” Connor said. “Labor and the Greens have stronger policies, but both Labor and the Coalition share support for the Paris climate agreement’s goals of net zero emissions and keeping global warming well below 2 degrees, as well as the pursuit of the optimal 1.5°C goal.”
“As we recommended in our election assessment, The Coalition and Labor can move to close the gap between their policy positions and the expectations of the community and business with three steps: 1) Pre 2050 net zero emission objectives, with credible emission reduction pathways and regular independent processes of review; 2) Economic and community strategies to manage the transition to decarbonisation, and; 3) Integration of climate risks and opportunity assessments into core decision making.”
“Australia has a 2017 federal climate policy review that provides the opportunity for an inclusive, evidence-based, solutions-driven process. Meanwhile, investors, leading businesses and the states and territories should not allow themselves to be left behind in the accelerating global shift to clean energy and innovative, net zero and below economies,” Connor said. “Australians wants real, credible action on climate change - delay by our politicians will further erode Australia’s prosperity and safety, as well as public trust.”

Links

Wednesday, July 13, 2016

Cutting The Cable: Kangaroo Island Eyes Switch To 100% Renewable Energy

The Guardian - 

Australia's third-biggest island could combine wind, solar, PV and battery storage to fuel own electricity needs – and set a blueprint for the rest of the country 
Admiral Arch on Kangaroo Island in Flinders Chase national park. Photograph: Alamy
Kangaroo Island is one of the great icons of Australian tourism. As Andrew Boardman, the chief executive of the Kangaroo Island council, says: "You can't buy a name like that."
But now the third-biggest island in Australia, which lies just 120kms from Adelaide, wants to make its mark in a different way: by supplying 100% of its electricity needs and much of its transport fuels through locally sourced renewable energy.
The island is calling for proposals that could use a mixture of its local resources – solar power, wind energy, biomass and even ocean energy – and combine those with battery storage, smart software and the existing diesel back-up. Even more dramatically, it is also supporting a push to cut the island from the mainland grid.
Indeed, the move has been prompted by a need to update and replace the ageing cable that currently supplies electricity from the mainland.
South Australian Power Networks has called for "alternative proposals". If someone can come up with a proposal that matches the $45m to $50m replacement cost of the cable, then they will consider it. They aim to make a decision by the end of the year.
Boardman says: "100% renewable is a very real, very clear target ... Technology is not the issue. We have got solar, wind, wave, tidal, biomass. There is nothing we can't really do."
If the idea works, Boardman says, it could make the island – with a population of 4,600 and 200,000 visitors each year – the first in Australia to be entirely reliant on its own renewable resources for electricity and transport. It could provide a blueprint for others to follow.
Other islands, such as King Island and Lord Howe Island, have or are about to install significant renewable and battery storage arrays but still rely on fossil fuels for 20% to 30% of their electricity needs.
"We could create a centre of excellence," Boardman says. "If we can make it work on Kangaroo Island, it is transferable for other areas."
Boardman says the island has received a "phenomenal response" to the call-out for alternatives and the council has teamed up with the Institute of Sustainable Futures in Sydney to help find the best alternative.
ISF director Chris Dunstan says the institute got involved because he saw the Kangaroo Island tender as an opportunity too important to miss.
"It's not just about deferring spending on networks for a year or two, it's about a whole new energy paradigm," Dunstan says.
He and Boardman are hoping that South Australian Power Networks allows more time for alternative proposals to be put together, which is why the ISF has stepped in to push the idea that there are good alternatives to simply laying a new cable.
Earlier this year, ISF put together a tentative plan that proposes 8MW of wind turbines, 4MW of centralised solar photovoltaics (PV) and 4MW of rooftop PV, with about 3MW battery storage, most of it co-located with solar PV.
This would be combined with energy efficiency measures and continuing the small diesel plant, which would account for just 3% of the load. Dunstan estimates the set-up could cut bills on the island by 30% but his team is also looking at other ideas.
Boardman wants to go one step further and use 18,000 hectares of blue gum plantations – the legacy of investment by the since-failed plantation company Great Southern Plantations – as feedstock for a renewable biofuel.
That could be used to replace the six million litres of diesel it imports at high cost from the mainland each year, as well as providing electricity and waste heat, and the power needed to desalinate water.
There is little else to do with the plantations, he says, as there is no port to export the wood back to the mainland.
And he is keen to play on the island's reputation as an eco-tourism destination. The council already has three Nissan Leaf electric vehicles for hire and six re-charging stations through the island.
The island is encouraging more electric vehicles and Boardman talks of creating the world's first renewable energy-powered "electric vehicle tourism highway", linking the island with Adelaide via the Fleurieu Peninsula. The island already has 50kW of rooftop solar installed on its airport and another 14kW on the council chambers.
Boardman says there is no doubt that the technology is there but he has concerns about other issues such as who runs an island-only grid and who do they answer to? And, in 25 to 30 years' time, when some of the technology needs replacing, who will pay for that? Another potential factor may be the pairing of fibre optic cable with a new electricity cable. Digital isolation is also a major consideration.
Whether the cable is cut or not, Boardman says that the island will need to upgrade its local network anyway. It features a series of "thin wires" or single-wire earth return lines built in the 1960s that no longer have the capacity to meet future demand. He envisages a series of linked micro-grids that can exploit local resources and increase reliability.
And, if the cable is not cut, Boardman sees opportunities for using that cable to export power from the island back to the mainland, taking advantage of its local energy resources, including the eucalypt plantation.
"If we can show that renewable energy is technically and economically viable for Kangaroo Island, it would be a powerful precedent for communities around Australia who are seeking to develop their own renewable energy."

Links

This ‘Other’ Form Of Solar Energy Can Run At Night, And It Just Got A Big Backer

Climate Progress - Joe Romm

Nevada's Crescent Dunes concentrating solar thermal plant went online last September. It is 110 Megawatt with 10 hours of built in storage. CREDIT: PHOTO BY AMBLE VIA WIKIMEDIA COMMONS
Converting sunlight directly into electricity, the photovoltaic (PV) solar panel industry has dominated the solar generation market recently because of its astounding price drops. Prices have fallen 99 percent in the past quarter century and over 80 percent since 2008 alone. This has also helped to slow the growth of the “other” form of solar, concentrating solar thermal power (CSP), which uses sunlight to heat water and uses the steam to drive a turbine and generator.
Fortunately, one country appears to be making a major bet on CSP — China. SolarReserve, the company that built the Crescent Dunes plant (pictured above) recently announced a deal with the Shenhua Group, the world’s largest coal provider, to build 1,000 megawatts of CSP with storage in China. And the country as a whole has plans to build some 10,000 megawatts of CSP in the next five years.
I say “fortunately” because CSP has one huge potential advantage compared to PV. The heat it generates can be stored over 20 times more cheaply than electricity — and with far greater efficiency. So CSP’s “killer app” is that it can provide power long after the sun has set — and it doesn’t disrupt the grid when a cloud passes overhead.

CSP has several possible designs, including a power tower such as the Crescent Dunes plant (top picture), which uses movable mirrors to focus sunlight on a central tower that holds the engine, and the parabolic trough, which uses mirrors to focus sunlight on a long tube filled with a heat-storing fluid (right).
Because of its built-in cheap, efficient storage, CSP — aka Solar Thermal Electric (STE) — has the ability to directly address the “variability” or “intermittency” problem that PV has when the sun isn’t shining. As a result, the 2014 STE Technology Roadmap from the International Energy Agency (IEA) concludes that while PV could generate 16 percent of the world’s electricity by 2050, as much as 11 percent could be generated by STE at the same time.
In this scenario: “Combined, these solar technologies could prevent the emission of more than 6 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide per year by 2050 — that is more than all current energy-related CO2 emissions from the United States or almost all of the direct emissions from the transport sector worldwide today.”
But this isn’t a forecast or projection by the IEA, it is a roadmap or scenario of what could happen with the right policies and continued technology improvement. In the past decade, though, solar PV has leap-frogged the competition because of aggressive pro-PV policies by governments around the world, most especially in Germany and China.
Both of those countries embraced massive deployment programs that turned PV from an expensive renewable source with limited deployment into one of the cheapest and most rapidly expanding sources of new power in the world:
Solar’s exponentially declining costs and exponentially rising installations (the y-axis is a logarithmic scale).
One technology’s miracle is, however, another technology’s competitive nightmare. And so the question has been, will any country try to do for CSP which Germany and China (and others) did for PV — make major investments to bring CSP down the learning curve?
Both the IEA and the U.S. National Renewable Energy Lab have said that after solar PV makes a deep penetration into the electricity market, CSP will likely become more valuable. A 2014 NREL study found a CSP project with thermal storage “would add additional value of 5 or 6 cents per kilowatt hour to utility-scale solar energy in California where 33 percent renewables will be mandated in six years.”
Right now, solar PV produces power at the most valuable time — the daytime peak in electricity consumption, especially during the summer, when air conditioning use creates a huge power draw. But once solar PV hits 10 percent to 15 percent of annual electric generation in a region, it can become less valuable. The IEA projects that when that occurs, perhaps around 2030, “Massive-scale STE deployment takes off at this stage thanks to CSP plants’ built-in thermal storage, which allows for generation of electricity when demand peaks in late afternoon and in the evening, thus complementing PV generation.”
But, again, that assumes the world sees continued investments in CSP so that its price and performance steadily improve, and it can scale up quickly to become a large-scale contributor to a zero-carbon power grid.
For a while it seemed as if the United States would be that big driver, but CSP was stalled by the collapsing price of PV. Also, the reputation of CSP as “green” was harmed in this country by a shocking estimate of 28,000 birds burned a year by one CSP facility — an estimate that turned out to be no more than pure speculation. The actual number of birds burned in one year appears to be 700 — and that was before any abatement actions were taken. It turns out that just using standard strategies to ward off birds can cut that number by two thirds. And the Crescent Dunes facility built by SolarReserve (see top picture) was able to virtually eliminate bird burning entirely by changing how the mirrors were operated when in standby mode.
But the public relations damage had already been done to U.S. CSP plants. And so this May, SolarReserve announced a partnership with China’s Shenhua Group, the world’s largest coal provider, to build 1,000 megawatts of CSP with storage. The two companies explain:
The unique power dispatch capabilities of these utility scale projects will facilitate the deployment of additional wind and PV generation, while ensuring the reliability and security of the new ultra-high voltage transmission lines being constructed to bring clean, renewable power from the north and west regions of China to load centers in the east.
This is important because China had been forcing wind plants “to shut down at times to let coal power plants meet their generation quotas,” as the American Wind Energy Association explained last year. As a result, some 17 percent of potential wind generation was lost due to curtailment in 2012. The figure may be even higher today.
China has committed to prioritize the dispatch of renewable power first as part of its overall “war on coal,” as we have reported. A big increase in CSP — together with a big planned increase in pumped storage at hydropower plants — could go a very long way to enabling further reductions in coal use in China.
And, indeed, China aims to build 10,000 megawatts of CSP over the next five years (and they have over a dozen plants planned or under construction right now). If China is able to achieve even half that target, they would likely become the world’s largest deployer of CSP. Here’s a chart of current CSP from the recent “Renewables 2016 Global Status Report” by REN21, the Renewable Energy Policy Network for the 21st Century:
CREDIT: REN21
The continued expansion of CSP worldwide is crucial to reducing its costs, just as it was for wind and solar PV. Obviously, CSP has a very long way to go to catch up to PV, which hit 227 gigawatts of capacity in 2015 and continues to rise rapidly.
That said, SolarReserve CEO Kevin Smith believes that by around 2020, with the help of its Shenua deal, it can reduced the cost of the electricity it provides up to 40 percent, “well into the single digits per kilowatt-hour.” And that’s pretty good for a carbon-free source of dispatchable power — cheaper than new nuclear.
Lastly, the biggest threat to CSP in a carbon-constrained world probably may turn out to be battery technology. If batteries continue their miraculous price drops, then the need for the kind of low-cost, built in storage that CSP delivers may be reduced, especially if electric vehicles also continue their recent exponential growth leading to widespread vehicle-to-grid systems.
May the best technology win!

Links

Renewable Energy to Surpass Coal and Nuclear by 2030: 7 Key Takeaways from EIA’s Annual Energy Outlook 2016

Union of Concerned Scientists - Steve Clemmer


As a certified energy geek, I always look forward to this time of year. On July 11 and 12, the Energy Information Administration (EIA) is holding their annual conference to discuss current energy technology, market, and policy issues, and will present results from their new Annual Energy Outlook (AEO) 2016 report.
One of the headlines this year is EIA's new projections for renewable energy, which under their reference case is expected to surpass nuclear power by 2020 and coal by 2028 to become the second largest source of U.S. electricity generation after natural gas (see Figure 1 below).
Here are seven key takeaways from AEO 2016 that explain why EIA is projecting such a large increase in renewable energy this year:

1. Federal tax credits and Clean Power Plan drive growth in renewables
EIA's reference case includes the recent five-year extension of the federal production and investment tax credits for wind and solar passed by Congress in December 2015, and implementation of EPA's Clean Power Plan (CPP). While the U.S. Supreme Court put a temporary hold on the rule in February 2016 until the merits of the case are decided, EIA decided to include the CPP in the reference case because the rule has not been overturned.
Figure 1. Renewables surpass nuclear power by 2020 and coal by 2028. Renewables include wind, solar, geothermal, biomass, and hydropower. Source: EIA, Annual Energy Outlook 2016.
The federal tax credits, state renewable electricity standards (RESs), and continued cost reductions for wind and solar will drive significant growth in renewables though 2021 (Figure 1). During this time, EIA actually projects natural gas generation to decline slightly as wind and solar are more cost-effective with the tax credits.
After the CPP targets kick in 2022, EIA projects both renewables and natural gas to grow as the two most cost-effective ways (along with a modest increase in energy efficiency) for states to replace coal and comply with the CPP. These results are consistent with recent analyses by UCS, NREL and the Rhodium Group.

2. Wind and solar lead growth in renewables
The renewable energy (including wind, solar, geothermal, biomass, and hydropower) share of U.S. electricity generation grows from 13 percent in 2015 to 24 percent in 2030, and 27 percent in 2040, with almost all of the growth from wind and solar PV (Figure 2).
This is because continued cost reductions are projected for these technologies beyond the 60-70 percent cost reductions already achieved since 2009. Under EIA's reference case with the federal tax credits and CPP, U.S. wind capacity nearly doubles by 2022, reaching 144 GW, while US solar capacity grows five-fold by 2030, reaching 125 GW. Geothermal increases a significant amount in California and the Southwest, but provides a relatively small share of US electricity generation.
EIA also projects virtually no growth in hydro or biopower. Despite EIA's inaccurate assumption that all biomass feedstocks are carbon neutral, biopower is still not economically competitive with wind, solar, and natural gas.  The lack of growth in hydro and biomass is consistent with recent analyses by UCS, NREL, and Rhodium Group that include the federal tax credit extension and CPP.
Figure 2. Renewable electricity generation by fuel. Geothermal = red, biomass = gray. Source: EIA, Annual Energy Outlook 2016.
3. Renewable generation increases in all regions of the country by 2030
The biggest increases occur in the West and Plains, which have abundant, low cost wind, solar, and geothermal (Figure 3).  The Southeast also sees a big increase in solar as costs continue to fall.  The Northeast and Mid-Atlantic see a smaller increase in renewables and a bigger increase in natural gas.
The Southeast also sees a modest increase in nuclear generation due to five new reactors currently under construction or operating in Georgia, South Carolina, and Tennessee. This growth offsets a modest reduction in nuclear generation in Mid-Atlantic and Northeast states where EIA assumes a small number of existing plants will retire before their current operating licenses expire. (Note that the retirement of Diablo Canyon in California is not included as the announcement was made after EIA completed its modeling). The Midwest/Mid-Atlantic states also see the greatest reduction in coal generation and the largest increase in natural gas.
Figure 3. Renewables increase in all regions under the Clean Power Plan. Source: EIA, Annual Energy Outlook 2016.
4. Renewables generation varies under different Clean Power Plan implementation scenarios
Figure 4. Cumulative difference in generation in the CPP vs. the no CPP case. Renewables = green, natural gas =blue, and coal = black. Source: EIA, Annual Energy Outlook 2016. 
EIA projects renewable generation to increase the most if states chose rate-based rather than mass-based targets as part of their CPP compliance strategies. Broader regional trading with mass-based targets also results in more renewables, less natural gas, and less reduction in coal than the more limited trading assumed in the reference case.
Not surprisingly, in their "extended case" EIA found that continuing to increase the CPP emission reduction targets through 2040 (the current program only goes through 2030) would result in more renewables and natural gas, and less coal than the reference case.

5. Increasing renewable energy is affordable
EIA projects that average retail electricity rates would be 3 percent higher between 2025-2030 in the reference case (with the CPP) than in the no CPP case.  However, total U.S. electricity expenditures would only be 1.3 percent higher in the CPP case over the same period because EIA assumes a modest increase in energy efficiency investments to comply the CPP.
A recent analysis by UCS found that energy efficiency could make a much larger contribution to state compliance with the CPP that would result in cumulative net savings to consumers of $30.5 billion between 2016 and 2030.

6. Renewables are competitive despite lower natural gas prices
While EIA's natural gas price projection is lower in AEO 2016 than it was in AEO 2015 (Figure 5), large amounts of wind and solar are still competitive due to continued cost reductions and the federal tax credit extension.
EIA projects natural gas prices to double by 2025, due primarily to an increase in LNG exports, and greater natural gas use in the electricity and industrial sectors. The competition from renewables helps avoid greater reliance on natural gas that could increase natural gas prices even further.
Figure 5. Average Henry Hub spot prices for natural gas (2015 dollars per million Btu).
7. EIA is finally using more realistic cost assumptions for renewable energy
UCS has been an outspoken critic of EIA's pessimistic renewable energy projections and assumptions for many years. We have written several blog posts on the topic and provided input directly to EIA on a few of their analyses and as a participant on several EIA modeling working groups. We also use a modified version of EIA's National Energy Modeling System (NEMS) in-house to show how renewables could make a larger contribution to the US electricity mix at a much lower cost when using more realistic assumptions.
One of the main reasons why EIA's projections have fallen short is because they have consistently overestimated the cost of renewable energy technologies like wind and solar. They often lag a few years behind what's happening on the ground. However, this year is different. For AEO 2016, EIA finally lowered their costs for wind and solar to be more in-line with cost data from a large sample of recent projects, as documented by DOE's national labs and the national wind and solar trade associations.
In EIA's defense, their reference case for each AEO only reflects state and federal energy policies that were enacted at the time they do their projections, as discussed extensively in a recent EIA report. With Congress allowing federal renewable energy tax credits to lapse several times before extending them for relatively short periods, and states adopting and increasing renewable electricity standards (RES) many times over the past two decades years, it is somewhat understandable that EIA's projections of renewable energy development have fallen short of reality.
While future EIA conferences and AEOs may highlight different topics, I'll remember 2016 as the year EIA turned the corner to show a bright future for renewables.

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative