Climate Progress - Joe Romm
 |
| Nevada's Crescent Dunes concentrating solar thermal plant went online
last September. It is 110 Megawatt with 10 hours of built in storage. CREDIT: PHOTO BY AMBLE VIA WIKIMEDIA COMMONS |
Converting sunlight directly into electricity, the photovoltaic (PV)
solar panel industry has dominated the solar generation market recently
because of its astounding price drops. Prices have fallen 99 percent in
the past quarter century and over 80 percent since 2008 alone. This has
also helped to slow the growth of the “other” form of solar,
concentrating solar thermal power (CSP), which uses sunlight to heat water and uses the steam to drive a turbine and generator.
Fortunately, one country appears to be making a major bet on CSP —
China. SolarReserve, the company that built the Crescent Dunes plant
(pictured above) recently announced a deal with the Shenhua Group, the
world’s largest coal provider, to build 1,000 megawatts of CSP with
storage in China. And the country as a whole has plans to build some
10,000 megawatts of CSP in the next five years.
I say “fortunately” because CSP has one huge potential advantage
compared to PV. The heat it generates can be stored over 20 times more
cheaply than electricity — and with far greater efficiency. So CSP’s
“killer app” is that it can provide power long after the sun has set —
and it doesn’t disrupt the grid when a cloud passes overhead.
CSP has several possible designs, including a power tower such as the
Crescent Dunes plant (top picture), which uses movable mirrors to focus
sunlight on a central tower that holds the engine, and the parabolic
trough, which uses mirrors to focus sunlight on a long tube filled with a
heat-storing fluid (right).
Because of its built-in cheap, efficient storage, CSP — aka Solar
Thermal Electric (STE) — has the ability to directly address the
“variability” or “intermittency” problem that PV has when the sun isn’t
shining. As a result, the
2014 STE Technology Roadmap
from the International Energy Agency (IEA) concludes that while PV
could generate 16 percent of the world’s electricity by 2050, as much as
11 percent could be generated by STE at the same time.
In this scenario: “Combined, these solar technologies could prevent
the emission of more than 6 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide per year by
2050 — that is more than all current energy-related CO2 emissions from
the United States or almost all of the direct emissions from the
transport sector worldwide today.”
But this isn’t a forecast or projection by the IEA, it is a roadmap or scenario of what
could happen
with the right policies and continued technology improvement. In the
past decade, though, solar PV has leap-frogged the competition because
of aggressive pro-PV policies by governments around the world, most
especially in Germany and China.
Both of those countries embraced massive deployment programs that
turned PV from an expensive renewable source with limited deployment
into one of the cheapest and most rapidly expanding sources of new power
in the world:
 |
| Solar’s exponentially declining costs and exponentially rising installations (the y-axis is a logarithmic scale). |
One technology’s miracle is, however, another technology’s
competitive nightmare. And so the question has been, will any country
try to do for CSP which Germany and China (and others) did for PV — make
major investments to bring CSP down the learning curve?
Both the IEA and the U.S. National Renewable Energy Lab have said
that after solar PV makes a deep penetration into the electricity
market, CSP will likely become more valuable. A 2014
NREL study
found a CSP project with thermal storage “would add additional value of
5 or 6 cents per kilowatt hour to utility-scale solar energy in
California where 33 percent renewables will be mandated in six years.”
Right now, solar PV produces power at the most valuable time — the
daytime peak in electricity consumption, especially during the summer,
when air conditioning use creates a huge power draw. But once solar PV
hits 10 percent to 15 percent of annual electric generation in a region,
it can become less valuable. The IEA
projects
that when that occurs, perhaps around 2030, “Massive-scale STE
deployment takes off at this stage thanks to CSP plants’ built-in
thermal storage, which allows for generation of electricity when demand
peaks in late afternoon and in the evening, thus complementing PV
generation.”
But, again, that assumes the world sees continued investments in CSP
so that its price and performance steadily improve, and it can scale up
quickly to become a large-scale contributor to a zero-carbon power grid.
For a while it seemed as if the United States would be that big
driver, but CSP was stalled by the collapsing price of PV. Also, the
reputation of CSP as “green” was harmed in this country by a shocking
estimate of 28,000 birds burned a year by one CSP facility — an estimate
that turned out to be
no more than pure speculation.
The actual number of birds burned in one year appears to be 700 — and
that was before any abatement actions were taken. It turns out that just
using standard strategies to ward off birds can cut that number by two
thirds. And the Crescent Dunes facility built by SolarReserve (see top
picture) was able to virtually eliminate bird burning entirely by
changing how the mirrors were operated when in standby mode.
But the public relations damage had already been done to U.S. CSP plants. And so this May, SolarReserve
announced a partnership
with China’s Shenhua Group, the world’s largest coal provider, to build
1,000 megawatts of CSP with storage. The two companies explain:
The unique power dispatch capabilities of these utility
scale projects will facilitate the deployment of additional wind and PV
generation, while ensuring the reliability and security of the new
ultra-high voltage transmission lines being constructed to bring clean,
renewable power from the north and west regions of China to load centers
in the east.
This is important because China had been forcing wind plants “to shut
down at times to let coal power plants meet their generation quotas,”
as the American Wind Energy Association
explained
last year. As a result, some 17 percent of potential wind generation
was lost due to curtailment in 2012. The figure may be even
higher today.
China has committed to prioritize the dispatch of renewable power first as part of its overall “war on coal,” as we have
reported.
A big increase in CSP — together with a big planned increase in pumped
storage at hydropower plants — could go a very long way to enabling
further reductions in coal use in China.
And, indeed, China
aims to build 10,000 megawatts of CSP over the next five years (and they have
over a dozen plants
planned or under construction right now). If China is able to achieve
even half that target, they would likely become the world’s largest
deployer of CSP. Here’s a chart of current CSP from the recent “
Renewables 2016 Global Status Report” by REN21, the Renewable Energy Policy Network for the 21st Century:
 |
| CREDIT: REN21 |
The continued expansion of CSP worldwide is crucial to reducing its
costs, just as it was for wind and solar PV. Obviously, CSP has a very
long way to go to catch up to PV, which hit 227 gigawatts of capacity in
2015 and continues to rise rapidly.
That said, SolarReserve CEO Kevin Smith believes that by around 2020,
with the help of its Shenua deal, it can reduced the cost of the
electricity it provides up to 40 percent, “
well into the single digits per kilowatt-hour.” And that’s pretty good for a carbon-free source of dispatchable power — cheaper than
new nuclear.
Lastly, the biggest threat to CSP in a carbon-constrained world
probably may turn out to be battery technology. If batteries continue
their miraculous price drops,
then the need for the kind of low-cost, built in storage that CSP
delivers may be reduced, especially if electric vehicles also continue
their recent exponential growth leading to widespread
vehicle-to-grid systems.
May the best technology win!
Links