The current presidential administration in the US has proposed to
almost completely eliminate funding for programs aimed at researching
and reducing the effects of climate change.
The Environmental Protection
Agency faces a cut of 31% or roughly $2.4 billion and almost 4,000
jobs.
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration could be cut
by a potential 17% which
would specifically eliminate $510 million (or ~22%) of their satellite
division.
These cuts would likely encompass climate programs like
EnergyStar, SmartWay, fuel emission standards, and weather warning
systems.
Let's look at 8 ways climate change poses risks, or potential risks, to our health and safety.
1. Extreme weather puts your safety at risk, especially when we cannot plan ahead.
Rising global average temperatures are linked to widespread changes
in weather patterns and an increase in the frequency and intensity of
weather events like heat waves, and rain or snow storms. Around 2.1 million acres
were burned by wildfires in the first 3 months of 2017, three times the
amount lost in the previous year. Massachusetts saw its first tornado since it began documenting weather patterns in the 1600s.
In many areas across the globe, like the northeastern US, we have
become accustomed to snowstorms that drop more than 20 inches of snow
each winter, but such blizzards
were once rare. Not only can extreme storms be inherently dangerous,
but their risk is compounded by cuts to satellite programs that are
tasked with tracking weather patterns. Without enough funding to
maintain existing satellites and for improving and adapting models of
weather phenomena, our ability to accurately forecast and thus plan
ahead for extreme weather events is significantly hindered.
2. Climate change puts our fresh water supply at risk.
As an astronomer, I can tell you that nothing is deemed more vital to our existence than water.
As an astronomer, I can tell you that nothing is deemed more
vital to our existence than water. When we discover a new planet, the
first question we ask is always, could there be water?
Rising temperatures and extreme weather events like droughts will
clearly place water supplies at risk. According to the US Geological
Survey, while surface water can recover
with just a few days of heavy rain, groundwater aquifers like those
tapped during the recent Californian drought can take decades to
replenish. Droughts also lead to drier conditions which put land at
higher risk for wildfires. In the US, you can check the level of fire danger in your area thanks to the National Park Service and the National Fire Danger Rating System.
But too much rain can also be a problem for our water supply.
Flooding from heavy rains can cause sewage to overflow and contaminate
drinking water. Earlier this year 1.5 million people were without water in Santiago
because mudslides and flooding caused by heavy rain contaminated the
Maipo River, a major source of drinking water. The rising sea levels
linked to rising global temperatures also threaten to groundwater used
for drinking with contamination from saltwater. One program that helps
US coastal communities in 33 states deal with flooding, the NOAA's Sea Grant program, faces drastic cuts in the newly proposed budget.
Let us also not forget that as water becomes scarcer, water bills
will go up, which may force some of us to make budget cuts in other
areas of our lives, even if that involves risk.
3. Food production could be disrupted leading to higher prices.
With some areas facing increased flooding and others enduring longer
droughts, food production could be significantly disrupted with the
onset of climate change. Some areas may become too hot for crops that
have grown there easily in the past. Too little water would cause
problems for irrigation while too much water in the form of rainstorms
could damage crops.
According to the National Resources Defense Council, 25% of the the honey bee population
has disappeared since 1990, in large part due to shrinking habitats,
or, in other words, a loss in areas with temperatures and conditions
suitable for bees to survive. Having fewer bees poses a further threat
to at least 30% of the world's crops which rely on bees for
cross-pollination, crops like apples, almonds, pumpkins, onions, and
avocados. On the flip side, some plants, like crop-harming weeds, as
well as certain pests that thrive in hotter temperatures may see
population booms, stealing resources from food crops.
4. Many allergens and disease carrying insects will thrive under the changing climate.
Among the pests that will thrive under the high temperatures and
higher levels of carbon dioxide that are associated with climate change,
ticks and poison ivy rank highly. Studies have shown that while the
average tree will grow 8% faster in a climate with high levels of carbon
dioxide, poison ivy grows 149% faster.
Scientists have already observed the poison ivy/oak/sumac populations
to be stronger, leading to more intense rashes. As a sufferer of poison
ivy myself, I know that each emergency trip to the doctor following an
encounter with the plant can also cost a pretty penny.
Tick populations are also booming in the US and the number of reported cases of Lyme disease has doubled since 1990. Warmer temperatures have lead to ticks moving farther and farther north expanding their geographic reach.
5. Microbes may be forced to adapt.
The impact climate change will have on microbes, including bacteria
and eukaryotes, is complex and, unfortunately, has not yet been
thoroughly studied. However, research
has shown that microbe communities tend to adapt rather than resist
rising temperatures and thus change their composition and function. We
know that microbes play critical roles in human health and the health of
certain plants, and so that adaptation may prove detrimental whether
the microbes are "good" or "bad" for us. They also produce much of the
air that we breathe, and so their possible extinction is worth
investigating.
6. Infrastructure and the safety it provides are at risk under extreme weather. $50 billion of federal aid was spent in the US to rebuild after Hurricane Sandy shook the northeastern US, Canada and the Caribbean and caused
at least 147 deaths.
Almost 164,000 residents in Connecticut, New York, and
New Jersey applied for federal assistance from FEMA.
Extreme weather
events threaten not only our personal property, but the roads, bridges,
sidewalks, highways, and other infrastructure that we rely on to keep us
safe.
7. Energy may be both more in demand and harder to produce.
We know
that our methods of energy production via coal and fossil fuels
increase the level of carbon dioxide in the air and thus contribute to
rising global temperatures. But, as reported
by the US Department of Energy in 2013, the effects of climate change,
including increasing temperatures, decreasing water supply, extreme
weather, and sea level rise, will in term affect our ability to produce
and transmit electricity from these and other, renewable methods.
For example, energy production from coal, nuclear power, natural
gas, and of course hydroelectric power, all require high water use and
may be significantly affected by drought. Drought, along with increasing
temperatures, also lead to increased consumption of energy, for
example, to run an air conditioner, and so can overload electrical grids
causing blackouts. Just as transportation infrastructure is at risk
from extreme weather, so is energy-related infrastructure like power
lines, transformers, and power plants.
8. Climate change poses a threat to national security.
Beyond our safety as individuals, climate change poses a potential threat to global and national security. In a 2010 report
from the US Joint Forces Command called the Joint Operating
Environment, climate change is named as a national security threat
likely to face the US military over the following 25 years.
According to officials of the United Nations,
"stronger storms, rising seas, drought, famine, and the migration these
events cause could each be the spark to ignite many potential conflicts
smoldering around the world, prompting wars and destabilizing
governments."
As part of his Senate hearing, US Defense Secretary James Mattis testified
that "climate change is impacting stability in areas of the world where
our troops are operating today." Humanitarian crises like typhoons and
famine due to drought also become more challenging to respond to in the
face of climate change.
And just as our infrastructure related to transportation and
energy production are at risk, so is that of our military. For example,
Hampton Roads, Virginia has the largest number
of military bases of any city in the world, but it is already
experiencing rapid sea level rise. Flooding could not only disrupt
operations, but also damage critical infrastructure.
The US is large and covers a range of climate diversity. Thus,
the impacts of climate change here will be many. However, our planet's
climate is globally shared and so the extent of climate change in the US
will ultimately depend on the strength cooperative efforts like those between European Union and China.
An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth to Power NYT Critic's Pick Directed by Bonni Cohen, Jon Shenk Documentary PG 1h 38m
Al Gore visiting Tacloban City in the Philippines after Typhoon Haiyan, from "An Inconvenient Sequel."Credit
Jensen Walker/Paramount Pictures
In
a summer movie landscape with Spider-Man, a simian army waging further
battle for the planet and Charlize Theron as a sexy Cold War-era
superspy, it says something that one of the most compelling characters
is Al Gore. "An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth to Power," a follow-up to "An Inconvenient Truth,"
Davis Guggenheim's Oscar-winning documentary from 2006, is a reboot
that justifies its existence — and not just because Mr. Gore has fresh
news to report on climate change since his previous multimedia presentation played in multiplexes.
Now
gray-haired and at times sounding angrier in his speeches, Mr. Gore, in
"Sequel," takes on the air of a Shakespearean figure, a man long cast
out of power by what he casually refers to as "the Supreme Court
decision" (meaning Bush v. Gore) but still making the same arguments
that have been hallmarks of his career.
If there is a thesis in this new documentary, directed by Bonni Cohen and Jon Shenk ("Audrie & Daisy"), it's that a rise in extreme weather is making the impact of climate change harder to deny. The movie touches on Hurricane Sandy, Typhoon Haiyan in the Philippines, the wildfire in Fort McMurray, Canada, and the Zika virus. Mr. Gore visits Greenland and the flooded streets of the Miami area. (He acknowledges a complicated relationship with Florida.)
A preview of the film. By PARAMOUNT PICTURES
"The dots are seldom connected in the media," he says at one point, but events like these are symptoms of global warming.
As positive developments, he notes the 2015 launch of the Deep Space Climate Observatory satellite, and visits a small city in Texas whose Republican mayor has decided that renewable energy makes market sense.
"An
Inconvenient Sequel" delves deeper into the arcane details of
compromise than its predecessor, with scenes of Mr. Gore working to find
a middle ground between the needs of developed and developing nations.
In a group meeting, Piyush Goyal, India's power minister, pushes back
against Mr. Gore's desire to replicate in India the expanded use of solar energy in the United States. "I'll do the same thing after 150 years," Mr. Goyal replies.
During
the 2015 Paris Climate Change Conference, Mr. Gore, who wasn't an
official negotiator, tries to persuade Lyndon Rive, then chief executive
of the American company SolarCity, to grant India the rights to a
patent on a type of solar technology. (The results aren't clear from the
film; India signed on to the Paris agreement without making a deal with
SolarCity and still hasn't made one.)
Mr.
Gore likens President Trump's election to a quip often attributed to
Mike Tyson: You always have a plan until you get punched in the face.
The movie has been updated since its premiere at the Sundance Film Festival
in January to include Mr. Trump's announcement of the United States'
withdrawal from the Paris climate accord, a decision that probably
forecasts another sequel.
In this July 21, 2016 file photo, the sun sets beyond visitors to
Liberty Memorial as the temperature hovers around 100 degrees in Kansas
City, Mo. A new U.S. report says last year's weather was far more
extreme or record breaking than anything approaching normal. (Charlie Riedel / AP)
Last year's global weather was far more extreme or record breaking than anything approaching normal, according to a new report.
The U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
on Thursday released its annual checkup of the Earth, highlighting
numerous records including hottest year, highest sea level, and lowest
sea ice in the Arctic and Antarctica.
The 299-page report,
written by scientists around the world and published in the Bulletin of
the American Meteorological Society, shows that 2016 was "very extreme
and it is a cause for concern," said co-editor Jessica Blunden, a NOAA
climate scientist.
Researchers called it a clear signal of human-caused climate change. A record large El Nino, the warming of the central Pacific that changes weather worldwide, was also a big factor in last year's wild weather.
"2016 will be forever etched in my brain as the year we
crossed a new threshold of climate change — one that gave us a grim
glimpse into our future," said Georgia Tech climate scientist Kim Cobb, who had no role in the report.
Scientists examined dozens of key climate measures and found:
At any given time, nearly one-eighth of the world's land mass was in
severe drought. That's far higher than normal and "one of the worst
years for drought," said report co-author Robert Dunn of the United
Kingdom Met Office.
Extreme weather was everywhere. Giant downpours were up. Heat waves
struck all over the globe, including a nasty one in India. Extreme
weather contributed to a gigantic wildfire in Canada.
Global sea level rose another quarter of an inch (3.4 millimeters) for the sixth straight year of record high sea levels.
There were 93 tropical cyclones across the globe, 13 percent more than
normal. That included Hurricane Matthew that killed about 1,000 people
in Haiti.
The world's glaciers shrank — for the 37th year in a row — by an average of about 3 feet (1 meter).
Greenland's ice sheet in 2016 lost 341 billion tons of ice (310 billion
metric tons). It has lost 4400 billion tons (4000 billion metric tons
of ice since 2002.
"2016 was a year in the Arctic like we've never
seen before," said NOAA Arctic research chief Jeremy Mathis, who called
it "a clear and more pronounced signal of warming than in any other
year on record."
Many of the findings have been previously
released, including that 2016 was the hottest year on record for the
third consecutive year. A separate study based on modeling and weather patterns shows three hot years in a row is close to impossible to be a natural coincidence.
The odds of three years in a row setting heat records without man-made
global warming is only 0.7 percent, compared to 30 to 50 percent with
greenhouse gases according to a separate study published Thursday in the
Geophysical Research Letters.
NOAA report co-editor Deke Arndt said the only notable normal global measure in 2016 was snow cover in the Northern Hemisphere.
The Commonwealth Bank has ruled out lending money to the proposed
Carmichael mega coal mine in Queensland in a move green groups say adds
pressure on the federal government to run out loans of its own.
A
bank spokeswoman confirmed Australia's biggest lender would not be
making loans to the Adani mine proposed for the Galilee Basin. The
initial thermal coal mine requires about $4 billion, but later expansion
could require as much as five times that investment.
Protestors wearing suits resembling Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull and
Adani chief, Gautam Adani, take part in a protest in Canberra on
Thursday. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen
"Whilst in general we do not comment on specific clients, we can
confirm that we are not amongst the banks who have been, or will be,
asked to consider this financing," she said.
A spokesman for
Indian-owned Adani said the miner "welcomes CBA's clarification and
confirmation of their view", adding it was in line with the bank's
stance earlier this year.
"Adani has not and does not intend to approach CBA for project
finance," he said. "Adani is well-advanced in discussions with
international financial institutions re project finance."
However,
Julian Vincent, executive director of anti-coal mining group Market
Forces, said the bank's move would dent Adani's prospects for raising
funds.
"These are desperate times for Adani," Mr Vincent said. "[CBA] plays
an important financing role but a critical credibility role."
The big four banks – which include NAB, ANZ and Westpac – had
supplied 75 per cent of project finance for fossil fuel ventures in
Australia over the past decade, Market Forces data shows.
Adani copped a $12,000 fine for releasing eight times its licensed
concentration of pollution from its Abbot Point coal terminal. Photo: Glenn Hunt
Mr Vincent said that with Indian banks increasingly wary of taking on
more risky ventures, the viability of the Adani mine could hinge on the
federal Northern Australia Infrastructure Facility (NAIF) – which is
mulling a $1 billion loan to help fund a rail line to the coast – and
the Chinese debt market.
The NAIF "is really the big game changer", Mr Vincent said.
Bank
exposure to fossil fuels drew attention from the Reserve Bank governor
Philip Lowe, who told a parliamentary committee on Friday that Australia
could have a lot of stranded assets if the Paris Agreement curbed
demand. While not an immediate threat to financial stability, the issue
would need watching over the long-term, he said.
"The RBA is now
starting to think about stranded electricity assets and an Australia
that exports less coal, which is more than Labor or Liberal governments
are doing," Adam Bandt, Greens climate and energy spokesman, said.
"But
the bank isn't yet on the same page as the financial regulator, APRA,
which is ringing alarm bells and telling us 80 per cent of coal needs to
stay in the ground."
Separately, Adani also copped some bad news
with a $12,000 fine for releasing eight times its licensed concentration
of pollution from its Abbot Point coal terminal during the aftermath of
Cyclone Debbie in March.
"If Adani can't safely operate the
Abbot Point coal terminal, how can they be trusted to build Australia's
biggest coal mine?, Basha Stasak, Australian Conservation Foundation
campaigner, said. "This is not a company that should be trusted with our
Great Barrier Reef, our clean water or the fate of the endangered
Black-throated finch." Links
The warming of the Earth's climate is indisputable.
A new
international climate change report, prepared by 450 scientists from
more than 60 countries, has published trends from thousands of data sets
that — across the board — present a clear-cut picture of a warming
world.
Led by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
(NOAA), the report revealed that heat-trapping gases, global
temperatures, ocean heat content, and sea levels reached record or
near-record highs in 2016. It is the 27th version of the report, titled State of the Climate in 2016, and is being published as a special 280-page supplement in the Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society.
NOAA released the report
documenting irrefutable evidence of global warming, even as President
Trump and high-level members of his administration have expressed
skepticism about the phenomenon, especially the human role.
Five
indicators from the report, in particular, offer a particularly
compelling illustration of the changing composition of the Earth's
atmosphere and the warming that has occurred in lockstep. 1. Concentrations of carbon dioxide, a heat-trapping greenhouse gas, are rising and hit a record high in 2016
Via NOAA: "The global average concentration of
carbon dioxide hit a record high in 2016. The increase from 2015 to 2016
was 3.5 ± 0.1 ppm — the largest one-year increase in the modern
record."
2. Global surface temperatures are rising and hit a record high in 2016
Via NOAA: "In 2016, the global surface
temperature was 0.45°–0.56°C (0.8°–1.0°F) above the 1981 — 2010 average —
a record high, according to multiple independent data sets."
3. The number of extremely hot days are increasing worldwide
Via NOAA: "As the global average temperature
has risen, so has the number of extremely hot days that occur each year.
This graph tracks the changing frequency of days on which the
temperature was in the 90th percentile of the historical record since
1950."
4. Sea levels are rising and hit a record high in 2016
Via NOAA: "Sea level hit a record high in 2016.
Independent estimates show that waters are rising due to meltwater from
glaciers and ice sheets (blue line) plus thermal expansion (red line)
of the ocean water as it warms (red line)."
5. Mountain glaciers are retreating
Via NOAA: "This graph shows glacier mass
balance — the difference between ice lost through melting and ice gained
through new snowfall — each year since 1980 (blue bars) for the 44
glaciers in the World Glacier Monitoring Service's reference network."
Supplementing these charts, Climate Central, the nonprofit science
communication firm in Princeton, N.J., created these visuals
illustrating some additional key findings from the report:
1. The United States had its second-warmest year on record
Via Climate Central: "The 2016 average
temperature for the contiguous U.S. was 54.9°F, which was 2.2°F above
the 1981-2010 average, this is the second warmest since records began.
Since 1970, the rate of warming has increased to 0.5°F per decade."
2. The 10 hottest years on record for the planet have occurred since 1998
Via Climate Central: "2016 was the globally
averaged hottest year on record, surpassing 2015. The record warmth
resulted from the combined influence of long-term global warming and a
strong El Niño early in the year. Then 10 hottest years on record have
all come since 1998."
3. Ocean temperatures in 2016 are rising and hit a record high in 2016
Via Climate Central: "Globally averaged sea
surface temperatures were the highest on record in 2016. Global sea
level was also the highest on record. The rate of warming and the rate
of sea level rise in the global oceans are both accelerating."
2016 was hottest year on record, for third year in a row
More frequent disasters 'putting a strain on local resources'
What the U.S. Departure Means for the Paris Agreement
Less than a week after President Donald Trump notified the United
Nations of his intent to exit from the Paris climate accord, his
government's chief science agency released a report demonstrating that
global warming is real and getting worse. The report,
prepared by almost 500 scientists from around the world, shows that
last year's average global temperatures were the highest ever recorded.
There were more major tropical cyclones than usual, longer droughts and
less snow cover. After years of increasing, Antarctic sea ice declined,
undercutting an argument by those who dispute the science of global
warming.
"The major indicators of climate change continued to reflect
trends consistent with a warming planet," said the report, which was
edited by Jessica Blunden and Derek S. Arndt of the National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration.
Reports, such as the NOAA-supported
one released Thursday in the Bulletin of the American Meteorological
Society, are "hard to dodge," according to David Schnare, who worked for
a short time at the Environmental Protection Agency
under Trump and wants the administration to abandon any efforts to
tackle climate change. He said this and other federal reports
documenting the severity of climate change could make it harder for the
EPA to reverse its 2009 finding that carbon dioxide emissions pose a
danger to the public.
Trump has labeled climate change a "hoax,"
and members of his administration have downplayed the role burning
fossil fuels is having on the Earth and its changing weather patterns.
While
Trump's administration seeks to unwind federal policies to address
climate change, local governments are being forced to act. Nick
Crossley, emergency management director for Ohio's Hamilton County,
which includes Cincinnati, said his agency dealt with more flash
flooding than usual last year.
"Some call it climate change; some call it something else,"
Crossley said in a phone interview. But whatever you call it, "it's
putting a strain on local resources."
Crossley, who is also vice
president of the International Association of Emergency Managers, said
his counterparts around the country are dealing with similar problems.
He said that while federal reports documenting the extent of climate
change might not capture the public's attention, they can help persuade
local officials to better prepare for future storms, floods and other
challenges. Those steps can include building storm-resistant
infrastructure, and helping people who live in vulnerable areas move
someplace else.
One of the surest signals that local governments
are taking climate change seriously is that they're looking for new ways
to pay for it. In South Florida, which is struggling with both rapid
sea-level rise and an increase in flooding, the city of Coral Gables is
looking for ways to start saving now for higher stormwater-managements
costs.
"The earlier you do stuff, the easier it is to prepare,"
said Abby Corbett, a lawyer who specializes in climate adaptation and is
advising Coral Gables. She said that while cities in South Florida have
long had to cope with flooding, climate change could cause people to
leave, shrinking the city's tax base.
"It may be that we have to struggle with revenues, just as costs are increasing," Corbett said.
Local
officials aren't the only ones trying to cope with the effects of
climate change. The accumulation of scientific data on global warming
has put pressure on the U.S. coal industry, which is already suffering
because of competition from cheap natural gas prices and renewable
energy. It increasingly has to deal as well with the perception that
coal is ruining the planet.
"I don't think the public is in the dark" about the
scientific consensus on climate change, said Luke Popovich, vice
president of the National Mining Association, which represents coal
companies. He asked why the U.S. should reduce its own coal use when
other countries, chiefly China and India, continue to burn it. And he
said that for most people, climate change remains low on their list of
worries.
"No matter how much information comes out of NOAA, it is
not going to help put more pressure on the U.S. to do more," Popovich
predicted. "We've got a hell of a lot of other problems to address."
Links
In 2005, at its annual meeting in Washington, D.C., the National
Association of Evangelicals was on the verge of doing something novel:
affirming science. Specifically, the 30-million-member group, which
represents 51 Christian denominations, was debating how to advance a new
platform called “For the Health of a Nation.” The position paper—written the year before An Inconvenient Truth
kick-started sense of public urgency around climate change—included a
call for evangelicals to protect God’s creation, and to embrace the
government’s help in doing so. The NAE’s board had already adopted it
unanimously before presenting it to the membership for debate.
At
the time, many in the evangelical movement were uncomfortable with its
close ties to the Republican anti-environmental regulation agenda. That
year, a group called the Evangelical Alliance of Scientists and
Ethicists protested the GOP-led effort to rewrite the Endangered Species
Act, and the NAE’s vice president of governmental affairs Richard Cizik
pushed for the organization to endorse John McCain and Joe Lieberman’s
cap-and-trade bill. “For the Health of a Nation,”
which Cizik also pushed, was an opportunity to draw a bright line
between their support of right-wing social positions on abortion and
civil rights and a growing sentiment that God’s creation needed
protection from industry.
“Evangelicals don’t want themselves identified as the Republican Party at prayer,” the historian and evangelical Mark Knoll said at the time in support of the platform.
He
was wrong. The rank-and-file membership rejected the effort. Like the
oil and utilities industries, they decided that recognizing climate
change was against their political interests.
At the behest of a
group called the Interfaith Stewardship Alliance, the board buckled,
releasing a statement in February 2006 “recognizing the ongoing debate”
on global warming and “the lack of consensus among the evangelical
community on the issue.” Just days later, an outside group of 86
evangelical leaders, under the aegis of the Evangelical Climate
Initiative, issued a “Call to Action” declaring that climate change was
real and that “millions of people could die from it in this century.”
Conservative
groups, funded by fossil fuel magnates, spend approximately one billion
dollars every year interfering with public understanding of what is
actually happening to our world.
For his trouble, Cizik was targeted by a collection of hard right Christians, who petitioned the NAE board
to muzzle him or force him to resign. “Cizik and others are using the
global warming controversy to shift the emphasis away from the great
moral issues of our time, notably the sanctity of human life, the
integrity of marriage, and the teaching of sexual abstinence and
morality to our children,” their letter read. It also implied that
Cizik, who had worked for the NAE for nearly three decades, supported
abortion, giving condoms to children, and infanticide.
The
NAE didn’t silence Cizik, but it didn’t take up his cause, either.
(Ultimately, his undoing was not climate change, but same-sex marriage.
“I would willingly say that I believe in civil unions,” he told NPR’s
Terry Gross in May 2007. “I don’t officially support redefining marriage
from its traditional definition, I don’t think.” He was fired ten days
later.)
The NAE did eventually endorse climate action
in 2015. But it was too late. By that time, a corps of right-wing
Christians, funded by fossil-fuel interests, had hijacked the public and
political machinery of the evangelical movement. They are now in the
White House, where the anti-environmental agenda is dominated by
Christian fundamentalists like EPA Commissioner Scott Pruitt while the
more moderate views offormer ExxonMobil CEO Rex Tillerson are ignored. This is the story of how they did it.
At
a town hall in Michigan last May, Republican Rep. Tim Walberg assured
his constituents that, while the climate may be changing, they don’t
need to be concerned. “As a Christian, I believe that there is a creator
in God who is much bigger than us,” he told them. “And I’m confident
that, if there’s a real problem, He can take care of it.”
This
idea—that whatever happens in God’s creation happens with His
blessing—has deep roots in the American evangelical community,
especially among the elite fundamentalists who walk the halls of power
in Washington, D.C. For years, an evangelical minister named Ralph
Drollinger has held weekly Bible studies for members of Congress,
preaching that social welfare programs are un-Christian and agitating
for military action against Iran. (In December 2015, he expressed his desire
to shape Donald Trump into a benevolent, Christian dictator.)
Drollinger also teaches that climate change caused by humans is
impossible in light of God’s covenant with Noah after the Flood: “To
think that man can alter the earth’s ecosystem—when God remains
omniscient, omnipresent and omnipotent in the current affairs of
mankind—is to more than subtly espouse an ultra-hubristic, secular
worldview relative to the supremacy and importance of man,” he wrote
recently.
Conservative groups, funded by fossil fuel magnates, spend approximately one billion dollars every year
interfering with public understanding of what is actually happening to
our world. Most of that money—most of the fraction of it that can be
tracked, anyway—goes to think tanks that produce policy papers and
legislative proposals favorable to donors’ interests, super PACs that
support politicians friendly to industry or oppose those who are not, or
mercenary lobbyists and consultants, in some instances employing the same people who fought to suppress the science
on smoking. In terms of impact, however, few investments can rival the
return that the conservative donor class has gotten from the small
cohort of evangelical theologians and scholars whose work has provided
scriptural justifications for apocalyptic geopolitics and economic rapaciousness.
The
Cornwall Alliance is an enforcer, stifling dissent in the evangelical
community, smothering environmentalist tendencies before they gain a
following.
“Throughout the history of the church,
people have always found ways to use God and scripture to justify
empire, to justify oppression and exploitation,” Kyle Meyaard-Schaap, an
organizer with a pro-environmental Christian group called Young
Evangelicals for Climate Action (YECA), told me. “It’s a convenient
theology to hold, especially when we are called to drastic, difficult
action.”
Many
of these soothsayers are gathered together in an organization called
the Cornwall Alliance—formerly known as the Interfaith Stewardship
Alliance, the same group that mobilized against Cizik’s environmental
proposal—a network with ties to politicians and secular think tanks
across the conservative landscape. In 2013, Cornwall published an
anti-environmentalist manifesto called Resisting the Green Dragon.
“False prophets promise salvation if only we will destroy the means of
maintaining our civilization. No more carbon, they say, or the world
will end and blessings will cease,”it warns. “Pagans of all
stripes now offer their rival views of salvation, all of which lead to
death.” Members of the Cornwall Alliance and their ilk are not simply
theoreticians but enforcers, stifling dissent in the wider American
evangelical community, smothering environmentalist tendencies before
they gain a following.
“Prayer for a Free Market Economy and Energy Abundance,” Cornwall Alliance. Illustration by Jim Cooke; photo by Shutterstock
The pull of fossil-fuel interests and the religious right is so
strong that even conservative politicians who privately believe climate
change is caused by humans have kept that view secret. Sen. Sheldon
Whitehouse, a Democrat from Rhode Island, has said that he knows of at least a dozen Republicans in the Senate
who accept climate science and want to take action, but feel they can’t
do so for fear of the political repercussions—despite the fact that
recent polling shows a majority of Republican voters believe that the
United States “should play a leading role”
on climate action. Half a dozen politically connected evangelical
Christians who are active on Capitol Hill backed up Whitehouse’s claim
to Splinter, saying they have either first- or second-hand experience
with politicians who admit in private that they accept climate science
even as they oppose regulations and reforms in public.
Bob Inglis, a former GOP congressman from South Carolina who lost his seat
to a primary opponent during the Tea Party surge of 2010, told Splinter
that there are Republican senators and representatives who want to take
climate action but are “terrified” to do so. Reverend Mitch Hescox,
president of the Evangelical Environmental Network, estimated that there
are as many as 20 senators who would take action for climate and clean
energy—but only if there were grassroots support to do so. Dr. Katharine
Hayhoe, director of the Climate Science Center at Texas Tech and an
evangelical Christian who believes in climate change, suspects that the
“vast majority” of those who dismiss climate science in Congress are
secret believers. “We don’t have a lot of years for these people to come
out of the closet,” Cizik, the ousted NAE board member, said.
Still,
Inglis, Hescox, Hayhoe, and other evangelical Christians were not
willing to expose the politicians who feel that climate action is
simply too great a political risk. They fear that Republicans who are
seen to support climate action, or even waver on opposing it, would
immediately be subject to well-funded primary challenges by more
ideologically committed candidates in the same way that Inglis was. “I
don’t want to scare them off before I have the grassroots support for
them,” Rev. Hescox told me.
The most prominent climate hardliner
in the U.S. Congress is Sen. Jim Inhofe. “Senator Inhofe will take an
act of God to be changed,” Rev. Hescox said with a laugh when I asked
whether the Oklahoma politician would ever see the light. “That one’s in
God’s hands, not mine.” In 2012, while promoting his book The Greatest Hoax: How the Global Warming Conspiracy Threatens Your Future,
Inhofe told a Christian radio program, “God’s still up there. The
arrogance of people to think that we, human beings, would be able to
change what He is doing in the climate is to me outrageous.” In 2015,
the Heartland Institute and the Heritage Foundation—two of the most
influential and well-funded think tanks in the conservative political
world—honored Inhofe with the Political Leadership on Climate Change
Award. In his speech accepting the award,
the then-chairman of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee
lauded the think tanks, telling their members that they “are on the
right side of the Lord on all of these things,” and that God “will
richly bless you for it.”
Together,
Cornwall, Heartland, and Heritage have been able to set the terms of
the conservative conversation—evangelical or otherwise—about the
climate.
Former Inhofe staffers and aides are flooding through leadership positions at the EPA, now led by Pruitt. About a month after Donald Trump took office, Drollinger began leading a weekly Bible study for members of the president’s cabinet. “It’s the best Bible study that I’ve ever taught in my life,” he told CBN News in a recent interview. “They are so teachable; they’re so noble; they’re so learned.”
A copy of Pruitt’s personal calendar,
released by the EPA in response to Freedom of Information Act requests
from Splinter and other outlets, shows that Pruitt began attending in
mid-March. All visitors hosting events in congressional buildings need
to be sponsored by a member of the House or the Senate. Drollinger’s
Capitol Ministries boasts 49 sponsoring representatives (including Walberg, who is a graduate of evangelical Taylor University and Wheaton College) and eight sponsoring senators, including Joni Ernst of Iowa, who neither accepts climate science nor denies it outright, and Mike Rounds of South Dakota, who allows that the climate is changing butclaims to feel that human activity is one small cause among many.
Both Ernst and Rounds sit (with Inhofe) on the Senate Environment and
Public Works Committee; their offices did not respond to requests for
comment.
Drollinger
declined to be interviewed for this story, and a Capitol Ministries
spokesperson wrote in an email that not all of the minister’s
congressional sponsors share his views. In a 2015 interview with the
Southern Baptist Theological Seminary (of which he is a trustee), Pruitt
said he believes
that, under a proper reading of the Constitution, “government would be
kept out of religion, not religion out of government.” At a ceremony in
the White House Rose Garden announcing the United States’ withdrawal
from the Paris agreement, Pruitt, in a linguistic nod to his fellow
evangelicals, declared: “We owe no apologies to other nations for our
environmental stewardship.” An EPA spokesperson insisted that any
questions about the administrator’s religious views be submitted in
writing, and stopped responding to emails after I did so.
“The
greatest solution, if we did face a problem, which I don’t believe we
do, is not central planning, is not putting U.N. bureaucrats in
charge—it’s innovation and technology,” Marc Morano, a former
speechwriter for Inhofe and prominent climate skeptic,
told me. “If we really do face a crisis, the solutions will just happen
naturally. You don’t need all this alarm. Whatever’s going to happen to
address the problem, if there is a problem, is going to happen on its
own.”
“There’s a wing of the evangelical church that’s
historically distrustful of science and of modernity,” Meyaard-Schaap,
the YECA organizer, told me, citing the publication of Darwin’s On the Origin of Species in 1859 and the Scopes Monkey Trial in 1925.“This
was a faction of the church that had been here for a while, who had
significant cultural power and saw that power diminishing,” he said. “In
the face of what they saw as significant threats to their identity,
that wing of the church decided that their best reaction was to retreat,
to pull away from public life, to invest in their own institutions, to
calcify this resistance to modernity and science.”
This
retreat lasted until the Reagan administration. In 1984, right-wing
Christian leaders and theologians formed a group dubbed the Coalition on
Revival for the express purpose not only of re-politicizing
evangelicals but of guiding them towards a particular fundamentalist
worldview. In its own words,
the Coalition’s aim was to “influence, penetrate, and permeate” every
aspect of society and to “rebuild civilization on the principles of the
Bible.” To accomplish this, members of the Coalition sought “to take
every thought captive to the obedience of Christ.”
As luck would have it, the “Christian World View of Economics” is avowedly business-friendly.
Over
the course of the next two years, the Coalition—guided by Christian
Reconstructionists like the influential R.J. Rushdoony, who believed
that the United States should adopt Old Testament laws—staked out
positions on the correct, Christian worldview on seventeen different
spheres of human life, including government, law, the family, education,
and science. A precocious young scholar named E. Calvin Beisner served
as the group’s general secretary, helping to draft the “Manifesto for the Christian Church,”
which was signed not only by religious groups like the Family Research
Council and the Home School Legal Defense Association, but also by a
Republican congressman, a representative from the National Republican
Senatorial Committee, and a White House liaison. Beisner also chaired
the Economics Committee, which ultimately produced a twenty-one page
document detailing Christian positions on economic issues. In an email,
Beisner confirmed that he still endorses both documents.
As luck would have it, the “Christian World View of Economics”
is avowedly business-friendly, condemning any economic policy that
would impede the enrichment of industrialists and financiers. “The root
cause of all poverty—spiritual and material—is the Fall of man,” the
paper proclaims. “The Bible and observation confirm that most poverty is
due to disobedience to God’s laws by individuals and their societies.”
The only way to deliver humanity from poverty, then, is to reshape
society according to Christian doctrine—which, as the Coalition
interpreted it, looks an awful lot like free-market capitalism.
In
the decades since its publication, the coalition’s members have risen,
fallen, and risen again in American politics. Beisner went on to found
the Cornwall Alliance; one of the first Cornwall Declaration’s signers
was Bill Bright—who was a mentor to the Trump Administration’s
unofficial preacher Ralph Drollinger. “Cornwall doesn’t matter to your
average politician, but it plays a very important role in buttressing
evangelical resistance to climate action, or even acknowledging that
climate change exists,” Bruce Wilson, researcher and co-founder of Talk to Action,
told me in an email. “Evangelicals can point to the Cornwall Alliance
as apparent evidence that there’s a broad coalition of conservative
evangelical and fundamentalist academics and theologians who reject
climate change science.” The group’s board of advisors has included a
number of other Coalition on Revival alumni, including founder and director Jay Grimstead.
Chart by Jim Cooke
For almost 20 years, Beisner and members of the Cornwall Alliance
have worked with establishment conservatives to bolster opposition to
climate change: The Heartland Institute identifies him as a policy advisor
on its web site, and he speaks regularly at the institute’s annual
conference on climate change (though in an interview he curiously denied
ever actually giving any policy advice to Heartland). The Heritage
Foundation hosted the 2015 premier of Where the Grass is Greener,
a documentary produced by the Cornwall Alliance. In May, Beisner and
senior executives from Heartland, Heritage, and a slew of other
billionaire-funded political entities like Americans for Prosperity and
the Competitive Enterprise Institute sent a letter to Donald Trump urging him to withdraw from the Paris climate agreement and asking him to stop funding United Nations global warming programs.
Together,
Cornwall, Heartland, and Heritage have been able to set the terms of
the conservative conversation—evangelical or otherwise—about the
climate. They determine what science is acceptable, which proposed
solutions can be considered, and what the consequences of inaction might
look like. “There’s a very strong connection between those institutions
and the evangelical Right,” Rev. Hescox told me. “Their denial of the
science—and really portraying this as a big government issue—is why
there was so much pushback among evangelicals.”
The
Cornwall Alliance, joined by scientists associated with organizations
partly funded by ExxonMobil, continued hammering away at Christian
groups that supported action on climate change. In 2008, it launched the
bizarrely named “We Get It!”
campaign, which targeted the Evangelical Climate Initiative and was
endorsed by a slew of conservative organizations, including the Family
Research Council and David Barton’s WallBuilders.
“The
‘We Get It!’ declaration speaks for me, and I believe it speaks for the
vast majority of evangelicals, who are as tired as I am of being
misrepresented by people who don’t bother to get their theology, their
science, or their economics right,” Inhofe said in a statement.
“Consequently, they put millions of the world’s poor at risk by
promoting policies to fight the alleged problem of global warming that
will slow economic development, and condemn the poor to more generations
of grinding poverty and high rates of disease and early death.”
According to journalist and historian Frances FitzGerald’s new book, The Evangelicals: The Struggle to Shape America, the campaign was funded in part by Koch Industries.
In 2013, Cornwall (with assistance from the Heritage Foundation) launched the Resisting the Green Dragon campaign, which the sociologist Antony Alumkal calls
“a case study in the paranoid style, using rhetoric that is extreme
even by Christian Right standards in order to scare laypeople away from
[environmentalism].” The campaign included both a book, written by
physicist and “lay theologian” James Wanliss,” and a 12-part DVD series
starring luminaries of the evangelical right, all laying out the case
that green Christian movements are born of a “spiritual deception” that
puts the needs of nature before people—a demonic worldview that requires
an explicitly Christian response.
Resisting the Green Drago Promo
“History is...not a matter of fate, conservation, or man’s abilities,
but of the decree of God,” Wanliss writes. “At the same time, God
commands men to take dominion in the name of Christ, to fill the earth
and multiply. This is not possible without a wholehearted embrace of
Jesus Christ, on a global scale...Rather than seeking to save the planet
on terms dictated by the Green Dragon, Christians ought to be preaching
the only message that can save the planet—the gospel of liberty in
Jesus Christ.”
Recently,
Beisner, a prolific writer equally comfortable deploying poststructural
literary theory or Calvinist theology, has infused his rhetoric with
even more fire and brimstone. “We are made in the image of the Creator.
So we don’t have to leave nature as we found it,” he argued recently.
“We can steward the earth to enhance its fruitfulness, beauty, and
safety. And we can do it to glorify God and serve our neighbors.” In
May, he described the climate marches
as “thuggery—typical of communist movements from the French Revolution
through the socialist revolutions of the 1840s and the Russian and
Chinese revolutions.” A prayer for the free market economy published on the Cornwall website reads:
Dear Father in Heaven, We
pray that trade and business across the globe would flourish. We pray
for the leaders of the countries and various international institutions
who decide economic policy. Please give them wisdom and let them uphold
an economic system that is not restrictive. We also pray for an abundance of energy that will support the growing economies of the world. We
ask You to help people understand the importance of conventional and
clean energy sources like coal and nuclear to the developing nations of
the world. Lord, let Your wisdom guide the decision makers in academia
and governmental institutions. We pray this in Jesus name, Amen
Beisner
sent fundraising emails before and after the Trump administration’s
announcement that it would withdraw from the Paris climate accord,
asking supporters to donate money to the Cornwall Alliance and to
implore the administration to pull out of the agreement. Beisner says
that the group doesn’t take corporate money and that most contributions
come from small donors. But the Cornwall Alliance is in fact a project
of a 501(c)(3) nonprofit called the James Partnership,
run by Chris Rogers, of CDR Communications, a Virginia-based consulting
firm. The James Partnership, financial records show, is embedded in the
very same world of shadowy corporate political spending as Heritage and
Heartland.
Given
that it is a relatively small operation with relatively low overhead,
the money that the Cornwall Alliance receives is a vanishingly small
fraction of the hundreds of millions spent by the Koch, the Mercer, or
the DeVos families. (The Kochs are oil, coal, and gas scions; Robert
Mercer is a hedge fund manager who, with his daughter Rebekah, fueled
Trump’s rise; Education Secretary Betsy DeVos and her husband Dick are
long-time Republican donors).
Their money flows through a
multitude of nonprofits, front groups, and donor-advised funds. (A
donor-advised fund is a kind of money-laundering service for
philanthropists who don’t want anyone to know where their money is
going: They make a contribution to the fund, and then tell the fund
where to send the money; as a nonprofit, the fund has to disclose all of
the grants that it makes, but it does not need to disclose its own
donors, nor what direction those donors attached to their money.) Donors
Trust, the “dark money ATM”
of the conservative movement, contributed $1,001,500 to the James
Partnership between 2009 and 2015; in most years, this constituted
around half of the Partnership’s total revenue.
“Maybe
God will express his judgement through the climate system. One
experimental way of trying to test that would be to end abortions and
see if climate change ended.”
In 2013, Donors Trust gave only $35,000, but another nonprofit, the Institute for Faith, Work, and Economics swooped in with a $100,000 grant; together these accounted for 46.3 percent of the Partnership’s revenue. (Beisner wrote a chapter
on why capitalism is less harmful to the environmental than socialism
in a forthcoming book to be published by the Institute.) The Institute
is controlled by EvangChr4 Trust, a nonprofit dedicated to convincing
lawmakers and academics of the Biblical foundations of free-market
capitalism; both are run by Paul Brooks, a retired Koch Industries
executive. Channelling millions of dollars from the Koch brothers’ Freedom Partners nonprofit,
EvangChr4 Trust has also made significant donations to the virulently
homophobic and anti-choice Family Research Council—a Coalition on
Revival signatory—and CitizenLink (a.k.a. the Family Policy Alliance), the political action arm of Focus on the Family.
Both EvangChr4 and the Institute for Faith, Work, & Economics were
listed in tax documents as “related organizations” of the Koch brothers’
now-defunct voter database project, Themis Trust; Brooks was also a
trustee of Themis. He did not return multiple requests for comment; nor
did the Institute.
Donors
Trust refers clients to Donors Capital if they are planning to
contribute more than one million dollars; the executive director and
co-founder of the Acton Institute for the Study of Religion and Liberty,
where Beisner is an adjunct fellow, sits on Donors Capital’s board of
directors. Acton’s other co-founder, a Catholic priest,
is also part of the Cornwall Alliance. Both Heritage and Acton have
received millions of dollars in funding from donor-advised funds
administered by the National Christian Foundation,
and, as with contributions that come from Donors Trust and Donors
Capital, it’s difficult to know whose money is going where when it
passes through NCF. As it turns out, the organization that would eventually become the Cornwall Alliance began in 1999, as a project of the Acton Institute,
which has received millions from Donors Capital, Donors Trust, NCF, and
private foundations controlled by the Koch, DeVos, and Bradley
families.
Beisner
declined to identify Cornwall or the James Partnership’s more
significant donors. When I asked about the contributions from Donors
Trust, he said, “You need to deal with the actual evidence rather than
just writing it off as bought and paid for by somebody.” Rogers declined
to comment.
The “evidence”
against climate change, as Beisner and the Cornwall Alliance’s network
of scholars interpret it, indicates that whatever fluctuations are
happening in the global climate are insignificant—that to whatever
extent the climate is changing, the consequences of those changes are
not catastrophic. “We think that an infinitely wise God designed, and an
infinitely powerful God created, and an infinitely faithful God
sustained the Earth and its various subsystems for the benefit of all
the living creatures in the Earth,” Beisner told me.
“It
could of course always be the case that the all-wise, all-powerful,
all-faithful God has so designed the system as to react to abusive
action in a manner that expresses God’s judgement on that abuse,” he
said. “We abort millions of babies every year. Maybe God will express
his judgement of that through the climate system. We have millions of
people killed in unjustified wars. Maybe God expresses his judgement of
that through the climate system. Or God doesn’t like our pulling coal
and oil and natural gas out of the Earth, so he’s going to make the
climate system react in a way that would not seem likely on our prior
thinking basis.” He added later: “One experimental way of trying to test
that would be to end the abortions and see if the climate change
ended.”
“A free market economy is the closest approximation in this fallen world to the system of economy revealed in the Bible.”
In
2015, Beisner wrote a position paper on economics and the environment
for Acton with Michael Cromartie, a Cornwall advisor and longtime courtier of the secular media. Free markets encourage both competition and stewardship, they argued paradoxically,
and are “essential to human welfare.” Therefore, capitalism must have
“a moral priority on our thinking about how society ought to be
ordered.” The influence of the Coalition on Revival’s Economics “World
View” from nearly two decades earlier is clear: “A free market economy
is the closest approximation in this fallen world to the system of
economy revealed in the Bible.” So concludes nearly four centuries of
Calvinist thought, decades of fundamentalist resentment, and several
billion dollars in political spending.
Those
billions are paying off. Not only have the people who funded Cornwall
successfully stopped the government from pursuing policies that might
make the lives of people who are living with the consequences of climate
change a little bit better, but under the Trump administration their
lackeys are actively working to dismantle what little progress has been
made. When Drollinger teaches that God’s covenant with Noah means that
the consequences of climate change not only will not but in fact cannot be as devastating as scientists believe,
he echoes a lengthy essay published by the Cornwall Alliance in 2009
that lays out the same argument. Typical of the organization’s style, it
appears to the casual observer like any policy paper drawn up at one of
D.C.’s many think tanks and nonprofits; in reality, the document blends
quotations from scripture with pseudo-scientific data—citing, for example, the Mercer-funded Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine. During Pruitt’s confirmation hearing, Republican Sen. John Barrasso favorably cited Beisner and the Cornwall Alliance’s support for the Oklahoma attorney general.
“A
guy who has given full-throated defenses of coal has told me privately,
‘Coal is dead. We know that. We’re just trying to figure out how to
move on.’ Meanwhile he keeps on talking about coal,” Rep. Inglis told
me. “Members of Congress are afraid of the people they represent, but
they’re terrified of the activists within their own party, because
that’s who takes you out in a primary.”
The former congressman recalled visiting Paul Ryan’s district with RepublicEn, his new climate lobby group,
to talk about climate change with the House speaker’s constituents. A
pair of vocal, anti-environmental activists disrupted the bipartisan
event. “At the end of the night, one of my guys said, ‘You realize those
are two of the most important activists in Paul Ryan’s district? These
two ladies, you sit them in a phone bank, they would wear out multiple
cell phone batteries destroying Paul Ryan if they thought he’d gone soft
on them.” (When I asked whether he cited that example because Speaker
Ryan has privately expressed support for climate action, Rep. Inglis
demurred. “Better not go into that,” he said with a laugh.)
“A
lot of people tend to go where they find theology that matches their
own opinions,” Reverend Hescox told me. “It’s much easier for people,
rather than being challenged by the Bible, to find some version of the
faith that matches what their pre-existing belief structure is.”
Meyaard-Schaap
believes that the green evangelical movement already has sufficient
support in Congress for climate action; the issue now is getting the
electorate to communicate to their representatives that this is, in
fact, what they want. “I continue to believe wholeheartedly that
grassroots power is more powerful than small, monied interests. If
politicians recognize that there is a bona fide grassroots movement
around this issue, and that their seat—regardless of how much money they
might be getting from the other side—is in danger, that’s when you get
their attention,” he told me. “I think in the next five or ten years, as
more and more young evangelicals get plugged into the political
process, that grassroots movement is going to grow to the point where
politicians who might be getting money from the fossil fuel industry
will say, ‘Look, this isn’t gonna cut it. I can’t protect my seat
anymore and I have to change tack.’”
Morano
dismissed these efforts. “Everything that needs to happen is happening.
It’s going to happen naturally,” he said. “If you’re concerned about
global warming, sit back and watch the innovation happen. It’s amazing.”
He added: “We just have to have the courage to do nothing.” *This post was produced by the Special Projects Desk of Gizmodo Media Group.