17/05/2020

(AU) Four Corners: Climate Wars

ABC Four Corners
“What climate policy? I mean, it's basically a mess. It's incoherent and has been for a decade.”  Former Department Secretary
Image: Four Corners


Climate Wars, reported by Michael Brissenden, goes to air on Monday 18 May at 8.30pm.
It is replayed on Tuesday 19 May at 1.00pm and Wednesday 20 May at 11.20pm.
It can also be seen on ABC NEWS channel on Saturday at 8.10pm AEST, ABC iView and at abc.net.au/4corners.

For more than a decade the climate wars have raged in Australian politics.

Brutal disputes over how and even if climate change should be tackled have claimed one political leader after another and resulted in a seesaw of policies.
“It's like watching a train wreck in slow motion, to almost be able to visualise this and to see this happening, and year after year after year go by.”  Former Chief Scientist
In Canberra’s corridors of power, the nation’s most senior public servants have been there through it all.

Usually they keep their thoughts private, rarely making a foray into public debate, even in retirement.

Now several of these former mandarins, who have worked with the highest levels of government, are speaking out. 
“I think the history of this has more to do with personal ambition than anything else,” Former Department Secretary

Four Corners Climate Wars Promo

Former heads of the Office of Prime Minister and Cabinet and the Department of the Treasury along with former Chief Scientists have decided they can no longer stay silent about what they believe has been a colossal failure by politicians of all stripes to comprehensively tackle climate change.
“The level of intellectual input into that argument has been close to zero.”  Former Chief Scientist
They describe cases of flawed decision making and reveal how parties on all sides of the political spectrum have squandered important opportunities in pursuit of their short-term political interests.
“I've asked myself this question many, many times. Why do I still feel angry about it? And the reason I feel angry about it is that I feel angry about what Australia has lost.”  Former Department Secretary
Many of them look back upon their time working with government with regret that they could not achieve more.
“We have failed, no doubt about that.  We’ve all failed I think. I mean, I look back on it now and I still feel gutted.”  Former Departmental Secretary
As these senior government policy specialists reflect on the challenge ahead, they are calling on Australia’s leaders to do more.
“It’s about having the strength to lead and it’s about staring down some people who you know are basically wrong, whatever their motivation might be.”  Former Chief Scientist
Links

(AU) Australia's Reserve Bank Fuels Call For Post-Pandemic Renewables Push

The Guardian - 

Exclusive: Government urged to make clean energy part of Covid-19 recovery, as RBA finds 50% slump in projects last year

RBA research shows the number of large-scale clean energy projects reaching the point of commencement slumped about 50% last year. Photograph: 5B

Research by the Reserve Bank showing renewable energy investment fell sharply last year is fuelling calls for federal and state governments to back changes to help the industry rebound and drive a post-pandemic recovery.

Renewable energy surged to make up nearly 5% of non-mining business investment across Australia in 2018, according to the research note by RBA economists, but the number of large-scale clean projects reaching the point of commencement slumped about 50% last year.

Investment is expected to fall further over the next year or two, in part due to the national renewable energy target being filled and not replaced and challenges in integrating solar and wind farms in remote parts of the national grid.

The Morrison government has defended criticism of its response to the climate crisis in part by saying record levels of wind and solar power were added to the grid last year as investment in 2018 flowed through. It is yet to acknowledge the subsequent fall.



The note says the renewable energy industry had supported activity and employment, particularly in regional areas. While most components used in solar and wind farms are imported, the RBA found 25-40% of spending went to local suppliers in some cases, and manufacturing companies had reported stronger demand for locally produced electricity generation equipment.

The former Liberal leader John Hewson, now at the Australian National University’s Crawford school of public policy and a director of an energy storage business, said the RBA had “gone out of its way to make a point” about the importance of renewable power to the economy.

“There’s no doubt this is more than a nudge and wink. It is saying this is where we should be going,” he said. “With Covid, it’s even more important. It is an opportunity to take a long-term strategic view in the national interest and looking ahead to where the country should be going given its [solar and wind] assets.”

The RBA note was published online on 19 March, before the impact of the Covid-19 imposed economic shutdown. Since the pandemic there has been a growing push internationally and in Australia for policymakers to use stimulus programs designed to help the economic recovery to also address the climate crisis.

Hewson said the renewable energy industry did not require subsidies, but needed improved regulations and a clear policy framework that made clear fossil fuels would be phased out and the country would move to low greenhouse gas emissions over the next three decades. With renewable energy cheaper than its fossil fuel competitors, he said the grid could run on 100% renewable energy well before 2050 with the right support.

Erwin Jackson, policy director with the Investor Group on Climate Change, said the RBA note showed renewable investment had been an important contributor to economic growth but had fallen, in part due to policy paralysis.

“The critical implication of the analysis is that the industry faces the risk of a boom-bust cycle,” he said. “Governments can help stimulate new investment, and in turn new jobs and growth, by prioritising a net zero emissions transition and clean energy plans in a sustainable recovery from Covid-19.”

The RBA research echoes assessments by industry group the Clean Energy Council and consultants Bloomberg New Energy Finance, which both found investment in renewable energy projects was cut in half last year.

Alan Rai, a former senior economist at the RBA, now a director with consultancy Baringa Partners, said the central bank’s focus on the scale and benefits of renewable energy spending was instructive. The bank had been concerned about the level of non-mining investment since the global financial crisis in 2008, he said.

“The fact that renewables have become such a big pipeline of non-mining investment and then fallen drew their attention,” he said. “It is important to the country on a macroeconomic level.”

The report found the longer-term outlook for clean energy investment was more positive, but would depend on government policy, electricity grid considerations and wholesale electricity prices holding up. Prices have fallen in recent months and are expected to stay low if the economic impact of the shutdown is extended.

Prof Frank Jotzo, director of ANU’s Centre for Climate and Energy Policy, said the renewable energy boom has helped bring down electricity prices in the wholesale market and cut emissions. Electricity sector emissions were 7% lower in the first quarter than at the same in 2019.

But he said lower electricity prices meant lower revenue for renewable plants, and there were no longer sizeable subsidies. “If the Covid economic trouble turns into a prolonged recession, this could also pull the rug from under planned wind and solar power investments,” he said.

“That means a risk that there may not be sufficient renewable power available to easily cover for the next coal plant shutting down. It also means that we would see an end to big annual emissions reductions from the power sector, making it harder to achieve the 2030 emissions target.”

Jotzo said federal and state governments should step into the breach and contract for the construction of wind and solar parks in identified renewable energy zones.

“Public investments or financial guarantees for developments in the renewable energy zones are a safe bet, because we know that these investments will be needed, and they will be an excellent way to stimulate the economy, especially in the regions.”

Links

Climate Scientist Katharine Hayhoe's 'Global Weirding' Videos

Yale Climate Connections - SueEllen Campbell

Scientist Katharine Hayhoe is widely recognized as a leading climate science communicator. This sampling of her videos provides a taste of why she's earned that reputation.

Katharine Hayhoe. Image credit: Climate Models / Global Weirding video


SueEllen Campbell is a retired Colorado State University English professor.
Texas Tech climate scientist Katharine Hayhoe is well-known for her skills as a climate science communicator and educator.

Search the internet for her name and you’ll get abundant results, many of them videos, often of talks she has given. (Many are linked on her personal website.)

If you haven’t been keeping up with her series of mostly 9- to 10-minute videos called Global Weirding, it’s time to treat yourself to a good handful of those pieces.

Even if you’re well-versed in climate change, you’ll enjoy them and learn from them.

They’re smart, informed, and thoughtful; they’re full of great analogies (and cartoon illustrations), metaphors, and examples; they are lively, direct, friendly, clear, and very accessible.

The series currently comprises more than 50 videos on a wide range of topics.

Here are some to begin with.


Climate Change and Coronavirus. One of the best and most informative pieces on this subject.


What’s the Big Deal With a Few Degrees? Exemplary in its clarity about this non-intuitive topic.


I’m Not a Tree Hugger. You don’t have to be an environmentalist to care about climate change; you just have to care about human life and civilization, since climate touches everything.


Climate Models. Again, exemplary in its clarity and how it addresses common confusions and mistakes.


I’m only a kid, I can’t do anything about climate change …. right? More substantive suggestions than usual, with inspiring examples.

Links
Other topics in the Global Weirding series include:

16/05/2020

(AU) New Comic Book The Grot Is A Timely Quarantine Read Imagining Australian Life In A Climate-Ravaged World

ABC Arts | Teresa Tan

Amy Reading's book The Mark Inside and old Hollywood con-artist films inspired Pat Grant's The Grot. (Supplied: Pat Grant) 

In 2012, musing what the future might look like for his children in the age of climate crisis, cartoonist Pat Grant conceived a world where harvested algae is a commodity worth more than gold, Kevin '07 campaign t-shirts are archaeological treasures, and a plague is decimating the population's migrant have-nots.

This is the world of The Grot: a darkly entertaining coming-of-age story exploring sibling relationships in a near-future Australian landscape scarred by environmental disaster.

Grant began writing The Grot in the "Julia Gillard and Obama days". (Supplied: Pat Grant) 



This month, the third instalment of Grant's graphic novel The Grot: The Story of the Swamp City Grifters was released online for free, after its physical release by US publisher Topshelf was postponed due to COVID-19-related industry disruptions.

For the first time, fans can access all three chapters online, for free.

Kate Evans says dystopian stories are popular among young adults because by exploring serious and dark themes "it's a way of emerging from childhood into adulthood". (Supplied: Pat Grant)



Grant's saga opens with teenage brothers Lippy and Penn Wise journeying north on a capitalist pilgrimage to Falter City, to make their fortune with their "medicinal yoghurt" business in tow.

For a story written between 2012 and 2013 and long before the COVID-19 pandemic, some of The Grot's ideas feel eerily of the moment.

The main character cultivates yoghurt starter (not sourdough) and instead of COVID-19, the book's rampant plague could be smallpox or typhus, which Grant says were "the sort of breakouts that happened all the time in big cities in the 1800s".

Grant researched "plagues that liquify people's innards", like Ebola, as well as the Spanish flu and Bubonic plague. (Supplied: Pat Grant)



Plague-ridden areas and buildings are marked and boarded up, while the dead are stacked up in a pile by workers in hazmat suits as the fortunate watch from behind barriers — echoing recent scenes from China and Italy.

Thanks to the breakdown of manufacturing and global supply chains, The Grot's population looks to medical workers "who brew things like beer, kombucha and fermented products … but also might be snake oil". Only last month a celebrity chef was fined $25,000 for misleading consumers about a natural therapy coronavirus treatment.

It took Grant roughly one year to write and six years to draw (with Fionn McCabe on colourist duty) to bring the story to life. Like his previous graphic novel Blue (based on his experience of the Cronulla Riots) and his Toormina Video (a poignant and ruminative ode to his late father), The Grot is deeply personal.

Grant spent a year working on a thumbnail manuscript to work out The Grot's visual structure. (Supplied: Pat Grant) 



After his father's passing, Grant's once-close sibling relationship became hard work, so the cartoonist plunged brothers Penn and Lippy into a bleak anti-utopia and cast them into a string of deeply trying situations, to test "how robust the sibling relationship is when the chips are really down".

The illustrator has even immortalised his eldest son as a muck-covered starving street urchin in one panel from the novel.

"That image is really horrifying to me," the Australian cartoonist and author told ABC Arts.
"Using fiction and imagery to project a day-to-day sort of moment in the future — where your child is starving — it's grim."
Grant says he has been fascinated and obsessed with climate change and its impact since he was a teenager (Supplied: Gabriel Clark)



A city sick with change

Seated on top of a MacGyvered "pedal-punk" vehicle made from a salvaged car body, bicycle wheels and bamboo, propelled forward by people pedalling bikes, and full of youthful ambition, Penn and Lippy are bound for Falter City — a lawless swamp-dwelling dystopian metropolis with "a sweaty armpit vibe", swarming with prospectors, swindlers, hustlers, hawkers, and con-artists on the make.

In the scene, Penn tells his idealistic younger brother Lippy: "It's the great migration of our times!"

Grant describes the technology and aesthetic of The Grot as "pedal-punk", and says people have retrofitted 19th-century machines to run on human energy. (Supplied: Pat Grant)



As they approach the swamp surrounding Falter City, Penn and Lippy's mother draws their attention to the stench: "Something foul. Something ancient … That is the smell of sick people," before matter-of-factly informing her son that whatever the malady "you'll be perfectly placed to profit from it".

Describing the world of The Grot, Grant says: "It's massively dysfunctional, there's no infrastructure, no groundwater. There's no real policing so organised crime is rampant and there's a plague too."

In Grant's vision of the future, people return to 18th-century ways of producing things.

"It isn't this wasteland apocalypse where there's no people," he explains. Instead, he forecasts that society will face "the gradual degradation of the human and non-human experience".

"We're going to lose technology rather than gain technology," says Grant.

Grant's stories share themes in common, including gentrification, inequality, the politics of place, and how migration changes urban places. (Supplied: Pat Grant)

"The way we think about industrial progress is this exponential uptick of technology, production, creation, energy, information and mobility. But what if that's a parabola curve?"
Good drama is flawed people doing their best

Under the current pandemic it's understandable some readers are avoiding dystopian fiction, while others rush towards it. As Caroline Zielinski wrote in a recent op-ed: "It exists, we should remember, to show us a way out."

Kate Evans, host of ABC Radio National's The Bookshelf, says "an important part of dystopian fiction is that it is based on something [real] in the world … it looks at reality, expands it and distorts it in really interesting ways" — citing Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale and The Testaments as examples.

"All of the things people just think she was imagining — those dark moments — all of them were based on real things," Evans says.
"It's that anchoring to the world while exploring the imagination that makes it effective and makes good ideas work. I think that's the secret to the writing that resonates in some little dark corner of your soul as you're reading it.
"Under the current pandemic, dystopian fiction seems more prescient — particularly because some of it is not very far from where we are now."

The world of The Grot references gold rush boomtown architecture, Indonesia's urban environment, and local institutions like Sydney Chinatown's BBQ King. (Supplied: Pat Grant)



Dr Pat Grant is a Sydney-based cartoonist, writer, graphic novelist, UTS School of Design lecturer, and holds a PhD in cartooning from Macquarie University. (Supplied: Gabriel Clark)

Grant says that the feeling of déjà vu when sci-fi, dystopian and speculative fiction seem prophetic is because the authors who write in that genre are "obsessed and fascinated with technology, history and the kind of cycles and patterns that repeat themselves".

When it comes to many of the grungy, bleak and gruesome scenes in The Grot, Grant says "everything comes from something I've seen with my own eyes".

Scrawled on a post-it note stuck above Grant's desk is a quote from The West Wing Weekly Podcast: "Good drama is flawed people doing their best."

"You can probably find enough horror in your daily life that you don't have to be too fantastical," says the author. "It's usually something people ignore or don't see, they edit it out.
"Stories draw from deep intuition and our subconscious, and package things up in a way that disguises [it] as entertainment."
He says one of storytelling's abilities is creating a plausible future.

"And whatever future does come to pass, you're just guaranteed that there will be a storyteller who's imagined it already — and not just what's going to happen, but also what granular sort of texture of life is going to be like too."

'An expensive hoax'

Grants says the literary conventions of The Grot come from crime fiction and hardcore sci-fi, and the world takes cues from gold rush era Australia and frontier-era America. (Supplied: Pat Grant)



Grant describes The Grot as "a book that really thinks through one future, one kind of life that lies ahead of us, one kind of possible and feasible experience of life that climate change could bring to us".

But since he started writing the series, he notes, climate change has "gone from being an abstract idea to something that's happening down the street".

In 2020, Australia was ranked the worst-performing country on climate change policy in the Climate Change Performance Index (out of 57); US President Donald Trump — who once called climate change "an expensive hoax" — has rolled back almost 100 environmental regulations in his first term.

The Grot doesn't feel quite so far from reality as it once did. But Grant is particularly pleased to have his "meditation on climate change" out in the world right now.
"I like to help people understand the world that we live in."
The Grot is out now as a free webcomic. A print version will be published by Penguin Random House in August

Links - Cartoons

Face Masks Show Earth's Grim Warming Trend

Mashable - 

Climate change "warming stripes" mask created by Ed Hawkins, a climate scientist at the University of Reading.

The planet's heating trend has ramped up over the last 40 years — as CO2 emissions have skyrocketed.

Nineteen of the last 20 years are now the warmest on record.

Such a stark change in the planet's surface temperature is easily visualized in the "warming stripes" created by Ed Hawkins, a climate scientist at the University of Reading. The stripes depict "global average temperature in each year from 1850 to 2018, clearly illustrating the warming planet as the colours change from cool blue to warm red."

The warming stripes — seen in live concerts, on a Tesla, and on ties and scarves — are now available as cotton face masks, in a reality where a historic pandemic is occurring amid human-caused climate change.

Earth's average global surface temperatures.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) now recommends wearing face coverings in public places where it's difficult or impossible to stay at least six feet away from people.

Importantly, wearing a coronavirus face mask isn't about you.

"Putting a mask on yourself is more to prevent you from infecting someone else," Dr. Anthony Fauci, the long-serving director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, told PBS NewsHour last month. The coverings reduce the amount of virus an infected person exhales.

What's more, around one in four infected people may not experience COVID-19 symptoms, meaning they don't know they're infected. So a mask can help infected people who "do not know it from transmitting [disease] to others," said the CDC.



The coronavirus pandemic will not end any time soon, as there's no vaccine nor proven medical treatments. Infectious disease experts expect the coronavirus to come in waves, perhaps like the 1918 influenza.

Meanwhile, the planet is already on track for finishing as one of the top few warmest years on record — and has a good shot of being the hottest year ever recorded.

Links

7 Climate Change Novels That Imagine Our Possible Futures

Gizmodo - Adeline Johns-Putra

Image: Hitoshi Suzuki/Unsplash, FAL

Adeline Johns-Putra is Reader in English Literature, University of Surrey

Every day brings fresh and ever more alarming news about the state of the global environment. To speak of mere “climate change” is inadequate now, for we are in a “climate emergency”. It seems as though we are tripping over more tipping points than we knew existed.

But our awareness is at last catching up with the planet’s climate catastrophes. Climate anxiety, climate trauma, and climate strikes are now all part of many people’s mental landscape and daily lives. This is almost four decades after scientists first began to warn of accelerated global warming from carbon dioxide increases in the atmosphere.

And so, unsurprisingly, climate fiction, climate change fiction, “cli-fi” – whatever you want to call it – has emerged as a literary trend that’s gained astonishing traction over the past ten years.

Just a decade ago, when I first began reading and researching literary representations of climate change, there was a curious dearth of fiction on the subject. In 2005, the environmental writer Robert Macfarlane had asked plaintively: “Where is the literature of climate change?”.

When I went to work in 2009 on one of the first research projects to attempt to answer this question, I found that some climate change novels were only beginning to emerge. Ten years later, the ubiquity of cli-fi means that the question of how many cli-fi novels there are seems irrelevant. Equally irrelevant is any doubt about the urgency of the climate emergency.

But the question of how to deal with such a complex challenge is paramount. The climate emergency demands us to think about our responsibilities on a global scale rather than as individuals, to think about our effects not just on fellow humans but on all the species that call this planet home, and to think about changing the resource-focused, profit-seeking behaviours that have been part of human activity for centuries.

This is where literature comes in. It affords us the headspace in which to think through these difficult and pressing questions.

Cli-fi has a central role in allowing us to do the psychological work necessary to deal with climate change. I am often asked to identify the climate novel that is the most powerful and effective and, just as often, I reply that no one novel can do this. The phenomenon of cli-fi as a whole offers us different ways and a multitude of spaces in which to consider climate change and how we address it.

Here, then, is my list of a range of novels that offer just such a diverse set of perspectives. These books provide readers with a range of thought (and feeling) experiments, from dystopian despair to glimmers of hope, from an awareness of climate change impacts on generations to come to vivid reminders of how we are destroying the many other species that share our planet.

                                      ****

1. The Sea and Summer, 1987
Australian novelist George Turner’s book is one of the earliest examples of cli-fi and is prescient in more ways than one.
Set in Melbourne in the 2030s, skyscrapers are drowning due to sea-level rise: a setting for a stark division between the rich and the poor.
Like many cli-fi novels, this novel’s dystopian future provides a sophisticated thought experiment on the effects of climate change on our already divided society.
Turner’s book deserves to be reread — and reissued — as classic and still relevant cli-fi.

                                      ****


2. Memory of Water, 2012
Water has become a precious commodity in this cli-fi dystopia by Finnish author Emmi Itäranta.
In Nordic Europe in the distant future, a young girl must decide whether to share her family’s precious water supply with her friends and fellow villagers and risk being accused of “water crime”, punishable by death.
This tender coming-of-age narrative is thus also a meditation on the value of resources taken entirely for granted by the contemporary, westernised reader.

                                      ****


3. The Wall, 2019

At first glance, John Lanchester’s novel could be a comment on the rise of anti-refugee sentiment in Britain.
In a not-so-distant future, every inch of British shoreline is guarded by an immense wall, a bulwark against illegal migrants as well as rising sea levels.
But through the experiences of a young border guard, the novel shows us how this national obsession with borders not only distracts from the climate emergency at hand; it diminishes our responsibility to fellow humans around the world, whose lives are threatened by climate change and for whom migration is a desperate solution.

                                      ****

4. Clade, 2015
Australian author James Bradley’s novel chronicles several generations of one family in an increasingly devastated world.
The day-to-day detail of their lives, as relationships hold together or break apart, unfolds against the backdrop of environmental and thus societal breakdown.
The novel contrasts the mundane miscommunications that characterise human relations with the big issue of global warming that could rob future generations of the opportunity to lead meaningful lives.

                                      ****

5. The Stone Gods, 2007
Jeanette Winterson’s stab at cli-fi offers, like Bradley’s novel, a long view.
The novel ranges over three vastly different timeframes: a dystopian, future civilisation that is fast ruining its planet and must seek another; 18th-century Easter Island on the verge of destroying its last tree; and a near-future Earth facing global environmental devastation.
As readers time travel between these stories, we find, again and again, the damage wrought by human hubris. Yet, the novel reminds us, too, of the power of love. In the novel, love signifies an openness to other humans and other species, to new ideas, and to better ways of living on this planet.

                                      ****

6. The Swan Book, 2013
This novel by indigenous Australian author Alexis Wright is unconventional, fable-like cli-fi. Its protagonist is a young indigenous girl whose life is devastated by climate change but most of all by the Australian government’s mistreatment of its indigenous populations. Weaving indigenous belief with biting satire, Wright’s novel is a celebration of her people’s knowledge of how to live with nature, rather than in exploitation of it.

                                      ****



7. Flight Behaviour, 2012
Unlike the other novels on this list, this one, by Barbara Kingsolver, is a realist novel set entirely in the present day.
A young woman from Tennessee stumbles upon thousands of monarch butterflies roosting on her in-laws’ land, the insects having been thrown off course by extreme weather events brought about by climate change.





                                      ****

From the scientists who come to study the problem, she learns of the delicate balance that is needed to keep the butterflies on course.

Kingsolver’s rich descriptions of an impoverished Appalachian community are combined with her biologist’s training, so that reader empathy is eventually shifted from the likeable heroine to the natural wonder that is the butterflies.

We are reminded of how climate change risks not simply human comfort but the planet’s ecological complexity.

Links - Books

15/05/2020

(AU) Youth Activists Challenge Clive Palmer's Waratah Coal Mine Saying It Impacts Their Human Rights

ABC 7.30 - Peter McCutcheon

An environment group is trying to stop a proposed mine by Clive Palmer's company Waratah Coal. (ABC News: Nick Haggarty)

Key Points
  • A group called Youth Verdict is taking legal action against a coal mine project by Clive Palmer's company Waratah Coal
  • The environmental group claims it infringes on a number of rights under Queensland's Human Right Act
  • LNP Senator Matt Canavan said environmental groups have been known to try to delay projects


In an Australian legal first, an environment group has challenged a proposed mega-coal mine on the grounds that it infringes on their human rights because of its contribution to climate change.

"The link between human rights and climate change is increasingly being seen in legal actions around the world," David Morris, chief executive of the Environmental Defenders Office, said.

"It was only a matter of time before we saw one in Australia."

The action is being taken by a new group called Youth Verdict against the Galilee Coal Project in central Queensland — a project of Clive Palmer's company Waratah Coal.

Youth Verdict has lodged an objection to the mine in the Queensland Land Court, arguing it infringes on a number of their rights under the state Human Rights Act, including the right to life, the protection of children and the right to culture.

Mel McAuliffe is a co-founder of Youth Verdict. (ABC News: Chris Gillette)

"We're facing a future that is increasingly uncertain, and that impacts our right to have a safe future," Mel McAuliffe, one of the founders of Youth Verdict.

"It means we won't have access to the same opportunities that generations before us have had."

LNP Senator Matt Canavan said although he was not aware of the specifics of the court case, he says these sorts of challenges usually fail.

"We know from the strategies of other environmental groups that they have sought to use our court system just simply to delay projects, not necessarily to protect the environment or even win the court case," Senator Canavan said.

"I just don't think our court systems are set up to handle such a disputed political issue. That's not their role and purpose and [to] try to retrofit them to this will just cause more division and angst in our community."

'An unsafe future'

Lily Kerley from Youth Verdict says the case is "daunting". (ABC News: Chris Gillette)

The Galilee Coal Project involves two open pit and four underground coal mines, making it one of the biggest coal operations in Australia.

It has secured federal and state approvals but needs to be assessed by the Queensland Land Court before the final state environmental authority can be issued.

Mr Palmer and the Waratah Coal project have been approached for comment on the case but have not replied to 7.30.

Youth Verdict spokesperson Lily Kerley admits it is daunting facing a businessman who has been involved in a number of high-profile legal battles.

"But I wouldn't say as daunting as the idea of facing an unsafe future for me and my generation," she said.

Ms McAuliffe said: "We have no precedent for this type of action, which is new and exciting, but we don't know what will happen."


7.30 Report: Youth activists claim Clive Palmer's proposed coal mine could breach their human rights

Human Rights Act to lead to 'lawyers' picnic'

Queensland's Human Rights Act only came into effect in January.

The LNP Opposition voted against the bill in Parliament last year on the grounds that it was unnecessary.

"It is irresponsible law-making to enact a law, the practical meaning of which no-one knows," Shadow Attorney-General David Janetzki told the Legislative Assembly.

"It is therefore likely … to encourage the ensuing lawyers' picnic."

The LNP declined to comment on Youth Verdict's challenge.

The Queensland Resources Council's Ian Macfarlane said the action was "a novel attempt by a minority group of young activists to use the court system to delay and/or prevent economic development in Queensland and jobs for Queenslanders during these challenging times".

Links

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative