Sunday, November 22, 2026

We’re killing our ancestors as well as our kids... - Julian Cribb

Surviving the 21st Century - Julian Cribb

The mindless onslaught by humans will take out both our past and our future

Portrait of Julian Cribb
AUTHOR
Julian Cribb AM is an Australian science writer and author of seven books on the human existential emergency. His latest book is How to Fix a Broken Planet (Cambridge University Press, 2023)
While the spotlight of current attention shines brightly on the horrors humanity is piling up for our grandchildren through the ten megathreats, the wholesale obliteration of our ancestors is passing almost without remark.

If you happen to have two eyes, a brain, ears, a nose, a backbone, a jaw, skin, lungs, two pairs of limbs and an internal reproductive system, then you owe them all to fish. They developed all these things first – and passed them on to their descendants, ourselves included. At two weeks, the human embryo still has a strong fishlike resemblance as a reminder. Our abilities to see, sense, smell, touch, feel and react all come to us from fish.

Yet, in little more than half a century, humans have gone a fair way to exterminating our ancestors, fish in particular.

In the latest chapter in the slaughter, scientists have reported “sudden, severe, and persistent declines in the abundance of deep-pelagic fishes, crustaceans, and cephalopods” in the Gulf of Mexico over recent years.

This comes on top of a spate of similar reports from around the world documenting the tragic ongoing destruction of fish life on Planet Earth.

Since the 1970s there has been a worldwide decline in fish populations and fish catch rates, which scientists attribute to overfishing and destructive fishing methods, marine debris and toxic chemical runoff from the land, coastal development and habitat change, poaching, invasive species, ocean acidification and climate change.

Currently almost 40 per cent of monitored fish stocks are being caught at rates faster than they can reproduce – which is the simple explanation for why fish prices are now so high in markets and shops around the world. Fishing is rapidly making seafood unaffordable to all but the very rich.

“The oceans of the Anthropocene are becoming increasingly impacted by destructive, human-driven activities, threatening critical ecosystem functions and services. Undoubtedly, the two greatest threats to ocean biodiversity are overexploitation and biophysical changes due to climate change,” says a recent report in Nature by Helen Yan, Dave Bellwood and team from James Cook University, Australia.

They studied an enormous spread of almost 1500 different fish species over the past 113 years and found clear signs of a decline in both populations and growth rates of fish generally, particularly those species subject to heavy commercial fishing.

Controversially, the team challenged the claims of “managed fisheries” behind which governments and the commercial fishing industry have hidden for decades, to excuse their ongoing plunder of the deep. The new research shows clearly that managed fisheries have the fastest declines in fish growth performance – and that strict management is rarely introduced until the fishery has reached the point of collapse.

This finding reinforces the work of Graham Edgar and team at the University of Tasmania whose study of 230 separate fisheries found that “populations of many overfished species are in far worse condition than has been reported, and the sustainability of fisheries was overstated.” In short, fisheries managers, like government climate policymakers, tend to take an unwarrantedly optimistic view of the data, probably because they are being leaned on by industry to do so.

“The extinction risk of many of the world’s most iconic and culturally valuable fishes is increasingly elevated by overfishing,” the James Cook team concluded. The added factor of climate change is compounding the problem, as is the slow incremental acidification of the world’s oceans which is eating away at the marine food chain.

Fig 1. Ocean acidification caused by human carbon emissions is rising sharply in the areas of ocean we most depend on for food. Source: Planetary Boundaries Report, 2026.

The destruction of the shells and skeletons of marine organisms caused by more acidic oceans is especially pronounced in the high latitudes where the world’s most productive fisheries exist, adding a double whammy to the havoc wrought by overfishing. Acidification is driven mainly by excessive carbon dioxide in the atmosphere from human activity dissolving into the oceans and turning them into dilute carbonic acid.

Its most serious effect is to weaken and destroy the shells and skeletons of the microscopic marine life on which all fish depend for food after hatching from the egg. In this way human activity destroys not only adult fish, but also their babies, in a disastrous circle than ends in extermination – and the ultimate loss of one of humanity’s primary food sources.

That the destruction of fish populations is not confined to shallow waters and commercial fisheries was underlined by the Gulf of Mexico report. Studying a period of less than four years they report a decline of 60-85 per cent in deepwater fish and squid. Since these species are not targeted by fishers, the only possible explanation was a change in the deepwater environment caused by humans. And here they found the oil spill from the Deepwater Horizon disaster to be the most likely explanation.

This raises the spectre of the accelerated destruction of sea life (and sea food) due to dramatic growth in deepsea oil, gas and minerals extraction. Deepwater oil and gas is growing faster than land-based sources and is predicted to increase by 60% by 2030. Deepwater mining is already worth $2.6 billion a year, and is expected to grow 346% to $9 billion 2036. Both activities take little or no account of their impact on sea life or human food, and augment problems such as toxic chemical and plastic waste.

Meanwhile the world’s fishing fleet, at around 4.9 million vessels, is shrinking in number – but growing in capacity. Its largest owner, China, for instance has reduced boat numbers from over 1 million to 568,000, yet fish consumption in China is rising, indicating the remaining boats are catching far more fish.

At present 80% of the world’s commercial fisheries are in decline. Fresh fish, as a regular human food, could become a thing of the past by 2050 warns a team of Canadian scientists. Farmed fish has already started to replace fresh-caught seafood in the global market, but aquaculture faces serious limits of its own as the man-made problems of pollution, climate change and acidification mount.

The likely outcome of this is that the only fish our grandchildren will ever taste will be grown from cell cultures in bioreactors, as may also be the case with red meat, eggs and milk as part of the trend to what is known as ‘cellular agriculture’.

Fig 2: What you’ll be eating in 2050… when beef, chicken and fish will be a thing of the past.
In the meantime the main concern lies with collapsing marine and freshwater ecosystems, that may in turn collapse the fish and fisheries on which we presently depend, driving some to extinction.

In the past, many societies revered their ancestors. But where our ancestral fish are concerned, humans are out to eradicate them, without thought or feeling.

Julian Cribb Articles

No comments :

Post a Comment

Lethal Heating is a citizens' initiative