(AU SMH) Critics Pan A Plan For The Barrier Reef As Bleaching Threat Rises

Sydney Morning Herald - Nick O'Malley

An updated plan to protect the Great Barrier Reef drafted by the Queensland and Commonwealth governments responding to a recommendation by UNESCO that the reef be placed on an “in danger” list recognises that climate change is its greatest threat.

But the updated Reef 2050 Plan is undermined by both governments’ 2030 emissions-reduction targets, critics say.

A UNESCO team is expected to inspect the reef next year before voting on its future status. The Australian government has been lobbying for it to be kept off the endangered list.

A UN body has recommended adding the Great Barrier Reef to its “in danger list”. Credit: Eddie Jim

The plan recognises global warming is the most significant threat to the reef, but also includes both governments’ 2030 emissions targets of 26-28 per cent and 30 per cent.

If adopted globally, these targets would not put the world on track to arresting climate change before the reef was largely killed.

“It’s like your house is on fire, and you recognise your house is on fire, and you say your house is on fire, but you don’t pick up a fire extinguisher,” said Richard Leck, WWF’s head of oceans and sustainable development.

Great Barrier Reef

Faced with destruction of the reef, a small band do ‘coral carpentry’

“Expert scientific advice is that at 2 degrees, we have 95 to 99 per cent loss of coral cover. Even at 1.5 degrees, we see a catastrophic loss of around 70 per cent.”

He said while it was clear Australia could not alone arrest global warming even if it met targets in line with 1.5 degrees, it could not lobby the rest of the world to help it protect the reef while its own targets did not measure up.

A spokesman for federal Environment Minister Sussan Ley said the updated plan was the result of significant work and scientific advice.

She said its release had been supported by the Reef 2050 independent expert panel chaired by former Australian chief scientist Ian Chubb, and had an increased focus on climate change as the biggest threat to the reef.

The updated plan included commitments to limit the impacts of climate change on the reef, with three new goals relating to climate mitigation and adaptation, he said.

Extreme weather 

What is La Nina and what does it mean for your summer? 

The plan is part of both governments’ response to the recommendation by UNESCO earlier this year that the reef be listed as endangered. Australia lobbied against that decision, but it will be revisited next year after a UNESCO team visits the reef.

Professor Terry Hughes, a global expert on coral reefs and bleaching and a member of the expert committee that helped draft the report, said the reef was considered at risk not only due to heating but also the impacts of industrialisation along the Queensland coast and damage caused by poor water quality.

Report cards on water quality had been produced late and suggested Australia was not on track to meet improvement targets, he said.

As the world considers the level of threat to the reef, scientists are becoming increasingly concerned about the prospect of another bleaching event by January, even though the region is experiencing a typically cooler La Nina weather pattern.

Climate policy

The climate clock: What’s the world’s carbon budget and what’s Australia’s share?

Professor Hughes said a Bureau of Meteorology update on Wednesday morning suggested bleaching could occur by the end of January or in February.

The Coral Sea ocean temperature was about 1 degree hotter than average and the region had experienced its hottest November ocean temperatures since records began 100 years ago, he said.

“And obviously, we’re still in the early stages of summer, so NOAA [the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration] and the Bureau of Meteorology are now predicting a strong chance of bleaching in January or February,” Professor Hughes said.

“If that happens, it would be unusually early sea temperatures normally peak at the beginning of March.”

But Professor Hughes said predictions made early in the season were not locked in. A heatwave could cause a bleaching and a cyclone could still cool temperatures enough to prevent one.

He said the potential for a bleaching event during an El Nino cycle was scary, but no longer surprising.

“So we don’t need an El Nino anymore to trigger mass bleaching because the temperature keeps going up and up through cycles,” Professor Hughes said.

Links

• (AU ABC) Promising Signs Of New Life On Australia's Largest Oceanic Reef, Despite Frequent Heat Stress
• (Washington Post) Photos Show Vast Coral Spawning Event In Great Barrier Reef, Giving Divers Hope For Climate Change Recovery
• (USA TIME) UNESCO Says Australia's Great Barrier Reef Isn't In Danger Yet. Many Environmentalists And Divers Disagree
• (AU The Conversation) Not Declaring The Great Barrier Reef As ‘In Danger’ Only Postpones The Inevitable
• (AU SBS) Australia Accused Of ‘Censoring Science’ After Great Barrier Reef Avoids World Heritage ‘In Danger’ Listing
• (AU ABC) Australia Avoids Great Barrier Reef Global Embarrassment, But The Dangers Of Climate Change Remain For The Reef
• (AU The Guardian) Coalition Believes It Has Numbers To Stop Great Barrier Reef Being Listed As ‘In Danger’