New York Times - Brad Plumer
 |
Clearing snow in Buffalo, N.Y., in January. Credit Lindsay Dedario/Reuters |
WASHINGTON — In
the summer, when heat waves scorch cities or heavy rains flood the
coasts, some climate scientists and environmentalists will
point out any plausible connections to global warming, hoping today’s weather will help people understand tomorrow’s danger from climate change.
Then
winter comes. And, like clockwork, those who want to deny the
established science that humans are warming the planet will try to flip
the script. In January, when large swaths of the country were gripped by bitter cold,
President Trump took to Twitter to mock climate fears: “Wouldn’t be bad to have a little of that good old fashioned Global Warming right now!”
Welcome to the weather wars. As battle lines harden between supporters and opponents of climate action,
both are increasingly using bouts of extreme weather as a weapon to try
to win people to their side. Weather, after all, is one of the easiest
things for people to bond over or gripe about, a staple of small talk
and shared experience that can make it a simple but powerful opportunity
to discuss global warming.
But, as
Mr. Trump’s words show, it’s also a framing device that can be easily
abused. That raises the stakes for how scientists, who have long tried
to distinguish between short-term weather fluctuations and long-term
climate shifts, draw out and discuss the links between the two.
“Weather, and especially extreme weather, is how most people will experience climate change,” said Susan Joy Hassol, director of the science outreach nonprofit group Climate Communication. “You
don’t experience the slow change in average temperature. What you
experience are the changes in extreme weather that are brought about. So how we talk about that is really important.”
One
reason that the weather can offer a potent messaging opportunity may
boil down to human psychology. Climate science itself is often complex
and abstract. It can be tough to feel, on a gut level, the implications
of a
chart showing global temperatures ticking up over time, or statistics showing that, on average,
95-degree days or
torrential downpours are becoming more frequent.
But
an unusual weather event that hits today, like a brutal heat wave or
heavy storm, is more visceral. Laboratory experiments have found that
people’s beliefs about global warming
can be swayed
by their immediate environment. Put someone in a hot room and they’re
more likely to agree the planet is warming. Thirsty people become more
alarmed by drought forecasts.
Psychologists
have suggested
these visceral experiences make it easier for our brains to imagine
future states of the world, and therefore make them seem more likely. An
exceptionally hot or cold day, other studies
have found, can play the same role.
Some messengers have long realized that emotion and immediacy can be a powerful force.
“Trump
is a branding guy,” said David B. Srere, co-chief executive and chief
strategy officer at Siegel+Gale, a brand consultancy. “He knows his
audience and understands how to tell a clear, simple story. Climate advocates
and the scientific community need to get better at understanding their
audience and figure out how to tell a simple, repeatable story of their
own.”
In
recent years, some climate scientists have focused on trying to turn
flare-ups of severe weather into teachable moments. “This is what global
warming looks like,”
scientists said during the summer of 2012, a season of widespread droughts, wildfires and extreme heat advisories.
And they have become increasingly comfortable drawing those connections.
Back in 2005, after Hurricane Katrina devastated New Orleans,
many researchers responded cautiously,
saying it was difficult to attribute a single event to global warming. A
few noted that rising ocean temperatures could make hurricanes more
destructive, on average, in the future. But even that was fairly
abstract.
Over time, that messaging has shifted.
Partly that’s because, as climate models have improved, scientists
have been able to demonstrate more rigorously
how rising greenhouse gas emissions have made recent heat waves or
droughts more intense or more likely to occur — a budding field known as
“extreme weather attribution.” Scientists
have also refined their communication strategies, using metaphors like “loaded dice” to talk about how global warming is now making certain severe weather events more likely.
“The
conversation today couldn’t be more different than it was a decade
ago,” said Hunter Cutting, director of strategic communications for
Climate Nexus, a nonprofit group focused on climate issues. “Back then,
at best, you might get scientists talking about what effects we could
see by the year 2100. Now we’re seeing leaders connect the dots in a
much more direct way.”
That strategy,
though, can cut both ways. Deniers of climate change have also sought
to use the daily weather to shape perceptions. Senator James Inhofe,
Republican of Oklahoma,
once brought a snowball to the Senate floor to suggest that global warming wasn’t a problem. When cold spells strike, Mr. Trump will ridicule worries about climate change:
Parrying Mr. Trump’s tweets can be a challenge, some supporters of action on climate change
concede. He can drive the conversation: One
recent survey from Media Matters,
a liberal watchdog group, found that broadcast television networks
rarely discuss global warming when extreme weather is unfolding. But
they do often note the president’s climate comments.
Scientists and environmentalists have tried various tactics to push back. They
might note that
record hot days are becoming far more frequent than record cold days,
and that no one expects global warming to eliminate snow altogether. Or
they’ll reiterate that the ups and downs of daily weather aren’t the
same as broader long-term shifts in the Earth’s climate, and that a
single cold day can’t disprove global warming anymore than a single hot
day proves it.
Still,
a casual observer could be forgiven for feeling a bit of whiplash after
that line. After all, haven’t we been hearing that severe weather is a
manifestation of climate change when it’s hot out?
 |
| Flooding in Townsville, Australia, in February. The area, in northeastern Queensland State, has seen unusual amounts of rain this year. Credit Ian Hitchcock/Getty Images |
Marshall
Shepherd, a professor of atmospheric science at the University of
Georgia, isn’t convinced that the president’s tweets about cold weather
have staying power.
“I see Trump’s
tweets as an opportunity to discuss the science,” he said. “To the 9 or
10 percent of the population that are going to be dismissive of climate
science no matter what, there’s not much you can say to them. But a lot
of people out there are legitimately curious” about how global warming
can be real if it’s cold out today.
That
raises the question of whether the messaging skirmishes around severe
weather and climate change are swaying public perceptions, or whether
each side is just preaching to those who are already converted.
There are some signs opinion is shifting. One
recent survey by researchers at Yale and George Mason University
found that 69 percent of Americans were “worried” about global warming,
an 8-point increase from the previous spring. One possible explanation,
the researchers suggested, was the spate of extreme weather disasters
in 2018, from wildfires to hurricanes, along with increased efforts by
scientists and even
local TV weathercasters to put that in a climate context.
“For
a long time, Americans saw climate change as a distant threat,” said
Edward Maibach, a professor at George Mason who works on climate change
communication. “But as of our most recent survey, I don’t feel I can say
that anymore. We’re seeing a lot of movement on people understanding
that climate change is already happening.”
Others
are more cautious about interpreting these trends. One 2017 study, for
instance, found that people who experience extreme weather are, for a
short period,
more likely to support climate adaptation measures than they were before. But the effect was modest and diminished over time.
It may be that people
mentally adjust to unusual weather patterns quickly,
updating their idea of what counts as normal. Politics may also play a
role: In a polarized country, many Americans are already hardened in
their beliefs about global warming.
Partly
for that reason, David M. Konisky, an associate professor in the School
of Public and Environmental Affairs at Indiana University and an author
of that 2017 study, said he wonders whether better messaging can
dramatically shift opinions. “It might be that climate has become so
wrapped up in one’s identity and worldview that it’s not the sort of
thing that’s susceptible to better messaging,” he said.
Wanyun Shao, an assistant professor of geography at the University of Alabama, lands in the middle. Her
research has found
that Democrats and Republicans do perceive severe weather
differently: Democrats tend to see it as part of a broader pattern of
climate change, Republicans as more of an aberration. But, she
has also found,
a consistent string of shifting weather — year after year of increasing
summer heat, for instance — does start to chip away even at
conservative doubt about global warming.
“For some people, it takes more time,” she said. “But eventually people start trusting their own experiences.”
Links